Video of 'nurse' denouncing Hamas occupation of Al-Shifa hospital in Gaza is fake • FRANCE 24
Вставка
- Опубліковано 14 лис 2023
- A viral video shows a suspicious testimony of a so-called 'nurse' working at Gaza's Al-Shifa hospital. In the video, the nurse claims that Hamas is stealing all of the hospital's food, fuel and medicine. We explain why this video is staged in this edition of Truth or Fake.
#gaza #israel #hamas
Read more about this story in our article: f24.my/9w91.y
🔔 Subscribe to France 24 now: f24.my/YTen
🔴 LIVE - Watch FRANCE 24 English 24/7 here: f24.my/YTliveEN
🌍 Read the latest International News and Top Stories: www.france24.com/en/
Like us on Facebook: f24.my/FBen
Follow us on X (Twitter): f24.my/Xen
Browse the news in pictures on Instagram: f24.my/IGen
Discover our TikTok videos: f24.my/TKen
Get the latest top stories on Telegram: f24.my/TGen
Shameless. The world started to know their lies. So disgusting
Please don't be one sided. For example Who are they? In such desperate circumstances, in a war zone both sides use propaganda. The result fires up more and more hate. A solution has to be found. The hate, intolerance and violence that has been dividing people and leading to terrorism, murder and barbaric behaviour for decades can only stop if people stop hating. We are all of the same flesh and blood.
The IDF is becoming desperate... 😂
Yep. What else have they lied about I wonder ? 🤔
That's an Israeli woman, she can't even speak Arabic...
@@susanharrisdemorales3446 For 75 years living in a cage, if that happened to you, what would you do?
They have lied since the beginning of this massacre. Disgusting!
@@amrut13 no need 2 rupee IT cell
Who lies I don’t see IDF representing this nurse
Of course this was fake. The nurses in Al Shifa are deeply supportive of Hamas terrorists.
@@amrut13 and where is your own opinion?, or you just getting your knowledge about the world from breaking news?!!!
So oct 7 is lie? 🤣
The fact that they have to "investigate" something that is so obviously fake is astounding 😑😒
People now days aren't as smart. They blind follow everything they see
It is there way of publicising it, and a huge percentage of people don't make it til the end of the video so probably a big portion of the views will believe it since they only reveal it is fake at the end. Typical Propaganda outlet!
This is called proof, many people don’t get it or blindly fall for the fake.
Hhhh
@@Rheinlander1904-uc5od shes an actress in israel so its really fake,
As a nurse i found so weird she is using gloves.. holding her stethoscope in a weird way.. putting gloved hands on her face. We dont do that at all. Her behavior doesnt fit a real nurse at all. We would never make a video with gloves on and rubbing our stethoscope around. Gloves and medical equipment are considered critical equipment for contamination. We dont touch our phones with gloves.
Liars like to give too much information to make it believable
But it usually backfires
This lie was caught. Imagine how many more remain unexposed
@@ijs8548hahahahaha keep trying
@@AmeerulZ99 I'm not tough 🤔 I'm having fun actually
@@thomastemmerman7276 hamas hasn't had arms ???,,!!! lmfao
@@thomastemmerman7276 concrete proof and I'll believe you simple not just rumors
@@Heshem_Joel link
No one who speaks Arabic would listen to that and say it was powerful. We all laughed at it. The accent 😂 😂
ikr
u mean israeli accent
Without looking and trying to find at the comment to validate my opinion, I was certain she isn't Arab but the west would believe anything lol
😂😂😂
Even her hijab doesn’t resemble how Arab girls wear their hijab
This doctor can act well and Hollywood should give him an Oscar🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Lol she is alreadyan actor
She's clearly lying she certainly learned the Arabic language recently Because this is not the correct dialect She made more than one word wrong
It's a she, not he. Learn English.
Pallywood
Noh give her Bollywood Oscar
Thank you for the English translation. We need, so badly, much more of this type of journalism.
The actor spoke English.
I don't even speak Arabic and I can tell that is an Israeli accent.
