@@nice2763 thats what im saying u would think Xander would've tried to make it sound more EPIC but i guess it was different for him in the anime ? Maybe
Sinful Shell feels so much more impactful in the game. Like it was truly the final blow. Yaldabaoth even leans his head back due to the force of the shell. In the anime, he doesn't move at all.
@@AngelYt-xs6yy that's the best part for me >Looking at only the Persona action available >"Sinful Sheel" >Hoo boy >Yeets god Also for me it is just better because it feels like YOU are delivering the final blown instead of Joker
I mean , it is a one season 30 minute episode series. They NEEDED to get it done as fast as possible for the runtimes lol Us steven universe fans suffered with this aswell on the season finale,,, we know how it feels,,
The game is waaay better. Yaldaboath actually sounds surprised that he lost to the rebellion of the world at the end. Where the Yaldaboath in the animation doesn’t seem to care at all.
I think the game was better in every single way. The sinful shell was done better in the game. I actually felt the impact when they used the camera cut in the game, instead of going into slow motion. I think it is better to feel the impact than to see the impact.
Joker's voice in the game showed pure, unadulterated rage, so deep that it was more akin to a vicious growl, while the anime sounds like a typical shonen hero... I think you know which version is better.
The anime did two things right, 1: The motion of Satanael aiming and the bullet firing(I like more of the scene on Satanael himself) 2: Ryuji said "Yeet"
There is just something about getting to do the actual killing yourself via the game’s combat menu that the anime simply cant replicate. I also think it looks better seeing Joker pulling out the gun and then camera cut to Satanael with his right after, instead of backwards like the anime did.
Saving the world in P3 from HIM was amazing and sad. Saving the world in P4 from that God was satysfing as hell. But sorry, saving the world from an angsty God during Christmas with an alternative version of Satan by an headshot it's just too epic.
Xander Mobus did a great job in the anime, but the few lines he has in the game are fucking phenomenal. I really don't know why they recorded different voice lines for each one though.
Dude the anime version had me chuckled by how forced and beta Sataniel sounded as opposed to the game when he sounded badass Santenial sounded. Now I know that's not how you spell it but that's how I heard it in both versions.
Fun fact, if you watch the Credits of the game, you will notice that many companies helped with the cutscenes including but limited to: studio Pierrot(Known for Black Clover and Naruto), TRIGGER(you know), MAPPA(you also know), and WIT Studio(Mainly Attack on Titan). Compared to one studio, CloverWorks, who had two works prior to this being a moe anime and co-producing with A-1 and TRIGGER on Darling In The Franxx. One was given around 5 whole years while one was given around two to three months. In other words: The Anime got fucked over.
Pillage him.. SATANAEL!! Vs Pillage him! Satanael! One shows the anger of man declaring an end. The other, a command given from man. Begone sounds so different
P5 the Animation: "Pillage him! Satanail!" "Impossible! You dare steals the wishes of humanity?!" "Begone." P5: "Pillage him. Satanael!" "Begone!" "Preposterous... You dare rob the people's wishes?!"
@@allenharper2928 To be fair, that is how it's actually pronounced. Obviously the game version sounds way more epic, BUT, the anime version is admittedly the correct pronunciation.
@@ThiccFurryBoi34 i disagree on both counts because in the game it shows yaldaboath rocked by the bullet like it actually knocked him back it didn’t just pierce him it blasted him also saying begone before yaldy can say anything is more fitting because he truly doesn’t care what the god of control has to say
They made 2 special episodes to complete the story. The special episodes are called "Dark Sun" and "Stars and Ours". This scene is from "Stars and Ours".
It is kinda fascinating how Anime reverced this scene a bit, with Satanael pulling his gun and pointing it, just to cut to Joker already pointing the gun, while in the game it is the other way around.
