Bro he isn't comparing, just because she pointed out Muslim men, he gave an example telling that this doesn't happen only in muslim but happens in all other religions. And therefore if you take the ratio , muslim men have only 1 wife compared to all other religions, and only the quran tells "If you cant do justice , marry only one". Hope you understood bro :)
For example,you want to buy a thing that many brand have made and you have to choose,of course you're gonna compare it to see which is the best. Whats the point of asking the specs of the item and when you bought it,you see other item with better spec/price. Its only logical as human being to compare and after that you can judge.
Yes there is....First wives permission is a compulsion or an option There are only under dire circumstances one can have another wife. And equal treatment to all and all must be happy( this is the hardest..men can't do justice among their children, siblings and others you think they are capable to handle more than one wife..even Allah knew it was impossible..hence the clause
Mark 10:11-12 And he said to them, “Whoever divorces his wife and marries another commits adultery against her, and if she divorces her husband and marries another, she commits adultery.”
@@sjsupa 1 Corinthians 7:10-11 To the married I give this charge (not I, but the Lord): the wife should not separate from her husband (but if she does, she should remain unmarried or else be reconciled to her husband), and the husband should not divorce his wife.
I don’t understand why he compares his Islam n quran with other religions and shows that i n my islam is great than other religions and target to insult other religions what kind of human is he. And portray himself as an intellect
stupidity on its peak!he doesnot insult other religion, he just put truth in the light. he puts different perspective on the table so you could use your brain to understand n see the difference. he is even stating some facts given by indian government itself
@@inshrahzahid3842 yes U r right doesn’t insult .. he himself is an insult to his own religion. just by brain washing the muslims who are already struggling to gain respect in the society. He is himself vanishing the logic to choose right and imposing the religion of his thoughts. He is living in his own delusion. “ the so called intellect”
@@inshrahzahid3842dont be blind follower of this stupid man . just by brain washing the muslims who are already struggling to gain respect in the society. He is himself vanishing the logic to choose right and imposing the religion of his thoughts. He is living in his own delusion by targeting the innocent brains
@@inshrahzahid3842 Zakir is a Dumbass who supports vile thing like polygamy.Rather than trying to reform Muslim society he is holding onto centuries old practices which have been discarded by most of the communities.No wonder there are so many ex-muslims.
She asked “how can a man have multiple wives without the permission of his first wife”. Apparently he didn’t answer her question properly. Your logic makes sense if permission is required there. At the end its all about human rights and freedom.
When men have extra marital affairs, do they ask their wives and get their permission..when they misbehave and divorce them, they ask for their permission..Marry two women is not easy..you have to support two families equally...but extra marital affairs and divorcing one wife and marrying another is easy..but in islam extra marital relationships are not allowed..and any man who don't do justice between two wives will be punished..
@@truthistruth80 your reply was on point but there's one more things for @DahamNavinda that the time all these sculptures were made women were totally dependent on men and when some man would die leaving his wife or children, other people there would start adulting (idk what is that called lol) her and so other men would make them their wives in order to save them from those people cause at that time even the step siblings were also seen with bad eyes specially those who made siblings after a particular age and not since when they were kids.. so that time people who wanted to save the women from those situations they used to marry them.. and the only thing left is 'se*' so that's because every human has the desire and so the men were made to marry more than one wife on the condition that only if they would be just with both or all of their wives and that's why need to fulfill their desires too.... Otherwise they would have been given more than just a punishment ✨✨
It’s difficult to handle one spouse itself Who will want to marry twice.. like he said only if u can do justice marry more than one, in the present scenario, I do not think people are able to do justice with one itself .. most important is being true in relationship..
Of course now that depends on the man whether he could do justice or not... If he could do justice he is free of sin but if he can't do he disobeyed the Koran... So it is a big sin for him
Hahaha i am a muslim but i so agree with you..1 wife men cant manage.. i would not be ok with my man even looking at another women let alone marry.. better divorce first wife n then marry the second time
Listening to this guy, I can see his brilliance. He avoids answering the question that was asked and instead decides to go on a tangent answering something he wasn't asked. "The Quran is the only book that says you should only marry one wife" Yet when you compare the Abrahamic religions Muslim men practice polygamy in the highest proportion. Answer that question first and stop beating about the bush.
@@Truth65003 polygamy isn't allowed in Islam. Those verses were revealed during war when Muslims died and their women became widow and orphan and were applicable during that time only. Now, there is no war, so no polygamy!! Plus, even if women get widow today, they have financial family support, plus they are in jobs. Lastly, if you want to say that you are following sunnah, then follow it full. Marry widows and even elder women ( Khadija Radiallhu anha was 2 times widow and 16 years elder to prophet Muhammad sallallaahu alaihi wasallam). Zakir Naik doesn't have sound knowledge on Islam!!
She asked a very simple question about Muslim men allowed to marry more than once with out their first wives permission..Mr Naik could have answered without quoting other religions, or saying demographic requires one to do so... Firstly Islam gives permission but one has to consider many factors...1. The reason to marry. 2. First wives permission is a compulsion 3. Does he have the means to treat all wives equally..even the difference of a mustard should not be in both the households... This man is such a dramatic person..he is the one that causes more misconceptions people have towards islam than anybody else Jab apna hi sikka cchota ho tho kisi aur se kya shikayat.
You’re true.... and the one which he quoted about Krishnas wives are in Thousands That is a completely wrong statement Krishna has only two wives who are Rukmini and sathyabhama ... and Radha is only her loved one.
First wife's permission is not required..we should only follow islam ..do not try to change it according to your wishes...4 marriages are allowed but only with justice which is not easy for everyone..
He gave 2 options ! what about third option to remain single . My aunt is single independent woman by choice and she lives a respectful life . All I'm saying it was too harsh to connect 2 marriage with public property.
She can remain single if She is confident that she won't ,commit adultery.No problem according to Islam. Also What should One do if his first wife is Barren and they have tired everything??See One of the ways, He can compensate her to be a parent is my marrying a second and sharing the upbringings of those children with her. Also there are situations where the female initiates the second marriage e.g if she has Cancer then her husband can opt to marry a second wife while she is alive and stabilise his family.
Your Aunt is a human being and also has feelings that needs to be natured and satisfied why should she neglect those feelings because society deems pologamy taboo
This is what I have read about Hindu dharma:- In ancient times, all men and women in society were allowed to have only one life partner throughout their life except royal families and kings. Kings were allowed to have multiple wives as it benefitted their kingdom in many ways like maintaining political relationships with other kingdoms,avoiding wars, keeping peace etc. Whenever any man had multiple wives, many times his wealth, property, family time was never divided properly within all wives and their children. Some of his kids start feeling they don't get justice in family once they grew and it would create hostile situation among step brothers- sisters. Men with multiple wives suffered horrible old age days compared to men with single wives as later on none of their families was completely happy. Therefore polygamy should be avoided to get peaceful society.
This happend in every society lol back then shit was wild it would be illogical to call this just a Hindu thing even in Arabia the kindgdoms practiced this and in Europe it’s just now we are critiquing Islam of this flaw beacuase it’s very outdated
Regarding Solomon and Abraham in the Bible is an old Testament, but with the coming of Jesus and the New Testament of the Bible is to marry only one women by a man
@@gulshanaalani3261 please read..Mark 10:6-9 ESV But from the beginning of creation, ‘God made them male and female.’ ‘Therefore a man shall leave his father and mother and hold fast to his wife, and the two shall become one flesh.’ So they are no longer two but one flesh. What therefore God has joined together, let not man separate.” The two will become ONE- God created marriage for man and woman- not one man with 4 women...This is the teaching of God taught by Jesus.
I remember our neighbors over 2 decades ago, was a Muslim family. The man had 2 wives. At first when the family moved next door to us, the man only had 1 wife. about a year later, this man married his 2nd wife and the 2nd wife moved into the same house, which I thought was odd as I believed the man should have gotten his 2nd wife her own house and not live with both wives under 1 roof. Since that 2nd wife moved in, there was constant loud verbal arguments coming from this house. The wives definitely did not get along and it got so bad that other neighbors started calling the cops to report domestic violence. Eventually the family moved out about a year later after this man got married to his 2nd wife.
Lord Jesus Christ Said in unequivocal terms that I am GOD, read the following: Gospel according to John(new testament) {8:56} Your father Abraham rejoiced to see my day: and he saw [it,] and was glad. {8:57} Then said the Jews unto him, Thou art not yet fifty years old, and hast thou seen Abraham? {8:58} Jesus said unto them, Verily, verily, I say unto you, Before Abraham was, I AM GOD's name is I AM. -------------------------------- Exodus(old testament) {3:13} And Moses said unto God, Behold, [when] I come unto the children of Israel, and shall say unto them, The God of your fathers hath sent me unto you; and they shall say to me, What is his name? what shall I say unto them? {3:14} And God said unto Moses, I AM THAT I AM: and he said, Thus shalt thou say unto the children of Israel, I AM hath sent me unto you. {3:15} And God said moreover unto Moses, Thus shalt thou say unto the children of Israel, The LORD God of your fathers, the God of Abraham, the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob, hath sent me unto you: this [is] my name for ever, and this [is] my memorial unto all generations. {3:16} So GOD's name is I AM. See above : I {3:14} I AM hath sent me unto you Hence, GOD's name is I AM. -------------------------------------------- Jesus Christ says Exodus {20:1 to 20:3), Please see below. I am the only GOD there is. Exodus {20:1} And God spake all these words, saying, {20:2} I [am] the LORD thy God, which have brought thee out of the land of Egypt, out of the house of bondage. {20:3} Thou shalt have no other gods before me. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- new testament is the continuation of the old testament. Since the old testament GOD and Jesus Christ are one and the same. All Muslims are Christians. John 8:58, Jesus Christ Said/implied, He himself is the GOD mentioned in the Old Testament Exodus {20:1 to 20:3} Jesus Christ Said "He is the only GOD there is" John 8:58 and Exodus {20:1 to 20:3), are just enough, to affirm in unequivocal terms, that He is the GOD stated in the Old testament and He is the only GOD there is. Hence, All Muslims are Christians.
Yah... That what im talking about... Muslim says marriage purpose is to have peace... Really??? How can they have peace when there are wives fighting over him?
If you are going to have a second wife both wives have to be bisexual and open to it being a three-way thing. Otherwise there has to be a strict and undisturbed schedule for splitting the time equally between them
but if u r a muslim i m sorry u cant go against the wish of ur husband..that will be sin..in islam its right even if its wrong..prophet himself married his daughter in law..
Why prophet David(dawood) had 100+ wives ....thn why Hindu gods had thousands wives??? I don't know you are Hindu or Christian....why don't your mock your belief thn ???
I am single and not a public property I live as a Muslim woman and not considering getting married :) so I am not the public property just because I am single. Best regards Rumeysa from İstanbul :)
Mre power to u..u dunt need to b pitied nd u certainly dunt deserve to b labelled as" public property".. thays so unethical ..chosing nt to get married is the mst normal thing..many divorce women r also living a respectful nd honorable life throughout the world.
❤️Success is not built on success. It's built on failure, It's built on fraustration. it's built on fear that you have to overcome. I pray that anyone who reads this will be successful in life All thanks to Mrs Deborah Davis 🇺🇸
I'm from Egypt I used to take loan from the bank for surviver but after trading with Mrs Deborah Davis expert she changed my financial status for real I'm now a creditor not a debtor anymore
Pretty regressive to say women who cant marry can be equated to public property. The whole argument given is totally flawed. Not everyone, male or female gets married, a lot of times for reasons beyond control. Not getting married should not be equated to being dishonorable, neither for males nor females.
Hold on a minute you can't really ignore human urge to reproduce which is embedded in our genes. It's true not being able to marry doesn't make you public property but he's probably referring to people eloping without getting married. There's higher chance of that happening when you are not married.
this is exactly the point, no one should generalize for either the male or female, that they become public property if unmarried. There is of course the argument of sexual urgea and doing these within the boundaries of marriage only in every religion, but no one can judge that a single person automatically is a 'private property' even if they opt not to get married at all.
@@muneeburrehman8188 . Public property is that how the Muslim community sees these unmarried women? As for eloping maybe in India, Pakistan and some other Muslim country, where a young girl is to marry her 54 year old male relative - what is the choice?
This is called "Self acquired knowledge without holy spirit". Encouraging youngsters to merry numerous of wives in order to defend ones personality is totally wrong.
In old Testament they had two or three wives but in New testament one can have only one wife. You don't have any answers that's the reason your answers are rubbish
Who knows that whose fault is in your relationship ,your or your wife's ?? If you were a good person u wouldnot say these things about your wife in public 🙂
I understand it was a time where women were dependent on men so that's why it was ok to marry multiple women but time has changed, so its really orthodox to carry it on that too without permission of 1st wife.
As I have just commented, only poor women agree to polygamy, I have never heard or seen a medical doctor, a rich business lady, a professor, a lawyer etc agreeing to be a 2nd, 3rd or 5th wife, men are lusty
Millions of side chicks having babies the courts have to force men to pay child support on prove polygamy is needed as the least of two evils. It works with nature and lives in reality. Instead of having us all live in rose-colored glasses. Hundreds of countries with job shortages, unliveable pay rates and no welfare do as well. Islam is based on reality. Not what we like.
@@fatimahkwape8621 Dang what kind of argument ad remark are you putting simply generalize men. I had a friend whose mother is a Surgeon, which shared her husband with 2 other wives of his. One is a teacher the other is a businesswoman. They are happy, my friend got a good grade in class, got along with his siblings with another mother, even came to his sick step sister when she got sick, invited us all for a big family gathering for dinner. What is so lustful about that. You are just being prejudiced towards men.
Maintaining multiple wives is different than getting married more than once and getting divorced. And she stood there simply without raising this point.
