In the Shadow of the Black Hole
Вставка
- Опубліковано 18 чер 2024
- The Event Horizon Telescope (EHT) - a planet-scale array of eight ground-based radio telescopes forged through international collaboration - was designed to capture images of a black hole. In coordinated press conferences across the globe, EHT researchers revealed that they succeeded, unveiling the first direct visual evidence of a supermassive black hole and its shadow.
This 17-minute film explores the efforts that led to this historic image, from the science of Einstein and Schwarzschild to the struggles and successes of the EHT collaboration.
More information and download options: www.eso.org/public/videos/eso1...
Credit:
ESO
Directed by: Lars Lindberg Christensen
Art Direction, Production Design: Martin Kornmesser
Written by: Sarah Leach, Laura Hiscott, Lars Lindberg Christensen and Calum Turner
3D animations and graphics: Martin Kornmesser and Luis Calçada
Editing: Martin Kornmesser
Producer: Herbert Zodet
Music: Johan B. Monell - Shadow of the Universe Part I-Shadow Of The Universe (parts 1-5) (www.johanmonell.com) and Stellardrone - Galaxies.
Footage and photos: ESO, Event Horizon Telescope Collaboration, ALMA (ESO/NAOJ/NRAO), IRAM/Diverticimes/Cinedia, Max Planck Institute for Radio Astronomy, BlackHoleCam/Radboud University/Cristian Afker/Cafker Productions, Digitized Sky Survey 2, De Gasperin et al., Kim et al., mediomix, ALMA (ESO/NAOJ/NRAO)/General Dynamics C4 Systems, Nicolle R. Fuller/NSF, Jordy Davelaar et al., B. Tafreshi (twanight.org), C. Malin (christophmalin.com), Glen Petitpas/SMA,P. Horálek, James Lowenthal (Dept. of Astronomy, Smith College), J. Weintroub, SMT/Used with permission from University of Arizona, David Harvey, photographer, William Montgomerie/JCMT/EAO,LMT/INAOE Archive, M. Druckmüller, P. Aniol SMT/University of Arizona by Bob Demers /©2019 Arizona Board of Regents, Junhan Kim (Department of Astronomy and Steward Observatory, University of Arizona), Spaceengine.org, L. Calçada, Y. Beletsky (LCO), M. Kornmesser, H. Zodet, ESA/Hubble,Onsala Space Observatory, Historische Museum Bern/Albert-Einstein-Archiv, Jerusalem, Ferdinand Schmutzer, Royal Observatory, Greenwich, Jonathan Riley,Luca Micheli, Karl Schwarzschild image courtesy AIP Emilio Segrè Visual Archives, Afshin Darian/The Smithsonian Astrophysical Observatory Submillimeter Array, Thalia Traianou (Max Planck Institute for Radio Astronomy), Steven H. Keys and www.keysphotography.com, and Robert Schwarz (www.antarctic-adventures.de).
Scientific consultants: Paola Amico and Mariya Lyubenova.
Web and technical support: Mathias André and Raquel Yumi Shida.
Executive producer: Lars Lindberg Christensen. - Наука та технологія
Humanity has truly come a long way
Raymar Football at gunpoint
Scientifically yes but overall not really.
Michael Sorry, I can’t hear you over the quality food on my table, healthcare, safety and access to all knowledge.
So dull..... Yak! 44 million long and you get this..... better to stick to interstellar
@B C that's after 44 million setup
The first image ever of a Black Hole is the perfect example showing that *both theoretical-based models and reality actually match together* .
In fact, this is what we simply call: SCIENCE!
April 10th 2019, therefore *will always remain a huge milestone for collaborative science* , and more particularly for collaborative Astronomy 🌌
*Congratulations to EHT collaboration*
Yes with the best tool being all these different science institutions collaborating together to cross verify everything. It's not just astronomy but interdisciplinary sciences and engineering to make it all work together. This restores my faith in humanity and reinforces my respect for the scientific institutions.