I'd be curious to see the scenes lined up together since it seems like the anime makes each cut faster than the game? It doesn't linger at all, especially when Joker says begone immediately after Yaldys final line, like he's saying 'shut up' in reaction to that instead of making a badass final order before ending the threat once and for all
I think the only benefit the animation has is the few frames where you can see the bullet making impact, which the video game doesn't seem to have Other than that, everything about the game is just better
There’s just no comparison of the impact of this scene when you’ve played the game for as long as you probably have. You just can’t make that impact and emotion in such a short anime.
I noticed Joker says "begone" AFTER Yaldy talks in the anime as opposed to the game where he says iy before. No wonder why the anime was less impactful.
Personally, I agree with using the All-out Attack, rather than Sinful Shell, for Joker's Final Smash. Though, I have pondered the use of 2 different Super moves for some characters, one beyond the Final Smash, the Infinity Smash (A guaranteed Instant Kill, if not Instant Win) Examples: Kirby would get the Star Sparkler from the end of Star Allies (Joined by Rick, Kine, Coo, Gooie, Adaline, & Ribbon [all his old allies against the Dark Matter forces]) Samus would get [Metroid Dread Spoilers] Pikachu would get Gigantimax Young Link would get the Fierce Deity (Like he should have) Rosalina would get her Comit Observatory barreling through Sonic would be joined by either Shadow & Silver or Tails & Knuckles in the Super form [maybe alternate between?] Mega Man would break out the Double Gear from Mega Man 11 And Joker's is fairly obvious, given the video.
Persona 4 anime was made by an actually competent company while persona 5 anime was made by A-1, who they also decided to hire to transform P4 golden's bonus content to an anime, for whatever reason.
idk, p4a kinda suck in my opinion, the proportion seems off most of the time and the fight against shadow kanji and so on are too comedic instead of being serious. kou and daisuke feels like the same person with different body, and so on. p5a just had bad animation and should've got more eps imo so it can fit the arcs better. the cgi was also well made
Is it just me or does animation joker without his mask kinda look like Makoto from P3? Also I’m surprised animation even got to shido, I’m watching it and it’s on episode 20 and just introducing Noir 😭
Voice direction can make all the difference in this case. Atlus made the calls for the direction on the game's voice direction, and I believe Funimation were the anime. My guess is that they wanted it to be different from the game's take and just went with, well, this.
the modern persona trilogy really went from emo jesus using jesus (somewhat) to seal death to a kid in prohibition shooting a bullet made out of people's sins via satan to a god's face to save christmas
00:00 Persona 5
01:23 Persona5 The Animation
Thank You! :D!
Persona 5: Want to see me kill a god?
Persona 5 Royal: Wanna see me do it again?
It reminds me of the goofy meme
“I’ll fucking do it again”
Strikers: I’ll fucking do it again!
Persona 5 Strikers: wanna see me do it again again?
@@Rezora06 Well, Royal isn't canon to Strikers so technically, only one again.
@@ShadowHunter31 true but not relevant to the joke
The delivery of, "Pillage him, Satanael!" was done a lot better in the game. The raw emotion in Joker's voice in the game just feels better.
Joker called out to Satanael much louder I’m the anime, that’s why it’s my favorite.
@@jasonmccool
he said it wrong though
@@catalyst539 They both mean the same thing.
@@catalyst539 yeah, i am kinda urked at the fact that he may as well said "Satan Eel" as if it was a fish.
Shouldnt be watchin in dub doe
This is a good example of how direction may affect the actor's performance
1:39 the Virgin "SATAN-AIL!"
0:19 THE CHAD "SATARN-AEL!"
Yeah he said it better in the game he sounded more badass
Given my native French background, I tend to put the emphasis on the 'Ta' sound, though I do prefer the in-game version as well.
@@nice2763 thats what im saying u would think Xander would've tried to make it sound more EPIC but i guess it was different for him in the anime ? Maybe
Wimp vs Chad
@@slickyami1877 Voice Director for the Anime probably didn't give a single crap
Sinful Shell feels so much more impactful in the game. Like it was truly the final blow. Yaldabaoth even leans his head back due to the force of the shell. In the anime, he doesn't move at all.
