I think the yagis are no help and shutting down the mic is what you saw. An actual test would answer the question , but you changed two things and chose the possible explanation. That fit your pre conceived notion. You technicly proved neither case.
The antenna are the issue. I’ve flown control systems of this type for many years. Directional control or patch antennas always solve the problem. DJI puts panel antennas inside all of their new controllers. Cheap Controllers use inexpensive wire type antennas. This controller could be modified, but its cost prohibiting. Yaggis do help. It’s a fact.
@DadRandom it is also a fact that the experiment you designed proved neither assertion. Other channels have shown marked improvement by switching off their DJI mics. You seem reluctant to do so ....and the only time you did, you then threw another variable into the mix. I am only now starting my journey with the atom and do not have a DJI mic, so I can not do the experiment myself, I was kind of hoping you would.
Yagis are excellent for narrowing the signal to make it go further. Just make sure you are generally pointed in the drones direction. Random’s videos convinced me to purchase a Potensic SE.
Those Yagi antennas are for 5.8GHz but the Potensic Atom uses 2.4GHz so they won't work! I noticed that too! I doubt they're providing any benefit, probably the opposite as they are interfering with the signal rather than helping it. Maybe try again with Yagis that are designed for 2.4GHz?
Just did a test flight with the 3-axis gimbal Atom and some $15 2.4 GHz Yagis I found on Amazon. Flying over water so no terrain interference. At 7000’ the drone disconnected and did a RTH. With the Yagis, the drone hit the fence at 10,000’ and no signal warnings. Was windy so I didn’t want to try further.
I can't imagine the yaggis even worked...especially being they had no power source going to them. I've built a few different type of antenna and they all have a main driven element as well as a grounded shield. Without being a part of the reciever board(not slipped over existing antenna), I cannot fathom them doing anything more than causing inteference with the main antennas.
i make drones and i make anttenas...i was making drones before there was gps hold it was all manual then...before dji flooded the market...i make quadrafilar antennas for the differant bands wich work very well..lots of fun....excuse my spelling
@@DadRandom I have seen a range test that went the whole 4.7km and 4.7km back again. Dessert test and ideal weather etc... but it can make it. And i believe it can make the 6km aswell.. ua-cam.com/video/aLnm2SVQcvQ/v-deo.html
I can get to 8,000ft without any Yagis in open space but it struggles a bit towards the end. My HS600 and F11GIM2 will go to 10,000ft without much trouble.
To the "doubters", I'll stand with Random on this topic. After watching this video, I viewed the video posted by UA-camr "Drone Valley". The host is an engineer in the field of electronics. I was able to follow him, given my background as a HAM radio operator (General Class). Keep on keepin' on, Random! You have my vote.
If he he is such an expert then why doesn't he know the difference between 2.4GHz and 5.8GHz Yagi antennas and which to use based on simply reading the Atom's specs?
By the time you get the Atom and 3-axis gimbal, you're at or near the DJI Mini2 SE price. Why would someone buy the Potensic over the quality and reputation of the Mini 2 SE? Nice test to debunk the interference problem.
Not even close to mini 2 Se in price.. No way...i got the 3 axis atom at 370 $ Aussie dollars and the Se is still selling second hand at 550 650 and new at 580 $ so it's a big difference.. You still can't compare the mini 2 to the atom unless it's sold even at 100$ difference.. I wouldn't of baught it if it was, I know they are selling it now overpriced but when it came out there were many special deals going on
Olá tenho um TB sou do Brasil esse avizo de vento forte no canto no meu não mostra isso e do aplicativo mesmo presiza ter internet ou tenho que ativar alguma função no app
How do I reboot the drone? A bird crashed my drone and it has numerous error messages. Compass error. GPS error. Geomagnetic error. No one can help me. Thank you for your time.
The reflector and directors of a 2.4 Ghz yagi are longer. Not saying a 5.8 Yagi will help you with the Atom, but it's set tuned for 2.4Ghz will probably do you better.
