Another Dead End 0:00 The Big Fall 1:13 The Escape 2:10 Duct Tape Solves Everything 6:43 Get To The Chopper! 7:57 Ellie The Expert Surgeon 8:57 David & Ellie Make A Deal 9:21 Fate 12:46 The Medicine 15:28 The Decoy 16:49
Some people claim that Joel was fundamentally selfish in the end and only saved Ellie because he'd come to see her as a replacement for Sarah but I disagree. She had his back numerous times and put herself in mortal danger to keep him alive after suffering such a devastating and unmanageable injury. She was more than just a surrogate daughter, she was a comrade and a battle partner. She protected him just as much as he protected her. It was only fair that he do the same for her, even if she never understood why he did it. It was a matter of honor.
Honestly I do get why the show didn't include the rebar there's literally a very low chance anyone would survive that without a hospital. Between The internal bleeding and high chance of sepsis after piercing a intestine. There's no way. But also when has a show been that realistic
I think games can push that unrealistic boundary a little further than TV. I guess people who never played the game before and only now seeing it's story through television, most viewers would not believe it at all. It could also have been laziness or time restraints, skipping the whole university fight and impalement with a simple knife wound and horse ride probably save them weeks of effort and filming.
Doesn't really make it bad that the game does this, you're kinda supposed to suspend your disbelief, and while very low its not entirely impossible to survive a rebar, people in real life have survived getting shot in the head or any wounds that would just be difficult to survive
Even though this is a game, and although Joel probably would not survive without surgery or proper medical attention, the only thing that shows how superhuman the guy can be motivated, except even he has limitations just like a powerful man with control over the world
yeah that 0.1% survival rate made it possible to pull this off off. Having something this dramatic simply adds more and more layers of emotional and memorable moments, even if it is far fetched.
I like any game better than the TV show/ movie adaptation. Halo, Tomb Raider, The Witcher, Resident Evil, Street Fighter, Mortal Kombat are all better in game version in my opinion. The only one that I think is better on TV is - Arcane, but that is so different to the game you really wouldn't know they are the same thing.
I agree the wound was too severe to survive, but having a 0.1% survival rate made it possible to go with. I guess they made it that serious of an injury to simply add tension for the player. if it was a knife wound it wouldn't be memorable at all, but how can you forget a pipe through the stomach and 10 minute gameplay segment of escaping the university with Joel flashing in an out of consciousness.
We could say the same thing about Rick Grimes. He fell on rebar in The Walking Dead, and yet he managed to survive despite blood loss it was an indomitable will leave. He’s the captain going and told Jade is you know called the Civic Republic helicopter to rescue her and him and when they reach the hospital they were able to save him but then again, if you saw the spinoff, she would know these guys have a lot of shit.
Everyone talking about how unrealistic Joel's injury is, but can we talk about the unrealism of the helicopter CLEARLY MARKED WITH MEDEVAC? It's one thing to be lucky enough to stumble upon such a helicopter, but there is absolutely zero chance of it not being raided already in this world. Don't get me wrong. I loved the game, but the show is doing much better. My only complaint about the show is the time restraints. The team behind the show could've done marvels if given 20 episodes to tell this story.
They used an entire episode to show why Ellie chose to not leave Joel when he asks her to leave( not present in the game ) and linked it to Riley which didn’t quite hit the spot for me.
@@meatbeater159 You mean they used an entire episode to highlight a key piece of story that was missing in the game that they made an entire DLC for it? Yes. Yes they did. The story of Riley is super important. It always has been. Hence why the episode is called "Left Behind"... You know... The same name as the DLC...
Most new viewers don't realise that games are made more unrealistic than TV to capture the intense situations. Imagine in TLOU part 1 Joel got stabbed by a pen knife and then continues with the same story that we know. It doesn't quite hit your emotions, and to be honest, most players would forget how he got injured in the first place. Having a 15 foot fall, an impalement and a 10 minute gameplay segment of escaping while losing consciousness made it so memorable, the unrealistic side of it doesn't even matter. The 0.1% survival rate made it work.
Up until ep 6 I still had hope that the show could be at least half as good. Never as amazing as the game but you know what I mean. But then we get several moments of Joel being unnecessarily weak, no raider attacks like in the game, and Ellie didn't run away which resulted in a harrowing chase to save her from raiders which then climaxed into their tearful argument. And then when they get back to Jackson is when Joel decides to stay with Ellie. Then we see Joel kill one guy at the university when in the game you have the option to either kill or sneak past a ton of clickers and a bloater. Then it's an epic struggle to fight their out as they first meet David's Group. I almost don't want to keep watching but I love Bella and Pedro.