False because relativity explain that inside a black hole space is infinite and time stop which is impossible because they release energy and evaporate one day or another. The only thing that match is the fact that stars which light can't escape exists, that's all. Our models never match with reality, they just get better over time
First clue it's a hoax, it's too blurry to make out what the objects are.
It's actually a blurry picture of Phobos eclipsing the Sun.
ua-cam.com/video/wwEoyntzAz0/v-deo.html
They would have taken a sharper picture if it was real, instead just used a really blurry stock photo. They can't do science, so they ended up doing fiction.
To think I was born in the right place in time to see this wonderful discovery.
I agree with this statement here. And as was said before, imagining is the first step to understanding. What great people: Einstein, and those who can show his theories as valid, despite the huge efforts of community cooperation and commitment required.
being the middle-children of history ain't so bad after all.
Too early to explore them though....
piece of CGI you mean
they discovered nothing but the projection of their own self confirming psychotic delusion
@@mapiasthriteen6623 ;-;
Sarcastically speaking, I just Love how in this biography, they casually speak about being held at gunpoint towards a resolution process......not over drugs, but over a bunch of telescopes!
All non-challant and what not!!?
Phenochs Mundala I’ve been scrolling through the comments hoping someone would say something about that lol
I wouldn't doubt that some douchebag had a gun at someone's head forcing them to do their bidding? Typical crap.
This vid was wrong, it was just the astronomers being robbed at gunpoint and had nothing to do with their work. Acoording to reddit
Remembering Stephen hawking he would have been delighted to see this...
I'm pretty sure he got to see some sort of image related to this. He has contributed a lot to the theories of black holes as many other scientists. It's cool to see this come together, never the day would I think of people "photographing" a black hole.
I like to think he 'd already seen it pretty accurately in his head. But yes, I do agree with you, shame he missed it by just a year.
He must have seen a version of it. The image we see is just the one they've released. I would imagine there was an earlier version that wasn't a visible spectrum photo that he would have seen via the data.
Qutysree R.I.P
To ease your mind he has probably seen it already, seeing as this project started years ago
Thanks guys. That's seriously an amazing team effort. I'm so proud of you guys eventhough I don't know many of you. Go science!
transfer is many for mi now tranfer now bisnis name Corneles mokodompit from indonesia asking
i can watch science like this all day without getting bored. its fantastic what the future will bring in hundreds of year!
There is a end to this world . The judgement day . God will judge us.
these nuts
space colonization or mad max future ^_^
@Claudia Juarez And what lies exactly? Tell me more.
Lmao true true but I highly doubt Humans will make it and a dance that far. JS.
Its good to live in a time frame where we first did a Black Hole simulation and got the first Actual Black Hole image at the same time
The best quote
Check out: THE KNOWLEDGE OF THE FOREVER TIME. buckle up though!😳
not only that. We also get to experience WoW classic, TWICE. What an amazing time to be alive.
Actually nope, we were born too early, imagine if we born in 2200 maybe we could sail the universe...
It is a CGI image, sorry to burst your bubble.
That image is a turning point in science. Congratulations and thank you so much !
I'd say more of an historic set of confirmations for physics and astrophysics, but a real turning point in methods of observation for sure. They just proved what can be observed using a virtual radio telescope with an Earth-sized aperture, all without building a giant floating dish covering the Pacific Ocean or something equally as impossible. Just think of what else we might be able to see with this and similar techniques. I'm sure quite a few astronomers are salivating right about now.
@@Kelnx God bless you
@@Kelnx Id rather hope for words peace TY! Now THAT would be an achievement !
Congratulations to all on the EHT team!!!! What a spectacular achievement!!!
Their team did a great job..
