Innocence Lost: Walmart Footage Exposes a Terrifying Case & Man's Dark Secrets | Cherish Perrywinkle
Вставка
- Опубліковано 16 вер 2024
- Join the 10 to LIFE Community for Exclusive Content & Perks: / annieelise
.
For Business Inquiries: 10toLife@WMEAgency.com
.
All things 10 to LIFE: annieelise.com/
.
10 to LIFE Merch: shop10tolife.com/
.
Follow me on Social:
Instagram: / _annieelise
Facebook: / 10tolife
Tik Tok: / _annieelise
.
*Sources used to collect this information include various public news sites, interviews, court documents, FB groups dedicated to the case, and various news channel segments. When quoting statements made by others, they are strictly alleged until confirmed otherwise. Please remember my videos are my independent opinion and to always do your own research.
••••••••••••••••••
Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed in this video are personal and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of any other agency, organization, employer, or company. Assumptions made in the analysis are not reflective of the position of any entity other than the creator(s). These views are subject to change, revision, and rethinking at any time and are not to be held in perpetuity. We make no representations as to the accuracy, completeness, correctness, suitability, or validity of any information on this video and will not be liable for any errors, omissions, or delays in this information or any losses injuries, or damages arising from its display or use. All information is provided on an as-is basis. It is the reader’s responsibility to verify their own facts.
Comments on this channel are the sole responsibility of their writers and as such the writers will take full responsibility, liability, and blame for any libel or litigation that results from something written in or as a direct result of something written in a comment. Please feel free to challenge or disagree in the comments section - but 10 to LIFE reserves the right to delete any comment for any reason- so please keep it polite and relevant. WARNING: Walmart's Surveillance Footage Exposes Predator's Terrifying Plans & His Dark Secrets
cherish perrywinkle, rayne perrywinkle, donald smith, cherish perrywinkle cctv, jacksonville, donald smith cherish perrywinkle, cherish perrywinkle court, cherish perrywinkle case, cherish perrywinkle murder, cherish perrywinkle trial, cherish perrywinkle documentary, florida walmart, jacksonville florida, 10 to life annie elise, true crime stories, true crime youtubers, true crime, cherish perrywinkle walmart, donald smith walmart, cherish perrywinkle story Innocence Lost: Walmart Footage Exposes a Terrifying Case & Man's Dark Secrets | Cherish Perrywinkle
If you’re looking for more true crime to consume on this long holiday weekend. I also uploaded a brand new podcast episode today called: “Extreme Wealth, Sex Parties, Drugs, & Murder: The Dark Side of Silicon Valley.” As a reminder SERIALously is available on all podcast platforms.
Apple: podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/10-to-life/id1519456164?i=1000614845616
Spotify: open.spotify.com/episode/608DBddl8hVBh7zCf6B3cV?si=n8JD6sC6QvS7nwLzNSbmaA
Love love love your hair Annie 💓
Love you & everyone from the bottom of my heart, please slow down with speech , wisdom 🫶🏻🫶🏻🫶🏻🫶🏻
Wow Annie, Lots of details
7g7uuu7?7
@Annie Elise OMG! Your at 750,000 subs!!! Congrats! Your hard work is very much appreciated & it’s so exciting to see your channel grow & flourish. I am loving all the collaborations your doing, it’s awesome to see you work with some other great creators! Hope you & your family are able to relax & enjoy eachother this long weekend. 💜🖤
Anyone who is proven to be a danger to children should never have another day of freedom throughout the rest of their life.
Or they could've just given him the death penalty after that first kidnapping attempt. (which I believe was a 13 year old girl who hid in a playground tube so he wouldn't find her.) The death penalty would've been much better than letting him out, when they knew what he was trying to do, and they should have guessed that he was going to try to do it again as soon as he was let out. He is a terrible monster, and his demise would not have been any loss to the world.
PREACH!!!!!!!!
cut off their feet, keeping the money shot in the cross hairs & instruct they dig the hole to bury their own feet. they will assume they will be taken out by you if they refuse. that is not an option, they have no option for assistance in ending their suffering. they will dig until they have drained themselves from existence.. or test labs. let the critters out of there.. but Imo $1.30 is cheaper than 3 meals a day & prison life..
❤
👏👏👏
Say it LOUDER for the PARASITES IN THE BACK!
Those PARASITES being the members of the judicial system in this country!
Whom once again, FAILED!
I'm sorry, but she let a STRANGER go with her YOUNG DAUGHTER into a DRESSING ROOM not once, but TWICE, and didn't think anything was wrong?! I'm sorry, either she is criminally negligent, or she is just that freaking stupid.
As a parent, I agree
I agree 100%!!!
Definitely needs a helmet 24/7. Cause there’s just no MF way!!!!
She should be charged for neglect in the least!!! Hopefully someone took away her other children
@@sharigraff871 one of hee older children still living in Australia took custody of them.
This man is a perfect example of how some people are a complete waste of oxygen.
The "mother" as well 😡
I agree makes me so angry, that poor child never had a chance with that mother . Im sorry how desperate i was id never trust a stranger with my child
@@angelabernal4076 this is what happens when you give babies to unfit Parents.
@@angelabernal4076 shes good at making babies then can’t take care of them.
Yup. He should’ve been aborted
PEDOPHILES should NEVER BE RELEASED FROM PRISON
I can't stand that this happens over and over.
Definitely not repeat offenders at the very least. Though the mom in this situation also made mistake after mistake. I don't want to victim blame but she made obvious terrible choices of negligence
The real hero here is the girl that called in the van behind the church. She did her civil duty to be watchful for that van. She should be praised for helping them solve the case.
If she wouldn’t have called it in, even if he was caught with his pants wet he would not have ever told anyone where she was. She may would have never been found and that would have allowed him to run free and do this again
Yes! 👏
May God bless her. 🌷
Agreed. She saw something and said something, and that was exactly what you do in that situation
It's a shame the Amber alert wasn't out earlier because the woman said she had seen the van earlier that day, pull into the church car park. Like they said, if it had of been made earlier, she could have been saved.
It drives me crazy that people are thrown in jail for like 30 years or more for dealing weed but monsters like this get slaps on the wrist over and over
I mean if you don’t know why … 🤷🏽♀️
I watch parole and probation hearings on youtube, you wouldn't believe how many offenders have these hearings and the victim is left alone to beg the board nit to release the monster but no one from the prosecution nor law enforcement shows up to protest the release. However the amount of people who will show up and even lie to the board to keep a drug dealer locked up for life.
Cus he's white that's why
@@Angel_gamer912 cuz the justice system is set up to protect the types of criminals that created it
Ew don’t make this about weed. Jesus Christ. This is why people hate stoners.
You have people spending 30 years in prison for marijuana, meanwhile sex offenders walk free to re offend, until they do something so awful such as this. MAKE IT MAKE SENSE!
RIIIIIIGHT!
I can MAKE IT, MAKE SENSE! people assume everybody is Nice, Well Mannered, Charismatic when you don’t know what they do when people aren’t watching. Anybody can make a TikTok video, on UA-cam or Social Media but do you really know them.
And that's our justice system in a nutshell.
Yup it’s total BS.
@@experiment_lain3292 that’s not Our Justice System that’s AMERICA’s Two-tier Justice system just like we have luxurious prisons for Rich people.
The fact that that cop stayed with her so she was protected from anyting else broke me. Mad respect
Same, that cop did more to protect her than her mom did
Everything in this case broke me. I took about 4 hours to see this video. I paused to eat, ask ChatGPT some questions about animal evolution, etc. but knew that I "had" to finish this video. I wanted but didn't want to continue, but I had to, so to understand some things.