And he keeps talking for some stupid reason, plus in the game the silence is punctuated with the wind
@@cosmiclikesminecraft he talks in the game as well
Plus the feeling though get when u pick the skill truly a satisfying finale being able to take part in it
@@AngelYt-xs6yy that's the best part for me
>Looking at only the Persona action available
>"Sinful Sheel"
>Hoo boy
>Yeets god
Also for me it is just better because it feels like YOU are delivering the final blown instead of Joker
To be fair, you never really see the shot going through Yaldy's head in the game, whereas in the anime, you see said bullet go through the head.
The anima just feels like, “let’s get this over with”, while the game was like,”let’s let the player soak this moment in”.
They even give you the regular menu, most games would've just continued the cutscene
Really? What more could they have done to let them soak in the moment?
@@emptyvending8964 Drawn out the aiming and firing, changed the timing of the voicelines, and drawn out Yaldabaoth's death scene.
I mean , it is a one season 30 minute episode series. They NEEDED to get it done as fast as possible for the runtimes lol
Us steven universe fans suffered with this aswell on the season finale,,, we know how it feels,,
The game is waaay better. Yaldaboath actually sounds surprised that he lost to the rebellion of the world at the end. Where the Yaldaboath in the animation doesn’t seem to care at all.
Joker's lines in the game give me chills every time but the animation just sounds a little flat
Anime is better in my opinion
@@grimreaper5864 bad opinion
@@joeymcbeyn9546 only to u
@@grimreaper5864 I can't imagine you'd find too many people who played this game, watched the animation, and thought that the latter was better.
They did this scene dirty...
"sAtAn-iSlE"
They did the entire game dirty
They did every scene dirty lol
I love how joker pulls that trigger on him without a second of thought, like "oh fuck off mate"
@@oogaboogie no I would say they did Yusuke awakening pretty good
Every time I see this scene just makes me wish sinful shell would of been his final smash
All out attack is not bad though, it does represent more than just persona 5. But it would have been cool
Only problem would be spoiling the game for people that hadn’t played it yet
@@VioletVaniaComposer that doesn't matter to them considering sephiroths entire stage
@@headcrab868 *WHEEZING*
Have*
The game did everything better, but the impact of that bullet, I love it
Your opinion
@@grimreaper5864 He's right you gotta accept it.
@@grimreaper5864 why are you in a lot of reply sections saying you like the anime better lol
@@jcoolguy1548 because it is
@@grimreaper5864 I know it's your opinion but at least respect other people's opinions
Anime voice for Satanael was bad. But hot damn that sinful shell piecing Yaldabaoth was good shit
I think the game was better in every single way. The sinful shell was done better in the game. I actually felt the impact when they used the camera cut in the game, instead of going into slow motion. I think it is better to feel the impact than to see the impact.
Satanael doesn't Have a voice, he has never spoken. that's Arsene who is voiced
Arcana74 maybe he meant how the anime pronounced the “satanael” part
Yeah the anime did some parts weird, and it feels like the bullet is slower, but gosh darn I liked the bullet piercing Yaldabaoth’s head better here
@@personguy2262 yeah the game didn’t show it actually going through, only the aftermath. So uh, 1-99 for the anime against the game ig lmao
Wow, Joker sounds like his voice cracked when he said the line.
Here is the time stand.
1:38
I mean he is a teenager
Joker's voice in the game showed pure, unadulterated rage, so deep that it was more akin to a vicious growl, while the anime sounds like a typical shonen hero...
I think you know which version is better.
How about...Both of them. 😛
@@johnathandavis8430 Begone... *shoots*
@@dyldev0320 ...For real!? 😒 LAME!
By away, you miss, HA! Nice try. See ya kid!
Well Yaldabaoth did erase Ren's friends from reality
Rage? He wasn't mad
A thing I liked about the anime is that we see the bullet hit him instead of the game cutting to the bullet colliding.
Love how Yaldabaoth accepts his demise calmly. He knows he's been bested, and just acknowledges it before fading away.
The anime did two things right,
1: The motion of Satanael aiming and the bullet firing(I like more of the scene on Satanael himself)
2: Ryuji said "Yeet"
When
@@achoch When Kaneshiro's Palace was crumbling
Ryuji did say "Yeet" indeed.
