Reasons Behind Pakistan's Economic Downfall - Ex-Foreign Secretary Explains

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 27 вер 2024
  • Watch The Full Episode Here: • Harsh V Shringla On G2...
    Follow Harsh Vardhan Shringla's Social Media Handles:-
    Instagram - / shringlaharshv
    Facebook - / harsh.shringla
    Twitter - / harshvshringla
    / harshshringla
    ✅ Subscribe To Our Other UA-cam Channels:-
    BeerBiceps (English Channel):
    / beerbicepsofficial
    Ranveer Allahbadia (Hindi Channel):
    / ranveerallahbadia
    TRS Clips हिंदी (Hindi Podcast Highlights):
    / @theranveershowhindi
    BeerBiceps Shorts (English Shorts):
    / @bestoftrs
    Ranveer Allahbadia Shorts (Hindi Shorts):
    / @bestoftrshindi
    RAAAZ. :
    / @raaazofficial
    RAAAZ Shorts :
    / @raaazshorts
    BigBrain Plus :
    / @bigbrain_plus
    Welcome to another amazing episode of The Ranveer Show. Today we welcome Mr. Harsh Vardhan Shringla on our podcast. He is the Chief Coordinator for India’s G20 Presidency in 2023 and has previously served as Foreign Secretary of India and India's Ambassador to the United States, High Commissioner to Bangladesh, and Ambassador to Thailand.
    In this episode, Mr. Harsh Vardhan Shringla delves into various geopolitical topics such as His Profession, Pakistan's Economic Condition, Terrorism, & more. He simply explained the working of the G20 Summit and how it originated from G7 and G8. Moreover, he talked about how Pakistan’s Economic crisis led to adverse situations in the country and how it has also affected its neighboring nations. We also discussed the current state of Dawood Ibrahim along with delving into how the terrorist organization actually works.
    Geopolitical conversations have become one of my favorites and I enjoy them through and through. If you're someone who loves to learn about politics, India, and the world, I'm sure you will enjoy this episode as much as I did. Feel free to share your opinion in the comments!
    #harshvardhan #geopolitics
    --
    INSTAGRAM : @beerbiceps
    / beerbiceps
    FACEBOOK : @beerbiceps
    / beerbiceps
    TWITTER : @beerbicepsguy
    / beerbicepsguy
    LINKEDIN : @beerbiceps
    / beerbiceps
    TELEGRAM: @beerbicepsguy
    t.me/beerbicep...
    SNAPCHAT: @beerbicepsguy
    ----------------------------------------------
    About :
    TRS Clips is a collection of SHORT CLIPS from The Ranveer Show podcast. Enjoy our latest knowledge-fueled videos from the BeerBiceps team. Every conversation on #TheRanveerShow is intellectual, deep & progressive. We cover everyone from entrepreneurs to Bollywood film stars to even athletes.
    Today, The Ranveer Show or TRS - Happiness Through Curiosity. A show where we host the world's greatest success stories and try digging out their secrets to success. Every conversation is an EXTREME learning experience for the viewer.

КОМЕНТАРІ • 176

  • @josealexander1674
    @josealexander1674 Рік тому +215

    I believe Indian media should completely ignore Pakistan problems and focus on the better and well being of India' s population.

    • @VGHINDUSTANI
      @VGHINDUSTANI Рік тому +9

      Yeah...but he asked him being a x foreign minister...that question is basically for Pakistani viewers...

    • @vivekandhavarapu7904
      @vivekandhavarapu7904 Рік тому +2

      We should be vigilant on India and its neighbours, especially Pak for sure.

    • @yashsonune4391
      @yashsonune4391 Рік тому

      totally agree with you. this pursuit of gaining views is the prime reason for such videos.

