US F-35 at Bengaluru flags strategic turn as all 3 Indian forces field lethal US weapon for 1st time

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 13 лют 2023
  • #CutTheClutter #AeroIndia2023 #IndiaUS
    As the 14th edition of Aero India 2023 takes place at Yelahanka airbase in Bengaluru, US F-35 debut there flags the turn in military & strategic relations between India & US. ThePrint Editor-in-Chief Shekhar Gupta explains what this fundamental shift is & how it is marked by the fact that all three Indian Forces - Army, Navy & Air Force are using lethal American weapons for the first time in history. Episode 1174 of ‘Cut the Clutter’.
    11:21 - 11:37 : Visuals shown are LCH Prachand not Apache AH-64E . Error is regretted
    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Read India-US Military Technology Cooperation: jgu.s3.ap-south-1.amazonaws.c...
    ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Join our channel to get access to perks. Click 'JOIN' or follow the link below:
    / @theprintindia
    ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Connect with ThePrint
    » Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/subscribe/
    » Subscribe to our UA-cam Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
    » Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
    » Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
    » Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
    » Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
    » Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintIndia
    » Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
    » Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8

КОМЕНТАРІ • 610

  • @ThePrintIndia
    @ThePrintIndia  Рік тому +12

    Early access, exclusive content, special privileges - Discover the great benefits of being a Member of ThePrint’s UA-cam channel. Take a Paid Membership today. It costs just Rs 159/month. ua-cam.com/channels/uyRsHZILrU7ZDIAbGASHdA.htmljoin

    • @kabzaify
      @kabzaify Рік тому +1

      Why would you want to replace your heavy lift helicopters with inferior Chinooks? I severed in the British army.

    • @urrasscal8380
      @urrasscal8380 Рік тому

      iindian log ek number k gadhe hote hai...agar todhi bhi akal hoti toh 47' main he popul. x-change kar liya hota....

  • @ganapatihegde1024
    @ganapatihegde1024 Рік тому +44

    Long live India- US relation. Modi government is managing its relation with all countries through strategic foreign policy. Get the best Arms and other military equipment for the Indian defence forces.

    • @vishwanathgangaiah1035
      @vishwanathgangaiah1035 Рік тому +1

      😜

    • @nsevv
      @nsevv Рік тому

      Just like how Japan, Germany, Skorea, Singapore, Taiwan progress rapidly after working with US, India will develop rapidly working with US. following russia was a major disastor. russia betrayed us when they didn't help India stop china from invading us. We will never forget the betrayal. Seems like russia is only interested in using us as a useful pawn against US.

    • @krishnakhatri2427
      @krishnakhatri2427 Рік тому

      @@RushiaKhan your name say it all

  • @chinmaysardesai623
    @chinmaysardesai623 Рік тому +119

    I have seen the F-35 upclose, the capability of that aircraft is impressive. However, operation costs could be an issue for most countries.

    • @truthseeking6611
      @truthseeking6611 Рік тому +6

      This is not the age of fighter jets: NaMo.

    • @ritikshaw5868
      @ritikshaw5868 Рік тому +8

      It won't be that high as you'd be tied in with the American logistics train which vastly reduces the cost and upkeep price tag.

    • @srujithreddy335
      @srujithreddy335 Рік тому +2

      Tech transfer service and maintenance make it affordable

    • @chinmaysardesai623
      @chinmaysardesai623 Рік тому +35

      @srujith reddy There is not going to be tech transfer on F-35s. Whom are we kidding here?

    • @hayrambsharma
      @hayrambsharma Рік тому

      @@chinmaysardesai623 ++

  • @shrekanu
    @shrekanu Рік тому +71

    Thanks for making these. Feels like listening to dadaji that I never had😊

  • @vijaykumar-vz7xf
    @vijaykumar-vz7xf Рік тому +25

    Very well researched and put across!! Yes. There has been a paradigm shift in our strategic leanings. Lethal platforms for our Forces are now coming from the US & France in addition to Russia. The present posture reflects an effort to get us the best equipment from the best bidder and an effort not to keep all eggs in a single basket. I feel maintaining this posture is critical to ensuring that we do not fall again into the trap of overwhelmingly dependent on one country for our needs. Acquiring self sufficiency is, of course the key, which needs to be balanced with our need to maintain operational readiness along the Northern and Western fronts. A robust economic trajectory over the next decade holds the key for these aspirations and that is where we need to focus for now.

