Woman Imam leading Prayer (Salah)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 17 вер 2024
  • / rashidu22
    Ruling on woman leading salah to men - Sheikh Dr. Muhammad Salah

КОМЕНТАРІ • 117

  • @mustaphaceesay2031
    @mustaphaceesay2031 10 років тому +36

    one hundred percent bidaa, disgusting.repent and stop this none sense

    • @FIRSTLAST-xd6rn
      @FIRSTLAST-xd6rn 2 місяці тому

      LMFAOOOOo look at how nasty you slamists are

  • @Brimsurfer
    @Brimsurfer 9 років тому +29

    This is completely against Islamic teachings.... Quran is for all ages, there is no room for change or innovation or modernization in the teachings of Quran and prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) and this is unanimously agreed upon by Islamic Scholars.
    Qur'an's teachings are best reflected and explained by the life of prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) and prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) never asked Hazrat Khadija (peace be upon her) , the first lady of Islam, mother of all muslims, one of the most powerful and wealthiest business personage in whole of Arab, behind whom whole of Arab and much of civilised world could very easily be gathered, but still prophet (peace be upon him) never asked his wife to lead salat congregation, even in his absence.
    No woman has higher claim than Hazrat Khadija (peace be upon her) to lead the salah congregation and Hazrat Khadija (peace be upon her) never lead any salah congregation in which men were also present.
    It was always and always his male companions, who lead the salat.
    Religeon was perfected and completed in the life of prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) reference can be taken from Quran 5:3.
    What was not part of the religeon then can certainly be not part of the religeon now, this is also unanimously agreed upon by Islamic Scholars, as well.
    And in the life of prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) no woman ever lead salah congregation of men in a masjid, not even Hazrat Khadija (peace be upon her). In fact, there was a woman who expressed the wish to pray with the prophet in his masjid, but prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) told her that the best place for her to pray is her inner chamber in her house. Yet another point on which Islamic Scholars unanimously agree upon.
    Also this is not about the empowerment and subjugation of women, instead this about the roles and separate places that the Creator has assigned to us and we follow His will. Islam gives women the highest degree of respect and establishes a complete and most comprehensive system of rights and laws to protect women, in comparison to any other religion.
    After all there are more muslim countries with female head of states then any other religion.

    • @sageofgame
      @sageofgame 9 років тому

      Brimsurfer i dont think she is leading more like educating non muslims like giving a tour in a mosque she reading surah arabic line then translation which is not common in prayer. she is showing non muslims how muslims pray and to try it so they can experience it. you can tell see the men and women are praying side by side. She is Not lead as people are portraying in comments.

  • @saifalichaudhry9299
    @saifalichaudhry9299 8 років тому +11

    This video makes me angry as a Muslim and I can understand the anger viewed by other Muslims as this video shows the ignorance out there in the world.But what I find disgusting as well are the posts of other Muslims showing their disgust using vulgar languageBad language is just as much a sin as the rubbish shown in the video Please , as a Muslim be wise in the words u use because our portrayal to others is the best way we can help Islam out of its problems

  • @MohamedSAhmed
    @MohamedSAhmed 9 років тому +6

    قل هل ننبئكم بالاخسرين أعمالا (١٠٣)
    الذين ضل سعيهم في الحياة الدنيا وهم يحسبون أنهم يحسنون صنعا (١٠٤)
    Sura Al-Kahf
    Say, (O Muhammad) Shall we tell you about those who lost the most (as to their deeds (103)
    Those whose efforts in this life went astray while they thought they were doing well (in deeds) (104)
    I ask Allah Subhanahu wa Taala to shield us from being among those who truly think they're doing good deeds while they're actually lost and their deeds went astray...
    Inna Lellahi wa inna elayhe raje3ooon...

  • @obaidah4489
    @obaidah4489 3 роки тому +4

    Imagine getting sins for praying lol

  • @zafar2073
    @zafar2073 5 років тому +3

    Astughfirullah ! What did I just see ?