    • @girishbhangale2703
      @girishbhangale2703 Рік тому

      Accha...humko sikha riya hai😂😂

    • @priyamawasthi6254
      @priyamawasthi6254 Рік тому +6

      We have a neighbor who is
      a. Nuclear armed
      b. Politically unstable
      c. With many powerful and radical extremist groups
      d. Existentially hostile to India with a history of leaders making their way up in Pakistani politics, solely on merit of how bad they hate India right from Ayub Khan to Mussharraf
      And you "believe", India should ignore it?
      Yes, unnecessary chest thumping and vitriol should be avoided and true that we should focus on our own issues but Pakistan is also our own issue and it is in our best interests to understand and discuss what's going on there as long as it is with a sane, rational, and cool minded approach. 😊

  • @DharmendraKumar-jz6hj
    @DharmendraKumar-jz6hj Рік тому +64

    When will you inviting Major Gaurav Arya?

  • @yourrmeet
    @yourrmeet Рік тому +66

    Hi, I am from Pakistan. I highly regard the guest speaking things about Pakistan. However, things in beginning that Ranveer talked about (stealing food, chicken and dessert) were not factually correct. They were visuals from 9th May incident of a Core Commander House, where protesters had burnt places and vandalized army symbols in a wake of Imran Khan's arrest. Big respect for the show

    • @rishisimply
      @rishisimply Рік тому +3

      As an Indian even I know the house that was burnt was if core commander and not a administrative officer. They have so much reach through youtube channel yet do t do basic sanity checks in reporting

    • @iracture
      @iracture Рік тому +2

      The reasons that formed Pakistan were different from that formed India. The people residing in Pak are largely overall ok with the direction their country is taking. That does not mean some people do not want to reach much higher than where they are today in terms of economic growth and other parameters. But do they want it badly enough ? I don't think that is of highest priority for them. And those are their choices as a group of people. I am not sure why Indians are obsessed with Pakistan's economic growth. India's desired growth still needs lots of efforts. It would be desirable if India focusses inwards towards their own growth rather than discussing how Pakistan should have better economic policies 🤭

    • @yourrmeet
      @yourrmeet Рік тому +1

      @@iracture Hi, I beg to disagree with you on a point of 'Pakistanis being okay with what is happening inside the country'. The narrative is factually incorrect. Just in last year, more than three hundred thousand Pakistanis, mainly professionals, have left the country due to the pertinent political crisis and economic turmoil.
      What you missed to identify was, Pakistan has a vast majority of people of different religions, ethnicities, and belief systems. With four provinces, ideologically indifferent from each other, it is absolutely difficult for such an administration (that was poorly brought in power) to bring all at one place. So the divide is visibly wide. Then, comes center-provinces vindication... Later on, the civil -military where the latter has implicitly or explicitly been in power.. these dynamics are even worse than those of Afghanistan, but we have always an opportunity that is amiss however. Therefore, making such statements about Pakistan is little injustice to its people.

    • @iracture
      @iracture Рік тому +1

      @@yourrmeet but you missed reading the key word of my comment namely - "largely". Naturally in a country with so many different cultures there is bound to be difference of opinion(s). No one is saying all that people of Pakistan are ok and celebrating what is happening. But are there enough citizens who are driven for a change in Pakistan. I think you can answer that question better. From my view point I will continue to hold that critical mass of population wanting change is not available in Pakistan. I hope a viewpoint will not result in Pakistani citizens feeling that they have been served injustice - that is not my intention i am afraid. Largely they are ok with what is happening is my view. India is not doing badly for itself actually. But yet many more students/professionals leave India every year in search of greener pastures in a globalized economy. I think migration and restlessness is in blood of many South Asians. I will also add from my understanding Pakistani is not a place where business houses would have thrived. The structure of the country is not very capitalistic friendly and that is by choice I believe rather than forced helplessness. They view wealth/resources etc from different eyes as a culture. There are very few cultures there that believe in business like Indian's Marwaris/Parsi section for example. I think you must be proud of your country and support it in its growth..Everyone gets there.. some fast some slow..but you will get there.

    • @iracture
      @iracture Рік тому

      @@Letslearn-ts4dv yup he is not...

  • @ashishrajoria2251
    @ashishrajoria2251 Рік тому +117

    Want Prashant Dhawan on this show

  • @namanbajaj7611
    @namanbajaj7611 Рік тому +29

    It wasn't a civil services officer (Pak), it was the Core Commanders house, which was ransacked and plundered while he and his family disappeared. These acts were egged on by Mr Imran Khan's multiple TV broadcasts and public rallies leading upto the events of that day..

