Tribal People React to Johnny Cash Hurt
Вставка
- Опубліковано 17 лют 2022
- Tribal people reacting to Johnny Cash cover of Hurt originally written by Trent Reznor of Nine Inch Nails
Our patreon: / trybals
Buy a coffee for Adnan: www.buymeacoffee.com/trybalse...
Merch: trybals.myspreadshop.com/
Follow us on:
Facebook: / trybals-105923538317572
Instagram: / trybals_official
Twitter: / trybals1
Please note that this is a reaction video and contains commentary.
For the original video please click here:
• Johnny Cash - Hurt
If you are the original copyright owner and would like this video to be taken down please reach out to me at trybalsofficial@gmail.com
All the participants in this video are from Sindh, Pakistan.
Make sure to leave a like and valuable suggestions and please support our channel by hitting that subscribe button. Thanks for watching
www.copyright.gov/fair-use/
Copyright Disclaimer under section 107 of the Copyright Act of 1976, allowance is made for “fair use” for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, education and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing.”
#TribalPeopleReact #JohnnyCash #Hurt
Sorry for being mistaken about June, Johnny's wife. Thank you to all for educating me on it. For most of the times when I show them a piece of music I introduce them with more than just music itself, so for this I read somewhere on the internet that June died three months before this video and the house burned after a few years which I shared with them as well. I'll try to use multiple sources for things like that from next time and would correct them on the mistaken facts. Thank you
People make mistakes, it's fine. I'm just happy you chose this song for everyone to react to. 10/10 reaction.
I have known this song for 20 years and didn't fully compreehend until I watched this. You did the same with Zombie, so I am grateful to you for that. Thank you sir..
You do great, and after all, we are human, we all make mistakes! I have learned a lot from you and this channel!
No worries, friend. Keep up the good work.
They should see the lghter side of Johnny. They should see "One piece at a time" by Johnny Cash. With lots of Luric translation.. Very fun song.
A man of faith saying people shouldn’t all follow his faith, but rather follow good and kind people like Mr Rogers and Bob Ross. That’s an incredible message.
And one I very much agree with 👍
I loved his phrase, 'surgeons of behavior'. That was beautiful.
Essentially what the biblical message really is
Follow Ideas Not Men:
★ If a person had done an extra ordinary achievement and helped most of the people , we come to a conclusion that he is good and we can follow whatever he says.
★ This is the Cognitive bias - a systematic error in thinking.
★ We think that a sample taken from a enormous quantity is same as that of others surrounding that sample.
★ This is the problem of sampling.
eg : a kind of thought that a sample of rice taken from a rice bag is same as that of the other rice samples present in that same bag. But the truth is that all the rice samples in the bag may not same.
★ When we realize that the person whom we followed had done a bad thing ; we would get struck into the halo effect.
★ Halo effect is the tendency to judge a person based on a previously formed favorable or unfavorable impression.
★ At this point we would come to a cognitive bias that whatever good things he had contributed to the society is meaningless and his achievements are meaningless.
★ The identity of that person makes us blind from observing his good thoughts and ideas. Here that person is not the loser but we are the losers.
★ The solution is Don’t Worship Men if you like their ideas . Think about their Ideas and fit those ideas into your life if those ideas made sense to you.
@@Uriel-Septim. Wow that's a lot of words to say you completely missed the point or context lol. It's about actions and good examples and trying to add those whenever possible... not worshipping someone who did a good deed and mirroring all of their actions.
Perhaps some people don,t understand how hard it is to translate songs and feelings in another langage but this guy conveys it. Well done guy behind the camera you let them feel it
Thank you, thank you so much. It means a lot ❤️
It makes it even more difficult being with people of different cultures than yours and for that I truly respect them for being so open minded and good listeners too.
I wouldn’t have thought of that but I’m sure it’s true. Sitting here watching and listening to these videos, it’s easy to take the camera person for granted.
@@TRYBALS you’ve always done REALLY well giving needed context to them, and it’s one of the things that sets your channel apart from other similar channels.
@TRYBALS I've honestly always been amazed and had a huge amount of respect for the way you've translated, because you're not just translating the words, you always translate the emotion and intellectual aspect of it. Some of these things you show them I myself have not seen, heard of, or known the history of, so one of my favorite things is to learn along with you. Sometimes I think "Hmmm, I don't think that is what it meant", but in those times I'm always fascinated to open my mind to your new perspective and see another angle as well. I don't even know who you are, but I know that you are an Artist and a Philosopher in your soul, from the way you translate.
"Follow people who are full of love, ethics and values." Very wise words.
Don't be a follower
@@ilacallya324 'follow' as in 'learn from'
@@WithmeVerissimusWhostoned there's not a worthy person on the planet to learn from child.
@@ilacallya324that's your opinion, I disagree with that completely.
@@WithmeVerissimusWhostoned good thing yours doesn't matter then I guess
This is an important channel! I have been a US Soldier and stationed in Europe, Iraq, Kuwait and worked with Bulgarians. I can safely say that people, no matter their location, mostly all want the same thing. They want love, peace and the ability to raise a family. Don't ever let them separate us by our differences because the differences aren't as large as our similarities!
I'm not religious but may whatever power is at work keep your heart as warm as it was when you wrote this. Thank you.
What would you tell Hamas? Most of their fighters, btw, are about 19 yrs. old.
@@veramae4098We tell anyone that they need Jesus Christ to be saved from sin and we should pray for the peace of both countries
@@veramae4098 the Palestinians & Hamas have known nothing but war.... how did you think they would turn out? Israelis have had their boot on the necks of Palestinians since the inception of the illegal state of Israel.. Way to go Israel, you're no better than Nazis of WWII with their ethnic cleansing. Congratulations the "victim" has become the Abuser.
...I needed this hope today. Thank you.
"I sometimes wish I could stay a kid forever."
Even separated by technology, distance, time, culture, it's something we can all empathize with. It's a feeling we've all felt at some point.
.......Wouldn't that be wonderful.
Many of us as kids cant wait to grow up and become adults, then it happens and all we want is to just be a kid again. Life is funny like that, but time is inevitable.
I thought Emerson taught this, something we should of all read along the way.