As for the mother, I understand that many times delinquents "outsmart" people just because it's an unexpected situation vs. a well-planned and crafted one. It's 40 years of experience in crime vs. 30 minutes of the mother dealing with it. All of us could behave stupidly when facing time-tested criminal plots. That said, I think that the mother falls in the extreme of the stupidity spectrum. So, in these cases, the best thing to do is to follow some thumb rules, as those stated by Annie Elise. DON'T OVERTHINK, JUST FOLLOW THE RULES. No boarding stranger's cars, etc. "But in this case he seems...", "But until now he has shown...", but nothing, just follow the rules.
I still think about the cop that stayed with my mom after my dad died unexpectedly until I showed up at her house and was able to be with her. Not the same thing exactly, but...the same mad respect.
That's his job, Dip Shit. A member of law enforcement has to stay and preserve/protect any crime scene until it has been fully processed and all evidence tagged and removed. I'm as pro-police as anyone, but the cop who happens to be posted to a crime scene until everyone else gets there isn't some kind of hero going above and beyond the call of duty. Stop glamorizing people doing exactly what they get paid to do.
That got my attention as well, true sadness and grateful for that Officer
I also blame the system! Cherish’s father kept telling them he felt his child wasn’t safe, but they kept disregarding his concerns. It’s so heartbreaking! I couldn’t imagine this as a parent.
And 4 decades of sexual assault crimes against minors, and still get the very bare minimum in sentencing. How truly manipulative is this guy to have fooled the system, including forensic psychologists?
Yep. Poor baby was just failed 😣
@@Shazzie_Roseright!! Are they sickos too???? Some of them must be……
@@Shazzie_Rose yes! The system was just useless all around unfortunately
Exactly the system is nothing but a big failure. They let creeps back on the streets and fathers are rarely taken serious when they fight for their kids.
This is exactly why sex offenders need to be locked up for life. They WILL reoffend bc they CANNOT be rehabilitated. It makes me so angry. Situations like this can be avoided by keeping the predators in prison.
Agree 1000%
They need to be offed after their first offense 🤷🏻♀️
@@marissaboomin General population. He'd have been gone a long time ago.
@@noomoon2833 true !!
@@noomoon2833 gotta love jail Justice !!!!
He doesn't sound like he has a mental illness. He's a predator that took advantage of helpless children. He knew what he was doing.
He definitely have a mental illness remember his stepfather did some things to him no child should’ve endure but it’s still no excuse he’s a MONSTER and I Hope he get what he deserve
My bio dad was a PDF file - mom had no knowledge just to get that out of the way - found out after he died that he had been SAd by his own father for his entire upbringing
I only mention this because while I despise what I know and what my family went through, I know my father also truly suffered. It’s likely impossible to come out of that kind of childhood trauma without a mental illness.
I truly believe there’s no way to eradicate this other than a life sentence in any kind of prison or asylum or chemical castration. The permanent kind. If they’re going to INSIST on letting them out of prison, they should be biologically altered so they’re no longer a threat. Probably a spicy take.
@@NotesNNotes no that’s actually the BEST, most thoughtful and level headed take I have seen, thank you for saying it. I’m reading comments saying that PDF files (ALL of them) should be disgustingly tortured until they succumb to a horrible death. I just can’t subscribe to that so it left me confused until I read your comment. THIS is the true answer, the way to ensure safety of the public without treating humans as sub-humans.
@@NotesNNotes You’re right, they should have the permanent one & the chemical one as well, they’ve still got their fingers. When I was a boy, there was a notorious PDF, who’s preference was digital penetration, he was imprisoned, always serving short sentences, he was murdered in prison but I have no doubt whatsoever, he would have kept offending if given the chance. These men cannot be “cured”, like you said they should be permanently fixed, chemically castrated and give much longer sentences, even life sentences because they permanently damage their victims, who suffer from trauma throughout their lives. Thank you for your comment.
@@sigh-ruh He was agreeing with the verdict. He wants to die but he's afraid to be killed, so death penalty is better in his mind.
Her mother, DCFS, and the justice system failed this little girl. NEVER trust a stranger with your children. That’s basic parenting 101.
Can we just take a moment and appreciate how the officer decided to stay with cherish to protect her body from alligators 😔 ❤
I agree with you, waited with her while I'm sure he was also traumatised by what he saw. I salute him.
That was an amazing act of mercy
That’s one great officer and one of the kindest thing a human being can do.
I must learn not to read comments 🙈 while watching the video.
Agreed 😢
The fact that she let HIM take her to the dressing room is just BEYOND me!!!
So do you think she sold her to him ? being she let him take her to the dressing .
Yup! Total stranger takes your child to dressing room?? Come on
@@soniag4516 Its like she and daughter knew him > Something is missing in this story like it was preplanned by Him and her both .
Sounds like my mom!
This …..I was like WHAT
The mom isn’t a victim here either. She got into a van with a stranger, let her child go to changing rooms with a stranger and then let her got to McDonald’s inside a Walmart with a stranger. That’s negligence 100%
Absolutely agree! She could've prevented this if she'd had an ounce of sense in her head. She sounded drugged in the 911 call too.
I just cannot understand her at all… she definitely doesn’t seem like she’s all there!
He probably offered her drugs cus that night he was also under drugs that’s what he said
@@elsiemendez3743 that makes way more sense than a gift card. I wouldn't even be surprised if she let him "borrow" the girl in exchange for drugs.
I completely agree! The mother should have got some kind of legal punishment for her part in this.
the fact that he didn’t stay behind bars for the rest of his life and was let out after EVERY SINGLE OFFENSE is beyond me
I’m just FLABBERGASTED by how gullible the mom was and how OBVIOUS the man made his intentions
Maybe this is mean, but I feel like she’s literally stupid 🤦♀️
I don't think she was . 😢
That's what I am saying this could of been preventable
She knew what he wanted and dangled the bait for 150 bucks trying to buy her heels too tall a stripper (her) wouldn't wear
She trusted this guy because HE WAS GOING TO SPEND MONEY ON HER AND THE GIRLS!! A COMPLETE STRANGER - NOTHING ODD ABOUT THAT, RIGHT??? Mom was CLUELESS!! TRUST NO ONE!!!
How monsters like him continually get released just to destroy more lives is beyond me. I heard Cherish’s story a few months ago & sobbed for what that poor precious girl had to endure. Absolutely heart wrenching
Democrats and bail reform is why this keeps happening. Dont take my word for it look into it for youself.
People like Don need to get a life sentence the first time they're convicted for assault on a child.
It's satan's world. Destroying children's psyche & morals is key.
Tutorial: what not to do.
I always wondered why many people sit in prison for life over drug charges but time and time again, pedos are let off easy.
Repeat offenders is a must, and after being caught so many times - then it becomes a case of murder in hopes to not have their crimes reported.
I don’t fault this mother. She was desperate for the cash , thought it was one and then the other - this man should have never been out in the first place and if the call of him lurking at a Walmart was taken seriously- it may have stopped this situation. Nothing in this world is free - no one is “nice” to a child for other reasons. Would I have let my child walk alone with the man - NOPE. But she was desperate to have money to provide for her child. How much time he invested , like she said “grooming “ them. So many things failed to cause this serious case and I’m happy the siblings atleast get to live with family in the end.
Poor Cherish !!
Mom's 911 call infuriates me. She KNEW something was wrong, repeatedly, and she still let him take her. She sounds high af. That little girl went through the worst of the worst at Don's hands and her mom basically offered her up. This story is sickening.
yes oi she did sound high!! makes a lot of sense
"I hope he's not raping her or murdering her" she knew exactly what the consequences could be...she didn't care about her daughter at all. The fact that this happened at 11pm the night before the child was going to be spending the summer with her dad makes me extra sus. Why bring out a kid who has to take a cross country flight the next day (at 4am) and keep them out til almost midnight?? I think she was perfectly okay with her child being taken, as far as she was concerned it was happening anyway. What an evil cunt....I hope karma gets her bad bad.
