How trail designers build good hikes
Вставка
- Опубліковано 21 вер 2024
- The design secrets that make hiking trails feel “organic”
Subscribe and turn on notifications 🔔 so you don't miss any videos: goo.gl/0bsAjO
Designing a hiking trail seems simple enough: It has to take a person from A to B, pass through scenic nature, and last through years of wear and tear. And for most of human history, trails did that without much intentional design at all.
But as trails shifted from essential transportation to a recreational destination, the way we make them did, too. Now, hidden in every trail is a carefully made design language of angles, alignment, and materials that keep them enjoyable for generations.
Watch our video to hear trail ecologist Jeffery Marion explain how these principles work - and why they’re more important now than ever.
Make sure you never miss behind-the-scenes content in the Vox Video newsletter, sign up here: vox.com/video-n...
Vox.com is a news website that helps you cut through the noise and understand what's really driving the events in the headlines. Check out www.vox.com
Support Vox's reporting with a one-time or recurring contribution: vox.com/contrib...
Shop the Vox merch store: vox.com/store
Watch our full video catalog: goo.gl/IZONyE
Follow Vox on Facebook: / vox
Follow Vox on Twitter: / voxdotcom
Follow Vox on TikTok: / voxdotcom
Thanks for watching. This video is part of By Design, our series about the intersection of design and technology. For more videos like this, from playgrounds to font decisions, check out the playlist here: bit.ly/3PAav9U
And if you're still reading, thread some of your favorite trails below!
Rostellan Woods, aghada Cork Republic of Ireland
Eagle Creek Trail in the Columbia River Gorge
Timp-Torne in Harriman and Bear Mountain New York state parks. I think a lot of the clips in the video are from that trail.
Shut up
This was a great and timely video! I just starting hiking regularly and started to notice a few of these details. Was wondering how they were created!
Some of my favorite so far are local to Georgia: Golden Branch by the Chattahoochee, East Palisades leading into a little bamboo forest off the same river, Stone Mountain (going around the mountain), and Wilburn Farm/Arabia mountain. (note, none of these are actual 'mountains' really).
As a former professional trailbuilder, it warms my heart to see such a large news outlet shining a light on a profession that often gets overlooked. You did a great job!
I live in Utah how can I get into trail building?
Haha, "overlooked." I see what you did there
Even only cleaning trails and setting up way signers is an incredibly important thing
@@losfogo7149 definitely, and it's hard work often done by volunteers. Much respect to volunteer trail crews.
Thank you for your service :)
As a trail planner, you guys did a FANTASTIC job giving a 5-minute overview! A few more things trail planners have to consider as they're designing trails: intended user, accessibility for all trail users, trail usage and long-term maintenance, feasibility of trail crews to get equipment to the site, flora and fauna impacts, trail surfaces, etc.
how does one become a trail designer?
@@jonline8105 Most have degrees in urban planning/design, construction project management, landscape architecture, or civil engineering. It's usually a team made up of people from all of those disciplines that help design the trails.
I'm curious if the usage of trails by animals, for example the surface used and its comfort when dogs walk on it, but also, trying to keep wild animals from getting too close to people using the trails. Is that part of the considerations too?
@@foff002 Yeah, impacts to wildlife and domestic animals is definitely a consideration when thinking about trail surfaces. Alternatives, like putting in culverts for animals only, is also very common.
@@AmericanEnglishman Lol I've designed a few tracks and have no qualifications whatsoever. Always fun to just absolutely wing it.
I never realised how highly designed trails are. I always thought they kind of emerge or are just created randomly with the minimal possible effort just to make hiking possible. That's fascinating.
well, some of them are created like that, especially outside of national parks between villages for example.
some are like that, my favorite ones are the ones that were just old logging extraction roads in the past. They are typically referred to as fall line trails.
w
Having worked on a trail crew, it gives you so much respect for the amount of WORK that goes into building steps, drainage mounds, moving boulders etc. An experienced trail crew may create 10-15ft of trail in an 8 hour day; absolutely mental!!
10-15 feet in a full day’s work is horrible even for a single person. This is of course barring special circumstances like extensive construction or having to carve trail through rock.
@@giuseppejones1554 So have you ever walked a steep but well-maintained trail on a mountain? It doesn't sound like you have
@@giuseppejones1554 sir have you ever done trailbuilding?
@@giuseppejones1554 Seriously. By my reckoning, at that pace, a trail would cost as much as a real, paved road in labor alone. I find it a bit hard to believe that the government is dropping millions into a few miles of dirt path.