Zakir naik cannot help insulting other community and other religions and thereby inviting the same to his prophet. Simple logic would be then if Mohammad f*cked 9 year old girl, should Christians too do the same? Quran being so called eternal book, could it not anticipate the 21st century and give advice wisely? Why does Zakir Naik have to utter the names of Hindu deities from his dirty mouth? I am glad that Indian government chased away this scoundrel and now all his followers should be chased too.
He repeatedly says marry multiple times only if you can do justice to them. But the wife who is the person who is in the recieving end of this justice has no say in the matter. So he can do anything and there is no accountability 😂
@@fax_spitter you fool,I'm talking about the first wife. Even if she married a person with no previous wives, the husband can marry another wife without her permission. Then she would have wasted her good years. Who will compensate her? Suppose the husband loves the new wife more and spends more time with her. The first wife with her kids and no job, in what strength will she divorce her husband even if she's not recieving justice? Where's the accountability.
If quran is word of god and all other religious scriptures are mythology, why zakir makes comparison between them? There is no point in comparing word of god and word of a human.
Brother, islam says their are more than 1 lakh 24 thousand prophets, which were sended towards earth. We don't know all and their books. One of them may be krishna Or ur religious messenger. Quraan clear ly says respect them and their books but in many casses their religious book was editid by human..
Brother Siddharth wrote if Quran only word of God why Zaki makes comparison ? If Zaki say any matter is Correct because it is written in Our Quran, will you accept ? By comparison we can think which one is correct which one is not, we never said Quran is only word of God, Allah send many messengers and books but time to time people changed it, the verses matches with Quran we have not any objection to take it, you people have guts to accept verses of Quran that matches with your scriptures ? If yes first to believe there is Only one God
Regarding "public property" we refer to this more professionally as "single".. men become available, by age, death, divorce and marriage can still be a part of the future regardless of a population count on any specific day.. a time being single is a time for personal development, community service, adventure, growth and so on.. being single shouldn't be frowned upon or considered sinful..
@nightingale3688 it is kind of true everywhere. I'm sure the stigma implies that single people are menacing. They are often available to people who aren't happy in a relationship and or are the temptation possibly.
I really like how much effort he puts in just to defend himself but we all know according to the current world that polygamy is still unfair to the women ... + He is comparing Krishna with himself and other mere humans when he don't even know the story behind Shri Krishna having 16008 wives , only 8 of them had any major role as wives in real life ... + Acc. to him Quran says have only one wife and still u have so many .. Hindu scriptures says have 4 wives and still Hindus have 1 wife ( u r not supposed to count divorced wives here ) .... U r talking about exceptions here , Exceptions are everywhere + he is comparing current times with whole another Yugas + remaining unmarried is also a choice for women . These are the things which I think can easily disprove his answer .
Brother i have read Gita and completely understood it . That is the reason, we also told Muhammad( PBUH) married 9 wives not for pleasures etc. only and only to support them. But you guys still mock us even if we give so many proof.
Let anyone marry as many as they want, it's their choice! What's anyone's business?! Why speak about any religion or faith?! It's very sensitive issue. Let's respect all!
@@vishwasmalhotra3714 That is debatable since it not mentioned in Quran. But it is mentioned in Bhagvad Gita that Krishna married 8 year old Rukmini. I can give you page no. if you want to check. Salam
it's some men but not all. the quran explain, in sura al-nisa chapter 4 verses 3 only those men who are Justice and can manage would marry moreover than 2 wives
Oh yes we can! Why is there still alimony for the ex wife?! Financial support is rhe biggest motive to have multiple wifes. Thats why it is only permissible when you can maintain up to 4 women! And when you commit fornication dont defend polygamy! When you f. 20x times without marriages your re a sinner and cheap profiteer the polygamy concept.
@@cherylwalker4242 Corinthians doesn’t mention any number of wives. And Timothy is talking about the overseer/bishop/minister. And even though Timothy does mention one wife, non of the translation of versions use the word ‘only’ in reference to one wife. That would be speculation based on deduction but nevertheless speculation.
Well answering a question and comparing other religions are different things , people in many religion doesn't marry more than once not cuz it's written in their books but because there books teach them this without specifically mentioning that marry once .
@Imran pathan umm actually there are no text which said marry only one. but we try to marry one because we got motivation from our gods, and we do not marry women for only children's like another religion we love them so we marry. In almost case our hindu also got 2,3 wife's as zakir said, many cases you will get because of some uneducated man. We want to be a holy person, don't you think this type then i will say you are using women's as children's machine.
@Imran pathan what do you understand, I didn't said for everyone I said them who thinks they can have 2 or more wifes, Who don't want to be holy as Lord rama. That's the difference between your and our thoughts. i didn't named the religion because I don't want to blame them but you named them, if I will name the religion specially I will say to Islam because their thought isn't worth to a perfect person. And stop producing 5,6,7,8 etc.. Number of children's.
@Imran pathan reply to my previous answer man, if you don't have answer for my reply then you are not worth to say about hinduism. And i will not say your Islam is fake because I respect other religion's but not to your thoughts. And another matter you said hinduism is based on fake things, which thing is fake tell me i will accept if that's proven wrong you have to accept our hinduism isn't fake. I gave you a open challenge💪💪
polygamy isn't allowed in Islam. Those verses were revealed during war when Muslims died and their women became widow and orphan and were applicable during that time only. Now, there is no war, so no polygamy!! Plus, even if women get widow today, they have financial family support, plus they are in jobs. Lastly, if you want to say that you are following sunnah, then follow it full. Marry widows and even elder women ( Khadija Radiallhu anha was 2 times widow and 16 years elder to prophet Muhammad sallallaahu alaihi wasallam). Zakir Naik doesn't have sound knowledge on Islam!!
@@Asif49858 same is in hindu polygamy is not allowed until there is a good reason behind it like for lord krishna he saved 16000 women from a demon and those women said the world would not accept us because we were imprisoned by the demon so lord krishna married all the woman so they can live as a queen in swarg lok.
@@kartikyadav4068 exactly. Sunnah is to marry someone who is vulnerable. Now, if you marry a widow, Or orphan or someone who has no means of Living and taking care of herself you can marry her with the intention of giving her support as there is hadith which says, "actions are judged by intention". If such a situation arises where a woman needs support and your intention is pure its fine. Whereas if there is a needy and you are helping her but in your heart you have lustful intentions you are digging your grave with your own hands and going towards hellfire!
@@Asif49858 I have a question, you can marry upto 4 wives not by Love but due to arise of some situations, rescue them or provide and protect them cases, No I'm confused, "marry upto 4 if u can do justice for all" wt exactly justice meant there?
Vishnu Puran chapter 24, verse 1 - The King said: 1. Venerable Sir! I now desire, to hear from you the story of the first incarnation of Lord Hari of miraculous exploits, wherein he assumed the form of a fish, through his deluding potency (Māyā). Hinduism is about spirituality not like this nonsense. Lord Krishna has only 8 wives originally. The remaining 16,100 women are from the pleasure house of Kamsa (who was killed by Krishna). After he was killed these women came to Sri Krishna and told him they want to die as no one is going to marry them nor are they getting any respect from the society. So Krishna decided to marry them so that they will get Royal status and respect as queen. DON'T SPREAD HALF TRUTHS.
Yup he didn't answer her question just beating the bushes and using some logical fallacy and trying to compare others to glorify his religion No straight answer
Live in the present generation. Follow moral standards, love urself love ur family and neighbors, love ur country. Don't sow enemity in people's mind .now a days people are craving for peace of mind. Preach them how to live happily and peacefully first 🙏.
@@ritisharajpal7464 I don't want to live how people lived 1443 years ago but want to live as the sahaba lived. When Islam came saudi was not the same as it was before. it totally changed and got better. Religion is not people. Religion cannot be changed but people can. But Muslims are the only people who have not changed even single word from quran nor did they stopped following it.. And if you're saying that religion should not be followed just because it's old then stop following hinduism it's anyways the most dumbest religion in the world🤣 oh I forgot hindus are hindus only because they are born in hindu family they never follow hinduism🤣😂😅😆😁
First of all the true fact is that even as per thousand years old Bhagavad Gita, You have to have only legitimate relationship with your legal wife. Even if you want to take to Sanyasam alone , you can't unilaterally take to Sanyasam unless your legal wife agrees for it. The rules in the Bhagavad Gita are very strict as per scriptural texts. Read slokas 16-23 & 16-24 of the Bhagavad Gita for further guidance in this regard.
@@yusufkhalil9718 polygamy isn't allowed in Islam. Those verses were revealed during war when Muslims died and their women became widow and orphan and were applicable during that time only. Now, there is no war, so no polygamy!! Plus, even if women get widow today, they have financial family support, plus they are in jobs. Lastly, if you want to say that you are following sunnah, then follow it full. Marry widows and even elder women ( Khadija Radiallhu anha was 2 times widow and 16 years elder to prophet Muhammad sallallaahu alaihi wasallam). Zakir Naik doesn't have sound knowledge on Islam!!
@@Zalimpathan-z1m halala means after divorce women become sister of ex husband. If she marry another man then she got divorced at any age of life then her ex husband will not seen as brother
At the same time we have Hindus divorcing their cheating wife and taking American woman as wives. If it is the American women's first marriage tell me now who her true husband is ? In America many women are 'Public Property' just as Muslim or any other men (8 partners?!?? Tell me who his wife is if he is 'Public Property'???) Being public property is NOT culturally equal to a previous marriage. Even Americans value Marriage too, so much that we STOPPED getting married to other Americans because the divorce statistics
@@imraanedwin3252Matthew 19: 3-6 : 3 The Pharisees also came unto him, tempting him, and saying unto him, Is it lawful for a man to put away his wife for every cause? 4 And he answered and said unto them, Have ye not read, that he which made them at the beginning made them male and female, 5 And said, For this cause shall a man leave father and mother, and shall cleave to his wife: and they twain shall be one flesh? 6 Wherefore they are no more twain, but one flesh. What therefore God hath joined together, let not man put asunder. Words of the LORD Jesus Christ
@@shovonalam8372 she's asking why have 4 wives? Zakir talk about Emperors having thousands concubines, King Solomon having hundreds of wives etc... Sidestepping the main question....
@@alantan9585 when did he talk about concubines, those were examples of the past. do you understand context or just have bad faith?? he did not sidestep anything but He has explained the whole thing in past context and then also in present context...did you even watch the whole thing?? stop doing this shitty bad faith comments. You are responsible for negativity in this world, you add to islamophobia speaking shit like that...STOP!!
@@alantan9585 end of the day, the Muslim family model, marriage model is the best way subhanallah! we have the lowest rate of divorce, single parent problem. Look at the west and their high divorce rate, high number broken family which affects children immensely. most Muslim men don't marry more than 1, only a few who has the means to do justice do that and that even only in very few parts of the world. The whole question was a bad faith thing, trying to show some flaw in Islam. His examples just shattered that bad faith argument.
@@alantan9585 you didn't carefully. He is not side steped. Well, I am asking you how many of your Muslim friends have four wives? Or point out how many? He gave today's example like Darnendara etc. If you are a Tamilian, Gemini Ganesan , ex CM Karunanidi you knows how many wives they got. Even though awere of law. So many have KEEP for sexual purpose. Some known by first wife some don't. No matter how rich you are its carry on by all class of people. KAMALA HASAN is today's example. And so many like him.
@Ankit Mehrotra 😂 chill son. You can’t disprove DR. Zakir’s argument. He is quoting form your scriptures. If you wanna verify his claim check on vedic websites.
@@sksuleman4735 krishna married 16000 girls to save them, he didn't sleep with them, he adopt them after freeing them cause the society denied to accept them..please know the full truth before saying anything..
@@sksuleman4735you won’t understand 😂Krishna before reading his life history…make a comment on any person who is the best of and bests …first read the scripture ..then you would get to know why Krishna married 16,108 wives and how many of them carried krishna’s kids in their wombs ?
To the amazing person who is reading this, I wish you all the best in life. Don't be too hard on yourself; accept your mistakes and move on. Allow no one else to define "success" for you. Get up, develop the necessary skills, and get to work; the keys to a happy life are in your hands. Continue to push forward.👍
Chomu they were God's who we never saw and following. Ate u God ? You even can't pronounce properly.... learn speaking English course in Delhi first. Chomu.
Brother, you are wrong. In Hinduism also it has been said that a man should marry only one wife.See the seventh word to be taken at the time of marriage which Hindu scriptures have given The girl tells the groom that you will consider foreign women like mothers and will not allow anyone else to come in between the love of husband and wife. If you promise to do so, I agree to come to your Vamang.See this is not the case for kings because they may have to marry princesses of other countries to have relations with other countries. But Shri Krishna ji had done such 16,100 marriages because when sri krishna freed 16,100 girls from a demon named bhaumasur. all girls did not go back to her home and started saying that no one will accept us. We have come back from this demon, so you accept us as your wife. Then Shri Krishna ji accepted him but he had done eight marriages. Shri Krishna ji did the rest of the 8 marrges. This was done for this reason to show that this may also have to be done to keep the empire established.and Dasrath jiwas also a king . And the things that you said that Brahmins can marry four, then all those things are written in the Baudhayana Dharmasutra which is written by humans and not any Purana. It is not written in Vishnu Purana . You said wrong.t was okay to have four marriages then. ISLAM IS GREAT According to Islam, because it would have been done after the war to give them shelter. But now it is not right to do this and a woman can easily spend her life alone.🙂🙂🙏🙏
(4:3) If you fear that you might not treat the orphans justly, then marry the women that seem good to you: two, or three, or four. If you fear that you will not be able to treat them justly, then marry (only) one,5 or marry from among those whom your right hands possess.
I am a Muslim woman … ❤ but I will never ever let any women touch my man other than his mother , daughters and sisters only . ❤ Allahu Akhbar . May Allah bless all spouses be one and only among both and love eternally aameen ❤❤❤❤
Going against the principle of Islam, you are opening the door of hell for yourself. In Islam men can marry 4 wives as commanded by our porphet saw and they don't need tour permission. And don't you dare deny the words of our prophet if you are truly a muslim. I believe men naturally have more responsibilities, so if they feel the need they deserve to have more wives just like our prophet saw had 11 wives and some concupines. Alhamdulillah!!