  • @the_Nameless_One99
    @the_Nameless_One99 Рік тому +91

    Thank you for this episode sir. I still remember the early to mid-2000s when Russia was seen as our natural ally and the US was seen with suspicion, if not outright hostility by us, the common people. I remember listening to scenarios where it used to the US and Pak vs India and Russia. This attitude has still not changed completely, but it has changed somewhat.
    While I appreciate your CTC series a great deal and am a daily viewer, I would love something which deals directly with the issue of the day. I would like a series of the type "Fact vs Fiction" where the Print team would take up some factual statements made by various political parties that day on the opposing sides of an issue and tell us, the viewers, how true or fictional they were. For example, central agencies raided BBC's office today. Then, we had two people dying in a fire while bulldozers were demolishing their homes in UP. The governor issue or the Adani issue. Random statements are issued all the time by either side, some of which contradict each other directly (even on live television). But, no media group fact checks them and informs us which side is factually correct. If such a series becomes popular and mainstream enough, it might even get adopted by other media outlets and make our parties more honest.
    Please think about this.

    • @tuckhorse
      @tuckhorse Рік тому +8

      America is full of wonderful people that came from India to make America their country. So in a way we are stuck with each because this makes us family.
      For sure we are a flawed people. We easily admit that and damn sure don't know what to do about a lot of our problems. With that said I got to ask, do many people move from India to Pakistan Russia or China. Please give my best to your family from ours 👍🇺🇸🤠

    • @illzn06
      @illzn06 Рік тому +13

      @@tuckhorse
      0) For the US government, there is a huge difference between the life of a skilled Indian who is living in the US and contributing to the US economy, and another Indian living in India who has nothing to do with the US.
      1) Like most other countries, USA is full of rational people who believe in respecting people of all backgrounds. In addition, thanks to the immense financial strength, USA and the other western countries have a robust law and order situation which gives some sort of protection to the immigrants from the nutcases.
      2) The suspicion in India is not about the common Americans like you, it's the government that has, in the past taken positions that are unethical and contrary to thier "principles". Take the example of the 1971 Bengali Genocide followed by the 1971 war, where the western world (mainly the US) supported a military dictatorship that was carrying out excesses on the Bengalis, while taking on a democracy that was trying to stop the genocide. At the very least, the US could have stayed neutral. But since they didn't, India had to seek help from the USSR.
      Anyway, we have moved on a long way since then and there are no hard feelings, but history is history.
      3) There are quite a few nutcases in India, but most of us acknowledge the importance of nations like USA, France, etc in the growth of developing nations.
      4) Like I said in the prev point, the perception is not about US the country, or the people from the US, it's US the state and some of the US media houses that sometimes peddle misinformation.
      By the way, strangely enough, there are quite a few Donald Trump fans in India (trust me) 😀

    • @the_Nameless_One99
      @the_Nameless_One99 Рік тому +5

      @@tuckhorse I get what you are saying. But, I don't fully agree. Sure, ties between India and the US are stronger because a lot of Indians immigrate to the US for jobs and eventually settle there. On the other hand, as you mentioned, Indians do not move to Russia, China or Pakistan. But, WHY do a lot of Indians immigrate to the US? Yes, the fact that the US is a "land of opportunity" and a very strong democracy with individual freedom and capitalism as core philosophies has a lot to do with it. But, IMO, a very important factor that might not be evident at first is - the English language. There are a lot of democracies in the world - France, Germany, Japan, South Korea etc. But, which countries do the Indians prefer? The US, Canada, Australia, and the UK. Why? Because language is not a barrier. For the countries you mentioned, Russia (speaks Russian, is too cold, is not really democratic or capitalist), China (speaks Chinese, is communist/autocratic and is almost an enemy) and Pakistan (failed democracy > autocracy/military dictatorship, failed economy, Islamic and a confirmed enemy).
      So, the positive that you mentioned wrt the US applies along with the ones that I mentioned (language, democracy, freedom and liberty). But, not to sound rude, there are a few issues wrt the US too - declining superpower, morally bankrupt, hypocritical nature, creating first world problems (like the whole gender thing), unable/unwilling to part with guns, lack of good leaders (Trump, Biden, Hillary), loves wars. I am not including racism, as we Indians take the cake there (IMO).
      I don't really know the point I am trying to make above, but these are just some random thoughts that I wanted to share.

    • @tuckhorse
      @tuckhorse Рік тому +1

      @@the_Nameless_One99 yeah ,im not a smart guy I don't know about all that stuff. I can just say I worked for a family of Americans that moved from India many years. He was a wonderful gentleman to work for.
      My brother out west is good friends with his long-time coworker who is from India .
      My buddies neighbors family also. My vote for president next election will be for an American with strong blood from India. Pretty much the only thing that matters to me and mine is their neighbors and family. I have four grandsons and they kind of feel this way also. Take care buddy 👍🇺🇸🤠

    • @tuckhorse
      @tuckhorse Рік тому

      @@illzn06 yeah we made a lot of mistakes in our 250 years plus history. Hasn't always been easy to figure out which way to go. Curious do you think your feelings will change if Nikki Haley

  • @dandmello5283
    @dandmello5283 Рік тому +13

    Shekarji 👍👍👍 ❤ we love your style of journalism of since then..1980's.loads of Academic info of the basic nature.
    You only has the capability to do it. please Keep it up and 🙏thankyou.