@@thiccityd9773 a lot of trail maintenance is done by volunteers or by underpaid/unpaid prison labor. That's why it doesn't cost millions. 10-15 ft is incredible when you consider that the crew has to carry all their tools and materials to the worksite on their backs over difficult terrain.
I would love to see the differences in trails in the US and in Europe. I feel they are very different and it might do something with the way people even perceive nature and their relationship to it.
Us trails are great, they are pure nature and great to get away from cities, where I live we have wayyyyyy more parks and trails than homes lol 😂 cuase I live in a master planned community in USA
I'm from Italy and I've never seen trails like the ones depicted in this video plus I've always thought trails are just what people back in the day used to move across mountain villages, farms and pastures, so it never even crossed my mind that people could make new trails from scratch, but you never stop learning.
In the UK there aren’t many ‘designed’ specific trails. It’s often just fields through people’s farms and/or they put stuff in places where people go anyway to make it easier/less hazardous.
We also have very little properly private property, there’s right of access for hikers on almost every single bit of property that’s not directly next to someone’s house.
Came here to ask for this. I think some modern ones might have been added (parts of existing) paths like this but assumed most of them just "happened" through centuries of usage.
@@r22gamer54 hope you dont mind me asking, what area is this?
I always thought trails were made naturally through constant use of a certain path 🤦♂️
That's how it is in my country. People have been using trails for ages and the only thing they considered was the path with the least resistance.
I forgot to say that people in my country also avoided making trails in the vicinity of Banyan trees especially the old growths since they are believed to be haunted.
Same 🤦♂️
Depends on how much tourism is in the region the national parks or the regional forestry departments do it les used are just constant paths that how it is in Switzerland.
Some are. Some aren't.
Edit: also, he said a lot of the work they do is maintaining trails which existed before recreational hiking.
Yes this video definitely overthinks the topic
Trail worker here! Love to see vox show everyone on what makes a good trail and how important a good trail keeps the impact of humans concentrated to a set area. We have to put more love to our outdoors! Respect them!
Mountain bike trails have recently gotten really good with the up hill/downhill sections to force water off the trail. This keeps trails open more often in wet climates, and also end up being fun features like rollers and jumps.
When I was designing a mountain bike trail back in Russia, I used Australian “playbook” on how to build sustainable trails and this video covers a lot of it, actually.
The thing that got me into designing trails is that not many trails in Russia live a long life. It is kinda sad… So I have found out that drainage is the part that most of the trail builders miss out on.
I've seen a lot of paths up in Scotland (ones that are still very much used by the landowners) where they use a few feet of plastic piping to culvert water under the trail surface
Trail creation and trail maintenance are incredibly arduous tasks, and more technical than many assume. I worked on an AmeriCorps crew in backcountry Arizona and New Mexico recreating a trail that hadn't seen maintenance in 10+ years. When this happens, the trail becomes severely overgrown. Recreational hikers will either get confused or lazy. They stray off the official trail and create infinite "dogleg" trails off the sides until there's no distinguishable network anymore. This increases the danger that people will get lost. Plus, desert ecosystem and soil is INCREDIBLY fragile. The top layer of soil is ecologically crucial. When hikers spread their impact way off the trail, they are harming the environment. No matter where you are, it's important to stay on the trail! Minimize your impact while you're enjoying the nature around you.
As a former trail crew leader with the US forest service I really appreciate this video. With the maintenance backlog land management agencies face these kinds of pieces are helpful for driving more public support for this type of work
i never thought designing trails is this complicated. i appreciate these amazing trails more now.
Now that I am aware of this, I know I'll treasure trails even more. In addition to being able to enjoy the splendor of the natural features on the path, I will be also be able to appreciate the thought and care that went into designing the trail, and why it dips, moves, and gently guides people to beautiful sites of interest. Can I say I see trails as slow motion roller-coasters now? 😄 So cool.
I love that they do such a good job that it looks natural. Definitely a cool job to have ❤
With regards to alpine and subalpine trails in Europe, I can't really imagine them being designed. They were used for centuries by all sorts of people; traders, shephards, soldiers; etc., changing as needed.
Yeah, I can't count the number of paths I've walked through in the Alps that are 1) paths that run through farmers land, or 2) doubled with a million other little paths because of either said farmers or because there's just a few different obviously good lines to take up or down the mountain.