This is what the God say in the Bible . 1 Timothy Chapter 3 verse 2 A bishop then must be blameless, the husband of one wife. 1 Timothy Chapter 3 verse 12 Let the deacons be the husbands of one wife, ruling their children and their own houses well. Titus Chapter 1 verse 6 if any be blameless, the husband of one wife, having faithful children unruly.
It has always been more males than females...only during the great wars did the male population decline substantially...he is just giving false data to favour his argument
End of the day, it is your beliefs vs their beliefs. No need to compare. Do what you think is ok for you. Society and ppl will always judge. This applies for members of all religions.
Well we practiced sati in Hinduism guess we should have let that huh? If something is immoral we question it. Even if it's God. I bet the real God dont make me question bcoz he is Good all the time
No we can't accept others belief if they are immoral. Like he said Sati Act. That would be ignorance. People won't change until someone else try to question them.
@@justanintrovertwithcooldp7 That was a belief shared by certain societies. Not every widow was burned alive, after her husband passed on. Lord Ramar's mother was the queen dowager until her son's accession to the throne, upon which she was widely honoured as the queen mother, despite her husband passed away years ago. Yet some societies refused to look at this
Exactly bro u have family u have ur relegion follow it y bother about others idk y people stress out so much y cant we leave peacefully relegions are meant to be peaceful but today people for their personal benefits made relegion a evil
Krishna releases 16000 women from narakasura prison. He didn’t marry them of lust. This misinformation that krishna having many wives was used as a tactic by desert religions from centuries.. yet they couldn’t dismantle sanatana dharma
Permission me aur use applicable krne me diffrence hai. Aese permission to Hinduism me bhi. Pr use apply to bhut km krte hai. Aur 4 wife's maje ke liye nhi krni hai agr koi gareeb hai. Vidhwa hai ya koi aur prblm hai tbhi insan krta hai.
So you didn't watch the video? 9:02 The number of women in the world is more than the number of men. This is why Allah permitted polygamy for men who are capable, to solve this problem, to protect the women from becoming public property.
@@MaskedGuyCh you People have favoured weirdest laws and rules in your religion,as like these are created by foolish men,non of God would preach this kind of knowledge
Bible tells about the remarriage and also the conditions Matthew 19:9 (ESV) And I say to you: whoever divorces his wife, except for sexual immorality, and marries another, commits adultery. Divorce is the only way to end marriage underthese conditions and even if a person wants to remarry these are the conditions, God clearly permits remarriage after the death of a spouse and actually encourages remarriage for younger widows (Romans 7:1-3, 1 Corinthians 7:8-9,27-28,39-40; 5:11-16). God never allowed CHRISTIANS for polygamy.
@@human7491 If you believe God doesn't make mistake and that same GOd ask you Muslim to believe the book before Quran and we all believe God to have knowledge of every thing including what will happen in the future so by this does it mean God didn't know that christians will change d words in the bible later in the future ??? So stop saying bible is not the word of God or it has been alter because that statement alone means you don't believe in Quran
@@human7491 I believe that Muhammed who rose after 6 centuries., with kinky mind., god have chosen only jacob., vexation from a branches Ishmael is a Muhammed who said himself as a prophet ., he wrote a book in which he said that bible is gods word but it is misleaded so god again wrote a new book through me so everyone believe me., and he also mentioned cleverly that he is the last prophet., so brainless one can change his kinky words.. cleverly he wrote a story book for his convenience and himself proclaimed it as holiest ever books., no offence it's my belief.
Well I very much appreciate the first answer that the gentleman gave that it's nowhere mentioned in the Qur'an Sharif to marry multiple times. But, his second answer is very much wrong. Is marrying a woman the only way to protect her?? That way the man plays with the feelings of his wife nd breaks her heart just to protect the other woman while not protecting his own wife's feelings. I completely disagree with his second answer. If it's mentioned in the Qur'an Sharif to marry only once, then it means marrying twice while your first wife is alive or you're not divorced is a sin as much as adultery. And talking about men protecting women, they should start considering every woman as a daughter, a mother, a sister nd their wife as a life companion and not a body to be used.
Clearly the Dr didn’t have time to got through 1 Corinthians chapter 7. US Christians do not support polygamy and the Bible clearly says this. Don’t group us in your dilemma, answer the question.
@@RDBclub40 It's promise of Creator that Quran is the last book and no one will change it till day of judgement..million of muslims memorise it by heart..so it's impossible to change..
Public property means, she can have sex with anyone irresponsibly. We morally degraded too far that adultery is dating. But i get your point, that's a poor choice of word that he use
@@chakravartin3356 not everyone has same mindset when it comes to morality if a women doesn’t have problem with what she does with her body than Zakir & people like u should mind ur own business
@@nehasheikh5492 then medieval sex slavery is not about women's body being sold, if every women back then using today's women mindset. So, what's all the fuss about those slavery? Is it because the money didn't goes straight to their pocket but instead to their slaver first? Who knows
@@chakravartin3356 wow 🤣what a comparison, people like u need to open dictionary and read the meaning of CONSENT, slave women doesn’t consent to sex it’s forced sex while when a women chooses to have sex without someone forcing her that’s called consensual sex and people like u & Zakir need to buzz away from women who don’t mind having consensual sex ... keep your morality compass inside your pocket
Its not obligatory to have 4 wife in Islam. It is optional to have more than one wife. Even marrying is not obligatory for everyone. And even marriage is unlawful for some people.
@@anupamatirkey2648 Optional means you can but it has some conditions. You must have the physical and mental and economical ability to care for more than one wife. If you can't make equity then it is forbidden in Islam to marry more than one wife. And there is no religious in the world says this. Other religious scriptures don't clear the number of wives. And why women don't have the right to marry more than one wife? Its very biological and psychological brother. Women have menstrual circle in a month. Mostly it stays 4-5 days(bleeding) and before the circle and after the circle they have many mood swings also. That means women should be left for 10 days in the month. But when one woman has more than 1 husbands she has to please them physically but how can she please them biologically...Its very tough for women. Then comes another thing, if a women has more than one husband, when a child will take birth, how can we know who is the father? In ancient time it was not possible. Now we have DNA test but it is very uncultural to do dna test for knowing the father. You can see in the animal kingdom also. One lion lead a group of women. It is very common in nature. And there are many countries, in which women ratio is larger than the male. Men have to take responsibilities of them. In accident, in disease, in war male die more than women. Women babies are physically more stronger than male child. Hope you got the answer.
I blame her for asking a question where she has done no research and hence left dumbfounded with no points for a productive debate. She helped establish "women are helpless without men, and if not under a man, will be a public property". I hope jounalists are able to defend their point. Dont ask questions unless you educate yourselves to defend your questions. She has helped glorify polygamy. You let us down Sister.
Why blame her ? She's not even a journalists , just a regular person who wants to ask a question . It's him who Never answered her one question , twisted stuffs ,spoke about the all religions , world demography ,circled around the whole world to defend polygamy in Islam .
@@MDgp5dl but yeah... He is a toxic bigot who's poisoning our country and the world with nothing but illogical unreasonable unsubstantiated statements. I pity the part of humanity who falls for it.
Mam ...it is not men vs women. It is patriarchal male muslims vs whole world. No religion is following polygamy now except Islam. It is against basic human rights which can be challenged anywhere across the globe but people like Zakir Naik are using their half cooked knowledge in converting people into Islam .It is his prime agenda to convert people of other religions into Muslims just by demeaning the religion and brainwashing them.whenever he talks he compares the religions to make people feel proud for Islam and feel pity or shame for their religion. He always shows one side of the coin. He never talks about triple talaq, Halala, Burqa and Hizab ban, Population control, Uniform civil code etc because he is a religious fundamentalist getting funded from gulf countries for converting people into Muslims. He is absconding from India because of fear of arrest .He is staying in Malaysia and doing the same business of converting innocent Malaysians. NIA and ED are looking for issuing red corner notice via Interpol to Zakir Naik foundation. He is involved in converting people and illicit funding from gulf or north Africa.
I think this Sir got confused with the question....he answered " What are your thoughts on polygyny according to various holy books of different religion"..... But the actual question was, "Whether polygyny and polyandry are given equal rights or not. And if not, then what's your take".
@@SUDMAA watch the video carefully. He said that girl child's are stronger than boy child when they born. That's why many male child die in the time of birth. Also many man die from accidents,wars,diseases etc. That's why there are more women in the world than mans. it can't be changed
Really I mean, he talked about so many religions. But didn't talk about that currently, Nobody's practicing polygamy expect the people he's defending. Man, world works on present.
@@ghostiexd4982 Marry two women is not easy..you have to support two families equally...but extra marital affairs and divorcing one wife and marrying another is easy..but in islam extra marital relationships are not allowed..and any man who don't do justice between two wives will be punished..
Please forget scriptures, which were written long back.Come to present age, live practical life, love all, dont hurt anybody.To live peacefully on this planet , logic is not necessary, we need tolerance and understanding.
question 1. जहां पुरुष ज्यादा शादी करे तो महिला भी करेगी क्या अपने husband को पूछने जाएगी। छुप छुप के करेगी या नहीं? 2. दूसरी तीसरी वाइफ को ही इन्साफ तो दे देगा पुरुष पर सभी बच्चों को education देके इंसान बनाए या बिना पढ़े जानवर बनाए । शादी सिर्फ मनौरंजन नहीं जिम्यादारी भी हे या नहीं ? 3. सभी धर्म ने पहले बहु पत्नी वाले रिवाज को हटाया और एक पत्नी रिवाज लगाया सिर्फ महिला और बच्चो के कारण अब इस्लाम कब सुधार करेगा। मुस्लिम भाई को कानून तो इंडियन चाहिए या वही इस्लामिक चाहिए ?
Last week one married Muslim surprised me when she said marrying many wives is Sunna then I asked her, what is Sunnah? She said that men with many wives their sin will be forgive by the Allah. I asked her how can true God forgive man's sin for marrying many wives? She kept quiet!
only the sex-obsessed will completely agree with Naik. 😁😁😁😁 ua-cam.com/video/TUU7997VTyY/v-deo.html I hope you understand Arabic, unfortunately there is no translation
Sunnah = ignorance...😁😁😁😁 sunnis want to understand god's book by reading people's books, putting aside god's book. polygamy is an invention of sex addicts
The reason for krishna marrying those woman was because they have been held captive for years by a demon called Narakasur, and they will not be accepted in the society.. So only to restore their honor krishna accepted them as his wives. Preachers like Zakir Naik should not utter a word if he cannot defend his religion without bringing other religions down. A preacher is someone who delivers a sermon publicly not a person who converts other people to his religion by taking advantage of people's lack of knowledge regarding their religion's scriptures...
so dear in islam its the prequationary step to give respect to women before she becomes the public property what krishna does is after step the womens got freedom from that rakshasa. The logic is very simple if only one man is there and he is having a wife with younger sister and if no men left in so to protect her from becoming scort/public property she wil choose the option to let her marry with her husband and also marrying is not only thing you have to give her an equal rights. Marriage is thats why a contract where 2 peopels by there will geeting into a relationship its not like that men wil force hes sister-in law to marry with him its ultimately her choice but as if you see a respectable answer then its best to get marry with a men rather becoming public property. Correct me if wrong. 😊😊
I see no logic/reason in him calling certain women public property. Chosing multiple sexual partners is an individual choice. However it does not gives others any right of using derogatory comments against them.
A true leader always has respect for other religion.... If your leader don't respect other religion don't follow such leader or such religion.... Because respecting other religion is the basic lesson of a religion
Is there an islam husband who satisfied having one wife and loyal to his only beloved wife while he is allowed to have so many wives 🥺?If there are these men ,salute 🔥 and for Poor Islam girls ,thousand hugs 🫂
@Digital Bath David wood is a psychopath hate preacher who lies about Islam for youtube views. He claims he's a Christian but instead of preaching christianity or going to a church and doing any work he decides to sit in his basement and falsely accuse another religion without any concrete evidence. He's a bum who got embarrassed by Mohammed Hijab and I doubt he's even a Christian. Where in the bible does it command someone to slander or lie about another religion?
@Digital Bath Ask or never dare to debate with David wood, David wood destroyed like his gradegrandfather in knowledge, that's why he knows very well, he will not survive. Zakir will say bring 10000 people to debate, why need 10000 people,
She asks about logically and he answers it first religiously and then logically and no one is gonna deny that fact a man has more than 8 female partners before he settles down with one, its like using 8 tissue papers throwing in a bin and then having a perfect handkerchief for himself!!!!
@@ramavtarpandey4200 not angry but frustrated....when u specifically try to demean those people and ignore a large section of your own community doing the same thing..... anyway talking against and in favor of polygamy in general is no problem.
@@randomthought2026 Law in India: that Hindus cannot do polygamy whereas Muslims still have the right of polygamy in the name of personal law. That is why it is said for Islam that this religion is not fit in today's time. In the countries where Islam is a majority, they become Islamic countries and violate the rights of women: But in secular countries, they keep spreading terror over non-Muslims and women.
@@randomthought2026 What is the rationale for creating an Islamic country? After all, why can't these people of Arabic religion remain secular? There is no christian or hindu country then why this Islam gives such teaching??
I don't know about other scriptures ,but I quote the Bible here 1Ti 3:2 A bishop then must be blameless, the husband of one wife, vigilant, sober, of good behaviour, given to hospitality, apt to teach; 1Ti 3:12 Let the deacons be the husbands of one wife, ruling their children and their own houses well Tit 1:6 If any be blameless, the husband of one wife, having faithful children not accused of riot or unruly.
