Thank you for speaking out to preserve our fragile country of India. Thank you for your courage and to do the moral thing. India needs more voices like yours. God bless you!
Seems like in this country every law is for the CITIZENS, govt. can do whatever they want even if it's unconstitutional. If SC agrees to SBI this will be another slap on the face of PEOPLE. Supreme Court reply to SBI will confirm that are we really moving to DICTATORSHIP and if so how fast.
It was totally anticipated, not at all a surprise. Now it's interesting to see when the Hon'ble SC would hear the SBI extension petition and what would be the outcome
Who is SBI fooling ? Didn't they work day and night when DEMONITISATION was announced without any preamble? SBI should not be allowed more time. Otherwise haul them up for CONTEMPT OF COURT.
Not really. Its the BJP govt who has become the laughing stock, but no one wants to speak up. SBI only did what the BJP govt forced it to do. Let us not forget the kind of people at the top that SBI has to deal with...
Is it digital India going to become a world GURU. Is it a sign of democracy. Couldn't SBI say on 15th of Feb that it was not possible to furnish the required data on Mar 6. Isn't it stupidity to go to court just one day before the scheduled date ?
Supreme court should demand SBI to submit details before declaration of Election. ( immediately ) It is in the tip of a finger. Everything is computerized and audited. Accounts are balanced daily. We hope the Honarable Supreme Court will stand with JUSTICES. DIGITAL INDIA.
Elections should take place only after the supreme court order is honoured and all details are shared as demanded by the court. If extension is granted then the delay period should be subtracted from 5 year tenure for the next election. The Supreme court must ensure that democratic rights and the right to information of citizens is secured.
SBI discloses information to IT officials in cases of tax evasions by ordinary people, why not for these, are they privileged. Maybe, SBI is helpless like Chandigarh polls presiding officer, BJP's interference. They must have already manipulated the list by now. Even in Rafale also, overnight suspended the then CBI chief, appointed pro-tem director, inspite of no powers to do so, wiped out all evidences, when the case was in trial, in the court.
Being a Branch Manager at SBI, I am able to collate information of 33000+ customers of my branch within 5 minutes if I need... This information is readily available in the reports of Core Banking Solution.
Good one Sujit! But you missed to point out an obvious detail! Why did SBI wait until now to inform the Supreme Court that they cannot provide the details requested by 06 March? If they needed time until 30 June then they should have made this clear as soon as thd verdict was announced! Meaning they were playing for time. Also through an earlier verdict by Supreme Court in 2019, the court had ordered that SBI should keep an account separately for all bonds sold from that day and should produce details anytime the court required in the future.
Banks close their books on a daily basis and balance sheets are finalized on annual basis, if not every quarter. So, the SBI’s claim/excuse is laughable, to say the least!!
Court has given Order in April 2019 to SBI to prepare and keep electoral bond Data Ready.. So from April 2019 - till date. Sbi was in sleeeeeping mode for almost 5 years.. Chairman of sbi must RESIGN...if he cannot provide Data.
Modi should not be allowed to contest election in next lok sabha election if the electoral bond was not made public. At the same time evm must be banned.
Sujith sir, nice coverage, all of us were pretty much aware that information will not be shared at any cost and we all know the reasons for it, I am not surprised at all.
The SC could have easily dismissed the request. The reason stated by SBI is just a Trivial One. For others it would have been dismissed. Hope the SC does not suffer another set back as it was in the appointment of Election Commissioner. It is very scary the SC verdicts are taken so lightly. Just think.
44 thousand makes sense.. Set A is electoral bonds purchased by donors Set B is electoral bonds submitted by parties for redemption. So its 2x dataset. But in digital world its just join of two sql tables.. Sql dbs can process lakhs of transactions per second. So june deadline is ridiculous
The SBI Chairman behaving like an obedient and corrupt goon of his Masters. Put the right kinds of pressure like BJP does, you will see the Chairman running like a horse with the complete documents and submit on your door steps. OR sent DRI, CBI and Tax Officials to his bedroom and recover what he has collected from every the Politicians from the Finance Ministry run by Hon’ble but failed Finance Minister. Treat them with the same medicines so they will spell the beans and tell the naked truth!!!