Oh she was absolutely hi. Without question. She was so calm and the way she explains the whole story. If something like that happened to my child I would be screaming I would be like my daughter's missing get your ass up ind my f****** daughter. Im leaving I'm going to find my daughter right now I got to hang up. I wouldn't be telling them a whole movie. I don't have time to have a whole back-and-forth conversation with them.
Don’t blame being high for her bad parenting, there’s plenty of parents who smoke weed and properly care for their kids. She’s just not a good mother, plain and simple.
Ikr! How could she do that. It's senseless. Whatever the child needed wasn't that serious. Like her dad couldn't get her whatever it was. I'm starting to believe the mom is a druggie.
The title should be, “what not to do as a parent.” This baffles me. Like how could a mother allow all this?
This is when DAs and Judges should be held accountable as well. When they allow people to repeat offend and allow them at any point to walk among society, that criminal should then be that judge/DAs responsibility and should face the same penalty as the criminals and this crap would stop!
How vile!!!! What a high price!
😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊
They are just like Don Smith. Just haven’t been caught. .
ABSOLUTELY..MAYBE if we had ACTUAL accountability for these Injustices..things would Change. And if the punishment was not an INSULT maybe it wouldn't be an epidemic of INHUMAN behavior
Thank you, I was just thinking the same thing, it has to be public defender's and judges , it is just awful this guy was on the loose!
👍
It is insane to see all the ways Cherish was failed by her mother and the system. The fact that Billy was just constantly denied full custody no matter what happened with her mom was bad enough. Then you see all the times this monster was just let back out into the world no matter what he did... It's just sickening. Yes, the mom is at fault her, but she was far from the first one to fail Cherish.
Ikr? Failed by the system for not allowing her bio Dad full custody... Then by her mom for not protecting her.... And by the justice system for letting this sicko back on the streets! 😭😡
Thank you for bringing up the two factors on my mind. One was how frequently the legal system handed down such light sentences to Don despite the violent and repetitive nature of his crimes, and how DCFS kept denying Billy's petitions to be given primary custody of Cherish, his own daughter. If the system had done a better job of keeping a dangerous predator imprisoned and/or granted Billy custody of Cherish, she would be alive.
@ J Liberatore Sadly it took a death for the legal system to lock this man up and throw away the key, Sad that The mother's desperation made her ignore her instincts. The unfortunate ripple effect was that the father lost his kid.
No she WAS the first one to fail her child! It’s her child and her main thing in life is to protect your children from anyone! Everyone else apart from the dad failed her too but the mother was completely the first person in that poor girls life to fail her!
How do you know that bio dad was better?
I usually find myself agreeing 100% with you Annie, but not today. She was not naive, she was negligent, and her baby suffered the consequences
I agree.
Too stupid to be raising children in my opinion…
Yup
Agreed
but the dad musta been worse, to give custody to a homeless mum if she was homeless? I don't really believe that part, unless the Dad was already known to police. Otherwise the dad would be buying her the dresses for her holiday.imho
This is probably one of the most horrifying story I’ve ever heard!
If I have to see how any good happened from this tragic story is that Cherish’s little sisters where adopted by their aunt in Australia and got a brand new chance in life.
Those two girls will forever carry trauma, but now they have a stable loving and safe family to care for them.
The part that truly chaps my cheeks is the fact that Cherish’s father fought for her. The system failed that baby because there were clear signs of extreme negligence. She was unfit as a parent and her reasoning skill were simply absent.
More outrageous is the other side of the system the kept unleashing such a creature into society.
BOTH SIDES are completely outrageous the system failed because, ya know, "woman" and "maps," smh! And to think that today pedos are being supported in many college universities by aligning them with the LGBT, something Christians have been warning about for decades and here we are with exactly this occurring. Pedophilia lines up with LGBT to some people somehow and they actually have the audacity to say it out allowed in class! wow, go figure!
My Mom is severely bipolar and has never stayed on her meds for more than a year. My Dad fought for custody of me for 3 years before it was granted to him. This was the early 90s so pretty rare. I think the way fathers are treated in the court system is insane. I just happened to be one of the lucky ones.
Countless studies show children are UNSAFE in the care of single mothers. We can't solve the issue of sin in the world, but we can correct the failure of our modern 'Divorce Culture' to protect children. The wife AND children are SAFEST when they are the BIOLOGICAL FATHER. And live in replacement puts them at a 20x HIGHER risk.
Only in 13% of child custody cases do men get custody of their children. Like an attorney once told me "Unless you can prove she's on drugs or tried to kill you, she'll get custody"
When the mom says she blames herself….she absolutely should. She should have protected her child.
She let him take her daughter to the dressing room twice for the free shopping spree come on how naive or stupid she thinks Americans are.
this is just a thought. where in the hell are the fathers and other relatives. yes the woman was wrong but sometimes the mother gives out and does stupid things. i use to blame women until i become
a single parent , doing it alone . we made it because i held on to THE MOST HIGH. without him it
would have been 10 times worse.
She’s an awful mother.
I agree that she has to share some of the blame and she will as long as she lives. However, the fact remains that this demon killed this baby. He is getting what he deserves!
In fact, he should have permanently locked away along time ago!
That poor woman who testified about him trying to kidnap her at 13. Now she can also have some peace knowing he will die in prison!
She used her daughter as bait.
I'm willing to bet that Cherish's dad would have HAPPILY bought her anything she wanted when she got there, and from the looks of it, it would have been much better than anything her mom could have provided. As a mom of 5, Rayne's choices baffle me. It's not this hard to not be THAT stupid when it comes to protecting your kids. Maybe I'm being harsh, but man this was infuriating.
That's what I was thinking. She should have just sent her with what she had and her dad could have gotten her stuff.
ya well if her DAD was so great then she would have already had everything she needed, at any time he could mail the items or money... you don't allow your kid to go without while they live with one parent and only provide when you have the child.. NO ONE did anything wrong but that disgusting pig
@@jimmyknows-p4mhow dare you criticize the father! Your type is always speaking nonsensically, you realize the court wouldn’t let him have custody. You know what, shut up, you aren’t worth any more of my time.
@@jimmyknows-p4mou sound SO ignorant! He was paying child support. You can pay what the court ordered but moms in control of that $$. Being she didn’t wk & struggled it obviously didn’t go to the needs of the child. Sadly courts FAIL kids everyday in our country and he was only going by all the denials the courts gave him. What was he supposed to keep her on one of there visits and get put in jail or Contempt in court when the court don’t believe you don’t go over well. And contempts of court wouldnt help his case for full custody. He did what he should have done by fighting for his rights then visitation then longer visits. Sadly the only way the court believed she was unfit was AFTER she was so irresponsible & negligent that the daughter is now DEAD! Court believe him now? Well too late! It’s not his fault. You sound really stupid w that comment. Tons of dads pay child support or even buy things and I’m sure she could have went w the clothes on her back an he would have provided being he was prepared to keep her permanently. The one who is to blame is the sick Fukk that raped and killed here! But but! The mother LET that disgusting pos have open access to be able to walk out the door w her! The mother was very irresponsible! You can’t trust any one w told kids that you just met. Idc how desperate she was for clothes. Such a sad excuse.
She would spend child support money on drugs thats why she couldn't afforf a 10$ dress for her daughter
this is yet ANOTHER example of how the system failed this family.. the mother was totally unfit & should have never had custody of ANY child. it's just mind blowing how much common sense she lacked ..