@@kwesifelixboafo5333 (4:3) If you fear that you might not treat the orphans justly, then marry the women that seem good to you: two, or three, or four. If you fear that you will not be able to treat them justly, then marry (only) one, or marry from among those whom your right hands possess. This will make it more likely that you will avoid injustice. Literally on the video 😂
Common sense and logic if she’s pregnant whose the father of the four husbands 😂😂😂 wats wrong with some of you logic please hving many wives doesn’t create any birth problems cause all women produce for the same man 😂😂😂
Common sense and logic if she’s pregnant whose the father of the four husbands 😂😂😂 wats wrong with some of you logic please hving many wives doesn’t create any birth problems cause all women produce for the same man 😂😂😂
It's haram for a woman to have more man as husband it's like that if your mother sleep's with more man then how your mother Will know that you are from which men and you are who's breed
You didn't watch the entire video Women are already more than men in population so if they merry more than one men the society will be unbalanced that's why.
I completely disagree with this person. When asked why Islam allows four marriages, instead of answering the question, he always compares it to other religions and makes irrelevant statements. This person just brainwashes people by looking at half-baked information. He doesn’t know anything.😡 The story of the 16,100 additional wives comes from the legend where Krishna saved them from the captivity of a demon named Narakasura. After being freed, these women had nowhere to go, as society wouldn't accept them, so Krishna married them to give them dignity and respect. This number is symbolic and represents Krishna’s divine nature and his capacity for boundless love and protection. It is not meant to be taken literally in terms of human relationships.
As a women I will say: Thank you? like, for the well-meant intentions????? Marriage as a social contract should no longer be a condition in order to protect anyone, every single human being regardless its gender, age, or civil state should be protected by their state. And this is an obligation for them (The State) to fulfill, and if not for us to claim. We, as human beings deserve all protection just by existing alone, any other input is absolute nonsense and *negligent.* Statements of this nature promote diminishing human values, case in point the absurd idea of people being treated as property, which is an insane, dangerous, outrageous and outdated belief to spread. *A single woman is never public property. No human being is.* The idea of marriage in the 21st century, polygamy-focused, based in the poor premise of justifying an ancient male hierarchy in order for woman to "be protected" (if you will) its just insanely obsolete and absurd.
For the proper development of human life, man needs two elements: 1. resources to maintain life and to fulfill the material needs of the individual and society, and 2. knowledge of the principles of individual and social behavior to enable man to fulfill himself and to maintain justice and tranquillity in human life. The Lord of the universe has provided for both of these in full measure. Marriage plays a major role in protecting someone from the sins of adultery, masturbation and homosexuality. Marriage takes away the possibility of all evils and sins such as child abortion, unknown birth father and irresponsible partner. Through marriage the couple will have righteous offspring. It is the survival of generation and it results in obtaining great and good rewards by having righteous children. Anyway, the Lord of the universe must have a reason for any restrictions imposed to the human kind regardless in the context of marriage or any other matters. If we're living in this world without any guidance and guideline, surely we'll be clueless and unjust.
The real question is who is saying you to do second marriage...if you have guts,or you can afford or your wife is happy you can marry..simple...its is not compulsary....as sir naik said..but you so called educated fool will not understand it..
I agree. Polygamy is evil of society. If u want to marry another women then divorce the women that u are currently living with, and then marry another women.
I am a Hindu but when I researched on Islam I found of it because Islam is the right way to live in kaliyuga , Islam saves lot of things in once life it is the only religion of real peace
Plus for me the “ you must do justice “ gets confused.. How can you equally treat, take care, love, 2,3 or 4 different people? Deep inside you will always prefer one over the other in certain areas right? Or simply preferring one over the rest.. it’s human nature! So my final idea on it..it’s you can’t do justice so just marry one 👍🏾
@@dhanwantieseeram8147 well by justice means providing equal to them and don't fancy one of them well some may not be able to do that but must can that's why they are living a happy life with their wives so it's about choice which one you prefer most either marrying one or more than one
Brother, you are wrong. In Hinduism also it has been said that a man should marry only one wife.See the seventh word to be taken at the time of marriage which Hindu scriptures have given The girl tells the groom that you will consider foreign women like mothers and will not allow anyone else to come in between the love of husband and wife. If you promise to do so, I agree to come to your Vamang.See this is not the case for kings because they may have to marry princesses of other countries to have relations with other countries. But Shri Krishna ji had done such 16,100 marriages because when sri krishna freed 16,100 girls from a demon named bhaumasur. all girls did not go back to her home and started saying that no one will accept us. We have come back from this demon, so you accept us as your wife. Then Shri Krishna ji accepted him but he had done eight marriages. Shri Krishna ji did the rest of the 8 marrges. This was done for this reason to show that this may also have to be done to keep the empire established.and Dasrath jiwas also a king . And the things that you said that Brahmins can marry four, then all those things are written in the Baudhayana Dharmasutra which is written by humans and not any Purana. It is not written in Vishnu Purana . You said wrong.t was okay to have four marriages then. ISLAM IS GREAT According to Islam, because it would have been done after the war to give them shelter. But now it is not right to do this and a woman can easily spend her life alone.🙂🙂🙏🙏.
that makes no sense...so you should have only one child because having 2 or more will make you love one more than other because of the human nature as well.
Why is a man allowed marry 4 wives but why is not allowed for women marry 4 men 😂😅
Wow😂
You blind
Men below members in world
because in quran :surah Al nisa ' Ch.4 V.3 said men only Me can marry women of your choice IN 2s, 3s OR 4s"... Lolllllllll "
@@Rabbitmamayt but why ??
I would love to hear him give answer without being comparative and biased. Straight without comparing other religions.
Bro he isn't comparing, just because she pointed out Muslim men, he gave an example telling that this doesn't happen only in muslim but happens in all other religions. And therefore if you take the ratio , muslim men have only 1 wife compared to all other religions, and only the quran tells "If you cant do justice , marry only one". Hope you understood bro :)
For example,you want to buy a thing that many brand have made and you have to choose,of course you're gonna compare it to see which is the best. Whats the point of asking the specs of the item and when you bought it,you see other item with better spec/price. Its only logical as human being to compare and after that you can judge.
It is like if hitler killed millions why can't i kill just 2 he didn't really answer it
Yes there is....First wives permission is a compulsion or an option
There are only under dire circumstances one can have another wife.
And equal treatment to all and all must be happy( this is the hardest..men can't do justice among their children, siblings and others you think they are capable to handle more than one wife..even Allah knew it was impossible..hence the clause
@@noohufaheemsadaq9002 but he didn't give those reasons nor did he give the conditions under which one can marry
Mark 10:11-12 And he said to them, “Whoever divorces his wife and marries another commits adultery against her, and if she divorces her husband and marries another, she commits adultery.”
Agreed!
Yes….. divorce… 🤦♂️
😂😂😂 he confidently said that there is no such words in the Bible.
Liars caught on camera 😂😂
What about not divorces his wife but marries another?
@@sjsupa 1 Corinthians 7:10-11 To the married I give this charge (not I, but the Lord): the wife should not separate from her husband (but if she does, she should remain unmarried or else be reconciled to her husband), and the husband should not divorce his wife.
I don’t understand why he compares his Islam n quran with other religions and shows that i n my islam is great than other religions and target to insult other religions what kind of human is he.
And portray himself as an intellect
stupidity on its peak!he doesnot insult other religion, he just put truth in the light. he puts different perspective on the table so you could use your brain to understand n see the difference. he is even stating some facts given by indian government itself
@@inshrahzahid3842 yes U r right doesn’t insult .. he himself is an insult to his own religion. just by brain washing the muslims who are already struggling to gain respect in the society. He is himself vanishing the logic to choose right and imposing the religion of his thoughts. He is living in his own delusion.
“ the so called intellect”
@@inshrahzahid3842dont be blind follower of this stupid man . just by brain washing the muslims who are already struggling to gain respect in the society. He is himself vanishing the logic to choose right and imposing the religion of his thoughts. He is living in his own delusion by targeting the innocent brains
@@inshrahzahid3842 Zakir is a Dumbass who supports vile thing like polygamy.Rather than trying to reform Muslim society he is holding onto centuries old practices which have been discarded by most of the communities.No wonder there are so many ex-muslims.
@@inshrahzahid3842he said lying about other religions to justify his answer means insult other religions,but he can't answer correctly what she asked
She asked “how can a man have multiple wives without the permission of his first wife”. Apparently he didn’t answer her question properly. Your logic makes sense if permission is required there. At the end its all about human rights and freedom.
You didn't understand his answer your brain is weak you should study harder go back to grade school.
When men have extra marital affairs, do they ask their wives and get their permission..when they misbehave and divorce them, they ask for their permission..Marry two women is not easy..you have to support two families equally...but extra marital affairs and divorcing one wife and marrying another is easy..but in islam extra marital relationships are not allowed..and any man who don't do justice between two wives will be punished..
@@truthistruth80 nicely explained. Thanks
@@truthistruth80 your reply was on point but there's one more things for @DahamNavinda that the time all these sculptures were made women were totally dependent on men and when some man would die leaving his wife or children, other people there would start adulting (idk what is that called lol) her and so other men would make them their wives in order to save them from those people cause at that time even the step siblings were also seen with bad eyes specially those who made siblings after a particular age and not since when they were kids.. so that time people who wanted to save the women from those situations they used to marry them.. and the only thing left is 'se*' so that's because every human has the desire and so the men were made to marry more than one wife on the condition that only if they would be just with both or all of their wives and that's why need to fulfill their desires too.... Otherwise they would have been given more than just a punishment ✨✨
Yes he should have a backing from first
It’s difficult to handle one spouse itself
Who will want to marry twice.. like he said only if u can do justice marry more than one, in the present scenario, I do not think people are able to do justice with one itself .. most important is being true in relationship..
Of course now that depends on the man whether he could do justice or not... If he could do justice he is free of sin but if he can't do he disobeyed the Koran... So it is a big sin for him
There's a polyandry in Tibet where women married more than one men, yet nobody bats an eye
Hahaha i am a muslim but i so agree with you..1 wife men cant manage.. i would not be ok with my man even looking at another women let alone marry.. better divorce first wife n then marry the second time
Then he has to play Justice League with all the four wives on bed.
@@stephenhawking2458 *Stamina has left the chat*
Listening to this guy, I can see his brilliance. He avoids answering the question that was asked and instead decides to go on a tangent answering something he wasn't asked.
"The Quran is the only book that says you should only marry one wife" Yet when you compare the Abrahamic religions Muslim men practice polygamy in the highest proportion. Answer that question first and stop beating about the bush.
Listen carefully he gave the perfect answer
@@sanabegum3462 If you think his answer was "perfect" I honestly cant help you.
Just goes to show you haven't heard the complete video
@@farazkhalid3542 If you say so. You cannot wake someone up who is pretending to sleep.
@@Truth65003 polygamy isn't allowed in Islam. Those verses were revealed during war when Muslims died and their women became widow and orphan and were applicable during that time only. Now, there is no war, so no polygamy!! Plus, even if women get widow today, they have financial family support, plus they are in jobs.
Lastly, if you want to say that you are following sunnah, then follow it full. Marry widows and even elder women ( Khadija Radiallhu anha was 2 times widow and 16 years elder to prophet Muhammad sallallaahu alaihi wasallam).
Zakir Naik doesn't have sound knowledge on Islam!!
Tell Zakir nalayak to bring this up with ex Muslims sahil and adam. His answers will be shot down😂
Ar u muslim ?
@@MdMudassir-cu4nd I am proud to be an ex muslim..
Are u from Pakistan. I am also exm..... @@saminarashid1605
@@saminarashid1605
Exodus 21:10: "If he take for himself another wife, her food, her raiment, and her duty of marriage shall he not diminish".
She asked a very simple question about Muslim men allowed to marry more than once with out their first wives permission..Mr Naik could have answered without quoting other religions, or saying demographic requires one to do so...
Firstly Islam gives permission but one has to consider many factors...1. The reason to marry.
2. First wives permission is a compulsion
3. Does he have the means to treat all wives equally..even the difference of a mustard should not be in both the households...
This man is such a dramatic person..he is the one that causes more misconceptions people have towards islam than anybody else
Jab apna hi sikka cchota ho tho kisi aur se kya shikayat.
You’re true....
and the one which he quoted about Krishnas wives are in Thousands
That is a completely wrong statement
Krishna has only two wives who are Rukmini and sathyabhama ... and Radha is only her loved one.
Exactly
The word is allowed. It's a choice given situation and not a mandatory.
I completely agree with u
First wife's permission is not required..we should only follow islam ..do not try to change it according to your wishes...4 marriages are allowed but only with justice which is not easy for everyone..
He gave 2 options ! what about third option to remain single . My aunt is single independent woman by choice and she lives a respectful life .
All I'm saying it was too harsh to connect 2 marriage with public property.
I agree. And remember even today muslims do less polygeny than others communities.
I respect your aunt. Third option must be provided.
Being a single and still do adultery does not count as 'single' i think
@@maisjoe9305 What the Hell?? how could you even talk about a person without knowing them???
Judging is a Authority of ALLAH.
She can remain single if She is confident that she won't ,commit adultery.No problem according to Islam.
Also What should One do if his first wife is Barren and they have tired everything??See One of the ways, He can compensate her to be a parent is my marrying a second and sharing the upbringings of those children with her.
Also there are situations where the female initiates the second marriage e.g if she has Cancer then her husband can opt to marry a second wife while she is alive and stabilise his family.
Your Aunt is a human being and also has feelings that needs to be natured and satisfied why should she neglect those feelings because society deems pologamy taboo
This is what I have read about Hindu dharma:-
In ancient times, all men and women in society were allowed to have only one life partner throughout their life except royal families and kings. Kings were allowed to have multiple wives as it benefitted their kingdom in many ways like maintaining political relationships with other kingdoms,avoiding wars, keeping peace etc.
Whenever any man had multiple wives, many times his wealth, property, family time was never divided properly within all wives and their children. Some of his kids start feeling they don't get justice in family once they grew and it would create hostile situation among step brothers- sisters. Men with multiple wives suffered horrible old age days compared to men with single wives as later on none of their families was completely happy. Therefore polygamy should be avoided to get peaceful society.
