Why asking stupid question? Hamas already offer them to be released in return israel army must leave gaza immediately but israel government dont want it 😂 . Ask your bibi why he dont want it and that's why protesters protest
I cannot stand people who occupy privileged positions and groups who have convinced themselves that they are victims. When will all the Palestinian hostages be released? When will we get our land back? What about our homes that our fathers built! Where’s our right? The hostages will probably never return and not because Palestinians are hurting them, because we saw the treatment of those who were released, they were safe, but Israeli does not serve or care for the hostages… over a year there is no tunnels and no hostages! All lies! Ask Israeli government to free everyone!
Yes, it is absolutely immoral to pander to Palestinian virulently antisemitic fantasies of getting rid of the Jews, helping Palestinians brush the terrible failings of Palestinian society under the carpet.
Yes and no. He did ask it as whether Israel should do so, but they all live with the reality that Israel has besieged the Gaza Strip. So they control the flow of goods, and lack thereof. The main rebuttal was either screw em or we don't want Hamas to get food. Neither of which are compatible with allowing food as aid into the Gaza Strip.
And? Regardless of the question, "Israel" is OBLIGATED under international law to provide food, as well as facilitate and guarantee protection of other organisations providing food. "Israel" is an occupying power and as such has a legal and moral responsibility to provide food, healthcare, water and electricity to Occupied people. The people answering show exactly why "Israel" is the problem. They've been illegally occupying for decades and still see themselves as the innocent victims. Everything they accuse Gazans and other Palestinians of, they themselves do. They do it in Occupied Palestine, they do it in Occupied Syria, they did it in Occupied Lebanon, they do it everywhere they go. These same people don't seem to grasp that if you illegally occupy people, hold thousands of them hostage for years, place an entire territory under complete seige, "mow the lawn" every year as a specific policy and terrorise them routinely, they WILL eventually hit you back in a brutal way. That's not justifying the loss of any innocent people on Oct 7, it is stating that Oct 7 could not and would not happen without all the above things happening.
Mind Begs the Question: ▪︎If a Semitic/Israeli Politician announced ▪︎Stopping Food,Water supplies ▪︎Charged with Crime of Starvation ▪︎Anti-Semitic or Pro-Law?
who in their right state of mind in any war would feed their enemy to ensure the war goes longer and their soldier keep dying.. for some reason the Jews are expected to do that... our hostages got no red cross and no meds and no one cares for their plight..
then tell the zionists to give the palestinians their homes back and to stop bombing them. bb made it clear he is not going to end the war so ur nonsense is just that nonsense
@@learningmode293countries are not responsible for non citizens. Israel is responsible for the Israelis, including Jews and Arabs. Israel is not responsible for Palestinians or Gazans, who are not Israeli citizens
SHOULD EGYPT OPEN THE BORDER? Should we have different standards for Europeans? Did Poland, Romania, Moldova, Slovakia keep their borders shut to UKRAINIANS fleeing the war? Gazans can thank the Egyptians for keeping the border closed to them. We all know that Hamas terrorists will get the aid, not the children or pregnant women. FREE THE HOSTAGES!
@@RedewaanJacobs When are you going to call out the brainwashing in palestinian schools? Still waiting for a pro-pal to even acknowledge that. I saw what they broadcast on their TV channels, did you?
@@tsopuaifa Yahya Sinwar AUTOPSY were found he hasn't eaten for 3 days and he only carried a Mentos mint candy with him. So WTH is Hamas control the food? The Gaza borders are control by your IDF. How on earth Hamas are at the borders taking control the food in? I swear all Israelis are BRAINSWASHED to the point there will be no cure.
0:54 they don’t deserve it ??? While holding you’re own child that you still have the audacity to say that a child don’t deserve some food but when you say something about them it’s anti semitic bla bla
if you want to give food, give food. it's not far fetched for people during wartime not to strengthen their enemies. and it's not even the people who get the food. Hamas robs most of the trucks... come look for yourself, instead of being high and mighty from afar like the keyboard hero you are
@@gustafa2170 chosen people means chosen to carry the burden of the commands from god... It's like being the kid who's told to take out the trash, it's not being better or something, but a carrier of responsibility. not something an antisemite A-rab would not anyways...
@@HonorOP As the chosenite Yoav Gallant said himself: "No food. No fuel. No Electricity. We are fighting human animals." In practice, not in theory, the chosen people is clearly defined. The chosen think they have the right to starve a population and commit genocide
@@fgerlits ohhh now i get it! But he really does deserve this amount in dollarbills... He makes more effort to understand both sides more than any president of the United States!
Withholding food and other basic necessities must never be used as a weapon, especially against civilians. This war has to end. I'm Israeli and that's my take.
israel must end its illegal occupation of palestinian land, and it must return settlers' homes to their original owners. with this, there would be no reason for resistance
Even if you saw the death with you’re own eyes it does not give you a reason to say “ Gaza should not exist” that is literally genocide on 2.2 million people
She has death in her eyes for all gazans. Sure, she's traumatized. You think Palestinians aren't? That lady was the very monster she said she saw over a year ago. It's straight up nazi shit, y'all are disgusting fascists.
why are you compasionate to her, she chose to live in an illegal occupation, she chose to go to a festival near the open air prison that is gaza. would you go live in the buffer zone between south korea and north korea?
No country is responsible for another's citizens or food. America was not expected to feed Afghanistan or Iraq. You are not required to feed the enemy.
Huh? US provided aid to every population we occupied, including Việt Nam, Japanese and German. It’s standard for us, and compliant with international law of armed conflict. Ask someone who served.
No. But you are required to follow international law. Israel is illegally blocking food and aid, to the people they are illegally occupying. Forced, intentional starvation is a war crime.
@@twinklemagic024 Israel isn't "illegally blocking" anything. Any country has its right to block any aid that could benefit his enemy when in state of war. Unfortunately, the few aids that Israel has allowed to enter have been robbed by Hamas. So it's very understandable and strategically favorable to stop bringing more aid when at the end it would be ended in the hands of the enemy. Secondly, Israel hasn't been occupying Gaza since 2005. So don't make false statements. Now, planned genocide against a state? That's a war crime. And Israel is making sure that Hamas pays for it. If the "Palestinians" don't want to cooperate with bringing justice to Hamas and instead cooperate with them, then they cannot play the victim in this conflict.
Very bad question as no one asks Israel to feed Gazans. Way enough food is sent by international aid. The sole interesting question is "Should Israel let food enter in Gaza", as the IDF blocks the entrance of intenational aid for food and most of all medical supplies. That is why Israel is accused under international law of intentional mass starvation of civilian population. Nobody asks Israel to feed Gazans, asks them the good question.
Israel is letting trucks in you are just a delusional little man that think otherwise even if there are evidences of that but why agree with facts? Let’s change reality to fit our narrative you freaking idiot
Nobody asks Russia to feed Ukraine and they didn’t suffer a terrorist attack. Israel lets food and aid trucks in daily (not to mention stop the war to give polio vaccines to Gazans). Sometimes in Gaza people steal the aid trucks. Those people are called Hamas. Demand that they allow ordinary people to have access to aid provided internationally and let in by Israel.
@@littlecatfeet9064 Provide evidence of the following: 1. Daily Trucks Israel is letting in 2. People in Gaza 'stealing aid trucks'. 3. Hamas stealing aid trucks. I await.
Quite a few people said yes, and they know that if the situation was reversed Gazans would not give them a sip of water and most of the world wouldn’t even care.
תחזרו את האנשים שלנו לשער של המצרים התקבלו אוכל מה הבעיה מאה אנשים תמימים חולים זקנים נשים וילדים חטפתם אין לכם רחמנות רצחתם ישלידים שלנו ואתה מדבר על ילדים שלכם 😂 אין לכם בושה אין לכם בושה
Israel is the one giving most of the food, so the question is: when will you start seeing the truth for yourself? Food came mostly from Israel but also from places like Jordan, Dubai, Egypt and more
@@NaJAl-v2l This is not a lie, about 200 trucks come into Gaza daily from 5 main passages: Zikim, Erez, Kerem Shalom, 96, and 147. Israel does not block the food and also gives fuel and other resources. Hamas takes most of it. You can see footage of coordinated attacks on trucks with weapons by Hamas. Try to say I'm lying one more time Ahmed, we all know your games. It's over.
@@bogumilaskowron2680sad that it seems to be impossible for you to see the pain and suffering on both sides. With mentality of comparing pain/ dismissing pain, no better future will ever come to the land
It was never about Hamas…..it’s all about the Trillions of dollars in Gas and Oil. The IDF has killed all of the hostages and ISRAHELL has thousands of Palestinians civilians as prisoners in their captivity…torturing, raping,and killing innocent civilians. ISRAHELL needs to get out of the Middle East and go back to Europe where they belong. Genocidal killers and the world is right by that. It’s only a matter of time before they spread across the world….Gods chosen people of killers…that’s what they are.
@@ajrhy6243if you are going to justify the actions of those who initiated or supported the violence that directly sparked the war you aren't part of the problem you symbolize it.
The way Corey spoke to the Nova survivor was really not acceptable in my opinion. It felt aggressive, lacking in compassion, and re-traumatizing. I'm horrified. Baruch Hashem, she survived.
The last woman was super smart. I think she is right. Hamas doesn't care about their people. The more hunger, the better for Hamas. So aside from any moral arguments, providing food to Gazans actually hurts Hamas, so Israel should do it.
@@texasdude1 What lies? Hamad has literally stated on tv that taking care of Gazan civilians is not their job or responsibility. What rock have you been hiding under
Hamas knows Israel would not do that , thats why it attacked . it knows Israel creates its own insecurity when it hurts the Palestinians and Denies them their rights , then Hamas gets even more support and the cycle continues , so if we take that woman's logic to its very end , then Israel should give back the Palestinians their territory , release the people its holding in prison and any other injustices like that , then obviously Hamas would not have any reason to exist .
As an Israeli: I don't want people to starve. But being expected to supply your enemy during war is ridiculous. I don't want people to starve, but I also didn't want to be attacked so...
You are not at war with them as equals, you are their occupiers. You have legal obligations to the well-being of the Palestinian people. Your comment speaks to the extent in which Israelis have lost the plot.
I am not Jewish. I have seen reports, not one report, of how the Palestinians in Gaza receive food from the United Nations and then sell it on the black market. There are women from Gaza who cook kunafeh and musakhan. In general, the Palestinians in Gaza have big bellies and are overweight, unlike Sudan. They do not need food. They are sad now that their cause does not bring them asylum and monthly salaries as it did before the war.
