A Tale of Pakistan’s Electoral System | Sarwar Bari

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 27 вер 2024
  • It appears elections are merely held to legitimize the elite control. And this is a major factor behind low turnout in Pakistan’s elections. People seem to be very well aware of elites’ modus operandi. No wonder a large majority of electorates never took part in elections. Those who use their right to vote, a significant number of them were being coerced or pressured. Therefore, our electoral system seems to have no relationship with democracy.
    About the speaker:
    Sarwar Bari heads Pattan Development Organization, which has been contributing to further the interest of the marginalized, the deprived and the underrepresented communities of Pakistan. Also, he is a columnist and an analyst.

КОМЕНТАРІ • 35

  • @shd_khan
    @shd_khan Рік тому +6

    Thank you for the excellent presentation. Very informative and helpful to understand where we stand today.

  • @peacelover2002
    @peacelover2002 Рік тому +10

    What nonsense!!! Just because Modi has been elected to power as PM in India, does that mean democracy has declined???
    Pakistanis have a personal grudge towards Modi and his policies, and because of this, they find fault in anything/everything with him and with today's India, which is not at all true. He is an elected candidate. He did not come to power by any other means!!!
    BTW, union has weakened in India over the years, that is because of strengthening economy nothing else and people have been losing trust in communism as these unions are usually backed by communist parties.
    Such debates bring some spoiled, half learned crooks to discussions like this guy in Pakistan.

    • @chandrakanthveluri9860
      @chandrakanthveluri9860 Рік тому +5

      What can u expect from a setup by Pervez Hoodbhoy who is a good friend Indian left lobby?

    • @CUOAYWHTCUY
      @CUOAYWHTCUY Рік тому

      @The Dark Arts Agar koi democratically reelect ho to wo dictatorship ke barabar hai - wah wah - aise aur is sarwar jaise dnishvron ke hote papistan ka mustqbil khoob roushan hai...

  • @BananaRepublicOfPakistan
    @BananaRepublicOfPakistan 10 днів тому

    Kamal Sir. Very Infomative.

  • @shanulhaq8641
    @shanulhaq8641 Рік тому +2

    please share the presentation for download. its loaded with information and insights

  • @aijazali8921
    @aijazali8921 Рік тому

    Teachers must listen this discussion

  • @SR-pk2ph
    @SR-pk2ph Рік тому

    Quality of democracy is determined by the quality of participating voters.

  • @NsrSRK
    @NsrSRK Рік тому +1

    Sir, speakers ki presentation aur data ki link agr description mein provide kr dain, please.

  • @shabbirahmeddar7765
    @shabbirahmeddar7765 Рік тому

    باری صاحب کا ڈیٹا بہت مفصل ہے۔لیکن انکی پی ٹی آی سے انکی جزباتی وابستگی واضح ہے۔

    • @MuhammadRizwan-xn9zr
      @MuhammadRizwan-xn9zr 2 місяці тому

      کیا کمال کی بات کر رہے ہیں ؟ وہ الیکشن کمیشن کی ویب اور ڈیٹا دیکھ کر بات کر رہا ہے ۔ پتہ نہیں حقائق بیان کرنے والے پی ٹی آئی کے کیوں ہیں بس مسئلہ یہ ہے آپکا

  • @armankhan-wn6mn
    @armankhan-wn6mn Рік тому +1

    Sir plz session on
    Teachers guidnce for school teachers
    How to teach ? How to stop rata system ? Plzz plzz

  • @AlphaSierra380
    @AlphaSierra380 Рік тому +1

    Nice video

  • @Abuzar-49
    @Abuzar-49 8 місяців тому

    Sir I want to become affiliate voter tell me further

  • @threeshadesfire
    @threeshadesfire 10 місяців тому

    can i get these slides?

  • @Tanmayl11
    @Tanmayl11 Рік тому +1

    How does election of Modi and Trump equal to decline in democracy? Both were elected in a free and fair election. Please keep your political biases aside.
    And a correction, indian EVMs do have a paper audit trail that a voter can check after casting vote.

  • @MritunjayLive
    @MritunjayLive Рік тому +1

    This gentleman has very little knowledge about EVM used in Indian Election. He should read about VVPAT. He has even little knowledge about the election system of India. He is saying that (so-called) Pakistani EVM is superior to other EVMs used around the world.😂
    When intellectuals have this level of knowledge, what can we expect from common men in Pakistan?

    • @ibratnak
      @ibratnak Рік тому

      VVPAT is just a receipt. How do you ensure that the vote was transmitted and counted correctly without any meddling.

    • @MritunjayLive
      @MritunjayLive Рік тому

      @@ibratnak Because some EVMs are selected randomly and number of votes each candidate gets in EVM is matched with number of receipts from VVPAT. Throughout this process and counting of votes representatives of each candidate are present there.

  • @SAVETHEHUMANRACE786
    @SAVETHEHUMANRACE786 Рік тому

    Dhdhd

  • @adityasharma-zi7tu
    @adityasharma-zi7tu Рік тому

    Pkmkb

  • @yogeshtest3602
    @yogeshtest3602 Рік тому

    It is not correct assumption to target pm modi as a anti democratic force. PM modi elected twice with majority on his own. Voter turnout is more than 60% which is far better if you consider size and scale of election. PM modi didn't dined any one on base of religious beliefs, even he bring out schem and mechanism which are more IT based. You rejecting the muslim vote which he got in last two election. How learned person like you make such generalized comments.

    • @adeebahanaan3975
      @adeebahanaan3975 Місяць тому

      You should watch druve rathae video on PM Modi

  • @CUOAYWHTCUY
    @CUOAYWHTCUY Рік тому

    Bohot solid wala plant hai bhaiya ye Sarwar - khud maoist proxy hai ye zara bariqi se iski research kro

    • @tdurrani5
      @tdurrani5 Рік тому

      This is a thought provoking presentation. Would like to send you soft copy of a 120 page review of the LG system in then NWFP after the LGO 2001 was launched. May be this is interest to some researcher or decision maker. The report was written in 2006/7. Your organization email address needed.

  • @rana-qc8qt
    @rana-qc8qt Рік тому +3

    Indian EVM machines also show a slip that comes out only after the vote is registered. That show party symbol. It is called VVPAT

  • @rana-qc8qt
    @rana-qc8qt Рік тому +3

    As an indian i think less populated countries can run countries well through democratic ways, and populated countries should use PR system in local elections with more powers and subjects alloted to them, state government should have limited powers and union government should work mainly on defence, communication and external affairs.