Same is with Christianity and Jews, according to our myth Adam and Eve god made one Eve for Adam
Polygamy is not necessary..n the only condition for polygamy is you should be able to do justice among your wives ...if not marry only one
This happend in every society lol back then shit was wild it would be illogical to call this just a Hindu thing even in Arabia the kindgdoms practiced this and in Europe it’s just now we are critiquing Islam of this flaw beacuase it’s very outdated
Polygamy is illegal in some US states look at all of the gun crime.
You call that peace?
Dear Muslim brothers men are allowed to marry 4 wives why then a women can marry 4 husband's
Where is the equality in Islam?
Regarding Solomon and Abraham in the Bible is an old Testament, but with the coming of Jesus and the New Testament of the Bible is to marry only one women by a man
No you are wrong. Read the Bible with your eyes open.
@@gulshanaalani3261In which chapter of new Testament is it written to marry more than 1 wife?
Coz Bible has changed by time to time
Which scripture in the bible want Cristian man to marry only one wife ?.
@@gulshanaalani3261 please read..Mark 10:6-9 ESV
But from the beginning of creation, ‘God made them male and female.’ ‘Therefore a man shall leave his father and mother and hold fast to his wife, and the two shall become one flesh.’ So they are no longer two but one flesh. What therefore God has joined together, let not man separate.”
The two will become ONE- God created marriage for man and woman- not one man with 4 women...This is the teaching of God taught by Jesus.
I remember our neighbors over 2 decades ago, was a Muslim family. The man had 2 wives. At first when the family moved next door to us, the man only had 1 wife. about a year later, this man married his 2nd wife and the 2nd wife moved into the same house, which I thought was odd as I believed the man should have gotten his 2nd wife her own house and not live with both wives under 1 roof. Since that 2nd wife moved in, there was constant loud verbal arguments coming from this house. The wives definitely did not get along and it got so bad that other neighbors started calling the cops to report domestic violence. Eventually the family moved out about a year later after this man got married to his 2nd wife.
Lord Jesus Christ Said in unequivocal terms that I am GOD, read the following:
Gospel according to John(new testament)
{8:56} Your father Abraham
rejoiced to see my day: and he saw [it,] and was glad. {8:57} Then said the Jews unto him, Thou art not yet fifty
years old, and hast thou seen Abraham? {8:58} Jesus said unto them, Verily, verily, I say unto you, Before Abraham was, I AM GOD's name is I AM.
--------------------------------
Exodus(old testament)
{3:13} And Moses said unto God, Behold, [when] I come unto the children of Israel, and shall say unto them, The God of your fathers hath sent me unto you; and they shall say to me, What is his name? what shall I say unto them? {3:14} And God said unto Moses, I AM THAT I AM: and he said, Thus shalt thou say unto the children of Israel, I AM hath sent me unto you. {3:15} And God said moreover unto Moses, Thus shalt thou say unto the children of Israel, The LORD God of your fathers, the God of Abraham, the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob, hath sent me unto you: this [is] my name for ever, and this [is] my memorial unto
all generations. {3:16}
So GOD's name is I AM. See above : I {3:14} I AM hath sent me unto you
Hence, GOD's name is I AM.
--------------------------------------------
Jesus Christ says Exodus {20:1 to 20:3), Please see below. I am the only GOD there is.
Exodus
{20:1} And God spake all these words, saying, {20:2} I
[am] the LORD thy God, which have brought thee out of
the land of Egypt, out of the house of bondage. {20:3} Thou
shalt have no other gods before me.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
new testament is the continuation of the old testament.
Since the old testament GOD and Jesus Christ are one and the same. All Muslims are Christians.
John 8:58, Jesus Christ Said/implied, He himself is the GOD mentioned in the Old Testament
Exodus {20:1 to 20:3} Jesus Christ Said "He is the only GOD there is"
John 8:58 and Exodus {20:1 to 20:3), are just enough, to affirm in unequivocal terms, that He is the GOD stated in the Old testament and
He is the only GOD there is.
Hence, All Muslims are Christians.
That's why Qur'an said " if u can't do justice, u r not allowed to marry more wives"
Yah... That what im talking about... Muslim says marriage purpose is to have peace... Really??? How can they have peace when there are wives fighting over him?
Justice? Theres actually no justice even the man is rich.
How can he divide his self to this 2 or 3 or 4 wives
There is no justice in that situation
If you are going to have a second wife both wives have to be bisexual and open to it being a three-way thing. Otherwise there has to be a strict and undisturbed schedule for splitting the time equally between them
Even if the sky falls I won’t share my husband 😂 I’m sorry but I’m selfish. 🤣🤣🤣
You don't have too😂😂
but if u r a muslim i m sorry u cant go against the wish of ur husband..that will be sin..in islam its right even if its wrong..prophet himself married his daughter in law..
@@referrefer872 that’s why men are also encouraged to take into consideration his wife’s feelings.
@@referrefer872 proof?
Jaake Kuch padhle pehle.
Yes you love public property or killing female babies 4 out of 10! Right?
How a unmarried woman became a public property?? She is a human being and deserves every right and privilege granted to other married citizens.
A real men doesn't need multiple wives but chooses only one loyal better half partner ❤
Correct brother this Dr.naik lead people's to hell
Agar wife dogali nikal jaye to dusri sadi karne mai fayda hai
To ram krishna ne 1 se zyaade wife q kare
Why prophet David(dawood) had 100+ wives ....thn why Hindu gods had thousands wives??? I don't know you are Hindu or Christian....why don't your mock your belief thn ???
@@banbhalangkharsati5938 Think about logic, don't act like a fool😂
I am single and not a public property I live as a Muslim woman and not considering getting married :) so I am not the public property just because I am single. Best regards Rumeysa from İstanbul :)
That's exactly true... Sis☺️ may allah bless you
Please do reply me
@@ArbazRahman15 thanks brother you too
You don't understand public property was example. Give me agreement that remaining womens don't have sexual desires like you
Mre power to u..u dunt need to b pitied nd u certainly dunt deserve to b labelled as" public property".. thays so unethical ..chosing nt to get married is the mst normal thing..many divorce women r also living a respectful nd honorable life throughout the world.
❤️Success is not built on success. It's built on failure, It's built on fraustration. it's built on fear that you have to overcome. I pray that anyone who reads this will be successful in life All thanks to Mrs Deborah Davis 🇺🇸
As a beginner what do I need to do? How can I invest, on which platform? If you know any please share.
I know this lady you just mentioned. She's really good with and on her job. She's helped a couple of families and individuals’ finances
She is really a good investment advisor.
I was privileged to attend some of her seminars,that's how I started my crypto investment
Started with 5,000$ and Withdrew profits 89,000$
I'm from Egypt I used to take loan from the bank for surviver but after trading with Mrs Deborah Davis expert she changed my financial status for real I'm now a creditor not a debtor anymore
So did Allah create 4 wives for the first men, Adam? It was Adam who decided he wants more😂😂😂
Pretty regressive to say women who cant marry can be equated to public property. The whole argument given is totally flawed. Not everyone, male or female gets married, a lot of times for reasons beyond control. Not getting married should not be equated to being dishonorable, neither for males nor females.
Hold on a minute you can't really ignore human urge to reproduce which is embedded in our genes. It's true not being able to marry doesn't make you public property but he's probably referring to people eloping without getting married. There's higher chance of that happening when you are not married.
this is exactly the point, no one should generalize for either the male or female, that they become public property if unmarried. There is of course the argument of sexual urgea and doing these within the boundaries of marriage only in every religion, but no one can judge that a single person automatically is a 'private property' even if they opt not to get married at all.
@@muneeburrehman8188 so you are talking about your family , don't equate yourself with others
@@muneeburrehman8188 tell ur dad to get some more wives ....we don't condem such BS
@@muneeburrehman8188 . Public property is that how the Muslim community sees these unmarried women? As for eloping maybe in India, Pakistan and some other Muslim country, where a young girl is to marry her 54 year old male relative - what is the choice?
This is called "Self acquired knowledge without holy spirit". Encouraging youngsters to merry numerous of wives in order to defend ones personality is totally wrong.
In old Testament they had two or three wives but in New testament one can have only one wife. You don't have any answers that's the reason your answers are rubbish
You may have permission or wish to marry other women
But you have not got the permission to break the heart 💔 of your first wife
Right
Polygamy is adultery.
If u still can’t understand then we can’t do anything 🤷🏻 their is detailed explanation
If still can't understand than we can't do anything
@@shakeebkhan5092 those explanations have no logical. Only value for Islam
If a man can niyog with 11 womens illegally. Than why a man can't marry 4 womens legally?
I have one wife and she drives me crazy. I pray for any man who has more than 1 problem
😂
me too
That's why it's only rich men who get more than one wives
Who knows that whose fault is in your relationship ,your or your wife's ?? If you were a good person u wouldnot say these things about your wife in public 🙂
@@suryanoor lol
I understand it was a time where women were dependent on men so that's why it was ok to marry multiple women but time has changed, so its really orthodox to carry it on that too without permission of 1st wife.
As I have just commented, only poor women agree to polygamy, I have never heard or seen a medical doctor, a rich business lady, a professor, a lawyer etc agreeing to be a 2nd, 3rd or 5th wife, men are lusty
Millions of side chicks having babies the courts have to force men to pay child support on prove polygamy is needed as the least of two evils. It works with nature and lives in reality. Instead of having us all live in rose-colored glasses. Hundreds of countries with job shortages, unliveable pay rates and no welfare do as well. Islam is based on reality. Not what we like.
This is the logical answer. Good one👍
Things which are not good for society we should avoid it.
@@fatimahkwape8621
Dang what kind of argument ad remark are you putting simply generalize men.
I had a friend whose mother is a Surgeon, which shared her husband with 2 other wives of his. One is a teacher the other is a businesswoman. They are happy, my friend got a good grade in class, got along with his siblings with another mother, even came to his sick step sister when she got sick, invited us all for a big family gathering for dinner.
What is so lustful about that. You are just being prejudiced towards men.
@@UltimateMegaMaster they are happy ? how do u know did you interrogate ?
Maintaining multiple wives is different than getting married more than once and getting divorced. And she stood there simply without raising this point.
Please watch full video. Or did you just not understand what he said? 😑
Tell these points to your Religious leaders. It seems that your Religious books are false
@@asifnaeem8783 I think your religious book is false.
@@asifnaeem8783 why you guys still live in stone age 😂😂
Zakir naik cannot help insulting other community and other religions and thereby inviting the same to his prophet. Simple logic would be then if Mohammad f*cked 9 year old girl, should Christians too do the same? Quran being so called eternal book, could it not anticipate the 21st century and give advice wisely? Why does Zakir Naik have to utter the names of Hindu deities from his dirty mouth? I am glad that Indian government chased away this scoundrel and now all his followers should be chased too.
He is like usko chocolate mila to hume kyu nahi?? He is like the oldest son in the family.
He repeatedly says marry multiple times only if you can do justice to them. But the wife who is the person who is in the recieving end of this justice has no say in the matter. So he can do anything and there is no accountability 😂
😂😂
So you left the vid at half? 💀💀
Then the wife dong need to marry him simple you fool, Islam never forces a women to marry a man with multiple wives 😂😂
@@fax_spitter you fool,I'm talking about the first wife. Even if she married a person with no previous wives, the husband can marry another wife without her permission. Then she would have wasted her good years. Who will compensate her? Suppose the husband loves the new wife more and spends more time with her. The first wife with her kids and no job, in what strength will she divorce her husband even if she's not recieving justice? Where's the accountability.
I believe the justice is meaning: if there are more women than men it is an injustice to leave some women without husbands
Zakir Naik give me thousand of reasons to be a hindu🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏 thanks u thanks a lot 😂😂😂😂
🤣😂🤣😂
Hahaha hopefully u won’t tell a Muslim that why they have more wife than one
how is he giving u a reason to worship cows 🐄
@@danielsabbah6766 yeah howww
@@danielsabbah6766 Don't pressurise your brain. That's a thing for enlightened people to understand.
If quran is word of god and all other religious scriptures are mythology, why zakir makes comparison between them? There is no point in comparing word of god and word of a human.
because it's more convincing that way for the believers of the respective scripture
Brother, islam says their are more than 1 lakh 24 thousand prophets, which were sended towards earth. We don't know all and their books. One of them may be krishna Or ur religious messenger. Quraan clear ly says respect them and their books but in many casses their religious book was editid by human..
@@UntoldArticles-tn1nvu nailed it ❤
u are right brother
Brother Siddharth wrote if Quran only word of God why Zaki makes comparison ?
If Zaki say any matter is Correct because it is written in Our Quran, will you accept ?
By comparison we can think which one is correct which one is not, we never said Quran is only word of God, Allah send many messengers and books but time to time people changed it, the verses matches with Quran we have not any objection to take it, you people have guts to accept verses of Quran that matches with your scriptures ? If yes first to believe there is Only one God
Regarding "public property" we refer to this more professionally as "single".. men become available, by age, death, divorce and marriage can still be a part of the future regardless of a population count on any specific day.. a time being single is a time for personal development, community service, adventure, growth and so on.. being single shouldn't be frowned upon or considered sinful..
people act like being single isnt allowed in islam or something😭
@nightingale3688 it is kind of true everywhere. I'm sure the stigma implies that single people are menacing. They are often available to people who aren't happy in a relationship and or are the temptation possibly.
I really like how much effort he puts in just to defend himself but we all know according to the current world that polygamy is still unfair to the women ... + He is comparing Krishna with himself and other mere humans when he don't even know the story behind Shri Krishna having 16008 wives , only 8 of them had any major role as wives in real life ... + Acc. to him Quran says have only one wife and still u have so many .. Hindu scriptures says have 4 wives and still Hindus have 1 wife ( u r not supposed to count divorced wives here ) .... U r talking about exceptions here , Exceptions are everywhere + he is comparing current times with whole another Yugas + remaining unmarried is also a choice for women .
