Stage Presence coach reacts to Pink Floyd "Comfortably Numb"
Вставка
- Опубліковано 10 січ 2023
- Author of Singer's Guide To Stage Presence
----------------------------------------------------------------------
My Patreon:
patreon.com/TheConfidentSinger
---------------------------------------------------------------------
Get my book here:
amzn.to/32ZmU4X
---------------------------------------------------------------------
Instagram - @Janet Tabaka
/ tabakajanet
----------------------------------------------------------------------
TikTok
www.tiktok.com/@janettabaka?l...
As David Gilmor's wife said about him, David struggles to express himself emotionally with words, but stick a guitar in his hands and he makes you feel everything.
tchaikovsky, beethoven, mozart & rossini etc, would have been in awe of pink floyd if they had seen pink them perform this brilliant piece of work!!!
Indeed, David is very eloquent with a guitar. I'm sure many generations in the future, they will still listen to their beautiful music.
Poly Samson has a very good way with words. And a keen eye of a true artist as well.
Her photos of Sir David and the band are so clean and telling!
@@mixmashandtinker3266 pink floyd is often heard being played in heaven!!!
Greatest of all time
FYI... David's solo on this song is widely recognized as the greatest guitar solo of all time. I've had the honor of seeing this song played live 4 times dating back to 1981. The first time I saw PF live was in 1975, at nite, outdoors, in a stadium with 80,000 people in quadrophonic sound. I am 67 years old now and I remember that nite as a 17 year old kid feeling that my life had just changed.
If you felt like your life changed, then it did. Happy for you. Those moments are precious
@@larrysims7235 Indeed they are precious Larry. Very nice comment.
my first concert at the age of 11..... will never forget that night. My all time favourite band, a life changer! So so sorry that we will never experience PF again.
@@patrickmckay6621I was at this gig
The only guitar solo that comes close to this is from Steven Wilson's song Drive Home. It is played by Guthrie Govan, a master guitarist.
Two things
1) I still get goosebumps listening to that solo and I've heard it hundreds of times.
2) Thank you _very_ much for not interrupting the song like many other reaction video people do to discuss things. Interrupting that solo is a crime before man and God. :D
Fax
100%--Nobody should stop and talk about Floyd and It's a crime while in his Solos that some people pause it...If I could get to them thru the screen, I would.
I have played with tons of musicians. I have been to literally hundreds and hundreds of concerts since the early 70s and David Gilmour is the only guitarist that made me shed a tear and he's done it every time I have seen him live. HIs hands are connected to his heart and soul and they all speak together fluently. He is the lesson that you don't have to play a thousand notes a second to be good. You have to make every note count for something.
B.B. King once said that, sometimes it's in the space between the notes.... If you can crack that.. I think you've got it. Blessings.
Totalmente de acuerdo amigo ♥️
@@elquepasadeti Gracias amigo. Pruebe Gary Moore, Habitaciones vacías.. Vive en Montreaux.
I cried during both solos. I've not seen this performance before, but seen others and loved the solos...but not wept. I dunno what it was this time...😂😊
Right on Brother!!!
Greatest solo of all time. Yes, the guitar is singing. Even if your brain can't understand the words...you heart understands every bit of it. A masterwork.
Agreed… Master Piece!
Makes me allways cry. Thank you for this Materpiece David ❤
I usually don't think much of all the extra 'junk' Pink and many big bands have going on during the music, but this song this solo this performance this setting fit so well with the lights and effects, I wish I was there!
Perfectly said! Gilmour will always be my 1 pick for best guitarist. His playing is so emotional.
I don’t think there will ever be a better way of putting that!
In my opinion, this is the greatest guitar solo in history. There may be others that are more technical, that play more notes, that may be more technically perfect, but this one just.......hits. It hits something primal inside of me. The last minute or two is almost transcendental. I don't know why, and I don't know how, I have no background in music, and have no musical ability whatsoever, but I love music and it is a huge part of my life. I have never heard another piece of music that can touch some part of me in this way. David Gilmour created art here.