But I think they also break the record for most data collected and the longest time taken to take a picture.. wonderful job
ecko_beatz frassworks they need Quit wasting tax dollars of space when they have already a million if not billions of times and focus on EARTH
"There is plenty of scope for things to go wrong, and one after another, they did. Equipment failures - OK
power failures - Yup
not enough hard drives to store data - It happens
... some of the scientists were even held at gunpoint during the observations." - WHAT
Soooo your just gunna skip over the scientists held at gunpoint part without elaborating?...
I thought that same thing.
Timestamp: 8:10 . Agreed: WTF was THAT about? Where? Which nation did THAT to them?
@UCpdO5cHsgJhhLYLsZZ54e_Q 8:08
lmao just a regular day for a scientist
@@EvilDogFilmsOfficial i was wondering if i heard right.. how was that not news
"Some of the scientists were held at gunpoint" Interesting, would like to hear that story.
is live black hol name corneles mokodompit from indonesia asking
We need a real movie about the scientist who worked their hearts out to give the humanity this beauty😍
Beauty?, it's just an orange ring round a black blot. Don't be so mesmerized. This is only stupid athiest theory where they feel they are getting closer to the questions about how universe began. The answer is right here on earth if they cared to look, that God created the universe and space is just a magnificent sky for us to praise God by gazing at his wondrous creation. Gazing with our naked eye rather than wasting billions on space exploration when we could use that money to feed the world's poor
Definetely
@@mrmusi4512 well said mate.
@@mrmusi4512 but still god also said to gain knowledge so this money is not waste it is useful
meanwhile people are starving to death on earth........fukin useless sheep
Magnificent and impecable work!
Thank you all who made this possible, what a time we're living on!!!!
What a great video. Thank you for all your work.
sees a black hole simulation: nice
sees a black hole image irl: *n i c e*
N O I C E
sees a black hole inr: *Niiiiiceeee*
sees a black hole first-hand irl:
It actually doesn't look impressive at all by any measure, and the supposed event horizon in the photo could be caused by a great number cosmic phenomena other than a black hole, but I'll see myself out since my job of bringing reality back into the conversation has been fully accomplished even though butthurts will deny that fact.
@@djhenyo name other phenomena that cause an accretion disk larger than the diameter of our solar system to complete an orbit in two days.
Thanks to everybody who have been part of the EHT. The result and what you’ve done is incredible and let’s me trust in human kind, although we live in mad, crazy times.
Thank you EHT for allowing us to see this in our lifetime. Next is the actual photo of an exoplanet, hopefully in this generation also. Kudos
Ricky King same thoughts haha
Jst wooooow... what an explanation .. and hard work behind it. big thumbs up ..
Extraordinary !!! Excellent video , congratulations . Thank for uploading . Greetings from Chili . ( Southamerican )
I was very excited to see the picture. I hope you can get even better pictures in the future. The Snowmobile just transports your data to Amazon where you store it with resilience. This was a cool project and I'm glad you were able to pull it off!
Kudos to the whole team
For such an incredibly marvellous
Discovery.
Your efforts undoubtedly deserve global glory.love you all guys
Congratulations you have done exceptional teamwork. Your discovery of seeing a black hole is truly phenomenal. It is good to see so many nations and researchers from all over the world, this is what should always happen in scientific research in every field. Union is always a great strength. Congratulations on your great success. I hope that this will always continue so many thanks to the whole group.🙏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏❣️
Phenomenal alright. So phenomenal its can't be real, and its not. Space is fake. We are being lied to.
Event Horizon Team u guys literally started a New Era in Astronomy.....Just Tooooooo Much Respect for all those painstaking Nights🔥🔥🔥🙌🙌....Thank you so Much....!! we need more people like u all💓🌌
They are not real. it's a fake one.
New era of population deception. Space is fake.
I'm proud at everyone who worked on this.
Well done to everyone involved, and what a nicely made video ESO. I wish I would of been involved in the project.
I got to say, as a graphic designer your thumbnail is absolutely awesome. Typography is crazy genius.