Don't forget that you actually see the Sinful Shell go through Yaldy's head.
Xander and Max carried the entire anime tbh
1:48 Impossibles!
I just noticed XD
the voice changer
help me
Omg joker you can't like just shoot me that's like impossibles
You dare steal the wishes of humanity?!
@@4drsak Begone
There is just something about getting to do the actual killing yourself via the game’s combat menu that the anime simply cant replicate. I also think it looks better seeing Joker pulling out the gun and then camera cut to Satanael with his right after, instead of backwards like the anime did.
Yes the game version is better obviously, but I like how we actually got to see the bullet connect in the anime.
Saving the world in P3 from HIM was amazing and sad.
Saving the world in P4 from that God was satysfing as hell.
But sorry, saving the world from an angsty God during Christmas with an alternative version of Satan by an headshot it's just too epic.
Also persona 5 final battle is symbolic of the gnostic bible
*god
It's cannon. The Entire final palace is actually simply Die Hard
@@sungyinatra Sooo... P5's a Christmas game?
@@KickoffDeuce Yes.
Game does it better
Agreed.
sAtAn IslE
Agreed
Ye
It's ur opinion so ok
Jaldabaoth: Preposterous, you dare rob the peoples wishes?
Joker(Doing his best Captain Jack Sparrow): Phantom Thief
Mexican Yaldaboath: Jaldaboath
Hate that in the animation Yaldaboath says "Impossibles!"
And now you'll never unhear it.
Xander Mobus did a great job in the anime, but the few lines he has in the game are fucking phenomenal.
I really don't know why they recorded different voice lines for each one though.
Luckily, he got more lines in Tactica, but only during cutscenes.
Dude the anime version had me chuckled by how forced and beta Sataniel sounded as opposed to the game when he sounded badass Santenial sounded. Now I know that's not how you spell it but that's how I heard it in both versions.
But....satanael doesnt speak?
@@wolfwarrior1176 I think he's talking about the pronounciation.
Actually all the personas can talk. How else can they become of use to joker?
how did you spell it wrong twice... when the name is in the title of the video?
@@binkidoot1047 It's the way Akira says it is how I spelt it.
How did he go from " *pillage him* ... SATANAEL 🗿"
To "pillage him satanael 🤓"
Fun fact, if you watch the Credits of the game, you will notice that many companies helped with the cutscenes including but limited to: studio Pierrot(Known for Black Clover and Naruto), TRIGGER(you know), MAPPA(you also know), and WIT Studio(Mainly Attack on Titan).
Compared to one studio, CloverWorks, who had two works prior to this being a moe anime and co-producing with A-1 and TRIGGER on Darling In The Franxx. One was given around 5 whole years while one was given around two to three months.
In other words: The Anime got fucked over.
Wait the studio of spyxfamily made this?
@@Minecrayey yep
drawing the Desert Eagle was the best part!
Also the game pronoun on Satanael is way better!
Yeah, the game pronunciation follows better to angelic nomenclature.
well the game doesn't pronounce it better. it pronounces it correctly
Technically the anime does pronounce it correctly, although the game does make it sound cooler.
It never gets old for me. I love both versions
Pillage him.. SATANAEL!!
Vs
Pillage him! Satanael!
One shows the anger of man declaring an end. The other, a command given from man. Begone sounds so different
P5 the Animation: "Pillage him! Satanail!"
"Impossible! You dare steals the wishes of humanity?!"
"Begone."
P5: "Pillage him. Satanael!"
"Begone!"
"Preposterous... You dare rob the people's wishes?!"
Honestly I feel like him saying “Begone” last is cooler
Kenzie Same glad they reversed it
@@kenzie2191 as if the Joker is saying "Just shut up and die "
@@kenzie2191 however, preposterous sounds better than impossible
the gigachad "SATANAEL"
vs
the beta "satan-aisle!"
Did the director have him pronounce Sataneal differently in the anime...?
