MEMORIES OF MURDER 살인의 추억 (2003) Movie Reaction! | Bong Joon Ho | Song Kang-ho | Kim Sang-kyung
Вставка
- Опубліковано 16 січ 2024
- From the acclaimed director of Parasite Bong Joon Ho comes one of his earlier feature films Memories of Murder. Set in a small Korean province in 1986, the story revolves around two detectives investigating the serial killings of young women in the area. The movie stars Song Kang-ho (Parasite, The Host), Kim Sang-kyung (What's With This Family, Dae Wang Sejong) and Kim Roe-ha (A Bittersweet Life, Little Girl K).
Watch the full length reaction to this movie (as well as many other movies and shows) on our Patreon page!
/ jabykoay
___________________________________________________
SOCIAL MEDIA:
~MICHAEL BOOSE~
Instagram: @BooseIsLoose
~VIVIAN DAY~
Instagram: @DarlingVivling
___________________________________________________
Jaby WEST:
/ getjaby
Jaby INDIA:
/ jabykoay
JABY KOAY'S SHORT FILMS PLAYLIST:
• JABY'S SHORT FILMS & F...
Click here to subscribe and know when the next video drops:
ua-cam.com/users/subscription_c...
Thanks for watching!!!
__________________________________________________
Music from www.EpidemicSound.com
![Memories of Murder - End Scene [HD]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/yJc9O8ogyuM/mqdefault.jpg)
The serial killer in the film was caught in 2019
Yes. Funny thing is that he was already in prison with other crime and thats why he was not caught.
Fact
@@guitar11diary Do you know which character of the movie it was I mean did they show him?
@rimamondal0405 movie was made before he was identified as serial killer for this cases. So this movie is motivated fictional. But really close to real cases.
살인의추억범인잡혓다~이춘재교도소수감
The movie was based on a true story, and even until its release in 2003, the culprit had not been caught(He was actually arrested in 2019). In the final scene of the movie, the protagonist's direct gaze into the camera symbolizes staring at the culprit who might be watching this movie from somewhere in the audience.
He was in jail for long time already. He couldn't stop killing.
DNA testing made him confess
맞습니다. 그래서 제목이 “살인의 추억”이 된거죠
정의는 승리한다.
음??그는 석방 됐을듯? 🥶🥶
The real killer did apparently watch the movie too.
Oh wow, I didn't catch this until watching your post discussion. Thought you guys knew about this going in.
The movie here is based on a true story called the 'Hwaseong serial murders'. 15 women and girls were found murdered between 1986 and 1994. It was South Korea's first case of dealing with a serial killer. Unsurprisingly, the entire investigation was a mess. The police were way in over their head. The interrogations, mishandling of evidence, sloppy detective work, etc. Bong captured all of this with the acts of the detectives in this film.
Long story short, they finally caught the culprit in September 2019 with heavy advancement of DNA testing. The guy's name is Lee Choon-jae, and he was already serving life in prison for the murder of his sister-in-law in 1994, which explains why the murders stopped all of a sudden. Lee confessed in full in 2020 and has also said he watched Memories of Murder in prison.
The character of Kwang-ho, the developmentally disabled character, is based on Yoon Sung-yeo. Yoon was beaten and coerced by the local police until confessing to the murders. It was a LONG process with a lot of cops thinking they had the right suspect as opposed to the majority of the public, who didn't believe he was the actual criminal. One of Bong's motivations of making the movie was to cast more doubt on Yoon's charge and reignite the talk of the case. All in all, Yoon spent nearly 20 years in jail before being released in 2009 on parole. After Lee's capture in 2019, Yoon and his family sought a complete acquittal and compensation for his wrongful conviction. He was awarded $2.2 million after a court sided with him.
As for the ending of the film. Bong wanted Song Kang-ho to look into the camera to remind the killer, wherever he was at the time, that the case wasn't going to be easily forgotten. He also wanted the public to realize that this killer was still out there, possibly among them, living his life like a normal "ordinary" person.
Thanks for watching this amazing film guys.