Never doubt the wisdom of the people whose efforts over the centuries led to those trails becoming what they are today. Imagine yourself thousands of years ago choosing a path to take in areas that had no pre-established trails, then think how you would have decided where to go as you walked. While you might call this decision making process organic, someone else would say that it is intentional because you were making decisions along the way. Imagine many other people used that trail as well since you created a convenient way to travel on foot from one point to another and you took it ofter, blazing a path for others to follow, or you guided them. Now imagine thousands of years later your exact trail is not completely followed, but much of it is followed because you chose wisely in determining your route, while some modifications were understandably made due to erosion, obstacles, and other factors. This may be the origin of an alpine or subalpine Trail in Europe. Now, with advances such as books and Computer based communication, trails could be designed even better. I learned how to build trails before the Internet, then later used the Internet to research communicate between trail builders.
Yeah, they were designed for centuries by all sorts of people…
Those people chose the best way looking at maps and natural features, maybe used a shovel here and there, went uphill on the easiest path, maintained it by removing fallen trees.
How is that different?
It's often not a completely new trail, but they are still "designed" by choosing which trails receive signage, which are maintained and closing/rerouting sections.
In touristic areas, you can often tell that the trails feel different than higher up and more remote - probably because they were more deliberately designed and planned. (Especially when they connect two touristic points, like a chairlift and a viewpoint)
That's still a design though. There's a reason they walked a specific way - even if that reason is just decades of trial and error.
As someone who designs, builds and maintains trails for a living, this video is a great distillation in just 5 minutes. Going to Dr. Marion was a good choice, too.
I was just in Glacier National Park and the Grinnell Glacier trail was one of my favorites I've ever done. The trailwork on that one is a thing of beauty. It hangs on a cliffside, with some heady exposure and big views, but never feels unsafe. As you hike up, you constantly think it must be about to evaporate into thin air, but then it finds a solid and surprising path. Good tread and easy walking the whole way. It's art.
I built a potion of the Cumberland Trail system in Tennessee in spring 2018 with a group from my university. I wish they would’ve taught us this stuff while we were there.
As a volunteer crew lead with The Colorado Trail Foundation I want to complement you for producing this spot-on video. A huge amount of work goes into planning and design before the first pick mattock is struck.
Wish this had touched on the logistics of how they move material in and out to create the trail. That’s something I have always been curious about.
Machinery (excavators, tracked buggies, skid steers, helicopters), mechanical advantage (rock bars, rigging with winches), or grunt labor and a keen awareness of body mechanics.
My company does deliveries by helicopters, and everything else is by hand and crowbars
A couple of weeks ago, I hiked the Green Mountain West trail near Boulder, and as I hit the last quarter mile (the hard part - a rough and steep rock staircase leading to the mountain summit), I was overwhelmed with appreciation and admiration for what a fantastic job the trail designers did.
The sound design (probably using that term incorrectly) here is admirable. The soundtrack, the synchronisation with the voiceover and each cut. Great composition, great editing, great production.
I blazed a small trail for a Ranger award in Scouts years ago. Now this video makes me I want to go back and look at maps for fall lines to make it better haha. Great stuff!
I was thinking the same thing about the trails on our 4-H property in our county. 🙂
Vox is back again with things I didn't know I want to learn.
Great video. On USFS/NPS trail crews we focus a lot on proper outsloping and frequent grade reversals when cutting new tread; doing that reduces the amount of maintenance a trail needs over the long run. We also try and put trails in places that minimize the amount of structures that need to be built. Think bridges, crib walls, turnpikes (a raised gravel bed), steps, etc. Those are all really cool to see on trail but are incredibly time consuming to build, and eventually need to be replaced or fixed. Most trail crews are operating on very minimal personel and any savings in efficiency is highly valued.
In my current role as a Civil drafter in PA, I discussed with locals during a recent camping trip about ways that state departments and organizational functions could have in co-sponsorship with each other in raising awareness and revenue in the maintenance of the trails. I think it's important for people to help each other "pay it forward" so that the next person can experience your local scenery in a way that a book hopes to describe.
watched this while hiking!! finishing up my AT thru (filp-flopping) about a month left :)
Ugh, love this video! I grew up in Boulder, Colorado and helped with trail work. I live in Los Angeles now, and it's not like there isn't good hiking here, there is, what is lacking is good trail design and maintenance.
Currently working on trail in RMNP on the North Inlet Route in Grand Lake, CO!
When I was using walking trails regularly I often wondered how they were maintained. I knew mother nature would reclaim areas and could see it on the parts that weren't traveled on as frequently. I never fully thought about how they were designed. This is a great video.