This is on the justice system. How on earth do you let someone out to reoffend for 4 decades. Someone should be held accountable for allowing this vile evil thing to harm and violate children over and over and over. This was preventable!
The mother should bear that guilt too..she handed her daughter to that man
Totally agree, he should never have been out in society!!
@@justshay she didn’t know his past the system that let him out did!!
@@kalliesinger967 Are you serious, so your gonna give your children to unknown strangers just because they helped you buy something at the Store.
AGREE this chomo Pos shouldn't have been out sleazing around
This guy is not crazy. He’s a sick predator, a hunter, and he preys on children. He was never going to stop. He knows exactly what he’s doing.
He saw the perfect prey. An overwhelmed mom with a crying child because they couldn't afford a dress. Mom had bad feelings but preditors know how to put people at ease. That's how they get their victims. People think that they would recognize a predator but they don't look like monsters. They look like "everyone". Always follow your gut. Even if your child is upset. Kids will get over not getting a dress. There was no coming back from Don. His jail interview with his mom made me sick 🤢🤮
Curious: what part of “kidnaps, abuses, and murders children” strikes you as the actions of a sane human being?
I don't care if he's crazy; should've been neutralized decades ago.
Yep!!!!!
@@DanLovesBooks There's a difference between being "insane" and just being plain evil.
"Insane" people who commit these kinds of crimes usually do not plan or try to cover up what they have done. It's usually a break from reality where they don't really know what they're doing and whether its right or wrong. Those kinds of people usually commit the crime and once they are brought back to reality, they usually feel a lot of remorse for their actions.
People who aren't insane and commit these crimes are usually people with an extreme lack of empathy, or none at all. They know what they are doing is bad but they don't care and a lot of them actually take some kind of sick pleasure in doing what they are doing.
I can't imagine being more concerned about a stranger's feelings than protecting my own child. And why do these monsters keep getting so many chances with such clear indications of serious danger and many offences
Seriously she literally put that child in his hand he didn’t have to abduct her because she was given to him smfh I’m disgusted
I remember getting into a taxi van with my mother and baby brother… I was a minor and I noticed the door only had locks on the outside and no air. My mother removed us and the guy kept saying what’s wrong 🤦🏻♀️ mind you we was in another country and it was dark
F being polite. When it comes to my safety and most certainly the safety of my babies I could literally not care less about some other persons feelings.
The ruler of this system is evil and all pretense fades as love grows cold
They got the $ for an attorney to get them off, the legal system is set up for whomever has the best attorney money can buy to get out of trouble. 90% of the ppl in prison are ppl who couldn’t afford good legal defense. It’s also crazy to know some of those ppl are innocent but this freak obviously not.
When it comes to my son, polite goes out the window. If I have to become a rabid monster, foaming at the mouth, I will. I am my sons ultimate protector. If you want to get to him, you literally have to get thru me. There are only a few select ppl that my son can be without my supervision. I have to know you will protect my son with your life as I do. I cannot believe she admits she had a bad feeling about him but yet she left him alone with him. We HAVE to trust our instincts, even if we look crazy as hell. I feel so bad that Cherish endured what she did and lost her life bc her mother didn't look at things the way most mothers do. Now Rain has to live with that on her heart for the rest of her life.
If only her father would have gotten custody of her when he tried so hard to. This story is heartbreaking. And her mother…mind boggling.
He was trying
maybe her dad should have bought her some shoes and mailed them to the daughter he provided for so well
The generous, kind father should have brought his daughter a dress or whatever she needed ,was she not going to CA the next day, he would had to provide for her anyway
@@jimmyknows-p4mdeadbeat mom should have given that baby girl up to her father.
@@chanelabdullah2087she should’ve had many clothes that fit her, not just because she was going to see her dad but because kids need clothes that fit, they grow.
The mom “didn’t want to seem too protective”?!?! I’d be watching my kid like a hawk. Wtf. Rip little angel, so heartbreaking.
Right like who gives a fck I’m a momma bear I bite!! Know that!!
CRAZIEST SHITE IVE EVER HEARD....I'LL GO TOE TO TOE WITH THE😈HIMSELF WHEN IT COMES TO MY CHILDREN! My 10yr old daughter's paternal grandma is theeeeeeeee best grandma ever aside from my mommy/ She has gotten her faithfully every other weekend since she was six mos old, when she goes over, all i have to send is her because she has her own room and a closet full of clothes....Well, one day gma decided to say some not so nice things about me that were not true and shouldn't've been said to a child. Maaaaan, i went crazy on her ass and kept her home a few weekends til she understood that what she did was a mf no-no! I said all that to say...even with me being a people pleaser at times, as a parent, YOU PROTECT YOUR CHILD(REN) NO MATTER WHOSE FEELINGS GET HURT OR HOW MUCH OR WHAT THEY CAN DO FOR YOU!! This shit pisses me off so bad cause it could have been avoided.
My dad's the same way I remember one time he turned his back andy brother was behind a car when he was about 4 or 5 and me my sister and dad freaked out for about 5 seconds until he came from behind the car. He had found a stick he liked, he liked sticks lol, and my dad damn near went off, like BOY don't scare me like that, had me thinking someone took you! He kept insisting that, that is all it takes
She quite mentally challenged.. she seems to be very naive and not very smart. The Predator noticed that in an instant. It's such a horrific Case.
I need to see her in an interview
Omg Annie please don’t give any room to this mother for this action. This was entirely her fault. This isn’t being naïve. I am a single mother of 3 toddlers and struggle a lot. THIS NEVER EXCUSES allowing your daughter to be alone with a grown man in a dressing room. No NO no NOOOOO
To all mothers out there: EVERYONE is a danger to your baby. Even the teachers, even the relatives, even the father in some cases! NEVER leave your child alone with another adult, let alone a STRANGER! And always watch out how your kid’s doing, if there’s any change to their behavior (in case of father/relative abuse). This horrific murder could have been avoided, would Rain follow this rule! Follow your mother‘s intuition 😢
You need to visit a psychiatric hospital. You are in the delusional phase . Get help before it's too late
I can safely say I TRUSTED NO ONE NOT 1 SINGLE PERSON WITH MY KIDS ( GROWN NOW ).
I EVEN TOLD MY IN LAWS AT THE TIME IF SOMETHING HAPPENED TO MY KIDS WHILE IN THEIR POSSESION TO LEAVE THE COUNTRY.
MY NICK NAME WAS " SECRET SERVICE "
Trust nobody with your child, your gift from God. There is no free lunch and Rain knows that.
To all humans out there. Not EVERY mother is meant to be mother. This is the text book example where societal norms of assuming the mother is more fit to protect the child than father and the court systems heavily weigh in the mother's side resulted in the death of a child. It's quite simple. After a child, who is 50% mother and father in terms of DNA, is born, they are equally responsible. Thus, the courts need to see it this way.. not just from a financial standpoint. This little girl would still be alive had the courts given custody to the father
Even the mother.
It’s really really hard for me to find any sympathy for this “mother” who created so many horrible scary situations for her children.
One unwise decision after another.
Exactly! She had so many red flags and not once did she went on protective mom mode ! He kept on pushing the boundaries and the mom never did anything that’s why at the end it was so easy for him to just walk away with cherish from Walmart
@@jocelyncruz8031 and her 911 call was so calm! If my child were taken I'd be a raging lunatic!!
I am convinced she knew what was going on, but she benefitted from it so why would she care?
@@corablah9809 yep..she was always very ready to give her kids up to others.. narcissistic cow
I’m a mom of 4. We have struggled, really struggled. I still would never accept help from a stranger, especially if it involved getting in someone’s car. I certainly wouldn’t allow a grown man to take my daughter to a dressing room. Wether or not I know you. The mother has blood on her hands here.