@@DadRandom yeah, these potensic drones look like they’re getting really good, but many people keep telling me they just ain’t DJI🙌🏼 Thanks for the advice👍🏻👍🏻
@@DadRandomI did buy a refurbished DJI mini 2 off of eBay and I have had it for 2 years and I haven't had any issues whatsoever with it and I also had the 4 hawks modification done on a refurbished DJI controller and it will go all the way until the battery dies with no interference great video thinking about getting a refurbished atom se from eBay
Great video mate, Yaggis definitely do help, improve signal. I did a test with the mini se with the Yaggis on and got a similar distance just short of 8000ft. Yaggis are great! 👍
@@DadRandom I sure do mate, I did a video of them and with the Parabolics aswell, it’s very rare il fly the SE without the Yaggis , I’ve got the 5.8ghz and the 2.4 aswell 👍 Merry Christmas, have a good one 😀
I don't understant why you did not do the test with and without antennas. Moreover, the distance you made is the normal distance I do. And yes the mike affect this drone, and No this yaggi is not tuned for 2.4 GHz. Useless test.
+@mast3rbug The drone sucks ass… End of test. Control system sucks, camera sucks and the sensor is garbage from an old dashcam. Let me know if you don’t agree. 👍🏻
Yagy antennas help but why not make and amplifier that would push it up to 2 watts of power..this mote then enough amplification for the battery application..your battery would be out of power before you use all the amplification....what it will do is allow you better control of the drone over the various noise levels out there..
If you are trying to show reception it would be nice if you showed the live capture for fpv quality and telemetry values. We aren't seeing the video break-up, distance delay, instedsee your back
The first test i saw like this was interesting ,,, as were a few more . Why the digital mic test again ? not yours but an internet repeat video as per every you tuber but you have an amazing area to fly!!!!! When u tested the Potensic Atom SE you called it a toy ........ I say entry level but bang for the buck
I try not to watch other tests. I was asked to do this test by a viewer so, if I had seen it done. I would not have even bothered with changing out the mic. I really only wanted to try out the antennas
+@aesthetic8780 if you actually watched the video, the mic was turned off and …. I actually said I was turning it off. So, you are the only troll 👿 in this case. Pay attention, actually watch the video 🫵🏻 🤪
@@DadRandom f0ck, you are right. I'm a real insufferable æsśhole. I'm mad at my surroundings and projecting it to innocent dudes on the internet. Sorry. Love your videos!
No, the transmission range will be no greater than say… mile 1/2 because of the components used (antenna and WiFi booster) it’s ok 👌🏻 this is good enough at this time. I chose not to do the test, because this drone is better working within is current parameters. I know people want to see it, but it’s really a non issue.
I know everyone claims picsync 3.0 3 axis atom is 5.8G. but look at the back of the remote. Clearly says 2.4g.. you didnt squash anything. So infact you just have the wrong yagi..
I did 4100 meters = 13.451ft With the Atom without yagi`s ... The reason i had to return was because of the battery got to low. ua-cam.com/video/8ldr51WK_rE/v-deo.html Your yagi`s are for the 5.8ghz frequency ... the Potensic Atom uses 2.4ghz only. So the yagi`s you use couldnt have helped. But non the less .. i like the video anyway .. i always like video`s of the Atom going for a distance.
Thank you for your review. Bought the New Atom not the se, & YES the Yagi Do WORK, no matter what the know it alls below say. These are people that read something some where & take that as truth not knowing with out ever trying it out on there own.Hope I helped to dis miss the bullshi##ers. 🤪🙄👏
I think the yagis are no help and shutting down the mic is what you saw. An actual test would answer the question , but you changed two things and chose the possible explanation. That fit your pre conceived notion. You technicly proved neither case.
The antenna are the issue. I’ve flown control systems of this type for many years. Directional control or patch antennas always solve the problem. DJI puts panel antennas inside all of their new controllers. Cheap
Controllers use inexpensive wire type antennas. This controller could be modified, but its cost prohibiting. Yaggis do help. It’s a fact.
@DadRandom it is also a fact that the experiment you designed proved neither assertion. Other channels have shown marked improvement by switching off their DJI mics. You seem reluctant to do so ....and the only time you did, you then threw another variable into the mix. I am only now starting my journey with the atom and do not have a DJI mic, so I can not do the experiment myself, I was kind of hoping you would.