As someone who hikes a lot, I loved watching this. Never knew so much effort went behind "creating" these trails. I just assumed people walked some favourable paths and the trails got made. :P
As someone who has studied environmental resource management, I LOVE this.
I worked as a single track mountain biking trail builder, there's a GNARLY amount of work that goes into trailbuilding
This was fascinating. Never realized the depth of planning for trails and how important it is.
This video made me remember a trail I have been to. It looked and felt "natural" but it also had evidence that someone was taking care of it, but not too much care as it also has evidence of erosion.
I am grateful for all these trail designers and those that maintain and protect our ecosystems. God bless.
As a hiker, I've always wondered about how trails are made/maintained, but I've never seen any information about it, so I'm happy to see this
As a trail planner, your 5-minute overview was OUTSTANDING! Here are a few additional factors that trail planners must take into account when designing trails: target user group, accessibility for all trail users, usage patterns and long-term upkeep, feasibility for trail crews to transport equipment to the site, effects on local flora and fauna, trail surface types, and more. Well-designed trails can reduce erosion and minimize the environmental footprint by up to 30%.
"it's not rocket science, but it's challenging." I love that perspective and self awareness.
Me too! Of course it's not rocket science, but it's way more sustainable than rocket science and more people benefit!
Trails in america: carefully crafted by skilled people
Trails in Europe: the path smugglers and sheperds used to go up a mountain
Im glad I stumbled on this video. Love hiking and never even knew all of the mechanics and complicated logistics behind trail design!
Just came back from the Appalachian trails in Quebec, Canada. They were amazing! A mix of rock, river crossings, forest paths, etc. Felt very natural but also easy to see. Gaspesie National Park was the highlight.
In Québec, most trails are natural, in the sense that they got their shape from people simply using the same path during decades. However, in National Parks and some regional parks where there are a lot of tourists some trails are improved artificially (with bridges, stairs made of stone, etc.)
I would watch a whole series of these. There was so much left unsaid!
In Cape Town, South Africa we have excellent trail crews who do an amazing job at maintaining the trails around our various forests and mountains. It’s cool to see what work goes into that.
This is very cool that so much work is going on behind the scenes. Definitely something we’ll be watching out for on trails in the future
Fascinating, In all those hours spent on trails I have never once thought about who put them there.
Love this! Spent 2 years working on AmeriCorps trail crews. It's fun work!
Hey wait a minute, that's my uncle! This video includes basically what Jeff talks about at thanksgiving each year.
This was fascinating. I had no idea so much planning went into building these trails.
Used to do work for a forestry department. A program that taught people these skills. To build, maintain, fix up trails. Was only a few weeks but was awesome!
I’ve been hiking and camping for years and never thought about any of this. Great video!
Vox by design is absolutely unmatched in their content!
Can always count on Vox media to make a video on an extremely relatable and niche topic
This makes me so thankful for all the trails I've hiked on.
When you see in Germany a street with the word "Weg" in it, there is a high possibility, that it was a former trail. Also there are some few trails, which are in so good positions that they were used for millenials. Like one trail in the mountains in my region was used for at least 1900 years.
Also, the part before "-weg" often indicates where it used to lead to. We also have this in the Netherlands. I used to live in a village named Gieten at the Eexterweg. Eext is the village next to Gieten. Weg just means road. There are also other suffixes that indicate routes. There is the Asserstraat, a street that was part of the road to Assen. In German, this word is Straße or Strasse.
Also, if you follow the route of the Asserstraat, you have a village named Rolde in the middle. The roads leading out are named Asserstraat and Gieterstraat. If you start in Assen, you follow the Rolderhoodfweg (something like Rolde main road). It's fun to see how the different sections of the same road are called.
I spent two weeks building and repairing trails! I never actually plotted one out though, and just had to deal with water on the small scale, so it's cool learning about this stuff!
I recently visited Shenandoah NP and was impressed by the clever use of drainage swales to slow and spread water that would otherwise course through and erode away the paths.
I wasn’t hoping to get a firsthand look at these swales in use, but we got caught in a sudden thunderstorm atop a mountain!
Even in the heavy flow rate of rain, the path was able to shed enough water off the path so it didn’t accumulate and wash us away 😅
Next time you are on a trail, look for "water bars". These are small features added to the trail to redirect water, to prevent erosion. They are one of the small things you can notice while hiking, that show some of the design and maintenance involved in the trail.
This is one of the most surprising discoveries I did in ages. I did not expect this.