The framing of the question is revealing of intent. It could have also been framed as - "Should Israel have the power to control entry of food into Gaza?"
Israel has the right to control its borders. Groups can negotiate the management of whatever borders it might share but that occurs by way of agreement.
@@SnowsStorm1Israel is not just controlling its borders, but the borders of Palestine, and they have been illegally restricting humanitarian supplies. Even before the war, Israel's control of Palestines borders is what perpetuated its occupation despite exiting Gaza.
Mind Begs the Question: ▪︎If a Semitic/Israeli Politician announced ▪︎Stopping Food,Water supplies ▪︎Charged with Crime of Starvation ▪︎Anti-Semitic or Pro-Law?
did you know that IDF took control over Gaza/Egypt border only around 7 months after the start of the war? How come they had a fully independent border with Egypt and were accusing Israel of starvation?
@ there is no legally formed Palestinian state so you have no borders and even to the extent that you believe you do those borders do not supersede Israeli borders. The only way you move beyond such issues is to negotiate the way in which areas of joint influence might be managed. That can only occur if and when the Arabs are open to compromise.
Tamir is incorrect because this is not a war between two countries. Gaza is an occupied territory and nothing gets nothing without the approval of the occupying power. Also see Geneva Convention IV.
Israel literally left gaza in 2005 until gazans elected hamas and hamas started firing rockets into Israel. The only difference is Israel controlled there borders to protect there citizens like any other country, billions of international aid from Europe went to Gaza and Hamas as the government only used them for under ground tunnels.
The question wasn’t phased right. Israel has not provided any food to the Gazans, all food has come form outside aide and Israel blocks Gaza’s border to Egypt. The question should have been should Israel continue to block the aide trucks? Remember it’s Hamas that feeds the hostages. The first hostages that came out said they were only fed once a day. Hersh Goldberg was 100 lbs when he died. If you don’t care about innocent children dying of starvation, then you are not true to your religion.
It's not our responsibility to feed the enemy, and the hostages appreciate that we put our safety first, If I was a hostage , I would choose the safety of the Jewish nation over my freedom
@@Itsdifferent-wv4jo You do not get the issue because is in the news in the entire planet except in Israel: Israel block the aide trucks. This is how genocides are done.
What is this comment full of lies: Israelis collected trucks of do food & aid donations during this year. Lots if volunteers working, the heck you are writing here.
The Palestinians in Gaza were given working farms after the Jews there were forcibly removed during a unilateral peace deal of withdrawing from Gaza in 2005. It was a good gesture but the Gazans destroyed the farms and dug up the irrigation pipes to repurpose into rockets. During this war, the IDF suspended operations (Hamas and Hezbollah sent rockets still) to vaccinate Gazans against polio. That was a good gesture as well. In any clash with Gaza and the West Bank, Israel sends text messages to “civilians” (really everyone since Hamas hides behind civilians) warning them that they’ll enter an area in two weeks, then one week then 24 hours. They also drop leaflets with the same warning. They put their own soldiers at risk to create humanitarian corridors for civilians. I think that’s a great gesture to the Palestinians, if not good for them. None of the above things have worked. Hamas, Hezbollah, the Houthis etc don’t want kindness. They want to destroy the Jewish state. And they’re letting food in of course, so they’re doing everything other armies won’t do. Hamas would certainly never do that. Don’t forget that Yayha Sinwar, architect of the October 7 atrocities, was in Israeli prison for killing fellow Gazans. Israeli doctors saved his life there when he had brain cancer and he vowed he’d kill all Jews anyway. He made good on his word when Hamas kidnapped the nephew of the doctor who saved his life and then executed him. Maybe Egypt, whose blockade fence of Gaza’s is bigger and more impermeable than Israel’s, could be the humanitarian heroes of Gaza. Unlikely, but it’s a thought.
Those are valid points but I always hear many Israeli saying Palestinians are all brought up to hate Israelis or become terrorists whatever but many might not grow up to hate them so much if they tried do an act of good to them right now amongst the constant bombardment. Also now that this war that is been noticed and condemned by people all over the world by people that don't even have basic knowledge of the region and many of whom are just using it to fuel their own hateful agenda it is just creating unprecedented levels of hatred towards Israelis and non Israeli Jews unfortunately. There are no winners the way things are going.
@@Karl-bw8rpThey are fed with hate since day 0, I feel sorry for those children, but our safety comes first, we need to be protected from any potential dangers, Palestinians can be happy and free away from the land of Israel, Europe is big they can move there
Hi I am an Israeli so I would like to answer also: Yes, but it depends on a lot of factors. of the top of my head here is a few of them: 1. Israel does not need to pay for their food, We will not feed the enemy with our own money. The aid will come from outside. 2. Israel will not let any unnecessary food enter, Such as watermelons and pineapples. Mainly not from Israeli companies with our own money. 3. We should make sure that the aid that comes from outside is not getting into hamas hands, Almost all free aid now is getting sold at Gaza markets for high prices by hamas and they are profiting big time. I'm sure theres more factors but that's just from the top of my head.,
@DanielMartinez.88first you are Mexican so you have no right to dictate what we may or may not fund with American resources and second you would still be wrong.
@@someguy1712 It does not depend on your personal opinion what starving persons need. When you get only "necessary" food like water and rice over a longer timespan you will become malnutritioned too.
its horrifying how people who have never been to war and are consuming one sided propaganda are shouting bs to the air and comments. both sides are to blame and its hypocritical to think otherwise
have you not watched the entire video?????You literally had Israelis showing sympathy for gazans meanwhile showing valid concerns that if they keep giving aid, hamas will steal them and get stronger!!!!!!!!
The artificial distinction between Hamas and ordinary Gazans is sickening. "Hamas represents the deepest ethos of the Palestinians." - Dr. Einat Wilf Gaza's children are not Israel's problem, or the international community's problem: it is Gaza's problem, and they have to try to solve it, by making peace with Israel. 1:24 How do you know what "Jewish values" are? Virtue-signalling. If Israel would not have provided humanitarian aid, the hostages would have been home after a week. 7:25 You're not starving them. Gaza needs to give up its plan to end Israel, if it's so worried about its children. Besides, there most certainly are laws in war: Israel has no obligation to provide aid at all; if someone else wants to provide aid, Israel is allowed to block aid if it might help enemy combatants. The bloc knows it can pressure Israel into being merciful; if Israel would stand its ground nothing would happen.
Israel has obligation provide food because israel is occupier .It is not war it is genocide.Hostages would be in home if israel do deal with hamas.And there are thousands Palestinan hostages
All you have to do is watch a documentary on what the Germans in WW2 believed about those they considered human animals at that time and how they treated them to see that history has repeated itself, Israel is the updated version of WW2 Germany with the US, UK and the EU along with others fully complicit in their actions.
@@niels3138-d2r Numbers, Israel is not self-sufficient in food. No food to give to anybody. The world is sending food to Gaza, and the occupiers are taking the food or letting it spoil.
That brave Nova survivor clearly triggered and still haunted by October 7th. O how I wish love and life on her and peace. It may take years or decades but one can heal ❤ its a possibility. And one I desire for her very very much. One will never forget but one can heal. Speaking as somebody who had ptsd from party watching a homicide as a child. Much love dear woman, so much love. ❤
@@fahmidarahman8688nonsense. The Arabs began the violence in 1920 and formally attacked in 48. If occupation were the cause of Arab violence how did all that violence occur well before any such environment ever existed
@@fahmidarahman8688oh is that why the Palestinians started the nakba themselves with the bus bombing that took place the day the partition plan did not go how they wanted? Is that why they threw a tantrum and chose violence, and got their just desserts?
"Half of the Palestinians Are Egyptians and the Other Half Are Saudis" - Hamas Minister of the Interior and of National Security Fathi Hammad Why aren't Egypt and Saudi Arabia providing the Gazans food and shelter? Why does only Israel need to provide the needs of the people who launch rockets at them?
Thank you for showing the true psyche of Israeli society. October 7 justifies everything. The Palestinians should just politely and obediently accept the ethnic cleansing that has been happening to them for over 70 years.
The real question you should be asking is is right for Israel to stop food and water--given by other nations-from going into Gaza-a concentration camp created by the Israelis. And while their hostages should be released, they should also release the 3000 Palestinians held in Israeli prisons without charge even before the war-and let Gazans have their freedom and stop “mowing the grass” by bombing Gaza every few years. Where is their humanity??
@@shainazion4073 it is a closed enclave surrounded and controlled by the Israeli military since at least 2008-no one can get out without Israeli permission to go back to their native lands in other parts of Palestine-if they fish in their own sea without Israeli permission they get shot at-and it is a place where Palestinians are concentrated after being kicked off other lands where the Israelis have taken over, and read any human right reports-much of the population was destitute even before the war because of Israeli occupation not allowing free economic activity. A few rich people in the enclave doesn’t make it any less of a concentration camp-it is one even according to Isreali government officials
@@sabeenamalik1663Surrounded by Israel? Are you sure about that? You don’t think maybe there’s another country blockading Gaza and that said country maybe has a reason? But no one goes after that country nor its unwillingness to take in any Gazan refugees.
Geneva Convention IV Article 55 - Food and medical supplies for the population To the fullest extent of the means available to it, the Occupying Power has the duty of ensuring the food and medical supplies of the population; it should, in particular, bring in the necessary foodstuffs, medical stores and other articles if the resources of the occupied territory are inadequate.
The same people continuously inhabited that place, from Canaanites to Hebrews to first Christians; most converted to Islam under Arab rule. Now, they are under the occupation of immigrant Jews (those Jews are native to other parts of the world; their ancestors somehow converted to Judaism). The food is not from Israel; it is what the whole world is sending to the native people of the Holy Land, the Palestinians.
Oh here we go again with another propaganda🙄. Israelis (not all) are native to the land you know why because Judaism is ethno religion, jews have been a diaspora and this includes Ashkenazi jews who dealt with racism in europe historically. It's not very clear if palestinians are indigenous since Arabs mass immigrated to that land under the Ottomans when jews were building economy. Jews weren't the only people immigrating to the land. Either way Jews always had presence in that land wether if they became majority or minority by many empires who conquered that land.
@@hermithefrog629 And that shows that Arabs rule the place without expulsing the population out of the land. Now, we have a ruler/occupier who is trying to take the history and identity of the Palestinians, not only the land.
I don't think there is any war where a country is expected to provide food for the enemy population. Has never happened. What Israel should have done though, is to facilitate aid coming in by non involved organisations.