These are the things which I think can easily disprove his answer .
Brother i have read Gita and completely understood it . That is the reason, we also told Muhammad( PBUH) married 9 wives not for pleasures etc. only and only to support them. But you guys still mock us even if we give so many proof.
then a brahmin can marry 4 wives ah ?
Let anyone marry as many as they want, it's their choice! What's anyone's business?! Why speak about any religion or faith?! It's very sensitive issue. Let's respect all!
@@thereisonlyonegod3807 bro but your prophet Mary a very young girl?
@@vishwasmalhotra3714 That is debatable since it not mentioned in Quran. But it is mentioned in Bhagvad Gita that Krishna married 8 year old Rukmini. I can give you page no. if you want to check. Salam
It’s hard for some men to manage even one wife let alone think about 4.
it's some men but not all. the quran explain, in sura al-nisa chapter 4 verses 3 only those men who are Justice and can manage would marry moreover than 2 wives
sorry, not moreover it is more than
الحمد لله. في كل واحد من المحظورات له هناك حكمة وفي كل واحد يسمح به هناك حكمة
Muslims having 3/4 wives just for gain their population
Bill Gates cant do sis ? 🤣🤣
As one wise women once said "im not Muslim but I have the answer! have u ever found 4 men worth marrying?"
Best reason I have ever heard. Well said 👏
Good one 🤣🤣
The best one 😂
Have u ever found 4 dish washers go do the job well?
The other side is, if one woman is worthy enough to marry why go for three more? Women, don't be deceived.
Day by day, my disgust towards this religion is growing ,all thanks to such people.who cant stop comapring .
Golden Point - When money is involved, there is usually no love between the male or female
Damn
Why is love a criterion for marriage? Keep your Western propaganda at bay.
So what? You don't have to be romantically in love in Islam.You just need to love each other for the sake of Allah.
@@ShaimaaBenaid western propaganda that love is a criteria for marriage.
@@Chainless_Slave7 love? You don't need to be in love to marry.You just need understand and cooperate.
He should speak about the present situation. The lady asked the question but couldn't defend it.
He did speak about the current situation, yes females are still being killed in India till date
Sri Ram father was a king. He wasn't depending on the government to support his children.
It prov clearly which scriptures influences the Korean
Very cunning muslims. they always divert and dont talk about the relevant or present situation
Chaos ye this journalist 😅
Oh yes we can! Why is there still alimony for the ex wife?! Financial support is rhe biggest motive to have multiple wifes. Thats why it is only permissible when you can maintain up to 4 women! And when you commit fornication dont defend polygamy! When you f. 20x times without marriages your re a sinner and cheap profiteer the polygamy concept.
"Thou shalt not have more than one spouse". - Word of God!
Reference pliz?
Source: trust me bro
Add that as well
1 Corinthians 7:2, 1 Timothy 3:2
@@cherylwalker4242 Corinthians doesn’t mention any number of wives.
And Timothy is talking about the overseer/bishop/minister.
And even though Timothy does mention one wife, non of the translation of versions use the word ‘only’ in reference to one wife. That would be speculation based on deduction but nevertheless speculation.
Assam Odisha Maharashtra Chhattisgarh Gujarat yaha bhi hota hai.... Please video banaaiye....
me as a hindu , bro almost convinced me to marry more than 1 wife cuz she need "MY PROTECTION" and i think why should i protect only 4 women...
Well answering a question and comparing other religions are different things , people in many religion doesn't marry more than once not cuz it's written in their books but because there books teach them this without specifically mentioning that marry once .
@Imran pathan umm actually there are no text which said marry only one.
but we try to marry one because we got motivation from our gods, and we do not marry women for only children's like another religion we love them so we marry.
In almost case our hindu also got 2,3 wife's as zakir said, many cases you will get because of some uneducated man.
We want to be a holy person, don't you think this type then i will say you are using women's as children's machine.
@Imran pathan what do you understand, I didn't said for everyone I said them who thinks they can have 2 or more wifes, Who don't want to be holy as Lord rama.
That's the difference between your and our thoughts.
i didn't named the religion because I don't want to blame them but you named them, if I will name the religion specially I will say to Islam because their thought isn't worth to a perfect person.
And stop producing 5,6,7,8 etc.. Number of children's.
@Imran pathan reply to my previous answer man, if you don't have answer for my reply then you are not worth to say about hinduism.
And i will not say your Islam is fake because I respect other religion's but not to your thoughts.
And another matter you said hinduism is based on fake things, which thing is fake tell me i will accept if that's proven wrong you have to accept our hinduism isn't fake.
I gave you a open challenge💪💪
But people can still cheating nowadays lol
@@lauraasybee8300 which cheating you are talking about?
Our beloved prophet had 11 wives he never mentioned that all he was doing is criticizing other religions
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Prophet had hunger of sex. That's why he didn't even leave 6yrs old girl 🤣
@Dave Wadude Nothing wrong for the desert n*ggas though. True.
@@thewonderer9551 Dave literally said "nothing wrong with it" Imagine
@@falakfatima Yep. Now I can imagine
This is the same explanation I'd write in my answer paper to the question I have absolutely no idea about!
polygamy isn't allowed in Islam. Those verses were revealed during war when Muslims died and their women became widow and orphan and were applicable during that time only. Now, there is no war, so no polygamy!! Plus, even if women get widow today, they have financial family support, plus they are in jobs.
Lastly, if you want to say that you are following sunnah, then follow it full. Marry widows and even elder women ( Khadija Radiallhu anha was 2 times widow and 16 years elder to prophet Muhammad sallallaahu alaihi wasallam).
Zakir Naik doesn't have sound knowledge on Islam!!
@@Asif49858 same is in hindu polygamy is not allowed until there is a good reason behind it like for lord krishna he saved 16000 women from a demon and those women said the world would not accept us because we were imprisoned by the demon so lord krishna married all the woman so they can live as a queen in swarg lok.
@@kartikyadav4068 exactly. Sunnah is to marry someone who is vulnerable. Now, if you marry a widow, Or orphan or someone who has no means of Living and taking care of herself you can marry her with the intention of giving her support as there is hadith which says, "actions are judged by intention". If such a situation arises where a woman needs support and your intention is pure its fine. Whereas if there is a needy and you are helping her but in your heart you have lustful intentions you are digging your grave with your own hands and going towards hellfire!
@@kartikyadav4068 yes, I have heard the story why Kanha married 16000 women . It was to save their dignity. Same goes for Islam!!
@@Asif49858 I have a question, you can marry upto 4 wives not by Love but due to arise of some situations, rescue them or provide and protect them cases, No I'm confused, "marry upto 4 if u can do justice for all" wt exactly justice meant there?
Vishnu Puran chapter 24, verse 1 -
The King said:
1. Venerable Sir! I now desire, to hear from you the story of the first incarnation of Lord Hari of miraculous exploits, wherein he assumed the form of a fish, through his deluding potency (Māyā).
Hinduism is about spirituality not like this nonsense.
Lord Krishna has only 8 wives originally. The remaining 16,100 women are from the pleasure house of Kamsa (who was killed by Krishna). After he was killed these women came to Sri Krishna and told him they want to die as no one is going to marry them nor are they getting any respect from the society. So Krishna decided to marry them so that they will get Royal status and respect as queen.
DON'T SPREAD HALF TRUTHS.
He lives by hypothetical situations! Always gives example of hypothetical situations😂😂😂
You are lack of comprehension your brain is so weak you should study harder.
The only decent comment was on the issue of female infanticide - a curse promoted by women and men in India especially Indian mothers!!
Well put
Yup he didn't answer her question just beating the bushes and using some logical fallacy and trying to compare others to glorify his religion
No straight answer
The number of females living in this world at any given time is always greater than the number of males, seems something hypothetical to you ??
Live in the present generation. Follow moral standards, love urself love ur family and neighbors, love ur country. Don't sow enemity in people's mind .now a days people are craving for peace of mind. Preach them how to live happily and peacefully first 🙏.
We are Muslims🔥we will not stop following Islam or change Islam even if you force us to do it 💪
@@Sprinklinkins ur the worst people on 🌎
@@Sprinklinkins cowards
@@ritisharajpal7464 I don't want to live how people lived 1443 years ago but want to live as the sahaba lived. When Islam came saudi was not the same as it was before. it totally changed and got better. Religion is not people. Religion cannot be changed but people can. But Muslims are the only people who have not changed even single word from quran nor did they stopped following it.. And if you're saying that religion should not be followed just because it's old then stop following hinduism it's anyways the most dumbest religion in the world🤣 oh I forgot hindus are hindus only because they are born in hindu family they never follow hinduism🤣😂😅😆😁
@@Sprinklinkins
Changed now tripal talak is banned .
The Quran says "If you but knew, one is better, because Allah gave you one heart."
that is so sweet
heart has 4 chamber 🤣
@@ayeshazeb4562lol
@@ayeshazeb4562😂😂
@@ayeshazeb4562 that's why Brahmins should be allowed to have four wives.
Ma Sha Allah! Amazed to see Dr Zakir Nayak's knowledge...❤️
First of all the true fact is that even as per thousand years old Bhagavad Gita, You have to have only legitimate relationship with your legal wife. Even if you want to take to Sanyasam alone , you can't unilaterally take to Sanyasam unless your legal wife agrees for it. The rules in the Bhagavad Gita are very strict as per scriptural texts.
Read slokas 16-23 & 16-24 of the Bhagavad Gita for further guidance in this regard.
Same is for muslims too , unless and until the current wife agrees that her husband should marry another woman he cannot
@@yusufkhalil9718 polygamy isn't allowed in Islam. Those verses were revealed during war when Muslims died and their women became widow and orphan and were applicable during that time only. Now, there is no war, so no polygamy!! Plus, even if women get widow today, they have financial family support, plus they are in jobs.
Lastly, if you want to say that you are following sunnah, then follow it full. Marry widows and even elder women ( Khadija Radiallhu anha was 2 times widow and 16 years elder to prophet Muhammad sallallaahu alaihi wasallam).
Zakir Naik doesn't have sound knowledge on Islam!!
@@yusufkhalil9718 what is halala 🤣
@@Zalimpathan-z1m halala means after divorce women become sister of ex husband. If she marry another man then she got divorced at any age of life then her ex husband will not seen as brother
At the same time we have Hindus divorcing their cheating wife and taking American woman as wives. If it is the American women's first marriage tell me now who her true husband is ? In America many women are 'Public Property' just as Muslim or any other men (8 partners?!?? Tell me who his wife is if he is 'Public Property'???) Being public property is NOT culturally equal to a previous marriage. Even Americans value Marriage too, so much that we STOPPED getting married to other Americans because the divorce statistics
It is in the New Testament that says a christian man must marry only one woman.
İn which verse?
@@imraanedwin3252Matthew 19: 3-6 :
3 The Pharisees also came unto him, tempting him, and saying unto him, Is it lawful for a man to put away his wife for every cause?
4 And he answered and said unto them, Have ye not read, that he which made them at the beginning made them male and female,
5 And said, For this cause shall a man leave father and mother, and shall cleave to his wife: and they twain shall be one flesh?
6 Wherefore they are no more twain, but one flesh. What therefore God hath joined together, let not man put asunder. Words of the LORD Jesus Christ
There are many verses in new testament
How many testaments are there!!
Brother, The Qur'an have only one Version, and it's says it. That's it😊
We are talking about the present time not thousands of years ago, I ask do we go to war using swords and horses etc...
your point??
@@shovonalam8372 she's asking why have 4 wives? Zakir talk about Emperors having thousands concubines, King Solomon having hundreds of wives etc... Sidestepping the main question....
@@alantan9585 when did he talk about concubines, those were examples of the past. do you understand context or just have bad faith?? he did not sidestep anything but He has explained the whole thing in past context and then also in present context...did you even watch the whole thing?? stop doing this shitty bad faith comments. You are responsible for negativity in this world, you add to islamophobia speaking shit like that...STOP!!
@@alantan9585 end of the day, the Muslim family model, marriage model is the best way subhanallah! we have the lowest rate of divorce, single parent problem. Look at the west and their high divorce rate, high number broken family which affects children immensely. most Muslim men don't marry more than 1, only a few who has the means to do justice do that and that even only in very few parts of the world. The whole question was a bad faith thing, trying to show some flaw in Islam. His examples just shattered that bad faith argument.
@@alantan9585 you didn't carefully. He is not side steped. Well, I am asking you how many of your Muslim friends have four wives? Or point out how many? He gave today's example like Darnendara etc. If you are a Tamilian, Gemini Ganesan , ex CM Karunanidi you knows how many wives they got. Even though awere of law. So many have KEEP for sexual purpose. Some known by first wife some don't. No matter how rich you are its carry on by all class of people. KAMALA HASAN is today's example. And so many like him.
Its a real big joke. Profit Muhammad says he can have more than 14 wives and 20 slaves and you Muslims can have only 4 wives. 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
She tried her level best to escape
@Ankit Mehrotra Who are you? 🤣
@Ankit Mehrotra 😂 chill son. You can’t disprove DR. Zakir’s argument. He is quoting form your scriptures. If you wanna verify his claim check on vedic websites.
😂👍
Third class religion, third class people.... 😄
@Ankit Mehrotra Alpa Vidya Bayankar 😂 That is Zakir Nalayak Converted Naik 😂😂
It is lust that a man marries more than one wife. Why so many wives.
@@dhandapanipalanisamy8165 oh so Krishna was a lusty person and so that Ram's dad dashrat also..
@@sksuleman4735 krishna married 16000 girls to save them, he didn't sleep with them, he adopt them after freeing them cause the society denied to accept them..please know the full truth before saying anything..
@@sksuleman4735you won’t understand 😂Krishna before reading his life history…make a comment on any person who is the best of and bests …first read the scripture ..then you would get to know why Krishna married 16,108 wives and how many of them carried krishna’s kids in their wombs ?
@Kolipurush-eq7ez he married 16100 after the war but before that he already had 8 wives.
