Masquerade/Why So Silent - Gerard Butler | The Phantom of the Opera Film

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 4 лют 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 339

  • @KingIshimaru
    @KingIshimaru 12 років тому +11256

    "Guys? Do you think we might wanna go easy on the masquerades while the masked psychotic is still living in the basement? I mean, every time there's an event he sort of walks right in and out again."
    "We haven't seen him in a while, man, lighten up!"

  • @MyHeartHeardMusic
    @MyHeartHeardMusic 11 років тому +8264

    Is it me, or do I just like the fact that Erik was dressed as Red Death, and Raoul was dressed as a prince....
    ...A prince is who Red Death kills in Poe's story.

  • @emilyhorney7319
    @emilyhorney7319 11 років тому +6415

    I Always wished I could go to a party like this.

  • @PhantomhiveT
    @PhantomhiveT 11 років тому +7980

    I love how Raoul just runs off at 1:45, like, "Um, okay, Red Death, I'm just gonna go, you good Christine, you good? Okay good, later." XD

  • @sarah-annbird8044
    @sarah-annbird8044 11 років тому +2988

    i love how he sings softly, "fondest greeting to you all" while touching his sword

  • @ritzeldraws
    @ritzeldraws 12 років тому +2859

    You notice something when christine and the phantom are staring at eachother for a long time. when the camera flashes to madame giry you see everyone else all panicked. but madame giry knows that there is something more between the two.

  • @taya89
    @taya89 12 років тому +786

    I LOVE when the Phantom starts singing, the throb from the drums turns into the low and deep hum from the strings... pure genius.

  • @MsDaydream3r
    @MsDaydream3r 12 років тому +3643

    when he says "why so silent?" I just keep thinking of the joker saying "why so serious?" :)

  • @CrazeddancerMomiji
    @CrazeddancerMomiji 12 років тому +800

    I've always loved how the conductor was up there keeping everyone on time. It's like they all got together and said "Hey, let's have this masquerade but we're an opera company so it's gotta be flashy! Rehearsals are 7-9 M-F, people! We gotta open with a choreographed number performed just for us!"

  • @vivianarojas40
    @vivianarojas40 11 років тому +3839

    If you look closely you'll see that he's buckling on a SWORD BELT. He wanted to fight the Phantom, he wasn't running away or going to the bathroom.

  • @WarriorOfMusic15
    @WarriorOfMusic15 11 років тому +4442

    I think its because he's the only one that truly believes shes a good performer. Raoul never mentioned her singing career much did he? All the Phantom talks about is how wonderful she is

  • @whiteXrose21
    @whiteXrose21 11 років тому +2592

    I love it how the phantom gets cocky with the sword in his hand! Rep! XD

  • @whiteXrose21
    @whiteXrose21 12 років тому +1035

    sometimes we all need dramatic music to indicate our footsteps

  • @garbagemancole2554
    @garbagemancole2554 11 років тому +3563

    I remember when I went to a masquerade, unfortunately we didn't have a man dressed as the red death crash the party.

  • @MissEdge102
    @MissEdge102 12 років тому +559

    "You belong to me" give me shivers every time (not to mention the really cool exit)

  • @Melstrife
    @Melstrife 13 років тому +462

    Always one of my favorite scenes on the stage and in the movie. Gerard Butler does a great job with this scene. Always wanted to be Christine because he just looks at her with pure adore! Love it!

  • @argusprimus
    @argusprimus 11 років тому +3717

    lol, Raol is like "youve got this right?" and then takes off. i know it wasnt really like that but you can imagin lol

  • @tanukigalpa
    @tanukigalpa 11 років тому +5143

    What's terrible is that she also loves Raoul (as shown by the ENGAGEMENT RING AROUND HER NECK) but when one is out of the room she chooses the other, when the other is out of the room she chooses the one. It's very sad because Erik looks down and she's practically throwing the engagement and herself at him at the same time.

  • @liljokerhaha1
    @liljokerhaha1 11 років тому +6184

    The Phantom should have said THIS IS OPERA!!!! and then kicked Raul into the hall of mirrors.

  • @StorytellerMatt
    @StorytellerMatt 12 років тому +608

    After multiple viewings of this film, I notice subtleties in faces. I love the way Madame Giry watches the Phantom, and the heartbreak on her face as he draws close to Christine--no secret she's in love (as we learn in her later monologue). It also makes her sung line "And what a masquerade!" which comes earlier, resonate more.