  • @ajitnairk010
    @ajitnairk010 Рік тому +22

    Hey dude. Pls remove the pumpkin hanging over the guests' head. Aint pretty

  • @jaiminbajaj
    @jaiminbajaj Рік тому +66

    Congress and it’s stooges would have turned us into Pakistan by now 😅 thanks to people of India for choosing a strong government

    • @trailblazer9325
      @trailblazer9325 Рік тому

      CONGIS ARE EXPERT IN MILKING SUCH INCIDENTS. OUR ONE THIRD OF POPULATION WOULD HAVE BEEN DIED DUE TO COVID IF CONGRESS GOVT WAS THERE. AND THEY WOULD HAVE DONE VACCINE SCAM ALSO LETTING PEOPLE TO DIE WITH DISEASE AND HUNGER.

    • @jaiminbajaj
      @jaiminbajaj Рік тому +7

      @@udayviruppal3730 Unsubstantiated! Indian Express once claimed army planned a coup 😅
      People will do anything to be in momentary limelight and stay relevant

  • @PathakRajendra1
    @PathakRajendra1 Рік тому +17

    Please bring Prashan Dhawan

  • @hotpot3704
    @hotpot3704 Рік тому +5

    Dear Ranveer
    Please bring Annamalai Sir..We want to know his perspective about life and Nation ..
    Your Sincere Subscriber

  • @best_from_bottom
    @best_from_bottom Рік тому +4

    I really want Annamalai sir and Prashant Dhawan sir in your podcast.
    Please try to make this happen

  • @rajeshpillaik
    @rajeshpillaik Рік тому +6

    Real reason was none of these ... Pakistan doesn't have any manufacturing or service industry basis last few decades it thrived on Foreign Aid plus printing illegal Indian currency.
    Pakistan had a security press in Press in Peshawar which used to print Indian Currency in 3 shifts .
    Indian currency Demonitisation was a nightmare to Pakistan and one of their biggest profitable revenue channel vanished out of thin air. There after Pakistan never recovered from the crisis.

    • @lifeasintention9500
      @lifeasintention9500 Рік тому

      Bro, I am from india (Bharat).
      Indian (bharat) currency printing fake
      What is use for Pakistan above mentioned work?
      Instead Pakistan will focus on manufacturing technology & information technology
      And clean your internal politics problem and Rearrange your army
      Pakistan Army is one of the reason currently Pakistan economy underground
      As a pakistani people's have a strength, anybody not raise their voice
      If you need anything, you can request. If you not got then u can fight with them
      Anyway I prayer to pakistani people's bcz were the same 😍

  • @narenvarne
    @narenvarne Рік тому +12

    Things will never go well in a country which took birth on grounds of killing lakhs of innocent people in the name of religion. This country is suffering its KARMA.

  • @NomanRizwan-u7h
    @NomanRizwan-u7h Рік тому +38

    being a Pakistani i watch your geopolitical because we share same culture same history but we are falling down gradually and I want to know the exact reason what you are doing for the economy and what we should do

    • @Dark81379uiu
      @Dark81379uiu Рік тому +9

      Institutional freedom and no place of radicalization in the society and decision making .

    • @krishSundar
      @krishSundar Рік тому +17

      No we don’t share same world view and even for that matter , we are extremely different mindset.
      Bharath: world view of love and let live
      Pakistan: pls use us to the hilt and somehow make us feel important which is otherwise worth nothing.

    • @bibhudattaardu9711
      @bibhudattaardu9711 Рік тому

      Sorry, there is no same culture , there is no case of forced conversion, there is no religion population unlike in paki reduced , we do nto produce terrorist, No Bin laden hiding . Pl be very clear. There is HUGe difference .

    • @sid8285
      @sid8285 Рік тому +13

      Same history yes but culture is completely different

    • @shirish4024
      @shirish4024 Рік тому +8

      Prioritise economy over religion!