I work on a State Parks trail crew and one thing I’ll add is that trails require a whole lot of maintenance. In woody and grassy areas the grass needs to be cut regularly and trees fall across trails all the time
Ive always wondered how trails were designed... Vox never ceases to amaze me
These people are literal trailblazers.
I just got back from Switzerland and did lots of hiking. It really amazes me with this video how a trail is designed and the work behind it.
I think trails in Swizerland are more natural than that
@@trago034 Depending where he was. I would say that in Switzerland stuff is rarely moved in to make it easy to walk. But also in Switzerland they have to design for water erosion.
PS: I don't think many trail builders that actually make trails in nature, care a lot about "anchors". You build in nature, and you have to go around stuff, which automatically makes anchors everywhere XD
loved seeing my favorite overlook featured in this video!
I just started making trails in Australia and I really appreciate this video
I always wanted to see a full-length documentary on trail making. Especially if it included historical footage and techniques.
had no idea that so much went into a trail! I never really put much thought into it when hiking and its so interesting to learn that the paths were strategically planned out by someone.
thank you trail builders and thanks for this video for the peek into their work!
edit: typo
So incredible for Americans to have access to such well thought out recreation places.
Nice, short, informative. I hike a lot and greatly appreciate the trail designers, builders and maintainers.
There’s a mountain not far from where I live, Mt. Miguel
These “desired lines” definitely decimate otherwise beautiful trails
There is an especially bad patch where it’s supposed to be switchbacks but people opted to go straight up through all the plants and now there’s a huge void space of rocks and dust
Thankfully trail markers and reminders have been put up, but who knows how long until it recovers
VOX doing a great job with these informative videos. Truly thankful for short running length.
well, I dont know man, the guy that made the hiking trail I took the other day in a way that you went through grass higher than you several times... pure genius
Anchors are just another word for things we don’t wanna move lol
Neat, love hiking. Appreciate the work I didn't realize went into it.
Wow, I never knew there were so many considerations involved when designing a trail
I've done mountain bike trail building. This video makes it seem more complex than it is. Sure, you look at a topo map to get an idea of where you want the trail to go, but most of the decisions are made the day you're building the trail. You mark out maybe 100' of trail with flags and then divert the trail or address potential water issues as you're actually doing the clearing.
Thank you to the trail designers and builders
From a regular hiker 🤙🏼😁
yesss i wish we had more trail documentaries especially for the historic parks in my city
As an civil engineer it pains me to see that Americans don't apply this design philosophy to regular roads. The knowledge is clearly there but the policy and will is not
I wish this video was longer!
Many of Colorado's trails are maintained by volunteers. Even the 14ers. Shout out to those heros!!
wow this was up there with my favourite vox videos of all time
99% invisible has a really good episode about trail design. I like this one too though.
As a civil engineer, this is a completely a new insight to me....
Definitely look into local hiking clubs where you live, many have volunteer days to do routine maintenance. Some groups also do larger scale projects (think staircases, bridges, retaining walls). Konnarock Volunteer Trail Crew out here in the eastern US is a great experience.
Very Interesting, never knew it takes all these efforts
My wife and I hike oddball trails here in North Carolina and it's fun to do a bit of trail maintenance along the way. The weirdest litter we commonly find are those plastic toothpick-flossing things. I've got 20 or so pictures of them.
Learned quite a few things in this video!
wanted this to be 2-3x longer it was so interesting
I love Vox videos like this
I love how their “expert” did the interview in a t-shirt and in his garage gym. So classy and professional, both y him and Vox. Next time, Vox should find someone to interview from his toilet while taking a dump.
Thank you for this awesome video! I hike and trail run and it's so cool realizing my little landmarks were actually carefully thought out and designed! There's this one really big boulder I like to stand on as an overlook, and before now I thought it was a happy accident!
I had no idea people designed trails! Wow I feel like a kid learning Santa isn’t real haha, very thankful to trail designers though! I’ll think of them when I’m hiking from now on, and curse them for hard uphills haha
This video shows everything we can we want to know if there is a problem,I know how to solve it.
I always think Vox videos are gunna be so interesting then I watch and it's just stock footage, jenky graphics and some zoom interview
Such important work for the souls of hikers 😊
This is an awesome subject an insight to something I have never noticed. I always thought trails originated by accident or along a topo line or by the movement of wild animals.
You hear that? VISITOR! YOU are a VISITOR. So act like one and respect nature and the area you are in. You are not above those living in the area. Respect nature and respect animals.
A 5min video and my hiking will never be the same