Joseph Nye | Are we seeing the end of the American liberal order?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 8 вер 2024
- A Graduate Institute lecture on 15 June 2017 from Joseph Nye, University Distinguished Service Professor and former Dean of Harvard’s Kennedy School of Government.
Regarding so called “rules of order”, because the world has changed in the last 40 years, some of the rules have to be updated. The rules set in 1940s and 1950s by a few countries including the US are out of date or no longer fair to many countries that did not participate in setting those rules. International rules should not be set by just a few countries. The UN is the international entity where many issues shall be discussed and resolved. What we have experienced, however, is that powerful countries such as the US often totally ignore rules of orders set by the UN. The US insisted that others follow the “rules of orders” while it does not lead by examples and gets away with its actions. That’s why the US is losing trust and soft power domestically and internationally.
I think the right name for such a system is call FRAUDULENT.
The USA is a fraudulent country that wants to impose on others a " rules based order " it imagined up for others to obey, but not itself although there is already in existence and internationally accepted UN supported Rules Based Order.
he completely ignored the fact that the US is not on a gradual decline but had already very much down the slope as of 2022, nearing the bottom of the heap.
@@slee4039 Roses promising outlook of the US future is self-glorifition and self-placate venue.
What rules do you speak of with out specifics? Certainly NOT national borders and sovereignty.
The “rules of order” for the post WWII American Liberal order where the U.S. would police the world and keep the seas safe for navigation, trade and commerce and countries would ally with the USA for security against the "Communist threat". Allies could run their countries, access U.S. markets and spend minimally on defense. They've had pretty sweet deal for 75 years now. Russia and China especially have benefitted from it as well. Did the U.S. do it perfectly? No, of course not, but for every Iraq or Vietnam, there was a Korea or Kuwait - Gulf War. The U.S. benefitted very little economically form this American Liberal order (export wise) other than in peace and stability to grow our consumer economy without having to shift to war mode.
What is it that you'd like to change about that sweet deal?
@@stephenlock7236 You're delusional. The U.S. guaranteed unprecedented peace (only smaller minor regional wars), stability and trade for 75 years and benefitted very little economically form this American Liberal order (export wise) other than in peace and stability to grow our consumer economy without having to shift to war mode. Did the U.S. do it perfectly? No, of course not, but for every Iraq or Vietnam, there was a Korea or Kuwait - Gulf War. Others could have stepped up to lead, but did they? Mostly no. They mostly laid back and criticized while taking advantage, as they could, of U.S. markets and they U.S. Navy guaranteeing freedom on the 7 seas.
The “rules of order” for the post WWII American Liberal order where the U.S. would police the world and keep the seas safe for navigation, trade and commerce and countries would ally with the USA for security against the "Communist threat". Allies could run their countries, access U.S. markets and spend minimally on defense. They've had pretty sweet deal for 75 years now. Russia and China especially have benefitted from it as well. What is it that you'd like to change about that sweet deal?
No other country comes close to being a real "super power". Russia can destroy the world with its nuclear weapons, nut it can't project power anywhere in the world like the U.S. can. Neither can China and that's the definition of a "super power". Neither of those powers seem to respect national borders and sovereignty (or human rights) except when it's convenient for them.
Would you rather have Putin and Xi in charge of the world order, because that's what they are aiming for?
Joseph Nye's analysis is precious on Neoliberalism and liberal order understanding.
Thank God that finally America’s domination is over During her cruel and inhumane domination period, a lot countries were destroyed and their population were obliterated in billons of lives lost Examples are Vietnam, Iraq, Libya, Syria , Afghanistan and list goes on. I hope one day America pays for all these atrocities
Mr Nye, overall is highly paid to be here tonight ! We just dont know who's paying. Now lets listen for 5 minutes to understand.
Dealing with the criminal US government is like playing a game against an opponent that changes the rules every time you score and adds your points to theirs.
Most unreliable and untrustworthy superpower who stabs at the back of its friends. USA created Talibans using Pakistan and then killed Pakistan's president Zia ul Haq. Soon after Russia defeat, sanctions were imposed on Pakistan. Again used Pakistan this time against Talibans and killed 26 Pakistani soldiers in Salala Post intentionally. Again Pakistan became a bad actor. This time USA has to leave with the taste of defeat. Pakistan was blamed for USA defeat. 48 countries army with so much sophisticated weapons could not defeat rag-tagged Talibans.