If then the main bulk goes to Hamas, and what is left, they are selling to their population in the markets, Israel should have provided evidence to the UN
She did not say they did not deserve food she said that it is not the responsibility to provide it. Have you ever considered that her opinion may well have been informed by the loses she herself experienced as the result of Hamas. For all you know her family member was killed that day
She should thank god she wasn't born in gaza but in a privileged place. She's going out shopping with the child and then maybe she'll go home and live her beautiful life there. Buying food and all to provide for themselves. Mothers in Gaza are in danger of being killed, they live in a tent (literally) in the middle of the street, they struggle to provide food and all this while these idiot Israelis talk nonsense.
No her kid will grow up just as heartlessly tarnished as his mom. Im sure they teach this in their schools also. Hell their holy book tells them its ok to be heartless because they are the chosen ones.
It doesn’t matter what these people think. As an occupier Israel has the obligation to deliver them food and all other essential goods. Otherwise Israel needs to get out there and stop denying the people their freedom. It’s that simple and the icj made it clear this year in July with their decision on Palestine. People need to educate themselves. Or does international law doesn’t apply to them??
@@frankozrin5611 Israel is the occupier of Gaza according to international law. It was before they started slaughtering ten thousands of human beings, and now it is responsible as an occupier by all military means.
This statement is based on a false idea that Israel is occupying Gaza. Israel is occupying Gaza as much as Egypt does - it simply has a border. If Egypt is not obligated to provide for Gaza, then neither is Israel.
"In such a situation, the person who has committed the crime is entirely responsible for their actions, and there is no legal or moral obligation for you to take care of their family, especially if they have harmed you or your loved ones. It would be understandable if you felt no responsibility toward their family, as they are not the ones who have wronged you." By chatGPT
As an American I feel no responsibility in helping such an entitled group of people do their dirty work. Good luck these next few decades, guys. Christ is King.
@@trevorrogers95 One reason America is so great is by doing things like helping Israel. Believe me, the U.S. gains much more than it gives. If there was no benefit, they wouldn't do it. So don't be naive; this is how countries operate
Did you mention the part where Gazans have no means to acquire their own food because Israel blockades all trade, or are you pathetically trying to validate your genocidal views through a large language model?
Does anyone else think that it is difficult not to remind oneself that these well-fed, well-clothed people in front of departmental stores are pontificating about homeless individuals less than couple of hours away dying of hunger, diseases and bombing with no hope of escape?
these currently homeless people had made their choices...by voting Hamass, and participating in the massacre of the Jews... that is not enough not to care
Have you not watched the survivors in this video about nova music festival or people in this video who did show sympathy for gazans? is every well fed, well clothed people expected to feel sympathy for people who participated in terror/suicide bombing attack and celebrates it?
It just shows how they and other pro-genocide people don't really care about the hostages. If all food stops going in. The hostages will also starve to death 🤦♂️
@@Thenoobestgirl And did you forget when some of the hostages were released and they did not appear to be starved at all? Just admit you don't care about the hostages
Just admit you are a filthy antosemite and that no matter what Israel would do YOU will never be satisfied!! So none of the efforts to minimize casualties ever registers in your brain! No huh? Coz you are too busy hating all jews and just want to continue doing so at any excuse. Israel is not obligated to feel the enemy! The very one that tried to kill it!
The Israelis have been providing hundreds of trucks a day of food aid but the UN has been unable to see them delivered to the Gazans as Hamas are hijacking them as soon as they enter Gaza and selling it to the people at exorbitant prices.🇦🇺🇮🇱
Wow I never saw a “war” like this! People in restaurants, shopping, on bikes having walks… that mother of Satan who said even children should b starved while she has a kid in a stroller absolutely disgusting human
What kind of question is this? Should we give someone foods after we occupied them and put embargo on anything and everything? Those people are so cruel and they are finally showing their true colours.
If you check the registers of COGAT or the POLIO vaccination plan, you will see that what you have been convinced by propaganda is not the reality of facts.
So far from being persecuted, the A b -- dul - s have crowded into the country and multiplied until their population has increased more than even all world Jw ‘ ry could lift up the Jewish population." -Winston Churchill
This video is exactly why I love this channel and project you're doing Corey! Diverse nuanced thoughtful answers from real people living this nightmare situation. I hope those here in the west can see this and if they want to wade in and have opinions about this conflict they can try to be as reflective and sensitive as those in this video
Should Russia give food to the Ukraine? Should Iran give food to Israel? Should North Korea give food to South Korea ? Should Ukraine give food to Russia? Should Hamas give food to Israel?
The question of food does not arise with Russia / Ukraine because Russia is not besieging Ukrainian civilians - Russia is not able to and perhaps does not want to besiege Ukrainian civilians. Also it is not a war because a war has two armies (like Russia vs Ukraine) - here there is only army - Israel - who uses tanks / jets etc to bomb civilians living in tents. The question is not should Israel supply food, it is should Israel allow food supplied by charities, UN etc or should Israel enforce a medieval type siege / blockade where civilians starve.
@@jurnet9 1/israel is not besieging gaza, gaza also has a border with egypt 2/ this war was not started by israel but by hamas, the “legal” authority in gaza 3/ it's the material used by israel to defend itself that conditions aid to the population, where did you see this rule? 4/ it's hamas that confiscates the teeth supplied by israel and uses them against its own people. 5/no one is starving to death in gaza
And who's funding you with gaz idiot ? Wasn't that Jordan itself where their citizens got too mad cuz their gov was able to do but couldn't feed their so called brothers in Islam till after three months of blocking? When Israel said no water no food no electricity! Remember that?!
Out of responsibility I say no, Israel has no responsibility to provide food for the people who have carried out a brutal attack to them last Oct 7. However out of love I say yes, because the Bible says love you enemies and pray for those who persecute you. Gazans must thank Israel even though the supply is not that sufficient but Israel tried their best to alleviate their hunger and provide their basic needs. I didn't hear Russia giving food and aid to Ukraine.
The way you triggered the Nova survivor's pain is boldly unethical. You also did not express any compassion on the spot. Sorry, I can see that this was not your intention, but this looks very cruel.
@Femmeaesthetic Stfu Yoav Gallant - "There will be no electricity, no food, no water, no fuel. Everything is closed. We are fighting human animals and we are acting accordingly."
@Femmeaesthetic Yoav Gallant -There will be no electricity, no food, no water, no fuel. Everything is closed. We are fighting human animals and we are acting accordingly."
In no war in the world has there been a case where a post that was attacked had to provide food and water for the side that started the war, not my problem, bring in the hostages and then we'll talk about humanitarian aid.
the idea of Israel giving anyone humanitarian aid is hilarious, Israel doesn't give anything to anyone, where are you on the world's donor country list, 210?
Yea, call me crazy but if you are a state that has a sliver of land on its side filled with the most intense poverty of the world that (even before the 10/7 terrorist attack) you seal off by land, sea and air - and you proclaim you are the savior of the western world and a world powerhouse- you better supply that population with survival mechanisms when necessary. Its almost like a strip of land that adjourns one of the most powerful states on earth, where people can't swim out to sea, or leave the land (without a work permit) or even go to an airport (wealthiest Gazans , it could be a 2 week journey to an airport prior to 10/7), in this thing called life- that environment has and will always grow terrorism.
@@trevorrogers95 Well, we survived 3700 years without your help and we will survive without it, but it turns out that we are the best of friends and my enemy is yours and he will come and go. You have an interest in helping me, and Trump understands this very well.❤️✡️❤️✝️❤️🇮🇱❤️🇺🇸
In an interview with Democra TV, former Israeli chief of staff and defence minister Moshe "Bogie" Ya'alon accused Israel of engaging in "ethnic cleansing" in the northern Gaza Strip.
Abduls would have sat in the dark forever had not the jw ‘ sh engineers harnessed the Jordan river for electrification. Now they swarm into Ptown seeking the light." - Winston Churchill
Well they should have thought about consequences before starting a war , dont u think ?! .. Its not israels responsibility to feed them but it does it bec israel values life and have morals
Only if they revoke their allegiance to Israel 's destruction. Einat Wilf says that northern Gaza can be a place where individuals one by one will need to sign something accepting Israel and denouncing violence and surrendering.
@@bogumilaskowron2680 Have you read the Hamas charter lmao? Yeah I would want my borders sealed tight too if I had neighbours who had a written goal in their constitution to wipe out my people... By the way, don't forget Egypt played a huge role in enforcing the blockade. If Egypt had been relaxed about letting them in, no one would have been 'trapped' there. It's as simple as this: Gaza had borders with 2 countries, Israel and Egypt. Both those countries have a right to control their borders. If you want your neighbours to let you in, maybe don't elect a 7th century nutjob fundamentalist government with g33n0cid41l ambitions and they might be a bit warmer to you...
This whole conversation assumes 1) there are mostly innocent people in Gaza, 2) that they’re actually starving, and 3) that a military is obligated to make it more difficult for itself to win a war (or rather said, that Israel shouldn’t be allowed to simply win a war). None of these statements are based in truth or morality. At this point, Israel has every right to decimate Gaza and its people, reabsorb the land into its territory, allow the so-called refugees to experience actual refugee-hood, and never look back.
Learn what decimate means (to reduce by 10%). Israel had surpassed that in the first week. You’re on the wrong side of history, supporting war crimes. It may be years or decades but, you’ll know & feel bad later, typical “shoot & cry.”
You islamnazim occupied us jews what Palashtina mean why rome empire that stole Israel judah kingdom named Israel in another name Palashtina you just lie and make fake country
Islam teach many bad, DECIEVING their believers, look what happened even now. many Arabs had been scam by their belief in Islam, they believed Israel belongs to them and always do bad things to their neighbors.
Why israel should provide them food? They have border with egypt, ask them to tranfer them food, israel is in war with gaza, yoh dont take care of your enemies, esoecially when 100 hostages are are still held in hamas tunnels
Israel provides an abundance of food to Gazan Palestinians but they have told the Israel press in Gaza that Hamas beat Palestinains, even shoot them to force them to give up any food and water they have and leave them with nothing. There is a video that proves this.
On the one hand, I really agree with this sentiment. On the other hand, what moral responsibility do these civilians bear for these terrorists? - The civilians elected the terrorists.And if the Palestinian Authority's refusal to hold elections is any indication, those civilians would do it again. - Most of the civilians support the terrorists' struggle against their common enemy, if not their methods (though a very large portion of them do support those methods). - The aims of the terrorists (a Palestinian state on all of the land and the Israelis gone) are pretty much what the vast majority of the civilians want. - The hatred towards the enemy within the civilian population is what makes it impossible for moderates to rise to power there politically, and what leads the most radical people in the population to become terrorists in the first place. The terrorists and the civilians are not fundamentally different in their views and their feelings, except when it comes to violence towards innocent civilians (even then, they have no love for the victims of the terrorists). - The civilians celebrated the actions of the terrorists which led to the war, or denied them. - The civilians refuse to rise up against the terrorists, or to collaborate with the ones fighting them (since they are "the enemy"). - The civilians are so strongly socially/culturally pressured to support the terrorists and hate the enemy that they could be killed for speaking any heterododox opinion. And not only or even mostly by the terrorists - by the other civilians. So what responsibility do they have for the terrorists? To what degree are they morally liable to suffer for the acts of the terrorists that they agree with and make inevitable?
