My unpopular opinion is that the best adaptation of The Lightning Thief is not the movie nor the show, but the musical. I know it was a bit different from the book's, but it still felt like the most faithful adaptation. The dynamics between the trio were on point, the humour was as flawless as in the book, and they recreated every iconic scene brilliantly. Plus the songs were all amazing and they managed to make a Bianca cameo. Love this musical so much, it should get more recognition.
Piper is actually one of my favorite characters. I thought she was really annoying at first, but by HoH and BoO, I genuinely cared for her character. I really enjoyed her relationship with Annabeth after she got out of Tartarus. She doesn't act as a pick me normally would to another girl. She comforts Annabeth and even sees in her point of view when they are facing the giant. She realizes that even though the giant is making her see horrible things, what Annabeth is going through is far worse, and she needs to focus on getting them both out rather than dwelling on her own thoughts.
Omg i didnt expect her to see my opinion. Thank u tho fur noticing my comment. Also kinda in defense fur piper, shes pretty badass in the books, like yes ur right she is a pick me to jason (altho i dont personally see whats interesting abt him) but theres moments in books 3 to 5 where shes left alone to handle things and she handled it pretty cool. Like when khione invaded the argo 2 and she had to charmspeak them out of there, and the chained heartbeat of a god where even annabeth couldnt get herself together so it was up to piper again, and the part where percy and annabeth were captured in book 5 , where she again had to save them and hold off the monsters until the argo 2 came, and lastly the part where percy,jason,and her went down the nymphs cave and were nesrly gonna die and drown but she saved them by saying to give the nymphs their all. Sorry fur the long comment u dont have to read it rlly, i feel happy already that u noticed my comment, just here to say pipers a cool character in my opinion, i feel like pipers issue is her personality cause there r times where shes like annabeth like and there r times where her personalitys bland but theres potential fur her i think. Thank you thank you thank you again for noticing my comment.❤❤❤❤❤❤
Ok, but I do think that Piper and Jason were good together. It was a good ship, and even though they broke up, during HOO they were really good together. The only reason they broke up in the trials of Apollo (I think) is because they didn’t know how to work together as a normal couple without constantly having to fight monsters and save the world.
that wasn’t the only reason. piper is actually lesbian i believe (i thought she was pan but my friend told me she was lesbian) and therefore isn’t attracted to jason. they were only a couple because hera had tricked piper into believing they were actually together through the mist while jason was actually getting his memory wiped. after jason gained his memories back and went on quests with her (TLH) and fell for her, and she at the time was excited because of the mist that had faked their relationship. in many of the books in HoO, though, she mentions how they aren’t that good of a pair and that they don’t understand each other many times.
That is true, but in the sun and the star, piper tells Nico that she was attracted to Jason and she genuinely like him. And I'm pretty sure that piper didn't know that she was lesbian at the time of the breakup, so while Hera did trick them into believing that they were a couple they still chose to be together.
@@Lunamoon144yippie actually rick has Piper as no actual flag. She says "If I don't ever love another guy does that make me lesbian?" Although I do see your point about their relationship Piper isn't sure what she is. that's great not everyone is sure. And I think it was Piper wasn't sure if she actually did like Jason or was it the fake memories or Hera and she wanted to figure it out before continuing or not wanting to play Jason along
People see a girl being herself without shoving it up to other people's throats and go "hm yeah that seems like a pick me" Leave the girl alone 😭 she didn't do any harm. So yeah, she's pretty without trying? No shit. Her mother is Aphrodite what did you expect? People hate on her for NOTHING. It's okay to not like a character or hate them sure but calling the character insults about something they aren't even being is something else. And I'm betting you most of them are down bad for Jason or Jason and Leo shippers that are pissed off because the two got together :/ Justice for Piper
it was but i hate hera 😭 it was risky and she knew it and i get that it was needed but she’s also spiteful and hates annabeth, and preaches about things she doesn’t even care about such as “family”
My opinion on Piper is: I love her, I will defend her, nothing can make me hate her. ELABORATING: I never saw her as a pick me. She never put other girls down for male validation, or searched for any sort of unnecessary attention. She wants the attention she didn’t get when she was a child, and that doesn’t make her a pick me. I liked Jasper fine, but it’s def not an OTP or anything seeing as they were put together because Hera.