SBI should be booked for contempt of court. They want to save BJP from getting exposed in front of the public.In this modern age of advanced computerisation this information can be given without much delay and difficulty .
In every SBI branch, there should be more than 10,000 active accounts. One transaction in an account in a day scale to 20k interaction, every day . SBi chairman says indirectly ,we need years to reconsel each bank transaction of a month. Which means,as per chairman, SBI is not competitive.
Even if they had so much sets to give out , they keep track of every transaction and produce when asked ! They should be punished for not keeping record if so , then also no extra time should be given! They should be behind bars !
With such advanced technology available with Banks, the SC should order the Chairman of SBI to give the data within 3 days or else sack him and put him in jail for contempt of Court.
SC will give permission as per SBI/BJP's request till June end. SC also part of ruling BJ. From this i come to know that each and everyone working for BJP's Modi
What SBI doing is a criminal act! It just takes an hour to download even tonnes of data. As a banker we know everyday from their core banking system how data is dumped to be processed. This is a classic cover up.
If electoral bonds are unconstitutional and illegal,what about the legality of a govt which comes to power using illegal money. Giving more time to SBI will give scope for manipulation and fudging The SC must also ensure safe custody of all information related to EB The SBI must be ordered to comply asap or face stiff penal action
There are 2 options open to all concerned. 1) File an emergent petition in the Supreme Court stating that SBI complies with the Supreme Court order. 2) File an emergent petition in the Supreme Court stating that General Elections be postponed till the SBI declares the necessary details in the appropriate forum. The General Public has to be in the loop in order to sustain Democracy .
Respects to our SC....If SBI is granted the extension, it will be yet another nail in the citizen's coffin by this Govt. strengthening their corruptive governance.
When SBI dares to lie to the Supreme court,the first shout of reprimand should come from the PMO.As a guardian of peoples trust in govt,its PMO and PM first duty to ensure institute (including financial) follow the law of the land.
A spreadsheet contains 3 major columns and another 3 more columns are enough for the entire information. If it fails to submit, the elections shall be postponed . Then automatically the government will be out after 6 months and president rules will be implemented.
Someone file RTI as to how many transactions are carried out by SBI on daily basis. If SBI has the processing power to bank an entire nation, 44K transactions are nothing.
We must support the political party which works in the greater interest of democracy! Politicians behind SBI's dilly-dallying tactics must be taught an appropriate lesson by rejecting them at hustings
Main Bhi Parivar implies 'Main Bhi Criminal'. It is the duty of the Social Media to make a note of all the politicians coining this phrase. This will come handy in future.
In our normal DB queries, we handle million resultsets and the output comes in minutes! And these folks, data must ve been in system only, asking for some unbelievable time. Any lazy employee will lose his/her job if responds in this fashion, simple!! So, SC must do some whiplashes on those fools, for taking the SC directive so lightly! SC must enforce them to submit within a day or face criminal charges!
keeping opposition leaders in jail for long without any trial is the fundamental flaw in our justice delivery system today. As long as that continues there is no hope for oppostion in electoral politics. Electoral bond is a non issue.
Simply the electoral bonds fund was strictly managed by the Boss himself and he had authority to use it, SBI did not do anything but allowed bank name and facility for the Boss to carry out his scam. If the truth will come out, the Boss will have to follow the path of many goons of Gujarat.
The statement of the SBI is utter nonsense! Its Computer age, it takes hardly a few hours to give the reply. Now lets see what the Hon SC of India says!
Sujitji Perfect Nail ✅ H'ble SC landmark judgement about electoral bond does not suffice everything/transparency. Recalling, most parties jolly well agreed upto 20k donation, nobody needs to disclose name. That means in multiples of 20k any / all parties can accept donation! It would hv been appreciated if all parties agreed that any amount of donation shall be recorded & disclosed!! H'ble SC could have stepped in then too. Thus unless every penny is made accountable, selective judgement on electoral bonds only can't help us to reach anywhere. That may be the reason the Attorney General statement makes sense too.
