Yes thats true becouse she is younger , lets see her sing this again in 30 years , it won't be good at all. Besides. Anything mafonna sings is flawless and magical becouse she is the queen
+waleed alawadhi In 30 years she'll be on top of the vocalists' category alongwith her contemporaries like Nicole Scherzinger, Amy Winehouse & Beyonce....just like once Whitney, Mariah and Celine were at the top. [I mean, they still are, but now, they're not the only ones] ;)
Gagas voice is more powerfull however I liked more Madonnas perfomance simply because was more natural and romantic.. Gaga was more teatrical and kind of fake like everything that she does.
madonna is more genuinely soulful and most appealing. this video was unfair, as it was madonna's least good performance of this song i've seen/heard. gag is all show, and who cares!
There is not even a competition to begin with. Gaga is so versatile and skilled vocally to be even compared to Madonna. Please next time if you’ll make a VS video compare those who are on a par with each other. As a suggestion Taylor, Madonna, Selena Gomez and Britney hahahahaha Gaga will end them with ease 😂
Of course, Gaga wins for me. Not only because she can belt, but because her voice projects me deeply, Madonna is singing as if it's a third grade karaoke show. Now, I respect both the artists, but IMO, Madonna ain't half as good as Gaga as a vocalist, whereas Gaga is both a good vocalist, and an above-average dancer..... :)
not agree Madonnas voice is not bad at all. she delivered a beautiful perfomance. yes gagas voice is better and powerful but is not a matter of having better voice.
mondy2000 I didn't say Madonna's voice is bad, either....however, I also strongly believe that Madonna ain't THAT GOOD either...she isn't good enough to be called a 'vocalist'. Whereas, Gaga is both a vocalist, and a performer.... :)
+rishabhrox1 Madonna is a very good vocalist and singer. You are just a little monster who tries to defend your mother to dead, with no sense arguments. good luck with that
mondy2000 No, firstly, I'm not a little monster, I very much respect Madonna and Gaga both. But, facts are facts. Gaga is much more versatile than Madonna vocally; and although Gaga is one step behind Madonna when it comes to dancing, I still find Gaga more respectable because she never lip syncs while dancing....while Madge does countless times... :P
You can have talent and the best voice in the world, but thats not the winning factor. you need to have charisma a great personality and love what youre doing thats the key to success. Madonna has it all
mondy2000 charisma...that's a matter of taste, Madge has been around longer than Gaga...so its kinda obvious that, she is gonna impact more people, but in 7 years, if Gaga can impact even half that no., shes a star imo.
charisma is not a matter of taste. is a special personal quality or power of an individual making him capable of influencing or inspiring large numbers of people. The perfect word that can describe Madonna. Again Gaga is super talented, I love her now on her new role in TV but I don't see her having a long career as a singer anymore.
+clara clara GAGA TAKES ALL ABOUT MADONNA. MADONNA IS NOT THE BEST SINGER BUT SHE MAKES HISTORY EVERY DAY. SHE IS THE ORIGINAL VERSION OF POP SINGERS TODAY
Gagas voice is more teatrical. her voice is powerful and she can sing anything. however Madonnas voice is not bad at all and her perfomance has more soul it was more romantic.
+Make Hyvönen LOL what a pathetic comeback, your saying she failed at everything when in reality she achieved more than all the other pop girls including Mafossil in just 8 years. You mafossil fans try way to hard to shade gaga. but you fail at it like madonna failed to revive her career since 2008
madonna is more genuinely soulful and most appealing. this video was unfair, as it was madonna's least good performance of this song i've seen/heard. gag is all show, and who cares!
Ok, Im a little Monster and im definitely with Gaga , her voice is so powerful, But i also love Madonna’s Version, its just so sweet and warm ❤️❤️❤️ cutie
I love both Gaga and Madonna but the people saying Madonna can't sing or sounds horrible are clearly biased af. Yes Gaga is a superior singer but saying Madonna can't sing especially evident in this video is just pure spite. She sounded wonderful.