We all have this wish and fantasy of being a kid forever, that’s exactly why Peter Pan is so beloved
@@ashishnalavade9244 What
The fact that pavarti is able to talk about her situation at all, let alone to a public audience, shows how much she trusts you. Please know that just giving her a place to breathe and a person to trust does more than you can ever imagine. I hope that she doesn't get in trouble for saying what she said, and I hope that someday peace comes to her.
That is my original worry, as well. I truly hope that the producers keep her safe.
@@cindym4577 maybe holding her in our thoughts will help.
@@Fairygoblet we can hope!
Amen, 💯🇿🇦
I feel so sad to hear her speak of her situation. I know that there are women and men all over the world in similar situations but seeing an individual that's going through it that you feel an almost (virtual) personal connection with makes it that much harder to witness.
My heart breaks for Parvati trying to keep her family in good health and not having the support to do so. I wish her the best.
I'll second that. And may I say she is extremely beautiful and her clothing and jewellery magnificent.
@@dee_seejayshe is attractive and intelligent and strong. it’s very sad to see her speak her truth
first time watching the channel and was looking to see if anyone else felt this way. very sad. "the law favors him" :(
The lady’s candid description of her life, was the highlight for me. It humbled me. May God ease her sufferings. She really conveyed the spirit of the song.
I was screaming at my screen, Servitude demeanour I WAS SCREAMING run run just ruuuun!
I like how they explained the cover; they prefaced the song by saying this is a cover done by a man who is many years senior of the original singer. This is why I never felt that either version is better or worse than the other- they are told from two different perspectives; a young man in the throws of immediate sorrow, and an old man reflecting on a lifetime of regrets. The song is the same, but it is so different.
Well put.
Yes 🖤
What a beautiful comment
Same story but different points of view 👌🏻 soon as ppl realise perception is everything life will get good for them
Exactly!
I'm 53 years old, and I was deeply affected by that statement about how we should let people like Mr Rogers and Bob Ross to be "Surgeons of Behavior" in our lives. What a blessing upon my life to hear such words which have deep and powerful meaning. Thank you.
52 here, and those two have been heroes of mine for a lot of those years. Rogers and Ross were good men who had a soothing and calming influence. Their demeanor and manner of speech conveyed love while educating and encouraging. Would that we had more role models like that in entertainment today...
I just turned 70, and I am very thankful to have found these videos. I can't believe that I am still learning a great deal about life's lessons. It's also me thinking oh wow, I could have died without knowing about these people and missed the gifts they offer up to others. They're honest and pure of thought, sharing not just their opinions but their knowledge and wisdom. I've been personally and deeply moved, and emotionally enriched in the spiritual sense as well. Thank you for sharing this and inviting people into your world.
Awesome vedio such interesting and intelligent people.they have powerful insights I'd love to know them..Ross and Rodgers were very good men 👍
I was getting teary-eyed watching them grasp the pain in Johnny's face and voice, and then the guy says "this uncle singing??" and I busted out laughing. Love this channel.
same thing, water in my eyes and first thing this guy says "his voice so clear he could teach me English in a month" what a legend
Calling someone uncle in their culture is a sign of respect, my friend
@@tonykulikovsky I kind of picked up on that, thanks for confirming :)
The two-shaven men, despite not understanding the language, can very clearly feel the song's message on a profound level, and they display a massive amount of empathy. Where words fail music speaks.
" ..my empire of dirt.."
@@MR-nl8xr?
The moment that literally made my eyes tear up is as the song ended the one gentlemen spoke out to Johnny and said "but the time has gone by now sir" then saluted him. This reaction video really touched me.
Yes same, still teared up now. That was really beautiful.
Same. He hadnt even heard the meaning of those lyrics yet, but he inherently understood.
.me too
I saw that. We are all one in the same, in our core.
Yeah, that got me in the feels.
I know cultures and ways of life are different, but still it’s not easy to hear about Parvati’s home life and not feel sad or angry. However, she seems to be a strong-willed and determined woman, and I’m sure she’ll pass that same strength on to her children. I’m glad she’s able to be a part of your channel and share her life with us, as well as being able to speak her mind and perspective.
By the end of the month some 25,000 to 50,000 men will have heard(read) that bit about home abuse and clenched their fists in rage.
Its very sad. These women r born poor, married into poverty and they become maids and are the ones bringing the money in becoz of addict husbands who dont work.
This happens in the capital too.
My feelings are with her. Parvati seems to be an amazing and strong woman!!! I wish her a good life.
@@AtomixIGN chill out white knight im with her but don’t act when you don’t have full context 🤦🏻♂️
@@skrt99 it’s Pakistan bro. What other context do you need.
For me the reason this cover by Johnny Cash is so emotional and relevant is that those who know Johnny's life story he suffered greatly from drugs, alcohol and family issues. The song has a deep connection to his actual life. Amazing cover and It is wonderful to see people of other cultures having an open mind and experiencing things from other cultures as we should also!
Johnny is one of the few artists that actually feels like everyone's dad, uncle, etc. It's almost like he has a one-on-one connection with every fan of his.
I can’t make it through this song without crying…seeing them react to it once he started singing just drives home how powerful this song with HIS voice was. The raw emotion he put into it is undeniable.
I'm with you I cannot make it through the song without crying
I am crying watching this. 😢
I ALWAYS cry to this song. Though Drugs are not my perticular addiction. I know the pain of hurting the ones I love. and this song HITS my sould EVERYTIME
Me too. This song also makes me cry every time.
Misty, I was a Johnny Cash tribute singer pre-covid for a handful of years, and every time I watch the Hurt video I almost bawl my eyes out. I don't know why, but I've never not shed a tear watching it. One of the most emotional music videos of all time.
And to think that Johnny's cover was so strong that once Trent heard it, he said it was no longer his song, but Johnny's. What a man.
That was definitely a respect move on both Men’s parts
To bad it's not his it's actually Trent's he shouldn't just give his song away like that the thought wasn't cash's
@@GeneralJiggle lol Trent had no platform no nothing so Trent is lucky John did this most are not lucky enough to have a song go out too millions
@@nunyabizz9804 both you and GR are such asshole.
GR, its not all about the damn money.
and Bizz, its not all about the damn fame.