👍👍
I'm Korean, and this is an A++ explanation.
TV Series SIGNAL was also based on this case and equally amazing.
hey, may I just add a little detail that amazed me, in the last part of the 2003 movie it showed that the suspect might be around somewhere looking "ordinary." They added that part because they believed he wasn't caught yet. (to cast doubt on Yoon's arrest)
The funny part is, the suspect was quite smug that he didn't get caught with the murders. He said that the police didn't suspect him at all. He said he just breezed through them.
When in fact, it was shown in the movie, that the prime suspect (the one the investigator almost killed in the end), had the characteristics of the real suspect himself. The actor and the suspect looked alike. Said he was skinny and had a look of some sort. Ultimately, he also just got out of the Military during that time. Which, in the movie, they all got those characters rightly portrayed.
The directors and investigators didn't know the fact that they were portraying the actual suspect; displaying an open ending in 2003, when in fact he was caught on 1994, and after the 2019 confession, it just shows they were right on track. While the suspect thought he hid well, the movie shows that he didn't do a very good job, in fact, they almost caught him. Too bad they didn't have "solid" evidence.
I just want to appreciate this comment and shower my love for putting up like this
Incredible movie. Firmly believe it's Bong Joon-ho's best movie, even over 'Parasite'. Heck, all 3 movies of his from 2003 - 2009 are masterpieces.
agreed. Parasite is a masterpiece, but the last scene of Song starring into the camera in Memories of Murder sends shivers down my spine.
This is a masterpiece and incredible film. The story is based on true crime event and very famous one, known as one of the most unsolved murder mystery/serial killing in Korea (but in around 2019, finally they caught the serial killer unintentionally and accidentally). When Director Bong made this film, it was still mystery and he could capture the uncertain and unclear killer but still gave us amazing story line. Sublime.
As I remembered the real killer was one of the many young men in that village that investigated by police but he was never be the suspect.
You can watch "Mother", that's another Director Bong's amazing murder mystery. really good one.
You should do more of these korean thrillers. The storylines and acting are always fantastic. . Tbh , better than anything from Hollywood.
Fact
@@mango2654 Yeah, try 'The Chaser' directed by Na Hong-Jin. You will love it.
FYI, they FOUND THE MURDERER in 2019. It turned out that he was already serving a life sentence in prison for murdering his sister-in-law. DNA matched with the sperm found in the crime scene and he confessed as well.
i got goosebumps after i watch the movie then made a research about it
omg this is actually the best true life/cop movie of all time... thank you for presenting this movie... it's a cultural milestone
This movie is simply an all timer not just for korean cinema but world cinema
I have interpreted this climax like this. At the time of release the killer was still not caught at least for the murders he committed so in the end the main actor was looking at the viewers in cinema halls by giving a impression that the killer might be sitting among them or watching the film from somewhere.
This is a great film. That murder's pov shot of choosing his victim is genius. I watch all films from this director and they're all really good and interesting. Apart from Parasite, Memories of Murder is my favourite from Bong Joon Ho. Knowing that the real murder was not yet captured when the film was made make this film even more impressive. What a vision by Bong Joon Ho.
When the movie was released, it was an unsolved case where the culprit was not caught yet
the girl's last line, "The culprit looks normal," means that someone who looks normal around us can be the culprit
actor Song Kang-ho looks straight into the camera, and by staring directly at the criminal who may be watching the movie somewhere, it means, "We're always watching you and we'll catch you."
I think Bong Joon Ho's movie is more fun because I can interpret the meanings that are presented
This is one of my top ten favorite movies
It had served the police force as a trauma. It was something that every police men echoed 'Gotta get this sucker' in their mind. Most of the detective served in 80's and 90's retired and they kept all the evidence from the crime scenes, hoping that future technology would better analyze the suspect. So it did. They found the DNA match from the inmate.
At that time, DNA analysis technology had just been released. Therefore, even if the suspect's DNA was collected, it could not be clearly identified.
The investigators in the case regretted for the rest of their lives that they could not catch the culprit and entrusted the case to their juniors.