my unpopular opinion is that i am not a luke apologist. i understand the point he was trying to make and that he was basically possessed. but i will never forgive him for what he did to those kids especially annabeth
I don’t like piper live Jason relationship was toxic. STOP READING IF HAVE NOT READ TRIALS OF APOLLO SPOILERS!!!!!! Jason didn’t deserve to die piper could’ve I would of liked it better
I mean I love Piper but yeah, her death would've been more of a plot twist and make the story better since there's really a pattern about who uncle Rick kills in each series
She isn't a pick me, she just wants the attention she never got growing up
I totally agree
That- omg…. 😳 😧
AGREED
My unpopular opinion is that the best adaptation of The Lightning Thief is not the movie nor the show, but the musical. I know it was a bit different from the book's, but it still felt like the most faithful adaptation. The dynamics between the trio were on point, the humour was as flawless as in the book, and they recreated every iconic scene brilliantly. Plus the songs were all amazing and they managed to make a Bianca cameo. Love this musical so much, it should get more recognition.
Same! I love the musical!
“i’ll save my mom and save the planet!!!”
same!
Do you know where I can see the whole musical ?
@@user-KK812 there are some fully filmed on yt
I love Piper. Shes such a girlboss! 💕
Piper is actually one of my favorite characters. I thought she was really annoying at first, but by HoH and BoO, I genuinely cared for her character. I really enjoyed her relationship with Annabeth after she got out of Tartarus. She doesn't act as a pick me normally would to another girl. She comforts Annabeth and even sees in her point of view when they are facing the giant. She realizes that even though the giant is making her see horrible things, what Annabeth is going through is far worse, and she needs to focus on getting them both out rather than dwelling on her own thoughts.
Omg i didnt expect her to see my opinion. Thank u tho fur noticing my comment. Also kinda in defense fur piper, shes pretty badass in the books, like yes ur right she is a pick me to jason (altho i dont personally see whats interesting abt him) but theres moments in books 3 to 5 where shes left alone to handle things and she handled it pretty cool. Like when khione invaded the argo 2 and she had to charmspeak them out of there, and the chained heartbeat of a god where even annabeth couldnt get herself together so it was up to piper again, and the part where percy and annabeth were captured in book 5 , where she again had to save them and hold off the monsters until the argo 2 came, and lastly the part where percy,jason,and her went down the nymphs cave and were nesrly gonna die and drown but she saved them by saying to give the nymphs their all. Sorry fur the long comment u dont have to read it rlly, i feel happy already that u noticed my comment, just here to say pipers a cool character in my opinion, i feel like pipers issue is her personality cause there r times where shes like annabeth like and there r times where her personalitys bland but theres potential fur her i think. Thank you thank you thank you again for noticing my comment.❤❤❤❤❤❤
Piper is my second favorite after annabeth. Piper is mis understood.
Ok, but I do think that Piper and Jason were good together. It was a good ship, and even though they broke up, during HOO they were really good together. The only reason they broke up in the trials of Apollo (I think) is because they didn’t know how to work together as a normal couple without constantly having to fight monsters and save the world.
that wasn’t the only reason. piper is actually lesbian i believe (i thought she was pan but my friend told me she was lesbian) and therefore isn’t attracted to jason. they were only a couple because hera had tricked piper into believing they were actually together through the mist while jason was actually getting his memory wiped. after jason gained his memories back and went on quests with her (TLH) and fell for her, and she at the time was excited because of the mist that had faked their relationship. in many of the books in HoO, though, she mentions how they aren’t that good of a pair and that they don’t understand each other many times.
That is true, but in the sun and the star, piper tells Nico that she was attracted to Jason and she genuinely like him. And I'm pretty sure that piper didn't know that she was lesbian at the time of the breakup, so while Hera did trick them into believing that they were a couple they still chose to be together.