This is about a man and his struggle while the other acknowledges the feat of said man did. Be respectful, ffs
@@neo7538 never said anything about money or anything nor was I being a asshole I just said Trent was lucky his voice was heard as most don’t get the chance specially ones with addiction so I guess you can say sorry for assuming cause after all what does that do makes a ass outta you not i
"The singer, or the writer?"
"Tell me about both."
A tribesman grasped what thousands of overly-tribal fans never could, that this song's story is that of both Reznor and Cash.
Exactly, kindred spirits.
The thing with the tribespeople like these in the video and even those in the middle of the Amazon they haven’t been corrupted by modern life as much as Cash’s fans. One day that’ll change but for now they still keep the pure wisdom of their ancestors.
Yes they sing about a common parallel in their lives. A threat that binds their souls.
I got chills! I love watching these good folk and this song is such a masterpiece but it is indeed both Johnny and Trents! They get it
I know this was a year ago, but someone else in the comments said it best, forgive me for paraphrasing a little;
"Claiming that one version of the song is better is not the answer. Both the original and Cash's cover are the same story, from different perspectives. Trent's version is from the perspective of a young man going through immediate sorrow, and Cash's version is from the perspective of an older man looking back on his life with regret." I think it's really beautiful how they said it.
Johnny Cash was a truly exceptional human being. He spoke for the underprivileged and disenfranchised every where. He was an honest singer and songwriter. There were no ‘performances’ just being in whatever state he was in a raw yet sensitive form. All were welcome to listen to his music and all can relate if they are brave enough to listen with their heart. If you do, there is a wealth of wisdom and wit in all of his songs.
That song makes me tear-up every time. Thanks Trent Reznor and Johnny Cash.
I was very touched by Parvati's words about her home life. She is a strong woman to endure this, my thoughts will be with her and her children. I hope things improve.
Can she leave her husband and his family? I doubt it.
same here.
I wish her all the best.
I was also touched and concerned. Stay strong Parvati for your children.
Parvati is a superhero.
@@j.h.3777 She would have nowhere to go except for her mother's home. Obviously that's not an option because of her brother. Also, I doubt she would be allowed to take her son with her.
Her sad situation reminds me how lucky I am to live in a place where women have their own agency.
The lady in the picture was Johnny's mother-in-law, the mother of his wife June. Johnny loved her very much, like his own mother. The beautiful, sorrowful lady on the stairs was his wife June. The sorrow she felt for her husband's pain is evident in her eyes and on her face. She died several months after the video was released. And Johnny died a few months after June. During his life and career, Johnny was addicted to drugs and alcohol, and was estranged from his wife and children. But he did recover from his addictions and reconcile with his wife and family. It takes a great deal of strength to give up drugs and alcohol, a great deal of strength to humbly ask forgiveness from one's wife and children, and it's a strong and loving woman who can forgive.
At 4:04 that is Cash’s mother. June’s mother is Mother Maybelle Carter
It was Johnny's strong faith in Jesus that saw him through his addictions and pain. Even in this video, you can see multiple references to his faith.
His wife was the woman standing behind him
And living with all of that regret is a difficult thing. 😢
bless you, Christine
"Follow such people who are full of love, ethics and values." A man who answered at the beginning regretting not having an education. Sir, thank you. YOU are more educated than WE ever will be. Much Love to you Sir and my respect.
I love how seriously they're able to analyze and reflect on something that is completely foreign to them with such honesty and openness.😊
Some things are foreign to no human
The human experience is more alike across cultures than it is different.
@@hdw237
"Nothing human is foriegn to us."
-Edward G. Robinson
^this?😊
@jonm2416 love that quote
They probably don't need to worry about offending others.
One thing i wish they included with this song is that when he played it for his daughter she cryed and said it sounds like you are trying to say goodbye. And he simply replied i am.
❤
Dude I’m literally crying right now.
This song and it’s connection to people cuts right to the bone.
When I heard it all I could think about was my deceased dad and my daughter (hopefully many) years down the road.
🚻
@@darthkorndog822 Me too, man. Me too.
I don’t know much about the man, but if what I understand about Johnny Cash is accurate I’d be willing to say that he’s easily one of the greatest men America has produced. A very profound man who held family and faith close to heart.
I truly enjoy watching all of their reactions, but I'm especially fond of Parvati. It's hard to describe, but there's a wholesomeness to her observations that is so touching. It's sad to think that she is going through what she is at home, and being blamed for the actions that are not her own. It also seemed that this song resonated with her on a deeper level...how we all "Hurt" in our own ways...how interesting it is to consider the similarities and differences in the human condition, no matter the culture or part of the world.
Spot on and so beautifully put
There's something about seeing a person show so much love and respect to a person they have never met that always brings a tear to my eye. That feeling that we are all family.
Chacha is so wonderful. I wish I could just hang out in his presence for a while. All of these people are so perceptive about the emotion behind the music. They understand the human experience and speak without hesitation.
The guy who runs this channel has been doing a phenomenal job lately.
One of the greatest covers ever done. Trent said when he first heard it, he kind of dismissed it as just a cover (he was in the middle of touring and working), and it wasn’t until he took the time to really listen to it that it’s revelatory power struck him and he realized what a complete work of genius it was. Now he absolutely loves it.
I myself consider this the greatest cover ever.
What would be your top 3?
@@Dhardy316 Hurt - Johnny Cash, Rise - Boyce Avenue, Just A Dream - Sam Tsui & Christina Grimmie
Reznor said that he no longer owns the song and that Johnny Cash made it his own.
@@beworgen Really? I would for sure put Hallelujah by Jeff Buckley in my top 3.
@@pittaaaabread I prefer the Leonard Cohen version. It shares a lot of qualities with this cover.
What I like about them is their genuine wisdom and how easily they can talk. I really wish them happy and long life.
Thank you for this sir. It's very interesting to see other cultures react to the music that I love personally. Every time I hear this song I cry. It's so relatable and it moves you and you can see it. It moved them as well. Which is exactly what Johnny Cash was trying to do. Rest in peace Mr. Cash.❤
"Surgeons of behavior." That is such a powerful line, truly. Very well said and so, so true. You go to a surgeon to get help in fixing something that is broken, and if your behavior and thoughts and feelings are what's broken, who better to turn to than such positive, wholesome and healthy models of what it means to be a good person like Mister Rogers or Bob Ross, etc. They can teach you things that you might be too afraid to ask or talk to your own parents about and that is such an important fact.