  • @anjalishejwalkar3400
    @anjalishejwalkar3400 Рік тому +6

    किती शांतपणे त्यांनी त्यांची मत मांडली!

  • @nunisa
    @nunisa Рік тому +4

    I think Pakistan's problem should be left to Major Gaurav Arya. It seems he can handle Pakistan like no other.

  • @pkochujpkochuj
    @pkochujpkochuj Рік тому +26

    From 2014 India's naration to the world about Pakistan is the main reason for their downfall. The world really started to listen & act accordingly by not funding them...Covid too brought their downfall along with China's downfall too

    • @nageswaraopatha5445
      @nageswaraopatha5445 Рік тому +1

      Agreed but burnol movement for aaman ki Aasha government 😂😂😂😂

    • @travel.music.food.5403
      @travel.music.food.5403 Рік тому +1

      Ab iska ka credit Modi ko dedo, gajab hai andhbhakt 😆

    • @Ai-wibes
      @Ai-wibes 11 місяців тому

      ​@@travel.music.food.5403 jali na teri jali na 😂😂😂

    • @travel.music.food.5403
      @travel.music.food.5403 11 місяців тому

      @@Ai-wibes Nai jali, ab bol 😂

  • @SruthiRavali
    @SruthiRavali Рік тому +4

    Not entirely true when you said Abroad has a fascist view of India.
    I live in Ireland and people here love India and indian culture.
    People ask me where I am from, I reply India. Then they ask, where in India. When I say Bengaluru / Chennai / Delhi - they understand what that place is.
    They know what north and south India are. They know the food and spirituality and Hindutva.
    Many of them have been to India and stayed there for few months.
    Some white countries do see India as a positive force.

  • @praveendesai885
    @praveendesai885 Рік тому +18

    India should stop obsessing over Pakistan. India has far more problems that needs attention & discussion.

  • @ramkumar1081
    @ramkumar1081 Рік тому

    Everything about him feels so stoic!

  • @nitindinodia
    @nitindinodia Рік тому +5

    Invite Prashant Dhawan

  • @nachiketachandra5287
    @nachiketachandra5287 Рік тому +2

    Why dont you bring rahul gandhi...???
    It will an interesting conversation

  • @RaviKumar-me7ph
    @RaviKumar-me7ph Рік тому +5

    Invite Prashant dhawan

  • @AbhishekKumar-xd1up
    @AbhishekKumar-xd1up Рік тому +2

    Prashant Dhawan sir

  • @playerraja2483
    @playerraja2483 Рік тому +1

    What's cooking in Sweeden and Denmark 😂

  • @Kinduncle123
    @Kinduncle123 Рік тому

    After uprooting hand pump, no drinking water also

  • @craxton6713
    @craxton6713 Рік тому

    Ok bro it's cool, now if you could please talk about the downfall of the indian economy and the 'jobless growth' it's facing since decades and especially post covid, as well as the sky rocketing inflation and bring an expert to enlighten and provide views on practical strategies both the central and individual state governments (especially consumer states like Kerala from where I come) can follow , would be great !!!!.... Not a Pakistani troll. Indian and Malayali..

  • @rahul2288able
    @rahul2288able Рік тому +1

    IAS equivalent is known as CSS

  • @sriramtandon6185
    @sriramtandon6185 Рік тому +19

    Love videos of Pakistani downfall.. Anyways Ranveer will go to any length to make his Pakistani viewers happy

    • @iracture
      @iracture Рік тому +1

      Are the Indian social media audience thinking they can cancel Pakistan as country ?? or has big boss style sadism got better of them ? Pakistan is a different country and it is better to actually live there before judging their downfall sitting out of India from media biased videos.

    • @psingh007
      @psingh007 Рік тому

      Ridiculous thinking. Focus should be on improving ourselves and not being happy with misfortune of others.
      We should however not help them for they funnel money into their terror infra and they are reaping what they've sowed since zia took over.

  • @rajvirdee1317
    @rajvirdee1317 Рік тому

    Everyone is corrupt starting from top to bottem.Given chance nobody miss chance to steal.