About 40 years later, DNA samples were obtained again from evidence left behind by high-ranking investigators, and the real culprit was finally revealed.
I'd actually put this above Parasite
Fun fact, the scene where those 2 detectives met at the field, that kick wasn't on the script, it was adlib by song. so that kick came surprisingly to actor Kim and his reaction in the movie was very raw.
와 ~~ 봉준호 감독님 작품 연달아서 두개 리뷰 올리셨네요^^ ❤ 한국인으로서
두 작품 모두 흥미롭게 잘봤고, 살인의 추억은 실화를 바탕으로 만든거기 때문에 당시 센세이션 했었죠..송강호님의 연기도 좋았구요 .약 20여년간 범인이 잡히지 않았었는데
몇년전 수사결과 당시 범인이
이미 다른전과로 감옥에 복역중이어서 그랬다는;;;;
20여년간 안잡힌게 아니나 30여년임 정확히는 33년
To this day, it is still my favourite Bong Joon Ho film. The ending is still as haunting as it was the first time I watched it. The fact that this was loosely based on true story is insane, but yeah, this film is a flawless masterpiece!
This is something i would watch along with zodiac
now this is a Korean classic!! such a good movie. demented and just unhinged
이 영화는 봉준호 최고의 걸작으로 평가 받는다
헐리우드 영화 조디악이 이영화의 영향을 많이 받았다
This is at least top 5 in cinema history. My journey in Korean movies started with this movie when I watched it back in 2009.
I rate this film the highest among director Bong Joon-ho's films.
This is a real incident. At that time, Korea was a dictatorship. It expresses well the atmosphere of the police at the time. In fact, there were several instances of this type of forced criminalization.
The actual culprit will be revealed much later.
The last scene of the movie is,
This scene was included because it was expected that the murderer, who had not been caught at the time of the film's release, would see this film.
(It is said that the criminal actually saw this movie.)
An absolute masterpiece movie.
This movie is absolutely masterpiece
1. The criminal was not caught when this movie was released, but in 2019, it was confirmed that the criminal was sentenced to death for another crime and is in prison.
2. Although this film does not reveal it directly, it indirectly criticizes the ruthless rule of the military regime in the 1980s.
3. Starting in 2003, when Memories of Murder and Old Boy were released, the Korean film industry began to expand both quantitatively and qualitatively, and for Koreans, this feels similar to the year 1492 when Columbus discovered the American continent.
I like the bit where Seo Tae-yoon reads the DNA analysis from the FBI with the words "examnation", "Octorber" and "directer", and says, "There's a mistake."
Audiences that know Bong Joon-Ho through Snowpiercer and Parasite might think Parasite is his best film, but I'd argue that his masterpiece is Memories of Murder.
Based mostly on the true case of the first identified serial killer in Korea's modern history, Memories of Murder shows beautifully yet with a lot of bleakness and cynism how the investigation was mishandleled in all the worst possible ways and let to the murderer evading police by the time the movie was made.
A pretty unflatering portray of Korea of the time, but such a riveting experience.
Since I've seen it, it has jumped in my list of 10 favorite movies of all time.
A required viewing for anyone who loves cinema (and for all aprentice detectives to know what NOT to do in an police investigation).
Zodiac movie was greatly influenced by Memories of Murder.
That was never confirmed. Just one of many internet facts
@@JohnJohnson27-cs6ix It's true that I was influenced. If you don't believe it, watch both Memories of Murder and Zodiac.
that flying kick at the beginning was improvisation by Song kang-ho.
Next you should watch Mother by bong joon ho. I liked Mother and Memories of murder more than Parasite. Also everyone should definitely check out the films of Bong Joon Ho and Park chan wook once. Watch the vengeance trilogy of park chan wook.