"I did my PhD in black holes."
How did you get the information back out once you were finished?
this comment is underated 😂
May I read the dissertation? Any possible link?
Hats off, ingenious network eyes, brilliant coop, really dark matters.
One word = Wow. Well done ~*~. Thank you to all involved.
Finally a real image of a black hole. I've waited years and never thought I'd live to see one.
In past we see storms(cyclones) on Earth, now we see it in the space, in the shape of black holes. It's really amazing and the most powerful phenomena of not only the universe but in fact the multiverse.
Awesome achievement guys! May the black holes continue leading you on your journey where the light goes!
Salute you all for this unprecedented achievement by global collaboration. I watched this more than once and I am exhilarated upon this work and congratulate you all. I am waiting for further discoveries about our universe like" what are quasars", what actually is gravity? etc.
Subramanian Areekode, Kerala, India
I love the fact that efforts are being put on discovering mysteries and not on flying cars that can destroy the atmosphere.
ua-cam.com/users/results?search_query=stephen+crothers+black+holes+and
*The people behind this, everyone, is amazing. WOW.*
How epic to be able to whitness something like this! Can't wait to see what other great things will be discovered in the future.
Class! Astronomy is so exciting right now
I am like crying here. So exciting to see again the power of the collaboration.
173 dislike? May be from those guys whose application to do research in those institutes got rejected? Seriously, I can't understand what people except? There should be a compulsory comment from the people who dislike such a great videos. At least we get to know what great thoughts they had while disliking.
my feeling is their mouse slipped as they about to click like and couldnt be bothered changing it lol
Great work going from theory to fact, keep it up!!!!!
It´s beautiful, it´s amazing.....Proud to be human in this era. Greetings from Mexico
2:07 a blackhole is the most mysterious object in the universe
Le random woman: Hold my damn beer.
Apocalypse HR17 😂
I dont get it... I want to, i really do but i cant seem to put the pieces together, wut u talkin bout willis??? Lol
Imagine of they could put a radio telescope on the moon, that would kick the resolution up a notch!
Christian Fuchs Wonder if the planned location of the James Webb telescope would be better or worse than one parked on the moon, when linked up with earth based telescopes in this way?
@@johnfrancisdoe1563 I think that where the JWST will be placed, is a zone with less sun radiation than if it was placed in the Moon. Imagine Moon's soil reflecting all that light from below.
No-No...better far away from any floor.
Or radio telescopes placed at every lagrange point, something much easier to do.
How about one at each lunar pole and then a few around the equator ? That way we could turn them on or off as needed for the best view possible , maybe next some in the Tropics (Cancer/ Capricorn)at alternating sites from the equator... WOW what a view we could get then, yes it would take a while to complete but ooh what a pay off, turn the moon into an observatory!
Yeah dude !
Just imagine the accomplishments humanity could achieve if everyone got along and worked together. The image if this black hole is just the tip of the iceberg. There’s so much more out there that we’ve yet to discover.
Thanks for this awesome project
Why not show the entie image? It's amazing!
That's the 54 million years old image. It's really cool.
Light years?
@@suborgtfo.4433 he means the image is of 54 million years ago.....as the light emmited that time would have reached earth now
IKR it's carzy imagining that when the black hole was in the form as in the image dinosaurs roamed our land
@@shashankkulkarni6877 The Cretaceous-Paleogene extinction event that killed off dinosaurs happened 66 million years ago. But yeah, this image of the black hole corresponds to the time of pretty distant past.
What a leap! Congratulations all and thank you!
This video is so good and well explained that I'm in love with it. Thanks for making things so easy to understand ang the narration is so good ❤️❤️❤️.
Awesome micro-documental, definitely a groundbreaking discovery
16:20 Clearly the moral of this story is that what the world needs the most are lots and lots of people to tell other people that whatever they do it is impossible, so when those people finally do it they feel great.
-Mama I am going to eat the whole pack of chocolate cookies.
