It's like Netflix for history... 📺 Sign up to History Hit, the world's best history documentary service and get 50% off using the code 'PARABLE' bit.ly/3uX3tTw
The visuals are all re-creations the sounds( the words, and the ideas they carry) are more substantial. The areas they emphasis is also likely important. For eg. that moment of disobedience towards the Oracle in resisting the Persians( probably the wrong thing to have done by Pericles)
The Greeks put far less emphasis on the afterlife than did either the Egyptians before them or the Christians that followed them. The video suggests that the Greeks were constantly seeking the answer to the afterlife, which is belied by the works of their greatest thinkers. Plato believed in reincarnation, not an ascent to an eternal heaven, and Aristotle believed that the soul perished with the body. Their works are efforts to ascertain, by use of reason as opposed to faith, the best way to live in the here and now. The gods were not beseeched by ordinary Greeks for eternal life, but for assistance in present difficulties. The result is that the video implies that Greek culture was deficient, and was finally completed by Christianity. This is the interpretation that was promoted by the Church and became popular during the middle ages and renaissance. It is a disservice to that great civilization to suggest that it was incomplete, particularly in comparison to the illiteracy and superstition that followed for 1000 years of western history.
The popular view seems to be that most of the dead resided in a bleak, shadowy underworld: only the worst offenders against the gods were punished in Tartarus; and only the privileged heroes were allowed into the Elysian Fields. The average person had to gain divine favor by participating in mystery cults: there are some hints that psychotropic drugs such as hallucinogenic mushrooms may have been involved, to produce the ecstatic experience there.
@@Lucius1958 Aside from the evidence reported in Scientific American about a vent in Delphi that may have emitted ethylene during the time the Pythia priestesses were going into a trance, I'm not aware of any source for psychotropic drugs except by speculation. I'd be most grateful if you could supply a reference.
The Persians were defeated at the Battle of Salamis in 480 BC, when Pericles was a wealthy young man who would not rise to power for another decade or more. So his role in deciding to fight the Persians is a bit anachronistic in this presentation as I understand it. The priestess gave two oracles in response to the query about war with the Persians. The first said, 'Why sit you doomed one? Fly to the ends of the earth. All is ruin for fire and headlong god of war shall bring you low.' But the second, which some scholars believe was issued the same day, was less sinister, yet mysterious: 'Though all else shall be taken, Zeus, the all seeing, grants that the wooden wall only shall not fail.' The traditional view is that this was interpreted by Themistocles as meaning that the Athenian navy, whose triremes were made of wood, would protect the Athenians, as indeed they did, in the battle noted above.
I liked the production value of this video as much as the content. The imagery, music and voiceover provided an engaging narrative. Loved seeing the ruins and footage on location! Thank you for this video.
Hm can't put my finger on the narrators dialect... irish? Those rolling r's... but they are not consistent through out. Scots melody... sometimes... northern Irish even... aaargh lol so frustrating
I too was curious as to narrator's origins so re-watched, at 1:37 it shows his name, it's Cristy Kenneally. Per Wikipedia he was born in Cork, Ireland.
Calling our native Americans ignorant and savage was uncalled for. Besides, look at the Incans and Mayans. The native Americans in North America were wise in other ways.
The spinning visuals and strange sound effects do nothing for this documentary. Does that statue of Athena still exist? If so where is it and how does this guy know the cost of it (ie it cost more than the temple)?
saying war against the Persians united the Ancient Greece and made Athens their leader is a gross oversimplification. and the Erechtheion has nothing to do with Poseidon! it was a monument to Athena Polis, Athena of the City, and to the demi-god Erechtheus, mythical founder and first king of Athens. good god at least try.
Good documentary, but didn't mention the Mycenaen Civilization, arguably the oldest and the most advanced in Europe (18th-11th Centuries BC). It's legacy gave way to the Classical Greece afterwards and it's Golden Age.
Did the Southeast Asian immigrants introduce the sky god they worshipped to the island of Cretes? Does it mean that Greeks also have Southeast Asian roots? The Minoans married sky and earth. The union of sky and earth produced mortals and immortals. Could you please elaborate on this "mythological" statement?