Lady Gaga es más apreciativa, es decir, la canta para dar a notar su potencia y vibrato (lo cual lo hace perfectamente)... Pero Madonna lo hace con sentimiento, es más relajada, usa tonos mas bajos para ambientar algo tranquilo y romantico Para mi ambas estan bien 💜
Lady gaga = Good stronger voice, but too concerned with hitting the nice notes..there's no emotion transmitted Madonna = not as powerful voice but the tones of the voice and feeling is there...not everything is about how loud you can sing....
my problem with lady gaga is the same with xtina, they lost the focus, we know they can sing so they don't need trying to demonstrate it everytime... I preffer Madonna version, I'm not saying she's better (nor worst), but she brings an special experience with this performance
Madonna by far! Because she actually understands and respects the song, her version is simple but very heartfelt and emotional and you can clearly see that by the crowd's reaction. Gaga's version is vocally impressive, but that's about it, no emotions and no connection with the song.
The reason Madonna's version connects more with the crowd is because she is in French speaking Canada, where the song has history and is immensely popular
+Will Shinn no, the reason why Madonna connects is because A) Madonna conveys emotion unlike gaga, B) it's Madonna...she will always be more interesting than Gaga. it is what it is.
madonna sang it soo beautifully! i absolutely loved her rendition! but mother monster just had something very special in her performance, hers was just magical.
Gaga is for sure a better vocalist,but Madonna is a better artist,she is a living legend!A pioneer!Shes been there for more than 30 years and still goes on,always inovating! I like then both,by the way,and I think we should just stop comparing them.
Both performances are just great in a different way!... Madonna does it more acoustic, with a very similar arrangement to the original sung by Edith Piaf and with an excellent french accent. Lady Gaga does it in that very lovely jazzy style that she's been showing us she handle so well, maybe not with such a perfect french accent (Not bad at all anyway) but with a very strong voice and high singing skills!!!... So there's no need to fight for none of them!... Btw, I love them both for different reasons and they both are wonderful, talented and clever artists!
@@AlexeBriand2002 and also she performed Marry The Night as the ENCORE of the show during the tour, sometimes even acapella, and it was one of the most emotional moments of the show
Im a big fan of lady gaga but please stop to insult madonna again and again , if you don't like her its okay , but you don't need to insult her , it's not the message that gaga give to her fans , and you really don't represent the community of the little monster by saying that ..
I’m sorry I’m prob gonna get hate I love both but Madonna’s version just touched my soul she’s such and emotive singer she might not be able to hit the notes of Gaga but it’s like she tells a story when she sings and I love that she’s embracing her French side
both versions are really good in their own right. Maddona's softer version is actually closer to the original Edith Piaff's interpretation as her voice was unique but not so powerful. On the other hand Gaga has a powerful very resonant voice and I love a powerful song. I love her Jayne Mansfield look as well. They're both talented singers
no son el mismo tipo de voces no hay punto de comparación cada quien en sus versiones es grandiosa ya que cada quien pone su esencia madonna con una versión Dulce y relajada logra controlar todo un concierto, y gaga con ese vozarrón que se carga es asombrosa, por que discutir de quien es mejor? es arte solo disfrutemos de estas grandes interpretes y canta autoras. ❤living for music ❤living for love
I'm a Little Monster and I prefer Gaga's version, but Madonna was good too. They sang 2 different version of the song, but they both sang the song well
Madonnas version is sweet and beautiful.
Gaga's version is bold, powerful and vocally impressive.
Both are fantastic.
Gaga is technically and vocally superior guys...let's be honest
Yes thats true becouse she is younger , lets see her sing this again in 30 years , it won't be good at all. Besides. Anything mafonna sings is flawless and magical becouse she is the queen
+waleed alawadhi *madonna
uhm.........no
+waleed alawadhi In 30 years she'll be on top of the vocalists' category alongwith her contemporaries like Nicole Scherzinger, Amy Winehouse & Beyonce....just like once Whitney, Mariah and Celine were at the top. [I mean, they still are, but now, they're not the only ones] ;)
Gagas voice is more powerfull however I liked more Madonnas perfomance simply because was more natural and romantic.. Gaga was more teatrical and kind of fake like everything that she does.