To the amazing person who is reading this, I wish you all the best in life. Don't be too hard on yourself; accept your mistakes and move on. Allow no one else to define "success" for you. Get up, develop the necessary skills, and get to work; the keys to a happy life are in your hands. Continue to push forward.👍
What if we get sick and if disaster comes is it in our hands 🤔🤔
Chomu they were God's who we never saw and following. Ate u God ? You even can't pronounce properly.... learn speaking English course in Delhi first. Chomu.
@@jakuchmk1555 so what do you want to do... remember..there are some powers which are not in our control.
@@SUDMAA That's why Our fate is also in God's hand Do you know why we have we have different Calibre and different talent even if eat the same food??
Brother, you are wrong. In Hinduism also it has been said that a man should marry only one wife.See the seventh word to be taken at the time of marriage which Hindu scriptures have given The girl tells the groom that you will consider foreign women like mothers and will not allow anyone else to come in between the love of husband and wife. If you promise to do so, I agree to come to your Vamang.See this is not the case for kings because they may have to marry princesses of other countries to have relations with other countries. But Shri Krishna ji had done such 16,100 marriages because when sri krishna freed 16,100 girls from a demon named bhaumasur. all girls did not go back to her home and started saying that no one will accept us. We have come back from this demon, so you accept us as your wife. Then Shri Krishna ji accepted him but he had done eight marriages. Shri Krishna ji did the rest of the 8 marrges. This was done for this reason to show that this may also have to be done to keep the empire established.and Dasrath jiwas also a king . And the things that you said that Brahmins can marry four, then all those things are written in the Baudhayana Dharmasutra which is written by humans and not any Purana. It is not written in Vishnu Purana . You said wrong.t was okay to have four marriages then. ISLAM IS GREAT According to Islam, because it would have been done after the war to give them shelter. But now it is not right to do this and a woman can easily spend her life alone.🙂🙂🙏🙏
(4:3) If you fear that you might not treat the orphans justly, then marry the women that seem good to you: two, or three, or four. If you fear that you will not be able to treat them justly, then marry (only) one,5 or marry from among those whom your right hands possess.
I am a Muslim woman … ❤ but I will never ever let any women touch my man other than his mother , daughters and sisters only . ❤ Allahu Akhbar . May Allah bless all spouses be one and only among both and love eternally aameen ❤❤❤❤
Then your not a Muslim 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Going against the principle of Islam, you are opening the door of hell for yourself. In Islam men can marry 4 wives as commanded by our porphet saw and they don't need tour permission. And don't you dare deny the words of our prophet if you are truly a muslim. I believe men naturally have more responsibilities, so if they feel the need they deserve to have more wives just like our prophet saw had 11 wives and some concupines.
Alhamdulillah!!
This is what the God say in the Bible .
1 Timothy Chapter 3 verse 2
A bishop then must be blameless, the husband of one wife.
1 Timothy Chapter 3 verse 12
Let the deacons be the husbands of one wife, ruling their children and their own houses well.
Titus Chapter 1 verse 6
if any be blameless, the husband of one wife, having faithful children unruly.
then marry me 🤭
i love your idea, keep your man to yourself, dont let religion mislead your marriage
Now the sex ratio in the world is 1:1 (101.68 males per 100 females). We may have to re-think his logic ??
Yah this fellow is still living in the stone age to justify his poor behavior
There's a polyandry in Tibet where women married more than one men, yet nobody bats an eye
So your taking the whole world? Look at Russia's index
It has always been more males than females...only during the great wars did the male population decline substantially...he is just giving false data to favour his argument
@@sharpiefatah3657 russia is in pluto? We are talking about the whole world
End of the day, it is your beliefs vs their beliefs. No need to compare. Do what you think is ok for you. Society and ppl will always judge. This applies for members of all religions.
Well said bro..💜
Well we practiced sati in Hinduism guess we should have let that huh? If something is immoral we question it. Even if it's God. I bet the real God dont make me question bcoz he is Good all the time
No we can't accept others belief if they are immoral. Like he said Sati Act. That would be ignorance. People won't change until someone else try to question them.
@@justanintrovertwithcooldp7 That was a belief shared by certain societies. Not every widow was burned alive, after her husband passed on. Lord Ramar's mother was the queen dowager until her son's accession to the throne, upon which she was widely honoured as the queen mother, despite her husband passed away years ago.
Yet some societies refused to look at this
Exactly bro u have family u have ur relegion follow it y bother about others idk y people stress out so much y cant we leave peacefully relegions are meant to be peaceful but today people for their personal benefits made relegion a evil
Krishna releases 16000 women from narakasura prison. He didn’t marry them of lust. This misinformation that krishna having many wives was used as a tactic by desert religions from centuries.. yet they couldn’t dismantle sanatana dharma
He still didnot justify her question… just quoted other religions to put his point …
Permission me aur use applicable krne me diffrence hai. Aese permission to Hinduism me bhi. Pr use apply to bhut km krte hai. Aur 4 wife's maje ke liye nhi krni hai agr koi gareeb hai. Vidhwa hai ya koi aur prblm hai tbhi insan krta hai.
So you didn't watch the video?
9:02 The number of women in the world is more than the number of men. This is why Allah permitted polygamy for men who are capable, to solve this problem, to protect the women from becoming public property.
@@MaskedGuyCh you People have favoured weirdest laws and rules in your religion,as like these are created by foolish men,non of God would preach this kind of knowledge
A wife shouldn’t be happy if husband has girlfriends outside instead she should get him a wife to protect from sins
बहुत ही घटिया जवाब..
Bible tells about the remarriage and also the conditions
Matthew 19:9 (ESV) And I say to you: whoever divorces his wife, except for sexual immorality, and marries another, commits adultery.
Divorce is the only way to end marriage underthese conditions and even if a person wants to remarry these are the conditions,
God clearly permits remarriage after the death of a spouse and actually encourages remarriage for younger widows (Romans 7:1-3, 1 Corinthians 7:8-9,27-28,39-40; 5:11-16). God never allowed CHRISTIANS for polygamy.
Don't reason with these things. These people won't understand.
@@human7491 show me only one error
@@human7491 If you believe God doesn't make mistake and that same GOd ask you Muslim to believe the book before Quran and we all believe God to have knowledge of every thing including what will happen in the future so by this does it mean God didn't know that christians will change d words in the bible later in the future ??? So stop saying bible is not the word of God or it has been alter because that statement alone means you don't believe in Quran
@@human7491 Ok tell me what contradiction have you found?
@@human7491 I believe that Muhammed who rose after 6 centuries., with kinky mind., god have chosen only jacob., vexation from a branches Ishmael is a Muhammed who said himself as a prophet ., he wrote a book in which he said that bible is gods word but it is misleaded so god again wrote a new book through me so everyone believe me., and he also mentioned cleverly that he is the last prophet., so brainless one can change his kinky words.. cleverly he wrote a story book for his convenience and himself proclaimed it as holiest ever books., no offence it's my belief.
He is the one who knows everything about everyone's religion but understands only his.
Correct..😢😂
Well I very much appreciate the first answer that the gentleman gave that it's nowhere mentioned in the Qur'an Sharif to marry multiple times. But, his second answer is very much wrong. Is marrying a woman the only way to protect her?? That way the man plays with the feelings of his wife nd breaks her heart just to protect the other woman while not protecting his own wife's feelings. I completely disagree with his second answer. If it's mentioned in the Qur'an Sharif to marry only once, then it means marrying twice while your first wife is alive or you're not divorced is a sin as much as adultery. And talking about men protecting women, they should start considering every woman as a daughter, a mother, a sister nd their wife as a life companion and not a body to be used.
Clearly the Dr didn’t have time to got through 1 Corinthians chapter 7. US Christians do not support polygamy and the Bible clearly says this. Don’t group us in your dilemma, answer the question.
Ur bible was changed thousands of times 😂
@@mongo5599 and Quran?
@@RDBclub40 It's promise of Creator that Quran is the last book and no one will change it till day of judgement..million of muslims memorise it by heart..so it's impossible to change..
@@RDBclub40 just copied from other books
@@truthistruth80 Not at all Quran is just a copy of other books
Being single is equivalent to public property 🙁 can't wrap my head around it..😅
That’s such a disgusting statement he made
Public property means, she can have sex with anyone irresponsibly. We morally degraded too far that adultery is dating. But i get your point, that's a poor choice of word that he use
@@chakravartin3356 not everyone has same mindset when it comes to morality if a women doesn’t have problem with what she does with her body than Zakir & people like u should mind ur own business
@@nehasheikh5492 then medieval sex slavery is not about women's body being sold, if every women back then using today's women mindset. So, what's all the fuss about those slavery? Is it because the money didn't goes straight to their pocket but instead to their slaver first? Who knows
@@chakravartin3356 wow 🤣what a comparison, people like u need to open dictionary and read the meaning of CONSENT, slave women doesn’t consent to sex it’s forced sex while when a women chooses to have sex without someone forcing her that’s called consensual sex and people like u & Zakir need to buzz away from women who don’t mind having consensual sex ... keep your morality compass inside your pocket
1500 years was a different suitation because several persons died in war. Now 99%muslim have one wife.
Its not obligatory to have 4 wife in Islam. It is optional to have more than one wife. Even marrying is not obligatory for everyone. And even marriage is unlawful for some people.
👍👍 I hope you understand Arabic, unfortunately there is no translation in this vdo.
ua-cam.com/video/TUU7997VTyY/v-deo.html
@@devduttirtha402optional to have more than one wife? It's weird. Why isn't it optional to have more than one husband?
@@anupamatirkey2648 Optional means you can but it has some conditions. You must have the physical and mental and economical ability to care for more than one wife. If you can't make equity then it is forbidden in Islam to marry more than one wife. And there is no religious in the world says this. Other religious scriptures don't clear the number of wives.
And why women don't have the right to marry more than one wife? Its very biological and psychological brother. Women have menstrual circle in a month. Mostly it stays 4-5 days(bleeding) and before the circle and after the circle they have many mood swings also. That means women should be left for 10 days in the month. But when one woman has more than 1 husbands she has to please them physically but how can she please them biologically...Its very tough for women.
Then comes another thing, if a women has more than one husband, when a child will take birth, how can we know who is the father? In ancient time it was not possible. Now we have DNA test but it is very uncultural to do dna test for knowing the father. You can see in the animal kingdom also. One lion lead a group of women. It is very common in nature.
And there are many countries, in which women ratio is larger than the male. Men have to take responsibilities of them. In accident, in disease, in war male die more than women. Women babies are physically more stronger than male child.
Hope you got the answer.
@@devduttirtha402 nice arguments.
Because the leader married 11 and had infinite slaves and women who donated their bodies. Now God had a sense of justice so he allowed followers 4.
I blame her for asking a question where she has done no research and hence left dumbfounded with no points for a productive debate. She helped establish "women are helpless without men, and if not under a man, will be a public property". I hope jounalists are able to defend their point. Dont ask questions unless you educate yourselves to defend your questions. She has helped glorify polygamy. You let us down Sister.
Why blame her ? She's not even a journalists , just a regular person who wants to ask a question .
It's him who Never answered her one question , twisted stuffs ,spoke about the all religions , world demography ,circled around the whole world to defend polygamy in Islam .
@@MDgp5dl "my name is Lakshmi, i am a journalist" is literally the first line of the video.
@@niveditakamath5366 oops , i must have missed that one out
@@MDgp5dl but yeah... He is a toxic bigot who's poisoning our country and the world with nothing but illogical unreasonable unsubstantiated statements. I pity the part of humanity who falls for it.
Mam ...it is not men vs women. It is patriarchal male muslims vs whole world. No religion is following polygamy now except Islam. It is against basic human rights which can be challenged anywhere across the globe but people like Zakir Naik are using their half cooked knowledge in converting people into Islam .It is his prime agenda to convert people of other religions into Muslims just by demeaning the religion and brainwashing them.whenever he talks he compares the religions to make people feel proud for Islam and feel pity or shame for their religion.
He always shows one side of the coin. He never talks about triple talaq, Halala, Burqa and Hizab ban, Population control, Uniform civil code etc because he is a religious fundamentalist getting funded from gulf countries for converting people into Muslims. He is absconding from India because of fear of arrest .He is staying in Malaysia and doing the same business of converting innocent Malaysians. NIA and ED are looking for issuing red corner notice via Interpol to Zakir Naik foundation. He is involved in converting people and illicit funding from gulf or north Africa.
I think this Sir got confused with the question....he answered " What are your thoughts on polygyny according to various holy books of different religion".....
But the actual question was, "Whether polygyny and polyandry are given equal rights or not. And if not, then what's your take".
😂😂
He doesn't know polygamy is the umbrella term for polygyny and polyandry.
1 Corinthians 7:2
Truem.
Yes....
The Quran says that if there are more female than male, you are allowed to marry more than one. What if it's the ratio is the other way round?
who told u that?
That's what even I also wanted to ask Zakir Naik.
@@SUDMAA watch the video carefully. He said that girl child's are stronger than boy child when they born. That's why many male child die in the time of birth. Also many man die from accidents,wars,diseases etc. That's why there are more women in the world than mans. it can't be changed
@@aleeyumuhammad6450 Ya Muhammad!!
It is though. There are 42 million more males than females
So he means that Staying unmarried is becoming public property??? 😅
Sometimes psychopaths get attention from the people. And Zakir #$cking Naik is the best example ever.
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣.
Really I mean, he talked about so many religions. But didn't talk about that currently, Nobody's practicing polygamy expect the people he's defending. Man, world works on present.
@@ghostiexd4982 100% true
@@ghostiexd4982 Marry two women is not easy..you have to support two families equally...but extra marital affairs and divorcing one wife and marrying another is easy..but in islam extra marital relationships are not allowed..and any man who don't do justice between two wives will be punished..
Dumb people see brilliant people as psychopaths..it's ok..