마더 올드보이 두개는
한국영화 리액트 하신다면 꼭 봐야할 영화입니다ㅎㅎ
이제 올드보이 리액션 갑시다
the fact that when this movie was released, the MURDERER IS STILL OUT THERE probably watching the movie🙃 cmiiw.
thanks for the reaction!>
it's from a real event btw (for u guys who didn't know)
@@jaehyunjjhyunoh The murderer actually watched the movie. And he got caught in 2020 btw
@@mclovin8435 righttt? that's what im sayin and it's so crazyyyy😭
the murderer was already in prison before the films realeased..
Thanks for the fun reaction! I would recommend The Outlaws and Round Up performed by Ma Dong Seok. Only one channel did the reaction of The Outlaws a couple of weeks ago, and they got many views out of it. The movies are fun, and there is only one reaction on UA-cam.
This case(화성연쇄살인사건) was solved after 30 years. The criminal was already in prison for another murder case.
DNA from evidence stored for 30 years and technological advancements solved the case.
그냥저냥 ❤옜날 ❤보고❤들어요 ❤😊네!!!
best movie 😍
I recommend "Joint security Area", "Castaway on the moon" and "The Handmaiden" These are three best korean movies ever
Oh... this is a really good movie!
If you're interested in good Korean movies based on true events and history, I strongly recommend these below.
"Taegukgi"(태극기 휘날리며, 2004)
"The Front Line"(고지전, 2011)
"Ode to My Father"(국제시장, 2014)
"Silmido"(실미도, 2003)
"The Man Standing Next"(남산의 부장들, 2020)
"12.12: The Day"(서울의 봄, 2023)
"May 18"(화려한 휴가, 2007)
"A Taxi Driver"(택시 운전사, 2017)
"The Attorney"(변호인, 2013)
"Memories of Murder"(살인의 추억, 2003)
"1987: When the Day Comes"(1987, 2017)
"Default"(국가부도의 날, 2018)
They are really fun to watch, too. Also, I advise watching them in the order I wrote above. Enjoy!
You guys have to watch Bong’s another movie called “Mother”. It’s crazy!!
뷰티풀 무비 ㄷㄷ💪💪💪
In the 1980s, especially in Gyeonggi-do, women were told not to wear red clothes in the evening
By the way, anyone notice that the last girl killed was the same girl that the smart detective interacted with at the school? The girl had the same band-aid that he applied on her at the school infirmary, which is why he tried to cover the girl's corpse with her clothes when the police removed her band-aid as a sign respect for her. This is also what i think motivated him to go mad and directly drag the killer from his own home and give some physical retaliation, which is very unlike his usual sensible character.
I recommend ’Mother’.
한국❤80년도❤같이보고❤싶어서요😊😊😊
저 영화는 실화를 바탕으로 만들어졌고 영화속 범죄자를 실제로 찾았습니다. 범인을 발견했을땐 이미 교도소에서 복역중인 상태였습니다.
This movie is a Korean real story, and the criminal was already in prison for another incident. I really enjoyed watching it and it's a movie with both cinematic and popularity.
watch another bong joon ho masterpiece "mother".
my favourite movie.......this is better than parasite as american s got exposed to korean cinema through parasite becoz of oscar .......😅
내가 '개 같은 날의 오후' 이후로 한국영화를 절대 보지 않기로 마음 먹고 정말 오랫동안 그 다짐을 지켰다가 '살인의 추억'을 보고 그 다짐을 접었음 ㅎㅎ
호....혹시.....연세가......
@@user-hq1qg6cj8d 19살에 데이트 때 극장에서 봤습...자세한 설명은 생략합니다;
어...음... 인정 합니다
옛날엔 한국영화 수준이 뭐같아서 절대안본다고 생각하며 산 사람들이 많았지요.저도 쉬리 후에 보기시작했네요.
finally found it in 2019. However, it turned out that in 1995, he sexually assaulted and killed his 19-year-old sister-in-law (that is, his wife's sister), received a life sentence, and was serving 24 years as a model prisoner at the Busan Prison.
I think I lived a meticulously exemplary life, knowing that only exemplary prisoners can be granted parole after 20 years. Scary guy. I almost got released.