Nicely put, John. I'm like you in the no musical ability but love music place. I've listened to this songs in various versions hundreds of times over the last 44 years, and it has never failed to move me. Prior to "Numb" I never knew a guitar solo could bring tears.
It's too bad Gilmour has reached an age where we can't expect much more new music from him, but, thankfully, he and fellow Floyders created such a large catalog we'll never run out of things to re-listen to and learn from. And, despite his lesser likeability quotient, I'm also very grateful to Roger Waters for his inspiration and contributions -- without both David and Roger, PF would never have achieved what they did.
I do have a background in music and I can assure you I feel exactly the same way you do. At the end of the day music is about emotion. And Pink Floyd have always had an amazing ability to draw that emotion from the listener.
He Stretches those strings like no other guitarist I have ever seen. He doesn't need fast fingers to hit deep in my soul.
Pink Floyd is a unique combination of epic, sentiment and emotion. Pink Floyd enters you and frees this bird that was not meant for captivity. A music that, if you let it, will take you on a journey that has no end indefinitely and will bring you to a place where you will find yourself again.
AMEN !!! Cannot be matched! Felt this way when I first heard it back in 79......When I seen pink floyd in 88 and heard it live I WAS BLOWN AWAY!
I'll be 64 in May, and my wife and I have been married for 42 years. We have seen Pink Floyd three times. We have seen EVERY major rock group, and NO ONE comes close to the pure, raw emotion that Pink Floyd does. And I must say, you have had the BEST reaction of any of the other reactors I have seen. Your emotions are pure, and that is refreshing in this day and age.
I first saw them in 1972. I hope you and your lady keep on rocking for many years to come.
I would have to agree. Saw them indoors in 1987 and outdoors in '88 on the backend of that same tour. Living in the SF Bay Area, I have been to a lot of concerts in my day, including Bob Marley at the Kaiser Theater in Oakland. Pink Floyd was without question the best group I've ever seen perform live.
Know what would make the guitar solos better? Yeah, I don't either. Every note, every hold, every release, every bend, every hammer on, every pull-off was placed perfectly. It's such an amazing work. How many guitar solos can bring tears to your eyes?
When I was younger I appreciated the music, but as time passed I really come to appreciate it more bc with the trash and now AI crap and autotune you won't get this kind of music again. The solo goes through you, gets the heart going, adrenaline rushing. The best ever done
Only one that comes close is Mark Knopfler....
@@JM_daDoc Knopfler is another prime example, yes. Very valid. Still...so very few. Sad in a way, but at least we have these few examples to point to. Would be far sadder had we none.
@@KozmikZootz Knopfler and Gilmour stand out for me also. Plus Ry Cooder. I know what I'd be taking to that desert island!
Gilmore understands the power of timing and allowing a note to decay, to fade, to be that perfect moment. He is not the fastest on the strings, he doesn't power cord. He is just brilliant and lets the guitar shine to be the mirror on his soul and inner being.
It's basically the greatest and most spectacular musical moment in music history. Nothing will ever beat how good this live version is. Nothing
It’s true man. It’s true.
1+1=2.
So easy it is
God bless you,guys
Od bless you, David Gilmour.
Music has still a lot of work to do to become Pink Floyd
I love this song, this is my favourite rock song , and I respect your opinion, but are you sure you do not want to hear some of the great music out there that might make you feel as great.
@Pablo Kaufer Vinent if something does beat this song then I will be a blessed man and will be amazed. Bring it on I say
David Gilmour is one of the greatest, most emotive guitarists in all of popular/rock music. His playing isn't overly technical, but his solos on so many songs carry you away to places nobody else can. So glad you got to experience this one.
Levels Of A Guitar Player
1 BEGINNER
2 ADVANCED
3 PROFESSIONAL
4 EXPERT
5 LEGEND
6 GOD OF THE GUITAR
7 DAVID GILMOUR 🎸
(SHINE ON💎)
🎼☮️👊
David Gilmore... A poet who just happens to have a six-string.
@@shotgun4348 Absolutely my good brother bless you ...
