I think this video is 'way better' than the 'original', just because it includes the crowd factor in it -their moves, their voices, their ENERGY -which after so many times of listening to it, this is what makes it still a great piece! I know my legs tremble every time i see it. thanks
With Roger posing like a Gerald Scarfe character, the superb graphics, the music, the moment, the crowd... make this one of Rock's great moments. Sit back and crank the volume. Tinitus here I come.
Blew my head off...epic..Got goosebumps when Roger breaks the wall... The video proves the point that there has never been a band better than floyd at giving live performances.... Stoned just by music....
I admit I was there that night (I actually was). I'd been driving for about 5 hours to get there, had a massive migraine, looked down and saw at the edge of the upper ring, about 40 people were down there pointing at the stage, why? Gilmour's Black Strat was sitting next to Roger's bass for the sound check. I went to a security guard to get a paracetamol and went for a walk with him to the first aid room, "Dude, is Gilmour actually playing tonight?" "Um...um....yes actually.". I cried, it was, nuts. I got back and uploaded my video at about 4AM before EMI took it down. No one realised as of that time WTF had happened. Shame Gilmour sung one of the verses twice, though I wouldn't be surprised he was trying to make sure Rog wouldn't be able to use it. I was in shock for about 2 days. True story. 😄
Che dire?semplicemente unici.favolosi eterni .le note della vostra musica si inalza nel cielo viaggiando nell'immensità dell'universo.w i Pink Floyd tutta la vita.Dainese Aldo.
@Petar1987Grobar I couldn't agree more it was absolutely breathtaking i stood there with my mouth dropped onto the floor just thinking i cant believe DAVE GILMOUR is here!!!!
This is my favourite o all the videos out there of this amazing performance - well done for really capturing that incredible feeling of "being there"!. This has really got me hyped for seeing the show on the 17th
Gracias Pink Floyd por ser mí vida, por enseñarme todo lo que nadie más pudo enseñarme sobre la música y la lírica de la misma, los amo para siempre ☮️♥️🙏
@therealsaintseiya Ive got another video of this song taken from the same angle going up on youtube now which zooms in more on Roger Waters and Dave Gilmour during his EPIC solos
@PFforever1 he made a mistake. at the end of the second verse. he left out " i turned to look but it was gone i cant not put my finger on it now, the child is grown the dream is gone.. pull up a lyric sheet and follow along. you see the change.
I don't think id like to see them live, i love there music so much id want it to sound exactly like the albums. And yea he changed the words round, or stuffed it up, at the solo was no where near as earth shattering, there were no people spontaneously combustion or no exploding heads like i would have thought
@RyanWehr Yes, it's a pitty, he fucked up the lyrics. And both solos were subpar, compared to what he usually does. I like to believe that it happened because he too was feeling in awe, just as the audience. He is cold, but that ambience impresses any guy.
@RyanWehr they slightly altered the lyrics for this show you can tell that from the fact the backing singers are singing the same words as david gilmour but i dont understand why are being so persistant in trying to fault one of the greatest songs i have ever seen live
still the song i want played at my grave,old school junkie i be,anti social,and proud,i want nothing to do with this new world order,its all soft as shit
Has anyone noticed Girmour singing the wrong verse? i was so excited that Gilmour finally showed up. then i noticed while he's singing the second verse something was wrong, and noticed that he made a mistake and repeated the first verse during the second verse. instead of saying "when i was a child i caught a fleeting glimpse he says when i was a child i had a fever.
JACKPOT!
Those guys must have felt like they won the lottery, when David Gilmour appeared.
We can only wish now…
anyone else get serious fucking goosebumps when Dave starts singing?
Incredible, mind blowing stuff
Goosebumps and some tears, actually
goosebumps is minor compared to what i felt
not just goosebumps literally crying wish i was there .
Every time i watch this, i cry.
I think this video is 'way better' than the 'original', just because it includes the crowd factor in it -their moves, their voices, their ENERGY -which after so many times of listening to it, this is what makes it still a great piece!