  • @mailtorajrao
    @mailtorajrao Рік тому +10

    Loved the episode! ...not a lethal arms buff and this was a sweet and crisp summary - thank you!

  • @Here4Now
    @Here4Now Рік тому +4

    Thanks!

    • @ThePrintIndia
      @ThePrintIndia  Рік тому

      Hi,
      Thank you for contributing to our journalism!

  • @suneelkanuri
    @suneelkanuri Рік тому +11

    Thank you for the detailed explanation about the prominence of F-35's presence in Aero India 2023.

  • @manojgaonkar5221
    @manojgaonkar5221 Рік тому +7

    Enjoyed the story, as much as your energy in narrating it.

  • @debarpitchandan2026
    @debarpitchandan2026 Рік тому +22

    Around 11:30 mistakenly some photos of LCH have been used against that of Apache

  • @kaushikofficial
    @kaushikofficial Рік тому +20

    I hope Shekharji or someone intended is reading this...
    Pls ask Franklin Templeton to change the ad ...it's horrible...it's a pain for 30s...lame to the core
    I try not to miss forwarding it, but sometimes I do hear on auto play...torture I must say

    • @mihirshetye4624
      @mihirshetye4624 Рік тому +1

      Yeah,I feel like my AdBlocker is not working when the video starts each time.

    • @SamirMishra6174
      @SamirMishra6174 Рік тому +1

      True, don't want forward the ad as I want the print to make money, but this ad is horrible

    • @harishs8567
      @harishs8567 Рік тому

      I thought i was only one to feel this way

    • @urrasscal8380
      @urrasscal8380 Рік тому

      @@mihirshetye4624 iidiots ..that ad is the part of the program ...u can't block that ad coz it is not included as a ad .this print wallas are very chalu they added that ad inside as a part of a program ..... but u won't understand this coz u iindian are the most murkh people in the whole world......

  • @rachjit
    @rachjit Рік тому +6

    Very good coverage of armed forces modernisation that was long over due since 30years.

  • @AkashSharma-wh8ks
    @AkashSharma-wh8ks Рік тому +3

    I daily see 2 Global Masters flying from Chandigarh to Leh. Such a Bulky Beautiful 🐦.

  • @akaj188
    @akaj188 Рік тому +5

    Very scholarly presentation , by Gupta Sahib , on Indo American defence equipment relations.

  • @surendrabarsode8959
    @surendrabarsode8959 Рік тому +5

    Informative video by Shekhar on the history of Indo US military purchases. Of course, henceforth India will have more deals from US but not as many for the finished products as for specific critical parts of the Atmanirbhar India designed systems, joint development of new technologies, co-production etc. That is the way to go for Indo US cooperation in defense. To be specific, F35 is not on our shopping list, however wonderful that aircraft is!!

  • @whowho4593
    @whowho4593 Рік тому +2

    I Cannot stress how underrated these CTCs are, Such a great watch everyday.

  • @manojkumarsahoo3119
    @manojkumarsahoo3119 Рік тому +3

    Excellent explained in simple way. Thanks sir.

  • @sanjeevbhattacharjee1936
    @sanjeevbhattacharjee1936 Рік тому +2

    Wonderful n enthralling piece of journalism …a hallmark of Mr Shekhar Gupta ..undoubtably one of the best in India and his new avatar of factual journalism is an interesting and a welcome change .

  • @abhigyanghosh9330
    @abhigyanghosh9330 Рік тому +38

    I love how while talking about Apache, the b-roll actually shows Prachand helicopters. Just goes to show how close our technology has come to the Americans

    • @srijoygan
      @srijoygan Рік тому +1

      That’s why it looked so similar. No wonder I thought i have forgotten how prachand looks.

    • @urrasscal8380
      @urrasscal8380 Рік тому +3

      use apache & see what kind of feature they r using & incorporate those feature in the next version of prachand. Ofcourse rreverse engineering is not part of a deal but still iindian scientist will gett pretty good idea about it's software but iindia needs research in metalurgy...

    • @JohnSmith-vn8dm
      @JohnSmith-vn8dm Рік тому

      Prachand is actually better than the Apache in some aspects like high altitude performance. The reason Indian equipment doesn't have the best reputation with the Indian military or in the West is not because of failures of design, the designs are often brilliant, cutting edge, and technically risky. Its because of failures of production.

  • @kannanv8981
    @kannanv8981 Рік тому +2

    nice CTC. Thanks SG and team

  • @abishekravichendar4512
    @abishekravichendar4512 Рік тому +6

    Hi Mr. Gupta sir,
    Could you please do a episode on new lithium discovery in J&K, and how it will impact Indian economy and mostly J&K economy and also Pakistan and China view about it.

