Oh looks like I’m going to be the second comment... well I love the founders series and, uh, Godric is by far my favorite with his jorts and unicorn costume.
oh thanks for reminding me who said that. I couldn't remember who made that video, I just had this little angry voice inside me going "INTENTIONAL METAPHORS ARE NOT THEORIES"
This is funny but as a matter of fact, she has said that she has been aware of this theory and says it's her favorite. Not sure if she's mentioned the theory again afterwards though.
Actually, I think there is a saying in Bushido that roughly goes: "Go into battle expecting to die and you will survive. Go into battle hoping to live and surely you will not." Worked for Harry and Voldemort...
That quotation is also mentioned, albeit in different words, by a great Korean admiral, Yi Sun-sin. He says "Those who seek death shall live. Those who seek life shall die."
Recklessness may provide more openings to its wielder than caution, agreed. İf you re not needed alive somewhere else after the fight, it might be a viable option. However, caution has its own ways to provide the needed aliveness in question let's say. İn short, depends......
@@ismata3274 Of course, 'depends' is usually the right answer. I think it's mostly a warning how fear can work against you, and can, ironically, get you killed in battle. I think there's value in all styles and perspectives.
Aki Mél Technically he said that he liked Lemon Drops in the first book. Sherbet Lemon was just a password, though I don’t doubt that he likes them as well.
I wasn’t really sold on this until 11:48 when you said “Harry dies and greets Death as an old friend” and showed Dumbledore in the afterlife. Beautiful moment there
Voldemort who feared death got the stone(power to revive dead but not completely). Dumbeldore who preferred not to kill if he could avoid it got the elder wand(power to kill). Harry who was brave got the cloak(power to hide). Poetic irony. Somones elses comment by the way. I borrowed it.
"Harry's willing to die for what he believes in and Voldemort tries every way to evade death" - I imagine Davy Jones sat down and intimidatingly asked them "Do you fear death" 😂
What about the Potter's headstone: "The last enemy to be destroyed is death?" Does that make Dumbledore the enemy? Or is it like more of the obstacle? Which to be fair that is really Harry's last challenge is to face Dumbledore. Once he comes back its game over for Voldemort.
Remember, it’s a quote from the Bible. I sometimes think Rowling included that because she wanted to get on the Church’s good side after all the controversy. If she really wanted to avoid it in the first place, she could have just left out the word “witchcraft” and made “wizard” gender-neutral, though I’m not sure it would have been quite the same. “Hogwarts School of Wizardry.” It doesn’t have quite the same ring, does it? The quote does fit very well, and you have a good point in applying it to Dumbledore. It’s a cool thought.
Lol I'm late, but I always paired it back to Book 1 where Dumbledore says "To the well organized mind, Death is but the next great adventure." Dumbledore has always maintained there is nothing to be feared from death and there are worse things than it. So I think it genuinely means living beyond the 'end'
@@senamilemadlala2655 for sure! also, that dumbledore quote is highly, highly reminiscent of ancient greek and roman philosophy, wherein the human soul is immortal and lives beyond the body's death. a number of ancient philosophers have extensive recorded texts about how death shouldn't be feared and should be embraced (like an old friend, even), when the time comes. idk if rowling intended this, but her books acquainted readers with integral greek and roman philosophy, and also the christian understanding of death being able to die. fascinating, frankly!
I think updating old theories would be really interesting. Like this one. But some might have a different conclusion with all the new information released since the prior theories.
“Dark days, Harry. Didn't know who yer trust, didn’t dare get friendly with strange wizards or witches... terrible things happened. He was takin’ over. Course some stood up to him - an he killed ‘em. Horribly.” - Hagrid describing the early days of supercarlinbrothers to Harry.
This a shot in the dark theory: I don’t think grindlewald will be the elder wand’s true master, I think dumbledore was and that’s how he beat grindlewald
Thought : Dumbledore, could very well death. But as he gave away his powers ( the original brothers ) he himself could not pass on or rest until their was one master of death. Thereby reclaiming all this powers again. This would also add to his actions, knowing Harry could be the only one to collect / own / control all three of the hollows. Dumbledor manipulated events to make it so.