Yagis are excellent for narrowing the signal to make it go further. Just make sure you are generally pointed in the drones direction. Random’s videos convinced me to purchase a Potensic SE.
It’s a good platform, the SE price is really reasonable and affordable.
Other reviewers have proven its the mike.As well as getting further with standard controls.
I believe those yaggi antennas are for 5.8 GHz and not 2.4 Ghz.
I believe those Yagi antennas you are using are designed for 5.8 GHz and the Potensic operates on 2.4 GHz, which would be ineffective on the Atom.
Those Yagi antennas are for 5.8GHz but the Potensic Atom uses 2.4GHz so they won't work! I noticed that too! I doubt they're providing any benefit, probably the opposite as they are interfering with the signal rather than helping it. Maybe try again with Yagis that are designed for 2.4GHz?
Just did a test flight with the 3-axis gimbal Atom and some $15 2.4 GHz Yagis I found on Amazon. Flying over water so no terrain interference. At 7000’ the drone disconnected and did a RTH. With the Yagis, the drone hit the fence at 10,000’ and no signal warnings. Was windy so I didn’t want to try further.
+@richardcarr1090 yeah people who fly, know the truth. Good test.
Can you please link the one you’re using? I’m invested I need more range
@@Kelvinsmingus606 there is a link in the description
Can you link the 2.4 ghz yagi @Richard
I am able to get that range without Yagi antennas with a hill in the way.
I can't imagine the yaggis even worked...especially being they had no power source going to them. I've built a few different type of antenna and they all have a main driven element as well as a grounded shield. Without being a part of the reciever board(not slipped over existing antenna), I cannot fathom them doing anything more than causing inteference with the main antennas.
the reflectors would work more so than the the fake yagis
He's using 5.8GHz Yagis on a controller that uses 2.4GHz!
@rob1957 Doesn't matter what he's using on them, they're still ineffective without a power source going to them
i make drones and i make anttenas...i was making drones before there was gps hold it was all manual then...before dji flooded the market...i make quadrafilar antennas for the differant bands wich work very well..lots of fun....excuse my spelling
@@DaleK-j9g so, are we in agreement on this matter?
Can a different controller be paired with the Atom drone?
No
Yes, another Atom controller
The potensic is rated for 6km or 19k feet. You only went half that. Why not go for the whole 6k or as far as you can?
Because it can’t, it’s overrated.
@@DadRandomdo you think the dji can get the 10k that it’s rated?
@@DadRandom I have seen a range test that went the whole 4.7km and 4.7km back again.
Dessert test and ideal weather etc... but it can make it.
And i believe it can make the 6km aswell..
ua-cam.com/video/aLnm2SVQcvQ/v-deo.html
Why would you use a 5.8Ghz extender on a 2.4GHz antenna???
I can get to 8,000ft without any Yagis in open space but it struggles a bit towards the end. My HS600 and F11GIM2 will go to 10,000ft without much trouble.
To the "doubters", I'll stand with Random on this topic. After watching this video, I viewed the video posted by UA-camr "Drone Valley". The host is an engineer in the field of electronics. I was able to follow him, given my background as a HAM radio operator (General Class). Keep on keepin' on, Random! You have my vote.
Only my humble opinion. I like the ATOM and anyone who gets it should hold their head high.
If he he is such an expert then why doesn't he know the difference between 2.4GHz and 5.8GHz Yagi antennas and which to use based on simply reading the Atom's specs?
No this yaggi is 5.8 GHz and the Atom is 2.4 GHz. The wave lenght not matched.
You are using yagis for 5Ghz,and your Potensic Atom is operating on 2.5 Ghz.When you order your yagi specify the friquency.So the test is invalid.
With the yagi antenna the polarisation is either vertical or horizontal, there is 20db difference if you get the polarity wrong
They sell this drone in Amazon claiming 6 kms (~20000ft) which obviously is not true!