I know my legs tremble every time i see it.
thanks
With Roger posing like a Gerald Scarfe character, the superb graphics, the music, the moment, the crowd... make this one of Rock's great moments. Sit back and crank the volume. Tinitus here I come.
Blew my head off...epic..Got goosebumps when Roger breaks the wall...
The video proves the point that there has never been a band better than floyd at giving live performances....
Stoned just by music....
I think youtube is only counting how many times ive watched this video
10 years on... Holy hell man what a moment
I love the faces Dave pulls when he solos. I have been wanting to see pink floyd my entire life and I have now missed both chances to ever do so :(
I admit I was there that night (I actually was). I'd been driving for about 5 hours to get there, had a massive migraine, looked down and saw at the edge of the upper ring, about 40 people were down there pointing at the stage, why? Gilmour's Black Strat was sitting next to Roger's bass for the sound check. I went to a security guard to get a paracetamol and went for a walk with him to the first aid room, "Dude, is Gilmour actually playing tonight?" "Um...um....yes actually.". I cried, it was, nuts. I got back and uploaded my video at about 4AM before EMI took it down. No one realised as of that time WTF had happened. Shame Gilmour sung one of the verses twice, though I wouldn't be surprised he was trying to make sure Rog wouldn't be able to use it. I was in shock for about 2 days. True story. 😄
Fantastic. Had the privilege of being there - great video, thanks for posting.
Oh man, why I'm crying?...
PD. Epic moment on the music history.
I missed maybe a last chance to be on concert of Pink Floyd ! I cried when I've watched this ! Pink Floyd in heart !
I don't know what it is, but these guys together create magic, or you can call it magical music. Pink Floyd forever!
my goosebumps have goosebumps
I'm going to Manchester next Saturday and David won't be there but that will not dampen the feeling. Can't wait
Today he's playing here in Athens Greece and he's recording the show for a bluray disc !!! Hope David Gilmour is also being here...
AMAZING!! Oh how I wish these guys would get back together and record some new material.
Che dire?semplicemente unici.favolosi eterni .le note della vostra musica si inalza nel cielo viaggiando nell'immensità dell'universo.w i Pink Floyd tutta la vita.Dainese Aldo.
It doesn't get any better on this planet. I hate to say it will probably never happen again, but I still pray for another tour!!!
Gilmour and Waters playing together....as it should be.
Everytime I watch this concert I fuckin cry
God bless you for posting this video. Greetings and respect from Serbia.
saw in Dublin and simply EPIC ! Just the best show ever..........cheers for posting, you captured it fantastically :)
hope to see this show in Argentina
The most amazing video I had seen . I'm shaking . THANK YOU SO MUCH
.This is what Music is all about.....Wow the goose bumps & chills .......so awesome .......FINALLY thats all that needs to be said.......
this makes my whole 2011 year good!!!! what a great great GREAT performance
Hope David will come to Düsseldorf.
Excellent, wish I had been there. Thanks for posting.
@Petar1987Grobar I couldn't agree more it was absolutely breathtaking i stood there with my mouth dropped onto the floor just thinking i cant believe DAVE GILMOUR is here!!!!
Millones los llevamos en nuestros corazones, han endulzado nuestra vida con esos sonidos tan bellos, únicos. La música los parió. Son inmortales ❤️
Gracias por tanta alegria!!!
This is amazing! I will never forget...
i have GOOSEBUMPS!!!
Amazing.... ΦΑΝΤΑΣΤΙΚΟΊ ΚΡΊΜΑ ΠΟΥ ΔΕΝ ΈΚΑΝΕ ΤΗΝ ΕΜΦΆΝΙΣΗ ΤΟΥ ΣΤΗΝ ΑΘΗΝΆ Ο Gilmour
This is my favourite o all the videos out there of this amazing performance - well done for really capturing that incredible feeling of "being there"!. This has really got me hyped for seeing the show on the 17th
Imagine how many grown men were crying in that room.