I am loving all the HP coverage. I know it must be hard to find new material to cover after so many years of dedicated research, but I want to say thank you!!!
Can we just take a moment to appreciate all that the super Carlin bros have done? They really go above and beyond to present with quality entertainment. Love you guys!
But the Dumbledore=death and the three brothers connection theory is as old as the 7th Harry Potter book. This isn't a new theory. It's been circling the web for years. I'm actually confused as to why they're JUST coming out with a video on this topic.
I’ve never actually thought that Dumbledore could be Death, but I had a hunch that he was the youngest “brother” from the tale so this is something that is definitely interesting and a new perspective.
Voldemort is the oldest,Snape is second eldest,Harry is the youngest.Just like the brothers they represent. Edit:spelling because autocorrect spelled Snape wrong .
I've always been a fan of this theory for all the reasons you said. Also, it's interesting that all 4 of them (HP, Voldemort, Snape, & Dumbledore) are half-bloods and hence outsiders to both the Muggle world and the magical world, they all feel most at home at Hogwarts, they all try to "find themselves" through trying out new kinds of magic, and they all come face-to-face with death in different ways.
9:56 Ignotus is Harry’s ancestor because you remember Linfred of Stinchecombe and how he was nicknamed the “Potterer” and that led to the family name Potter? Well Linfred married Ignotus’s granddaughter which is how Harry is Ignotus’s descended
me: sees the title also me, and intellectual: *reads in head in a great booming voice* DUMBLEDORE IS DEATH *echo* DeATh *echo* death!! Also, also me: *reads in a small, squeaky voice* a Harry Potter theory..!
I watch many of your videos and enjoy the majority of them. But this video I enjoyed alot, from start to finish. Lots of thought and consideration put into it. Well done, keep up awesomeness.😎
Not to overlook the engraving on Harry's parents graves "The last enemy that shall be destroyed is death." Once harry defeats death Voldemorts power no longer has any lasting effect and he is finished.
@@Fracturedspleen Well then 1. they need to specify that, and 2. a metaphor/symbolism doesn't lose value if the author didn't intentionally write it that way.
CaitLumos well 1: why do they need to do that? It’s pretty obvious if you know what a metaphor is. And 2: yes it does. The author was intending to send a message no matter if they’re writing their manifesto or a work of fiction. Reading into the work doesn’t make it true
@@legen_dharyll Harry became master of the Elder Wand by disarming Draco, who had disarmed Dumbledore. Albus could become master of it by getting a technical win over Grindelwald. Something like, for example, destroying the blood pact that Grindelwald forced him into to keep him out of the fight. Newt will be taking care of Credence. He's the one that has experience with obscurials.
One of the things I think is paramount to the story is that defeating death is possible, but not in a physical way. Physical immortality is ultimately a curse. It's the mark you leave in the world and the people who's lives you touch. Harry will be remembered forever for defeating Voldemort, but moreso through his friends and family and their memories and stories.
11:18 "Harry simultaneously possesses all 3 hallows", I have always maintained that this is why he survived, instead of the given reason which seemed like a reach.
As Snape was headmaster after Dumbledore's death then you could assume he at least looked after the stuff in Dumbledore's office until the point it was handed out in his will meaning he could have possessed the Golden snitch with the stone inside at least until it was retrieved and given to Harry.
You know I completely believes this theory because he had direct role in the 'deaths' of the people representing the three brothers.It just fits nicely!
I think maybe the death dying part just refers to death taking people from the world to the afterlife. Maybe it counts as dying to move from the world of the living to the world of the dead
Question: Did the Gaunt’s know how to use the Resurrection Stone? If so, then wouldn’t they be able to contact Salazar from behind the grave and he would be able to give his descendants instructions on how to open the Chamber of Secrets. Which would be why they treasured it for so long.
I've always been a bit confused. Did Cadmus want to bring back his love, or humiliate Death? Also, imagine if Harry came back after being killed by a gun. "So... how do I fix the hole in my head?'