(SHINE ON 💎)
🎼☮️👊🤝
@@peterchios9637 Bless you, too, brother.
i have heard it said that David Gilmor puts more feeling in the spaces between the notes than most guitar player's fit into three notes
Real musicians no auto tune
Just pure talent
This song now makes me cry, cause it took a whole new meaning since I turned 50. On my 50th birthday, I went to see him in Toronto. When he sang " the child has grown, the dream is gone", it just hit me like a 2 x 4 on the head..
me too, I do think people should experience it alone with the eyes closed no other input as we have been lucky to experience originally
I was at Pink Floyd on my 20th birthday - Frankfurt 26.01.1977 !
Yep, just like the lyrics in "Time" from Dark Side of the Moon: "...shorter of breath, and one day closer to death."
It just hits you in the feels.
After having cancer and all the treatments and being drugged out of my mind, this song hits me differently at my age. I mean right in the soul.
how about " I was just a boy then , now I'm only a man " from The Final Cut
Probably the best guitar solo ever... I'm a Floydian since 50 years.. and still get goosebumps..
"How is less more? Makes no sense. More is more."
-Yngwie
@@picklesmcmillan217 .. If you wrote less, it is more for us..😁
@@picklesmcmillan217 Yngwie J Malmsteen. Awesome guitarist who couldn't write a song if his life depended on it!
@@picklesmcmillan217 the ability to play licks and cram a ridiculous amount of notes into a second of time doesn't make it better, unless you are Stevie Ray Vaughan. The thing that Malmsteen and and Vai don't get is that music isn't a race. Go look up my countryman, Tommy Emmanuel, and find a guitarist who can do both, and you'll find Jerry Douglas on your travels. Maybe you'll hate the music, but you'll see some serious craftsmen at work.
Probably? Name a better one. :)
It doesn't matter how many times I hear this song. I get Goosebumps constantly..
Same here
Same here!
Me too. I also got something in my eye...
Yup.
Don't wear make-up girls when you're listening to this.
To use your own words... "This solo alone.... it's telling a story". Exactly!! One of the most iconic solo's ever.
For me it wasn't how he got the whole audience to stand up and cheer, it was that the entire time, right up until the end he had them all mesmerized. No cheering, no waving, no cameras, they were all entranced in the music. Gilmor can make you feel every note.
Thank God this show was performed well before smartphones existed. It would be such a shame & a tragedy if everyone who was lucky enough to be there for that moment was obsessively trying to capture the magic & staring at their screens instead of simply being fully present in the moment and in total awe of what they were witnessing & feeling inside. One of the top greatest performances of all time
I was there and you are 100% correct. I was totally mesmerised from start to finish, just blown away and lost in an experience that I doubt will ever be equalled in my lifetime.
Like I have said my entire lifecre PF they do not create a concert they ceeate an environment
Remember when people enjoyed music without having to film it needing a music video?
I do.
Kids under 20 have no clue. If you don't film it, "it didn't happen", so they look at their screen rather than enjoying the music like they should.
@@benjaminz2523 Why thank a fantasy figure for something that human's had not done yet?
That's weird.
I’m old. So old it sucks. BUT, David Gilmore, Rick Wright, Nick Mason AND Roger waters have given me 50 Years of wet eyed, heart wrenching, beautiful music and I’ll never be able to adequately express my lifelong thanks. I LOVE YOU GUYS.
I'm old too, and different parts of my body hurts. But I belong to the generation growing up with this music, and I don't want to change that.
I feel the same way brother, so glad I was alive to witness it and see them in concert a few times
I'm pissed off at old people ! ...I'm old now too, and those old SOB's before me didn't give me a head's up on everything crapping out as I got in my 60's. Now in my mid-60's, I gotta chase 70-80 year old's on the golf course and they won't tell me anything now either. We're doomed ! But I'm still comfortably numb.
I was blessed to be there in the audience! No other concert comes close... it was truely a spiritual experience 🙏
Blessed indeed!