@@Femmeaesthetic The people who didn't say no all are satisfied with the status quo, which is to starve the population. I didn't see a single person say an unqualified yes or express horror that their government fails to allow food or aid through.
And yet the high obesity rates in Gaza haven’t gone down. Their women are some of the fattest on the planet, prime example, Sinwar’s wife with or without her $32,000 Hermes bag. No wonder; they’re getting on average over 3,000 calories per day which is hell of a lot more than those in surrounding areas get.
I don't think we are paying for the food it's mostly payed by the world's donations, but we control the borders so if we don't allow it to enter it's a a WC and b it's starving millions of people
Now ask Palestinians if the hostages should be returned.
fr
Why asking stupid question? Hamas already offer them to be released in return israel army must leave gaza immediately but israel government dont want it 😂 . Ask your bibi why he dont want it and that's why protesters protest
@@zmc2585 lol. Why should israel leave gaza?
Why should israel even agree to be blackmailed by hamas?
They say: let's exchange the hostages. Human beings against human beings ❤
I cannot stand people who occupy privileged positions and groups who have convinced themselves that they are victims.
When will all the Palestinian hostages be released? When will we get our land back? What about our homes that our fathers built! Where’s our right? The hostages will probably never return and not because Palestinians are hurting them, because we saw the treatment of those who were released, they were safe, but Israeli does not serve or care for the hostages… over a year there is no tunnels and no hostages! All lies! Ask Israeli government to free everyone!
This comment section is absolutely horrendously disgusting. Some people's moral compasses are beyond repair.
Maybe they never had a moral compass to start with!
Yes, it is absolutely immoral to pander to Palestinian virulently antisemitic fantasies of getting rid of the Jews, helping Palestinians brush the terrible failings of Palestinian society under the carpet.
Mind Begs the Question:
▪︎D3ath to Jews chants - Nazi
▪︎D3ath to Arabs chants - Not Nazi?
Yeah. How dare some of these people suggest violent terrorists who killed their friends and want them dead not be fed on their dime!
Mind Begs the Question:
▪︎If Oct 7th - Horrific
▪︎If Pre Oct 7th - Not Horrific
▪︎Equality or Supremacist?
Smh. People in the comments are missing the question.
He did not ask if Gaza should get food.
He asked if Israel needs to provide it to them.
Yes and no. He did ask it as whether Israel should do so, but they all live with the reality that Israel has besieged the Gaza Strip. So they control the flow of goods, and lack thereof. The main rebuttal was either screw em or we don't want Hamas to get food. Neither of which are compatible with allowing food as aid into the Gaza Strip.
He also followed it up by whether the U.N. should supply food aid?
And? Regardless of the question, "Israel" is OBLIGATED under international law to provide food, as well as facilitate and guarantee protection of other organisations providing food.
"Israel" is an occupying power and as such has a legal and moral responsibility to provide food, healthcare, water and electricity to Occupied people.
The people answering show exactly why "Israel" is the problem. They've been illegally occupying for decades and still see themselves as the innocent victims. Everything they accuse Gazans and other Palestinians of, they themselves do. They do it in Occupied Palestine, they do it in Occupied Syria, they did it in Occupied Lebanon, they do it everywhere they go.
These same people don't seem to grasp that if you illegally occupy people, hold thousands of them hostage for years, place an entire territory under complete seige, "mow the lawn" every year as a specific policy and terrorise them routinely, they WILL eventually hit you back in a brutal way.
That's not justifying the loss of any innocent people on Oct 7, it is stating that Oct 7 could not and would not happen without all the above things happening.
Mind Begs the Question:
▪︎If a Semitic/Israeli Politician announced
▪︎Stopping Food,Water supplies
▪︎Charged with Crime of Starvation
▪︎Anti-Semitic or Pro-Law?
who in their right state of mind in any war would feed their enemy to ensure the war goes longer and their soldier keep dying.. for some reason the Jews are expected to do that... our hostages got no red cross and no meds and no one cares for their plight..
Thank you Corey. Morality is not what you think about the world, is how you act in it.
I agree 100% with the last woman, letting innocent Gazans starve is morally and strategically wrong.
There are no innocents in Gaza
@@tomerhuss Hamas says the same thing about Israelis.
@@fafolaw That's why Hamas is punished and banned in many many countries
@@fafolaw In October 7th videos, the Gazan CIVILIANS take part of the atrocities
Hamas are withholding aid from their own people
if humanitarian aid to gaza was dependent on the release of the hostages, the war would have been over months ago and with much less deaths
then tell the zionists to give the palestinians their homes back and to stop bombing them. bb made it clear he is not going to end the war so ur nonsense is just that nonsense
@@hadassaharrel2007
You want to take 7 million Palestinians hostages , I hope the icc is watching these videos, you’re a very rude thief.
Terrible idea, I can't immagine the backlash and outrage if Israel did that.
@@learningmode293countries are not responsible for non citizens. Israel is responsible for the Israelis, including Jews and Arabs. Israel is not responsible for Palestinians or Gazans, who are not Israeli citizens
@@learningmode293 theres backlash and outrage anyways. we shouldnt run a war based on what the world will think
SHOULD EGYPT OPEN THE BORDER? Should we have different standards for Europeans? Did Poland, Romania, Moldova, Slovakia keep their borders shut to UKRAINIANS fleeing the war?
Gazans can thank the Egyptians for keeping the border closed to them. We all know that Hamas terrorists will get the aid, not the children or pregnant women.
FREE THE HOSTAGES!
Basically these europeans had more empathy for their fellow humans despite being on the enemy side.
What hostages?You mean the 10 000 palestinians held hostages in 'israeli' prisons.
@@RedewaanJacobswhat's palestinians? Never heard of it.
@@RedewaanJacobs No wonders you conflate hamas and civillians number when talking about casualties. 10.000 innocents in prison, yeah, sure
@@RedewaanJacobs When are you going to call out the brainwashing in palestinian schools? Still waiting for a pro-pal to even acknowledge that. I saw what they broadcast on their TV channels, did you?
No-one is asking you to give them food, just to let the trucks with food through... Not the same thing
So that Hamas can get it and sell it to the hungry Arabs in Gaza.
They did already let Tons upon TONS of aid to Gaza
Not to mention 90% of the aid was stolen by Hamas every time it passed the gates of Gaza.
@@tsopuaifa Yahya Sinwar AUTOPSY were found he hasn't eaten for 3 days and he only carried a Mentos mint candy with him. So WTH is Hamas control the food? The Gaza borders are control by your IDF. How on earth Hamas are at the borders taking control the food in? I swear all Israelis are BRAINSWASHED to the point there will be no cure.
@somegirl4631 Lies again!
The average at the beginning of the war was 15 TRUCKS per day vs 200 TRUCKS/day before this Palestinian genocide!
exactly, giving food and blocking food are two completely different things
0:54 they don’t deserve it ??? While holding you’re own child that you still have the audacity to say that a child don’t deserve some food but when you say something about them it’s anti semitic bla bla
if you want to give food, give food.
it's not far fetched for people during wartime not to strengthen their enemies.
and it's not even the people who get the food. Hamas robs most of the trucks...
come look for yourself, instead of being high and mighty from afar like the keyboard hero you are
Chosen people's syndrome
You've heard only one answer?
@@gustafa2170 chosen people means chosen to carry the burden of the commands from god...
It's like being the kid who's told to take out the trash, it's not being better or something, but a carrier of responsibility.
not something an antisemite A-rab would not anyways...
@@HonorOP As the chosenite Yoav Gallant said himself: "No food. No fuel. No Electricity. We are fighting human animals."
In practice, not in theory, the chosen people is clearly defined. The chosen think they have the right to starve a population and commit genocide
I love your interviews, please keep them coming!
Wow thank you on behalf of the viewres/commenteres!
Corey is going to be so happy when he sees this!!!
@@edithabramowitz1275 it's in Hungarian forints, so it's not that much money -- but every little helps, I suppose
@@fgerlits ohh but looks like a dollarbill sign...
@@fgerlits ohhh now i get it!
But he really does deserve this amount in dollarbills...
He makes more effort to understand both sides more than any president of the United States!
@@edithabramowitz1275yes, I agree, on both counts
Withholding food and other basic necessities must never be used as a weapon, especially against civilians. This war has to end. I'm Israeli and that's my take.
Thats what i'm thinking. Who gives them the right to choose if they would eat or not. Thats not normal.
israel must end its illegal occupation of palestinian land, and it must return settlers' homes to their original owners. with this, there would be no reason for resistance
הזיה.
@@UA-camr20011 I agree. Everyone has the right to eat, that should not be a question.
@@Brevislux112so feeding na zis is your moral imperative? This is your morality?
Poor Nova festival survivor. u can clearly see she's so traumatized. i can understand her. she was almost murdered.
True she was right 😭
Even if you saw the death with you’re own eyes it does not give you a reason to say “ Gaza should not exist” that is literally genocide on 2.2 million people
She has death in her eyes for all gazans. Sure, she's traumatized. You think Palestinians aren't? That lady was the very monster she said she saw over a year ago. It's straight up nazi shit, y'all are disgusting fascists.
She is liar. See her body language if you understand it. See the eye looking up right corner when she is "creating" memories. She is crock.
why are you compasionate to her, she chose to live in an illegal occupation, she chose to go to a festival near the open air prison that is gaza. would you go live in the buffer zone between south korea and north korea?
one thing I noticed. the people answered in hebrew, mostly do not support food to innocent Gazans
Okey.... meaning what exactly?? What's your stigma??
Are gazans still supporting their terrorist sons, brothers, fathers?
No country is responsible for another's citizens or food. America was not expected to feed Afghanistan or Iraq. You are not required to feed the enemy.
yeah but they still force us to do it.. because its all rotten money involved.. hopefully trump will change that quickly
Huh? US provided aid to every population we occupied, including Việt Nam, Japanese and German. It’s standard for us, and compliant with international law of armed conflict. Ask someone who served.
@@npgibson69after the respective conflicts, not during.
Don't make fallacies.