My mind was blown was J said that if the ring had succeeded in killing Dumbledore, Voldemort would have become the master of the Elder Wand... I never thought about that before! Also, can you imagine Voldy's reaction if he ever found out how close he was to killing Dumbledore? 😂😂
I've always seen death as a dementor the cloak would be there hood, the wand is just a wand with a dementor core somehow, and the resurrection stone revives people but without there soul (probably not true I just like the thought of it)
@@h3nder wait so if the cloak is made of Thestral hide then wouldn't those who have witness death (and undergone the stages of grief) be able to see the cloak? Like, I'm genuinely curious.
I’ve seen a comment saying that on Lily and James’s gravestone it said “The last enemy destroyed will be death.” Funny how the descent of Ignotus manages to defy death, which could possibly be Dumbledore, seeing as that Harry succeed in winning the war without death beside him, having cheated him twice. Funny how these things work so well in the Wizarding World.
Was rewatching and thinking about the invisibility cloak, quick question. Pottermore article on the Potters says James’ parents saw him marry before they died and then passed on the cloak before Harry was born. He married in 1978, the same year he graduated Hogwarts. However, it has always been my understanding that James used the cloak at school to achieve mischief. Is this a misconception?
i know Dumbledore manipulated everything for what he thought was right and it even seemed so if only harry has to die why harm anyone else. but the admiration in Dumbledores voice when he says you wonderful boy you brave brave man. you can tell he's truly Proud of him.
Me reading the title: hey I think I have seen this one before! Me within the first three seconds of the vid: oh ok Me 1 min into the vid: wait I haven't seen the original vid, but I swear I've seen this before. Now I'm mega confused
Great video! Got suggestions for 2 more videos 1. Why is Fawkes the phoenix not harmed in any way while destroying the Basilisk's eyes (no effect of murderous look on it?) 2. The cloak of invisibility helped Ignotus Peverell in cheating death but how is Moody's eye able to see through it in The Goblet of Fire? Also in Chamber of Secrets, while in Hagrid's hut, Ron and Harry were sure Dumbledore saw them through the cloak while talking to Lucius Malfoy. How does the cloak function really?
Voldemort could represent the second as he is related to him and also because he desperately to keep someone alive (himself) but found he could never truly do it.
In The Elder Scrolls lore community we talk about this kind of role-taking as Mantling, and because it's a core mechanic of the setting we actually describe a couple of distinct kinds of Mantling. Amusingly, Harry, Dumbledore, Voldemort, and Snape all Mantle by way of the Fourth, the Steps of the Dead. Though Harry also Mantles by the First, the Prolix Tower, which is how he escapes Ignotus' Doom.
Today’s quiz question: In the goblet of fire book, what is the second password for the gryffindor common room? The first is balderdash, but it changes to _______________
In the duel, Arinanna could have "defeated" Grindewald, which means Albus defeated or (killed) her and he was the master, so he won the legendary duel. This was in a video of who killed Arianna.
When I saw this I was like “ I’m pretty sure I’ve seen this before.... must have been another channel”. Yes indeed there was and no turns out it was you
![Aberforth's Goats EXPLAINED [Harry Potter Theory]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/8NIIU8XcQIg/mqdefault.jpg)
![Aberforth's Goats EXPLAINED [Harry Potter Theory]](/img/tr.png)
![Salazar Slytherin Is STILL Alive?! [Harry Potter Theory]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/bu5hTg1qxEk/mqdefault.jpg)
![Lp. Сердце Вселенной #60 РОЖДЕНИЕ ЛОЛОЛОШКИ [Финал] • Майнкрафт](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YoR0pAV9FVQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Check out our Sims 4 Founders Series!
And before you ask, yes, of course Godric is wearing jorts… duh!
ua-cam.com/video/Z8JEtdSA6g8/v-deo.html
Last time i came this early my girlfriend screamed at me
First reply is gold
Oh looks like I’m going to be the second comment... well I love the founders series and, uh, Godric is by far my favorite with his jorts and unicorn costume.
Jorts!
maybe the wand was made so that it the brother would never lose a duel, but after that it just depended on the wizard who owned it
Title: Dumbledore is death [Harry Potter *Theory* ]
Seamus Gorman: *Angry metaphor noises*
Can I like that again? Please?
