How To Put A Horse In A Trance | QI

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 28 сер 2024
  • You can now watch every full episode of QI, including this one, on iPlayer! ▶ qi.com/iplayer
    Follow QI on Twitter ▶ / qikipedia
    Follow QI on TikTok ▶ / theqielves
    Follow QI on Facebook ▶ / officialqi
    Follow QI on Instagram ▶ / theqielves
    Subscribe on UA-cam ▶ / theqielves
    For more visit ▶ qi.com
    This clip is from QI Series H, Episode 12, 'Horses & Hunting' with Stephen Fry, Alan Davies, Clare Balding, Jimmy Carr and Dara Ó Briain.

КОМЕНТАРІ • 92

  • @SabotsLibres
    @SabotsLibres Рік тому +68

    A twitch CAN be effective, but is not infallible. They don't always go into a trance like state and often horses unused to it will fight it.

    • @ShannonJacobs0
      @ShannonJacobs0 Рік тому

      But UA-cam is all about censorship. Noticed all the extra ads lately?
      You better not DARE say anything about them. The google is so EVIL these days.

    • @GandWizard
      @GandWizard Рік тому +4

      Good to know. To me it's advice like: "when a shark wants to attack you, hit it on the snout."
      It may be perfectly sound advice, but I'm not going to try that on such a large and potentially dangerous animal, thank you very much.

    • @justincronkright5025
      @justincronkright5025 Рік тому

      I suspect if you get them to have a good experience the first few times they have it put towards them. Then it will increase the likelihood that they will be more amenable to a future case when it involves having to drug/generally interfere with them more than usual.

    • @defeqel6537
      @defeqel6537 Рік тому +5

      @@GandWizard with a shark attack, do you really have a choice?

    • @MichaelKingsfordGray
      @MichaelKingsfordGray Рік тому +2

      @@justincronkright5025 Quite. With equines, it is a case of once-bitten, ten-times shy.

  • @hiltonian_1260
    @hiltonian_1260 Рік тому +26

    Your vocabulary word for the day: Feague. To make a horse look livelier by putting ginger up it. Cart drivers would use a feaguing stick; a long slender pole with a ginger juice soaked rag on the end.

    • @fehoobar
      @fehoobar Рік тому +1

      Ah the old ginger beer trick...

    • @bob_._.
      @bob_._. Рік тому

      A live eel can also be used.

    • @221b-Maker-Street
      @221b-Maker-Street Рік тому

      @@fehoobar "lashings"!

    • @daxdasche6112
      @daxdasche6112 Рік тому

      @@bob_._. Grose's description involved ginger first, then the eel. Together. I wonder if the eel responded to the ginger in there!

  • @GandWizard
    @GandWizard Рік тому +15

    I feel disappointed that the trick to activating them isn't applying the twitch to the lower lip.

  • @Jesusexplains
    @Jesusexplains Рік тому +2

    The final remark, “So, to look 10 years younger you …?” Exactly! 👀🙄😳

  • @xaviotesharris891
    @xaviotesharris891 Рік тому +16

    I deny completely the supposition that I am now planting ginger root in my shaded garden.

  • @Tao_Tology
    @Tao_Tology Рік тому +9

    'How to put a horse in a trance?'
    Easy.
    Make sure it's a big enough trance.

  • @howardsmith9342
    @howardsmith9342 Рік тому +1

    I knew about the ginger from Susie Dent and Rachel Riley from Cats does Countdown.

  • @bettneyskye
    @bettneyskye Рік тому +2

    i grip my bottom lip like that when i'm a bit stressed or when i'm trying to concentrate. . didn't ever think about it until watching this. lol.

  • @andrybak
    @andrybak Рік тому +24

    The ginger thing was also mentioned on "8 out of 10 cats does countdown" 😄

    • @PrimalxCepterk
      @PrimalxCepterk Рік тому +2

      I was surprise that Jimmy didnt remember this. 😁

    • @L83467
      @L83467 Рік тому

      +

    • @benjaminfranklin329
      @benjaminfranklin329 Рік тому +1

      This is from a long time ago... Are you sure you've got the order right

  • @tonyppe
    @tonyppe Рік тому +1

    Here comes Dave all gingered up

  • @christopherlawley1842
    @christopherlawley1842 Рік тому +23

    Terry Pratchett knew about the ginger trick

    • @GandWizard
      @GandWizard Рік тому

      I did not know! In which novel(s) did he use it?

