CUT COUNT UPDATE: The first test was on cuts that were ranging from 8" to 14" in diameter. I got 15 cuts on the first charge. I got 10 cuts on the second charge; however, the cuts were 14" and 15". I did the math, and that is about the same amount of material that was cut. Round one cut through approximately 1527 square inches of material. Round two was close at 1675. Even though there were fewer cuts per charge in round 2- the amount of cut material was pretty close to the same, which makes sense. I used pi*r^2 to calculate the amount of material per cut. So an 8 inch round cut would have been 50.25 In^2, and a 15 inch round cut would have been 176.625 in^2. I'd love for others to do the same test and let us know how many square inches your electric chainsaw can cut.
Have both. Like both. Have the Dewalt 16" saw and a Husqvarna 55 Rancher in 20". Husq cuts a "tiney" bit faster, but it's a more agressive 20" chain. Overall, I'd say they cut "comparably". Electric is fine for small jobs (one little aspen/birch), but you would need to own a bunch the 9Ahr batteries or bigger to cut down, limb, and buck a single whole large pine tree (3ft base diameter, say 100ft tall tree... normal). If you don't have a bunch of batteries (I only own two that cost as much as another saw), then you'll spend a lot of time waiting for them to recharge since they deplete way faster than they charge when you run the saw hard. The gas advantage is huge in that you just add gas. A tank of gas lasts way longer than the battery and when it runs out, it takes less about 1 minute to refill and you're back to work. If you have a huge job and are trying to get it done in spare time (like most people) that's a huge advantage. Also, if you run a saw for a living and need it to run hours straight, the gas would be better w/o question. Both saws are about the same price, but the two batteries cost as much as an entire new "third" saw. So overall, w/ a bunch of extra batteries, the electric costs way more and still has a lot of downtime to charge. The electric is awesome for quick "little" jobs, it's light weight, and it's easy on the ears. But for any big project where you'll be running a saw for hours straight, the gas is the way to go. Also, the batteries stop holding charge after time (just like a phone) and you have to buy new ones. Gas (as expensive as it is lately) is still the cheaper way to run the saw and for longer w/o a lot of long stops. For quick little projects though, the electric is nice. Owning both is awesome, but that would be hard to recommend to someone looking to spend as little as possible.
Nice! I look forward to seeing more on this topic, and on lawnmowers as well! About how much are extra batteries? Also, I was curious maybe how long the gas-powered machine runs on how many fill ups? Just in terms of how you think they compare, like how much hassle one is vs the other. I guess if the back up batteries aren't that expensive, the hassle is light, as they're easy to change? I would honestly do more work outside if it was cleaner. I hear you on not wanting to deal with fumes, or spills.
I would guess that the whole tree would be cut up if I used the gas-powered saw. I don't mind changing out the batteries (if I had more) since it is a quick exchange. It beats smelling like fumes for the rest of the task. Not sure about the retail cost of the batteries. I always wait for the tools to go on sale so I can get a tool and battery for the same price as a battery.
Thanks for the heads up. This vine had 5 leaves and was probably Virginia Creeper or something like that. There is poison ivy on the property which has 3 leaves that are glossy.
Yes. The 2 main types of batteries are 60V (as shown here) and 20V. Both can be charged with the same station. I have tools on both platforms so it is convenient.
I have not tried it out yet but would love to get some feedback on it. I bought the Dewalt since I already had Dewalt tools, batteries and chargers. Overall, I have been pleased with their performance so did not see the need to switch to another platform yet. Dewalt is not a sponsor (yet) so these are bought with my own money at this time.
@@SawHorseDesignBuild no doubt, I appreciate the reply. I looked at the dewalt but can never seem to justify their prices if I won’t be using the tools that often. My dad has all dewalt but HATES battery powered tools haha he’s old school
@@JsChannel8 You really don't know if the tool will work well until you try it. I own some Rigid tools, however this tool failed in less than 30 min for me so I bought a Makita instead. ua-cam.com/video/Ekrb_RHe348/v-deo.html
CUT COUNT UPDATE:
The first test was on cuts that were ranging from 8" to 14" in diameter. I got 15 cuts on the first charge. I got 10 cuts on the second charge; however, the cuts were 14" and 15".
I did the math, and that is about the same amount of material that was cut. Round one cut through approximately 1527 square inches of material. Round two was close at 1675. Even though there were fewer cuts per charge in round 2- the amount of cut material was pretty close to the same, which makes sense.
I used pi*r^2 to calculate the amount of material per cut. So an 8 inch round cut would have been 50.25 In^2, and a 15 inch round cut would have been 176.625 in^2.