I was Blessed to grow up near the Spectrum in Philly during the 70's and witnessed many a great show. Anyone who has experienced any of Floyd's shows knows there aren't words. I saw this tour at Mile High in Denver. Blessed is an understatement. Speechless for daze..
You lucky bastard!...
i was there too, 28. Oktober 1994 and 29. Oktober 1994
May 1993 - simply incredible
I’m in my sixties now and I still fight to hold back the tears every time I hear that final solo. A masterpiece that’ll never be bettered.
Agreed!!
Absolutely. It’s like listening to ‘Nessum Dorma’
I have been listening to Pink Floyd all my life and they are the only band that can make me travel emotionally to another level. I am 70 yrs old now and everytime I hear them again I feel like I did when I first heard them. Every morning I would listen to Comfortably Numb my whole day just lightened up, it was just like the sun had just come up and David solo at the end just lifted my spirits and filled me with a zest for life.
His solo at the end of Poles Apart is pretty sweet, too.
I really love this song and I'm thankful that as Mr. Gilmour aged, he still sounded GREAT singing his parts of this song. Live 8 blew me away. I had tears in my eyes.
I'm the same age,so I know where your at and I agree with you 100% pink floyd where on another level every member of the band where masters at they're craft,,perfect...😮😮...
This version, every day when I come home from work.
Loud and proud.
I'm 36 but I will keep it going until I am 156.
What you said about David’s guitar singing is what makes him the greatest guitarist of all time in my opinion. You can hear the depths of his soul when he plays. Also, what is so great about Pink Floyd songs in general is how they give it time to germinate, the slow buildup, giving it time, nobody ever has done it quite like them. Seeing this performed live a couple of times, best experience of my life. I guess apart from my wedding and the birth of my kids, but honestly they’re all in the same conversation.
With all due respect,but seems to me that every long time Floyd admirer(I included, of course)wanna delete Roger Waters due to his tyrant behavior before The Wall!Or for sure,many people dislike his present ideology (me excluded)! But I say,if Lennon needed McCartney & vice versa,Roger needed Dave(& late Rick🙌🙏) ten times more & vice versa! I've always preferred Dave's esthetics & Roger's thought process! That combination made Pink Floyd greatest band ever(in my humble opinion).But those two have been in beef since late 70's & now they are even more distanced cause of war in Ukraine! I'm afraid that they'll pass without burring the hatchet! Sorry if I bored you, but that could possibly be real life Eclipse (btw,best tune that Roger was ever singing/Braindamadge🌚🙌🙏
@@josiplilic3384 At his core, Roger is a tortured poet. Great lyricist but an ass of a man. It takes nothing away from his lyrical genius but I am glad he's not in the band anymore . What he did to Richard Wright is unforgivable IMHO.
@@coolcat8b agree 💯 about Rick!!! Although I'm leaning left & agnostic,I have philosophy that everyone aside murderers,rapists, pedophiles & their protectors does deserve forgivnes if one showed remorse for the "past sins"(using quotation marks, cause I sound like a priest🙄😯😝🤣). Idk..I was following Roger recently & although he was showing signs of ego trips from past,his ideology is close to mine & he's been friendly with my beloved & favorite living intelectual,dr Cornel West! So at least, he's a half decent ass(in my book)! I just can't stand him singing Wish You Were Here 🤣 🤣🤣
@@coolcat8b one more quick point, you can't deduce Roger just to writing lyrics! He was least talented musician of them all,but he had gift of conceptualing,DSOTM for example,to perfection! Why do I feel like his lawyer now?
@@josiplilic3384 I did not see that coming : Scott Ritter talks about Roger Waters' music and war [ ua-cam.com/video/8GaAr9QURLg/v-deo.html ]
David Gilmour isn’t just a lead guitarist, he’s truly the master of his craft. I don’t think any guitarist on earth plays with such emotion and feeling as he does.
"if you can get audience to stand like that, you have good stage presence."
Thanks for validating what is regardless considered #1 live concert climax in rock history.
This is not music. It is the music, an absolute masterpiece.