-That is impossible!!!
I did it ,and I feel great. Where is mi nobel?
On Monday July 1st 2019 at 6:57 PM a sum of 512 conspiracy theorists and guys who like to get angry about things they don't understand (= Dunning Kruger effect) dislikes this great documentary about one of the greatest achievements of man(kind). 😞
Luckily it has more than 18.000 likes which speaks for the intellectual capabilities among the 838,222 viewers as of the same date and time I already mentioned. 😏
In other words:
Thanks European Southern Observatory (ESO) UA-cam channel to put up this great short documentary.
And a list of questions:
To all the conspiracy theorists and guys (and gals) who spread anger and false theories, playing the enlightened ones without understanding how science actually works.
- Do you want to feel like a Neo from Matrix, albeit a Neo falling for false mentors?
- Why do you who refuse to understand the way modern science should be presented, likes to get angry instead of using this by now wasted energy to understand what you see?
- Why don't you pay attention to the explanations in this video and learn by carefully listening what is explanatory computer animations and what's the actual pictures? Especially when one thinks that I as a German to whom English is the second language understood the overall picture and when was shown what, this should especially tell native English speakers something about their attention span.
- Why do you accuse NASA of lying but fully ignoring that this documentary was hosted by a part of the European space programm and observation.
- Why do you feel the need to spit out hatred and distrust on true authorities on science and research who earned their reputation (almost on par with the ancient Roman concept of Auctoritas) by learning for decades of their lives.
- Can it be that you're against Einsteins discoveries because he is of a certain religion antisemites hates?
- Can it be that you're against this video just because you're against women doing science stuff thus being misogynist?
- Why do you conspiracy theorists and anti-science guys are so prone to use strong and violent language?
- Aren't you eloquent enough to ask your questions or state your opinions in a polite and cultivated grown up manner?
Well, just asking questions here. 🤔
And a call for:
- Being proud to be a member of a species which has the ability to observe things so far away, a species which learned to overcome its natural limitation by ingenuity and intellect trumping over feelings and a backwater thinking.
- Being proud that so manny people choses to cooperate to achieve a greater goal, to overcome old fashioned hate and mutual prejudices.
- Being proud that they overcame all the diverse issues and problems by sheer will and cleverness.
- Being aware that we live in such a great time of new discoveries, knowledge. Well, we might not colonize new continents anymore, but we can "conquer" worlds millions of light years away.
- Being aware that we now live in a world full of knowledge, achievements, technology our ancestors 100 years ago would have considered a strange sureal fantasy, not even respected as science fiction anymore.
So, again, thank you European Southern Observatory (ESO) UA-cam channel for putting up this great video. 🤗
Very nice documentary. Awesome content and narration.
for the first time I realy don't understand, how can something like this have dislikes...anyway, I'm so proud of humanity...
True progress to human intellect. Bravo!
I think the most amazing thing about this is actually how smart all the people on this team are. The mathematics, electronics, computers, timing etc. It is easier for me to imagine the blackhole itself than to imagine being half as smart as these scientists. These peolple should be our societies rockstars for what they do. They're awesome!!
No words to describe this victory...simply priceless...
I'm getting chills down my spine
Can you send me your profil pic on instagram please?
@@seponatis3122 me too, pls. i want it
Wizard Ono he didn't send it.. :,(
@@seponatis3122 sad :'
It was John Michell who first posited the idea of 'Black holes' in 1783. _in a paper for the Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London._
Care to explain further? That is a very early date and I find it interesting
I had to look it up.
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Michell
@@xiphosura413 Don't be lazy - look it up - en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Michell#Black_holes
Great team work
What a great video.
It's awe inspiring.
10:24 that's a very happy dancing Telescope doing his job!
Randall Rodriguez specky twat😂
Swaggy Telescope Dance!!!
I wonder if this is the most expensive picture ever taken... Probably. And it should be! A picture this amazing is worth every euro spend on it!