Please forget scriptures, which were written long back.Come to present age, live practical life, love all, dont hurt anybody.To live peacefully on this planet , logic is not necessary, we need tolerance and understanding.
So your not following the old version of ur bible? Ur following the new verse of the bible that human being's writen?
Sometimes we thought that we are more wise than the creator,,,atheism is rising
200%right
Hahahaha 😂😂😂
@@stalkerstvvlog1500 sometimes u need logic to understand comments....
For one word answer he has written 100 sentences 😆
So what, he still have a good arguments based on evidences and statistics
The essence is to make u understand coz it's more important than just knowing
@@khaledaskalany510it shows that he’s deflecting
question
1.
जहां पुरुष ज्यादा शादी करे तो महिला भी करेगी
क्या अपने husband को पूछने जाएगी। छुप छुप के करेगी या नहीं?
2.
दूसरी तीसरी वाइफ को ही इन्साफ तो दे देगा पुरुष पर
सभी बच्चों को education देके इंसान बनाए या बिना पढ़े जानवर बनाए । शादी सिर्फ मनौरंजन नहीं जिम्यादारी भी हे या नहीं ?
3.
सभी धर्म ने पहले बहु पत्नी वाले रिवाज को हटाया और एक पत्नी रिवाज लगाया सिर्फ महिला और बच्चो के कारण
अब इस्लाम कब सुधार करेगा।
मुस्लिम भाई को कानून तो इंडियन चाहिए या वही इस्लामिक चाहिए ?
Last week one married Muslim surprised me when she said marrying many wives is Sunna then I asked her, what is Sunnah? She said that men with many wives their sin will be forgive by the Allah. I asked her how can true God forgive man's sin for marrying many wives? She kept quiet!
Its not a sin
only the sex-obsessed will completely agree with Naik. 😁😁😁😁
ua-cam.com/video/TUU7997VTyY/v-deo.html
I hope you understand Arabic, unfortunately there is no translation
😂😂😂
Sunnah = ignorance...😁😁😁😁
sunnis want to understand god's book by reading people's books, putting aside god's book.
polygamy is an invention of sex addicts
To each their own.
The reason for krishna marrying those woman was because they have been held captive for years by a demon called Narakasur, and they will not be accepted in the society.. So only to restore their honor krishna accepted them as his wives. Preachers like Zakir Naik should not utter a word if he cannot defend his religion without bringing other religions down. A preacher is someone who delivers a sermon publicly not a person who converts other people to his religion by taking advantage of people's lack of knowledge regarding their religion's scriptures...
so dear in islam its the prequationary step to give respect to women before she becomes the public property what krishna does is after step the womens got freedom from that rakshasa. The logic is very simple if only one man is there and he is having a wife with younger sister and if no men left in so to protect her from becoming scort/public property she wil choose the option to let her marry with her husband and also marrying is not only thing you have to give her an equal rights. Marriage is thats why a contract where 2 peopels by there will geeting into a relationship its not like that men wil force hes sister-in law to marry with him its ultimately her choice but as if you see a respectable answer then its best to get marry with a men rather becoming public property. Correct me if wrong. 😊😊
According to him muslim community are still living in early age 😂😂 bro don't understand according time society and there laws changes
I see no logic/reason in him calling certain women public property. Chosing multiple sexual partners is an individual choice. However it does not gives others any right of using derogatory comments against them.
Dharmendra changed his religion and converted to islam to marry hema malini, so logically he isn't hindu anymore 🤦
That kid who writes what he knows ignoring question paper
He answered every thing bro
A true leader always has respect for other religion....
If your leader don't respect other religion don't follow such leader or such religion....
Because respecting other religion is the basic lesson of a religion
I agree
@@junaidfayaz729 I agree too
I agree
but i didnt found any disrespect or any harms to other religions
@@SJ_streetrider you can't find cause your brain washed already
Is there an islam husband who satisfied having one wife and loyal to his only beloved wife while he is allowed to have so many wives 🥺?If there are these men ,salute 🔥 and for Poor Islam girls ,thousand hugs 🫂
Come in Pakistan
Thanks
Muslim women should leave this anti women religion
Lol Muslim women themselves support all this
It is because women are "compatible" with eachother, and not men. Thats why 1 man, more wives.
He proved that he doesn't know the New testament well.
😂😂😂
You must be disappointed
Even your jesus doesn’t know the new testament
Accurate🤣😂@@RukshanRahuman
@@marufhussen6271 never go to argue with a christian, they are the most illogical human beings i have ever met in life
I think zakir naik has gone mad. I think zakir naik have forgot what bible says about marriage.
@Digital Bath Then watch david wood debunked by zakir naik lol...You wanna debate? Debate with me
@Digital Bath David wood is a psychopath hate preacher who lies about Islam for youtube views. He claims he's a Christian but instead of preaching christianity or going to a church and doing any work he decides to sit in his basement and falsely accuse another religion without any concrete evidence. He's a bum who got embarrassed by Mohammed Hijab and I doubt he's even a Christian. Where in the bible does it command someone to slander or lie about another religion?
He doesn't know anything, he manipulate people's only with his intellectual, most stupid person in the world, great manipulator
@Digital Bath Ask or never dare to debate with David wood, David wood destroyed like his gradegrandfather in knowledge, that's why he knows very well, he will not survive. Zakir will say bring 10000 people to debate, why need 10000 people,
You coward face us
He’s hiding the truth. Little educated being knows the truth.
Haha he spoke the truth
You public property
With all due respect, I am sure you are not in China or North Korea. So you have the right and luxury to do your own research.
@@impermanence5206 You are being too poetic and seem to care more about sounding cool than understandable.
@@muneeburrehman8188 thank you for the compliment. I appreciate.
She asks about logically and he answers it first religiously and then logically and no one is gonna deny that fact a man has more than 8 female partners before he settles down with one, its like using 8 tissue papers throwing in a bin and then having a perfect handkerchief for himself!!!!
Its always funny to see people arguing about who has got a better imaginary friend.anyways...
For those who are supporting polygamy for men, I will pray to Allah that their sister's daughter's husband should have multiple wives too
That's why Hindus marry more than one wife....they r someone's sisters or daughters too.
@@randomthought2026
If so, then why only those who follow all Arabic religion get angry after speaking against polygamy?
@@ramavtarpandey4200 not angry but frustrated....when u specifically try to demean those people and ignore a large section of your own community doing the same thing..... anyway talking against and in favor of polygamy in general is no problem.
@@randomthought2026
Law in India: that Hindus cannot do polygamy whereas Muslims still have the right of polygamy in the name of personal law.
That is why it is said for Islam that this religion is not fit in today's time.
In the countries where Islam is a majority, they become Islamic countries and violate the rights of women:
But in secular countries, they keep spreading terror over non-Muslims and women.
@@randomthought2026
What is the rationale for creating an Islamic country? After all, why can't these people of Arabic religion remain secular?
There is no christian or hindu country then why this Islam gives such teaching??
I don't know about other scriptures ,but I quote the Bible here
1Ti 3:2 A bishop then must be blameless, the husband of one wife, vigilant, sober, of good behaviour, given to hospitality, apt to teach;
1Ti 3:12 Let the deacons be the husbands of one wife, ruling their children and their own houses well
Tit 1:6 If any be blameless, the husband of one wife, having faithful children not accused of riot or unruly.
You are Christian ?
Yes but, these "husbands of one wife" is not a command, its a status someone already has, where is the "Marry Only One" verse?
@@aziepratama2435 Where is marry 2 or 3 verse too?
@@kwesifelixboafo5333 (4:3) If you fear that you might not treat the orphans justly, then marry the women that seem good to you: two, or three, or four. If you fear that you will not be able to treat them justly, then marry (only) one, or marry from among those whom your right hands possess. This will make it more likely that you will avoid injustice.
Literally on the video 😂
@@aziepratama2435 Mohammed Law? He can't be a standard for us.
My question for you if you see this" If man can marry more than 1 in your religion, why can't his wife have more than 1 husband?
Common sense and logic if she’s pregnant whose the father of the four husbands 😂😂😂 wats wrong with some of you logic please hving many wives doesn’t create any birth problems cause all women produce for the same man 😂😂😂
Common sense and logic if she’s pregnant whose the father of the four husbands 😂😂😂 wats wrong with some of you logic please hving many wives doesn’t create any birth problems cause all women produce for the same man 😂😂😂
What happens if she doesn't want or can't have children is it still wrong for her to have multiple husbands?
It's haram for a woman to have more man as husband it's like that if your mother sleep's with more man then how your mother Will know that you are from which men and you are who's breed
You didn't watch the entire video
Women are already more than men in population so if they merry more than one men the society will be unbalanced that's why.
I completely disagree with this person. When asked why Islam allows four marriages, instead of answering the question, he always compares it to other religions and makes irrelevant statements. This person just brainwashes people by looking at half-baked information. He doesn’t know anything.😡
The story of the 16,100 additional wives comes from the legend where Krishna saved them from the captivity of a demon named Narakasura. After being freed, these women had nowhere to go, as society wouldn't accept them, so Krishna married them to give them dignity and respect. This number is symbolic and represents Krishna’s divine nature and his capacity for boundless love and protection. It is not meant to be taken literally in terms of human relationships.
As a women I will say: Thank you? like, for the well-meant intentions?????
Marriage as a social contract should no longer be a condition in order to protect anyone, every single human being regardless its gender, age, or civil state should be protected by their state. And this is an obligation for them (The State) to fulfill, and if not for us to claim.
We, as human beings deserve all protection just by existing alone, any other input is absolute nonsense and *negligent.*
Statements of this nature promote diminishing human values, case in point the absurd idea of people being treated as property, which is an insane, dangerous, outrageous and outdated belief to spread.
*A single woman is never public property. No human being is.*
The idea of marriage in the 21st century, polygamy-focused, based in the poor premise of justifying an ancient male hierarchy in order for woman to "be protected" (if you will) its just insanely obsolete and absurd.
For the proper development of human life, man needs two elements: 1. resources to maintain life and to fulfill the material needs of the individual and society, and 2. knowledge of the principles of individual and social behavior to enable man to fulfill himself and to maintain justice and tranquillity in human life.
The Lord of the universe has provided for both of these in full measure.
Marriage plays a major role in protecting someone from the sins of adultery, masturbation and homosexuality. Marriage takes away the possibility of all evils and sins such as child abortion, unknown birth father and irresponsible partner. Through marriage the couple will have righteous offspring. It is the survival of generation and it results in obtaining great and good rewards by having righteous children.
Anyway, the Lord of the universe must have a reason for any restrictions imposed to the human kind regardless in the context of marriage or any other matters. If we're living in this world without any guidance and guideline, surely we'll be clueless and unjust.
Absolutely right well said👌👍
The real question is who is saying you to do second marriage...if you have guts,or you can afford or your wife is happy you can marry..simple...its is not compulsary....as sir naik said..but you so called educated fool will not understand it..
I agree. Polygamy is evil of society. If u want to marry another women then divorce the women that u are currently living with, and then marry another women.
@@saguftakhanam4818 but all the reply for the answer given by zakir
I am a Hindu but when I researched on Islam I found of it because Islam is the right way to live in kaliyuga , Islam saves lot of things in once life it is the only religion of real peace
Ex muslim zafar heretic
Plus for me the “ you must do justice “ gets confused..
How can you equally treat, take care, love, 2,3 or 4 different people?
Deep inside you will always prefer one over the other in certain areas right?
Or simply preferring one over the rest.. it’s human nature!
So my final idea on it..it’s you can’t do justice so just marry one 👍🏾
Islam allow them to marry 4 time BUT u must love them equal God instructed that because he know man can not do that BUT never the less the do it
@@dhanwantieseeram8147 I couldn’t agree more to your reply.
That’s exactly what I meant with my question.
Thanks
@@dhanwantieseeram8147 well by justice means providing equal to them and don't fancy one of them well some may not be able to do that but must can that's why they are living a happy life with their wives so it's about choice which one you prefer most either marrying one or more than one
Brother, you are wrong. In Hinduism also it has been said that a man should marry only one wife.See the seventh word to be taken at the time of marriage which Hindu scriptures have given The girl tells the groom that you will consider foreign women like mothers and will not allow anyone else to come in between the love of husband and wife. If you promise to do so, I agree to come to your Vamang.See this is not the case for kings because they may have to marry princesses of other countries to have relations with other countries. But Shri Krishna ji had done such 16,100 marriages because when sri krishna freed 16,100 girls from a demon named bhaumasur. all girls did not go back to her home and started saying that no one will accept us. We have come back from this demon, so you accept us as your wife. Then Shri Krishna ji accepted him but he had done eight marriages. Shri Krishna ji did the rest of the 8 marrges. This was done for this reason to show that this may also have to be done to keep the empire established.and Dasrath jiwas also a king . And the things that you said that Brahmins can marry four, then all those things are written in the Baudhayana Dharmasutra which is written by humans and not any Purana. It is not written in Vishnu Purana . You said wrong.t was okay to have four marriages then. ISLAM IS GREAT According to Islam, because it would have been done after the war to give them shelter. But now it is not right to do this and a woman can easily spend her life alone.🙂🙂🙏🙏.
that makes no sense...so you should have only one child because having 2 or more will make you love one more than other because of the human nature as well.
Because of him, I remain as a Hindu. He doesn't convince me at all... Pls don't get deceived
she could say what if the population gets the way around and for each woman there would be 5 men
That will never happen.Is this logical even?
So what would happen then? If female marries more than one women, population would still remain same🤣🤣🤣. Plus many more diseases n effects
There are more males than females currently...his statistics is false
Or maybe she could ask, Allah gave men the choice to have multiple wives, why not women? Can they have husbands?
there are tribes where all brothers in a family marry one female because shortage of female population . Robert sapolsky.
He's giving more confident for man...
He's the reason of any marriage problem in every household
... Women Objectifying...
... Women Oppression....
Lust is mans weakness,this draws man to islam.jesus is the saviour, salvation and my everything.turn your eyes upon him.love from India