osu!mapping: year 2 of "loved"

talking with Toy about the second year of the Loved category and player perspectives on mapping
Toy's profile: osu.ppy.sh/u/2...
twitter: / pishifat
patreon: / pishifat
loved map listing: osu.ppy.sh/p/b...
loved subforum: osu.ppy.sh/com...
first loved video: • osu!mapping: "loved"
second loved video: • osu!mapping: loved -- ...
loved map submissions: docs.google.co...
maps referenced:
Camellia - GHOST by JeZag: osu.ppy.sh/s/5...
Amatsuki - Chiisana Koi no Uta by Frost: osu.ppy.sh/b/9...
DECO*27 - Ghost Rule by caren_sk: osu.ppy.sh/b/9...
TheFatRat - Mayday (feat. Laura Brehm) by Voltaeyx: osu.ppy.sh/b/1...
shikata akiko - Katayoku no tori by elchxyrlia: osu.ppy.sh/b/1...
Aitsuki Nakuru - Monochrome Butterfly by Settia: osu.ppy.sh/s/5...
kors k - Insane Techniques (Extended) by RLC & fanzhen0019: osu.ppy.sh/b/1...
Unlike Pluto - Everything Black (feat. Mike Taylor) by CoolGuyRift: osu.ppy.sh/s/5...
a_hisa - Synesthesia by elchxyrlia: osu.ppy.sh/b/7...
Lime - Smiling (Speed Up Ver.) by elchxyrlia: osu.ppy.sh/b/9...
DragonForce - Heroes of Our Time by Jenny: osu.ppy.sh/b/2...
onoken - P8107 by Kloyd: osu.ppy.sh/s/1...
Morimori Atsushi - Paradigm Shift by P o M u T a: osu.ppy.sh/b/9...
NAOKI underground - L'amour et la liberte (DDR Ver.) by PandaHero: osu.ppy.sh/s/6...
Sakuzyo - FAFNIR by Sulfur: osu.ppy.sh/b/1...
Gojou Mayumi - DANZEN! Futari wa PreCure Ver. MaxHeart (TV Size) by Sotarks: osu.ppy.sh/b/1...
Ranko - Sei Natsu by Skystar: osu.ppy.sh/s/5...
Noriko Mitose - Unreal Player by mappers: osu.ppy.sh/s/8...
MY FIRST STORY - Fukagyaku Replace by Moway: osu.ppy.sh/s/2...
Kano - Walk This Way! by Settia: osu.ppy.sh/b/1...
Primary - Naked flyer by Nao Tomori: osu.ppy.sh/b/1...
SENTIVE - Don't Lose Luck (Short ver.) by LKs: osu.ppy.sh/b/1...
Basic Element - Touch You Right Now by Kiiwa: osu.ppy.sh/b/1...
Hanatan - If by Rizia: osu.ppy.sh/s/2...
Hanatan - Jishou Mushoku by Kiiwa: osu.ppy.sh/b/4...
Mamonis - The Sampling Paradise (Extended) by RLC: osu.ppy.sh/b/1...
Aoshima Moka (CV: Mimori Suzuko) - kibo refrain by Sotarks: osu.ppy.sh/b/1...
ClariS - Hitorigoto TV MIX by Monstrata: osu.ppy.sh/b/1...
Asriel - Kegare Naki Yume by Settia: osu.ppy.sh/s/3...

[@hypercyte]

8:53 "i um dont like it"
ok map deleted +1 kudos

[@kayineo201]

Who wouldn't like a map made by Hypercute tho?

[@ulko6036]

m a r k e d a s r e s o l v e d

[@streakertree14]

When toy introduced him self i hoped he was gonna say, I'm most well known for rolling a 1

[@pori8898]

LMAOOOO

[@Impcent]

*TOY DONT ROLL*

[@paper2222]

2:28 this is why you don't have a cursor the size of a hitcircle

[@ScubDomino]

the mod answering god DEETZ is back!!

[@bananya6020]

osu!mapping: Toy

[@qwuzzy]

Nice.

[@hyun631]

congrats being the first "Nice."

[@vertoHUN]

My conspiracy is that it was mappers those voted no for Insane Techniques, so they can whine about lower quality maps making it in.

[@DeviousHands]

i can confirm that ive been voting no on everything since the 90% change made it so easy to veto anything getting into standard loved, this conspiracy is entirely true !!!

[@MrJoezapyofrulers]

ok but then how can you explain why opacha didnt get in

[@vertoHUN]

imperialist spies, comrade

[@TruTrolldier]

mappers don’t even vote in loved bc we don’t care

[@lumineon.]