I liked the analogy of the surgeon, too.
Seeing this gives me just a little hope for the world, you know?
As a recovering opiate/heroin addict who lost the love of her life and who has endured enough tragedy and pain for 10 peoples lifetimes this song makes me weep like a baby every single solitary time. It doesn't matter if it's Trent...Johnny or Sevendust (my fav).
The military started me on my addiction to opioids and psychotropics because of chronic pain from injuries and ptsd. After 8 yrs I got off them using cannabis. In 10 yrs I lost my parents, sibling and 8 other family members, I was still an addict when I lost my mom and even though i was there I really wasn't there. In those 10 yrs I also lost over a dozen military brothers and sisters to suicide or overdose. I still have "my" bullet sitting on a shelf, I carved my initials in it and daily look at it as a reminder of where I was. I'm glad you got off that poison. Keep them in your heart and live for their memory.
@@fmfdocbotl4358 when you say “where I was” I hope you mean it (“was”), I hope you’re no longer feeling hopeless. Please reach out if you need someone to talk to. You’re worth fighting for.
@@sondra4789 it's something I live with. During the pandemic I been staying home and the whole thing justified why I hate people, because they just think about themselves and not others.
I now your pain to well. Addiction is a soul twisting experience. And who is affected is like waves in the ocean.
My absolute fave too…Johnny Johnny Cash, Y’all!
Amazing! The "Needle" was also a reference to the imprisonment he felt by needing almost constant insulin injections. He had such advanced diabetes that he was almost blind and crippled from it. It ultimately killed him from complications of it. Love hearing these people's opinions. Excellent!!
Lmao no? The song was written by a heroin addict named Trent Reznor
These wonderful people are so wise and kind, they are so honest and open it is a breath of fresh air to watch x
Breaks my heart when I hear Parvati talk about her home. She's strong, I wish her and her family all the best. I'm glad she's learning new things from this channel, and I hope her life can continually improve.
That goes for the whole crew you have here, they are all so amazing, glad this channel is helping them so much.
I think that if she was born into a different life she would be a total badass. I realized that the day she talked about how much she liked Metallica.
@@flamoby right! 👍⚡⚡
@@flamoby and how she likes it LOUD!
@@flamoby I totally LOVED how she got into that! Girls night out if she came here to Canada!!
And it's helping us, as well (if I make speak for others here). Amazing insight in other cultures and people!
Every time I hear Johnny Cashes cover Hurt, I tear up and feel a big wave of pain. I can hear the pain in his voice as he relays the message. Rest in peace Johnny Cash 😢😢❤❤.
It's so beautiful, how they can all feel the song. Parvati and Muharam especially, so touching. We all need to listen to more music together...it would help forget the little differences!
I love the Tribal People. So much honesty, sincerity, mercy, sobriety, strength and thoughtfulness. Blessings to all of them.
Just messaging here, I do think the traits you said here are some things I need to learn for myself..^^;
@@Bladespeedy traits everybody could learn.
Sobriety?? One out of 6 admitted he was smoking heroin for years. wtactualf.
EDIT: 10:30, sorry, two heroin addicts mentioned in 7mins.
2nd EDIT:12:40 3 ADDICTS IN 8-9mins, paragons of sobriety, addiction doesn't care how much you fantasise about a group of people somehow escaping the problems people have and will have since we started walking on 2c legs, also animals suffer from addiction too, so basically since life on Earth began, keep up the casual racism though, it's cute,
@@likelemmyidabasest3882 Sobriety means something completely different in this context mate
@@zeallust8542 really? What?
I met Johnny Cash and his wife June when I was a teenager, after a concert they did in Colorado. They were both wonderful, down to Earth people. My father listened to his music all the time when I was growing up, so
I have great affection for his music today as a grown woman, especially this song. You are so very missed Mr. Cash. God rest your soul.
My grandmother met him in the 80's with my grandfather. They are both in heaven. I miss them dearly.
@@lukephillips4123 such wonderful people, both of them. The world became a bit more dim when they passed on.
I met him and June about a year before June died. I agree that they were both very friendly, down to earth people. I've met and worked for a lot of celebs over the years, and they were probably the highlight of my life. I'm in no way a country music fan, but Johnny is a legend, and deserves a great deal of respect for that but, more importantly, the kind and gentle man that he was, even after 50 years of fame.
Oh WOW!!! You are blessed ..
@@SundaysChild1966 yes I truly am. I have fond memories of meeting him and his wife. I have the photos somewhere. The man is a legend, yet was so humble, kind, caring and giving of his time.
Moved beyond words, both by the melancolic song, and by the wise and touching comments of the people whome you presented it to.
Truly in the greatest depths of my soul, I cannot determine which version of this song I love the most. They both hit so brutally. Trent Reznor’s version has always spoken to where I am currently, in whatever despair I feel. It emphasizes the pain and is so raw that makes me feel alive-like hurting oneself might. It changed apathy into anguish, and i want that sometimes. Cash’s version makes me feel so full of sorrow for him and for how long he suffered, but the building tension and more epic quality actually gives me a glimmer of hope: that maybe I can learn, and not live my whole lifetime paralyzed by depression. It makes me realize how incredible NOT worth it it is to go down the familiar spiral. What is comfortable in the short term while waste your years on earth. I believe Cash covered this song specifically to tell us, from the perspective of an older man, exactly that. I am so grateful to both artists for the honesty with which they did this song.
"You can't buy it sir" He said it with such conviction. He knew he was speaking wisdom
I was very moved by the empathy and kindness of the tribal people. This version of "Hurt is very beautiful."
Johnny Cash would have loved these tribal people.
Agreed! Empathy is a very beautiful trait to have ❤
This version of hurt puts a lump in my throat every time
Their words chocked me up; however, the salute broke the damn. It is proof that music truly can bridge the gaps and bring people together. Thank you, for what you are doing. Blessed Be!