The Carlin Brothers did it first, you know.
oh thanks for reminding me who said that. I couldn't remember who made that video, I just had this little angry voice inside me going "INTENTIONAL METAPHORS ARE NOT THEORIES"
I agree with Seamus tbh
🙉
Harry appears at a heavenly, ethereal King's Cross:
Dumbledore: DID YOU PUT YOUR NAME IN THEGOBLETOFIRE!!?
How is Yharnam so far?
dumbledore asked calmly
I can imagine JK Rowling watching Harry Potter theories and thinking “That makes so much more sense, that’s exactly what I meant”
Love this!!
Candyce Monroe thanks
Oh fo sho
I feel like that’s what I’d do as an author.
This is funny but as a matter of fact, she has said that she has been aware of this theory and says it's her favorite. Not sure if she's mentioned the theory again afterwards though.
Actually, I think there is a saying in Bushido that roughly goes: "Go into battle expecting to die and you will survive. Go into battle hoping to live and surely you will not." Worked for Harry and Voldemort...
and neville
That quotation is also mentioned, albeit in different words, by a great Korean admiral, Yi Sun-sin.
He says "Those who seek death shall live. Those who seek life shall die."
Recklessness may provide more openings to its wielder than caution, agreed. İf you re not needed alive somewhere else after the fight, it might be a viable option. However, caution has its own ways to provide the needed aliveness in question let's say.
İn short, depends......
@@ismata3274 Of course, 'depends' is usually the right answer. I think it's mostly a warning how fear can work against you, and can, ironically, get you killed in battle. I think there's value in all styles and perspectives.
Dwarven daemonslayer there
Me reading every single video’s title: that’s ridiculous there is no way
After every video: Yeah that sounds right
Same tbh
True
Me too! At this point, they can probably convince me of anything
Yeah me too. The way the explain everything could make me believe just about anything
mood
"Who was able to hide from death for the rest of his life" doesn't everybody?
Big brain
Big brain
Big Brain
Big brain
Big Brain
*Me:* _sees title_
*Me:* “Didn’t they already make this?”
_J begins explaining_
*Me:* “Oh good I’m not going crazy”
RIGHT!?!?!?
OMG LITERALLY SAME
OGs remember the original
Exactly why I came to comments first to see if someone else noticed.
Exactly the same thought!
“Who was the one person he always feared?” Commercial: “This is Nancy” 😂😂😂😂😂💕
I JUST REALIZED WHAT THIS MEANS
*reads title*
me: So...Death has eyes that twinkle and is fond of lemon sherbets, got it.
I hope we live in a reality where Death has eyes that twinkle, and loves lemon sherbets...
And gay
Aki Mél Technically he said that he liked Lemon Drops in the first book. Sherbet Lemon was just a password, though I don’t doubt that he likes them as well.
And Cockroach Clusters and Acid Pops
Read discworld
“But no, Harry is not death, he is the master of death”
1 year later: Harry is death
I wasn’t really sold on this until 11:48 when you said “Harry dies and greets Death as an old friend” and showed Dumbledore in the afterlife. Beautiful moment there
Voldemort who feared death got the stone(power to revive dead but not completely). Dumbeldore who preferred not to kill if he could avoid it got the elder wand(power to kill). Harry who was brave got the cloak(power to hide). Poetic irony. Somones elses comment by the way. I borrowed it.
I just realized now that Harry and Voldemort are distantly related since they both descend from the two of the three brothers.
All pure-blood wizards are distantly related, the Sacred Twenty-Eight went full Alabama
Ben Snow full Alabama 😂😂😂
They are related to all of the brothers because they are brothers...
@@OfficialPortlandFilmCollection only 2/3 directly
Ben Snow so... Harry is a descendant if slytherin?