I'd love for others to do the same test and let us know how many square inches your electric chainsaw can cut.
Have both. Like both. Have the Dewalt 16" saw and a Husqvarna 55 Rancher in 20". Husq cuts a "tiney" bit faster, but it's a more agressive 20" chain. Overall, I'd say they cut "comparably". Electric is fine for small jobs (one little aspen/birch), but you would need to own a bunch the 9Ahr batteries or bigger to cut down, limb, and buck a single whole large pine tree (3ft base diameter, say 100ft tall tree... normal). If you don't have a bunch of batteries (I only own two that cost as much as another saw), then you'll spend a lot of time waiting for them to recharge since they deplete way faster than they charge when you run the saw hard. The gas advantage is huge in that you just add gas. A tank of gas lasts way longer than the battery and when it runs out, it takes less about 1 minute to refill and you're back to work. If you have a huge job and are trying to get it done in spare time (like most people) that's a huge advantage. Also, if you run a saw for a living and need it to run hours straight, the gas would be better w/o question. Both saws are about the same price, but the two batteries cost as much as an entire new "third" saw. So overall, w/ a bunch of extra batteries, the electric costs way more and still has a lot of downtime to charge. The electric is awesome for quick "little" jobs, it's light weight, and it's easy on the ears. But for any big project where you'll be running a saw for hours straight, the gas is the way to go. Also, the batteries stop holding charge after time (just like a phone) and you have to buy new ones. Gas (as expensive as it is lately) is still the cheaper way to run the saw and for longer w/o a lot of long stops. For quick little projects though, the electric is nice. Owning both is awesome, but that would be hard to recommend to someone looking to spend as little as possible.
thanks for sharing your experience.
I bought the 80 volt greenworks model. We should do a head to head.
I have a couple logs that need cutting. I can get ESPN OCHO to come to document the event!
Nice! I look forward to seeing more on this topic, and on lawnmowers as well! About how much are extra batteries? Also, I was curious maybe how long the gas-powered machine runs on how many fill ups? Just in terms of how you think they compare, like how much hassle one is vs the other. I guess if the back up batteries aren't that expensive, the hassle is light, as they're easy to change? I would honestly do more work outside if it was cleaner. I hear you on not wanting to deal with fumes, or spills.
I would guess that the whole tree would be cut up if I used the gas-powered saw. I don't mind changing out the batteries (if I had more) since it is a quick exchange. It beats smelling like fumes for the rest of the task.
Not sure about the retail cost of the batteries. I always wait for the tools to go on sale so I can get a tool and battery for the same price as a battery.
Good choice. I can't pull start any Stihl gas chainsaw. What good is it if I can't pull-start it? Dewalt is a great chainsaw. Just add oil and go.
I agree. I almost threw my shoulder out trying to start my gas one so the electric was the better choice for me.
Awesome review! Thanks.
FYI: I think that's poison ivy on that tree.
Thanks for the heads up. This vine had 5 leaves and was probably Virginia Creeper or something like that. There is poison ivy on the property which has 3 leaves that are glossy.
Good intel. Can you get a whole suite of tools that share batteries so that the investment of them pays off with multiple tools?
Yes. The 2 main types of batteries are 60V (as shown here) and 20V. Both can be charged with the same station. I have tools on both platforms so it is convenient.
Wish me luck I’m gonna try it tomorrow 😂
Let us know how you liked it. I use mine every other week in the yard and I don't have to worry about finding the gas can.
What was the ah rating on battery used?
6 AH
I had a few questions about Dewalt batteries so I got a rep to talk through all of the options- ua-cam.com/video/nuLOCMhJyko/v-deo.html
Ever use the 40v 14 inch ryobi??
I have not tried it out yet but would love to get some feedback on it. I bought the Dewalt since I already had Dewalt tools, batteries and chargers. Overall, I have been pleased with their performance so did not see the need to switch to another platform yet. Dewalt is not a sponsor (yet) so these are bought with my own money at this time.
@@SawHorseDesignBuild no doubt, I appreciate the reply. I looked at the dewalt but can never seem to justify their prices if I won’t be using the tools that often. My dad has all dewalt but HATES battery powered tools haha he’s old school
@@JsChannel8 You really don't know if the tool will work well until you try it. I own some Rigid tools, however this tool failed in less than 30 min for me so I bought a Makita instead. ua-cam.com/video/Ekrb_RHe348/v-deo.html
60watt?
60 Volt Flex- this way it can work with other tools as well.
Essa madeira é mole
True- hardwoods such as oak would take more out of the battery faster.
Hi🙂
Hello- thanks for checking in