This isn't actually about the Greek Pantheon. It's kind of a meandering list of facts and events about the Mediterranean civilizations of the Bronze Age.
None of these ideas came from greece, we don't owe anything to the greeks, they owe to the Persians, and other early Asian cultures. Also the use of terms like barbarian and savage is extremely offensive.
this was really good. i was sad when the program ended. i expected it to keep going! lol but i expect we can not do 2000 years in 30 minutes. i was riveted and enthusiastically consumed. thank you for this
Thet didn't get anything wrong they said one of the great kingdoms was could fall. They didn't say which one they assumed it was them they was going against.
"One of the first cities of the Sumerians was Eridug/Eridu. It was first settled around 5400 B.C. It doesn’t mean that there weren’t other people around, like the Aboriginal Australians or the Ancient Egyptians near the Nile River. It just means that this is where “a relatively high level of cultural and technological development specifically: the stage of cultural development at which writing and the keeping of written records is attained.” These were the first people to keep records of the Anunnaki. rebirthoftheword.com/sumerians/ facebook.com/groups/853331861951805/
It's like Netflix for history... 📺 Sign up to History Hit, the world's best history documentary service and get 50% off using the code 'PARABLE' bit.ly/3uX3tTw
I got sick of all the spinning images and gave up.
The visuals are all re-creations the sounds( the words, and the ideas they carry) are more substantial. The areas they emphasis is also likely important. For eg. that moment of disobedience towards the Oracle in resisting the Persians( probably the wrong thing to have done by Pericles)
This made me seriously laugh. Nailed it.
@@apricus3155 yes the lesson is important
The Greeks put far less emphasis on the afterlife than did either the Egyptians before them or the Christians that followed them. The video suggests that the Greeks were constantly seeking the answer to the afterlife, which is belied by the works of their greatest thinkers. Plato believed in reincarnation, not an ascent to an eternal heaven, and Aristotle believed that the soul perished with the body. Their works are efforts to ascertain, by use of reason as opposed to faith, the best way to live in the here and now. The gods were not beseeched by ordinary Greeks for eternal life, but for assistance in present difficulties.
The result is that the video implies that Greek culture was deficient, and was finally completed by Christianity. This is the interpretation that was promoted by the Church and became popular during the middle ages and renaissance. It is a disservice to that great civilization to suggest that it was incomplete, particularly in comparison to the illiteracy and superstition that followed for 1000 years of western history.
The popular view seems to be that most of the dead resided in a bleak, shadowy underworld: only the worst offenders against the gods were punished in Tartarus; and only the privileged heroes were allowed into the Elysian Fields. The average person had to gain divine favor by participating in mystery cults: there are some hints that psychotropic drugs such as hallucinogenic mushrooms may have been involved, to produce the ecstatic experience there.
@@Lucius1958 Aside from the evidence reported in Scientific American about a vent in Delphi that may have emitted ethylene during the time the Pythia priestesses were going into a trance, I'm not aware of any source for psychotropic drugs except by speculation. I'd be most grateful if you could supply a reference.
The Persians were defeated at the Battle of Salamis in 480 BC, when Pericles was a wealthy young man who would not rise to power for another decade or more. So his role in deciding to fight the Persians is a bit anachronistic in this presentation as I understand it. The priestess gave two oracles in response to the query about war with the Persians. The first said, 'Why sit you doomed one? Fly to the ends of the earth. All is ruin for fire and headlong god of war shall bring you low.' But the second, which some scholars believe was issued the same day, was less sinister, yet mysterious: 'Though all else shall be taken, Zeus, the all seeing, grants that the wooden wall only shall not fail.' The traditional view is that this was interpreted by Themistocles as meaning that the Athenian navy, whose triremes were made of wood, would protect the Athenians, as indeed they did, in the battle noted above.
I liked the production value of this video as much as the content. The imagery, music and voiceover provided an engaging narrative. Loved seeing the ruins and footage on location! Thank you for this video.
The screeching noise throughout and the spinning images put me off. I couldn’t see it through.
Thanks to Absolute History for recommending this! ☺️
Why is the first video not available in my country UK?