  • @nndkrsnbadami
    @nndkrsnbadami Рік тому

    Wear ear studs in both ears for all males in that place no need for gold any studs will do.

  • @Awesome08401
    @Awesome08401 Рік тому

    Bhai why can't we just focus on our economy?

  • @aashaykadu6549
    @aashaykadu6549 Рік тому

    Video does not answer exactly why Pakistan economy is in downfall (they are in downfall since before COVID)

  • @Dipanajan
    @Dipanajan Рік тому +1

    Please bring maj Gaurav Arya

  • @mischuschubhan3618
    @mischuschubhan3618 Рік тому +4

    Another propaganda channel of BJP and RSS

  • @nicksharma9520
    @nicksharma9520 Рік тому

    Gaurav Arya Sir ❤

  • @Annesrandomthings
    @Annesrandomthings Рік тому +6

    love DR JAISHANKAR

  • @deepak-ku7nv
    @deepak-ku7nv Рік тому

    Why it's always a bjp person

  • @ardamansingh6812
    @ardamansingh6812 Рік тому

    Soon same factors will be said for India

    • @syhuhjk
      @syhuhjk Рік тому +1

      Definitely, that's wish of some anti nationals. That's not gonna happen.

    • @lalzuimawiahmar513
      @lalzuimawiahmar513 8 місяців тому

      Noway,,,We learn from pakistan mistake

  • @Ravi-b9j5o
    @Ravi-b9j5o 6 місяців тому +1

    Any Fakistani watching

  • @saurabhsaksena324
    @saurabhsaksena324 11 місяців тому

    Clickbait

  • @rizwanrasul9744
    @rizwanrasul9744 Рік тому

    India will soon have 160 crores beggars time is not far

  • @jeetu3
    @jeetu3 Рік тому

    The needy poor still do not get foodgrain under govt covered sponsored ration cards and an even larger number r kept away from medical attention at govt hospitals under some pretext or another .
    It's all good to sit in comfy armchairs in AC rooms in hi rise towers ..but poor Needdy r still all at sea with no recourse aor accoubtanility of officers and politicians ..

  • @sarthaksuri8672
    @sarthaksuri8672 Рік тому +1

    I am first

  • @drmuhammadrazaalvi4830
    @drmuhammadrazaalvi4830 Рік тому

    Cry hard Ranveer 😂

  • @galabdeka7636
    @galabdeka7636 Рік тому

    L ka downfall
    They will be back stronger

  • @Politicalexposure12
    @Politicalexposure12 Рік тому +1

    Kabi Buddhism Indian monk ko bulavo ranveer (godi youtuber) you spreading false information an promoting imaginary region(Hinduism)

    • @yashugoyal9818
      @yashugoyal9818 9 місяців тому +2

      If he is fake then who is forcing you to watch. Don't watch, Just leave

  • @abhaylondon
    @abhaylondon Рік тому +10

    Godi youtube 😂😂😂

    • @devasish21
      @devasish21 Рік тому +2

      Suru suru me acha tha.. fir bik gya.. Hinduism aur Bjp chor k kuch nahi hai..

    • @bhaveshtamboli546
      @bhaveshtamboli546 Рік тому +6

      @@devasish21 kk geopolitics thinker.

    • @baslatz_
      @baslatz_ Рік тому +15

      Bhaiya tattoo bnwa lo. Kyu ki apki jinzgi ka constant hai yahi 😂
      No critical thinking only bla bla

    • @goldenG978
      @goldenG978 Рік тому +11

      Aur kuch?