Exact name of criminal US government. Because of the American liberal order is to legalize the ilegal criminals to take the power of State Apparatus as personal crutch to look for harm others ae pleasure.
Too bad they're not smart enough to realize that in cutting the throats of the American people in order to have it all; in the end their own throats will be cut as America crumbles and collapses into the ocean of history like so many former great powers have. Whereas Rome died laughing, I believe America will die screaming unfortunately.
you know that america changes government every 4 years right?
@@lucasolsson7346 If you believe that then I have some beach front property to sell you in Arizona.
Whether you agree or not, Prof Nye's lecture is really remarkable, educational and informative. Wish more US politicians watch this
That would be something now wouldn't it
He lost the thread entirely at the "magically technology I/we don't understand will just insure America is well/only in relative decline", actually. This is common in leadership... believing the marketing hype (often of orgs barely viable if at all).
A very anti-creactive and boring speech. Nothing new at all. Totally disappointed. Just can't believe he's dean of a department in Harvard. Or maybe many others like him in Harvard or others similarly achademica.
I have an impression that Nay’s theory lacks an understanding of human nature and morality. That’s why US could never think of taking the vaccine as a public goods to establish her soft power. Furthermore, according to Behavioral Economy, no one actually likes free ride.
The ranking of university, like the ranking of Health Care System, has no practical use at all. US education system no doubt remains no. 1, as long as there is H1-B.
@@explorerofunknownworlddept6232 Your comment is right. However, as Richard Wolff said, the education of Ivy League is to teach people to love the US system rather than to know how it works. Nay performs well in this aspect.
In as much as I reverred Joseph Nye, I would say if he watch this again, he would realise he was completely off tangent and allowed his biases affect his long earned integrity!
Not true.
Not true.
Very true..it's hard to listen to Never trumpets...biased approach
@@Futhi.Johnson You're just exposing your own personal biases with this comment. But you're probably not very smart and very arrogant so you probably think you don't have any bias.
He was very careful with his words. I would agree that it was somewhat bias because he didn't want to hurt one or the other. Their has to be a good guy and a bad guy. And we all know who the bad guys are. Were no longer going to be able to touch a Benjamin Franklin. America is going rogue. I am keeping in mind that this was written 4 years ago. It's amazing what AI brings up on my phone. I'm only now understanding history. Although I took history classes but it was very shallow. They taught me what they wanted me to hear. Have you ever listened to Professor John Meirsheimer? I enjoy reading the chats!Helps me to expand my knowledge and vocabulary.
With China,Russia and iran forming, an Axis the most important thing we need to do is put America back together! Were unable to have our leaders conduct a congressional or senate meeting in an honest and civil discussion. This is what is wrong with our country presently! If we arent able to have compromise, we are done! 0ur enemies will destroy us!!!
The idea of destroying one another should not have come up to a rightful mind. Coexistence is the word we should more adhere to. Here you would find rich and poor, strong and weak lining side by side. What are you going to do? In helping the weak and poor you get stronger. At least you don’t smash the rich to enrich yourself. There’s always a super rich you have to accept. The more worrying is the rich-poor gaps going bigger and bigger. Certain ceiling tags should be introduced. The chinese saying there’s a fortune roller turn around, you have your time but of course you work for it, there’s no free dinner.
To clarify the South China Sea arbitration issue, China did not uphold the ruling because such ruling itself is not ligitimate. First of all, arbitration commitee has no jurisdiction over soveignty affair; secondly, China reserved her right， just like the other thirty countries did， to exclude China from any arbitration in relation to soveignty; thirdly, most countries never accept any international arbitration related to soveignty ，to name a few, US, UK, France, Russia. Stop disguising the truth and making groundless accusation.
Right on, Well said and documented realities.