Supreme Court often gives good judgments but cannot handle what crooks do thereafter. Hope this wont happen in this case. After all, SBI has only to give details of 22000 cases.
If the SBI doesn't care Supreme Court of India and trying to mislead the Court, the persons responsible should be proceeded against and the Court should order the next level officers to abide by its directions to submit information needed
The Supreme court should demand all sealed covers in court, check them रैंडम तो से if this is true. The SC should bring in volunteers and experts who can do quick data entry and give them AI to analyse it. It will get done in a week.
Thank you for speaking out to preserve our fragile country of India. Thank you for your courage and to do the moral thing. India needs more voices like yours. God bless you!
Shame on SBI & the leaders who are responsible for such decision of SBI..
You are right, Mr Nair. The public must know, the public NEEDS to know. The public will DEMAND to know.
Seems like in this country every law is for the CITIZENS, govt. can do whatever they want even if it's unconstitutional. If SC agrees to SBI this will be another slap on the face of PEOPLE. Supreme Court reply to SBI will confirm that are we really moving to DICTATORSHIP and if so how fast.
It was totally anticipated, not at all a surprise. Now it's interesting to see when the Hon'ble SC would hear the SBI extension petition and what would be the outcome
Same thing happened with SEBI enquiry on Adani.
I didn't think SBI would stoop so.low. the only bank we trusted.
The SBI Chairman should be sacked and action taken Is it.not a criminal conspiracy?
Sadly Yes Sir, It is a Criminal Conspiracy.
Maybe, he hardly has options!! Sad state of affairs for our beloved country
THE MAN BEHIND SBI OUTRIGHT REJECTION OF SUPREME COURT IS NOT CMD OF SBI. IT IS SOMEBODY ELSE WHO IS EVERYTHING IN OUR COUNTRY.
SBI CUSTOMERS.BETTER TO B CAUTIOUS WHILE.DEALING.
SUPREME.COURT.HAS BECOME A.LAUGHING STOCK IN OUR COUNTRY.
Supreme Court should sack the Chairman of SBI ,the required information could be furnished within hours
This is a criminal case and all the SBI chairman, MD and the Board of Directors should be in the Jail on contempt of court.
SBI is
Scammers Bank
Lead by
Scammers king
Sanyaasi in the name of
Sriram 😂😂😂😂
Absolutely
They should be in jail by 8 AM of 7th March, 2024.
ABSOLUTELY ...SBI SHOULD BE TAKEN TO TASK.....OR SUOREME COURT SHOULD FREEZE THE ELECTROL BONDS...OR INValid.....supreme court wake up...
Don't people know this is digital India? 😂 2 criminals running the show for 2 economic criminals. Shame on SBI.
Matter of few clicks to retrieve this data from system. Supreme court should take strict action on SBI .
Sbi is known for its incompetence
If SC agrees to the time SBI is asking for - it would not only be a Shame on our digital capability but also how ridiculous our democracy can get.
Exactly
Supreme Court will not agree. After studying the matter directives issued
100% RIGHT.... It's a BIG EXCUSE. SC should not grant their petition.
And it is a mockery of so called transparency 😂
What is the stand of RBI on this issue?
SBI - Shameless Bank of India.
(The bank of every criminal.)
SC should throw the SBI's petition, summon SBI Chairman and put him behind bars for contempt of court for this joke of the year in this digital era.
Digital India
&
NO DIGITAL SBI
What a joke 😂😂😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Shame, shame SBI
Ek Gobarandu bol raha tha ki details dene keliye paperworks lgta hai matlab kis jamane mai jeete hai yeh log 😂
The sad thing is they are playing this joke on us, citizens.
This was expected. The same thing happened in Maharashtra.The speaker took so many extensions which were granted by the Supreme court.
One of the best editorial. Hats off to you
This has crossed all limits. No fear of contempt of court. Now. It is time for contempt of the people. Vote them out.
Most of the northies have been brainwashed by gobar and mandir. So, most probably no use. 😢
The Ganpati collections example was hilarious 😂😂😂 SBI claim is absurd. I can vouch for it (being an IT professional).
If extension is to be granted then what is the logic in passing the historic judgement.