    • @archonix
      @archonix Рік тому +2

      @@GandWizard Night Watch. Vimes uses it to cause a commotion so he can sneak past a barricade.

    • @GandWizard
      @GandWizard Рік тому

      @@archonix Cool to know, thank you!

    • @christopherlawley1842
      @christopherlawley1842 Рік тому

      @@GandWizard It's in Night Watch

  • @jodrabls4817
    @jodrabls4817 Рік тому +1

    And thats where "cocktail" comes from. They might say that right afterwards in the episode, I haven't seen it.

  • @Jesusexplains
    @Jesusexplains Рік тому +13

    GINGER makes the horse look 10 years younger 🤣 but 🌶️ chilli turns them into colts and fillies! 😳

    • @JJONNYREPP
      @JJONNYREPP Рік тому

      How To Put A Horse In A Trance | QI 0920am 24.7.23 ginger mcabe - was he a horse beautician? as for chill... did you mean chilli haw-haw - the gelder of aintree?

    • @Jesusexplains
      @Jesusexplains Рік тому +1

      @@JJONNYREPP No … just red hot chilli peppers 🌶️

    • @JJONNYREPP
      @JJONNYREPP Рік тому

      @@Jesusexplains ​ @Jesusexplains How To Put A Horse In A Trance | QI 1027am 24.7.23 so the red hot chilli peppers geld horses... or maybe flea is the horse beautician?

  • @dondoodat
    @dondoodat Рік тому +22

    I thought Ginger Rogers was a person, not an activity.

  • @bsjeffrey
    @bsjeffrey Рік тому +9

    just gotta think ginger in the bottom works on more than horses.

  • @mannmctrash
    @mannmctrash Рік тому +3

    How to put a horse in a trance? Ketamine.

  • @wilsonli5642
    @wilsonli5642 Рік тому +4

    Finally, a safe way to look a gift horse in the mouth!

  • @grahamstubbs4962
    @grahamstubbs4962 Рік тому

    Turn it upside down.
    Oh, no, that's a shark.
    As you were.

  • @heavymetalbassist5
    @heavymetalbassist5 Рік тому +1

    A shot works much better in most cases

  • @AllenKnutson
    @AllenKnutson Рік тому

    I'd heard this as the etymology for "to gin up" something.

  • @stone5against1
    @stone5against1 6 місяців тому

    Oh so it's like holding the scruff of a cat's neck to turn them off

  • @starjake
    @starjake Рік тому +11

    "Pop a ginger up the bottom" has other meanings...

  • @hunterG60k
    @hunterG60k Рік тому +26

    As another commenter mentioned this is nonsense, if someone grabbed your top lip you wouldn't be moving very much either. As prey animals horses respond to stress with either fight, flight, or *freeze*. Just because it's not moving doesn't mean it's calm.

    • @jenkinseric2
      @jenkinseric2 Рік тому +13

      hard to believe you think you know more than the university researchers vets etc.

    • @Tao_Tology
      @Tao_Tology Рік тому

      If a horse is not happy with what you are doing, they will let you know.

    • @mattiasmattsson8758
      @mattiasmattsson8758 Рік тому +2

      ​@@jenkinseric2 Quite easy really. Endorphins are released during pain or stressful events. Using this technique has it uses for vets etc. But I would never condone the use myself and will never use it on my horses under any circumstances.

    • @ThomasSawyers
      @ThomasSawyers Рік тому +1

      ​@@mattiasmattsson8758 is that because you've not and will not ever work with horses beyond seeing them in a field as you drive by?

    • @mattiasmattsson8758
      @mattiasmattsson8758 Рік тому +1

      @@ThomasSawyers I wrote that I would never use it on my horses. But you just ignored that in an attempt to humiliate? I have three swedish warmbloods if you must know to appease your worries. How many horses do you have yourself? Or do you just like to cause animals pain?

  • @YaShaheed
    @YaShaheed Рік тому

    How did they figure out the upper lip thing, he asked? How on Earth did they figure out the ginger thing?!