Agreed. I have 4 and pregnant with #5. Would NEVER EVER allow a stranger to do ANYTHING with my kids. I'm even leary of some family members!!
Right I'm finishing raising 11 on my own (not all bio but still mine most chose me) my ex-wife abandon mine I adopted a friend's after she died and a friend's parents asked me if I could take their oldest daughter's after she left them for dope because their health wouldn't let them deal with the issues they had after a year with me and counseling they asked her to sign the papers so they could be mine she jumped at it to get out of child support I watch strangers and as a member of BACA I( don't hide I belong it's tattooed on my forearm in big bold letters) nobody's messing with my kids 100+ hogs would be rolling over the creep people don't ever call dcf call your local BACA chapter that'll get news attention so dcf has to do their job not just fill out paperwork to clear a case
I almost feel like she should be charged as an accomplice.
I disagree, the mom was 100% negligent. She cared more about a gift card than her own daughter’s safety. Who in their right mind lets a child go into the dressing room with a stranger or let her go by herself with him because apparently shopping is more important??? 😡Like her daughter in Australia said, the predator was looking for a kid to take no matter who it was, and this mom was stupid enough to fall for the bait
The mom is negligent and lacked so much common sense! How can you justify going with a stranger for a gift card?! Also how had she been continued to have custody of the kids?
I agree 💯 you just can't trust anyone over my dead body someone gets close to my child this breaks my heart that poor baby girl I hope they fry this demon 👿 piece of shit
She’s a straight dummy this the type woman who possibly could date and bring in the wrong men
I have so much anger for this woman I'm struggling to keep watching
Completely agree!! You NEVER let your child walk off with a stranger! Never! Such a tragedy all around. Glad the remaining children are out of her custody and doing well.
Hearing the woman who Donald targeted in 1992 give her testimony was heartbreaking. The trauma was so evident even all these years later.
Yes! It scared me just listening to her retell her account… I felt like I was there with her! Terrible 😞
Yeah, she got to me. I feel her pain. Such a monster. Just looking at that man just turns my stomach.
Yeah, what a monster. As in children's worst nightmares. 😓
Had he been a black man, he would have been sentenced to life from the beginning.
Well, some people are really good at holding onto their victim status
How no one has attacked this man in the courtroom is beyond me
This is absolutely awful. He deserves the death penalty
Agreed if that was my child I would have tried my best to kill him in the courtroom
His smug and sneaky smirks ENRAGED me
Where to watch trial
Oh it's coming. Someone will get to him someday and it'll be sweet sweet vigilante justice
The mother is an imbecile. She is a bad mother. She abandoned her first child. The sheer stupidity or negligence is unbelievable. She had so many opportunities to wake up and smell the coffee. Who lets their daughter go into a dressing room not once but twice?! I feel bad for that poor beautiful child. RIP Cherish. You are an angel now 👼
I totally agree. She knew good and well she was making a bad decision. When she called 911 she even basically ratted on her self when she said the POS went into the dressing room with her daughter 2 times. She had to have known that was a red flag for her to even mention it. She was desperate to get items for her daughter to take to her dad’s house because she probably worried how it would look if her daughter got there with what little she had. The dad had already tried getting custody. If he sees that the child support is not actually being used for child support then that would be a good excuse for him to try and get custody again. I can’t get over the fact that she POS murderer was not already in prison for life. Also, how did the mom think she was going to get home! Was she keeping her fingers crossed 🤞🏻 that he would just pay for everything and then drop them off at home safe and sound?! Just praying that him creeping around the first store was a coincidence?! Just praying the fact his phone did not actually ring was because it was on vibrate?! Just praying the reason the wife never showed was because she’s a slow poke?! Just praying the wife wanted to meet at Walmart instead of the first store was because she was closer to Walmart?! Just praying the rope in the cart wasn’t meant for something sinister?! Just praying the worst that could happen in the dressing was him exposing himself?! Just praying it was no big deal that she left her phone in the classic murder/rape/abduction van?! Just praying it was a coincidence that the middle seat was missing from said van?! Just praying that the little children he mentioned were grandchildren because he clearly looks too old to have his own children around that age?! I still have 30 minutes left of this video and I’m already beyond angry at the mom, the POS and the Justice system.
This was also greed on the mother's part. Her greed for things over common sense took over.
And when she was talking about that the man wanted to buy her daughter some high-heeled shoes.... And that didn't hit her as odd??
this was a clear cut case of the mother pimping out her daughter, she knew exactly what she was doing and now she felt bad after it went sour.
Hearing about the officer discovering her and waiting with her to protect her body broke me. Devastating.
That little girl paid the ultimate price for her mother’s NEGLIGENCE. That mother put Cherish directly into the hands of that monster. Period.
Yet its the man who fooled them all & took advantage of their hour of need. Lets not lose focus on who did this horrendous crime.
@@annemarie5427I’m not buying it. You should know better as a grown woman and a MOTHER to not accept hand outs from a stranger. Thats what kids do. She should’ve been charged criminally.
The mom.... wow. How negligent and dumb can you be? I'm having a really hard time sympathizing with her after she basically traded her daughter for a non existent gift card.
That poor little girl deserved so much better.
She did not seem competent enough to be the protector of children, poor girl 😭
Literal victim blaming. Men are responsible for their crimes.
It almost like she was letting him go into the changing room with her thinking he would get his "payment" for the gift card then. 🤮
She was in special ed...
wow.. that is harsh.. what a horrible thing to say.. if you have kids I think it is fair to say you took your eyes off them in a walmart once or twice .. there are ppl out there what do nice things for those in need.. NOT you clearly.. she wanted her daughter to have shoes and a dress to see her dad, knowing he would use it against her.. there are far worse moms in an sure
“I didn’t want him to think I was being over protective.” EXCUSE ME!?
You didn’t want a grown man to judge you because you made common sense decisions to protect your children and not allow a stranger to take your daughter to a dressing room in a giant department store!? I’m absolutely horrified at these parenting choices.
You are absolutely right !!!
I go out of my way to SHOW the mama lioness in me! I’ll tear your throat out before I allow you to take my child out of my sight. “Mammalioness” is the beginning of my email. And that is exactly wtf I am.
He was probably thinking wow this is easier than it needs to be. Poor baby..
I have to blame the mother as well. Her gut said don’t trust, or this isn’t right. She failed her children. She didn’t keep them safe. Letting your child walk off with a stranger is not my idea of safe
THIS!!!!!! I hate victim blaming but holy hell.
Some mothers are totally useless. Billy should have had custody. The mother is not always the best parent.
I agree. In the 911 call where she says he took her to the changing room twice and 'i was hoping she would be ok' - what?? You let your child go off with a strange man to a changing room and just hope she will be ok 🤦
It's a horrible situation but she doesn't sound very bright.
Agreed, it astonishing how many mothers get full custody over father that are willing to lay down their own life's for the protection of their kids
@@xtina6569 sounds horrifying.. how'd she had the custody 😢
In this case CPS was useless
Absolutely Billy should have had the custody. Heartbreaking..
Poverty is not an excuse, my momma was a single parent and at time we were so broke that she’d go hungry just so that we could eat. She never left us with strangers or accepted anything that strangers offer her. My mother also warned us constantly to trust no one. I blame Rayne as much as I blame Don for Cherish death.
I teach my 6 yr old the same thing trust no one n be aware of ur surroundings
Rayne paid the ultimate price for making a very dumb decision. So did Cherish may she rest in peace. ❤
How does one expect a child abide by “stranger danger” lessons when as the parent, you just got in this persons vehicle with them and was communicating and walking around with him. As a child, I’d imagine they would no longer see them as a stranger. Can’t expect a child to understand it when their adult figure doesn’t even understand.