Loved his words Vargani😂
Who is SBI fooling ? Didn't they work day and night when DEMONITISATION was announced without any preamble? SBI should not be allowed more time. Otherwise haul them up for CONTEMPT OF COURT.
SBI HAS BECOME THE LAUGHING STOCK OF THE COUNTRY. STUPID NOT STATE BANK 😂😂😂
More the SC than SBI
Stupid Bank of India
Not really. Its the BJP govt who has become the laughing stock, but no one wants to speak up. SBI only did what the BJP govt forced it to do.
Let us not forget the kind of people at the top that SBI has to deal with...
Is it digital India going to become a world GURU. Is it a sign of democracy. Couldn't SBI say on 15th of Feb that it was not possible to furnish the required data on Mar 6. Isn't it stupidity to go to court just one day before the scheduled date ?
@@vishwamitterbammi PM Modi told SBI to keep quiet till 5th March...😂😂😂
Thank you sir for bringing the real story to the public you are doing great work for the country and the public
It will b a test for CJI DYC. Will he fight back n pass or buckle under pressure?
I strongly hope he doesn't turn out to be a dud.
The CJI is sure to buckle under pressure. He has done it in the case of Maharashtra and I'm sure he'll do it again.
Supreme court should demand SBI to submit details before declaration of Election. ( immediately )
It is in the tip of a finger.
Everything is computerized and audited. Accounts are balanced daily.
We hope the Honarable Supreme Court will stand with JUSTICES.
DIGITAL INDIA.
Mr. Francos interview the best. I watched it twice. I have never seen some one as honest in his interview
I too watched 3 times. Excellent.
Elections should take place only after the supreme court order is honoured and all details are shared as demanded by the court. If extension is granted then the delay period should be subtracted from 5 year tenure for the next election. The Supreme court must ensure that democratic rights and the right to information of citizens is secured.
Your suggestion is good.
Great suggestion. Election on June 7th would give a fitting lesson
SBI discloses information to IT officials in cases of tax evasions by ordinary people, why not for these, are they privileged.
Maybe, SBI is helpless like Chandigarh polls presiding officer, BJP's interference. They must have already manipulated the list by now.
Even in Rafale also, overnight suspended the then CBI chief, appointed pro-tem director, inspite of no powers to do so, wiped out all evidences, when the case was in trial, in the court.
Simply ridiculous.. Banks like Axis or other Pvt. Banks should challenge SBI that this data can be produced before the nation in just one day..😅
Being a Branch Manager at SBI, I am able to collate information of 33000+ customers of my branch within 5 minutes if I need... This information is readily available in the reports of Core Banking Solution.
SBI is taking time to tamper.
24 days was crucial SBI should fined for contempt of court and resignation of high official s
Good one Sujit! But you missed to point out an obvious detail! Why did SBI wait until now to inform the Supreme Court that they cannot provide the details requested by 06 March? If they needed time until 30 June then they should have made this clear as soon as thd verdict was announced! Meaning they were playing for time. Also through an earlier verdict by Supreme Court in 2019, the court had ordered that SBI should keep an account separately for all bonds sold from that day and should produce details anytime the court required in the future.
Credibility and Trust on SBI is a question today.
They should be asked why they should not immediately discharged from their positions.
It is a question of Nation's Interest.
Very clear message given by Nair sir.. Great observation ❤❤
This is rediculous! The Apex court should take tough action against the SBI.
Your right. Nobody in their right mind will be ready to swallow the reasons given by SBI for the delay in disclosing the details of the bonds.
Banks close their books on a daily basis and balance sheets are finalized on annual basis, if not every quarter. So, the SBI’s claim/excuse is laughable, to say the least!!
SBI chairperson should be behind the bar. They are workers of BJP.
Excellent Analysis and Prediction Sir
Court has given Order in April 2019 to SBI to prepare and keep electoral bond Data Ready..
So from
April 2019 - till date. Sbi was in sleeeeeping mode for almost 5 years..
Chairman of sbi must RESIGN...if he cannot provide Data.
Modi should not be allowed to contest election in next lok sabha election if the electoral bond was not made public.
At the same time evm must be banned.