  • @Ilmwaqalb
    @Ilmwaqalb 8 років тому +9

    This is....just so wrong. Even her hijab is wrong, can we start with the basics here, way to not cover properly . just so sad

    • @md.mehedimasud7578
      @md.mehedimasud7578 4 роки тому

      THIS IS COMPLETLY AGAINST ISLAM.THIS PRAYER IS NOT FOR TRUE MUSLIM.THIS WORK IS ONLY FOR MUNAFAQUE.

  • @11mirandacosgrove
    @11mirandacosgrove 9 років тому +8

    I think she's educating the people in the back not really being an iman be because some of the ladies in the back don't even have a hijab

    • @vintagemuseum4363
      @vintagemuseum4363 8 років тому

      How would you bloody know!!!!

    • @forgivenesssave2172
      @forgivenesssave2172 8 років тому +3

      Vintage Museum cause a muslim female is forbidden to pray without hijab

    • @Hiddensoull
      @Hiddensoull 8 років тому

      if its to educate why doesnt she say out loud what she says in ruku and sajdah?

    • @NoahKhan918
      @NoahKhan918 5 років тому

      @ni blue nahh some of these mosques are soooo “progressive” that they let it rock if your hair isn’t covered

  • @zaidabdulrasheedabdulrouf376
    @zaidabdulrasheedabdulrouf376 4 роки тому +1

    Astaghfirullah..... This is Biddahhh...... Why she is translating..... What tge hell the women is praying without head scarf

  • @helensarwar6070
    @helensarwar6070 7 років тому +2

    the women have got no scarfs on and have there arms on show ! what sort of salah is this ? free mixing ?? really? astaghfurallah !!

  • @rahilhabib
    @rahilhabib 6 років тому

    There are so many things wrong with this salah that I don't even know where to start! Woman leading men and women (women can only lead women), men AND women mixed in the rows, HUUGE gaps in the rows, the "imam" reading the english with the arabic!! her tajweed of the arabic is awful!
    Plain and simple, Islam is Islam. If you change it then it is no longer Islam and you have changed YOUR religion. If you do not comply with a fundamental part of salah then your salah is NOT valid (like missing surah fatiha).

  • @latifa1092
    @latifa1092 8 років тому +5

    bro y'all need to chill because in the time of the Prophet the woman sometime led the prayers . educate yourself

    • @IbnSharif24
      @IbnSharif24 8 років тому +7

      U sound dumb as hell women never led salaat

    • @hamzahoka3977
      @hamzahoka3977 8 років тому +4

      they still lead...just never in front of men buddy.

    • @hamzamohamed3879
      @hamzamohamed3879 6 років тому

      latifa I WILL NOT CURSE YOU BUT YOU ARE UNEDUCATED JUST READ THE QURAN AND SAHIH BUKHARI. MAY ALLAH GUIDE YOU

    • @hamzamohamed3879
      @hamzamohamed3879 6 років тому

      I WILL NOT CURSE YOU BUT YOU ARE UNEDUCATED JUST READ THE QURAN AND SAHIH BUKHARI MAY ALLAH GUIDE YOU

  • @Brimsurfer
    @Brimsurfer 9 років тому

    lol look at the dislike, good job everyone.
    This is completely non-muslim practice, praying like this breaches so many Islamic teachings and yet these ignorant christians/jews like to come here and lecture us how to follow our religion without knowing even the first thing about Islam.
    It is our religion, we know how to implement and follow it.

  • @abdullohibnmasud
    @abdullohibnmasud 6 років тому +1

    May Allah guide her and the rest of the Muslims, Ameen.

  • @catotheelder9524
    @catotheelder9524 6 років тому +1

    Their prayers are invalid. They will have to repent and make up for them.