It just defies all logic doesn't it. Makes zero sense what she did.
That really irked me! She said it in a way that seemed to imply that the girls should have known better, that they were somehow at fault.
That’s what I was screaming!!! He’s no longer a stranger to her! A child can’t truly know where that line is on their own so if you as the parent display with your actions that this person is someone I trust, they will too.
She's deflecting the blame to Cherish.
I swear I feel like she was waiting to just be offered more money for her honestly. No body I know, no matter how desperate would put their children in a compromising situation like this. She couldn’t have not known.
I think the mother was very reckless but why the hell was this POS still on the streets and not behind bars 😡
I do not believe the mother. did she sell her for money? b/c I would believe that more.
@@ihateurlifemore She may have been ignorant, clueless and made Terrible decisions, but no, I don't believe this was intentional. There was so much footage to back her story up.
This happens so much 😢 makes me wonder if the judge that allowed his release wasn't a pedo himself 🤷♀️
XTina I agree with both of your comments
@itsmelili326 OH I could almost guarantee it. Because if you were a judge and could give him life after he tried to abduct that girl, wouldn't you? I would. Mandatory sentences for these sickos need to be changed.
In my eyes..Ultimately, that little girl no longer considered that that man was a “stranger”. especially since her mother so willingly got in the car, spoke too,& browsed shop isles and left cherish with him multiple times in the store before she walked away with him. In a young child’s mind he wasn’t “stranger danger” after mum allowed that to happen. Rest in peace Cherish. Such a beautiful young & trusting soul. Rot in hell, Don.
Spoke to *
@@Iamyodaddy_Spoke to*
@@DreaLaShayLLC that’s wtf I said
@@Iamyodaddy_ no. It's not. 😂
@@DreaLaShayLLC look at the names and the comments goofy 🤡
He is disgusting. He even chuckled when they played the audio of his conversation with the other inmate on solitary confinement. My heart breaks for the family of Cherish, especially the dad. He tried everything to get custody of his daughter because he knew she wasn't safe with the mother. Unfortunately he was right.
they should have put him in population from he get go after they discovered the child's body ... we wouldn't be mad at him for being alive by now.
unfortunately we don't know what could have happened if she went with him either....
Notice the disgusting reply above this? Anyone who isn't *FULLY* blaming the mother 100% is the *TRUE* risk to child-safety with their Feminisnts agenda of broken homes and harmed children - its them who are likely covering up what likely *really happened* - you know, the mom selling *change-room time* for the going rate of of $150. This time she met up with the wrong client.
Certainly not the fate she met with her mother. @@asmrcrafts9279
How hard is it to get a job & clean the house & feed the kids!?
She’s so sad of losing Cherish & would never want a Mother to go through this but she can’t even do the simple stuff, cleaning the house, having food for the kids & clean clothes. I’m sure she was getting help from the state for food & maybe a place to even stay, but she couldn’t even clean the place up. I saw pictures of the inside of the house and it was a total mess! Her Man couldn’t get it together either, so the sister & oldest daughter adopted them in Australia! Thank God!
RIP CHERISH & GOD BLESS THE RELATIVES IN AUSTRALIA FOR GIVING THE GIRLS A CLEAN AND STABLE PLACE TO LIVE!!!
I hope that Dirtbag burns in hell!!!
Great Job Annie, this one is going to stick with me for a while!!! So sad! RIP Cherish 🙏🙏🙏
Cherish walking out , following that monster, is some of the most haunting footage ive ever seen. This case punches me in the gut every time I hear about it. That POS never should have been released from prison. It makes me sick to know how many kids have been killed by men who were set free from the justice system.
Or men who haven't been arrested.
There's a reason most people avoid that walmart on the northside...that situation didn't help them either.
@@karentucker2161 Stay away from Old Man Tucker ...
Couldn't have said it better
The mother saying that she talked to her daughter about stranger danger is one of the most hypocritical things I have ever heard! That man is a monster and the system failed miserably letting him off numerous times. Sickening what he did and I am happy the other 2 children were removed from that house!
Plus, how is the daughter going to know not to go with the man out the door, when her mom had them going in his car, taking them to Wal-Mart and shopping around with them.... That's totally not teaching your child about stranger danger
That statement made me mad too. It was almost like she was blaming the little girl.
That man should of been locked up long ago! What is wrong with this country?
She was too trusting and was only interested in the $150 "gift card"!! Don't trust a grown man who is extremely attentive to your daughters!!
exactly!
Don is so unbothered in the interrogation room he even naps like it’s just another morning. For him it’s just another arrest for the same charges. He literally has a mugshot for every decade. How sad. What an incompetent mother.
And he himself even commented on how he was allowed to just keep getting away with progressively worse crimes.
Yes, all parents make mistakes.. I understand, and this was a BIG, BIG mistake... but some things aren't to be commented for the public to see. Must she see this. Parents should be advised for all of the red flags in this video... but she already blames herself and I think she has learned her lesson.
Praying Mantikos, I get what you're saying, BUT she made my blood boil! Like no other!
This guy needs to be put away for the rest of his life
@@catherineseiler7407 he was sentenced to death so, wish granted.
I’m sorry but that “mother” should be in jail too. Criminal negligence!!!!! She let that strange man take her to a dressing room alone, excuse me?
She can play dumb about McDonald’s but she KNEW.
Absolutely tragic and that poor child. I’m so glad the two youngest children and her oldest daughter got away. RIP Cherish 😞
The 911 call was very telling. She’s defending herself and her thought process the whole time. She knew she was wrong.
She said I hope she’s not getting raped like I had before like wtf girl
All for a damn Walmart gift card. TF?! She obviously has been the type to exchange things physically for gain, poor Cherish just happened to be a little extension to her to gain things. Rip sweet girl. 🙏🏽
@@anandabliss9997 this mom was under constant criticism from the dad who wanted her full time.. the reason she did what she did was so her daughter had proper shoes and a dress when travelling to her dad's , keep him from complaining.. there are ppl that do nice thing for random ppl in need, often shopping with then paying instead of cash to person they are helping... this father failed her also, why was he not helping the mom pay for things daughter needed? and sending his daughter alone on plane was a.o.k by him .. if you ever done without with children that damn gift would make a lot more sense
She is a taco shy of a combo platter if you couldn’t tell.
She knew there was no free shopping spree she let him take her to dressing room twice!
I cant imagine how the dad is feeling, seeing that the mom basically handed out his daughter for a 150 gift card that never existed
I’ll say it again…
Listening to this mother say she let a strange man take her daughter into the dressing room twice so she could look at items, absolutely makes me sick. You should want people to think you are overprotective of your children. I’m so sad for Cherish. ❤
She could have easily just said "it's not appropriate for a little girl to go with an adult man to the dressing room." No explanation needed, no need to be rude; just stating the obvious. That's all she had to do. People used to be so trusting like this back in the day though and that's kinda crazy to think about.
When you said that the cop waited with her to protect her lil body from gators😭😭😭 I started crying not gonna lie. SO. FREAKING. SAD. Rip to that lil angel. And how the hell did this LOSER keep getting away with his actions????? Upsetting.
This little girl had a horrible mother and a tragic ending 😔. Some people do not deserve to be parents!
Totally agree Susan in SA JHB REGARDS
Facts
I agree 100%!!!!
I'm FLOORED that he wasn't in prison for life!!! So many of his offenses were preventable if the court system just operated differently or just got their ish together. Wow.