If you compare the costs for this picture with the fees of Hollywood stars, it was actually relatively cheap.😅
Black Hole:
"You didnt even get my chocolate-side..."
Image not picture. Pictures relate to photographs, images relate to imagination.
*it was not taken but it was generated* .
@@Q_QQ_Q Reconstructed is a better word.
Love the voice over.
I'm glad to see Space Engine footage used in something this serious, it really is an amazing program, perfect for such an amazing event :D
Scientific teams show the power of cooperation & collaboration!!
What we've achieved till this day is really unprecedented & what we can achieve further is unimaginable.
We've seen a black hole now !!!!!! (doesn't matter whether it's a shadow)
Amazing!!!!!
Such collaborations should also be done for relatively nearby objects as well. Our observations will be refined to the greatest ever achieved !!
I know it's costly but it'll unravel great mysteries for sure.
You guys are the modern day Stanley and Livingston.... your accomplishment is nothing short of theirs.....
Incredibly amazing!
Keyword: TEAM [teamwork makes the dream work]
cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/0535/6917/products/teamworkclassic.png?v=1511509623
The put chills to the bone. So astonishing.
Gracias Javier por compartir este video! ♥
What a fantastic discovery. Amazed and enthralled.
Wow just wow. It's so amazing
Truly remarkable. A tribute to the human race.
Lovely video, congratulations!
This video motivates me so much to keep on studying so one day I could work into something like this
This is surely a very big achievement in science and It will continue to amaze us!
It's so scary to see something that exists. :D
Big thumbs up for everyone involved!!
Awe inspiring stuff
This is so fascinating.
WOW! Congratulations all the Scientists!
Need a telescope the size of Earth? Make the Earth a telescope. Good job team.
Congratulations to each and every one of those who made this scientific effort possible, you are the true superheroes of science, I want the universe to reward you with more successes, more revealing answers and the satisfaction of new great discoveries.
what a special day. congratulations and gratitude
This was the best documentary on black holes 💯, thank you so much 👍🏻
historical moment for physicist
😂😂😂😂😂.
SPACE DOES NOT EXIST. Completely fake.
2nd law of thermodynamics violation.
Fake space, enjoy...
Not!!!
I like how the scientists all over the world came together as a team combined efforts and worked with dilligence and resilience day in day out for quite some years just to capture the image of this mysterious object THE BLACK HOLE.
Now, about those politicians😉
@@rdallas81 what about the politicians?
@@jayadams35 coming together to resolve problems.....like the scientific community.
@@rdallas81 Yes it is possible. But today's politics is crap and politicians are morons. It is close to impossible.
@@jayadams35 they are driven by greed. Anyone driven by the deadly sins will die by them.
thanks to all team
I hope everyone realises how important this was for us as a species, not only have we now actually seen something once thought science fiction but imagine now what’s possible with VLBI
We too are proud of you team... and we are privileged to live in your times..
....ahahahahahahaha
Great job!
Beyond impressive!
Heartly congratulations for the team.. who made expectations to reality.....👍👍👍👍
Can anyone explain me what the 2 big plasma green lights that ara coming out from the black hole are??
when I first saw this picture it's beauty made me cry.
You must have been a mess when lady di got killed by that fat opera singer paparazzi
You know what will really make you cry? Homeless people living in bushes, eating out of trashcans, while a bunch of rich people waste billions on crap like this. They have to keep the lie going, if you found out you can't go into space you would be mad as hell. The reality is all of it is a lie, sure they sprinkle a tiny bit of truth in just to keep your interest, but it is mostly lies. No one is going anywhere, they just sent peoples imaginations into space. Why do you think they call it science fiction? Key word is fiction, it's not real.
@@faithismespeaks6848 Take that shit somewhere else dude, I'm sorry that you think space doesn't exist lol
I love all of this
All those hard work and dedication made the image of the black hole...