Hm can't put my finger on the narrators dialect... irish? Those rolling r's... but they are not consistent through out. Scots melody... sometimes... northern Irish even... aaargh lol so frustrating
I too was curious as to narrator's origins so re-watched, at 1:37 it shows his name, it's Cristy Kenneally. Per Wikipedia he was born in Cork, Ireland.
@@laly0033 google is our friend, duh... ty for your trouble!
There seemed to be a lot of emphasis on the Greeks not having an idea of what the afterlife held and that just simply isn't true.
The too-loud and melodramatic “music” and sound effects make this unwatchable.
Every stoic was a stoic, but in christiandom where is the Christian? RALPH Waldo Emerson
Please stop with the terrible editing.
Explore Golgumbaz Deccan india 🇮🇳
You mean pelasgian gods? The olympians were never once referred to as Greeks but pelasgian and dodonean 😂 👍
Calling our native Americans ignorant and savage was uncalled for. Besides, look at the Incans and Mayans. The native Americans in North America were wise in other ways.
It took another three four hundred year'smaybe more before Christianity came to Greece. ✌️
The spinning visuals and strange sound effects do nothing for this documentary. Does that statue of Athena still exist? If so where is it and how does this guy know the cost of it (ie it cost more than the temple)?
Really poor photography. Don't do rushing photos; it detracts rather than adds.
It would have been great except for the unnecessary visual spinning of the images - its nauseous to watch!
Is the narrator Carson from Downton Abbey?
There are many mistakes and outdated opinions. Thumbs down.
saying war against the Persians united the Ancient Greece and made Athens their leader is a gross oversimplification. and the Erechtheion has nothing to do with Poseidon! it was a monument to Athena Polis, Athena of the City, and to the demi-god Erechtheus, mythical founder and first king of Athens. good god at least try.
Agen Greek mythology hoto german mejdet
What about the Mycenaeans? It seems odd that you just skip over 1000 years of history...
Good documentary, but didn't mention the Mycenaen Civilization, arguably the oldest and the most advanced in Europe (18th-11th Centuries BC). It's legacy gave way to the Classical Greece afterwards and it's Golden Age.
Starting sentence suits even for today
Did the Southeast Asian immigrants introduce the sky god they worshipped to the island of Cretes? Does it mean that Greeks also have Southeast Asian roots?
The Minoans married sky and earth. The union of sky and earth produced mortals and immortals. Could you please elaborate on this "mythological" statement?
This isn't actually about the Greek Pantheon. It's kind of a meandering list of facts and events about the Mediterranean civilizations of the Bronze Age.
idiotic sound effects that drown out the narrative at time , very frustrating and annoying ,
not to mention just plain STUPID !
hello
hello
Great video!
None of these ideas came from greece, we don't owe anything to the greeks, they owe to the Persians, and other early Asian cultures. Also the use of terms like barbarian and savage is extremely offensive.
I I'm neither an athenian nor even a Greek but a citizen of the universe!
Jesus is King he is coming back soon real soon repent turn to him now❤️❤️❤️
Wacko😂
great video! clean graphics and editing .. i hope to get to this level in a few months!
Hi nice video
Remember The Commandment Thou Shall Not Have Flase Gods Before Me.☘🇮🇪
this was really good. i was sad when the program ended. i expected it to keep going! lol but i expect we can not do 2000 years in 30 minutes. i was riveted and enthusiastically consumed. thank you for this
I didn't purchase premium youtube. But I'm literally watching history about Gods. 2 amazing things happened in 1 day! God is good..
Thet didn't get anything wrong they said one of the great kingdoms was could fall. They didn't say which one they assumed it was them they was going against.
Only one God not many.
Many meaning fake.
The Holy Trinity.💚
"One of the first cities of the Sumerians was Eridug/Eridu. It was first settled around 5400 B.C. It doesn’t mean that there weren’t other people around, like the Aboriginal Australians or the Ancient Egyptians near the Nile River. It just means that this is where “a relatively high level of cultural and technological development specifically: the stage of cultural development at which writing and the keeping of written records is attained.”
These were the first people to keep records of the Anunnaki.
rebirthoftheword.com/sumerians/
facebook.com/groups/853331861951805/