The mother made it about herself... "I hope he's not r*ping her right now because I've had that done to me and it's not fun" and "I hope he doesn't kill her, I don't want to be one of those parents that goes through all of this" like what the actual hell. Disgusting. Although what do you expect from a mother who just ditched her first born child with her family and never looked back. Cherish deserved better.
Relieved that I'm not the only one who noticed this.
Sounds narcissistic.
She probably was closer to borderline than bipolar. Borderline w strong narcissistic features
She knew exactly what he wanted and dangled the bait too close for 150 bucks and got bit that's all kids were to her $$$
@davidwoermansr Yep I completely agree.
This is exactly one of the main reasons that you don’t treat ur daughters to the point where they’re ppl pleasers… idc if u look like a wild banshee, when it comes to your children you do what makes sure they stay safe!!
My god! Imagine being too afraid of being “overly protective” of your own child?! Wtf. This is terribly sad and infuriating. Not everyone should be a parent.
I’m over protective and NOT afraid to say it or show it.
@@Tiffani_AnnA Same. They’re our children! Who else will protect them if we don’t.
@@lvigilful couldn’t have said it better
I actually had a friend say something similar. She had been severely SA’d and she wanted to be “normal” and trust her child to be with others. Sad.
@@ltovar34 Jesus! That’s awful. Normal is taking care of your child under ANY and ALL circumstances.
If only her daddy had gotten custody. What parent would get in a stranger’s car with their babies? Then letting him take Cherish to a dressing room. It’s so sad.
It's actually ridiculous how the courts would grant custody to that mother
they may have known something about the ex, not allowed to put it out there in the public
Yes- it's all because the System is actually Luciferian (which Rules even here on North America Land), and all of this evil besides that it all runs deep from where it comes. But these Luciferians also use the evils within society, to bring forth such evil upon the masses. Being unfortunate people for whom the evil is done unto, of this Luciferian Sect which Rules, and the evils they use from others to assist their evil. Being the targeted who pay the price for this evil, which Rules a percentage of government power (I even think possibly the majority these days, hopefully NOT), and Ruling- they freely do what they do- being tough luck to the public which is preyed upon.
The sinister, diabolical, demonic, dastardly, despicable, treacherous they do- for their boss/king/god- being Lucifer they worship (numbers to show how evil such is).
AMEN!!!!!
@@bluevelvet2976no. Chances are is that they didn’t want to separate sisters. It’s complete BS. That mother is a POs
The so called “mother” hopefully lost custody of her other kids, but she had to live with her stupidity and I’m pretty sure people around her will make her life a living hell!
I'm fortunate to learn about the "politeness" theory in time to teach my son that he (he is trans) doesn't HAVE to be nice to anyone. He doesn't owe a stranger anything. Don't do anything you even have an inkling of doubt. Don't help a man when he asks you for help. Don't go anywhere with anyone you don't know. Don't be afraid to be rude to anyone.
As you explained the police officer waiting with her body to keep her little body from any more harm, I burst into tears. That poor baby girl. And that poor officer. I can’t imagine how hard that would be, especially being a father, himself. 😢
The justice system failed that little girl over and over until this happened to her. Also, seeing the fear in that adult woman witness who he tried to kidnap before as she recalled her story just goes to prove the horror the little girl experienced.
I can only add how brave Miss Buck was to face this monster who hunted her as a young girl. I pray she is healing & realizes what a strong woman she is.❤️🙏🏻 Thank you for covering this & telling Cherish story.😥
She is a friend of mine. She is indeed very strong.
This is the most emotional I've been from your videos. This man is pure evil. The smirk and the fact he looked like he was going to laugh while listening to the secretly recorded video is just something else.
These child predators should be put UNDER the jail! 🤬🤬🤬
They belong underneath Hell in my opinion
And so should these so called mother's that willingly hand their kids over to them
I’ve seen this case before, and it absolutely haunts me. I am so outraged that children are left with parents who are just basically stupid. Unbelievable. As people always say, you need a license to drive a car, but you don’t need a license/test to become a parent. So incredibly sad.
this!!
I hate this one. I've heard it in more detail on a pod and I was shaking as I listened to it. My heart hurts so much for this beautiful child with a beautiful name and she could have had a beautiful life and grown up to be someone great.
Stupid being the operative word here 🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️
Yes that a valid point , every child deserves a parent , but not every parent deserves a child
A license to raise a child, come on...
Most of us can raise our children perfectly fine.
That officer 😭 he was extremely perceptive, instantly made the correct conclusion, rushed to do what he could as fast as possible and then saw what looked like his own daughter, deceased in the water 😭😭😭 the trauma that poor man will have to deal with the rest of his life 💔
I’ve been binging all your videos. You are an amazing story teller and the lengths you go to do thorough research is highly appreciated.
The court system in general is broken. They allow parents who fail children over and over again and the allow sex offenders to get out of prison, when they should never be allowed to mingle with society. It’s the definition of insanity.
This is disgusting. The mother should be ashamed. How on EARTH do you let your young daughter in a dressing room with a GROWN MAN let alone get in some strangers CAR?! I understand she was struggling but nothing is worth putting your child in danger for. Crimes against children are truly the most evil types in my opinion. It hurts my stomach and heart to even hear about things like this.
These disgusting pedophiles pray on young dumb women.
A total stranger WAITING OUTSIDE OF A STORE comes up to you and just offers you a $150 gift card, and you say OK??? Then you let this TOTAL STRANGER take your 9 YEAR OLD DAUGHTER TO THE DRESSING ROOM - TWICE!! And if that's not ridiculous and neglectful enough, you allow this TOTAL STRANGER TO TAKE YOUR 8 YEAR OLD DAUGHTER TO MCDONALD'S??? You've known this man a whole hour, but you trust him with your daughter?? Yeah, great parenting!!! So glad the other 2 girls are not in their mom's custody!!
@@mariahillenbrand8396 yeah, she’s obviously not a very intelligent person
Understand she is struggling? lol
Trying to understand is what is wrong in this society, you can't unless you explain why she did it.
She already left one child behind so leaving others with other guys is just normal for her.
I'm sure the mother is feeling more guilt than you could ever feel toward her. It's so easy to be on the outside looking in and judge people and judge their decisions & actions...... but what good is that going to do? I'm sure she feels horrible, her daughter died and it's all her fault in her eyes. She could have prevented it & she should have protected her. I'm sure she tells herself these things every single day . I'm sure she's very ashamed of herself. I don't know if that makes YOU feel better about being right. I think we need to ease up on this poor mom she's already gone through enough and suffered and she's going to continue to suffer for the rest of her life, so I can't in good conscious point fingers at her and criticize every decision she made. Talk about kicking someone while they're down I just can't do that.
The mom was negligent in my opinion. She became star struck by the thought of a gift card and missed all the red flags. She lived her life with a lack of structure, planning and thinking ahead so that’s why she got her kids into this dangerous situation. Poor Cherish. I hate to think about what happened to her in that van. As for Don. He is a predator and the system and doctors failed to do their duty responsibly which put this piece of garbage back on the street again and again. How can they sleep at night. Great work bringing this case to life Annie. Thanks ❤
I rather my kids walk around in a shortage of clothes than to put them in DanGER!!
I don’t think she missed the signs, but chose to ignore them.
@@channahnoyb4803 Yes, she even admits that she saw the signs. She just didn't care because she wanted something from him. It's sickening.
She should have gotten herself fixed if she didn't want to have kids
the sigh of relief I gave when you said her younger children were sent to Australia... Thank goodness. Those poor children.
Rayne Perrywinkle lives everyday with the knowledge that her poor decisions lead the death of her child and the removal of the other 2, AFTER abandoning her firstborn. Everyday, she wakes up and lives the day she deserves.
Damn.
It’s still not enough 😔😔😔
Yep.