There are obvious signs US Empire is in decline: 1) It is no longer the most powerful economy, nor the most technologically nor militarily advanced, 2) It is no longer a moral beacon. In fact, it has become the opposite: A source of evil, of conflict, of danger (pushed by the greed and desperate needs of the immoral Military Industrial Complex) wherever It goes, as it is happening now with NATO approaching russian bordes. It is hated abroad, with few exceptions. It has destroyed physically and morally several countries: Vietnam, Irak, Afghanistan, Libya. It has unilaterally withdrawn from signed treaties and since then its promises and signatures are no longer trusted. It is also afraid, with good reasons, to join the United Nations' ICC (International Criminal Court) specialized in war crimes, 3) It has become fully drug-addicted: Who has not tried (or continues using) narcotics there?, 4) There are clear signs of deep divisions, hatred among groups of citizens based con race, origin, income, ideas
Our Media/Government keeps us brainwashed, busy, in debt and at each others throats while the already wealthy flee with our blood and treasure...and nobody thinks to rebel.
Yep. The US and the UN use the term "spreading democracy" as an excuse to overthrown other country's who reset. The US Ambassador who was killed in Libya, Chris Steven's, worked for the UN prior to his appointed position.
Nice to see you here Otro (i see you often in comments and chats in Geopolitics in conflict channel)
@@elboon_80 Indeed, El Boon. Those 2 PhDs guys (and Elizabeth) of GeopoliticsInConflict represent the best of US citizens, many of whom I have known personally: Nice, knowledgeable, and above all, honest, fair... They run what I consider perhaps the best Geoplitics channel in UA-cam, along with Alexander Mercouris and The New Atlas of Briam Berletic... Not easy to find among all that western anti China&Russia MSM, just for the hugely profitable, mighty US MIC (Military Industrial Complex) which works so hard to keep the world away from PEACE !
@@efeocampo yeah. Totally agree with you on these points. I find it sometimes too depressing to listen to Brian Berletic… In the sense that the MIC and its ancillaries have had so much time and resources and it seems so difficult for these countries to break out… anyways, these channels have really brought me some relief.
Anyways, again… wanna say I am happy to see you here. Take care brother.
Let's hope so I'm sick and tired as an American citizen of having to pay for and defend people who despise me and stab me in the back any chance they get.
@JON ADAMS the world outside of Russia and China from Russia and China. Now if you don't know that you have the intellect of a baboon and that's why I'm going to meet you.
Like who?
As a Brazilian and a Latin , I feel humiliated and ignored by this great world the Prof reassures.
Brazil, similar to more than the rest of the Americas and 105 other countries across the world, is ignored and despised by this hegemon. Appeasement has not worked and neither has obedience. It has even encouraged this hegemon. Collective denial of its wishes remains as the only cure for this cancerous growth on human society. Resist them in every way possible and deny them the satisfaction they seek when they bully you.
As a global political economist, I see the world being divided into two blocs just like the East and West blocs during the cold war. But this time, it will be the West(liberal Order) on one side versus Russia and China(mixed and rich ideology-socialism, marxism, realism,&liberalism) on the other side. All other world countries will have to choose sides because there will be no room and tolererance for neutrality as neutral states will be considered untrustworthy. There will be two totally different world orders operating in the anarchic international system.
I don't believe it's over, not in the least, I believe we have let loose too much and we also financially crippled our most productive class, the working class. When you have to worry about working 3 jobs to survive, you don't have time to be creative and have children and the social cohesion needs to be unified.
You're contradicting yourself.
@@savagemako17 correct
This man truly challenges your assumptions. Ty for this. 🙏
Why does liberal/Lucifer order have to be exported to other countries that do not value this order/principle? Stop it at your borders. Under this order winner takes all (which US is interested in). It should be a multi-polar world where countries are free to choose and thrive.
At 1:12:00, the US wishes that CN allows "civil society more leeway". It will then see an opportunity to support the voices that are in line with its own agenda and will threaten CN with sanctions on the grounds of repression of civil society even if this voice represents a very small minority. It has its people on the ground in CN shaping the opinion/mindset with it false promises e.g. in HK. The US managed to fool the rest of the Western world with its spiel and the rest of the world should learn the lesson of the US hypocrisy. Today the rest of the Western world thinks they are ally (at par with US) while the reality is that they are its subordinates.
1:12:30 reason why not to take advise from your rival. Just saying.
I became a fan of this great professor. 👍
So am I Bro.!
Yessir 🇰🇷
Remember this: Becoming a fan of someone who is arrogant and has been a member of Washington Cabal, the Elites, does not speak very highly of who you are!
@@homayounshirazi9550 would you care to expand on what you imply?