That means Dumbledore is the main character of the Grim Adventures of Billy and Mandy
What j said “ we got the champagne saber”
What we all know he really said “ we got a fancy knife”
A fancy *shiny* knife
And little pieces of glass in the campagne
His scream the 1st time he showed it was hilarious
"Harry's willing to die for what he believes in and Voldemort tries every way to evade death" - I imagine Davy Jones sat down and intimidatingly asked them "Do you fear death" 😂
The actor that plays davey Jones is the new head of the ministry in the deathly hallows part 1 actually haha
@@BigSweaty_cc bill nigh, Is his name btw. No relation to the eugenicist science guy
What about the Potter's headstone: "The last enemy to be destroyed is death?" Does that make Dumbledore the enemy? Or is it like more of the obstacle? Which to be fair that is really Harry's last challenge is to face Dumbledore. Once he comes back its game over for Voldemort.
Remember, it’s a quote from the Bible. I sometimes think Rowling included that because she wanted to get on the Church’s good side after all the controversy. If she really wanted to avoid it in the first place, she could have just left out the word “witchcraft” and made “wizard” gender-neutral, though I’m not sure it would have been quite the same. “Hogwarts School of Wizardry.” It doesn’t have quite the same ring, does it?
The quote does fit very well, and you have a good point in applying it to Dumbledore. It’s a cool thought.
Lol I'm late, but I always paired it back to Book 1 where Dumbledore says "To the well organized mind, Death is but the next great adventure." Dumbledore has always maintained there is nothing to be feared from death and there are worse things than it. So I think it genuinely means living beyond the 'end'
@@senamilemadlala2655 for sure! also, that dumbledore quote is highly, highly reminiscent of ancient greek and roman philosophy, wherein the human soul is immortal and lives beyond the body's death. a number of ancient philosophers have extensive recorded texts about how death shouldn't be feared and should be embraced (like an old friend, even), when the time comes. idk if rowling intended this, but her books acquainted readers with integral greek and roman philosophy, and also the christian understanding of death being able to die. fascinating, frankly!
“Who was the one wizard he always feared.. “
AD: “big jack”
I think updating old theories would be really interesting. Like this one. But some might have a different conclusion with all the new information released since the prior theories.
Stonypotter I didn’t know I wanted this series until now
One more like... and then... (btw Im the 68th like)
fordie 16 done 😏
"And who is the one wizard he always feared?"
Ad: "Goldfish flavour blasted"
Remember the old days when Ben didn't have a beard
GLORIOUS!
No I really can’t 😂
Or further back when he had bangs.
it's hard to go back that far
“Dark days, Harry. Didn't know who yer trust, didn’t dare get friendly with strange wizards or witches... terrible things happened. He was takin’ over. Course some stood up to him - an he killed ‘em. Horribly.”
- Hagrid describing the early days of supercarlinbrothers to Harry.
This a shot in the dark theory: I don’t think grindlewald will be the elder wand’s true master, I think dumbledore was and that’s how he beat grindlewald
how does it feel making a comment in 2020 when the third fantastic beasts movie releases in 2022
When i saw the title i instantly thought «Seamus Gorman would not approve of This»
"I like how the stock image of death almost covers all of Harry."
10/10
*gets notification* oh I already know this theory *clicks immediately anyway*
SAME YO
I like how in the scene that snape is hugging Lily’s dead body there’s just Harry’s baby self is just crying and snape doesn’t even acknowledge him
“Maybe” -Ben Carlin
Thought : Dumbledore, could very well death. But as he gave away his powers ( the original brothers ) he himself could not pass on or rest until their was one master of death. Thereby reclaiming all this powers again.
This would also add to his actions, knowing Harry could be the only one to collect / own / control all three of the hollows. Dumbledor manipulated events to make it so.
And then Harry destroys the Elder Wand so that none in the next generations to come to become obsessed with being the Master of Death.
I'm honestly obsessed with your Harry Potter theories!
Thanks!
Now I got my sister obsessed too
most of these were figured out by other people long before youtube was a thing
I am loving all the HP coverage. I know it must be hard to find new material to cover after so many years of dedicated research, but I want to say thank you!!!
Last time I was this early, these socks were amazing.
congrats to your new borns I have been following since it was three of you and im just so proud of everything you guys have accomplished! congrats
Can we just take a moment to appreciate all that the super Carlin bros have done? They really go above and beyond to present with quality entertainment. Love you guys!