Also its amazing that she managed to keep her clothes so crisp and clean after 30 days of siege and bombardment..
@imbackdoe7395 no i am arab she cant pronounce the ح or ع she is a liar
@@imbackdoe7395isr1eli spotted .
Literally my exact thoughts
@cynthiademario7331ummm what kind of a nurse living in an open air prison with limited or no access to water be able to have clean clothes??
@@cynthiademario7331beriyaa 😂😂😂
She must be the 'nurse' who placed all the weaponry behind the MRI.
😂😂
😂😂😂
Are you suggesting HAMAS doesn't use human Shields? Fool.
@@spiritualawakening2675
You need to see a psychologist
@@spiritualawakening2675 Where is the video show us....show proof and we will believe
As an Arab, I knew she is not Arab straight away when she said “itla-u” the letter T and the letter ein are not correctly pronounced 😂😂
.....thank u for standing for the truth like true journalists
As a journalist, I could already tell something was off when she didn't pan her camera to actually show all the items she claimed were missing. Because of course she knew that if she does a pan, it would be very easy to tell that she's not filming in Al-Shifa Hospital
as a journalist, do you find it odd there was no mention of who put out that video? how could we not ask that question while dealing with the validity of the video?
@@ObjectiveCritic exactly. It is crucial to have a named source for the video which isn't the case!
And the fact that Israelis were so swift to share this was also telling. Of course I believe that Palestinian supporters have probably doctored some things at some point but the point is that Israel wields more power and have a responsibility to protect civilians but they don't seem to care
@@ObjectiveCritic that's true, who put out the video in the first place?
@Future_proof203 Probably the Israeli govt, they fund other influencers to put out Israeli propaganda.
@@ObjectiveCriticthis nurse isn’t even Arabic. She speaks like how a Jewish person would speak. Just listen to how she pronounces words. Don’t believe this bs video
A deaf person could tell you that's not an Arabic accent.
😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂😂😂
Yeah, but Westerners are deaf when it comes to Arab accents. We do need native speakers to tell us. Back in the days before the Internet, this fake would have worked.
Factual
Surely you were not deaf too to hear the alive call the dead as "martyrs" and the press is Hamas agents filming the atrocities on 7th Oct are the ones filming the sufferings AFTER bombing their own hospital.
Well done. The real truth seekers in the mainstream media are a rare breed nowadays and deserve all the support and appreciation they can get. Bravo!👏
They didn't mention the important part which i don't expected them to tell in first place. This video was shared by israeli official twitter and later deleted after the whole world started mocking.
I couldn't believe this truth was broadcasted in French media...
Even CNN broadcasted this and they have arabic speaking journalists
Yeah it was amazing lol, not only just because it is French media, but the way they talked were really neutral, logical, and intelligent
@@fa5234CNN is very biased they literally used a clip of the Arabic calendar and said it was an Hamas shift change schedule
Don't fall for that, they want more views.
@@lil0296 or DW documentary, all are such baits lol
How gullible does a person have to be to think that's real!
So you think it's not real?
easy, just be American or Israeli
Yes. Some say she also found WMDs in Iraq 😅
@@chrisperez3614no it’s not that’s been debunked just look at the teeth, unless she’s had a new full set of teeth in a Couple days.
I agree it seems acted but I also know both sides are guilty of this ridiculous act like the Palestinian actor (also a poor actor) popping up all over the place. Not trying to say one side is worse than the other. Doing this on either side is ridiculous and damaging to the truth!
Give the "nurse" an Oscar.
She’s really bad at arabic btw
How can we confirm that she is a staff from that hospital?
Thank you for great journalism and standing for truth.
Thats what called hiding the truth 😂😂😂
I swear, as a French France24 english seems completly different from the French one
@@andyhoward940 i think they started reporting the truth because they knew the occupier/terrorists losing the narrative so they dont want to lose credibility. nobody believes them anymore. demonizing the oppressed is an old colonizer tactic
@@dhardhirdruha6916are you a hindu
What you're doing is called delusion. @@dhardhirdruha6916
She has not got a speck of dust on her... If people can't see the fakeness of the video, then they really are lost.