This guy is brilliant - to think that he understood all of this way back in 2017! It is 2021 now, and I think that most of America is either STILL catching up, or will never fully understand this!
Meh. John the Apostle already understood all of this and a whole lot more in the year zero +30. He wrote a book about it. It's called The Revelations of John of Patmos. It's quite easily obtainable. It's the last book in the Bible. Useful reading if you want to know what's in store for us in this coming century. One world globalist government under the control of a certain fellow called the Antichrist. Truly terrifying stuff. But don't worry the book has a happy ending "IF" you joined the right team.
@Jeff Whitman for your 1st assertion, i guess my comment had reflected on it prior I saw your comment here (please refer to my other comment in the order of the newest), for which, meant his speech, I had a 7th instinct sense, of he's from some where, under the formally official tone, rather an analytical research. For your 2nd assertion, yes, Noam Chmosky has very much said so.
It's now 2022 and pandemic is still ravaging the rest of the world and Trump is a one term president where does his comments or opinion now stand? I grade him a B minus so is that fair ?
@@normanberg9940 kkg
@@normanberg9940 WHO ruined YOUR ability to think for YOURSELF. YOU are quoting from a book that is about 2,000 years old written by Jews most of whom may never have existed. What IF. Just what IF, there was never a Moses, Mary, Jesus, and any of the Apostles. What IF there are all old legends? Can YOU imagine it at all? The good news is that there was never
an antichrist. Lucky YOU.
This is very interesting information. Perhaps the much needed voice of reason for our times. Thank you for sharing.
9d9dd99dd9d9
How about America getting most of its famous scientists from Europe and other countries the last 75 years ?
Some of our scientists. The United States actually has produced many more great scientists than the rest of the world combined. Scientists come to the United States to study here and learn. we train the world!!
We teach the world.
American liberal hegemony and its expansionist policy of democracy to the entire world, from the very beginning, is wrong and has been a failure. I second John Mearsheimer in this regard for his very realistic approach.
China's soft power's impact is yet to be decided. The lady's question of America lying multiple times and deceiving the public has damaged the America's soft power is very meaningful.
Anyhow, with the rise of China, the unipolarity will vanish and that may result in a more stable system.
just as an imagination exercise, how do you envisage the second half of the 20th century would be without the rules based order promoted by the US?
What evidence do you have that bipolarity is more stable?
@@m1nty99 Can you count how many open wars involved major powers in the centuries previously to the WWII.
@@mustavogaia2655 my comment wasn't addressing you. I agree with your premise because it is empirically true
@@m1nty99 I've noticed. Maybe I write to fast. But I think we agree.
Frontiers are closed. No efforts will secure privileged American access to mineral resources in Eurasia (Afghanistan, China, Russia, Uzbekistan, etc.). We are slowly losing economic relevance to African resources. Without air power, Taliban won recently like Vietcong won 50 years ago. See? America's post-WW2 military modus operandi is overwhelming costs with almost no benefits. Americans will need to cultivate their gardens here in North America.
So true. America should spend its money at home for its people on education,health care and infrastructures instead of military expenses in trying to support corrupt governments elsewhere. Has US manage to institute democracy in countries it has bombed and interfered? Just look at Libya,Syria and Afghanistan.
@@slly4276 And after we lose, foreign militaries don't want to buy our expensive war toy "innovations." With "climate" foreign countries wants trains from China, not weapons from USA. Ours has become a multifaceted and cascading losing strategy.
the diagnosis is that of a failed state
@JON ADAMS Agree Chris Hedges is the sane voice compare to those loonies in DC
The vital point of the TRUTH is not been addressed here.
Very good event and very góod questions from the public
Dear Americans, friends, countrymen
Lend me your ears,
I came to bury USA, not to praise her.
Love it. And Thank You.
Did you hear this man condescending answers regarding china.
Sour grape and jealous transfixed in the US DNA. No one can ever better than me - a idiot.
What we are witnessing is a shift in America politics, from liberalism to a conservative ideology supported by the working-class and by those who were left behind by globalization...
And what is globalisation anyway except a single global government modelled on the European Union...the world ruled by unelected privileged persons....the destruction of nations and national identities.
Please end. Regular healthy nations again
Prof Nye has turned out wrong on many points made in this speech.
Posted from the Future.