  • @elaynet382
    @elaynet382 Рік тому +13

    Bonus fun facts: This is where the phrase "stepping gingerly" comes from and also probably the origin of the word "cocktail," because early cocktails were made with ginger, which at the time was said to be used to make horses "keep their tails cocked."

    • @EebstertheGreat
      @EebstertheGreat Рік тому +15

      These are just folk etymologies. "Gingerly" doesn't come from ginger at all but from _gensor_ meaning "daintier." In English, the word meant "daintily" until about 1600, so there is no way it originally came from figging. "Cocktail" probably comes from the practice of docking a horse's tail, but there isn't enough evidence to be sure. There is nothing at all connecting it to ginger though.

  • @evansfamily8156
    @evansfamily8156 Рік тому +27

    The lip twisting can be B.S. Watched a filly fight for all she was worth to break free from the twist. I was horrified! Poor thing.

    • @c0mputer
      @c0mputer Рік тому +8

      The two kilos of ginger you crammed in her first might have been the problem.

    • @JohnyG29
      @JohnyG29 Рік тому +1

      Sure...

  • @feekygucker2678
    @feekygucker2678 Рік тому +1

    Farced!

  • @Wienerblutable
    @Wienerblutable Рік тому

    It was more common to give them arsenic to look good before selling a crappy horse. Long long ago

  • @NomadSoul76
    @NomadSoul76 Рік тому +9

    Just to pile on to what everyone else is saying about this, the fact that it causes the release of endorphins is not necessarily a good thing. That's a pain response. I don't think that's reinforcing the idea that it's a magical horse calmer, it suggests that this is an intensely painful action and that their own biology is trying to damp the pain.

  • @robertoseveno
    @robertoseveno Рік тому

    Ocado > ginger please

  • @brianm6337
    @brianm6337 Рік тому

    Peppermints.

  • @barneylaurance1865
    @barneylaurance1865 Рік тому +3

    Alan makes a very different horse to Kristen Schall.

    • @giustobuffo
      @giustobuffo Рік тому +4

      I don’t see him dance, or go!

    • @barneylaurance1865
      @barneylaurance1865 Рік тому +2

      @@giustobuffo Well look at him not dance, like a look at him not go, like a look at him not dance like a horse!

  • @TonyHavenMusic
    @TonyHavenMusic Рік тому +12

    “Pop a ginger up the bottom” is how Meghan Markle will describe her honeymoon in her book “Bare”

    • @richardchisenhall387
      @richardchisenhall387 Рік тому +3

      I thought it was called Waaaaahhhhh was that the other book?

    • @michaeldeane9243
      @michaeldeane9243 Рік тому

      ​@@richardchisenhall387 do you think he was the Hancock of the royals? The fall guy reveals what we tell him to and plays it as a tell all vicitimhood

    • @Tao_Tology
      @Tao_Tology Рік тому +1

      'No one is talking about her, so I'll bring it up myself and hopefully people can enjoy Being Upset'

  • @commandert5
    @commandert5 Рік тому +2

    I want to know why they're tossing dogs in the air in that painting

  • @laurajarrell6187
    @laurajarrell6187 Рік тому +5

    Sorry guys, they twist it and it is pained because, it twists the nerve at the top of the gum. Or, twists the ear badly. I hated their use and showed people how to use other methods! Don't believe me, just press the nerve under your top lip, very top. Almost to nose. HURTS!👍💖💙🥰✌

  • @sstills951
    @sstills951 Рік тому +2

    I wouldn't care if the ginger works on humans. I think I'll just stick with feeling my age without the ginger in my bottom.

    • @Maya_Pinion
      @Maya_Pinion Рік тому

      🥴

    • @Tao_Tology
      @Tao_Tology Рік тому

      'feeling my age'
      Is that what it's called now?

    • @sstills951
      @sstills951 Рік тому

      @@Tao_Tology well that’s the right way to put it.

  • @pleasy13
    @pleasy13 Рік тому

    Twitching is fucking barbaric.

  • @Serai3
    @Serai3 Рік тому +1

    Seems a bit of an evolutionary disadvantage.

  • @willman85
    @willman85 Рік тому

    Also works with humans.

  • @TheAlllseeeingFish
    @TheAlllseeeingFish Рік тому

    Claire Balding is painfully unfunny.

    • @readmylisp
      @readmylisp Рік тому +1

      She doesn't purport to be a comedienne.