No. But you are required to follow international law. Israel is illegally blocking food and aid, to the people they are illegally occupying. Forced, intentional starvation is a war crime.
@@twinklemagic024 Israel isn't "illegally blocking" anything. Any country has its right to block any aid that could benefit his enemy when in state of war.
Unfortunately, the few aids that Israel has allowed to enter have been robbed by Hamas. So it's very understandable and strategically favorable to stop bringing more aid when at the end it would be ended in the hands of the enemy.
Secondly, Israel hasn't been occupying Gaza since 2005. So don't make false statements.
Now, planned genocide against a state? That's a war crime.
And Israel is making sure that Hamas pays for it. If the "Palestinians" don't want to cooperate with bringing justice to Hamas and instead cooperate with them, then they cannot play the victim in this conflict.
Very bad question as no one asks Israel to feed Gazans. Way enough food is sent by international aid. The sole interesting question is "Should Israel let food enter in Gaza", as the IDF blocks the entrance of intenational aid for food and most of all medical supplies. That is why Israel is accused under international law of intentional mass starvation of civilian population.
Nobody asks Israel to feed Gazans, asks them the good question.
Its a perfect question and thats y Israel is being tried for genocide in the ICC.
Israel is letting trucks in you are just a delusional little man that think otherwise even if there are evidences of that but why agree with facts? Let’s change reality to fit our narrative you freaking idiot
Nobody asks Russia to feed Ukraine and they didn’t suffer a terrorist attack. Israel lets food and aid trucks in daily (not to mention stop the war to give polio vaccines to Gazans). Sometimes in Gaza people steal the aid trucks. Those people are called Hamas. Demand that they allow ordinary people to have access to aid provided internationally and let in by Israel.
@@littlecatfeet9064 Russia isnt occupying Ukraine. Israel is occupying Gaza and has the under siege.
@@littlecatfeet9064 Provide evidence of the following: 1. Daily Trucks Israel is letting in 2. People in Gaza 'stealing aid trucks'. 3. Hamas stealing aid trucks. I await.
Quite a few people said yes, and they know that if the situation was reversed Gazans would not give them a sip of water and most of the world wouldn’t even care.
Nope this video clearly exposed how genocidal the Israeli public are and now you're embarassed
We don't need your food... just let the aid from other countries come in... we don't need yours
Check the registers of COGAT and see what it is really happening.
Bite the hand that feeds you some more. It worked out so well for you up until now hasn't it.
The real question is should Israel stop blocking food aid to Gaza
שיחזור את היהודים לשער ויקבלו אוכל פשוט וקל
תחזרו את האנשים שלנו לשער של המצרים התקבלו אוכל מה הבעיה מאה אנשים תמימים חולים זקנים נשים וילדים חטפתם אין לכם רחמנות רצחתם ישלידים שלנו ואתה מדבר על ילדים שלכם 😂 אין לכם בושה אין לכם בושה
Israel is the one giving most of the food, so the question is: when will you start seeing the truth for yourself?
Food came mostly from Israel but also from places like Jordan, Dubai, Egypt and more
@@HonorOPstop lying, Israel is not paying for the food, it’s all donated by other countries
@@NaJAl-v2l This is not a lie, about 200 trucks come into Gaza daily from 5 main passages: Zikim, Erez, Kerem Shalom, 96, and 147.
Israel does not block the food and also gives fuel and other resources.
Hamas takes most of it. You can see footage of coordinated attacks on trucks with weapons by Hamas.
Try to say I'm lying one more time Ahmed, we all know your games. It's over.
I felt the pain of the lady that was at the Nova Festival 🙏🏾
I feel pain of Palestinans .Israel robbed them and killed for decades with total impunity.Stop playing victim israel!!
Mind Begs the Question:
▪︎If Oct 7th - Horrific
▪︎If Pre Oct 7th - Not Horrific
▪︎Equality or Supremacist?
@@bogumilaskowron2680you clearly have a very jaded view of history.
@@SnowsStorm1History tells us who the aggressors are. It's Jews! What's Jaded about facts? 76 years of never ending violence and hatred!
@@bogumilaskowron2680sad that it seems to be impossible for you to see the pain and suffering on both sides. With mentality of comparing pain/ dismissing pain, no better future will ever come to the land
The last woman is a natural strategist. The only one possessing both intelligence and kindness out of all the interviewees.
OK, I agree Israel should not give food >>>but from outside sources-->those Aid Trucks should have been let in---that is a crime against humanity.
They are let in. If not there would’ve been 2 million dead from starvation. It’s been more than 12 months. A human can only survive 2 months.
@@yomama5656the blockades of the trucks have been documented on video, rabbi
Why let in food instead of allowing the gazans to leave the region to their 22 arnab home countries?
@@porqueeso ppl magically survive in gaza with no food for 12 months? Gazans are magical creatures abdool?
It was never about Hamas…..it’s all about the Trillions of dollars in Gas and Oil. The IDF has killed all of the hostages and ISRAHELL has thousands of Palestinians civilians as prisoners in their captivity…torturing, raping,and killing innocent civilians. ISRAHELL needs to get out of the Middle East and go back to Europe where they belong. Genocidal killers and the world is right by that. It’s only a matter of time before they spread across the world….Gods chosen people of killers…that’s what they are.
Super interesting video Corey! Seeing nuanced views on the situation that you don't see anywhere else.
Supporting the mass killing of civilians through starvation is not a nuanced view you absolute turd
@@Rev-bb9ej yeah, admitting to their hatred
@@Rev-bb9ej if you’re going to reply justifying these people’s statements on camera, you’re part of the problem.
@@ajrhy6243if you are going to justify the actions of those who initiated or supported the violence that directly sparked the war you aren't part of the problem you symbolize it.
@@SnowsStorm1So every other Israeli?
The way Corey spoke to the Nova survivor was really not acceptable in my opinion. It felt aggressive, lacking in compassion, and re-traumatizing. I'm horrified. Baruch Hashem, she survived.
Would they give us food?
NO
I doubt it
Absolutely no
No
No they not they laughed probably while we hungry yes
The last woman was super smart. I think she is right. Hamas doesn't care about their people. The more hunger, the better for Hamas. So aside from any moral arguments, providing food to Gazans actually hurts Hamas, so Israel should do it.
It doesn’t hurt hamas to steal the food and eat it themselves
The bubble 🫧 of lies you guys live in is amazing
@@texasdude1 What lies? Hamad has literally stated on tv that taking care of Gazan civilians is not their job or responsibility. What rock have you been hiding under
@@arielaw4
Ariel the whole world can see that your existence was bad idea, you’re evil and we need to clean the Middle East from your evil.
Hamas knows Israel would not do that , thats why it attacked . it knows Israel creates its own insecurity when it hurts the Palestinians and Denies them their rights , then Hamas gets even more support and the cycle continues , so if we take that woman's logic to its very end , then Israel should give back the Palestinians their territory , release the people its holding in prison and any other injustices like that , then obviously Hamas would not have any reason to exist .
As an Israeli: I don't want people to starve. But being expected to supply your enemy during war is ridiculous. I don't want people to starve, but I also didn't want to be attacked so...
Israeli os not jew and they starve and kill our people so
You are not at war with them as equals, you are their occupiers. You have legal obligations to the well-being of the Palestinian people. Your comment speaks to the extent in which Israelis have lost the plot.
@@Ben-Murderin Ben-Gurion would have hated Bibi and religious Zionists.
@@Ben-Murderin
“Legal obligation”
@Ben-Murderin No such as a Palestinian people and we can't occupy our own land.
I am not Jewish. I have seen reports, not one report, of how the Palestinians in Gaza receive food from the United Nations and then sell it on the black market. There are women from Gaza who cook kunafeh and musakhan. In general, the Palestinians in Gaza have big bellies and are overweight, unlike Sudan. They do not need food. They are sad now that their cause does not bring them asylum and monthly salaries as it did before the war.
Swollen abdomen is a sign of protein deficiency.
@@npgibson69 oh please, it's not just their abdomen. Fat is also a sign of being fat.
@@npgibson69it was a figure of speech she didn't mean they are actually fat she means they eat very much
You're a disgusting horrible excuse for a human being
@@npgibson69
She said Overweight. Not skeletal body with big belly.
Those are not even remotely the same
The framing of the question is revealing of intent. It could have also been framed as - "Should Israel have the power to control entry of food into Gaza?"
Israel has the right to control its borders. Groups can negotiate the management of whatever borders it might share but that occurs by way of agreement.
@@SnowsStorm1Israel is not just controlling its borders, but the borders of Palestine, and they have been illegally restricting humanitarian supplies. Even before the war, Israel's control of Palestines borders is what perpetuated its occupation despite exiting Gaza.
Mind Begs the Question:
▪︎If a Semitic/Israeli Politician announced
▪︎Stopping Food,Water supplies
▪︎Charged with Crime of Starvation
▪︎Anti-Semitic or Pro-Law?
did you know that IDF took control over Gaza/Egypt border only around 7 months after the start of the war? How come they had a fully independent border with Egypt and were accusing Israel of starvation?
@ there is no legally formed Palestinian state so you have no borders and even to the extent that you believe you do those borders do not supersede Israeli borders. The only way you move beyond such issues is to negotiate the way in which areas of joint influence might be managed. That can only occur if and when the Arabs are open to compromise.
Tamir is incorrect because this is not a war between two countries. Gaza is an occupied territory and nothing gets nothing without the approval of the occupying power. Also see Geneva Convention IV.
Israel literally left gaza in 2005 until gazans elected hamas and hamas started firing rockets into Israel. The only difference is Israel controlled there borders to protect there citizens like any other country, billions of international aid from Europe went to Gaza and Hamas as the government only used them for under ground tunnels.
@@Femmeaesthetic@Femmeaesthetic Israel controls what gets in or out; don't spread misinformation.
@@adrianabotello9911 I genuinely believe these people are HasbaraGPT. Always the same nonsensical response.
@@adrianabotello9911
What about Egypt?
@@shainazion4073@shainazion4073 It is a nice place on this earth. Did you see how amazing that culture is?
The question wasn’t phased right. Israel has not provided any food to the Gazans, all food has come form outside aide and Israel blocks Gaza’s border to Egypt. The question should have been should Israel continue to block the aide trucks? Remember it’s Hamas that feeds the hostages. The first hostages that came out said they were only fed once a day. Hersh Goldberg was 100 lbs when he died. If you don’t care about innocent children dying of starvation, then you are not true to your religion.
It's not our responsibility to feed the enemy, and the hostages appreciate that we put our safety first, If I was a hostage , I would choose the safety of the Jewish nation over my freedom
@@Itsdifferent-wv4jogood, now go do your duty to your country without coming to America with your hands out like paupers.