@@wyattchandler6359p 7 was cheeks imo the way Ellie jus goes up stairs finds a needle and thread then stitch’s Joel up was dumb, idk why they didn’t include her getting the medication from the mall like she did in the game it showed how eager she was to save Joel and what she was capable of.
@@ii_wav_ii3629 yeah no I agree. The writing and directing feels really half-assed. Cuckmann and Craig Maizin are giving the least amount of effort they can.
@@wyattchandler6359 Neils honestly a dumbass unless he tryna raise money for a lou3😭, this game ain’t need to get turned into a show it was perfect the way it was now we got ppl saying the shows a masterpiece this that the 3rd the shows better blah blah when it literally isn’t.
@@ascohen11180 unbias opinion. The show was alright. I liked the extra detail. The game was better in my opinion. (mainly because the experience was unique for me.) BUT DAMN YOU GOT HIM GOOD. He needs some ice with that one.
Another Dead End 0:00
The Big Fall 1:13
The Escape 2:10
Duct Tape Solves Everything 6:43
Get To The Chopper! 7:57
Ellie The Expert Surgeon 8:57
David & Ellie Make A Deal 9:21
Fate 12:46
The Medicine 15:28
The Decoy 16:49
😄😄😄😄😄😄😄😄😄😄😄😄😄😄😄😄😒😮🐴
😜😜😜😜😜😜😜😜😜😷😷😷😷😷😷😅😮😮
Some people claim that Joel was fundamentally selfish in the end and only saved Ellie because he'd come to see her as a replacement for Sarah but I disagree. She had his back numerous times and put herself in mortal danger to keep him alive after suffering such a devastating and unmanageable injury. She was more than just a surrogate daughter, she was a comrade and a battle partner. She protected him just as much as he protected her. It was only fair that he do the same for her, even if she never understood why he did it. It was a matter of honor.
"Move it!"
"I was impaled on a f*cking piece of metal, you little sh*t, YOU move it"
Honestly I do get why the show didn't include the rebar there's literally a very low chance anyone would survive that without a hospital. Between The internal bleeding and high chance of sepsis after piercing a intestine. There's no way. But also when has a show been that realistic
I think games can push that unrealistic boundary a little further than TV. I guess people who never played the game before and only now seeing it's story through television, most viewers would not believe it at all.
It could also have been laziness or time restraints, skipping the whole university fight and impalement with a simple knife wound and horse ride probably save them weeks of effort and filming.
Doesn't really make it bad that the game does this, you're kinda supposed to suspend your disbelief, and while very low its not entirely impossible to survive a rebar, people in real life have survived getting shot in the head or any wounds that would just be difficult to survive
Of course tv series are unrealistic and push the boundaries have you ever seen stranger things ? 😂
I think Ellie did an excellent job taking care of Joel at that time, even in cold weather.
idk why but ellie's "yeah no shit" made me cackle out loud
Ellie's attitude is what make's her Ellie.
just came here after watching episode 6 :D
Same here lol!
Me too
me too!
Yeahp same here
Haha, me too, because I want to know, if Joel is gonna make it.
Even though this is a game, and although Joel probably would not survive without surgery or proper medical attention, the only thing that shows how superhuman the guy can be motivated, except even he has limitations just like a powerful man with control over the world
yeah that 0.1% survival rate made it possible to pull this off off. Having something this dramatic simply adds more and more layers of emotional and memorable moments, even if it is far fetched.
Hugh Glass survive a bear attack and manage to make it back
@@yosoyyo9487 lol the film was heavily exaggerated. I love the film but Hollywood exaggerates things
14:27 he throws the penicillin and the glass vial breaks xD
Very nice find my friend. XD
Honestly I like the game way better
I like any game better than the TV show/ movie adaptation. Halo, Tomb Raider, The Witcher, Resident Evil, Street Fighter, Mortal Kombat are all better in game version in my opinion.
The only one that I think is better on TV is - Arcane, but that is so different to the game you really wouldn't know they are the same thing.
Anyone who likes the show better has some serious issues.
4:06 GOD I LOVE ELLIE😭😭😭😭
Me too
No way he survived that or even the show one without surgery
I agree the wound was too severe to survive, but having a 0.1% survival rate made it possible to go with.
I guess they made it that serious of an injury to simply add tension for the player. if it was a knife wound it wouldn't be memorable at all, but how can you forget a pipe through the stomach and 10 minute gameplay segment of escaping the university with Joel flashing in an out of consciousness.