Sujith sir, nice coverage, all of us were pretty much aware that information will not be shared at any cost and we all know the reasons for it, I am not surprised at all.
Excellent
Good journalism 👏👍
The SC could have easily dismissed the request. The reason stated by SBI is just a Trivial One. For others it would have been dismissed. Hope the SC does not suffer another set back as it was in the appointment of Election Commissioner. It is very scary the SC verdicts are taken so lightly. Just think.
44 thousand makes sense..
Set A is electoral bonds purchased by donors
Set B is electoral bonds submitted by parties for redemption.
So its 2x dataset.
But in digital world its just join of two sql tables..
Sql dbs can process lakhs of transactions per second.
So june deadline is ridiculous
The SBI Chairman behaving like an obedient and corrupt goon of his Masters. Put the right kinds of pressure like BJP does, you will see the Chairman running like a horse with the complete documents and submit on your door steps. OR sent DRI, CBI and Tax Officials to his bedroom and recover what he has collected from every the Politicians from the Finance Ministry run by Hon’ble but failed Finance Minister. Treat them with the same medicines so they will spell the beans and tell the naked truth!!!
SBI should be booked for contempt of court. They want to save BJP from getting exposed in front of the public.In this modern age of advanced computerisation this information can be given without much delay and difficulty
.
In every SBI branch, there should be more than 10,000 active accounts. One transaction in an account in a day scale to 20k interaction, every day . SBi chairman says indirectly ,we need years to reconsel each bank transaction of a month.
Which means,as per chairman, SBI is not competitive.
What a ridiculous reply from the SBI.. hope our Supreme court declines the request of SBI.
This is not the surprise for me...I expected this...we are in peak form of democracy and transparency crisis
Even an LKG child knows SBI is lying 😢😢😢
SBI chairman should be arrested and sent to jail for taking money and not doing his/her jobs.
You are right , pl do your best to get the information from SBI.
Why can't SC ask EC to postpone elections until SBI provides the data ?🤔
Elections should be held only after this information is received by the supreme court&is satisfied with the evidence
Elections should be held only after this information is received by the supreme court&is satisfied with the evidence
Any simple guy eho knows Excel can sort out the Payee, Recipiebt in 6 hours. SBI had defeated the Digital India claim of Govt of India and Mr Modi.
SC shall impose heavy penalty on SBI and it's directors. Then only they will understand whom to obey. Modi or the honourable SC.
Every information is in digital format and available in a click. Contempt petition to be filed against SBI
the govt. needs time not the sbi
Now the nation wants to know the truth.
Even if they had so much sets to give out , they keep track of every transaction and produce when asked ! They should be punished for not keeping record if so , then also no extra time should be given! They should be behind bars !
If they cannot account for the money received can it be called unaccounted money as it's done for the layman ?
With such advanced technology available with Banks, the SC should order the Chairman of SBI to give the data within 3 days or else sack him and put him in jail for contempt of Court.
Then why sisodia is behind bars?
Why can’t sbi give details of bigger denominations?
SC will give permission as per SBI/BJP's request till June end. SC also part of ruling BJ. From this i come to know that each and everyone working for BJP's Modi
This monologue has taught people that everything which government does should be transparent .
What SBI doing is a criminal act! It just takes an hour to download even tonnes of data. As a banker we know everyday from their core banking system how data is dumped to be processed. This is a classic cover up.
If electoral bonds are unconstitutional and illegal,what about the legality of a govt which comes to power using illegal money.
Giving more time to SBI will give scope for manipulation and fudging
The SC must also ensure safe custody of all information related to EB
The SBI must be ordered to comply asap or face stiff penal action
Notorious timing of the judgment
If SC agrees to the time frame requested by SBI, remaining judges should revolt against the Consution Bench
As a member of S B I family I strongly ask the chairman to quit the post if you cannot obey the C J I 's order.
There are 2 options open to all concerned.
1) File an emergent petition in the Supreme Court stating that SBI complies with the Supreme Court order.
2) File an emergent petition in the Supreme Court stating that General Elections be postponed till the SBI declares the necessary details in the appropriate forum.