  • @bellasmith1507
    @bellasmith1507 10 років тому +1

    This video is truly an insult to Islam, a woman can not lead a prayer where men are present, it's forbidden during prayer to speak even if it's the translation only salat can be recited in Arabic, woman are not even wearing hijab, hair is showing, arms and necks are showing. What is this to betray to the people this is Islam! This is not the true and real teachings of Islam it's a mockery. Allahummasaliallahmuhamidinwaaleemuhamed.

    • @sageofgame
      @sageofgame 9 років тому

      Bella Smith i dont think she is leading more like educating non muslims like giving a tour in a mosque she reading surah arabic line then translation which is not common in prayer. she is showing non muslims how muslims pray and to try it so they can experience it. you can tell see the men and women are praying side by side. She is Not lead as people are portraying in comments.

  • @niblue5383
    @niblue5383 8 років тому +2

    Where does it say in the Quran that this is permissible? Their is no surah, no Hadith, nothing so why do it?

    • @khair7549
      @khair7549 7 років тому

      Nadia Amiri women can lead other women in salat, not men

  • @sageofgame
    @sageofgame 9 років тому

    i dont think she is leading more like educating non muslims like giving a tour in a mosque she reading surah arabic line then translation which is not common in prayer. she is showing non muslims how muslims pray and to try it so they can experience it. you can tell see the men and women are praying side by side. She is Not lead as people are portraying in comments.

  • @gyorgyimre6004
    @gyorgyimre6004 8 років тому +1

    I think she was helping aducate a group on Islam, not actually being imam.

    • @khair7549
      @khair7549 7 років тому

      György Imre if u think that Ur an idiot. no offense

  • @BlessedElizabeth
    @BlessedElizabeth 2 роки тому

    We need this in Fredericton New Brunswick Canada Insha'Allah

  • @khair7549
    @khair7549 7 років тому +1

    I felt like throwing up after watching this. my head hurts

  • @mr9rakib1
    @mr9rakib1 3 роки тому

    The lady in the back dont even cover their head

  • @jptoitle2122
    @jptoitle2122 9 років тому +2

    Assalaamu alaykum. It appears they are new Muslims. Maybe none of the men know the adhan or prayer? If the town is really small, and the only knowledgeable Muslim is a woman, I can understand. Allah swt knows the situation. Maybe she is teaching and will step down when enough knowledge is gained? Always try to give understanding. Allah swt is Most Merciful.

    • @forgivenesssave2172
      @forgivenesssave2172 8 років тому

      Its Assalamualaikum take good notes for what you are missing brother

  • @abdulwaheedcopeland1022
    @abdulwaheedcopeland1022 7 років тому

    christians jews and non Muslims have tooken themselves for gods. What Allah says goes bottom line. The audacity of some people is really shocking. May Allah guide in shaa Allah ta'ala Alhamdulillah I found Islam ☝

  • @liamenglish5632
    @liamenglish5632 6 років тому

    Astaghfirullah.. someone in the back is praying with their hands by their side!!

  • @WARGIRLWARGIRL
    @WARGIRLWARGIRL 9 років тому

    I will very much will like to pray behind a women but not next to a man also not a man behind of me. That said the second Imam on the video is talks like a ghetto Imam. In this times where man take away our rights do away with them I will like to see more woman leading the prayer.

  • @ayaancr
    @ayaancr 10 років тому +1

    hasbunallahu wa ni'mal wakeel.Astaghfurullah.what is this??woman "Imam" leading salah to men??and the women that are praying without hijab and aren't dressed properly??Inna lillahi wa inna ilayhi raji'un.this is fitna.stop this bida' and turn to Allah and ask forgivness.Wallah we are living in the end times.

  • @TheLondoner789
    @TheLondoner789 8 років тому

    she can't even recite with correct tajweed

  • @mohamuddeqfarah8915
    @mohamuddeqfarah8915 8 років тому

    To all Womens out There Dont be fooled By shaytaan and let him lead u in the wrong way. Fear allah and follow Prophet Muhammad Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam.