@@Lunamoon144yippie actually rick has Piper as no actual flag. She says "If I don't ever love another guy does that make me lesbian?" Although I do see your point about their relationship Piper isn't sure what she is. that's great not everyone is sure. And I think it was Piper wasn't sure if she actually did like Jason or was it the fake memories or Hera and she wanted to figure it out before continuing or not wanting to play Jason along
@@Hoshino745 ohhh okay i got that information from my friend but that makes sense.
THANk YOU🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏❤🤗
Agreed, she wasn’t a pick me
Yeah, no way she was a “pick me”
I found you :)
@@r3dd.pj0 Lol :)
i feel like most people who say piper is a pick-me or annoying with jason (in hoo) have never experienced comp-het
People see a girl being herself without shoving it up to other people's throats and go "hm yeah that seems like a pick me"
Leave the girl alone 😭 she didn't do any harm. So yeah, she's pretty without trying? No shit. Her mother is Aphrodite what did you expect?
People hate on her for NOTHING. It's okay to not like a character or hate them sure but calling the character insults about something they aren't even being is something else. And I'm betting you most of them are down bad for Jason or Jason and Leo shippers that are pissed off because the two got together :/
Justice for Piper
piper eventually broke up with him, she had a lot of development as a character i think
also, my unpopular opinion: piper is the best character!
the only pick me thing she did was randomly hating on dresses in the CHB scene in TLH. like girl why u gotta yuck peoples yum
My unpopular opinion:
I don’t think people should hate Hera for taking away Percy and Jason’s memories. I mean it was to save the world right?
it was but i hate hera 😭 it was risky and she knew it and i get that it was needed but she’s also spiteful and hates annabeth, and preaches about things she doesn’t even care about such as “family”
Oh you can hate her for that it’s just this one thing that kind of peeves me 😅
To be honest I don't hate Piper but I just don't like her and Jason together 😅(SO SORRY TO PEOPLE THAT LIKE THAT)
Well you are going to love TOA
@@SleepyHollowKnight I'm working my way up there 😂
Tbh they acted more like best friends, I honestly forgot they were together while reading hoo
Hehe burning maze 🤭ྀི
I don't like her and Jason together as well . I ship Valgrace
My opinion on Piper is: I love her, I will defend her, nothing can make me hate her. ELABORATING: I never saw her as a pick me. She never put other girls down for male validation, or searched for any sort of unnecessary attention. She wants the attention she didn’t get when she was a child, and that doesn’t make her a pick me. I liked Jasper fine, but it’s def not an OTP or anything seeing as they were put together because Hera.
My fav characters are piper and reyna so yeah i totally agree with this!! ❤
REALLLLLL
Unpopular opinion- Blood of Olympus is the best book in the Riordanverse
I like Piper.❤
I love piper she is amazing
my unpopular opinion
is that i am not a luke apologist. i understand the point he was trying to make and that he was basically possessed. but i will never forgive him for what he did to those kids especially annabeth
they could never make me hate u piper
Piper isnt a pickme, she just a lesbian, like the next book she in she either be a huntress or a lesbian
She’s not a pick be but she acts like her trauma is sooo bad when a lot of people in REAL LIFE have to deal with that
Tbh Leo and Jason have WAY more chemistry.
REAAALLLLLLL!!! Piper and jason was just awkward
My unpopular opinion is that Drew is worse than Octavian
I don’t like piper live Jason relationship was toxic. STOP READING IF HAVE NOT READ TRIALS OF APOLLO SPOILERS!!!!!!
Jason didn’t deserve to die piper could’ve I would of liked it better
I mean I love Piper but yeah, her death would've been more of a plot twist and make the story better since there's really a pattern about who uncle Rick kills in each series
no piper was just in love that’s it
No hate but why do you always say "As always Im very right and youa are very wrong" When sometimes you agglree with people ?
It’s a general reminder
@@Unclaimeddemigod thanks