We could say the same thing about Rick Grimes. He fell on rebar in The Walking Dead, and yet he managed to survive despite blood loss it was an indomitable will leave. He’s the captain going and told Jade is you know called the Civic Republic helicopter to rescue her and him and when they reach the hospital they were able to save him but then again, if you saw the spinoff, she would know these guys have a lot of shit.
It's called make believe. We learn about it at 5.
Everyone talking about how unrealistic Joel's injury is, but can we talk about the unrealism of the helicopter CLEARLY MARKED WITH MEDEVAC? It's one thing to be lucky enough to stumble upon such a helicopter, but there is absolutely zero chance of it not being raided already in this world. Don't get me wrong. I loved the game, but the show is doing much better. My only complaint about the show is the time restraints. The team behind the show could've done marvels if given 20 episodes to tell this story.
They’re still wasting a bunch of time showing flashbacks though
They used an entire episode to show why Ellie chose to not leave Joel when he asks her to leave( not present in the game ) and linked it to Riley which didn’t quite hit the spot for me.
@@meatbeater159 You mean they used an entire episode to highlight a key piece of story that was missing in the game that they made an entire DLC for it? Yes. Yes they did. The story of Riley is super important. It always has been. Hence why the episode is called "Left Behind"... You know... The same name as the DLC...
Most new viewers don't realise that games are made more unrealistic than TV to capture the intense situations.
Imagine in TLOU part 1 Joel got stabbed by a pen knife and then continues with the same story that we know. It doesn't quite hit your emotions, and to be honest, most players would forget how he got injured in the first place.
Having a 15 foot fall, an impalement and a 10 minute gameplay segment of escaping while losing consciousness made it so memorable, the unrealistic side of it doesn't even matter. The 0.1% survival rate made it work.
The game is so much better
8:20 that relief "I'm not letting you go". She probably meant for Joel.
Where does the scene with Ellie taping and stitching up the wound occur in the game? I haven't seen that before. Are they deleted cutscenes?
They are part of the Left Behind DLC where she gets flackback moments. I ordered them in chronological order to make it as a full story.
Thanks
Game> tv series
Up until ep 6 I still had hope that the show could be at least half as good. Never as amazing as the game but you know what I mean. But then we get several moments of Joel being unnecessarily weak, no raider attacks like in the game, and Ellie didn't run away which resulted in a harrowing chase to save her from raiders which then climaxed into their tearful argument. And then when they get back to Jackson is when Joel decides to stay with Ellie. Then we see Joel kill one guy at the university when in the game you have the option to either kill or sneak past a ton of clickers and a bloater. Then it's an epic struggle to fight their out as they first meet David's Group. I almost don't want to keep watching but I love Bella and Pedro.
@@wyattchandler6359p 7 was cheeks imo the way Ellie jus goes up stairs finds a needle and thread then stitch’s Joel up was dumb, idk why they didn’t include her getting the medication from the mall like she did in the game it showed how eager she was to save Joel and what she was capable of.
@@ii_wav_ii3629 yeah no I agree. The writing and directing feels really half-assed. Cuckmann and Craig Maizin are giving the least amount of effort they can.
@@wyattchandler6359 Neils honestly a dumbass unless he tryna raise money for a lou3😭, this game ain’t need to get turned into a show it was perfect the way it was now we got ppl saying the shows a masterpiece this that the 3rd the shows better blah blah when it literally isn’t.
I agree but to be fair they couldn't really do the game version because lets be realistic he wouldn't of survived that
16:28 😭
best part 16:36
Your so nice Ellie you saved your dad joel congratulations
"No thanks "I have my dad to protect me
David's a creep, I would have said no thanks also.
1:26 bro thinks he's Rick Grimes
This game has is own vibe 😴♥️
1 in a million
No one’s talking about how Ellie got hit across the face with a pipe and didn’t get knocked out
7:24
Same
Great episode once again
So the ep8 is out, pretty same to this
Yeah very subtle changes. Nice episode.
16:06
❤❤🎉🎉😊😊😮😮😢😢
🤗🤗🤭🤭😣😣😫😫🥰🥰
Did u guys know Abby is immune? I didn’t believe it at first but utuber *Cooking With Kratos* actually proves it!!
HBO made this episode woke just to cater to the mentally unstable Alphabet brigade
How exactly did they make it woke?
And yet you'll still tune in at 9pm EST every Sunday
@@ascohen11180 unbias opinion. The show was alright. I liked the extra detail. The game was better in my opinion. (mainly because the experience was unique for me.) BUT DAMN YOU GOT HIM GOOD. He needs some ice with that one.
"Unstable". Pot meet kettle.
7:24
16:29
7:25
7:25
7:27