    • @niblue5383
      @niblue5383 8 років тому +2

      Epic-Games HD-vg takbir-Allahuakbar

  • @Aualan
    @Aualan 4 роки тому +1

    Should i cry or laugh🤔

  • @hasibabdullah1849
    @hasibabdullah1849 8 років тому

    you can't do the translation firstly and then a women cannot not not not not lead the prayer.

  • @Authentic_Islam90
    @Authentic_Islam90 7 років тому +1

    Subhan'Allah. completely jahil, someone needs to teach them their deen

  • @AlAndalusiIbnRagnar
    @AlAndalusiIbnRagnar 7 років тому

    I know people are pissed because it's in english translation.. but there is Many New Muslims who don't know the Arabic yet, So it'll be like them saying something which they don't know.
    And Having a Woman Imam.. Why Not ? Quran doesn't reject the idea BUT.. I Don't like that women are mixed with men. They should be separate because of Distractions

  • @reddevil8421
    @reddevil8421 7 років тому

    what flow it this, they r salah but not hearing mukenah( cloth salat for women) and imam is women. :(

  • @Eman.gazz98
    @Eman.gazz98 8 років тому

    Wow this is so bloody corrupt 😒 what in the world does she think she's doing! Okay first of all since when do we even interpret or translate the SALAT? and since when do women and men pray together, or when does a women even lead the salat with men? Wow if this is what this world has come to than I don't want to live till the next generations to come! ASTAGHFURALLAH!!

  • @catotheelder9524
    @catotheelder9524 6 років тому

    Inna lil lahi wa inna ilayhi rajioon.

  • @0o603
    @0o603 8 років тому +1

    not funny
    this cia islam
    it's making me vomit
    lurid

  • @hummyhumacide3688
    @hummyhumacide3688 7 років тому

    What kind of fuckery is this?

  • @user-sb7zv8sq1r
    @user-sb7zv8sq1r 3 роки тому

    Hahahahhahaha. Is this Islam? Or other religion. I'm confused

  • @hamzamohamed3879
    @hamzamohamed3879 6 років тому

    HOW DO READ QURAN IN SALAH AND TRANSLATE TO ENGLISH MAYBE YOUR UNEDUCATED MAY ALLAH GUIDE THIS UMMAH

  • @chicago1237
    @chicago1237 8 років тому

    in lihaah wa in haye raja onnnnnnn

  • @chicago1237
    @chicago1237 8 років тому

    what kind of islam is this ?

    • @0o603
      @0o603 8 років тому

      cia islam

  • @mohamedelgharbawy
    @mohamedelgharbawy Рік тому

    Bruh

  • @SaiyanGeneral
    @SaiyanGeneral 6 років тому

    CRINGE

  • @ekosudono1789
    @ekosudono1789 7 років тому +1

    hopefully .. they still learning and keep it up learning.. appreciated.. ..actually no need to translate as they understand the meaning..

  • @ameirameir3615
    @ameirameir3615 6 років тому

    WTF

  • @umal1085
    @umal1085 9 років тому +1

    filth.

  • @AsadAli-dn2vs
    @AsadAli-dn2vs 6 років тому

    Hahaha funny

  • @omarhabib7016
    @omarhabib7016 8 років тому

    reotardeds

  • @saanikaddafi846
    @saanikaddafi846 5 років тому

    Dayum.. cringeeee

  • @hasanmamedov3915
    @hasanmamedov3915 5 років тому

    Haram

  • @tanzeemkhanam3564
    @tanzeemkhanam3564 4 роки тому

    Laanat.....

  • @monicapedraza2781
    @monicapedraza2781 9 років тому

    shaytan

  • @HandsomeHunkization
    @HandsomeHunkization 7 років тому

    Wth .... everything is wrong in this from Imaam to Muqtadi....

  • @SayTheTruth313
    @SayTheTruth313 8 років тому

    I am vomiting

  • @g1heart
    @g1heart 9 років тому

    What nonsense it is