    • @aaryansharmaa4019
      @aaryansharmaa4019 Рік тому +1

      NAhi banayega , modi ji ki jykar is se suni nahi jati.

    • @navneet8269
      @navneet8269 Рік тому +1

      Aapke is tamam conversation ka koi bhi aur chhod nahin tha aapane 50 60 80 Tak Jo details diye Hain vah samay ke hisab se kharij ho chuke abhi sirf do teen salon mein DRDO HAL ne Jo technology mein Jo bemisal development Kiya hai uska to aapane koi zikr hi nahin kiya aap khud ek narrow minded journalist hai jo Hindustan ki tarkki mein bhi mean mein nikalta hai Jara kisi Pakistani retired wing commander ko court karte to aur bhi maja a jata western country aur America Ko hamari jitni jarurat hai hamen unki utani nahin defence aapke bus ki nahin hai aap negativity se bahar nikal kar likhen 10 mai aap ko zero number fir bhi shukriya

    • @urrasscal8380
      @urrasscal8380 Рік тому

      is par debate nahi ..... 47' main popul. x-change kyon nahi karwaya is par debate hona chahiye......45'46' election result ---mmoosslim constituency ( Bombay Province 100% vote goes to M. league, Madras Province 100%, Bengal 95%, Assam 91%, Orissa 100%, Central Province 93% so on so on .....) 47' main he popul. ttransfer karna tha ....

  • @AndyKos
    @AndyKos Рік тому +22

    Professor, you forgot to mention that the Soviet Union and now Russia have passed to India, and continue to do so, a lot of critical military technology that no other country would ever do. So, it's not only about who sells more weapons to India.

    • @sshiva101
      @sshiva101 Рік тому +4

      That goes without saying. The essence of this report is that, Pakistan has fought India using US weapons and continues to do so. The new Indian acquisition of US hardware is a game changer

    • @mihirshetye4624
      @mihirshetye4624 Рік тому +3

      True,but the West also now sells many weapons to India,while at the same time Russia today offers most advanced arms to PRC too.

  • @dennisvazquez2140
    @dennisvazquez2140 Рік тому +4

    As far as I know Sig Sauer is a Switzerland company not American. I read a story many years ago that IBM was prevented from selling computers and software to India so India was forced to train and educate its people and forced to become self-sufficient in many high tech areas.

    • @EveryDayMan808
      @EveryDayMan808 Рік тому

      The company split. Sig Sauer Inc. is exclusively made in America and is an American company.

  • @kiranhoskere9932
    @kiranhoskere9932 Рік тому +2

    Fantastic episode. Thanks Shekarji

  • @mailmeabhilash
    @mailmeabhilash Рік тому +8

    F35 is the most lethal weapons platform ever created, the amount of data interpretation it does is simply Marvel on its own.

  • @tonyraheja1
    @tonyraheja1 Рік тому +1

    Well covered sir.

  • @respondto6323
    @respondto6323 Рік тому +1

    Excellent episode containing rare info that only SG kinda experienced & knowledgeable journos can put out !

  • @DipankarKaul
    @DipankarKaul Рік тому +1

    Such an in-depth research, right from the early days of independence, Nehru-Gandhi era to the most recent Manmohan-Modi time. The story speaks how much your researchers work and how aptly you put forward to your viewers. Thank you for presenting India’s defence equipment story so well.

    • @ThePrintIndia
      @ThePrintIndia  Рік тому

      Thank you for watching...best wishes, Shekhar

  • @mithileshkumarpandey8346
    @mithileshkumarpandey8346 Рік тому +2

    Salute #Modi #2047

  • @libertas57
    @libertas57 Рік тому +3

    As far as I remember, the major sticking point was always production facilities. Whether it was for aircraft or even steel plants. The significant turning point was Kruschev's offer of his latest front-line interceptor fighter, the MIG-21 with manufacturing facilities, provided Nehru fired Kurt Tank, who had designed the HF24 in India. Nehru accepted because it had become obvious that although the HF24 was excellently designed, Rolls Royce of Britain suddenly demanded unaffordable prices for the under- development engine around which it was designed, thereby dooming it to underperformance. Even the Gnat was bought by India off the drawing board with the intention of making it in India from the west around the same time.

  • @butan9019
    @butan9019 Рік тому +1

    Excellent analysis

  • @prosenjitsen5173
    @prosenjitsen5173 Рік тому +5

    11:29 these are "Prachand (LCH)" not Apache

  • @sshray1115
    @sshray1115 Рік тому

    A notch above brilliant ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

  • @siddharthpantoji3999
    @siddharthpantoji3999 Рік тому +2

    Shekhar Sir, which is your favorite military aircraft?
    @theprintindia

  • @ohyeahyeah6430
    @ohyeahyeah6430 Рік тому

    Can someone tell me what the 1961 war is, i've heard the term before but never been able to get a clear idea about the topic. Thanks.