My absolute favorite Pink Floyd song. As someone with neuro-muscular chronic pain, the lyrics of Roger Waters and the guitar of David Gilmore is a form of pain relief all their own. I've always said you don't just listen to PF, but you experience it.
My brother-in-law passed away a number of years ago, and they played this song at his funeral. He was a very avid Pink Floyd fan. He even has "Comfortably Numb" on his tombstone. ...R.I.P. brother.
My sister passed away suddenly in January 2022, and Comfortably Numb was played at her funeral. Weirdly a few days earlier, when I was driving over to help with arranging things for her service, this track came on my cd player just as I was passing by her house!
I've always told my ppl, when i leave this place, i wanna go out with his song!
No theatrics. No running and jumping. No screaming. Just standing there and killing it!!!
This solo has to be one of the best I have ever seen. So much emotion and passion in his phrasing. I feel THIS is the best performance of this song. Just flawless from beginning to end, and by the end he literally has you in tears.
Your reaction, your face, Your joy were as good as this epic performance..
Gilmor’s outro solo literally tells the story of the song. That minor drop is when the “numb” hits, concluding with the literal sirens wailing with the protagonist spiraling into that “numb” abyss.
Such a masterpiece and work of art.
I was so incredibly fortunate to have been able to attend this concert. It will live with me forever.
"This solo is telling a story" Most truth on the internet.
If you don't have that reaction when you hear this song, you really need to question yourself, seriously, this to me is the greatest song ever put to paper and played out.... That second solo is just astounding, it brings a tear to my eye every time I listen to it.
Comfortably Numb is one of the most extraordinary pieces of music ever composed. I always felt that towards the end, it became the funeral march of a lost and tormented soul. All of the anguish and regret of something glimpsed and lost is distilled and channeled into one extended searing cry. This never gets old. Ever. It speaks to something that we all know and cannot be expressed in any other way. Music - real music is a language all its own. Extraordinary musicians like David Gilmour can communicate their inner experiences as few can today. Gilmour’s guitar appears to be connected directly to his soul. Some musicians can manage that for a few moments. For Gilmour, it’s his natural state of being. It is unmistakable and cannot be faked.
Wonderfully explained.
автор музыки и стихов Роджер Уотерс! Гилмор только соло на гитаре.
да великолепное соло.
НО! Почему ни слова о Роддере?
This performance never fails to give me goosebumps and tears of joy. Nothing else comes even close to the emotion David Gilmour is able to express through his guitar.
History will look back at this live performance as one of the greatest guitar solos ever. Kudos to the entire Pink Floyd band, flawless perfection.
The guitar solo in this has been voted by fellow musicians as the best of all time... I wouldn't disagree
Hard to argue, even if I prefer his work on Dogs the most.
So refreshing to see a much younger person like yourself really enjoying the music of my time growing up, and getting it, really getting it and getting into it. How can you not? Love your heart felt reaction.
Often a live performance does not capture the studio perfection. This is a magical exception
You are absolutely right. THAT is REAL music! I was a guitarist for 21 years and reactions like yours are worth more than money, imo. 🥰
been listening to Pink Floyd since 68 and it still bring tears to my eyes listening to them especially this song
It actually makes my eyes water and I get chills every time I listen to this particular video. It's just soul moving
you are not alone !!!
☝☝️thanks for watching
I've Prize for You 🎁🎉🎀
Note:Nicegram📥❤
Just when you think this couldn't possibly go next level ...
It goes next level.
I love watching her facial expressions; it's like she can't find the words but her smile and her eyes tell you how she feels.
Welcome to the world Pink Floyd....
Some of us have been here most of our lives.
It’s hard to react, and give pointers to things like stage presence with this band and this track. I think you nailed it Jan. Commitment (genius too) and it was really cool seeing you rock out. Awesome. Loved the reaction. I was there, and what people miss is that CN was in the encore, right at the end of the concert which included all of TDSOTM wish you were here etc. At that point I was hoarse, emotionally spent and then he did that. There is nothing, musically, I have experienced that has come close except maybe Beethoven’s 9th. This is nearly 30 years old. It won’t be surpassed…
Yeah, there were the trippy mini movies, the light effects, the crazy teacher, the crazier pigs, the airplane, the vapors floating around... it's a miracle there were no casualties (other than the bleachers falling at one show - if memory serves.)
