Melody. It’s always been melody. I bought the album when it first came out. I’ve been singing Melody for 50 years. You sing melodies. It only makes sense that way. This song has not changed.
This song is about lonely people in a bar thinking about their mistakes and regrets. It's always been memory. That's in context with the message of the song. The word melody is in the song. You're just mixing up where.
This song is about lonely people in a bar thinking about their mistakes and regrets. It's always been memory. That's in context with the message of the song. The word melody is in the song. You're just mixing up where.
@Vegan Higler 1. Your memory isn't proof or evidence. 2. Being in a cover band isn't proof or evidence. 3. Residual isn't evidence. It's cherry-picking what agrees with you. The actual song is the proof. 4. Being a songwriter, you should understand symbolism in lyrics. Playing a memory makes perfect sense within the context of the message of the song. 5. Why can't you just be wrong? Why is it that saying some unknown force changed Billy Joel's voice is a more reasonable explanation to you?
@Vegan Higler Total straw man. Memories can be right, but they can be wrong, too. Numbers aren't an indication of what's true or false. Yes, but you and wakeuporelse are missing something important. After a memory testimony, the opposing attorney cross-examines the witness, followed by the jury determining if the testimony is true or false. You're presuming memory testimony is automatically right just because it's allowed.
It's "memory". It was always been memory. I've been playing and (badly) singing the song for forty years, always "memory". Pick any song and trawl through enough lyric websites, and you'll discover numerous mistakes. Many of them just copy from one another. Sheet music copies made under copyright are the only reliable versions, and even they have occasional errors. I remember a keyboard tutorial book produced by a Japanese company that erroneously changed "Londonderry Air" (the tune for "Danny Boy") to "London Dairy Air"!
This song is about lonely people in a bar thinking about their mistakes and regrets. It's always been memory. That's in context with the message of the song. The word melody is in the song. You're just mixing up where.
Symbolically. This song is about lonely people in a bar thinking about their mistakes and regrets. It's always been memory. That's in context with the message of the song. The word melody is in the song. You're just mixing up where.
@@roccodonato6236 Of course the supernatural is real. I've been saved and forgiven by the blood of Jesus for nearly 45 years. I've witnessed and experience God moving in ways humans can't explain.
It's memory. He's asking for an old song. Lyrics would be very boring if they were absolutely literal. I still have VHS video recording of Joel singing this live on the "Old Grey Whistle Test" TV show in the early 1970s. He songs *"MEMORY!!"* It's not the so called Mandela effect, it's the stupidity of putting faith in tinpot song lyric websites.
Such a awesome find, excellent video thank you for the share
Melody. It’s always been melody. I bought the album when it first came out. I’ve been singing Melody for 50 years. You sing melodies. It only makes sense that way. This song has not changed.
This song is about lonely people in a bar thinking about their mistakes and regrets. It's always been memory. That's in context with the message of the song. The word melody is in the song. You're just mixing up where.
Absolutely ....Thank you!!!!! ...I'm not really sure how it goes, but it's sad and it's sweet. That MELODY that's now a MEMORY.
I heard this song and beat but from a meme🤦🏾♂️😭
This song is about lonely people in a bar thinking about their mistakes and regrets. It's always been memory. That's in context with the message of the song. The word melody is in the song. You're just mixing up where.
Do you remember the sun being white your entire life? 🤔
@@MoneyBags73 I've noticed that the sun appears different.
@Vegan Higler Proof and evidence please. As U wrote in my original post, he does sing melody in a different part of the song.
@Vegan Higler 1. Your memory isn't proof or evidence. 2. Being in a cover band isn't proof or evidence. 3. Residual isn't evidence. It's cherry-picking what agrees with you. The actual song is the proof. 4. Being a songwriter, you should understand symbolism in lyrics. Playing a memory makes perfect sense within the context of the message of the song. 5. Why can't you just be wrong? Why is it that saying some unknown force changed Billy Joel's voice is a more reasonable explanation to you?
@Vegan Higler
Total straw man. Memories can be right, but they can be wrong, too. Numbers aren't an indication of what's true or false.
Yes, but you and wakeuporelse are missing something important. After a memory testimony, the opposing attorney cross-examines the witness, followed by the jury determining if the testimony is true or false. You're presuming memory testimony is automatically right just because it's allowed.
It's "memory". It was always been memory. I've been playing and (badly) singing the song for forty years, always "memory".
Pick any song and trawl through enough lyric websites, and you'll discover numerous mistakes. Many of them just copy from one another.
Sheet music copies made under copyright are the only reliable versions, and even they have occasional errors.
I remember a keyboard tutorial book produced by a Japanese company that erroneously changed "Londonderry Air" (the tune for "Danny Boy") to "London Dairy Air"!
How do you remember 1999 by prince? I'm gonna party 🥳 or we're gonna party like it's 1999. Go listen 🎶
I remember can you play me a melody
This song is about lonely people in a bar thinking about their mistakes and regrets. It's always been memory. That's in context with the message of the song. The word melody is in the song. You're just mixing up where.
Mandela effects are always inferior. How the heck do you play a memory?
Symbolically. This song is about lonely people in a bar thinking about their mistakes and regrets. It's always been memory. That's in context with the message of the song. The word melody is in the song. You're just mixing up where.
@@Chess-Panda Do you know your bible?
@@roccodonato6236 I know a lot of scripture, but I don't have every verse perfectly memorized like you bible-changers do.
@@Chess-Panda Can you open up your mind enough to say that the supernatural is real. Whether you see them or not?
@@roccodonato6236 Of course the supernatural is real. I've been saved and forgiven by the blood of Jesus for nearly 45 years. I've witnessed and experience God moving in ways humans can't explain.
I'm back Because I can time travel now. Way!
Sounds weird. Play me a memory? How do you even do that? It's melody of course. Great video!
It's memory. He's asking for an old song. Lyrics would be very boring if they were absolutely literal. I still have VHS video recording of Joel singing this live on the "Old Grey Whistle Test" TV show in the early 1970s. He songs *"MEMORY!!"*
It's not the so called Mandela effect, it's the stupidity of putting faith in tinpot song lyric websites.
@Vegan Higler
The Mandela affect mantra.