@@NCAdventuress he might have done a live show for them 🙂
Whenever I see these videos, I always feel like Abdul knows so much about the things that he sees already, and almost sense a feeling of thankfulness that the world knows these things that he has learnt. He strikes me as a very wise and thoughtful man, and it’s amazing that he enjoys doing these videos and learning still even as an old soul.
This song was a part of my childhood. My father listened to that album on loop after my grandfather died, so it is a very strong memory in my life. My family had generational alcohol issues on my fathers side, but I was lucky my life was overall good. But to see people of other nations and walks of life hear it, listen to it, and take it in like a first time... it was everything to see and listen to their takes on Mr. Cash's version of Hurt.
Nothing hurt my heart so unexpectedly like hearing Parvati speaking one of her truths by connecting her experience to the lyrics of this song. I was not prepared to digest someone else's pain aside from the focus being on Johnny Cash. Wow, powerful. I want to feel sad for her or her situation but it doesn't feel like the correct emotion. I'm feeling proud of this channel and of Parvati. Yo go girl! Thank you to this channel in particular for finding a way for my heart to connect with hers.
I've been a fan for a while, always love the personalities, and the wisdom and thinking from the guests reacting. I feel a fondness for them all and unconsciously had my favorites....but damn. Parvati stole this show in an instant for me.
Individual truth is a lie. She was relating her experience in life and how it made her feel. I'll never understand why that wasn't good enough for people, so much so they had to change personal experience to personal truth.
@@brahtrumpwonbigly7309 uh what?
@@lualady936 He’s expressing his distaste for the use of “personal truth” when “personal experience” could be used instead. Given that there is no such thing as personal truth, I understand where he’s coming from.
@@GraysonMckernan I'm not understanding from either response how or why a personal truth is not acceptable to use as I did. Saying someone has shared a personal experience or personal truth in my mind is one in the same and I honestly used personal truth as it felt more powerful than experience. Experience as a word imo has lost a lot meaning and has become watered down and dismissive in a way. "Well in my experience...." or "applicants must have 5+ years of industry experience.."
My brain naturally prepares to disregard it and in a way subconsciously I wanted to convey that I accepted what it was she shared as I think there is tendency to take everything someone has to say about abuse with a grain of salt or just flat out no believe. like maybe it's not legally defined as abuse in one country and is in another. I don't know her circumstances nor would I want to try to pick it apart as to why our why not it was abuse.
Both replies are from people telling me personal truth is not correct. If I believe Jesus is the only saviour, that's my personal truth. It's not the truth or the only truth because there's many religions. If I say my personal truth is living with an abusive spouse despite in-laws taking the spouses side, I'd argue both experience and personal truth would be acceptable to use. I by no means am trying to say personal truth is an objective truth.
I just want to understand the thinking, clearly there's more than one person who feels this way and I cant comprehend why there is no such thing as a personal truth? Haha sorry I'm not satisfied with it doesn't exist.
@@lualady936 Truth implies something that can be proven and is universally accepted. Someone’s personal experiences and outlook on life is unique to that person and is not something that can necessarily be proven or disproven. Therefore there can be no such thing as “personal truth”. The statement contradicts itself.
This song always makes me cry. It was amazing to get to see people watch it for the very first time. Thank you for that
I cry like a baby... every time. Even telling others to watch it, thinking about it...
I am sorry the director didn't point out his wife, June, who wasn't intended to be in the video, and died soon after filming... that look of love and understanding...
Me too. There is just another song that makes me wet eyed and that is Nightwish - Nemo.
In an interview with Roseanne Cash who cried when she heard this album and this song. She said to her dad, " It sounds like you're saying goodbye." Johnny replied, "I am"
Same, I'm always crying after.. doesn't happen with any other song..
I love how respectful and also curious these individuals are. To want to understand fully the ideas and feelings being portrayed and to actively listen. I love music in the fact it can transcend barriers and languages. We may not know what is being said, but we can feel the emotions conveyed. The power of music is something that has been around for ages and it still ceases to amaze me it’s evocative nature.
Watching these videos feels like a philosophy course on the true meaning of life and on what is really important. The people in them are so wise, honest and kind. I am learning so much from what they say. It is amazing how one can share the same values as someone living in an entirely different country or culture. I wish many blessings to the kind people in these videos. ❤️
Im really sad to hear that about Parv. It was actually quite heartbreaking to hear that at the end of the video. Please let her know that a lot of us here in the west a million miles over think she seems like a wonderful wife and mother
I feel worried for her safety for that information to be out in public like this.
I'm not the one to do it, but we should send Parvati + kids to Europe/the US.
She's so nice, and strong. She deserves a new beginning.
@@melmueller-spude8467 She has also expressed in multiple videos how she wants to see a zoo, and an airport. She longs exploration and freedom... I felt really sad about this whole thing.
@@razorian100 At least she gets some type of exploration from watching and discussing these videos.
What is beautiful about this song was even after all he accomplished “his empire of dirt” the things he valued most was his wife.
She was special, she had a voice like a bell and it was hard to find amidst all the noise
It would be fun to show them Johnny and June singing "Jackson" together in their prime, as a contrast. Something tells me they would get a kick out of the lyrics, too - it's a universal story, LOL.
Dude, I work for EXTREMELY WEALTHY people.
THEY ALL SAY THE SAME THING
"THEY WASTED THEIR HEALTH ATTAINING WEALTH, THEN WASTED ALL THE WEALTH TRYING TO PROLONG THEIR HEALTH"
Holy moly, I hadn't really processed this song in this way until this video. Thank you for putting this out there and sharing it.
This is so beautiful. The song is amazing. But the reactions just add another layer. It just shows the power of wonderful music. It can transcend language barriers. Hearing them all give such heartfelt and truthful responses as well as sharing such open and honest views about depression and regret was beautiful. It's nice to hear people speak about that subject with such integrity and courage.
The song was originally about the downward spiral of a young mans with drugs. Johnny Cash made his version to give the feeling of a man at his lifes end. The needle for illness and pain, the loss of things he loved, his regrets.
I love this song from both perspectives
this version of Johnny Cash is so deep, so breathtaking, goosbumps bringing... I believe him every word... It brings me to tears every time I hear this version..