Very very clean for someone in a warzone!
She was dressed-to-the-nines in her outfit - way down to the stethoscope she waved around...
Also the lights are fully on. There's been no power for weeks and generators were out.
@@zaki17-And there would have been the sound of crying and screaming patients in the background, and absolute mayhem. There was none of that .
Are not nurses supposed to be clean?
@@mikeregan2135Have you NO idea what is going on in Gaza at the moment. ! It's an effing building site , everywhere. Watch some of the vids coming out. 😠😠
Respect this is true journalism
This is beyond disgusting.
Props to France 24 for pointing it out and for their unbiased approach to the issue.
Mainstream media is so bad nowadays that it's refreshing to see real journalists.
This is BS the video is real!!
@BobbyJardine-vs8yc
Yes, it's real but the woman is not a nurse in shifa hospital. Not a Palestinian and not an Arab.
This is trt broadcasting it
@@BobbyJardine-vs8yc yea its real like the list of the hamas terrorists name shown by idf on a calendar like capt monday colonel tuesday
The reporters themselves are controlling their laughter seeing her desperation and acting
Lol😂
Idk why, this video is one of the creepiest things I’ve ever seen.
I like how he made out the fact that it was moving stand out more than whether it was real or fake....
Thank you for exposing lies and telling the truth.
Sad but the world needs to know the truth
But now you know what crisis actors are, a term you never heard of. And now you are supposed to believe that Gaza use crisis actors. Western media is wicked.
I just don’t understand why the so-called nurse lied about this in these very difficult circumstances? We don’t need drama because we’re all experiencing a lot of depression and anxiety! Isn’t that enough?
The gentleman and the lady did their best to expose the fake nurse. Thanks a lot to both of you!
She lies ,she is not arabe
Even IF the video was a lie, what she’s saying is still true. Hamas does steal from the hospital and make no mistake the IDF soldiers are the only ones helping and trying to provide aid to the hospital. Still Hamas refuses to allow the desperately needed aid because they’re counting on the destruction of the hospital to gain international sympathy and support.
This is an example of excellent journalism. Breaking down everything in real time. Other news organizations should take note of how to do their jobs professionally.
break down what?!?!? it was obvious she is a fake from the beginning of the video with her israeli accent...no need for the backround noise confirmations!
This is TERRIBLE journalism because even though it is fake, they are treating it up until the big reveal as if it could be authentic. That's not how NEWS is supposed to work; like it's some kind of game show. You state on the offset, this video is a fake and here is why.
@@greenleaf8226u kids the point , without the some western journalist breaking things down , west would never believe it
Too bad they don't apply the same due diligence to the propaganda from Hamas media releases, which they take as gospel.
@@greenleaf8226are you a hamas?
I would appreciate if France 24 investigates tunnel under Al Shifa hospital and live broadcast without any cuts.
Thank you so much for being unbiased
Thank you for spreading the truth
Is far far far away from truth is lying
she could also be planted. it is obvious that doctors, staff and even UN members are aware that Hamas is just working w/n the hospital. she could be put up also to discredit Israel that all allegations about Hamas working just w/n the hospital is not true.
This is what called hiding the truth .
@@dhardhirdruha6916really????? Do you have any shame???
That's fake
Thank you for your effort to defend the truth.
It would be credible what she is acting unfortunately for her all the world know that Palestinians do not have electricity, nothing to eat, nothing to drink…no medicine, no electricity…there are trucks full with aid that is not permitted to enter to Palestina… you only are lossing your time…Our Creator has shown the suffering of Palestinians for 75 years…
IDF!
Acting 😂
an Israeli actress named Hannah abutbul
@@rnatour IDF!!
As soon as I saw the gloved hands, the gig was up!
Non medical people tend to assume we move around with gloves all the time, but on contrary, we wear gloves only when handling instruments, patients and drugs.
A nurse holding their phone with gloved hands is unheard of!
In medical school, I once opened a door with gloved hands and got a 10 minute scolding from the ward nurse in-charge!