I was there too - I took my son and the show was amazing, we didn't want it to end, but with an ending like that - it was truly a whole body experience. That track alone demonstrates the power of top-notch rock music and PF are the best at it. People will still be playing that track 100 years from now. I hope!
Actually, The Wall was released 43 years ago
I've listened to this track many times, but holy crap, seeing this again now with your live reaction made my eyes tear up! As you said, his guitar sings!
there will never be another group of musicians who blend so well and make you feel the music everytime i hear this song it takes me to a better time in my life
One of the greatest live performances in the history of music. @The Confident Singer: Welcome to the world of Pink Floyd and David Gilmour!
Greatest band of all time 50 years ahead of their time. Greatest guitarist ever! I grew up listening to pink floyd
☝☝☝️thanks for watching
I've Prize for You 🎁🎉🎀
Note:Nicegram📥❤🎊🎊
They where not ahead of time. They where the pinnacle.
Yep.
That's why they're so good and timeless...
Now or 50 years later, people will still listen to this group and admire ❤
I was at this absolutely amazing concert.
I have no words to express how good they are live.
Saw Division Bell in San Antonio. It was the most totally immersive experience of my life. I was in Heaven on Earth. A true religious experience. After the concert people were silently walking toward the exits trying to comprehend what they just witnessed . Thanks for the reaction. This song always brings tears to my eyes.
You don't just hear their music, you feel it in your gut and heart. Tears.
I’m really glad you liked this so much as a young woman. I have seen the song performed many times live. (I’m now 63). But emotions always get the better of me whenever I hear or see it again. It’s not just nostalgia. I feel kind of sad that we will never hear such musicianship again.
Indeed,it is quite bittersweet listening to that masterpiece. Between SRV and David...weve listened and been blessed to bear witness.
Transcending.... absolutley astonishing. No others like it... anywhere, ever. What has happened to music? Where are the greats today... the Pink Floyds, the David Bowies etc. Amazing.
I was privileged to see them perform four times between '87 and '94......epically flawless is about all I can say! And yes, still the intensity of the song and watching you get caught up in the sheer magnificence of the performance as well brought tears of joy and laughter. You should just go ahead and check out the full Pulse '94 show! Thanks and keep em coming!
Me too, my 4 times were 75, 77, 87 & 94, best shows of my life.
Hell yeah! Saw them twice, in NYC Long island, 1988 and then in NJ 1989, East Rotheford Complex when the "Momentary Lapse of reason" album came out then when the Delicate sound of Thunder came out, will never forget those concerts, nothing like it to this day.
@@marcoss6212 Yep, same here in Oakland, California. When I left, I was literally in a daze. Maslow, who created the concept of "peak experiences" ...this was definitely one of them.
I was in Earls Court in '94, totally amazing show, and still brings back the chills when I watch others see this for the first time.
Even after all these years David's guitar solo in this song still brings tears to my eyes. OMG just doesn't seem to cover it. Thank you David for such a wonderful gift.
Pink Floyd. Pure. Musical. Genius.
The audience never sat down during the entire Show 3 hours plus of mind blowing music and light show. Greatest Concert Ever
That solo will never be topped. Greatest solo ever. Period. Literally touches the soul.
I close my eyes, lay my head back and Pink Floyd takes me to a special place. No other band has ever done that to me, the guitar work is pure heart & soul.
I'm just very thankful that I'm just alive this century. I can say that he did this when I was alive later when I'm very old. All the people in the next centuries can listen to this but will never have the exactly same goosebumps I had when I was at this concert and many others. It was amazing, every song... and as a orgasm there was Comfortably Numb. Then to make your feeling more better as it was, they played Run Like Hell to make you more satisfied then you already wore. The audience went crazy...every time gain. Each concert. Thank you Pink Floyd, thank you David Gilmour, thank you so much for the music you bring to us!