There's so contest. Lady Gaga is, and always has been, the better singer
madonna is more genuinely soulful and most appealing. this video was unfair, as it was madonna's least good performance of this song i've seen/heard. gag is all show, and who cares!
Kelly ok. But to me there is no winner both are great
clearly you do lmao
True :) but Maddy’s voice is really emotive!
There is not even a competition to begin with. Gaga is so versatile and skilled vocally to be even compared to Madonna. Please next time if you’ll make a VS video compare those who are on a par with each other. As a suggestion Taylor, Madonna, Selena Gomez and Britney hahahahaha Gaga will end them with ease 😂
Anyone saying Madonna is better must suffer of serious earing problems!
Gagas voice is better and powerfull however Madonnas perfomance was more romantic. Gaga was more teatrical sounds fake just my opinion
+mirko vettori anyone thinking that Vocal range and a loud performance without any soul is superior is a BASIC BITCH
These bitches are bugging out... Madonna didn't suck, but loll compared to gaga vocally she does. Sorry bout it!
waw u nust have very sensitiv ears dont u? ;)
Lady Gaga has a stronger vocal ability obviously but Madonna sang it so beautifully aswell ❤
Madonna actually impressed me, however this has got to go to Gaga, without a doubt. Both good though. :)
I with you Madonna did great but that cant out stand Gaga's...
GaGa is obviously a better vocalist but Madonna was not that bad
Of course, Gaga wins for me. Not only because she can belt, but because her voice projects me deeply, Madonna is singing as if it's a third grade karaoke show. Now, I respect both the artists, but IMO, Madonna ain't half as good as Gaga as a vocalist, whereas Gaga is both a good vocalist, and an above-average dancer..... :)
not agree Madonnas voice is not bad at all. she delivered a beautiful perfomance. yes gagas voice is better and powerful but is not a matter of having better voice.
mondy2000 I didn't say Madonna's voice is bad, either....however, I also strongly believe that Madonna ain't THAT GOOD either...she isn't good enough to be called a 'vocalist'. Whereas, Gaga is both a vocalist, and a performer.... :)
+rishabhrox1 Madonna is a very good vocalist and singer. You are just a little monster who tries to defend your mother to dead, with no sense arguments. good luck with that
mondy2000 No, firstly, I'm not a little monster, I very much respect Madonna and Gaga both. But, facts are facts. Gaga is much more versatile than Madonna vocally; and although Gaga is one step behind Madonna when it comes to dancing, I still find Gaga more respectable because she never lip syncs while dancing....while Madge does countless times... :P
+rishabhrox1 Ok darling
GAGA FOR SURE... this woman can sing anything Literally
I love both versions but prefer Gaga's version.
Talent always wins, so Gaga wins.
+Mac Buckingham REMEMBER GAGA TAKES ALL FROM MADONNA. MADONNA IS MUCH BETTER
You can have talent and the best voice in the world, but thats not the winning factor. you need to have charisma a great personality and love what youre doing thats the key to success. Madonna has it all
+mondy2000 Yeaaaah!
mondy2000 charisma...that's a matter of taste, Madge has been around longer than Gaga...so its kinda obvious that, she is gonna impact more people, but in 7 years, if Gaga can impact even half that no., shes a star imo.
charisma is not a matter of taste. is a special personal quality or power of an individual making him capable of influencing or inspiring large numbers of people. The perfect word that can describe Madonna.
Again Gaga is super talented, I love her now on her new role in TV but I don't see her having a long career as a singer anymore.
By the way Lady Gaga did it better :)
no she didn't
+Make Hyvönen you wish
+Ricky Santos Do you know why Gagas fans are called monsters, cuz they like Gaga and she sounds like dead chicken
Make Hyvönen Madonna can't even sing, you better shut the fuck up, don't be ridiculous
Ricky Santos jealousy old hag XD
Gaga's voice is like silk. As both women are good, Gaga's voice flows and her high notes are more powerful.
MADONNA BETTER??? HAHA PLEASE
GAGA CAN SING ANYTHING, LIKE THIS
SLAY MOTHER!!!!!