  • @ramgopalkoda7044
    @ramgopalkoda7044 Рік тому

    Wonderful !!

  • @speedbird109
    @speedbird109 Рік тому +7

    Just want to share something on the F20 Tigershark.
    The ad of this fac use to regularly figure in the Scientific American magazine my dad subscribed for 30+ years in Mumbai. It had the original red and white livery.
    Many years later when I went to the US myself and visited the Dayton Ohio AC museum, I sat in the cockpit of this aircraft and took a photo. They have kept the aircraft on display and you can sit in that ridiculously cramped cockpit.

  • @harisundar8698
    @harisundar8698 Рік тому

    Great story telling of our military relationship with the US and its evolution. It was a treat to listen to SG .

  • @kidschannel_15
    @kidschannel_15 Рік тому +5

    Outside NATO, Israel and Japan have F-35 in their inventories.

    • @WORLDCITIZEN2004
      @WORLDCITIZEN2004 Рік тому

      The US sells F-35 if the US trust them completely.. Still the US does not trust India.

  • @seshagirivemuri6503
    @seshagirivemuri6503 Рік тому

    A very concise and informative presentation, Sir.

  • @rajeshyagnambhat
    @rajeshyagnambhat Рік тому

    Shekhar Ji
    A small observation . The picture shown at minute 19.38 is not a missile boat as mentioned . Missile boat is much smaller

  • @12345614489
    @12345614489 Рік тому

    Thank you Shekhar ji

  • @akshytube
    @akshytube Рік тому +4

    By the time record this episode, another bomber 1-B1 has landed in Aeroshow 23

  • @suvratjain9189
    @suvratjain9189 Рік тому +17

    Some of the pictures shared as Apache helicopters are actually the indigenous LCH, a.k.a. Prachand. This is a testament to how far the Indian Helicopter programme has come over the years. Would request a CTC from Shekhar Sir or Snehish about the state of the indigenous aerospace manufacturing & R&D setup.

  • @timmommens901
    @timmommens901 Рік тому

    Favorit speaker 👍

  • @reynantenuella9368
    @reynantenuella9368 Рік тому

    Wow!

  • @sanjaydongre
    @sanjaydongre Рік тому

    thanks shekhar for absolute info.

  • @12time12
    @12time12 Рік тому +1

    Don’t forget the intelligence and technology sharing too, india is working together with quantum computing, hypersonic weapons, and other important technologies. Very cool.

  • @srinik5758
    @srinik5758 Рік тому +8

    He completely bypassed how this happened. As if Modi n his team has nothing to do with it. Somehow everything magically fell in place.
    So much bias.

  • @mihirchitnis905
    @mihirchitnis905 Рік тому +2

    In most of the talking points of apache helicopter, you are showing images of LCH prachad helicopter.

  • @ekantokgb
    @ekantokgb Рік тому +2

    Also, American B 26 bombers used as transports in the strategic airlifts. They were modified by HAL.

  • @ArunPunnathatta
    @ArunPunnathatta Рік тому +1

    It is great to know that our armed forces are getting the latest high tech weapons from USA and how SG is happy about it... All these years our fighters were fighting with bows and arrows, 303s and Tipu sultan's rockets.... Glad that our fighters are getting better few now....

    • @rajnikantchande2677
      @rajnikantchande2677 Рік тому +1

      " ...fighting with bows & arrows.." is , I think, an over statement....it was more like fighting using stones & pebbles

  • @anvithakrishnan2147
    @anvithakrishnan2147 Рік тому

    Very good information

  • @arpangargsarmah5787
    @arpangargsarmah5787 Рік тому

    Hey yo!! Did you just put images of LCH instead of Apaches at 11:30 ?

  • @mohandas1621
    @mohandas1621 Рік тому +1

    Mera joota hai Japani
    Yeh patloon Englistani
    Sar pe laal topi Rusi
    Par ye engine? Engine Americani!
    Yahi hai atmanirbharatha, meri jaan!

  • @abhimuk7806
    @abhimuk7806 Рік тому +6

    Whenever it comes to India US relation I always quote one line from a song
    "Aapki dushmani qubool mujhe,
    Aapki dosti se darta hoon".

    • @d16024
      @d16024 Рік тому

      Sahi pakde hai Bhai 👍

    • @user34274
      @user34274 Рік тому

      very good one. very accurate

  • @sudiptodas1313
    @sudiptodas1313 Рік тому +1

    Those are LCH prachands .. only one apache ah64 was shown .. please correct

  • @SaSa-gd9qp
    @SaSa-gd9qp Рік тому +1

    Indian AF in market for some major upgrade in military. Previously Russian companies were the favored choice for india, but now seeing their performance in Ukrainian fields, they are going for US equipments. It’s a major change in Indio-West/ Russo relationship.