    • @ashwanithakur5622
      @ashwanithakur5622 Рік тому +9

      Aur phir jab inko anti national bolte h to inko bura lagta h

  • @sangitasurdkar7680
    @sangitasurdkar7680 Рік тому

    Yeti ne barbad kiya pakistan ko 😂😂😂😂😂

  • @rahulskanaka
    @rahulskanaka Рік тому +25

    Prashant Dhavan sir - Next on podcast❤

  • @rahulanand2142
    @rahulanand2142 Рік тому +39

    Reason without watching video,
    1. Religious fundamentalism and Hindu hatred
    2. Army interference in Politics
    3. Political instability
    4. Safe haven for International terrorists
    5. Debt traps and loans on high interest rates
    6. Non stop military funding and huge corruption
    7. Lack of basic education
    8. Aid economy
    9. Friendship with America
    10. Enmity with India
    11. And most importantly Major Gaurav Arya

    • @aashaykadu6549
      @aashaykadu6549 Рік тому

      Political instability due to interference of army, Long term mismanagement, elite control, aid economy, less social awareness on education and birth, policy instability

    • @sridharanramdas3038
      @sridharanramdas3038 Рік тому +2

      😂Major Gaurav Arya😂

  • @rishuuuuuu
    @rishuuuuuu Рік тому +8

    Reason = islam.

  • @spartans_jio
    @spartans_jio Рік тому +7

    Prashant Dhawan sir 🧐

  • @asimjavaid5836
    @asimjavaid5836 Рік тому +65

    As a Pakistani, I found this person to be quite honest. However, I believe that their point of view about Pakistan is not entirely correct, but I agree with a large portion of their overall conversation

    • @surudog4929
      @surudog4929 Рік тому +16

      What point on Pakistan did you think was incorrect. He spoke very little about Pakistan and sounded sympathetic to issues beyond their control.
      Pakistan has a governance issue for generations. Elected leaders reporting to unelected generals and that is usually the end of democracy.

    • @theawesomeman9821
      @theawesomeman9821 Рік тому +2

      I'm sorry things are not going well for your country. I hope things improve and wish your nation the best of luck.

    • @anishs5652
      @anishs5652 Рік тому

      @@theawesomeman9821 no need of being apologetic .They have bought this on themselves by promoting terrorism against our country. They have fallen in the pit which they dug for us.Let them suffer if they cannot stop promoting terrorism.

    • @playerraja2483
      @playerraja2483 Рік тому +2

      I agree with you but I disagree with the part where you disagreed with the speaker in the podcast

    • @jongxina4908
      @jongxina4908 Рік тому +2

      Pakistani ese hi hote hai. Koi data nahi dete aur hawai bate karte hai. Hope you see this comment and actually tell what he said was wrong.

  • @shantanushekharsjunerft9783
    @shantanushekharsjunerft9783 Рік тому +1

    What an excellent guest! Harshavardhan Shringla has done terrific job as a foreign Secretary.

  • @anchalgoel9043
    @anchalgoel9043 Рік тому +1

    The title of this video is so missleading . It should be 'cleaver ways to make audiences watch pro modi ad'. All your content now a days seem like that.... unsubscribed! Not worth my time!

    • @santusanturohit4832
      @santusanturohit4832 Рік тому +2

      Please don't go...Ranveer will feel bad..he may go through depression. .his life will be destroyed. .please don't go..

    • @barunbiswas4157
      @barunbiswas4157 Рік тому

      Please unsubscribe from life will be good for our country

  • @GandlaUmamaheswar
    @GandlaUmamaheswar Рік тому

    High drama by Pakistan for Arabs oil dollars.

  • @rajgopal9708
    @rajgopal9708 Рік тому

    Could china be milking IMF using Pakistan?

  • @doomguy4668
    @doomguy4668 Рік тому

    nice clickbait pak downfall bolke india ki baaten bata dis XD XD

  • @drifcygnus189
    @drifcygnus189 Рік тому +3

    First comment 😁

  • @unnikrishnankp5873
    @unnikrishnankp5873 Рік тому

    Hi is like subhash bose😃

  • @ek_minute_
    @ek_minute_ Рік тому +2

    i want you to talk on manipur

  • @user-zb3ih3vh4n
    @user-zb3ih3vh4n Рік тому

    If you are watching this just for feel good and proud and not to learn from it then remember the same thing will happen to India too
    We have to learn and grow
    Laughing on others is never been an Indian things

  • @sachinkumar-mi6gz
    @sachinkumar-mi6gz Рік тому +1

    YOUR videos are like back door way for GODI MEDIA CRUSADER