I voted NO for Opacha. I simply did not like the map.

[@xerxstirb]

Something that I've wanted to request from you for a while now has been an osu!mania special, or something. That would be nice.

[@bananya6020]

Pishifat,
osu!mapping: playability
it seems redundant but just having the info compiled helps my shitmaps turn into less shitmappy

[@osku2290]

Hello there

[@TheNakedPuppet]

I love toy he is the love of my life

[@kilianvo8636]

2:05 HEY THAT'S ME ,HEY

[@RoroTheDeer]

There isn’t going to be any forward momentum in mapping in all gamemodes until the ranking criteria is made less strict to allow mappers to have more creative freedom. BNs should also be aware that mappers have their own style and they should be judging maps off of that, not if it suits their personal tastes. That’s also a huge problem facing mappers today and is making the ranking process have a huge barrier to entry if your style doesn’t suit the tastes of those nominating.

[@wholetthispersonon]

I started playing before loved was a thing and I don't feel like I've played for 2 years yet...

[@boirjama]

About the rank section: As the most popular maps are ussualy the "pp maps", i think if the pp system changes a little bit from time to time it will provide the ranking section some diversity. Xexxar's proposals are intresting, like the high BPM buff or the Length PP Rework, people like changes on the game and we can see diffrent kind of maps, win-win imo. (sorry if bad english lol)

[@TheZorkas]

toy is my favorite human being

[@m4sterred853]

Here’s how I think we could rework the different categories of maps:
1. The addition of a fun category: this would be composed of maps that the players enjoy playing, regardless of its quality.
2. The loved section should be exclusive to mappers (or people who know what they’re talking about) when it comes to voting: this would allow to regroup high quality maps in one category. People who want to be voters for loved should pass a test to ensure they know at least the basics of mapping theory.
3. Ranked maps should be composed of maps that comply to the ranking criteria, regardless of their quality.
4. All completed maps that aren’t pending should be either in the graveyard or in at least one of the previously mentioned categories. Also, a map could be in more than one of these categories.
I think this would allow to have an environment that encourages innovation a bit more when it comes to mapping.

[@legokitsune]

kudos to toy for really bringing the loved voting to life in a much better way

[@snuffles-]

I love toy

[@emrep98]

it just takes 2 guys to approve a map even when the community dislikes it" and thats what i hate about this system but well i cant think of a system that work around that

[@infinite_cows]

I stopped playing osu! months ago but I still tune in every Sunday for you pishi

[@luca3812]

Toy is our boy.

[@Zarven1]

YES, add burai and 2b for ranked!

[@bananya6020]

i wish in osu!lazer every map had a leaderboard, but not promoted as much as loved, if it has a quota of favorites or plays.

[@derrrtee]

Electroblade can you stop spamming comments on this video

[@bananya6020]

Derr Rtee too late, did that 8 hours ago

[@osku2290]

Hello there

[@bananya6020]

@@osku2290 help i'm retarded

[@osku2290]

@@bananya6020 i am too

[@RaphaBaruffi]

Nice

[@VirginSlayerosu]

I dont even map but I enjoy your videos.. Nice

[@oxey_]

His voice is the best asmr

[@sweatybabypowderhands843]

Toy my boy

[@vgd6228]

legend

[@crestive1877]

I would love it if every single youtube tutorial had pishifat narrating it.

[@cjmurray6096]

2:57 wouldn't graveyard have worse quality?

[@thatoneguy2274]

nice.

[@DandyDude]

Nice. Also, Natsu (99) did nothing wrong.

[@huuishuu]

Interesting how he mentions that "mapping quality doesn't matter" yet on the spreadsheet there are a few maps denied by captains for being too low quality of a map because "doesn't belong in the category". Really contradictory there.

[@goldcrane7347]

huu I think there’s someone else that co-manages Loved with Toy. (Not saying any names)

[@hachikuji_mayoi]

I mean something timed incorrectly and without any structure at all would not fit in I guess

[@elkemist]

@@hachikuji_mayoi well yeah, if it hinders gameplay ofc. I don't think people would favourite a map like that tho

[@oxey_]

Take Everything l
Black, such a bad map but timed fine and somewhat fun, and still loved

[@celektus]

From what I can tell this isn't really hypocritical since "mapping quality doesn't matter" isn't actually an argument he literally made. There's a difference between just kinda bad mapping and something with incorrect timing, if these maps had say correct timing or Metadata (the latter being simple to change) then the only thing hindering them from getting in is the team finding these maps and the community voting

[@bananya6020]

How do you make your voice so clear and nice?
Also, what do you do as planning for these videos? I don't know how you get stuff this good out this fast.