+clara clara GAGA TAKES ALL ABOUT MADONNA. MADONNA IS NOT THE BEST SINGER BUT SHE MAKES HISTORY EVERY DAY. SHE IS THE ORIGINAL VERSION OF POP SINGERS TODAY
+clara clara MADONNA BECAUSE SHE SINGS LIKE A WOMAN DOES. SHE IS A REAL WOMAN SINGING
+clara clara ok baby yaaaassssss
Gagas voice is more teatrical. her voice is powerful and she can sing anything. however Madonnas voice is not bad at all and her perfomance has more soul it was more romantic.
MADONNA IS THE ORIGINAL
tHIS IS NOT FAIR CAUSE MADONNA CAN'T SING
this isnt fair because gaga tried too hard to sound better but faild it like every other thing she is just a ARTFLOP
+Make Hyvönen LOL what a pathetic comeback, your saying she failed at everything when in reality she achieved more than all the other pop girls including Mafossil in just 8 years. You mafossil fans try way to hard to shade gaga. but you fail at it like madonna failed to revive her career since 2008
+Make Hyvönen Considering ARTPOP sold more than MDNA and Rebal heart combined! Gaga is the Queen
Christian C.H Exactly
Doesn’t that make it fair? And besides, Madonna has the nerve to diss Gaga so I mean. Why diss a singer who can actually sing lmao
GAGA ALL THE FUCKING WAY
Gaga is so much better
Gaga can hit really HIGHT notes so easily
gaga has such a beautiful, soaring voice. madonna, meh. have to say she did give a good performance though. but it's gaga all the way for me.
Gaga for the win!
madonna is more genuinely soulful and most appealing. this video was unfair, as it was madonna's least good performance of this song i've seen/heard. gag is all show, and who cares!
holarc we don't care
holarc how many times are u gonna type that, we dont give a fuck
Gaga is better.
Gaga is much much much better 😍
Lady Gaga Queen of music , your voice is best ♥♥♥♥♥♥
+tiago tavaresMADONNA BECAUSE MADONNA SINGS LIKE A WOMAN DOES
Hahahahha Madonna best vocal ? :v kkkkkkkkkkk
Madonna sing Jazz , Rock , Opera , Blues , well ? Madonna sing bad pop , I do not see she sing Opera , Blues or Jazz kkkkk
I do not know if you understand
me, because I do not write very
well in English
(y)
+tiago tavares Madonna sang all of them, look it up bitch
I don't think madonna can sing
josh kardashian she definitely can carry a tune she's just not a powerhouse. but she's a creative and a hit maker and that has merit as well
Don't Cry For Me Argentina says hi
It's time for you to believe in it couse she do it from 1977
Gaga is wayyyyyyyy better obviously
Ok, Im a little Monster and im definitely with Gaga , her voice is so powerful, But i also love Madonna’s Version, its just so sweet and warm ❤️❤️❤️ cutie
Same!!!!
Gaga (y)
I love both Gaga and Madonna but the people saying Madonna can't sing or sounds horrible are clearly biased af. Yes Gaga is a superior singer but saying Madonna can't sing especially evident in this video is just pure spite. She sounded wonderful.
Madonna version is so sweet but Gaga's power is unique
Lady Gaga es más apreciativa, es decir, la canta para dar a notar su potencia y vibrato (lo cual lo hace perfectamente)... Pero Madonna lo hace con sentimiento, es más relajada, usa tonos mas bajos para ambientar algo tranquilo y romantico
Para mi ambas estan bien 💜
Lady gaga = Good stronger voice, but too concerned with hitting the nice notes..there's no emotion transmitted
Madonna = not as powerful voice but the tones of the voice and feeling is there...not everything is about how loud you can sing....
Finally a comment that makes sense!!
+TarantulaCandy Exactly!
But they can each interpret the song however they want hun.
TarantulaCandy ua-cam.com/video/pmkT1Mor7n4/v-deo.html
No Competition Lady Gaga is WAY!!!! better in EVER SINGLE WAY!