But the Dumbledore=death and the three brothers connection theory is as old as the 7th Harry Potter book. This isn't a new theory. It's been circling the web for years. I'm actually confused as to why they're JUST coming out with a video on this topic.
@@333pinkelephant333 because they only make so many videos a week and they have just got around to this theory
I’ve never actually thought that Dumbledore could be Death, but I had a hunch that he was the youngest “brother” from the tale so this is something that is definitely interesting and a new perspective.
Voldemort is the oldest,Snape is second eldest,Harry is the youngest.Just like the brothers they represent.
Edit:spelling because autocorrect spelled Snape wrong .
Isn’t the snipe the thing under Carl Fredricksons porch? From up?
ThatOmePerson DAM AUTOCORRECT!!!!!!!!
They are even in three different generations
Anna Kilifa True.
I've always been a fan of this theory for all the reasons you said. Also, it's interesting that all 4 of them (HP, Voldemort, Snape, & Dumbledore) are half-bloods and hence outsiders to both the Muggle world and the magical world, they all feel most at home at Hogwarts, they all try to "find themselves" through trying out new kinds of magic, and they all come face-to-face with death in different ways.
remember that one seamus gorman video?
seamus: *STOP CALLING METAPHORS THEORIES!* (shows example of dumbledore is death)
scb: makes another one.
ikr!!!
Well, the metaphor is a theory unless JKR confirms the metaphor was intentional.
@@carlrood4457 more accurately it's a theoretical metaphor.
I was just watching that video 🤣
@@arandomuser9459 😹😹
9:56 Ignotus is Harry’s ancestor because you remember Linfred of Stinchecombe and how he was nicknamed the “Potterer” and that led to the family name Potter? Well Linfred married Ignotus’s granddaughter which is how Harry is Ignotus’s descended
Everyone: I said no but I watched the video and I agree now.
Me: *_sees title_*
Ok.
Same
Its SCB their always right. Whats there to doubt?
Haddi .J honestly
@@s.i3na 😂😂😂
That last part confused me but the “greeting your old friend” part with dumbledore at kings cross is freaking wavy
Looks like a good theory
She already said this isn’t true, but she likes the theory.
I mean, it works too well. She shouldn't have said anything.
It is very possible that the books are more than Rowling intended. She may not have planned this but it could be true.
me: sees the title
also me, and intellectual: *reads in head in a great booming voice* DUMBLEDORE IS DEATH *echo* DeATh *echo* death!!
Also, also me: *reads in a small, squeaky voice* a Harry Potter theory..!
*an* intellectual, but 😂
Well done for continually getting good, high quality content from the same seven books.
25k views
2.5k likes
25 dislikes
Me: Immediately takes a screenshot to show nobody and one day delete
Perfectly balanced, as all things should be.
HAHA! Glad I'm not the only one that does stuff like that.
@@johnmckenzie6661 that one niche thing that you and some other dude on the internet have in common is truly one of the best things.
I watch many of your videos and enjoy the majority of them. But this video I enjoyed alot, from start to finish. Lots of thought and consideration put into it. Well done, keep up awesomeness.😎
Not to overlook the engraving on Harry's parents graves "The last enemy that shall be destroyed is death." Once harry defeats death Voldemorts power no longer has any lasting effect and he is finished.
With Strange Aeons, even death may die - HP Lovecraft
@@numenlad7903 ah yes. I see you are a being of class 🧐
He does that twice
Perfect with a new SCB video on my birthday, the best gift
Seamus Gorman is going to be coming after you for calling this a theory instead of a metaphor 😂 Really good video though
BooksForever well they’re theorizing that this is the metaphor that JKR is going for
BooksForever well they’re theorizing that this is the metaphor that JKR is going for so
@BooksForever My thoughts exactly XD
@@Fracturedspleen Well then 1. they need to specify that, and 2. a metaphor/symbolism doesn't lose value if the author didn't intentionally write it that way.
CaitLumos well 1: why do they need to do that? It’s pretty obvious if you know what a metaphor is. And 2: yes it does. The author was intending to send a message no matter if they’re writing their manifesto or a work of fiction. Reading into the work doesn’t make it true
"The ones that love us never really leave us."