Liberals always do, Mearsheimer would run circles around this fool.
Thank you.
Considering the theory of offensive realism, China’s obstacle for becoming a hegemon is the existence of the US in the Indo-Pacific region. So, from the perspective of Beijing, the US behaviors can be regarded as containment.
The theory predicts that China’s neighbors will seek to constrain it…
@@darbyheavey406 China's neighbors are constraining it, but not too tightly, as China is also their biggest business partner.
His talk can be summarized as one sentence. Whoever having innovations and technologies will have the world. China can have technologies but cannot surpass US unless it can unleash its innovation capabilities. It is very true.
But the US aren't the big manufacturers anymore. We can't compete on the world market with all the government agencies, permits and regulations it costs here. What good is having innovated capabilites if our government won't protect them and China keeps stealing them?
@@MelissaR784 , You sound so helpless! You can't even keep your secrets! How sad! I believe China stole the space station from USA?
@@MelissaR784 When US failed, it always needed a scapegoat to cover it's inevitable failures in every directions.
China has been innovating before many of us been born. It's silly to think they won't now.
ោះឿ
A highly educated and urbane ideologue. You can keep him, made more obvious with the passage of time, completely out of date even then. I dont have his knowlege but feel smarter in hearing his litinay of misconception. Thanks for that.
Great lecture
Please understand that Blame is for war ,
Please understand that give and take is for peace,
Please understand that war that last 20 years are built on lies and blame,
I think this professor make good impression only to Europeans. And if that is his best maybe he supposed to get a little bit more than 700 likes. And of course we can't see the 👎.
The professor and the question coming from the public were representing any aspects of life but the realistic aspect. I had a feeling he was not very happy with the US behavior as a super power. I think it all comes to whatever Margaret Thatcher said once. All that liberal order is gonna end when you run out of money. This is the case on one hand. All this world initiatives required support, a financial support. And US was paying for most of that world order so far. The problem is there is no more money. The US has printed about fourthy trillion dollars since Bush junior onwards. I guess this approach has been existed.
On the other hand to be a president you must say and maybe do something that is gonna get you elected. And Trump did exactly that.
The situation was good globally but Wich each year was getting from bad to worse for the Americans. Trump started to change that. He didn't became a president second term bur that doesn't change anything. Now Biden when it comes to international world order does everything Trump was about to do and maybe more. I was thinking he will reverse everything. He did not. I guess I was right in my thinking. It is not about left or right. It is about that there is no more money. The maintenance of the world order is expensive.
No one in the political circles in US is gonna tell out loud that US doesn't have any more money that is why we will withdraw. They are gonna tell you America first or Bring the jobs back. And that's the end.
I have a feeling that the more US is not paying for the world the less the world is gonna like it. But that's the reality.
The biblprophecy that the end of Anglo american empire is near read rev.17:10.
Ninety per cent of the owners of capital in London have their headquarters offshore. Jersey and the Caymans are the access gates to criminal capital in Europe and the UK is the country that allows it. ‘London is the most corrupt city in the world’.
R.Saviano
While both of Eastern nations we're Fighting the westerner nations single handedly.
Nye has written excellent books
He is a member of Elites of Washington Cabal who view everyone as irrelevant and inconsequential. His entitlement drips from his lips.
Years ago I was listening too the radio and heard a statement that America has a orderly liberty.
Powerful retaliation should be allowed once for ever.
As a legitimate scholar, I considered Mr. Nye, the bias view is inevitable as a American pundit. Painted the US pictures too rosing and promising is side track the realities for the public to be misguided and mis led.
Indeed a truly great intellect to be respected greatlly
What was practice as rule base order is WHAT IS MINE IS MINE, WHAT IS YOURS IS MINE
Better words 'Dictatorship'.
Let's support BRI and AIIB so that China can provide some public goods and avoid both traps.
This professor praising American soft power but conviniently avoid mentioning the 1% obscenely rich elites owning 90% of American wealth. Then he avoid talking about China BRI that help poor countries building infrastructures to spur economic activities. To him this is not soft power.