  • @arunavapal3676
    @arunavapal3676 Рік тому

    Sir the pics were of indigenous HAL LCH and not Apache at 11:23 onwards

  • @reallywicked1
    @reallywicked1 Рік тому +17

    A scholarly discussion by Shekar Gupta. Very well done . My question to you is will the Americans allow India to acquire these technologies for indigenous production .

    • @dipoboyrogu9366
      @dipoboyrogu9366 Рік тому +4

      no

    • @Ram6669
      @Ram6669 Рік тому +2

      No. How can you expect that any country going to share their cutting edge technologies with any other country??
      Even Russia not going to give you their best product.
      Once things get old,new technologies arises and then they will share these technologies.

    • @preranpjm1
      @preranpjm1 Рік тому +3

      Absolutely not! American's never ever will give transfer of technology.....

    • @break_it_down350
      @break_it_down350 Рік тому

      They gave that to israel

    • @urrasscal8380
      @urrasscal8380 Рік тому +1

      the answer is no ....america is not murkh like iindia ...iindia is no. 1 murkh country in the entire world...

  • @ThePrabutube
    @ThePrabutube Рік тому +11

    Hope we get tech transfer too.

    • @AdityaJape
      @AdityaJape Рік тому +1

      don't want us tech.

    • @sankalp6872
      @sankalp6872 Рік тому +6

      Nope. No chance.

    • @prabhatism
      @prabhatism Рік тому +3

      @@AdityaJapethanks for commenting this protest on UA-cam 🇺🇸. 👏

    • @rishavkumar1250
      @rishavkumar1250 Рік тому +1

      @@AdityaJape the beggar is refusing assistance?

    • @shubs3566
      @shubs3566 Рік тому

      @@rishavkumar1250 🤔 I think you need to revisit the definition of beggar in the dictionary.

  • @hardikyadav9204
    @hardikyadav9204 Рік тому

    Very intresting

  • @bhaskarjitborah1565
    @bhaskarjitborah1565 Рік тому +2

    Where can I meet u!‽

  • @kpkdhar3674
    @kpkdhar3674 Рік тому +2

    It's completely waste of money to acquire weapons from USA, because they are so expensive, those choppers cost more than 200 to 300 millions dollars each.
    India should invest money in their education and research of developing these weapons and defense equipment.
    there is no special educational degrees for studies like, weapons development, research on developing to defense systems to IITs or top engineering colleges, make them competitive.
    most engineers and scientists work at DRDO, DRDL, BD etc etc, just normal engineering students with general knowledge, not combination of engineering subjects, or subjects that integrate multiple engineering fields.
    most guys don't know how mechanical, electrical, electronic, computer science engineering are combined are work.
    If india invest heavily in research and funding to institutions with specific targets, these things are very well achievable.

  • @stevenkraft8070
    @stevenkraft8070 Рік тому +1

    Regarding the U.S. only selling F-35 to NATO allies. Finland bought 64 F-35 A2 fighters before it applied to join NATO. South Korea also has F-35s and Japan has purchased about 150 F-35s and Australia purchased 72 F-35s, and though these three are all treaty allies of the U.S., none of them are in NATO.

  • @RealChristianTV
    @RealChristianTV Рік тому +3

    Good information and analysis 👍

  • @visheshsanghvi
    @visheshsanghvi Рік тому +14

    Was highly expecting appointments of retired SC judges as governors yesterday and whether it is moral or not.
    Please do a CTC on that tomorrow please, that's much needed
    Thanks SG

  • @nitovatorsnitj
    @nitovatorsnitj Рік тому

    @11:20 - HAL's Advanced Light Helicopters (ALH) pictures were used in place of Boeing Apache!

  • @NeelkanthMehta
    @NeelkanthMehta Рік тому +2

    What makes CtC interesting is the fact-based data. In this episode reading from the archives to support the story and its authenticity. Thank You @ShekharGupta @theprint #CutTheClutter #AeroIndia2023 #IndiaUS

  • @samkay-od5jc
    @samkay-od5jc Рік тому

    the cream of technology a true wonder of engineering

  • @yogeshchauhan9311
    @yogeshchauhan9311 Рік тому

    @4:27 saw something popping out.