It is easily his opus magnum.
He is not the creator, it’s cover, written by Trent Reznor. This “version” of Johnny cash doesn’t exist, these aren’t his words.
@@uncomfortablynumb9800 that’s a terrible take. It absolutely his version. It’s his inflection, his vocals, his instrumentals, his tempo.
@@uncomfortablynumb9800 we all know, that the original is from Nine Inch Nails. But the cover (-version) of Johnny Cash is for me (just my personal opinion) much more intense than the original.
@@sonnenkoenigreich Just don’t forget to give credit where it’s due. The original song is from NIN. The interpretation is certainly Cash’s
11:14 Johnny was granted many gift, but he felt remorse and regret for what he decided to do with said gifts- I feel that is why he was able to do this song so well, in my opinion.
This song still gives me chills even after all these years
The absolute best reaction video ever! Johnny Cash's rendition of Hurt, clearly speaks truth to every gender, age, race, nation, and religion. R.I.P. Legend.
"But the time has gone by now sir". That simple, beautiful statement brought tears to my eyes. As someone with PTSD and for those out there who suffer as well, it is so easy for us to live in the past. But what this man summed up in eight words is EXACTLY what we need to remember. The bad times have passed, and so long as our mind is occupied with the past we lose our ability to focus on the good times yet to come. This song is being sung by a man who is haunted by his past, consumed with it, and ultimately robbed by it. It robs us the HERE and the NOW, and our ability to actively engage in meaningful relationships. We cannot start again a million miles away, but we can start again with the next step. I hope this writing helps someone who is currently suffering from PTSD or any traumatic life experiences present or past. "When life leaves us blind, love keeps us kind" - Chester Bennington
You said clearly what I've been trying to say for over 30+ years.
I'm 55 (2022), suffer from PTSD (multiple reasons why). I've been stuck over half my life in past trauma. I've only recently began to find a way out.
I'm telling people to look forward, not back.
Steve Harvey told an anecdote that helps me a lot....
_"Think of life from the view you have in your car. Look how big the windshield is. So you can see everything in front of you._
_Now look in your rear view mirror. Look how small it is compared to the windshield._
_That's because what's ahead of you is more important than what's behind you._
_Don't focus on the past, or you're miss what's up ahead!"_
These words left me speechless. I watched them several times a day, for weeks, until I had them memorized. I still find myself looking back sometimes, but when I do, I remind myself to look ahead!
Thank you so much for taking the time to write. Yes it's really helpful. I'm making progress but I'm seeking professional counselling to get me out of this PTSD trap of social anxiety and the worry that it could happen again, and the insomnia and comfort eating. I'm doing my own healing, getting involved in nature, Earthing, trekking, gardening, praying, meditating, self care treatments, going out with friends. Support of friends and family is so crucial. Even though I've became a bit of an introvert, I need that contact. God bless us all, and give us the strength to get through and thrive v soon 🙏🏽
@@PurePeacePower I am so happy to know my words have helped so many others
I keep that sentiment in my head often, with the phrase
This too shall pass
It helping me right now through some difficult times in my life, and has helped me before
Although I sometimes amend it when things are really rough
This too shall pass, it might pass like a kidney stone, but it will pass
Dear Jimmy, thank for your precious words. They help me a lot in my present situation. I bless your soul, life, family and you being here. Theodor from Germany
I truly enjoy your discussions, thoughts and insightfulness, thank you for sharing these videos with us☺
This is a beautiful concept for content … music breaks all barriers. It’s a form of communication, of articulating oneself.
Parvati is an absolutely amazing heroic woman. Just saying.
I was more feeling sad for her. Feels like she is stuck in a situation with no way out.
@@BmanNL1 Indeed. But as Johnny sings in another video, she won't back down. The fact that she actually appears on these reaction videos despite the opposition she faces from some around her is a sign of strength. I wish I could help her, but I admire her immensely. She knows who she is. Having seen her with her children it's obvious she is a great mother.
@@blindknitter Right? I wish MY mother had been even half as good as Parvati is to and for her children. I sit much straighter, shoulders back, chin out, and smiling because of Parvati's strength she has shown here. It's a terrible thing to find yourself having to walk such a fine line as she is. I do not envy her this. But I am proud of her. So proud, I think my heart just might burst. She is a warrior and a queen, and I am so grateful for her strength and love for all of us. Parvati is an example we would all do well to emulate. God love her and bless her. 💚
@@xMarque101x the saddest part of the entire video. I didn't know.
I imagine that she likes doing these videos as this may be the only place where she can open up and speak more freely. I hope her husband or anyone else from where she lives become aware of anything she says as that may place her in danger, or she may not be allowed to keep doing the videos. She is, along with the others, having her eyes opened up, this is an education for all of them.
Wow. This one hit hard. That "My Husband is abusive" comment is a cry for help. Please TRYBALS, please take care of this beautiful woman (Parvati) and her children if it's within your power. Protect them. No matter the culture, equality is vital. No women or man should have to live in fear of the ones they love day after day. That's not love. That's hell.
I know Mark, but I am not allowed to interfere. If I do, she'd not even be able to come here at all. Things are really complicated for women of her tribe. It's not just Parvati but every women within Bheels in Sindh. I know it's sad but it's true for most of the time 😕
@@TRYBALS I understand. Thank you for all you do for these beautiful people. I'm certain it's more than most are capable of. If we can change one mind to treat others better through example, we can change others. One day at a time.
It is a very delicate situation, it's not as simple of just taking her away from this situation. Their culture centres heavily around their beliefs. Divorcing is heavily frowned upon and those who do are shunned.
@@Sword420 I think what this channel is doing for her (giving her money and showing her things that she would never see before) is helping her more than what the channel owner could do by interfering. Just my 2 cents.
@@ivanho34 THIS!
This channel is giving her a source of income, a place to express herself honestly, and the information to understand the injustice she faces.
That is all she needs. That is all our feminist ancestors needed to start changing our culture. And there is a good reason Parvati’s in-laws are worried about her coming to make these videos. They know she is capable of acting on the ideas she is exposed to here. They know she could be a leader in making changes. She reminds me a lot of my own rabble-rousing feminist ancestors, and she isn’t facing anything they didn’t.