[@mercylessplayer]

Watch his 2 years video, all your questions will be answered

[@bananya6020]

Pandan Pandaro *Nice.*

[@fidelcashflow5976]

giri giri ai.

[@novaue4905]

IKENAI BOOOORDERLIIINEEEEEEE

[@Vinnie740]

‘I am Toy and I’m known for rolling a one’

[@manasser99]

what is it with all these comments saying 'nice'?

[@mercylessplayer]

Ikr?

[@Doggo420]

@@mercylessplayer nice

[@GenuineRage]

Nice.

[@radekdarappa5193]

Nice

[@ixcors]

hi manasser
Nice.

[@askplays]

Nice one Pro Box LOOOOOL, that maps great, quit being salty.

[@youknowihadtodoittoem3579]

*N i c e*

[@asmylia9880]

Year 2 of Nacht 100 when? :^)

[@bananya6020]

i didnt know that toy managed loved. Video about toy?

[@Akeruyri]

this is essential a video on toy tho

[@bananya6020]

Yolou1024 that was what i meant

[@n3ktOo]

!roll

[@ixcors]

1

[@bananya6020]

!roll 2147483647

[@chitoge4321]

i love toy

[@rimi321]

0:00 General Kenobi

[@kaihuizing5970]

Hueellooo there!

[@bananya6020]

I wish loved had more people involved though. The maps many people don't check out makes me wonder just how many haven't been promoted simply because people haven't seen it yet. Perhaps if stars were back but instead they used something like hype (1/person) they could promote them to a list where more people noticed them, like a qualified section for loved.

[@osku2290]

Hello there!

[@Njox]

Toy Pog

[@user-br7ry7cz5y]

Its been a year now pishifat wheres the 3rd year video??????????????????????

[@Abyssalosu]

cool

[@0bread286]

I'm confused. Why can't every map have a leaderboard?

[@bananya6020]

Hello There!

[@osku2290]

Hello there!

[@l1mi13]

Saying that loved maps most often lack quality is the biggest understatement ever. But the loved section is a good thing because then I know what maps to avoid. With a few rare exceptions ofcourse.. I hate "fun" maps.

[@pronet227]

!roll 1

[@mynion24100]

eciN

[@bananya6020]

osu!mapping: getting attention

[@osku2290]

Hello there

[@bananya6020]

Goodbye there!

[@slashfly]

now that’s a lot of comments to make on the same video

[@bananya6020]

Slash also a lot of ideas

[@osku2290]

Hello there!

[@epicreplays1595]

Hey that me 2:00

[@AkkaOniVA]

*lip smack*
Noice.

[@TackKeyNack]

Isn’t 90% way too high?

[@jorlando1094]

Bro
Great video but that cursor is ass

[@bananya6020]

disable stacks in the editor pls

[@osku2290]

Hello there!

[@bananya6020]

69 views, 15 likes. Nice

[@osku2290]

Hello there!

[@4fiHysteria]

Not nice.

[@DempseyBoss]

hej hej monika hej hej hej monika

[@VirginSlayerosu]

What's the skin of your last video. Inferno ending FC

[@b00msticklol]

0 dislikes lets go

[@bananya6020]

Nice.

[@lokikaos3777]

Nice

[@weewooweewoo1414]

nice.

[@meiyagii]

Not nice.

[@hyun631]

Nice.

[@caj9949]

Nice.

[@A117-x9t]

Nice.

[@AngieYonaga]

Nice.

[@SmokeAndClickCircles]

Nice.

[@medischu5845]

Nice.

[@antoniomariani2678]

Nice.

[@memememegaming]

Nice.

[@sadzake]

Nice.

[@wyd132]

Nice.

[@LeMustache]

Nice.

[@kyupin1075]

Nice.

[@mcwgz113]

Nice.

[@crikhard]

Nice.

[@tarasRinakushisu]

Nice.

[@Yaa602]

Nice.

[@slinkie423]

Nice.

[@ALTCODE255]

Nice.

[@rack1994]

Nice.

[@mqnoarak5237]

Nice.

[@niu_arx]

Nice.

[@niku103]

Nice.

[@zenyros]

Nice.

[@melkemann]

Nice.

[@kameosaw1364]

Nice.

[@eyemuikai3062]

Nice.

[@josh1234567892]

Nice.

[@Doggo420]

Nice.

[@solitaire836]

Nice.

[@piotr88e]

Nice.

[@doinkson]

Nice.

[@Cubic1612]

Nice.