  • @Arjun-xr5kd
    @Arjun-xr5kd Рік тому +2

    This episode is showcasing the incompetence of Indian Policymakers than anything of appreciation about them.
    Imagine for a country & Defense market like India which fought many wars, is still a client state & can't produce anything valuable of its own.
    The newspapers in 1950s & 2023 publish the same news, Indian Govt signs deal with France, Russia or US to buy this & that!
    We in India likes to boast about our army's scale & mass, but how much material strength do they have? How much can India's industry back them? If only our babus had the vision for ToT or manufacturing in India about these purchases in 1950s! Even worse is that the Air India deal which is boasted as an achievement is Assembled in US & France not in India. So much for a historic deal that Vishwaguru didn't even had the strength to Bargain for a Assembly line in Gujarati? Or maybe a co - develp of an engine with Rolls Royce, GE or Saffron?
    But then again who's going to be their partners in India right! DRDO which works on Army tents & Biriyani to eat in cold climates to high precision material science in Kaveri engine is the "works for all" corporate in India, are they really that good for everything organization? ! Unless we pump up our private industries our nation will remain as a client state when it comes to defense equipment.

  • @lovenature9000
    @lovenature9000 Рік тому +1

    Take a opportunity while you get.it is smart.make india number 2 economy in the world.

  • @digetalised
    @digetalised Рік тому +10

    The distrust with Americans still prevail as Navy did not approve F/A 18 super hornet as ceitical tech releted to RWR was not offered to India. India was also not offered the latest AIM 260 BVR missiles and AGM100 bombs along with host of other sensor suites. US once again offered the entry level trim or as SG said the economy version of F/A18 Super hornet. Indian Navy approved Rafele Marine instead.

    • @digitalcommunist6335
      @digitalcommunist6335 Рік тому +5

      Rafale M made more sense anyway. It just the way it is with US . Unless countries are part of their treaty alliances ,especially close allies UK, France,Japan, South Korea, Aus etc they wont sell you best stuff.

    • @Ram6669
      @Ram6669 Рік тому +7

      How can you expect best product of any country with whom you are not properly aligned?
      I

    • @digitalcommunist6335
      @digitalcommunist6335 Рік тому +2

      @@Ram6669 exactly.

    • @sangeeth49
      @sangeeth49 Рік тому +1

      @@digitalcommunist6335 Isn't that what QUAD is all about? If they are serious about QUAD and its role in Indo-Pacific, I would expect them to put their money where their mouth is. The Europeans, especially the French have been long term Space and Defence partners : hence purchasing Rafale makes sense.

    • @libertas57
      @libertas57 Рік тому

      This makes sense and is in keeping with past American practices.

  • @yogeshchauhan9311
    @yogeshchauhan9311 Рік тому

    Assam CTC only 35K views and this one already clocked 78k views.

  • @ganeshsundararajan913
    @ganeshsundararajan913 Рік тому

    What is happening to the helicopter scam Shekar Gupta is accused off?
    Why don’t you provide an update and analysis on that?

  • @ShinwariTuber
    @ShinwariTuber Рік тому

    8:20 onward the Phone Appears magically on the Table under that figher Jet.

  • @utkarshsrivastav6693
    @utkarshsrivastav6693 Рік тому

    The polarity of Indian leaders decisions matches exactly with "Mithrokin Archives" details.
    Anyone else feeling the same?

  • @gaisingduangonmei8898
    @gaisingduangonmei8898 Рік тому +5

    Thanks for this great episode!
    One thing- please don't use the word/phrase 'inherited from the British' here because it sounds like the British Raj legacy is a good thing for us. It also sounds like a son inheriting something from his father, which in our Indian case was never that. We had a painfuland sorrowful legacy which still, we are trying to improve and move on from. Thank you sir.
    -Tamenglong, Manipur, India

  • @anandananthaswamy6589
    @anandananthaswamy6589 Рік тому +1

    Pictures of Helicopter is showing Indigenous Prachand helicopter.. Not only Apache

  • @mohitrana3540
    @mohitrana3540 Рік тому +3

    Sir my house is near to pathankot airbase and i have seen apache many time on the sky even one of it did emergency landing in a nearby village due to some problem so as you said they are used for survilence also in addition to combat...chinook I have seen two times ... sir i think in future Indian army is to be merged with airforce the future wars will be of airforce and role of army will be very less so ground force of airforce will replace army this will reduce cost plus this will give army also an advantege as even today army has helicopters like apache and others so I think that army in future is going to merge with airforce and it is going to beneficial to the country too

  • @soyuz281
    @soyuz281 Рік тому +7

    So far US had denied sale of F35 to any country that has S400 air defense system. India is a major user of S400.

    • @besam
      @besam Рік тому

      India 🇮🇳 has special status. The Congress is already authorized selling to India.

  • @ranajitbiswas8340
    @ranajitbiswas8340 Рік тому +1

    Keeping in mind the challenges from china all the time it is strategically discreet of indian defense think tanks to have good relation with both Russia, who is a all time friend and USA, and other powerful countries, as they want to help india and to be helped as well.

  • @thirupathivarma3024
    @thirupathivarma3024 Рік тому +1

    I watch all your episodes and earning lot of information which I don’t know

  • @harisundar8698
    @harisundar8698 Рік тому +2

    Great story telling of our military relationship with the US and its evolution. This episode is a gem.