AWESOME.
This is insane!!! I love these guys!!!
Ahh, awesome performance! The wall breaking into that insane view must have been some speechless stuff!
Simplemente excelente!!!! Emocionante.
What a great surprise to see them together again!
Siete la storia della musica
GRACIAS AMIGOS POR SUBIR ESTE VIDEO IMPRESIONANTE.
SALUDOS DESDE UCACHA EN ARGENTINA
Amazing !
GRANDIOSO!!!!!
holy shit thanks for posting this, you shot from a great angle!
wooooowwww.........
Awesome,,,,,,,, nothing else to say except awesome.
Dave IS playing the guitar !!!
Gracias Pink Floyd por ser mí vida, por enseñarme todo lo que nadie más pudo enseñarme sobre la música y la lírica de la misma, los amo para siempre ☮️♥️🙏
amazing!!!!! roger and david!!!!
I noticed Roger had 2 guys covering David at a different show! They were very good but there's only one Gilmore....
Great stuff.
Son mis idolos, por favor no se mueran nunca!
David Gilmour the greatest human in England!
EPIC
@theconcertking69
=S that's like being on both sides of the force ....
@therealsaintseiya Ive got another video of this song taken from the same angle going up on youtube now which zooms in more on Roger Waters and Dave Gilmour during his EPIC solos
This seriously brings a tear to my eye!!! I love these fucking guys!!!
The reconciliation should be last forever 😢
@nuamadresa a panasonic lumix tz10 if you want more details about settings and things inbox me and i'll be happy to help you with anything
Well look at that, David stole the show...
I've always thought that as well that he could of been on the drums
They finally gave him a railing
@ThePulsePF those are my videos i took when i saw My Chemical Romance in America
@marquinez Don't we all?
It does sound like Nick's simple drumming, but how do you know for sure? Did he ever appear during the show?
@PFforever1 he made a mistake. at the end of the second verse. he left out " i turned to look but it was gone i cant not put my finger on it now, the child is grown the dream is gone.. pull up a lyric sheet and follow along. you see the change.
I don't think id like to see them live, i love there music so much id want it to sound exactly like the albums.
And yea he changed the words round, or stuffed it up, at the solo was no where near as earth shattering, there were no people spontaneously combustion or no exploding heads like i would have thought
@RyanWehr Yes, it's a pitty, he fucked up the lyrics. And both solos were subpar, compared to what he usually does. I like to believe that it happened because he too was feeling in awe, just as the audience. He is cold, but that ambience impresses any guy.
@RyanWehr they slightly altered the lyrics for this show you can tell that from the fact the backing singers are singing the same words as david gilmour but i dont understand why are being so persistant in trying to fault one of the greatest songs i have ever seen live
maybe the back up singers heard the mess up and adjusted??
The first vid on youtube without dislikes ? :D
Just the synthesis of what has always been the big true about the Floyd:
Gilmour above of Waters
2:28 ;o happends to best ;o
there used to be cigarette lighters lit during those kinds of songs....now its cell phones...:S:S:S
Dudes! And when the server will burn down finally and the Internet will die-that we shall do and where we shall share IT...?
Ja pierdziu, jaram się! :D
still the song i want played at my grave,old school junkie i be,anti social,and proud,i want nothing to do with this new world order,its all soft as shit
Why are there My Chemical Romance on the related videos?
Has anyone noticed Girmour singing the wrong verse? i was so excited that Gilmour finally showed up. then i noticed while he's singing the second verse something was wrong, and noticed that he made a mistake and repeated the first verse during the second verse. instead of saying "when i was a child i caught a fleeting glimpse he says when i was a child i had a fever.
DIOS EXISTE!!! God exists!
Dudes! And when the server will burn down finally and the Internet will die-that we shall do and where we shall share IT...
Simplemente excelente!!!! Emocionante.
What a great surprise to see them together again!
Awesome,,,,,,,, nothing else to say except awesome.