Yes, Joseph - but you are 'in de-Nye-al' and you know it !! Ignorance and Arrogance, without exception lead to the down fall of any system, particularly one that has been built on pretence rather than honesty. Being brothers ignorance and arrogance have been at the very foundation of USA politics - nationally and internationally - since its very beginnings and therefore seal its fate - further, anyone who builds him or herself up to a point of claiming to be 'The Best' is doomed from the get-go -- "PRIDE COMES BEFORE THE FALL" --
'de-Nye-al', that's a gd one ! lol
@@sashaa4412 ...and happens to fit ! Thanks for your feedback Sasha
The received talking points in one lecture. Convenient.
The British Empire : 25% World's Landmass, 25 % of Population. Thinkers, Planners, FSOs, Wise Minds, Wholistic Analysis . . . Wham ! All Gone. But we are so much smarter.
IF WE COULD ONLY BE SO LUCKY!
Yep and that is the beginning of the end of the USA. Order?
You could take all the economist in the world and lay them and on end, and they would still not reach a conclusion
I'm not sure that what you propose is how economists theorize. hehe.
Wonderful 💋 Presentation And Explanation.
What he meant by "Global Public Goods" are sticks and carrots which the US uses to keep other countries in their places, hence maintaining America's global dominance.
Very intelligent man, but as he said,, bet he is glad he didn’t bet his mortgage on it.
33:00 only using a country's military budget is a poor way of gauging how good and effective its military is.
This was pre-covid and I think maybe this is very different now with Russia plus China.
time to dissolve the judge and jury dominance of one country
That happened years ago.
I LOVE THE GREAT AND BEAUTIFUL AMERICA AND AMERICANS ❤️
WHAT?????!!!!!!!
Absolutely 👍
Still a very attractive nation...🧐🇺🇸
Change the Languages and Change the Educations and Change the Various Religious or Non-Religious thought processes -- You Completely Change the Order of Things! Fact Scientifica!
The speech of this guy is like a knife on meat... it parts the meat in two pieces and the two sides are correct acording to his point of view. USA is trying to rise India to contain China and the statistics and demographics he talks about are all based on UN studies. Its nice to hear this Prof. Joseph Nye.
The UN, Nato and EU reminds me of the Mexican Cartel.
I hope so. It is past time to move on past this.
It looks like the world is close to a WWI situation in that political structures of long-standing were breaking down namely the Ottaman, Austro-Hungrian, British, French, and perhaps the Russian empires. 5 empires went down during and in the aftermath of WWI.
A time of cons and liars not really a political platform. Elite few wanting all the wealth and power. Lawlessness rules.
@@1m2rich The end is near.
Where|ver = anywhere = di ma-na ma-na sa-ha-ja
dri|ve = pan-du
dri|ver = pe|(m)an-du
When people criticize the USA, I say people should start protecting their nation from outside threats. We protect the nations and our kids die, maybe the nations should start assisting us, just a thought
So when the usa goes into a foreign country are they not protecting there nation from outside threats ? Just a thought
You created the threats, maybe for a purpose. And nations were never at peace.
NOT AS LONG AS WE HAVE THE 2ND AMMENDMENT.
These must be the new star wars series episode one
I was disappointed in his fixation on Trump. He had sufficient reason to reference the leader of subject liberal hegemony, but his audience is capable of making value judgements.
*it's very simple,if you abide by absolte JUSTICE you'll rule the World forever*
Eustace Mullins "Rape of the Justice". American's Court is a Joke run by the Bankers.
@@joellis5915
*And verily, We had made a covenant with Adam beforehand, but he forgot, and We found in him no determination to disobey*
*And when We said to the angels, ‘Submit to Adam,’ and they all submitted. But Iblis did not. He refused to submit*
*Then We said, ‘O Adam, this is an enemy to thee, and to thy wife; so let him not drive you both out of the garden, lest thou come to grief*
*It is provided for thee that thou wilt not hunger therein, nor wilt thou be naked
And that thou wilt not thirst therein, nor wilt thou be exposed to the sun*
*But Satan whispered evil suggestions to him. He said, ‘O Adam, shall I lead thee to the tree of eternity, and to a kingdom that never decays?’*
*Then they both ate thereof, so that their shame became manifest to them, and they began to cover themselves with the leaves of the garden. And Adam observed not the commandment of his Lord, so his life became miserable.* Quran
Without God nothing lasts
America is Godless
Peace be with you
ua-cam.com/video/NQErICgt4SM/v-deo.html
I worry more about the rise of Trump than China 🤦♀
How can you discuss politics and military without looking at the economic stranglehold the corporation and oligarch has on either side? An interesting discussion but in this light almost a waste of time....
absolutely !
to U.S.'s end
it'll be in 22
He looks like the ultimate candidate to play Professor X in the next X-Men reboot lol
4 years old
Yesssssss gurrrrrrrllllll
I have less confidence in his view cover adequate scope coverage
God I hope and pray it does. Good fucking riddence
Wake up call for USA, Canada, UK Europe.