  • @tapemaj
    @tapemaj Рік тому +12

    As you are presenting this episode today , news is coming in that Air India has placed a mega order of 220 Boeing and 250 Air bus aircraft’s from USA and France .
    Such importance is being attached to this order along with job creation in their respective economies that both Presidents of France and USA have been speaking to their domestic audience .
    Therefore this Air show in Yellahanka has back room political ramifications .
    “ You scratch my back - I scratch yours “

    • @urrasscal8380
      @urrasscal8380 Рік тому

      typical librandu bangali ... lost half of bengal in 1905 and gonna lose half of w. bengal to jjihadis within 30-40 yrrs ...where ever u go in w. bengal u see mia camp every where ....... this chutiya bengali allowed this mmooslim and rrohingya to settled there and ruin w. bengal ........... chal bhag librandu yeha se jaa k machli kha....

    • @tapemaj
      @tapemaj Рік тому

      @@urrasscal8380 😀😀😀😂 …
      Learn to write properly. Then reply to posts 😀.

  • @ThatsMrPencilneck2U
    @ThatsMrPencilneck2U Рік тому

    From everything I've read, the F-20 had a lot of advantages over the F-16 that really would have worked well for nations with limited resources. The problem was that without the USAF adopting it, there would be no updates, and the availability of spares and would be questionable.

  • @ramsinghjaganatharaja5703
    @ramsinghjaganatharaja5703 Рік тому +1

    All credit to our PM

  • @viklovescheesecake
    @viklovescheesecake Рік тому

    F5E Tigershark aircraft model on the table next to him…. What’s the story there?! 😃

  • @gilbertfranklin1537
    @gilbertfranklin1537 Рік тому +3

    For those of you who do not regularly watch the military channels, the latest versions of such equipment as fighter aircraft, missiles, artillery, ships and tanks is a constant struggle to see who can come up with the best of the newer and better stuff. But, I can assure you that having American made lethal versions will keep you at the front of the battleline. And considering that you are in a rough neighborhood (China, Russia, Pakistan), you deserve to have the very best when it comes to your own defense. Good Luck!

  • @siddharthabanerje2093
    @siddharthabanerje2093 Рік тому +5

    M777 guided shells, are we going to produce them? This can be a bottleneck.

  • @chandreshdave5063
    @chandreshdave5063 Рік тому +1

    Oh poor Shekhar.
    Now you will not get kick back.
    In any Deals.

  • @adityamukherjee7038
    @adityamukherjee7038 Рік тому

    Imo purchasing an American aircraft will prove to be costly for India in the long run. As such, I think it'll be better for us to just purchase drones (surveillance/UCAVs) and other things like ARs and all but not aircrafts, specifically fighter jets like the F-35 Lightning. The operational cost of that aircraft is absolutely mind boggling. Also, I feel that French or Israeli technology is really beneficial for the Indian Armed Forces. It's good that we're diversifying our sources and not just depending on one partner, that is, Russia. Simultaneously, it's equally important for us to get on with our own fighter jet programs like the Tejas Mk2, TEDBF and AMCA(which is finally now in analysing stage). I was really glad to see that more than 800 companies that exhibited their products in Aero India 2023 were Indian companies (public/private)

  • @Roadrunnerzma
    @Roadrunnerzma Рік тому

    Few of the apache images are wrong, otherwise great report

  • @coolboy71293
    @coolboy71293 Рік тому

    11.30 the helicopter shown is HAL not American

  • @Karan-pl7iu
    @Karan-pl7iu Рік тому

    These news don't excite anymore..
    But the ist flight of amca, tedf and a indigenous jet engine surely will

  • @aayakshchadha
    @aayakshchadha Рік тому +5

    Getting the f35 would be a diplomatic coup for India
    Not just the airspace , it could change indo-us relations for the next 30+ years.

    • @randhirnikam
      @randhirnikam Рік тому +5

      Not needed, US equipment comes with a lot of unnecessary baggage and lectures on how and when to use the weapons we bought with our own money and we will be dictated by the US on when and where we should be using them.

    • @gkbbkg64
      @gkbbkg64 Рік тому

      It would be useless .. since they will not give technology transfer for it ... make us like Pakistan, but from USA, then keep dealing with them for each spare part and missiles

    • @kedarisgreat
      @kedarisgreat Рік тому

      F35 is cheaper than Rafale
      No big coup here

    • @sid8285
      @sid8285 Рік тому

      @@kedarisgreat Isn't F35 the most expensive of all Jets?🤔

    • @sargunangoppalan7809
      @sargunangoppalan7809 Рік тому +1

      @@kedarisgreat nope the basic varient is slighly cheaper then Rafale. But the advance varient cost much more

  • @dheeraj86mathur
    @dheeraj86mathur Рік тому

    Singapore bought 4 F-35B last year with option for 8 more