That’s if you believe she has any remorse.
No. That's a revolting statement, there's one and only one evil sick culprit.
There HAS to be a reason the judicial systems repeatedly reduce sentences for sex offenders, especially those against children. If you're labeled "high risk to reoffend" why in gods green earth would they be like "off you go!" ?!?!?!?!?!?
I suspect it’s because our justice system is full of predators. I mean they’re literally everywhere 😮.
You know why
@@HeyIwasaValedictorian no why? I follow many Predator Catchers on UA-cam and I NEVER understand why half of them aren’t arrested OR when they are they are released so soon. I truly don’t know why.
@@Tiffani_AnnABecause alot of people in power are the same way as these guys.
And meanwhile 100x100 inmates are being held 20-30+ years for minor drug charges ….our Judicial System is Beyond screwed up! Makes me so sick how many violent Predators are being released
Poor, desperate, whatever the case is… that is no excuse to allow your baby to just go off with a strange man that YOU HAD A BAD FEELING ABOUT. This is absolutely insane and disgusting. How could a mother allow this?! If you need the money or help, let them give that to you and nothing more. This mother should be held responsible to some degree for pure lack of common sense and neglectful actions on her part. I’m so effin pissed. None of this needed to happen.
Agree 💯
I agree, she was extremely neglectful and dumb. Literally put your children in danger over $150. She left her other child in another country she is a terrible mother
Not even a bad feeling but SHE JUST MET HIM
Totally agree, I just can't wrap my brain around how could she let her go with him, terrible mother
Twice he went w her
I learned about this case a few years ago and nothing makes me more mad than this, the amount of people that failed that beautiful little girl is maddening
This man is so infuriating. I don't have words. I don't know how everyone was able to restrain themselves from beating the shit out of him
When she said the officer patted him down and found his pants where wet. She said the officer became emotional, she didn't elaborate but yeah. My first thought was the realization of what took place hit him and made the officer snap! Emotional overload response takes a split second to go from human to animal instinct! That takes a LOT to control! In a case like this, personally I'm not sure I'd want to control my response. Not justifying it would be right mind you.
Seeing the rest of the video, was that the officer on the the stretcher with the ambulance on the scene? 😢
I felt nauseous hearing about the acts he forced onto this little girl. I am angry and heartbroken. We can’t keep letting this happen. May her sweet and innocent soul rest in heavenly peace
Don loved sitting there when his past victim was crying. He loved the attention. He is a disgusting human being.
I noticed that as well. Literally soaking it all in with pleasure. I screamed out loud when I saw that.
I wouldn't call him a human being. Human excrement sounds better .
This case shows how incredibly weighted the court system is for the mother's custody. Here is the father, who was not even told he was the father for years, stepping up to be a stable parent for his daughter, even pleading for full custody, denied over and over in favor of the clearly toxic mother. Unbelievable
This is literal proof that the government doesn’t care about kids or women they kept letting him out after he even confessed to his disgusting crime..
The government doesn't give a fug about anything. Women, children, men..etc. They care about one thing.. $$$
I'm sorry, did anyone actually believe the government ever cared about anyone?
What do you think the government big wigs were all doing at Epstein island…
Not to mention they let the child stay with the mother 🤦🏼♀️
Watching a veteran medical examiner breakdown on the stand is a very rare occurrence. She was so shaken up, it was so hard to watch 😔
Yeah that was tuff.
I can only hope She's actually in a better place where she no longer hurts😢
I can’t believe this mother…. I’m so disgusted and I don’t even know what happened yet. She’s despicable… HOW WOULD YOU LET YOUR LITTLE GIRL GO WITH A STRANGE MAN?! How would you let a strange man go in a dressing room with a man?! What the actual hell?!
My guess is the mother had been through a lot of emotional and mental trauma throughout her life, which could be why she was more trusting than she should have been. People that have been manipulated and kicked down throughout their lives tend to be more naive and trusting than they should be. While I would never allow any of this with my children I can easily see how in a moment of desperation your judgement could be clouded. I just heard them say he took her to the dressing room, which is definitely a red flag and never should have happened but didn't hear that he went IN there with her unless I missed that part. Regardless, this sick monster is the one to blame in this situation and the failed justice system. He never should have been allowed into society after the fire time he harmed a child, but he had multiple offenses and was still allowed to walk free. He took advantage of a desperate, naive, vulnerable woman and she will suffer for it. I can't even imagine what little Cherish went through and my heart breaks for everyone who loved her including her mother that will live with guilt for the rest of her life. I believe anyone who harms a child should be immediately put to ☠️.
@JustPeachy🍑 nah, you have to quit giving "mothers" like this a pass...cherish was a monthly paycheck and that's why she didn't want to lose custody of her to a man who could provide a good life for her.
@@lynndavis9207 I try to save my hate and judgement for the mothers that intentionally harm, sell, murder, etc their children. This Mom was obviously distraught and while yes she made some bad decisions I reserve my judgement bc I don't believe she intentionally put her child in harms way.
@@kytruth1027 probably not intentionally however she made a very bad choice. I’ve been through some very bad things. Very bad BUT those bad things is what would make me NOT trust a random stranger even more so. Something definitely clouded her judgement.
She said she thought she'd taught her kids all there is to know about stranger danger, yet she went (with her kids)with a stranger 🤦🏼♂️
normally i listen to to true crime podcasts while i’m doing chores, but this one, i could not take my eyes off for a second. not even because my name is cherish but just everything happening one after another. floored. as soon as i started to try and do my chores again the cop yelling she’s in the water where’s the water and i was back to the screen
I watched the whole trial of this case. What I saw and heard will stay with me forever. That monster did horrendous things to that precious baby girl. And her mother will have to live with her poor decisions forever. This entire thing is fucked up no matter how you look at it. Rip sweet girl.
I am from Jacksonville and Cherish Periwinkle was a horrific hit to our community esp. after Maddie Clifton and Josh Phillips...the mother is a drug addict and made awful decisions, one cost a price that no child should have to pay for...im disgusted she had NO CHARGES for this.the least was negligance!!!
It's heartbreaking..and I HATE anyone who harms the most innocent. Kids. Animals. Disabled/infirm people..
She(the mother) sounds completely intoxicated
Fwiw..when someone refuses to get help for addiction..they should Not be allowed to breed
She should have been charged. There is no way in hell I would ever as a parent or just as someone that could have been in that dressing room to allow that. It makes me wonder if her mother allowed it and she just told a story to cover it up! F him! Death is no justice
She definitely should of been charged.
As a mother I couldn’t imagine the multitude of decisions this mother made that endangered her child/children. Heartbreaking the fact that he was allowed out of prison and not monitored due to past behavior.
The mother says " I thought I tought her everything about stranger danger and never leaving with a stranger." Victim blaming at its best. Wow, great mom to put what happened to her daughter on her daughter. Disgusting man, disgusting mother, and I'm so sad for that poor girl, her father, and her siblings.
Love your videos girl! I so appreciate all the awareness you bring to these poor souls. ❤
So the dispatcher got suspended but Rain gets sympathy. That’s the biggest joke. Rain should do time for child neglect. When I heard the call her story seemed unbelievable too. Who waits 30 minutes to call the cops about an abducted child?!
I'm still in the middle of this but was so thrown off by how SLOW she was speaking on the call, your kid is missing wtf ma'am get help faster!
@@viceb7I thought she was high on that call. I believe he gave her drugs in exchange for her daughter.
I'm not going to lie, but that medical examiners testimony had me in tears. Pure evil to inflict that kind of trauma to a child.
Oh my god- that 911 call….
How was he not kept from living in society? So many bad decisions cost this little precious girl her life. May she rest in peace.