I am taking a language and cultures class right now and this immediately made me think of it. Such an interesting concept for a video, I’ve watched so many reactions to this song but none as unique as this. I commend the people that went through the effort of translating and explaining this song to them, great job!
It doesn't matter who you are, what your race is, or what your language is, everyone can understand the emotions that music can bring to people
I will remember the phrase “surgeons of behavior.” What an insightful expression! The people you surround yourself with are your surgeons, as well as those you respect highly. Thank you for this thought. 🙏
I thought the same thing when I heard that! Genius!
It has another meaning as well, When it comes down to it, there is no one else you trust more then your Surgeon. Because they are literally holding your life in their hands. And translating such an analogy gives a nice topic. Like, when it comes to such good hearted people, you're opening yourself, giving your trust, for someone who can shape your behavior in an amazing way.
I love this song. I loved Nine Inch Nails version but Johnny Cash's version just brought out emotions that is hard to escape from. Trent Reznor said, after listening to Johnny's version, that it was no longer his song; it belonged to Johnny Cash now. Just a little correction, the woman in the photo was Johnny's mother. Johnny's wife was the one standing on the staircase. Her name is June Carter Cash who was also a wonderful singer and sang with Johnny as well. June died shortly after the release of this version. Johnny died about 4 months after her. It's said that even though he had health complications, he just couldn't live without her.
Splicing in the footage of him as a younger man I think also adds a lot to the music video.
I'm not sure I'd believe it but I know of a man who lost his will to live after his beloved wife passed. I felt poorly for his kids and grandchildren.
It has been proven that you can actually die of a broken heart
Trent said that after watching the video, when he first listened to the song he wasn't impressed. Nor should he have been, Rubin butchered his arrangement.
npyh vers are abpit different age/stage in life. origanal is about escaping drug addiction and depression as a young man and cashes version is about a old man coming to terms with his life ending
such a powerful song. still is. it's a timeless classic
This is a genuine step in bringer the world closer. Well done, love from Belgium!
"Follow such people who are full of love, ethics and values, consider them as your surgeons, Surgeons of behavior"
This spoke to me in a way not many words do, Thankyou.
Johnny Cash's rendition is so hauntingly beautiful it just moves me to tears. Its a song that you don't need to understand the lyrics to feel. Considering this song released in 2002 a year before he died, it is one of the greatest goodbye songs ever written.
For real. And the fact that it came out only a few months after his wife’s passing (a fact I didn’t know) makes it so much harder to listen to.
Very well said!
She actually died a few months after he recorded this
Every time I listen to a reaction I hear a different perspective on I’m the meaning of the lyrics. Some talk about his loathing for his wife, some his addiction to drugs, others his fleeting fame. He truly did do the song justice and I’d say a perfect song to sum up his life
Honestly. Every time he goes “What” in “What have I become?”, I got insane chills. I was almost violently shaking from it the first time I heard it, then “…have I become” came in, and that’s when the frisson turned into an overwhelming welling in myself it just had to escape out of my eyes.
I play lots of guitar, this song is the one that will make me bawl my eyes out all over my strings. Every time. Sung or Unsung
The gentleman in the red vest is my favorite. So kind, so understanding, so empathetic ❤❤❤❤
I really like this channel. I just discovered it right now.
Watching these videos makes me feel a deep love and respect for the people being interviewed.
The "Surgeons of Behavior" quote was the most profound reaction I have ever heard in my life! I was so deeply moved by his words I began to cry...
ya took the words right out of my mouth bud
Could you explain me this quote please, english is not my native language
Me too.
@@bamblille872 He is saying that people should allow people like Mr. Rogers and Bob Ross to heal your behavior like a surgeon would heal your body.
@@paulpardee aah ok thanks
I wish I could give Parvati the biggest hug. She is precious.
It was interesting how the guy, the record label guy, who suggested the cover, was the same man who convinced him to join the label by letting him finally put out his own music and thoughts. As opposed to the entertainment number he had been for the record labels earlier in his career. I think he was very thankful of that, that he got the revive his career and make it bigger by his own thing.
They had insightful thoughts to share.
well done guys! i think this speaks to the universality of music and how the emotions of a song have no cultural or language barriers, it transcends everything and the raw emotion of it speaks to us all
I remember listening to the original version by nine inch nails for years. How unpopular it was in mainstream. Johnny Cash really captured this song beautifully, and made me cry a bit. But the effect was that everyone was able to enjoy this song, and not be locked down because of musical taste.
The original has the curse words, which serve a powerful role when used sincerely.
It was pretty popular where i was back then 🤷🏻♂️
@@tylerp3397 same
Even though the JC version comes from a place in his heart that you can feel and is a phenomenal cover. I still will always prefer the NIN version
It's funny because the NIN, and Cash version both have completely different meanings, at least for me. NIN is singing about a young heroin addict who's driven away everyone, and addiction has stolen everything from him, leaving him broken, and destitute. Johnny Cash's version is about an old man at the end of his life, looking back with many regrets, and lamenting that of all the money, everything he does have is now useless, and would trade it just to have his loved ones back, and maybe even making different choices to not end up like that again.
You can clearly see how moved they all were. Especially the older man really grasped Jonnies' music and felt/understood his pain
He saw Johnny's past through his eyes. He was the only one staring at the screen as if he were watching something that was breaking his heart.
Thank you for sharing Mr. Cash's song to the world. He is one of my best favorite song artist and the message of "hurt" relates to my life and what I go through. I have been listening to his album for the past weeks and just shed a few tears as i listen to this song today. Keep up the good work my friend!
- Greetings from the Nevada Desert, USA!🤠🏜🏕
Watching this brings every emotion to my soul...
In addition, music unites EVERY ONE OF US 🙏🏻💜
Pavarti is such a deep thinker. She's so thoughtful and she takes in so much of this. I love her perspective most of all.
I truly admire these men and women. Clarity of thought and morals. God bless them.
So true
Uncorrupted.
Love your channel and all the nuggets of wisdom provided by the panel. Music is truly universal! We can all feel and relate no matter the language all that is needed is an open mind and an open heart. God bless!