Lies… all lies
By the time you get the Atom and 3-axis gimbal, you're at or near the DJI Mini2 SE price. Why would someone buy the Potensic over the quality and reputation of the Mini 2 SE? Nice test to debunk the interference problem.
+@kodak_jack its always curiosity with me. I just want to see where the toy industry is versus the prosumer drones.
Not even close to mini 2 Se in price.. No way...i got the 3 axis atom at 370 $ Aussie dollars and the Se is still selling second hand at 550 650 and new at 580 $ so it's a big difference.. You still can't compare the mini 2 to the atom unless it's sold even at 100$ difference.. I wouldn't of baught it if it was, I know they are selling it now overpriced but when it came out there were many special deals going on
@@MiltonPapa The mini 2 SE is $349/ $329 in US dollars. The Potensic is $289 US dollars.
The benefit of the atom it doesn't have geofencing like the DJI drones
Olá tenho um TB sou do Brasil esse avizo de vento forte no canto no meu não mostra isso e do aplicativo mesmo presiza ter internet ou tenho que ativar alguma função no app
It was a strong horizontal wind. Look at the attitude indicator to see your drones tilt.
How do I reboot the drone? A bird crashed my drone and it has numerous error messages. Compass error. GPS error. Geomagnetic error. No one can help me. Thank you for your time.
@@guywilson8601 sounds like you damaged your flight controller. In this case, the drone needs major help. I think you may be out of luck 🍀
@@DadRandom cheers
Thank you for the video and info. I'd be very interested in seeing what the clamshell or a parabolic booster would do.
I can fly with one. They probably perform the same. This unit needs a patch antenna
@@DadRandomcan you make an updated video trying 2.4ghz
The reflector and directors of a 2.4 Ghz yagi are longer. Not saying a 5.8 Yagi will help you with the Atom, but it's set tuned for 2.4Ghz will probably do you better.
I was just experimenting. these were for my DJI goggles 2 which are a diversity setup
I see youve got ft and mph on the displays id been wondering for ages to expect standard or metric hud
you can have either on the hud, adjust your settings to imperial or metric
I am interested on where to get this support you have for the controller to adapt a larger screen pad.
@@AndreBarbowzki here is the one that will work. Just place it where you usually place your phone. amzn.to/4dopikT 🙏🏼
Great vid!!🙌🏼 I’ve got a question, for my fist ever drone, should I go with this atom or the mini 2 SE?
Mini 2 SE every time
I actually would buy a mini 2 refurbished if I were looking for a bird today
@@DadRandom yeah, these potensic drones look like they’re getting really good, but many people keep telling me they just ain’t DJI🙌🏼 Thanks for the advice👍🏻👍🏻
@@DadRandomI did buy a refurbished DJI mini 2 off of eBay and I have had it for 2 years and I haven't had any issues whatsoever with it and I also had the 4 hawks modification done on a refurbished DJI controller and it will go all the way until the battery dies with no interference great video thinking about getting a refurbished atom se from eBay
@@DadRandom over the atom? Why?
Wow 😮 i love this drone
Great video mate, Yaggis definitely do help, improve signal. I did a test with the mini se with the Yaggis on and got a similar distance just short of 8000ft. Yaggis are great! 👍
Finally, someone who knows the secret too. Cheers! Merry Christmas
@@DadRandom I sure do mate, I did a video of them and with the Parabolics aswell, it’s very rare il fly the SE without the Yaggis , I’ve got the 5.8ghz and the 2.4 aswell 👍 Merry Christmas, have a good one 😀
@@Drone.visionwhat's the maximum distance you get with the se
I don't understant why you did not do the test with and without antennas. Moreover, the distance you made is the normal distance I do. And yes the mike affect this drone, and No this yaggi is not tuned for 2.4 GHz. Useless test.
+@mast3rbug The drone sucks ass… End of test. Control system sucks, camera sucks and the sensor is garbage from an old dashcam. Let me know if you don’t agree. 👍🏻
@@DadRandom 😅😅😅😅🤡
Yagy antennas help but why not make and amplifier that would push it up to 2 watts of power..this mote then enough amplification for the battery application..your battery would be out of power before you use all the amplification....what it will do is allow you better control of the drone over the various noise levels out there..