Im a monster and Madonna did great but undeniably Gaga considers one of the greatest voice of our generation
Madonna is the Queen but Gaga is THE GODDESS.
#VENUS
Queeny Agreed
Cher says hi
Sorry but the goddess is the only Cher, Madonna is the queen
Ahmhm fine, gaga is the queen, cher is the goddess, screw madonna
Lady Gaga
Gaga
my problem with lady gaga is the same with xtina, they lost the focus, we know they can sing so they don't need trying to demonstrate it everytime... I preffer Madonna version, I'm not saying she's better (nor worst), but she brings an special experience with this performance
MauPictures Your problem with Gaga is because she can sing and Mad could never
I like Madonna and Lady Gaga... but Madonna is the better one!
Both singing are great, but I prefer Madonna's version because I think is more romantic
Madonna by far! Because she actually understands and respects the song, her version is simple but very heartfelt and emotional and you can clearly see that by the crowd's reaction. Gaga's version is vocally impressive, but that's about it, no emotions and no connection with the song.
+idc Flopdonna does not know the full song she can't sing she spunds horrible she is a flop
+Sebastian War MADONNA IS THE REIGNING QUEEN OF POP TROLL. GET A LIFE PLEASE . SHE IS A REAL WOMAN
In your opinion right?
The reason Madonna's version connects more with the crowd is because she is in French speaking Canada, where the song has history and is immensely popular
+Will Shinn no, the reason why Madonna connects is because A) Madonna conveys emotion unlike gaga, B) it's Madonna...she will always be more interesting than Gaga. it is what it is.
madonna sang it soo beautifully! i absolutely loved her rendition! but mother monster just had something very special in her performance, hers was just magical.
Madonna voice is sweet and sentimental
Okay, I really don't know why people say madonna can't sing like, she can sing y'all
Lmao well Ofc she can sing... just not like gaga, who’s vocal ability and range is far more superior compared to Madonna.
@@hogwartsismyhome6474 Both are mezzos with 3 octaves, their ranges arent very different.
@@eurech can Madonna pull off a sound of music tribute, the way Gaga did? I’d love to see that then I’ll believe “their ranges aren’t very different”
@@hogwartsismyhome6474 Madonna literally played the part of Eva Perón
Gaga is for sure a better vocalist,but Madonna is a better artist,she is a living legend!A pioneer!Shes been there for more than 30 years and still goes on,always inovating! I like then both,by the way,and I think we should just stop comparing them.
Gaga 💞💞💞💞
of course lady gaga 😍
Lady Gaga without a doubt.
Gaga = technique/performance. Madonna = emotions/love. Both are great but different.
Exactly!! Emotions trump technique any day!!
LADY GAGA
No contest....GaGa hands down!! Her rendition is beautifully fluid & graceful.
Lady Gaga of course! :)
LADYYY GAGA ITS BESTTTTT
Gaga wins.
REBEL HEART TOUR ...THE BEST ....MADONNAAAA💓😍👑👑👑👑👑👑👑👑
La verdad, Madonna tiene el don de transmitir sentimientos a travez de su música y gaga tiene muy buena voz también, ambas diferentes
Gaga just Gaga 💙
Gaga! ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
Both performances are just great in a different way!... Madonna does it more acoustic, with a very similar arrangement to the original sung by Edith Piaf and with an excellent french accent. Lady Gaga does it in that very lovely jazzy style that she's been showing us she handle so well, maybe not with such a perfect french accent (Not bad at all anyway) but with a very strong voice and high singing skills!!!... So there's no need to fight for none of them!... Btw, I love them both for different reasons and they both are wonderful, talented and clever artists!
Agree.
Madonna has such a sweet and smooth voice, like candy and chocolate, and it just makes me melt! God I love her voice
Gaga puts more emotion into it. Madonna just sat there.
because it was literally the second to last song from the Rebel Heart Tour
alexe. Gaga’s last song of her born this way ball tour was scheiße and when she sung scheiße, she danced the whole way through the song
@@AlexeBriand2002 and also she performed Marry The Night as the ENCORE of the show during the tour, sometimes even acapella, and it was one of the most emotional moments of the show
@@mj4032 Gaga is half Madonna’s age. of course she can dance during the last song of her show. Madonna used to do that when she was younger.