Normal countries block food to na zis like pastalizis
@@Itsdifferent-wv4jo You do not get the issue because is in the news in the entire planet except in Israel: Israel block the aide trucks. This is how genocides are done.
What is this comment full of lies: Israelis collected trucks of do food & aid donations during this year. Lots if volunteers working, the heck you are writing here.
Keep asking and shedding light to this part of the world. 🇮🇱💙
No child should be denied food. Also Israel giving food to Gaza would be smart on Israel's part as it would be good gesture to the Palestinians.
The Palestinians in Gaza were given working farms after the Jews there were forcibly removed during a unilateral peace deal of withdrawing from Gaza in 2005. It was a good gesture but the Gazans destroyed the farms and dug up the irrigation pipes to repurpose into rockets.
During this war, the IDF suspended operations (Hamas and Hezbollah sent rockets still) to vaccinate Gazans against polio. That was a good gesture as well.
In any clash with Gaza and the West Bank, Israel sends text messages to “civilians” (really everyone since Hamas hides behind civilians) warning them that they’ll enter an area in two weeks, then one week then 24 hours. They also drop leaflets with the same warning. They put their own soldiers at risk to create humanitarian corridors for civilians. I think that’s a great gesture to the Palestinians, if not good for them.
None of the above things have worked. Hamas, Hezbollah, the Houthis etc don’t want kindness. They want to destroy the Jewish state. And they’re letting food in of course, so they’re doing everything other armies won’t do. Hamas would certainly never do that. Don’t forget that Yayha Sinwar, architect of the October 7 atrocities, was in Israeli prison for killing fellow Gazans. Israeli doctors saved his life there when he had brain cancer and he vowed he’d kill all Jews anyway. He made good on his word when Hamas kidnapped the nephew of the doctor who saved his life and then executed him. Maybe Egypt, whose blockade fence of Gaza’s is bigger and more impermeable than Israel’s, could be the humanitarian heroes of Gaza. Unlikely, but it’s a thought.
Those are valid points but I always hear many Israeli saying Palestinians are all brought up to hate Israelis or become terrorists whatever but many might not grow up to hate them so much if they tried do an act of good to them right now amongst the constant bombardment. Also now that this war that is been noticed and condemned by people all over the world by people that don't even have basic knowledge of the region and many of whom are just using it to fuel their own hateful agenda it is just creating unprecedented levels of hatred towards Israelis and non Israeli Jews unfortunately. There are no winners the way things are going.
@@Karl-bw8rpeggs of today are snakes of tomorrow, the Austrian painter was once a child, save your sympathy for more precious creatures
@@Karl-bw8rpThey are fed with hate since day 0, I feel sorry for those children, but our safety comes first, we need to be protected from any potential dangers, Palestinians can be happy and free away from the land of Israel, Europe is big they can move there
Hi I am an Israeli so I would like to answer also:
Yes, but it depends on a lot of factors. of the top of my head here is a few of them:
1. Israel does not need to pay for their food, We will not feed the enemy with our own money. The aid will come from outside.
2. Israel will not let any unnecessary food enter, Such as watermelons and pineapples. Mainly not from Israeli companies with our own money.
3. We should make sure that the aid that comes from outside is not getting into hamas hands, Almost all free aid now is getting sold at Gaza markets for high prices by hamas and they are profiting big time.
I'm sure theres more factors but that's just from the top of my head.,
Unnessecary food? You must be joking. 😂
@Tatokala expensive watermelons and pineapple are not necessary.
The food is trying to get in from the outside you nitwit.
@DanielMartinez.88first you are Mexican so you have no right to dictate what we may or may not fund with American resources and second you would still be wrong.
@@someguy1712 It does not depend on your personal opinion what starving persons need.
When you get only "necessary" food like water and rice over a longer timespan you will become malnutritioned too.
It's horrifying how people feel free to show their callousness.
Even chatgpt agreed that it's not Israel job, and gpt based on most human answers
@@RoniabcabcabcChatGPT has biases, mate.
@@trevorrogers95 By choosing the most common answer chosen by people, you know that GPT doesn't have its own opinion
its horrifying how people who have never been to war and are consuming one sided propaganda are shouting bs to the air and comments. both sides are to blame and its hypocritical to think otherwise
have you not watched the entire video?????You literally had Israelis showing sympathy for gazans meanwhile showing valid concerns that if they keep giving aid, hamas will steal them and get stronger!!!!!!!!
The artificial distinction between Hamas and ordinary Gazans is sickening. "Hamas represents the deepest ethos of the Palestinians." - Dr. Einat Wilf
Gaza's children are not Israel's problem, or the international community's problem: it is Gaza's problem, and they have to try to solve it, by making peace with Israel.
1:24 How do you know what "Jewish values" are?
Virtue-signalling. If Israel would not have provided humanitarian aid, the hostages would have been home after a week.
7:25 You're not starving them. Gaza needs to give up its plan to end Israel, if it's so worried about its children.
Besides, there most certainly are laws in war: Israel has no obligation to provide aid at all; if someone else wants to provide aid, Israel is allowed to block aid if it might help enemy combatants.
The bloc knows it can pressure Israel into being merciful; if Israel would stand its ground nothing would happen.
Israel has obligation provide food because israel is occupier .It is not war it is genocide.Hostages would be in home if israel do deal with hamas.And there are thousands Palestinan hostages
@@bogumilaskowron2680 The issue is not Israel providing, or not, food to gazans; the issue is that Israel is impending the supply of food to gazans.
You need some serious reprogramming. You support genocide
You are sick 😰🤮
Actually that is against the rule of war!Then again what do you expect from zionist jews.They do not apply human rules.
All you have to do is watch a documentary on what the Germans in WW2 believed about those they considered human animals at that time and how they treated them to see that history has repeated itself, Israel is the updated version of WW2 Germany with the US, UK and the EU along with others fully complicit in their actions.
You are Brainwashed. Look at numbers instead of the videos at x and at the news.
@@niels3138-d2r Numbers, Israel is not self-sufficient in food. No food to give to anybody. The world is sending food to Gaza, and the occupiers are taking the food or letting it spoil.
Who in the middle east were allied and still admire ww2 germans?
Who is haj amin al husseini?
You should watch what palestinians are teaching their children then.
@@anthonyr963 I see more brats full of hate in your side of history than the Palestinian ones.
That brave Nova survivor clearly triggered and still haunted by October 7th. O how I wish love and life on her and peace. It may take years or decades but one can heal ❤ its a possibility. And one I desire for her very very much. One will never forget but one can heal. Speaking as somebody who had ptsd from party watching a homicide as a child. Much love dear woman, so much love. ❤
That is how all Palestinians feel under Israeli Occupation. They cannot sleep at night in their own homes. Imagine that happening to you for 75 years.
Oh what she did on festival near ghetto Where 2 million people were held hostages for 17 years?
@@fahmidarahman8688nonsense. The Arabs began the violence in 1920 and formally attacked in 48. If occupation were the cause of Arab violence how did all that violence occur well before any such environment ever existed
@@fahmidarahman8688shut up we kews live here before you 5000years old learn history
@@fahmidarahman8688oh is that why the Palestinians started the nakba themselves with the bus bombing that took place the day the partition plan did not go how they wanted? Is that why they threw a tantrum and chose violence, and got their just desserts?
"Half of the Palestinians Are Egyptians and the Other Half Are Saudis"
- Hamas Minister of the Interior and of National Security Fathi Hammad
Why aren't Egypt and Saudi Arabia providing the Gazans food and shelter?
Why does only Israel need to provide the needs of the people who launch rockets at them?
Where did you get that quote from?
Israeli are mostly European 😂
Why aren't the Arabs helping their fellow Arabs?
Hammad said it in a video on Al-Hekma TV dated March 23, 2012.
@@SydPat is that material history! You twit
Thank you for showing the true psyche of Israeli society. October 7 justifies everything. The Palestinians should just politely and obediently accept the ethnic cleansing that has been happening to them for over 70 years.
Finally showing their TRUE face by denying food to poor innocent CHILDREN‼️ 😡
Did you even watch the video..?! My guess is No.
Wt are u talking about ?? Losing a war they started doesnt make them poor innocent bla bla ..
dont start wars and no one will starve ! Problem solved
@V.CatCroissant
Watched Untill the End❗
Not that surprised though, to be honest......
Disgusting all of you 🤢 🤮
Hasbi Allah Al - Yahud 🤬 😡
no innocents in Gaza
but our 108 hostges
The real question you should be asking is is right for Israel to stop food and water--given by other nations-from going into Gaza-a concentration camp created by the Israelis.
And while their hostages should be released, they should also release the 3000 Palestinians held in Israeli prisons without charge even before the war-and let Gazans have their freedom and stop “mowing the grass” by bombing Gaza every few years.
Where is their humanity??
Water and medications are provided by Israel.
A concentration camp? With Mercedes cars, beach resorts, 5 star restaurants... you really should look up what a Concentration camp is!!
@@shainazion4073 it is a closed enclave surrounded and controlled by the Israeli military since at least 2008-no one can get out without Israeli permission to go back to their native lands in other parts of Palestine-if they fish in their own sea without Israeli permission they get shot at-and it is a place where Palestinians are concentrated after being kicked off other lands where the Israelis have taken over, and read any human right reports-much of the population was destitute even before the war because of Israeli occupation not allowing free economic activity.
A few rich people in the enclave doesn’t make it any less of a concentration camp-it is one even according to Isreali government officials
@@sabeenamalik1663you really don't know what a concentration camp is.
@@sabeenamalik1663Surrounded by Israel? Are you sure about that? You don’t think maybe there’s another country blockading Gaza and that said country maybe has a reason? But no one goes after that country nor its unwillingness to take in any Gazan refugees.
Ask hamas and iranians, there are no inocents in gaza
Geneva Convention IV Article 55 - Food and medical supplies for the population
To the fullest extent of the means available to it, the Occupying Power has the duty of ensuring the food and medical supplies of the population; it should, in particular, bring in the necessary foodstuffs, medical stores and other articles if the resources of the occupied territory are inadequate.
The same people continuously inhabited that place, from Canaanites to Hebrews to first Christians; most converted to Islam under Arab rule. Now, they are under the occupation of immigrant Jews (those Jews are native to other parts of the world; their ancestors somehow converted to Judaism). The food is not from Israel; it is what the whole world is sending to the native people of the Holy Land, the Palestinians.
Not this again. The only group indigenous to the holy land in the jewish people.