As of today , in May 2022, his predictions proved to be not on the mark. He has a clear vision and excellent analytical skills but became tunnel visioned in seeing the obvious.
The Roman Empire crumbled through decay and that is apparent in the US. Jan 6th, congress delaying the decision on debt limit which was clearly necessary to not go broke, size of debt, budgeting for negative propaganda on China.
A country of 200 over years trying to tell a country with thousands of years of civilization?
Any clear strategy? The fear of China rising is a direct product of its own propaganda.
AI prowess is not the limit of what has y been achieved but what has been done with it, G5 comm lags years behind China, infrastructure is crumbling, homelessness rampant, the middle class has not gained purchasing power in the last 4 decades. Inflation at 8.5% and rising
The writing is on the wall
Doesn't exactly work so well right now does it with Russia and China not buying into this concept.. Gas is going up and soon all goods will go up than they already have. To rely in this theory sounds nice but as our current situation with Russian, China not so well. Nationalism still has its place. I would say a balance between their "everyone get along" theory and nationalism is the better way to go.
Larry Summers a distinguished economist?!!!! When capitalism manufactures/employs “intellectuals”. I weep for this planet
When a evil man dig a trap for Uther's he will fall in it!!!
Oyibo Grand Unified Theorem
Big talk no action talking about hours about nothing bicouse the postman brings it social wellfare
Yes,We need,Tamil,DNA
Russia is self efficient in food, fuel, population growth, and defense is secure, soft power in Eurasia is beyond that of US. So how is Russia in decline? 🐸
Russia's economy and demography are in a quite serious decline, and should the price of oil go to and remain under $50/bbl then they are pretty much screwed since over 60% of it's exports are petroleum related and it accounts for over 30% of the GDP. As countries turn more and more towards renewable clean energy and clean nuclear, and as production from the U.S. Permian Basin continues to grow by multiples and production costs continue to decrease, Russia will find itself with ever shrinking revenues from energy and an ever aging population, that's a deadly combination.
look for Peter Zeihan lectures and you will see.
ТЫ ИЛИ БОТ ИЛИ НЕВЕЖДА...
РОССИЯ - НИЩАЯ УБОГАЯ ОКРАИНА КИТАЯ
РАБЫ!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Speed to 1.25, this guy is a slow speaker.
What liberal order?
" end of the American liberal order?" Who says there was actually one in the first place?
That is literally the first point he makes...
@@m1nty99 this is a lie he said for past 30 years world has been under American liberal order some countries directly some are indirectly but it was American liberal order.
Hell yes!
Pax Americanah means over one million US soldiers spread over 800 military bases in more than 70 countries. There is no other country under heaven with such awesome military and economic powers. Others are emerging but not as fast. US order will continue to accommodate China, Russia, India, EU, and Nigeria.
I agree with you. At some point, they say that Japan has the ability to triple the number of atomic bombs with the amount of uranium they have now.
By 2030 China will be twice the size of the USA with no wars or big military leaking away $1 trillion a year!
Not if they keep printing money like they are doing now.
Onakunle, But our imperial regime in Washington is borrowing between $1 and $3 trillion every year. This level of gross fiscal negligence is not sustainable, and our bloated military & war expenses are a major part of the problem.
@@Sam-tz8ou Free money to buy resources from the world. Of course US needs all the military, interference and subversion to keep this advantage to rip off the world.
Relax and You Do well
He says not to fear china's rising and yet they are being very nationalistic and forceful in the south China Sea.
Are you an american? If so maybe you should stop talking...