Of course, it can't be concluded in the movie. It was one of the top three unsolved cases in Korea that couldn't be concluded.
However, DNA was recently discovered at the end of September 2019, and it was revealed that the leading suspect was Lee Chun-jae, who is currently serving a life imprisonment sentence.
(After flatly denying it, Lee Chun-jae confessed to committing all nine cases of Hwaseong on October 1, 2019, after putting in a profiler, presenting DNA evidence, and persuading him. A total of 14 cases were involved. He confessed more that he had raped three cases before Hwaseong murder and two and 30 cases before sister-in-law murder in Suwon and Cheongju, North Chungcheong Province. In the best eight years in the history of the Republic of Korea, 15 people were killed, 30 were raped and attempted rape.
It's a 100% real case, and it's a rare serial murder case that all Koreans know except for children.
At the present time, it would have been caught quickly, but at the time of 1986, scientific investigations and CCTV were so poor that it is a pity that we could not catch them.
I found out that it's so similar to Park Hyun-kyu in that movie that I got goosebumps. At that time, the green montage and high school graduation pictures were almost identical, and the place where you live, the company, the appearance, the crime after the military discharge, etc. were so consistent.
Yesss finally!
Classic
If u love serial killer movie i recommend u watch "the chaser"🇰🇷 it's kinda good .
Too bad they couldn't indict the perpetrator for the murders. S. Korea had statutory limitations on murder of 17 years back then. The limitations have been lifted since 2015 effective for murder cases from 2003. The perpetrator of the murders rendered in the movie is still incarcerated for other crimes he committed. He practically kissed his chances of parole good-bye with the revelation though. The movie is my all-time favorite along with the entire Star Wars franchise.
Wow 2003?
one thing I like in this movie is
you get to see naturally how korea was under military dictatorship at 80s without noticing
This film was based on true story of Korea in 1980's. That serise killer was under arrested in 2020.
37:00 they ended it like that becoz she said he looks like an ordinary person.....so the detective is looking at the audience.....and also research more you will get more info about the criminal being out at the release of this movie and watching this film alsoooo.............i think this film is not for you who r busy watching marvel kids stuff...............that last STARE was the most impactful scene and u were like😐
Finally
19:26 Drama Principal 😆😆😆
I suggest you read about the case. The murderer was caught in 2019 and just like his description, he was an average looking guy with soft hands.
While the guy they suspected (the one whose DNA results came back inconclusive) was not the murderer, the actor in the film does look like the real culprit, that's some weird twist of fate.
They caught someone, or rather, dropped the case on someone, who was in jail for 30 years before he was exonerated and the man was LIMPING.
Like how did they even think it could have been the same man running after young women in the open?
Like the movie describes, the interrogations were anything but proffessional and 4 of the scores of people suspected actually commited suicide.
The worse part is that one of the victim was only 8 years old and the police feared the public outrage would put too much pressure on them so they lied to her parents and said she ran away.
For 30 years they had the hopes she was still alive.
This movie is superb, a masterpiece, but also a cautionary tale waht NOT TO DO as a detective.
Btw, the murderer was in jail sice 1994. He had been arrested for the rape and murder of his sister in law and by chance and an advancement in forensic he was discovered to be linked to the murders 15 years after the film was made.
He wasn't interested in seeing the movie and said he won't be demanding parole because he knows there is no chance he could get out and people would just ignore him so he rather stay in jail till his last day.
영화학 전공자에게는 교과서같은 영화죠.
명작입니다.
This movie is based on a true story.
It was unfinished until the ending of the last movie. However, in reality, the movie was completed when the culprit was revealed in 2019.
In fact, the culprit looked like a prime suspect in a movie.
This movie was truly completed like that.
The movie is based on a real incident. It was not able to catch the culprit at the time, but in 2019 it was caught with the development of DNA analysis technology. The scene where the last ending of the movie, Park Doo-man (Song Kang-ho), looks straight ahead and ends
Detective Eun makes eye contact to see you
That's what I wanted to do. It's the best ending ever.
Watch "Mother" Thought!!