If it turns out to be a real video you should be arrested.
Thank you. At least someone is showing truth.
They realised they’d make a big mistake if they keep on hiding the truth. The world is waking up
Of all the footages I've seen coming out of this hospital, the wall colour and door frames don't seem to match and her outfit seems brand new.
This video is a few weeks old. It was recognized as fake in Israel.
Room too bright, camera too close up and childish.
Everything is new and clean in this video. Even nurses clothes and makeup is new, in Palestine they don’t have new walls and equipment
And she speaks english trying to send message to people of gaza 😂😂 palestinian uses arabic with each other 😂😂 and she sounds like she has an accent too
es su "otro uniforme", una mentira mas de Israhell
also the clean gloves . when she said she treated boys who well most likely be bloody .
And yet still no one listens and the press are claiming its fake .
How fake can you get??? Gosh who you are fooling??
Have you seen Gaza videos over the years? Especially around 2008 and 2014? Same acting(over acting).
sadly a lot of dumb people
Fooling the Israelis
She is a Mexican zoinist acror hanah
an Israeli actress named Hannah abutbul
Should win the Oscars this woman. Then there was the CNN actress & there was Romanian journalist who was flat on the floor as if bombs were falling beside them then suddenly Israeli civilians passing by😅.
Nahhhhh, that crying thing is not an Oscar material...as said in the debunking video above, the Arabic accent that she was mimicking was bad, that means she is a very very rookie actress, maybe just a tiktok level grade actress, who needs more films to act in before she can become a well train propaganda tool.
truth is hard to digest... take your time or maybe it isn't hard, you just simply like to believe what you want
@@rananimeedits seriously?? Even after all the exposing you come up with this? Shame on you
No the oscar should go to rashida tlaib thats the truth
And everyone is acting like professional on psychology and masters of linguistics shut up
Disgusting.. why so much hypocrisy.. filled in her heart..
Quite incredable how these journalists are behaving .
Good work! The world needs more investigative reporters like you.
OK. Let suppose the video is fake. The question is: IS THE MEANING OF THINGS GIRL SAYING IN THE VIDEO FAKE?
@@stearin1978 Yes she is an actress
@@stearin1978 yes it is. Because if it was real, they wouldn’t need to act it out.
@@stearin1978suppose what?!
it is extremely obvious this video is fake
@@salihmohmmed9846What soup? I never talked about soup... (did you even read my question?)
Thank you for spreading the truth when the others are spreading their propaganda 👍
thing is the false video had 1 milion views, while the debunking one only some thousand views
That's an incredibly clean costume she's wearing.
Her clothes is too pristine for someone without food, water, supplies and surround by deaths for weeks
Well said, respekt!
As an arab i can identify that she is not arab because of the accent she mispronounced the letter ط 😂
there are many people who misprounce ..whatever.
I've seen many people in my country misprounouncing many many things.
it's common.
Just cus it fits your agenda, it doesn't mean that she is not arab.
She could be, even if she misprounounces a single letter...
@@akhsdenlew1861Even a kid can realise she is not Palestinian and especially not a Gazan!
شكلك غبي
@@akhsdenlew1861We know our language well
@@akhsdenlew1861 wow amazing u, a random youtube commenter, are smarter than analysts, the actual journalists! Also never mind the crisis actress got doxxed!!
Because you said so!! WOW!
@akhsdenlew1861 bro that letter itself is incredibly crucial in its pronunciation because any difference in its pronunciation can change the word completely. She made the mistake twice in a row as well lmao. No agenda being inserted here, just pure lies.
im so happy people start to wake up
now i dont feel like an alien
this really makes me happy, so so so happy that people now questioning what they are being fed the whole time
She has no shame omfg
Thumbs up for showing the lying truth
You mean the lies and acting
Israel= lies, lies,lies, endless
Hahaha acting
an Israeli actress named Hannah abutbul
it's not,,it's a Mexican woman, the Israel paied for her to act this video against Hamas,, search always behind your cheater chanels.