Two movies later, Sirius yells "Nice one, James!"
😭😭😭😭😭😭
What if Grindlwald lost with the elder wand because he wasn't the actual master of the wand.... what if.
Newt will probably be the master of it some time in their story
That Sounds plausible, but wouldn't that mean, that Dumbledore will defeat Newt?
@@melonlord1414maybe, it doesn't have to end with Newt dying. Harry defeated Voldie with Expelliarmus. I just don't know if that would be enough.
@@legen_dharyll Harry became master of the Elder Wand by disarming Draco, who had disarmed Dumbledore. Albus could become master of it by getting a technical win over Grindelwald. Something like, for example, destroying the blood pact that Grindelwald forced him into to keep him out of the fight.
Newt will be taking care of Credence. He's the one that has experience with obscurials.
I actually had that thought as well. Or maybe Newt would get to talk Credence into destroying the pact since he's an obscurial and is hella powerful
One of the things I think is paramount to the story is that defeating death is possible, but not in a physical way. Physical immortality is ultimately a curse. It's the mark you leave in the world and the people who's lives you touch. Harry will be remembered forever for defeating Voldemort, but moreso through his friends and family and their memories and stories.
I don't believe it but I know by the end of the video I will agree
That’s how I feel on every video
That's our goal!
SuperCarlinBrothers You’ve done a very good job of doing it!
@@SuperCarlinBrothers goal accomplished
Duh! It is amazing how you guys can always find an extra detail I missed that makes this channel pretty awesome!
You could make the argument that the ORIGINAL Sonic movie character design was perfect and the internet would believe you lol.
11:18 "Harry simultaneously possesses all 3 hallows", I have always maintained that this is why he survived, instead of the given reason which seemed like a reach.
The floating head section... I can't deal, I love it😂😂
Saber made me think of the old knife you had "Kindness" that you would use for crate box unboxing
I’m simple. I see a SuperCarlinBrothers video, I watch it.
As Snape was headmaster after Dumbledore's death then you could assume he at least looked after the stuff in Dumbledore's office until the point it was handed out in his will meaning he could have possessed the Golden snitch with the stone inside at least until it was retrieved and given to Harry.
I skipped past the last part of the promotion and got “use the promo code... death” 😂😂
When I was this early
James and lily were alive
I am not sorry
And I am not sorry I clicked “read more” !!!!
4:45
The visual of Voldemort with a Glock now lives rent free in my head.
i belive this theroy about dumbledore being death more then i do that hes a phenoix
You know I completely believes this theory because he had direct role in the 'deaths' of the people representing the three brothers.It just fits nicely!
J must have been like, "Ben you did good.... but I can do it better. Just watch the quiz episodes."
I think maybe the death dying part just refers to death taking people from the world to the afterlife. Maybe it counts as dying to move from the world of the living to the world of the dead
Scott, editing on POINT as always
Missed a "crossing", though. :(
Question: Did the Gaunt’s know how to use the Resurrection Stone? If so, then wouldn’t they be able to contact Salazar from behind the grave and he would be able to give his descendants instructions on how to open the Chamber of Secrets. Which would be why they treasured it for so long.
Weird, I work for bespoke post. Never thought I would hear an ad for it.
This is so beautiful! Thank you for sharing!
this theory has literally been going on since the month after the release of the deathly hallows like wow
I've always been a bit confused. Did Cadmus want to bring back his love, or humiliate Death? Also, imagine if Harry came back after being killed by a gun. "So... how do I fix the hole in my head?'
09:18 - 09: 49 "Snape kills Dumbledore". No, Dumbledore killed Snape.