Yes because the voice director is probably different from the game's
It is.
He wanted to emphasize "Satan-ael"
@@allenharper2928 To be fair, that is how it's actually pronounced.
Obviously the game version sounds way more epic, BUT, the anime version is admittedly the correct pronunciation.
@@genericusername2426
Yes, but the game used japanese pronunciation Sa-Ta-Na-El, but thr anime used the real name with is just Satan-Ael
1:30 this is an orb of truth that dissipates the lies.
Imagine summoning a giant demon lord and just barking an order at him like that, I love Joker's confidence and enjoyment of being a phantom thief ❤️
Just got to this in the game on p5r gotta say that transition with the gun made me more hyped. I absolutely loved this scene through and through
The thing The Anime does better is it shows the bullet going through Yaldabaoth's head
Also when he says begone
@@ThiccFurryBoi34 i disagree on both counts because in the game it shows yaldaboath rocked by the bullet like it actually knocked him back it didn’t just pierce him it blasted him also saying begone before yaldy can say anything is more fitting because he truly doesn’t care what the god of control has to say
What the actual fuck did they do to Yaldabaoths voice
I’d love to see the animation again, but with the same delivery from the game, I wonder how different it would’ve been
SATURN-AEL!! ITS PRONOUNCED SATURN-AEL!!
i thought it was more sat-uhn-eye-al
Wasn't it Sat-uhn-a-hell?
The direction and the line deliveries is like night and day
Wait, didn’t the animation have the bad ending?? Can I get some help here?
They made 2 special episodes to complete the story. The special episodes are called "Dark Sun" and "Stars and Ours". This scene is from "Stars and Ours".
@@MertTech aaaaaah I see yeah. I wish they’d do a remade animated series based around this and royal combined
@@splatoonistproductions5345 then they should do Strikers story as well...
@@xBlaster totally. been waiting for strikers, but I can already tell it’s gonna be my new second favourite
@@xBlaster yep pretty sure they will
Snice coverwork getting better with spyxfamily ( yeah that who produces the persona anime)
I wish I had the Chad voice to say "Satanael" like Joker does at 0:19
It is kinda fascinating how Anime reverced this scene a bit, with Satanael pulling his gun and pointing it, just to cut to Joker already pointing the gun, while in the game it is the other way around.
A persona of Danny devitos character frank reynolds could’ve saved the day.
“So anyway I started blasting”
Pillage him, Satan Isle!
The only good part about the anime was the sound effect they put for Satenial's gun
The music is just perfect timing for the game
Imma tell you, the Yaldabaoth and Satanael moment felt like Transformers due to the sound effect
Omg, the CGI is so good in this
gotta love “satan aisle”
I liked how to game presented it, but I liked actually seeing the bullet hit him
I'd be curious to see the scenes lined up together since it seems like the anime makes each cut faster than the game? It doesn't linger at all, especially when Joker says begone immediately after Yaldys final line, like he's saying 'shut up' in reaction to that instead of making a badass final order before ending the threat once and for all
If only he said Satanael better in the Anime, because HOT DAMN was the animation in that scene great.
the cgi in p5a was amazing, sad that the animation is inconsistent
The Chad Yaldabaoth vs the Virgin Yaldabaoth with shitty voice changer.
The animation?
Pfft more like power point presentation
I think the only benefit the animation has is the few frames where you can see the bullet making impact, which the video game doesn't seem to have
Other than that, everything about the game is just better
this is almost as good as the Adolf Hitler fight from Persona 2: Innocent Sin
Sinful Shell should have been Joker’s Final Smash in Smash Bros Ultimate
I M P O S S I B L E S!!
Gives me chills every time, what a game
The shot give she same vibe as Sasuke saying "With the thunderclap begone"
There’s just no comparison of the impact of this scene when you’ve played the game for as long as you probably have. You just can’t make that impact and emotion in such a short anime.
The delivery of the line was definitely much better in the game. The headshot though was better in the anime.
I noticed Joker says "begone" AFTER Yaldy talks in the anime as opposed to the game where he says iy before. No wonder why the anime was less impactful.