I just wanted to give a thumbs up for the video but I don’t see that below the video? But thanks 👍🏻
Looks good to me. The far cliff close ups were nice.
Looking at the specs, the Atom uses 2.4G rather than 5.8G.
The clamshell may be a more effective signal booster then…
Dont think he figured it out yet
I noticed that too! I doubt they provide any benefit, probably the opposite as they are interfering with the signal rather than helping it.
so if the Atom use's 2.4ghz,and the 5.8ghz yaggis wont work on the controller is there a 2.4ghz pair anyone would recommend?
If you are trying to show reception it would be nice if you showed the live capture for fpv quality and telemetry values. We aren't seeing the video break-up, distance delay, instedsee your back
Nice video, but super annoying you don't use the metric system
@@barkeeperJJ 1976 we tried and failed at the metric conversion. I just so happened to be in 3rd grade. I know what no know. Feet 🦶🏻
,so how can i get the yagi antenna sir?
Click here to amzn.to/4ejlW2C
I just got this drone about 3weeks ago 500’ high and 1000’ distance is as far as I’ve got.. this video definitely helps my confidence 😂
The first test i saw like this was interesting ,,, as were a few more . Why the digital mic test again ? not yours but an internet repeat video as per every you tuber but you have an amazing area to fly!!!!! When u tested the Potensic Atom SE you called it a toy ........ I say entry level but bang for the buck
I try not to watch other tests. I was asked to do this test by a viewer so, if I had seen it done. I would not have even bothered with changing out the mic. I really only wanted to try out the antennas
Is this a joke? Or why do you testing it with 2.4ghz DJI Microphone?
So this is clearly a troll. You would turn the mic off with a real test.
+@aesthetic8780 if you actually watched the video, the mic was turned off and …. I actually said I was turning it off. So, you are the only troll 👿 in this case. Pay attention, actually watch the video 🫵🏻 🤪
@@DadRandom f0ck, you are right. I'm a real insufferable æsśhole. I'm mad at my surroundings and projecting it to innocent dudes on the internet.
Sorry. Love your videos!
Nothing come close with the DJI Mini 2
Yeah, especially forced geo fencing is fun!
Nothing? Lmao. Oh my.
dO YOU HAVE A TEST WITH THE CLAM SHELL VIDEO.?
No, the transmission range will be no greater than say… mile 1/2 because of the components used (antenna and WiFi booster) it’s ok 👌🏻 this is good enough at this time. I chose not to do the test, because this drone is better working within is current parameters. I know people want to see it, but it’s really a non issue.
I know everyone claims picsync 3.0 3 axis atom is 5.8G. but look at the back of the remote. Clearly says 2.4g.. you didnt squash anything. So infact you just have the wrong yagi..
yagi.....not yaggy
@@DaleK-j9g oh thanks spell checker . Should become a teacher.. stop being a Karen. And at least ad to the Original conversation
Also states 2.4GHz in specs part of manual.
For a moment i thought u was standing next to samsung 24 ultra advert
I get over 10,000 ft without any yagi... They won't help.
That’s awesome
You the best
thanks, i really appreciate it
Can you do fpv goggles with this drone?
+@emperorkalel no
Drone mask 2 is close as you can get
the C-FLY mini 2 better range
I did 4100 meters = 13.451ft With the Atom without yagi`s ...
The reason i had to return was because of the battery got to low.
ua-cam.com/video/8ldr51WK_rE/v-deo.html
Your yagi`s are for the 5.8ghz frequency ... the Potensic Atom uses 2.4ghz only.
So the yagi`s you use couldnt have helped.
But non the less .. i like the video anyway .. i always like video`s of the Atom going for a distance.
Thank you for your review. Bought the New Atom not the se, & YES the Yagi Do WORK, no matter what the know it alls below say. These are people that read something some where
& take that as truth not knowing with out ever trying it out on there own.Hope I helped to
dis miss the bullshi##ers. 🤪🙄👏
It helps without a doubt