Oh here we go again with another propaganda🙄. Israelis (not all) are native to the land you know why because Judaism is ethno religion, jews have been a diaspora and this includes Ashkenazi jews who dealt with racism in europe historically. It's not very clear if palestinians are indigenous since Arabs mass immigrated to that land under the Ottomans when jews were building economy. Jews weren't the only people immigrating to the land. Either way Jews always had presence in that land wether if they became majority or minority by many empires who conquered that land.
They did not convert to Islam, they were conquered and made to convert. They were colonized
@@SnowsStorm1, prove it with actual facts; do not bring suspiciously adjusted history books here.
@@hermithefrog629 And that shows that Arabs rule the place without expulsing the population out of the land. Now, we have a ruler/occupier who is trying to take the history and identity of the Palestinians, not only the land.
I don't think there is any war where a country is expected to provide food for the enemy population. Has never happened. What Israel should have done though, is to facilitate aid coming in by non involved organisations.
If then the main bulk goes to Hamas, and what is left, they are selling to their population in the markets, Israel should have provided evidence to the UN
Ask Gazans why not a single one of them has assisted in hostages' release, not 1!
Did any zionist assist in the release of the more than 10 000 hostages in 'israeli' prisons?
can u, as a normal civilian go into a prison and release a prisoner?
@@RedewaanJacobs lol you in jail because terrorist attacks
@@Meatriderphobic he not normal he do terrorist attacks or plan one you stupid islamnazim
@@RedewaanJacobs 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
The lady with the child saying that children in Gaza doesn't deserve food. Her kid will learn this from her and abandon her one day unfortunately
She did not say they did not deserve food she said that it is not the responsibility to provide it. Have you ever considered that her opinion may well have been informed by the loses she herself experienced as the result of Hamas. For all you know her family member was killed that day
Great twisting of the narrative. Not what she said. And what is Gaza, 99% kids or something? Tell their hamasfanclub parents to get morals, first off.
She should thank god she wasn't born in gaza but in a privileged place. She's going out shopping with the child and then maybe she'll go home and live her beautiful life there. Buying food and all to provide for themselves. Mothers in Gaza are in danger of being killed, they live in a tent (literally) in the middle of the street, they struggle to provide food and all this while these idiot Israelis talk nonsense.
No her kid will grow up just as heartlessly tarnished as his mom. Im sure they teach this in their schools also. Hell their holy book tells them its ok to be heartless because they are the chosen ones.
It doesn’t matter what these people think. As an occupier Israel has the obligation to deliver them food and all other essential goods. Otherwise Israel needs to get out there and stop denying the people their freedom. It’s that simple and the icj made it clear this year in July with their decision on Palestine. People need to educate themselves. Or does international law doesn’t apply to them??
Gaza is not Israeli territory, why would Israel be responsible to feed the enemy?
Egypt has a border with Gaza and Egypt can do it
nothing seems to apply to these people.. and we going to see a big back lash on the Israelis because of that all over the world.
@@frankozrin5611 Israel is the occupier of Gaza according to international law. It was before they started slaughtering ten thousands of human beings, and now it is responsible as an occupier by all military means.
This statement is based on a false idea that Israel is occupying Gaza. Israel is occupying Gaza as much as Egypt does - it simply has a border. If Egypt is not obligated to provide for Gaza, then neither is Israel.
Israel has no rule over gaza therefore what you say is not relevant, or you confirm that Israel is the one that should rule there?😏
"In such a situation, the person who has committed the crime is entirely responsible for their actions, and there is no legal or moral obligation for you to take care of their family, especially if they have harmed you or your loved ones. It would be understandable if you felt no responsibility toward their family, as they are not the ones who have wronged you."
By chatGPT
Good comment
As an American I feel no responsibility in helping such an entitled group of people do their dirty work. Good luck these next few decades, guys. Christ is King.
@@trevorrogers95 One reason America is so great is by doing things like helping Israel. Believe me, the U.S. gains much more than it gives. If there was no benefit, they wouldn't do it. So don't be naive; this is how countries operate
Did you mention the part where Gazans have no means to acquire their own food because Israel blockades all trade, or are you pathetically trying to validate your genocidal views through a large language model?
@@trevorrogers95as an American I feel an obligation to prevent our Allies from being slaughtered as they were in October 7th.
Does anyone else think that it is difficult not to remind oneself that these well-fed, well-clothed people in front of departmental stores are pontificating about homeless individuals less than couple of hours away dying of hunger, diseases and bombing with no hope of escape?
Says a lot about their 'humanity'
You mean like we see from those in cities like Ramallah?
Don't sleep on the H word. And don't believe all of Gaza is starving and homeless.
these currently homeless people had made their choices...by voting Hamass, and participating in the massacre of the Jews... that is not enough not to care
Have you not watched the survivors in this video about nova music festival or people in this video who did show sympathy for gazans? is every well fed, well clothed people expected to feel sympathy for people who participated in terror/suicide bombing attack and celebrates it?
🇬🇧❤️🇮🇱🎗️ I stand with Israel! 🇬🇧❤️🇮🇱 ✝️🤝✡️ 🇮🇱🕊️🇬🇧
76-77💔💔💔💔♂️♀️🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🍉🍉🍉✌🏻✌🏻✌🏻✌🏻✌🏻✌🏻🕎🇯🇵🇿🇦🇦🇽🇹🇷🏴🇭🇰🇰🇷🇺🇸🇨🇦🇬🇧
No one gaf
It just shows how they and other pro-genocide people don't really care about the hostages. If all food stops going in. The hostages will also starve to death 🤦♂️
You've got it all mixed up, bud, and the hostages are getting starved either way.
@@Thenoobestgirl They are still alive. Having little food is still better than no food at all.
@@Thenoobestgirl And did you forget when some of the hostages were released and they did not appear to be starved at all? Just admit you don't care about the hostages
Just admit you are a filthy antosemite and that no matter what Israel would do YOU will never be satisfied!!
So none of the efforts to minimize casualties ever registers in your brain! No huh? Coz you are too busy hating all jews and just want to continue doing so at any excuse.
Israel is not obligated to feel the enemy! The very one that tried to kill it!
The Israelis have been providing hundreds of trucks a day of food aid but the UN has been unable to see them delivered to the Gazans as Hamas are hijacking them as soon as they enter Gaza and selling it to the people at exorbitant prices.🇦🇺🇮🇱
I would have donated if I could because this channel is useful. Apologies and thank you.
Hamas take donated food and sell them to Gazans for money
Wow I never saw a “war” like this! People in restaurants, shopping, on bikes having walks… that mother of Satan who said even children should b starved while she has a kid in a stroller absolutely disgusting human
You have never seen a war, then. Period.
The short answer: BIG. FAT. NO.
True
What kind of question is this? Should we give someone foods after we occupied them and put embargo on anything and everything? Those people are so cruel and they are finally showing their true colours.
If you check the registers of COGAT or the POLIO vaccination plan, you will see that what you have been convinced by propaganda is not the reality of facts.
Israel has always been the rational one
Israel is the colonizer, the occupier.
"Most Zionists don't believe that God exists but they do believe he promised them PALESTINE"
- Ilan Pappe
Just lies as always from you. You must be a follower of the illiterate child m0 l est er.
Bot
incel
So far from being persecuted, the A b -- dul - s have crowded into the country and multiplied until their population has increased more than even all world Jw ‘ ry could lift up the Jewish population." -Winston Churchill
Most zionists believe in history. If Ilan Pappe dislikes Israel so much, why doesn't he go elsewhere to live?
This video is exactly why I love this channel and project you're doing Corey! Diverse nuanced thoughtful answers from real people living this nightmare situation. I hope those here in the west can see this and if they want to wade in and have opinions about this conflict they can try to be as reflective and sensitive as those in this video
Should Russia give food to the Ukraine? Should Iran give food to Israel? Should North Korea give food to South Korea ? Should Ukraine give food to Russia?
Should Hamas give food to Israel?
in which war has one of the belligerents supplied food to the enemy's population? It's crazy, are we asking Russia to send food to the Ukrainians?
The question of food does not arise with Russia / Ukraine because Russia is not besieging Ukrainian civilians - Russia is not able to and perhaps does not want to besiege Ukrainian civilians. Also it is not a war because a war has two armies (like Russia vs Ukraine) - here there is only army - Israel - who uses tanks / jets etc to bomb civilians living in tents. The question is not should Israel supply food, it is should Israel allow food supplied by charities, UN etc or should Israel enforce a medieval type siege / blockade where civilians starve.
@@jurnet9 1/israel is not besieging gaza, gaza also has a border with egypt
2/ this war was not started by israel but by hamas, the “legal” authority in gaza
3/ it's the material used by israel to defend itself that conditions aid to the population, where did you see this rule?
4/ it's hamas that confiscates the teeth supplied by israel and uses them against its own people.
5/no one is starving to death in gaza
So why arabs dot give food to Israel?
And who's funding you with gaz idiot ? Wasn't that Jordan itself where their citizens got too mad cuz their gov was able to do but couldn't feed their so called brothers in Islam till after three months of blocking? When Israel said no water no food no electricity! Remember that?!
Israel has more money than Palestinians
Because Arabs are not maintaining a blockade in Israel, if they were, then it would be their responsibility to let humanitarian aid into Israel.
@@fafolaw Arabs do blockade againts Israel from lebanon and syria side.
Because arabs are nt occupiers israel come to euro to middle east this why
וואו. אני בשוק. מירב שירתתי איתך לפני 30 שנה. את נראית מדהים. את נראית בדיוק אותו הדבר.
Simple equation:
Hamxs gives back hostages, we give food..
Hostages = food
And if hostages starve alongside Palestinians? Then you have the land don't you, you sick individuals
Out of responsibility I say no, Israel has no responsibility to provide food for the people who have carried out a brutal attack to them last Oct 7. However out of love I say yes, because the Bible says love you enemies and pray for those who persecute you. Gazans must thank Israel even though the supply is not that sufficient but Israel tried their best to alleviate their hunger and provide their basic needs. I didn't hear Russia giving food and aid to Ukraine.
They do as per the Geneva Convention, you ignorant! That's why the are convicted of committing war crimes!
7:30 this lady gets it
The Torah would have spelled it out, but it seemed so obvious. Like do not rape. That's not in there either.
One key difference between both extreme ends of this spectrum is the Israelis still call Gazans people on the contrary to Gazans and supporters
@@vladuzaurus "Human Animals"
- Yoav Gallant
No other country would give food to their enemy... No other country is insane as us :P
The way you triggered the Nova survivor's pain is boldly unethical. You also did not express any compassion on the spot. Sorry, I can see that this was not your intention, but this looks very cruel.