Why am I not surprised..thank you for exposing the truth 😔
same tbh. she pretty much was apart of making propaganda for the IDF to justify bombing a friggin hospital.
she didn't forget to show you the prop in her hand 🤣 just so you know she is an actual nurse lol
Al Jazeera never shows these News
If they go to these lenghts to stage this, wouldn't you question the "evidence" they say they found at the hospital? The truth always comes to light.
Who stage it how do you know it israel who staged it where does it say I DF on opposite I would say it Hamas staged it to compromise israel
Or what happened on the 7 October, an Israeli newspaper "the hazaard" claimed that the idf's tanks and helicopters were shooting arbitrary and were even targeting civilians, which confirmes that yasmin porat was telling the truth.
I was wondering,,,this is France 24 kikikk! Hamas used hospital as there commanding Centre and video was and is true! Shame on you!
@@kaitanokagalu Oh, so now the whole world is conspiring and the Zionists are the only ones telling the truth? Even your own people doubt you, the end of Israel's apartheid supremacy state is almost upon us.
@@kaitanokagalukeep saying that and it might be true in another world
She is the only doctor to complain about Hamas 😂
Of course the others get paid too well 😅
You mean khamas
The others fear of reprisal from Hamas 😂😂😂
Brave..others are coward
You can watch videos of foreign doctors from all over the word who's been working in gaza saying that they have never seen any hamas member or ever been under hamas control the whole time they've been working in gaza, but you chose to turn your brains off and believe isisrael
Props to you for exposing the truth..
The explosions on the backround sounds exactly the same ....and she has a thick israeli accent.. nevermind the arabic she tried to speak which was just halarious
Thank you standing up the truth.
Fake
@@tonythebomb4147your mom is fake
indeed . only disgusting people said it fake
She looks clean compared to the other medical staff in other Hospitals.
A "nurse" telling Gazans to leave in Arabic, but the rest of her message is in English 😂
She is wearing the same exactly eye glasses 🤣🤣
They trying so hard to change public opinion which is based on truth
This is an example of "true" journalism.
Example of fabricated news 😡😡😡😡😡😡
not really they claim it to be straight fake. the proofs are not heavy enough. Audio from phones could have bad quality with low frequences at distances also the Graphic shows slightly differences while they claim the sounds are the same. By that, i wouldnt suggest to say its fake.
true journalism goes deeper and not like a 5 minute long france24 video :D
Oh wow that’s really deep hypocrisy😢
Why would someone have to LIE about a group so that we will hate them? If they were really the bad guys, then truth would have been enough. Or am I missing something?
An actual nurse in the hospital would not look into the camera non-stop...looks like she's auditioning. Also, too gushy. If she were that upset, she'd wouldn't maintain the look nor the pace of her speech.
You"'ll be surprised how many Gaza-made videos have this bad acting style. I'm pretty sure this is made by some random Israeli, but judging by acting alone, I would be careful because Palestinian actors use this kind of acting far more.
Cell phones exist to make a recording
Ever seen a nurse whilst being bombed? Different ppl react differently and they live in the middle east. Do you not think they are somewhat conditioned to this by now?
U Isroillik akterisa
an Israeli actress named Hannah abutbul
I find it amazing the power of Arabic language , when a non Arab person speaks Arabic it can be spotted by native Arab , really hard to decieve
It is in all language not only Arabic
an Israeli actress named Hannah abutbul
@@yrysf1876 but not all people are like that. some people never lose accents, it's tricky
@@zh3nox of course not all people lose accent but so what ? the fact that some can lose accent in other languages shows something different and powerful about Arabic language
@@billjourney999 thank you for your reply . what was hidden in my comment is the fact that a non-Arab has to be born and raised in an Arab society to be able to speak Arabic like native Arab. That is not the case with other languages , for instance my brother came to Portugal at age of 7 and now he speaks Portugese just like real Portugese people.
We all know how crowded the Al Shifa is these days. How is it possible that no other person appeared in the video. Her name is Hannan, an Isreal actress.
at first i had the same thought, the explosions in the background are somehow everytime the same. but, did we put in the fact that phones dont have the best audio or that the audiographic shows slightly a little bit of differences on the frequence? also all the other proofs are not heavy enough to claim its full fake??