Real music, real musicians. Just as you said. And as much as you enjoyed it here... imagine being in that audience, that night...
Amazing amount of emotion in his solos. Not just “shredding”. The way he uses feedback near the end of his solo is astonishing.
David knows when and how to NOT play a guitar. In other words, he has mastered the art of just letting a note sing, letting that pause between notes linger to make you anxious in that split second, yearning for the release of that next note that you know is coming. He can hit you with a flurry that just about knocks you out of your seat and then pull back on the reigns, leaving you stunned into awe. Truly a master of his instrument and I wish more guitarists would learn that you don't always have to be hitting the strings as fast as your fingers are capable. His finesse and feel for the instrument is breath taking. As I say, he is a master of knowing when and how to NOT play the guitar!
@@tattoodude8946 Agree. I grew up listening to Be Bop in the early 70’s. When the shredders came along in the eighties it was difficult for me to appreciate their playing as I didn’t hear great ideas, just fast playing.
One of the Best Song's ever, Best Guitar Solo's ever and Best Light Show's ever. Can't be beat.
Pink Floyd is the most beautifull magic in this world, the lyrics are Extra-terrestrials, they are Legend, i could live 1000 years and still listen to there music!!! Makes you think of the world, the universe, everything in a life !!!
Love your reaction! Gilmore is like a medium channeling emotions from the ether of a distant galaxy 💕
What I love too is this solo is longer and 1000x better than the recorded track. The solo on the track is really good but I only listen to this live version because of this solo. It’s so much longer, more emotional, and the artistry is god tier. One of my favorite solos of all time.
Mr Gilmour is a brilliant musician. i was lucky enough way back in '94 to see that show in Syracuse NY. Comfortably Numb, was the last encore tune. Definitely saved the best, of everything for last. If you left early you were a fool.
As a 50 year Pink Floyd fan, nothing makes me happier than to see reactions like this about this band that has always been so dear to me since my teen years in the 70’s.
Thank you!
You are adorable.
🤘
This is simply the best guitar solo ever, it was so great that even the phenomenal guitarist Sir Dave Gilmour could never play it as good as then! I was there at Earl's Court for what was a life-changing experience!
That guitar solo by David Gilmor, is considered one of the greatest off all time, played by a guitarist who's considered one off the greatest off all time.
I've been a big Pink Floyd fan since the 70's, and this solo still carries me away every time I hear it, whether it's live or from the album. Though live is another level again.
I still get goose bumps. How David hits those glass breaking notes is legendary. Love you guys ❤
I really like your reaction to this phenomenal song and performance. Think how I felt when seeing it live at Earls court in 1994. Was best day in my life.
Real Musicians = Yes 100%. That guitar solo at the end blows my mind every time I hear it. Like you said, that guitar sings so beautifully. I only wish I could've been there.
Pink Floyd is on another level. From the same Pulse Concert, check out SORROW and also RUN LIKE HELL.
One of These Days, hell, the entire PULSE concert is a masterpiece.
@@tracithomas6543 correct the whole concert is a masterpiece.
@@tracithomas6543 I agree 100% - EVERY song at the Pulse Concert is excellent!
I've had possibility to listen to David Gilmour on stage in Wroclaw, Poland and Comfortably Numb was the last piece at this concert. I can tell just one thing - although I'm quite big and old man i was almost driven to tears. This performance I'll never forget!
I always envy people who are only now experiencing Comfortably Numb. I'm 64 now , and ever since I saw The Wall at Earls Court in London in 81/82 that song has continued throughout my life to make me emotional every time I hear it. Thanks for the very honest and enjoyable reaction.
I couldn't agree more. It's always so satisfying to see a younger generation appreciate the talent of the past the way so. At the same time you can't be jealous of someone else hearing it for the first time. It's an experience we all wish we could have again.
I think it’s us that should be envious of you. You had the pleasure and the privilege to have grown up with some of the greatest bands to grace the Earth. I was born in the 90s, but I grew up with the Wall album because my dad owned the album.