Michael is a great reactor and fun with lots of good points, but tends to talk over Vivian a lot. Would be nice to hear more of her thoughts too!
If you like crime, mystery, and detective stuff. Please react to Signal 2016!
어머!!! 살인의 추억을!!!!!! 대박!!
If you liked this movie, you should also like another Korean film titled The Wailing.
try " i met the devil " / " old boy " / " 2 sisters " / " a bitersweet life " / " train to busan " / ... :)
올해 20주년
Thank You!!!😍
26:22 😂
please, please, react to Twinkling watermelon! It's really good!
React to Death's Game please its a awesome story ❤
please react to death's game or reborn rich🙏
PLEASE IM BEGGING YOU REACT TO THE FIRST SEASON OF TAXI DRIVER THE KDRAMA. IT’S TRUE CRIME REVENGE SHOW ABOUT A GROUP OF VIGILANTES THAT TAKE REVENGE FOR OTHERS AND ALL THE CASES ARE BASED ON REAL ONES.
Next react deaths game please...
TV Series SIGNAL was also based on this case and equally amazing. If Michael loves Korean detective movies, watch the Veteran.
Old boy plz❤🎉❤
At the time the movie was set, DNA technology was non-existent in Korea,
but with the development of DNA technology, the criminal was eventually caught in prison.
The criminal was already in prison serving a life sentence for killing his sister-in-law.
Previous murder cases could not be punished because the statute of limitations had already passed.
Until 2015, there was a statute of limitations for murder, but it was abolished.
Now, if the evidence is well preserved, even the last name of the criminal can be found using DNA.
This is because the last name is paternally inherited, except for adoption or some cases.
The criminal said he watched the movie in prison and didn't think much of the ending scene.
한국의 k드라마 k뮤비 정주행 중이시군요
신과함께 7번방의 선물 태극기 휘날리며
범죄도시
도깨비 대장금 허준 가을동화 겨울연가 등등
추천합니다
you should try reacting to signal (2016). It is a great detective serious tv show. this one is fictional oldy but a goody
I SAW THE DEVIL next
Please do a reaction for movie "Cold Eyes" (2013) from Korea.
Vivian is so beautiful. 😍 Her smile is sunshine. i think i have a girl crush
이영화는 1980년대를 배경으로하고있다.~ 영화가알리고자하는건 범죄는 절대로 잊혀지지안는다는것을 실화를 바탕으로하고있다.~
리액셔너 여자분 정말 아름다우심
한국분임?
@@skyyy1004 저분 국적이 어떤지 저야 모르죠..
It is unknown whether the movis's popularity in fluenced it, but it was not until 2019 that the real culprit was caught through DNA analysis due to the development of scientific investigation.
He was already serving a life sentence for other murder crimes, and he obtained a confession through interrogation with analytical evidence.
Unfortunately, however, the cases at that time were past the statute of limitation, so additional punishment was impossible...
Please reaction k drama ( it's okay to not be okay ) Netflix k drama 🙏🙏
봉준호 감독의 다른 명작인 ' 괴물 ' 도 추천드립니다~
This includes criticism of the then incompetent police and coercive junta
Throughout the movie, the wrong people were tortured or killed
31:20 detective has blood on his hand
28:14 female college student sexual assault torture investigation was on the TV news, and it actually happened
violent flight jacket,military boots-style detective lost his leg after being stabbed by a nail
23:25 At this point, the investigation team leader asked for a 2 company
But they didn't support the pro-democracy protests because they were suppressing them
Please reaction to movie V.I.P ❤❤❤❤
The culprit was caught in 2019 and the content of it is linked below though it was broadcast in Korean language.
ua-cam.com/video/hONphATdzTI/v-deo.htmlsi=DY41IrTI0Vu_qDJu
Yooooo
엉망진창 ❤!
이춘재 연쇄 살인 사건
Great movie but when I watched it i just felt awful to the point I couldn’t enjoy it cause I watched it before 2019 and at that time it was believed that he was still free
React to Twinkling Watermelon kdrama