As arab woman i laugh so hard😂😂😂
IDF Please keep intertain us😂😂😂😂
If you look at the poster, it is NOT IDF. Just saying.... 🤷
@@HDracer🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱💪
LIe, thieft. nazioniz israHELL@@halfevilhalfgood2206
I thought you have fafo tiktoker from Gaza who is already doing that 😂
😂😂😂
They say it themselves - repeat a lie long enough and it becomes the truth.
Can't believe they showed the truth
Native arabic speaker here can confirm that she is definitely not a native arabic speaker
It looks quote acted to me… On top of that she cries, but not a tear is coming out!
I can tell from her accent that she speaks Hebrew originally ,this is not an accent of someone speaks Arabic
It is clear that this girl, who is pretending to be a nurse, is a huge liar. People who are working in that hospital denied that they know that girl, and that she definitely does not work in Al shifa hospital.
Lol. It’s already proven that Al shifa is infested by Hamas and Hospital workers denied it prior 😂 Hamas are liars.
Thank you France 24
She’s the worst actor 😂😂😂😂
Yes, it's almost as if they want us to realize it's fake.
I can't get over the Hamas Calendar😂
That is a very clean nurse, how can she maintain her uniform stay clean white🤷
She is super clean.
And that's a doctor suit, no nurse wearing that suit.
@@tyarchie5143thats not even Arabic accent sound like an Zimbabwe learning arabic
Her gloves are so clean too 😂
She had time to put on nice, tidy makeup
Shes a mexican-israeli woman who already claimed its not her bland shows pics of the differences of her and the video. But they really look still very similar. She uses different face expressions to try and make herself look different
When truth is exposed they call it Fake.
Thank you for showing the truth!
@@yusufibntachfin7978 jooobot #723595 reporting for duty
@@yusufibntachfin7978No, i believe he meant to say thank you for showing the truth to the world of their lies.
@@temujinchannel8584
You're right
she is not palasthini she is from israil, israil playing dirty game, medias spreading fake videos of a woman, but they blind about dying womens and childrens, in palasthin, look guys The media is doing the same genocide that Israel is doing, now we found there is only one trusted media to the world that "ALJEZEERA",
What truth thats a lie HER NAME ITS HANNAH she is actres in israel.
It’s simply fake
If only journalists put in half as much effort looking into hamas...
Pathetic desperation
Give her an academy award
Wow I applaud the journalism, didn’t expect this from france honestly. Much love from 🇹🇷
Your govermnet is way worse, what are you proud of by tagging your bloody flag?
CNN.and bbc are also reporting unbiased
Why, the French are some of the most antisemitic people on the planet!
Thank you, France 24 for this service.
We want you please to investigate the video shared by IDF showing alleged Hamas members bringing in hostages to Ashifaa hospital
Her Israeli accent is so strong lol
Fake, of course. FIrst of all the nurses and female doctors don't dress like that.
yeah, like onlyfans
He refers to the patient. You just never know the videos! If I was suffering I wouldn’t want to be on video?? My prayers out to all those injured. Fake or not.
Offcourse you won't believe
@e t ethics So who is dress in the scrub? Your M*m*? Looks like you have never entered into hospital. What an abdul. I used to work in Hospital So I know she is a Doctor! Do you see that expensive Sthethoscope? Oh you cannot recognize her dress so how do you recognize her sthethoscope??? Abdul is being an Abdul!
From School Labs. Childish play at work.
you can hear that she is clearly acting! This behavior is beyond horror f-up!
Don't condemn until you k ow who it is...
She is liar... Thankyou telling truth
an Israeli actress named Hannah abutbul
Unbiased fact-based journalism. This should be the norm, not the exception. But unfortunately that's the world we live in.
Thats FAKE. she kept touching her face with that gloves. A nurse wont do that, even in emergency.
Nobody noticed that the nurse's clothes are completely clean? There is not even running water in Gaza right now.