There is no parallel to this solo, its breadth, depth and emotional impact in all of rock history.
The Best!!! Been watching Mr Gilmour for years a class act. And Janet you too are a class act!
Every single damn time I hear this solo I have goosebumps. EVERY. SINGLE. DAMN. TIME.
Never fails to bring tears to my eyes and a lump in my throat. I’m 75 years old. Thank you for the video
Been listening to and loving this song since 1979. It's still as mesmerising now as it was then. Timeless Floyd.
David was a master of two great instruments, voice and that spectacular guitar. This is the greatest stage performance I've ever witnessed.
Even now, at 74, still, the sound sends electric shivers up and down me backbone.
Hendrix version of, "All Along the Watchtower" still has that effect.
I was there at he best gig ever, can you imagine the whole audience stunned to silence and immobile till the last bars!
The atmosphere was magnetic and the entire hall was "Comftably Numb" incredible. Thank you for reminding me!
Hello Jannet, yes the spinning speaker does mean something. They are custom, higher powered versions of an old Leslie rotating speaker usually found in organs. They give this live performance that amazing swimming, chorus-like sound. By the way, I love your chirpy enthusiasm and appreciation for artistry.
I was just about to comment on the Leslie speaker before seeing your response. I would like to give kudos to Jannet for her curiosity about a revolving speaker, though. Other reactors have commented that it's just a spinning light, with one going as far to say that it must have been what they used "back in the old days" before strobe lights were invented -- but after laser beams and disco balls?!
@@islandseeker1260 . Hey thanks for the comment! I'm sure the special effects team were happy to utilise another lighting angle as a bonus though. Keep well and all the best.
☝☝☝️thanks for watching
I've Prize for You 🎁🎉🎀
Note:Nicegram📥❤🎊🎊
The “classic” Leslie speaker design features two drivers-a treble driver with horns (only one works; the other simply acts as a counter-weight) and a bass driver. The horns of the treble driver and the sound baffle of the bass driver are physically rotated by electric motors.
I was in the audience for this concert at Earls Court in London, my wife was supposed to go with me but she was heavily pregnant with son number 2, so I took a mate who had never been to a Floyd concert, he lasted one song then was a lifelong fan. It was amazing, now in my 60s it still moves me to see a reaction to this concert, thank you for sharing a lovely memory ❤
One of the greatest live performances ever given!!!
Your reaction is as beautiful as the performance! It shows that you feel it. :)
Greatest guitarist to have lived! He will take your musical soul, shake it around, cuddle it, make it cry, throw it on the floor and stamp on it, then put it gently back like it never left!
Agreed!
Imagine being such amazing artists and musicians, that the light show and all that isn't even really necessary, and just adds the icing on the cake? They don't need to worry about 'stage presence' per se, they already have such deep respect from everyone.
It’s magical to see someone who loves Pink Floyd as much as I do.
I need to say this to you. One of the best reactions ever. I saw this concert in 1994. I think the combination of the song's, the truly gifted musicians with the lights and video, floating pigs and crashing airplanes all contributes to their stage presence. My favorite part, is when the lights hit that giant disco ball because it reflected those light inside the entire stadium. Every soul in there was 'touched' by that. Made a part of the experience. Like you said, Real music! Thanks for sharing!
The solo is a perfect expression of the emotional roller coaster that is Pink- he uses the very lows to the soaring highs so effectively
The circulating speakers are called Leslie speakers, originally used with organs, but later used as an effect on many instruments, live and recorded. They give a tremelo effect. Appreciated your comments about real music and real musicians, it is a big deal and worth noting and praising as you did, especially is this modern age of lots of sterile music.
David plays with such passion and feeling like no other guitarist.
You have just witnessed one of, if not the best solo in music history. You felt it in your soul. Welcome to the club.
David Gilmore is such a brilliant guitarist's ,it's truly an awesome guitarists ,makes the hair stand on your back every time I hear his guitar
Greatest guitar solo ever! I wish I could give extra thumbs up to you for not interrupting it!
The best guitar solo ever.
I must cry every time I listen to this masterpiece.