Commiting genocide is cruel.
@@gustafa2170 That's why Israel is trying to stop Hamas from commiting genocide against Jews/Israelis - as Hamas has publicly vowed to do.
@@gustafa2170 Genocide doesn't happen by headcount but intention. Gaza is collateral damage, not genocide
@Femmeaesthetic
Stfu
Yoav Gallant -
"There will be no electricity, no food, no water, no fuel. Everything is closed. We are fighting human animals and we are acting accordingly."
@Femmeaesthetic Yoav Gallant -There will be no electricity, no food, no water, no fuel. Everything is closed. We are fighting human animals and we are acting accordingly."
I heard alot of stupid answers what about the hostages? they need food and water they still in gaza so we let them die?
That is not how the hostages are dying.
In no war in the world has there been a case where a post that was attacked had to provide food and water for the side that started the war, not my problem, bring in the hostages and then we'll talk about humanitarian aid.
Thank you. I said this is a very detailed manner with examples in the comments here and it was deleted 3 times.
Great point. Now, can you guys clean up this mess without interfering with and receiving foreign aide from my home country, please? Thanks. 🇺🇸 🦅 ✝️
the idea of Israel giving anyone humanitarian aid is hilarious, Israel doesn't give anything to anyone, where are you on the world's donor country list, 210?
Yea, call me crazy but if you are a state that has a sliver of land on its side filled with the most intense poverty of the world that (even before the 10/7 terrorist attack) you seal off by land, sea and air - and you proclaim you are the savior of the western world and a world powerhouse- you better supply that population with survival mechanisms when necessary. Its almost like a strip of land that adjourns one of the most powerful states on earth, where people can't swim out to sea, or leave the land (without a work permit) or even go to an airport (wealthiest Gazans , it could be a 2 week journey to an airport prior to 10/7), in this thing called life- that environment has and will always grow terrorism.
@@trevorrogers95 Well, we survived 3700 years without your help and we will survive without it, but it turns out that we are the best of friends and my enemy is yours and he will come and go. You have an interest in helping me, and Trump understands this very well.❤️✡️❤️✝️❤️🇮🇱❤️🇺🇸
In an interview with Democra TV, former Israeli chief of staff and defence minister Moshe "Bogie" Ya'alon accused Israel of engaging in "ethnic cleansing" in the northern Gaza Strip.
As Gazas population keeps increasing 😂
Go back to school and learn what basic words mean.
Must be why the numbers of the foreigners keep increasing.
This Iranian bot is everywhere
Abduls would have sat in the dark forever had not the jw ‘ sh engineers harnessed the Jordan river for electrification. Now they swarm into Ptown seeking the light." - Winston Churchill
@@solvingpolitics3172gazas population has increased since 10/7?
I am shocked by the inhuman reactions.
Well they should have thought about consequences before starting a war , dont u think ?! ..
Its not israels responsibility to feed them but it does it bec israel values life and have morals
All of them are complicit, Sinwar was a baby one day
@@tomerhussthe Austrian painter was a child one day too , thank you
@@Itsdifferent-wv4johe was a better artist than Churchill
Israel values life and have morals? I think what the world saw happen in Gaza contradicts what you just said.
Israel has No values and humanity.And Yes it is israel duty provide food because it is occupier
Only if they revoke their allegiance to Israel 's destruction. Einat Wilf says that northern Gaza can be a place where individuals one by one will need to sign something accepting Israel and denouncing violence and surrendering.
This people dont need surrending izrael need surrendung because is occupier.In nordhern Gaza is commited genocide and land theft
Idiot didn't say that.
Doesn't she implicate her self by saying what she said at 3:08? You think gaza should be erased
We still have hostages there 😢 , we don't want to lose them
She doesn't, because she wouldn't feel that way if they didn't want to kill her first.
she was at Nova....
@@brunetteXeryou mean on festival near ghetto Where 2 millions people were held hostages for 17 years?
@@bogumilaskowron2680 Have you read the Hamas charter lmao? Yeah I would want my borders sealed tight too if I had neighbours who had a written goal in their constitution to wipe out my people... By the way, don't forget Egypt played a huge role in enforcing the blockade. If Egypt had been relaxed about letting them in, no one would have been 'trapped' there. It's as simple as this: Gaza had borders with 2 countries, Israel and Egypt. Both those countries have a right to control their borders. If you want your neighbours to let you in, maybe don't elect a 7th century nutjob fundamentalist government with g33n0cid41l ambitions and they might be a bit warmer to you...
This whole conversation assumes 1) there are mostly innocent people in Gaza, 2) that they’re actually starving, and 3) that a military is obligated to make it more difficult for itself to win a war (or rather said, that Israel shouldn’t be allowed to simply win a war). None of these statements are based in truth or morality.
At this point, Israel has every right to decimate Gaza and its people, reabsorb the land into its territory, allow the so-called refugees to experience actual refugee-hood, and never look back.
Learn what decimate means (to reduce by 10%). Israel had surpassed that in the first week. You’re on the wrong side of history, supporting war crimes. It may be years or decades but, you’ll know & feel bad later, typical “shoot & cry.”
@@abd5441at the moment the death toll is 1,5%....
76 year occupation, and they see themselves as the victims.
76 years British mandate rule there not you islamnazim
We jews live in Israel judah kingdom 5000 years in Israel judah kingdom from jeusha Ben nun time till today 5076 years
You islamnazim occupied us jews what Palashtina mean why rome empire that stole Israel judah kingdom named Israel in another name Palashtina you just lie and make fake country
There is no occupation abdul
Islam teach many bad, DECIEVING their believers, look what happened even now. many Arabs had been scam by their belief in Islam, they believed Israel belongs to them and always do bad things to their neighbors.
But they cut off the food in the first place.
Why israel should provide them food? They have border with egypt, ask them to tranfer them food, israel is in war with gaza, yoh dont take care of your enemies, esoecially when 100 hostages are are still held in hamas tunnels
Israel should provide food after all the food produced and flourished is on stolen palestinian land.
Israel provides an abundance of food to Gazan Palestinians but they have told the Israel press in Gaza that Hamas beat Palestinains, even shoot them to force them to give up any food and water they have and leave them with nothing. There is a video that proves this.
Prove this accusation.
Are you sure they are not Israeli goons?
now ask americans if they should be forced to pay for israel's military
Wow, absolutely wow, they ALL hesitated before answering. What a sick society.
Your side wouldn't even hesitate before saying no. Hypocrite.
@@Thenoobestgirl Palestinians would say no to helping other Palestinians. If you say so your vile Israeli.
Civilians should never suffer on behalf of terrorists , many civilians are trapped and have no choice, we should show them compassion.
On the one hand, I really agree with this sentiment. On the other hand, what moral responsibility do these civilians bear for these terrorists?
- The civilians elected the terrorists.And if the Palestinian Authority's refusal to hold elections is any indication, those civilians would do it again.
- Most of the civilians support the terrorists' struggle against their common enemy, if not their methods (though a very large portion of them do support those methods).
- The aims of the terrorists (a Palestinian state on all of the land and the Israelis gone) are pretty much what the vast majority of the civilians want.
- The hatred towards the enemy within the civilian population is what makes it impossible for moderates to rise to power there politically, and what leads the most radical people in the population to become terrorists in the first place. The terrorists and the civilians are not fundamentally different in their views and their feelings, except when it comes to violence towards innocent civilians (even then, they have no love for the victims of the terrorists).
- The civilians celebrated the actions of the terrorists which led to the war, or denied them.
- The civilians refuse to rise up against the terrorists, or to collaborate with the ones fighting them (since they are "the enemy").
- The civilians are so strongly socially/culturally pressured to support the terrorists and hate the enemy that they could be killed for speaking any heterododox opinion. And not only or even mostly by the terrorists - by the other civilians.
So what responsibility do they have for the terrorists? To what degree are they morally liable to suffer for the acts of the terrorists that they agree with and make inevitable?
That's nice. You're now incentivizing terrorism.
98% of pasaltizis are proud of october 7th
@@amitb.e.5244 your word vomit can be summed as "I'll casually stand by as ethnic cleansing happens amongst millions of people" lmao.
I'm glad so many people answered "yes" ♥️
Did you watch the same video as I did? They were mostly for preventinf food from entering Gaza.
@@SuperKripke some said yes and some said no and some were in between because they don't want hamas to gain power
@@Femmeaesthetic The people who didn't say no all are satisfied with the status quo, which is to starve the population. I didn't see a single person say an unqualified yes or express horror that their government fails to allow food or aid through.
NO! They have their own government. If they want Israel to provide, then they should let Israel take over gaza.
Would they have the same rights like a Jewish citizen of Israel
You mean land theft ? This is what you can best zio
Israel is thinking it's clever whilst asking for whom the bell tolls.
@pantehine66 no they kill us
Starvation is a war crime and Israel is the occupying colonizing force here, so yes.
This did not begin on October 7.
sure but october the 7th made it a lot fuckin' worse didn't it?
@ it also exposed what Izrahell has been doing to Palestinians for decades
For all the comments about the hostages, do you not want them to get food also?
Only if they surrender.
Israel has never "provided food" for Gazans. They just determine if food provided by other nations will be allowed in to Gaza.
Israel might not provide food directly, but the water and medical provision are direct.
thanks corey.
תודה!
Starvation as a weapon of war
Wow u are so smart
Why dont u Complain to hamas who is stealing the aid
Did you see what Hamas does to gazans who try to get heir hands on the food? It's horrible, truly heartbreaking, im traumatized that i saw this
And yet the high obesity rates in Gaza haven’t gone down. Their women are some of the fattest on the planet, prime example, Sinwar’s wife with or without her $32,000 Hermes bag. No wonder; they’re getting on average over 3,000 calories per day which is hell of a lot more than those in surrounding areas get.
it's not the first time. The germans did it Russia during WW2.
@@RenyH716 Provide evidence of Hamas stealing the aid.
Wrong question. No one asks for israeli food. Israel HAS TO ALLOW aid trucks in! Period.
Check the registers of COGAT and you will see how it is already heppening.
It's immoral to aid the enemy, esp while those held are really starving.
Yea we need to end this virus no way you think like that
I don't think we are paying for the food it's mostly payed by the world's donations, but we control the borders so if we don't allow it to enter it's a a WC and b it's starving millions of people
Who is the enemy, Hamas or all Palestinians?
You're saying babies and innocent civilians, elderly people and women, are your enemies? Enemy of humanity, then?
Where did you see that those who are held are starving?
I have big respect for the third guy
No. That’s UNWRA’s job.
Israel and the US called them terrorists and aren't allowed to bring in food.