@@gvrnmnthooker_6398 Marry The Night is not that good of a song
MADONNA❤
Madonna is a good pop star....Lady Gagas voice is versatile...
GaGa 🙌
gaga
Lady GAGA sings beautifully in French !
Queen Gaga of course, keep trying Oldonna.
+Andrew Hossam queen? haha Lol
QUEEN? HAHAHA
where is your "Queen" nowdays
Im a big fan of lady gaga but please stop to insult madonna again and again , if you don't like her its okay , but you don't need to insult her , it's not the message that gaga give to her fans , and you really don't represent the community of the little monster by saying that ..
Madonna might be old ish but she is still much better than Leidi Kakka ( it means Lady shit in finnish)
both are fantastic, but Gaga have more "passione"
They both did a good job but I like Madonna's better. It sounds more romantic and simple.
You might like madonna but this one is for GAGA
Christian C.H I LOVE BOTH THEM
Christian C.H And yeah Gaga wins
Gaga is better, not Madoldna
Gaga
HOWEVER, CAN WE STOP HATING ON MADONNA? PLEASE
I prefer Madonna's version, because it's so cute and tender ❤️
Gaga gets me more emotional
wow Gaga tiene la mejor voz que he escuchado en esta década. Lo siento, mejor que MADONNA si
The one and only - Lady Gaga
both version are sweet but madonna touch me more as this song is not a music hall song
Check out the rendition Gaga did after her concert in Denmark if you want a "intimate concert" feel to it.
Madonna sing it like a kids, is terrible....GAGA.
Gaga's version may be vocally superior, but it's lacking the seduction and feeling in Madonna's. I enjoyed The Queen's rendition far more.
I liked Madonna’s version, it was very soft and sweet. But there’s no doubt who is vocally superior here come on.
Gaga Eveeeeer
Gaga is the best.
+LuciaJazmin Mohammad SHE TAKES ALL FROM MADONNA, PLEEEAAASSSSSEEEEEEE REMEMBER
I’m sorry I’m prob gonna get hate I love both but Madonna’s version just touched my soul she’s such and emotive singer she might not be able to hit the notes of Gaga but it’s like she tells a story when she sings and I love that she’s embracing her French side
Gaga is obviously the best ! Did you see the oscars 2016 and 2015 ? I don't think Madonna can't sing that !
Gaga's vocals are powerful.Only a few singers in our years can compare their voices with her's.And Madonna is not one of them
powerful but it's not pleasant like Whitney's or Mariah's or Celine's or Adele's or Jessie J's or Ariana's
Im a Little Monster but Madonna sing it better.
Madonna was good in her day but Gaga is SO much better!
Madonna is better at delivering emotion, Gaga has a better vocal technique
Madonna
gaga !!! epic , so perfect!
Can we stop comparing they're both marvellous versions whether they are simply being born this way or expressing themselves
gaga has better vocal
but madonna has better performance
Cheeky Ifa exactly !
Gaga 💕
both versions are really good in their own right. Maddona's softer version is actually closer to the original Edith Piaff's interpretation as her voice was unique but not so powerful. On the other hand Gaga has a powerful very resonant voice and I love a powerful song. I love her Jayne Mansfield look as well. They're both talented singers
Well Ofc Queen Gaga
Madonna is the best!
Em técnicas Vocais Gaga leva a melhor!
Gaga is Better!
no son el mismo tipo de voces no hay punto de comparación cada quien en sus versiones es grandiosa ya que cada quien pone su esencia madonna con una versión Dulce y relajada logra controlar todo un concierto, y gaga con ese vozarrón que se carga es asombrosa,
por que discutir de quien es mejor? es arte solo disfrutemos de estas grandes interpretes y canta autoras. ❤living for music
❤living for love
I'm a Little Monster and I prefer Gaga's version, but Madonna was good too. They sang 2 different version of the song, but they both sang the song well
BOTH