You ain't never lied
My mind was blown was J said that if the ring had succeeded in killing Dumbledore, Voldemort would have become the master of the Elder Wand... I never thought about that before! Also, can you imagine Voldy's reaction if he ever found out how close he was to killing Dumbledore? 😂😂
I've always seen death as a dementor the cloak would be there hood, the wand is just a wand with a dementor core somehow, and the resurrection stone revives people but without there soul (probably not true I just like the thought of it)
kawal kaur I like the thought. Almost like he’s an advanced form or ancestral form of the dementors
The Elder Wand is made with a core of a Thestral hair, the cloak is likely made from Thestral skin/hide.
h3nder I know I just like to think of it that way because it would be pretty interesting if it was true
@@h3nder wait so if the cloak is made of Thestral hide then wouldn't those who have witness death (and undergone the stages of grief) be able to see the cloak? Like, I'm genuinely curious.
@@storytellingsnek5255 It's only a theory, it's not confirmed but since the wand has thestral hair the cloak is likely similar.
I’ve seen a comment saying that on Lily and James’s gravestone it said “The last enemy destroyed will be death.” Funny how the descent of Ignotus manages to defy death, which could possibly be Dumbledore, seeing as that Harry succeed in winning the war without death beside him, having cheated him twice. Funny how these things work so well in the Wizarding World.
1,336 views in 2 minutes
That's why I like this channel
y'all are killin it lately, great analysis!
That was some beautiful champagne sabering!
I'm not sure what happened, but I lost your channel for about a year..now you're back all over my recommended and it feels good, brother.
Was rewatching and thinking about the invisibility cloak, quick question. Pottermore article on the Potters says James’ parents saw him marry before they died and then passed on the cloak before Harry was born. He married in 1978, the same year he graduated Hogwarts. However, it has always been my understanding that James used the cloak at school to achieve mischief. Is this a misconception?
Ok, your videos are so amazing. Thank you. They're good for my whole family, and highly intriguing.
What if it was a prophesy, acted out by Dumbledore, but actually happening in the past to become the real story for the next generation of wizards!
That last line gave me the chills. Great vid
When I saw this I was like “hold up we’ve covered this before-“
i know Dumbledore manipulated everything for what he thought was right and it even seemed so if only harry has to die why harm anyone else. but the admiration in Dumbledores voice when he says you wonderful boy you brave brave man. you can tell he's truly Proud of him.
Me reading the title: hey I think I have seen this one before!
Me within the first three seconds of the vid: oh ok
Me 1 min into the vid: wait I haven't seen the original vid, but I swear I've seen this before.
Now I'm mega confused
Great video!
Got suggestions for 2 more videos
1. Why is Fawkes the phoenix not harmed in any way while destroying the Basilisk's eyes (no effect of murderous look on it?)
2. The cloak of invisibility helped Ignotus Peverell in cheating death but how is Moody's eye able to see through it in The Goblet of Fire? Also in Chamber of Secrets, while in Hagrid's hut, Ron and Harry were sure Dumbledore saw them through the cloak while talking to Lucius Malfoy. How does the cloak function really?
Voldemort could represent the second as he is related to him and also because he desperately to keep someone alive (himself) but found he could never truly do it.
I have been shouting this to people i know for almost a Year! Finally this is spoken about! Love it!
By the way, since Harry is a descendant of one brother and Voldemort of another, this means Harry and Voldemort are secretly related
In The Elder Scrolls lore community we talk about this kind of role-taking as Mantling, and because it's a core mechanic of the setting we actually describe a couple of distinct kinds of Mantling. Amusingly, Harry, Dumbledore, Voldemort, and Snape all Mantle by way of the Fourth, the Steps of the Dead. Though Harry also Mantles by the First, the Prolix Tower, which is how he escapes Ignotus' Doom.
Today’s quiz question:
In the goblet of fire book, what is the second password for the gryffindor common room?
The first is balderdash, but it changes to _______________
Fairy lights in Christmas
Nitin Jain ‘Fat lady swings open’
In the duel, Arinanna could have "defeated" Grindewald, which means Albus defeated or (killed) her and he was the master, so he won the legendary duel. This was in a video of who killed Arianna.
When I saw this I was like “ I’m pretty sure I’ve seen this before.... must have been another channel”. Yes indeed there was and no turns out it was you
All death wants is a pair of thick woolen socks. Someone get this man some socks!
Seamus won’t like this theory...
This *metaphor*
he will not
This channel is like when successfully puts a square in a circular hole with logic and reason