Personally, I agree with using the All-out Attack, rather than Sinful Shell, for Joker's Final Smash.
Though, I have pondered the use of 2 different Super moves for some characters, one beyond the Final Smash, the Infinity Smash (A guaranteed Instant Kill, if not Instant Win)
Examples:
Kirby would get the Star Sparkler from the end of Star Allies (Joined by Rick, Kine, Coo, Gooie, Adaline, & Ribbon [all his old allies against the Dark Matter forces])
Samus would get [Metroid Dread Spoilers]
Pikachu would get Gigantimax
Young Link would get the Fierce Deity (Like he should have)
Rosalina would get her Comit Observatory barreling through
Sonic would be joined by either Shadow & Silver or Tails & Knuckles in the Super form [maybe alternate between?]
Mega Man would break out the Double Gear from Mega Man 11
And Joker's is fairly obvious, given the video.
In MY opinion for this scene, the only hing that P5A did do better than the other is how Ren said "Begone!"
the p5 anime has a lot of potential, i just wish the animation is way more consistent
Something that throws me off is how good P4A is to P4 when all I compared before was P5 vs P5A
Persona 4 anime was made by an actually competent company while persona 5 anime was made by A-1, who they also decided to hire to transform P4 golden's bonus content to an anime, for whatever reason.
idk, p4a kinda suck in my opinion, the proportion seems off most of the time and the fight against shadow kanji and so on are too comedic instead of being serious. kou and daisuke feels like the same person with different body, and so on. p5a just had bad animation and should've got more eps imo so it can fit the arcs better. the cgi was also well made
bro got the deagle
You see the reason Joker actually shot Yabladoth is because he said prepawsterous such a call back
Anime does it worse but Satanael lining up the gun looks slightly cooler in the anime
I prefer the way they did the bullet in the anime a bit more but the game did everything else better
The Satanael theme bro
Why does the anime cut the music. The music is what makes the scene so good
At least the anime actually lets you see the bullet hit?
Joker saves Christmas by shooting a god in the head
So... this is where the whole budget went... huh...
Yeah, the bullet and the chalks seconds take 99% of the budget.
As much as I love the game, I love the sound design from the anime
I think both did it pretty damn good
The voice in the game sounds very strong
Mans shooting .50ae into yaldabaoth
I wanna loose memory to just blind play the game again.
they need to merge the anime and the game it would be perfect
Fire the guy at bang zoom who directed the dub 😂
I always wondered: How did Xander get it right in the game but say it wrong in the anime? Did he get a bad pronunciation guide?
I cant tell if the theme is Our Beginning or Yaldabaoth.
The anime one really wasn't feeling that Igor revelation
Is it just me or does animation joker without his mask kinda look like Makoto from P3? Also I’m surprised animation even got to shido, I’m watching it and it’s on episode 20 and just introducing Noir 😭
They both do good
Unpopular but I like the animation better, it's like the only time the animation did something better
THAT'S WHY HE'S THE GOAT. THE GOAT!!!
Augh the animation one was that even Xander Mobius?? I know the va were the same in the games
Voice direction can make all the difference in this case. Atlus made the calls for the direction on the game's voice direction, and I believe Funimation were the anime. My guess is that they wanted it to be different from the game's take and just went with, well, this.
@@OurJynx Funimation isn't responsible for how it was dubbed. They just published the dub. I believe everything was recorded at bang zoom
Why does Yaldabaoth just sound annoyed after he is killed in the anime.
Emo kid shoots a God with a pistol with the help of Satan to save Christmas!
the modern persona trilogy really went from emo jesus using jesus (somewhat) to seal death to a kid in prohibition shooting a bullet made out of people's sins via satan to a god's face to save christmas
ImPosSiBleSs!1!
Nearly shit my pants watching this the first time I was HOLY FUCK HE JUST SHOT HIM RIGHT IN THE FACE literally the most gangsta shit ever 😂
The game easily did it better for this particular scene heck even the entire anime
*Miss*
Futaba:Joker missed!?