Any country would do the same if internationally renowned warmongering troublemakers, namely the USA is sailing close to your country. What China is doing defensively is perfectly understandable and reasonable in this context.
we the u.n. no. 56 engrant we of permits to all in opium,alcohols,bhang.as we see much that will stop as crimes. CRIME WILL COME DOWN IN THREE STEP THESES..BY TEN MILLION TIMES.SO WE DIRECT OUR INDIA TO START IT AS WORLD OF FIRST TO BE IN THIS,WE DEFINITELY WANT LOWEST PRACTICAL MARGINS TAKEN AS THAT WILL ALLOW BUSINESSES TOO CRIME TOO TO VIE EACH OTHER NOT .LIFE OF HAPPINESS WE WANT TO SEE.
Hegemony means dominance Chima was dominated by the US which is why the succumbed to friendship and the USSR was dominated by the US as 1991 proved.
Why shouldnt we dominate, we are in fact superior!!
Hard Power verse Soft Power = 得道多助，失道寡助
以前人8个字就说明白了的东西，
现在人写本书说这个道理
There is a date AND time after which every second American citizen and American secret agent started behaving like Rambo in the international political scene:: August 6th, 1945 :: The nuking of two cities. The American nuke bombs were built from exact Soviet drawings of the atom bomb designed in a nuclear facility in the European part of Russia by Soviet dissident scientists between 1937 and 1944, just east of Moscow. The smugglers were two former nuclear scientists who came to Washoington DC in about 1944 with Soviet drawings gifted to them by a Soviet dissident nuclear scientist or two working at the Soviet nuclear research facility somewher in the Soviet Union. Before August 6th 1945, there was no need to drain the swamp. No american official befoe august 6th 1945 tried to impose international gun control or Soviet control. Russian Fed says their military was conducting exercise near the border with Ukraine. Fewer Americans traveled abroad before ww2, and even among those Americans who did travel abroad, they had the Charles Lindbergh mindset of non intervention. Before ww2, the average American travelling as a foreigner in Europe used to be harassed when travelling abroad. Europeans used to say to any hapless American citizens travelling in Europe, "SO, when will you all elect your next native American President?", as the Frenchmen and Germans used to say to Americans before ww2. Americans during ww2 had to answer when racism will end and when American will elect a native American president, until America destroyed two cities. This gained respect for Americans in Europe. No more insults to Americans travelling abroad after ww2. America in it's present form, where everybody is a Rambo, intent on world dominance, and full of deep swamp people, was created by the Soviet Union. Soviet dissident scientists started designing the atom bomb starting in 1937, to defend Sakhalin islands in 1937. In 1944, two former nuclear scientists from central America visited Washington DC to give smuggled complete Soviet drawings and blast calculations and materials list of the Soviet atom bomb to the president of the United States in about 1944.President first hied radio tinkerer Marconi to head the "Build the Soviet atom bomb in America" project which started in 1944. The Soviet drawings of 1944 smuggled into America were clear enough that even Sadam Husain could have built an atom bomb. You see, before ww2, the average American couldn't show his face in world discussion groups, everybody used to laugh at an American entering the stage: look at this guy who had killed all the native Americans in the western hemisphere. Wherever an American showed up before ww2, the average Frenchman and average German would insult traveling Americans up to the day before Nagasaki and Hiroshima were destroyed. After this, the French and suddenly, the Germans along with the Americans started talking against Russian nationals wherever possible. all drawings and blast calculations and materials lists were to be given by dissident scientists of Soviet Union to the president of the United States after he gave them audience. They were to give their drawings and materials lists of the Soviet atom bomb to the President of America, "Nazi fighters and bombers may bomb this Soviet nuclear research site of the atom bomb research facility." The Soviet armed soldiers naming the telephones in side the nuclear research facility in the Soviet Union actually let the dissident scientist talk on the phone to former nuclear scientist living in central Europe or elsewhere, to help them smuggle the drawings of the Soviet tom bombs to America.
Thanks for the critical info. Secretary of State Mike Pompeo stated loud and clear the facts "We Lie, We Cheat, We Steal" fits the
realities perfectly.
It might be of a small value to ask Mr. Nye if he still thinks that US continues to enjoy the supremacy of singularity on the world stage. His unwillingness to assign a rank to US suggests his uncertainty to view events up to the present as the harbinger of the end of the US Hegemony. He tries to avoid identification with the narrative of the Washington Cabal, pretending that he is not a partisan when his record shows that he is.
Nice farry tale
No!