The General Public has to be in the loop in order to sustain Democracy .
Bycott SBI
Lets wait for supreme court to respond to this application of extension
Respects to our SC....If SBI is granted the extension, it will be yet another nail in the citizen's coffin by this Govt. strengthening their corruptive governance.
Supreme Court of India will give a verdict of their decision
When SBI dares to lie to the Supreme court,the first shout of reprimand should come from the PMO.As a guardian of peoples trust in govt,its PMO and PM first duty to ensure institute (including financial) follow the law of the land.
A spreadsheet contains 3 major columns and another 3 more columns are enough for the entire information. If it fails to submit, the elections shall be postponed . Then automatically the government will be out after 6 months and president rules will be implemented.
The SBI CEO had secured his member of parliament seat after his retirement under BJP 😂
Excellent said 💯✔️✅✅💯✔️✅✅💯✔️✅💯✔️✅✅✅
Someone file RTI as to how many transactions are carried out by SBI on daily basis. If SBI has the processing power to bank an entire nation, 44K transactions are nothing.
If the manager of the SBI is so incapable, then the court should appoint an experienced person who can get the job done in a day
We must support the political party which works in the greater interest of democracy! Politicians behind SBI's dilly-dallying tactics must be taught an appropriate lesson by rejecting them at hustings
If SC can’t make sure the law is respected by SBI, people should law in their hands. That’s the only way now to deal with this situation.
It seems very purpose of the judgment by the honorable Supreme Court may be defeated as per the public opinion.
SBI is under CBI under ED under BJP under government.
Main Bhi Parivar implies 'Main Bhi Criminal'. It is the duty of the Social Media to make a note of all the politicians coining this phrase. This will come handy in future.
In our normal DB queries, we handle million resultsets and the output comes in minutes! And these folks, data must ve been in system only, asking for some unbelievable time. Any lazy employee will lose his/her job if responds in this fashion, simple!! So, SC must do some whiplashes on those fools, for taking the SC directive so lightly! SC must enforce them to submit within a day or face criminal charges!
SBI Chairman should be sent to jail for contempt Supreme Court order.
keeping opposition leaders in jail for long without any trial is the fundamental flaw in our justice delivery system today. As long as that continues there is no hope for oppostion in electoral politics. Electoral bond is a non issue.
Simply the electoral bonds fund was strictly managed by the Boss himself and he had authority to use it, SBI did not do anything but allowed bank name and facility for the Boss to carry out his scam. If the truth will come out, the Boss will have to follow the path of many goons of Gujarat.
The statement of the SBI is utter nonsense! Its Computer age, it takes hardly a few hours to give the reply. Now lets see what the Hon SC of India says!
Sujitji
Perfect Nail
✅
H'ble SC landmark judgement about electoral bond does not suffice everything/transparency.
Recalling, most parties jolly well agreed upto 20k donation, nobody needs to disclose name.
That means in multiples of 20k any / all parties can accept donation!
It would hv been appreciated if all parties agreed that any amount of donation shall be recorded & disclosed!!
H'ble SC could have stepped in then too.
Thus unless every penny is made accountable, selective judgement on electoral bonds only can't help us to reach anywhere.
That may be the reason the Attorney General statement makes sense too.
RBI must intervene and take strict action against SBI.
Supreme Court often gives good judgments but cannot handle what crooks do thereafter. Hope this wont happen in this case. After all, SBI has only to give details of 22000 cases.
So well explained. I being a lay person also could understand. Thank you
As per SBI, it is strange that they have the manpower to compile only 370 sets of information sought per day.
I was under the impresstion that SBI had hornest officers but now I realized the HEAD BUS CORRUPT.
I don't think SC would commit such blunder by accepting the plea of SBI.
If the SBI doesn't care Supreme Court of India and trying to mislead the Court, the persons responsible should be proceeded against and the Court should order the next level officers to abide by its directions to submit information needed
The Supreme court should demand all sealed covers in court, check them रैंडम तो से if this is true. The SC should bring in volunteers and experts who can do quick data entry and give them AI to analyse it. It will get done in a week.
Hopefully SC reject SBI plea
Well done nair you said it.