This song really makes you think about life and how short it is, just the fact that fame, family, friends and a relationship goes away in the end really just kicks in and makes you want to cry
I was an addict in the early 2000's and I just remember playing this version and also Trent Reznors on repeat because addiction is so so lonely and the song spoke to me directly to say "Hey, you're not alone. What you are feeling is valid, and you are not alone in this." That sentiment is what really carried me through the darkest times in my life.
When I was deep in my addiction this was one of my go to songs as well. It said the same thing to me as it did to you. And after being sober for almost 5 years this song still touches my heart deeply.
Everyone is an addict of something, just some proverbial drugs in life aren't as damaging while others are worse.
@@nocturnal101ravenous6 Ain't that the truth. Some are addicted to drugs, alcohol, and obviouslly damaging stuff. Others are addicted to lying, of hurting people, themselves or otherwise. "Everyone is drunk on something"
Why are you doing this to me?
Am I not living up to what I'm supposed to be?
Why am I seething with this animosity?
(Hey god) I think you owe me a great big apology
I can't ever make it through this song without crying my eyes out. He reminded me of my dad who was also a musician who also passed away shortly after my mom did. 2 weeks... So I get it. He has real pain when he sang this and I feel an unbearable ache in my heart for him and myself. Rest now...
Same...every single time, no matter with or without the video, i cry my eyes out
I absolutely loved everyone who was listening to the song in this video. They were so open to the music and honest in their responses. ❤
This is the fist of your videos I watched. I love them all, the views of these folks are amazing and insightful. Thank you!!!!
This is one of the most genuine, unique channels. Rather than just “reactions” we get to hear the thoughts and insights of people who seem more attuned to the nature of man, the ebb and flow of religion and the wisdom to understand what or who can bring happiness to others and themselves. I myself do not understand the traditions that Pravati and her children live within. I admire her strength to live beyond barriers and instill kindness and love in her children, that is not easy, but she puts her children first. Thank you all for sharing parts of yourselves and your lives with us that watch your channel. 💜
That is the draw of this channel for me. I enjoy hearing their perspectives.
This was amazing. Mohammad brought tears to my eyes with his wise words about Mr. Rogers and Bob Ross. I also loved the older man's thoughts about gratitude ~ appreciating what we have rather than focusing on what we don't have. It's amazing how this song allowed the shy woman to open up about her situation ~ I hope she can get some help and support. 🙏 And I loved the screen where we can see all the reactions at once.
Can you imagine the smile that would have put on My. Rogers face as he thanked deeply thanked him for his words and told him loved him?
Loved that surgeons of behavior line, odd but it makes sense.
Watching these people from different people watch songs that are pillars of my culture and it really resonates with them as well, that's a really connecting feeling.
These are very pure reactions something I haven’t seen in reaction channels in along long time🖤
I love Parvati 🥺💜 she's a strong woman for all she puts up with outside of the channel, Adnan please try to keep her safe sometimes I really worry about her but I get it things are different on your side of the world 🌎
What does she put up with outside of the channel?
@@LordVader1094 abuse from her husband and in-laws, restriction from men outside of her family, things like that
@@LordVader1094 i think towards the end is when she mentions her husband gets abusive
@@LordVader1094 she mentions it o n 12:34
@@LordVader1094 Not to mention that in a previous reaction video, she mentioned how much flack she catches from neighbors etc. just for going to the studio as a married woman. In the west, we are able to do as we please, so it's difficult to imagine a place where the disapprobation of your inlaws and neighbors can have such a strong hold on one's life.
"Wow, bro, wow", wasn't expecting to start crying watching this. This video here is the First time I heard the song (sang or covered by any artist, was totally new to me) so that in and of itself was obviously emotional, but hearing the stories and thoughts shared. My heart aches for Parvarti I really hope that she continues to do this channel because she adds a great deal and is much loved by us viewers. I feel sad though, as she has mentioned a couple of times now how her neighbours and in-laws badmouth her and it seems she has little autonomy at home - her father in law changes or turns down quiet her music, her neighbours (and in-laws) make "backbiting" comments, her own husband and father of their children, her babies, puts his own wants first, I was shocked at hearing that he prevents his small child from eating the breakfast his mother lovingly prepares for him to instead get him cigarettes and even light them for him! That his family defend and condone such behaviours. She can state so matter of factly that her husband is abusive, and she doesn't have to hand any of the support systems like exist in my country, to help her. And on top of all that, and being a mother, and her work, she has the worry and stress of her brother having an addiction and stealing from their mother.
She has expressed in previous videos that she feels a lot of stress, and clearly she feels some guilt that has been put upon her, it is not a burden of her making, but then she feels the weight and is then regretful if she is short tempered with her children.
Just imagine how you would feel if instead of hearing Parvati telling this, imagine it is your sister, or best friend, or daughter etc, how you would feel, what you would say and do right away, to try and start to help... I feel like that, but I have no way of helping, no idea what to say or do if there even is anything.
I remember hearing this song when it first came out and that it had a profound effect on me. Hearing it here now, I was basically sobbing. There’s just something about the vibe and the emotions conveyed in this song. The message touches the soul.
Yeah, this was a VERY powerful video, wich it makes sense, both versions of the song are as well, but Mister Cash's version is soul penetratingly powerful.
LOVED the original. Johnny did it very well also.
@@salahad-din4114 that last part would have to be left to taste. As much as I liked Johnny's version, no one can present the full emotion like the person who wrote it.
I believe Johnny only sold more due to his higher fame.
@@salahad-din4114not an attack in any way, but a big part of that is environmental. Have they heard any NIN before or since, or been around anyone who liked NIN.
Johnny's version was more "relatable" due to the type of music. There are many that will hate the real version, simply due to the style of his music.
Unfortunately this world puts WAY too much emphasis on how someone looks. Not the thoughts they can add to the world.
"Follow such people who are full of love, ethics and values..."
Such a great thing to hear! Thanks!
I had a young girl come to my nurses office, about 11 years ago. She was a “cutter”, when I told her I understood it was an outer expression of an inner pain, everyone around her ignored, she was surprised. Till I showed her. We all suffer, some people are just forced to do it alone, because their parents teach them that. Please, only have the children you can love. RIP JC. Your suffering is done.