  • @danigirl800
    @danigirl800 12 років тому +1586

    Hmm, I'd be in the middle of the crowd saying, "God! the phantoms sexy!"

  • @kaitlynrausch1371
    @kaitlynrausch1371 12 років тому +621

    And because she knows the phantom is basically harmless but he's so in love with the girl. Madame Giry was the one who saved him from his terrible childhood

  • @LittleBohoChick
    @LittleBohoChick 12 років тому +425

    Aww, when he looks at Christine, all he's evil intentions vanish in the air

  • @kelswalker5414
    @kelswalker5414 11 років тому +4946

    funny how everytime he takes a step (phantom) it makes a sound

  • @Lala16ss
    @Lala16ss 12 років тому +260

    Dramatic sound effect when descending down the stairs. Need that !

  • @themusic199
    @themusic199 12 років тому +242

    I had never noticed until today that this was inspired by "The Masque of the Red Death" by Poe. Now I can appreciate both even more.

  • @bellscomstock5797
    @bellscomstock5797 12 років тому +401

    Gerard is one of the best actors of all time

  • @MyPlaylistPerson
    @MyPlaylistPerson 12 років тому +170

    There are some awesome camera angles in this scene. The music is amazing as well.

  • @MrsBlack88
    @MrsBlack88 12 років тому +370

    Imagine the sexual tension in this room when Christine started walking towards the Phantom

  • @Sharavis
    @Sharavis 12 років тому +125

    God I love him. The poor guy just has serious communication issues, it could work!! Love that entrance!!

  • @lilypad12322
    @lilypad12322 11 років тому +431

    When i first saw this i honestly thought Raoul was leaving to hide or run away or something...especially with that "good luck" tap he gave her.

  • @ThatOneIsaac
    @ThatOneIsaac 11 років тому +211

    Yes, even though practically everyone in Paris is there, they won't touch the Phantom out of sheer terror. That's his secret weapon.

  • @KUCaldog187
    @KUCaldog187 12 років тому +413

    Gerard is a good phantom

  • @Phoenix61310
    @Phoenix61310 12 років тому +44

    I love how the music pauses for a moment then switches to the Phantom's Song.

  • @EnterElysium
    @EnterElysium 12 років тому +448

    We goes to get his rapier to duel. Such is the culture, rather brave considering the Phantoms rep.

  • @midnightstwilight
    @midnightstwilight 12 років тому +141

    Raoul is sweet and all but I'm cheering for the Phantom!

  • @zubatlover45
    @zubatlover45 12 років тому +68

    I love the way Christine and Raoul are watching everyone like, "LOL! They look so dorky spontaneously breaking out into song and dancing! Good thing WE don't do that!"

  • @OPrimeandKupfan
    @OPrimeandKupfan 11 років тому +188

    The Phantom is making an Edgar Allen Poe's "Masque of the red death" style point, and that crowd knows it! listen to them gasp in shock, horror and even disgust!

  • @ElderGrimm1994
    @ElderGrimm1994 11 років тому +133

    I gotta say, that skull mask is pretty cool.

  • @Sleepinglily
    @Sleepinglily 12 років тому +105

    1:42 Raoul's all like, "I'll be back, I gotta go water my plants."

  • @londonrobinson2922
    @londonrobinson2922 12 років тому +143

    2:44 Christine doesn't seem scared of him at all; she looks pretty... Loving.

  • @loitagrl12
    @loitagrl12 11 років тому +216

    She was going to go for it- WHY DID YOU HAVE TO SAY THAT AT THE END!?

  • @the15thoftheNOAH
    @the15thoftheNOAH 12 років тому +139

    Ok, who the HELL clicked the dislike button?! This is one of my favorite songs from the movie! We gon drop a chanderlear on this fool.

  • @OPrimeandKupfan
    @OPrimeandKupfan 11 років тому +715

    The Phantom just made an Edgar Allen Poe's "Masque of the red death" style point, and that crowd knows it! listen to them gasp in shock, horror and even disgust! you'd have to have read Masque of the red death By Edgar Allen Poe to know what I mean! I read it, I know!

  • @calihoyer1415
    @calihoyer1415 11 років тому +50

    I love how Raoul wears his jacket off one shoulder. I never knew that was possible.

  • @cankcorn
    @cankcorn 12 років тому +228

    I LOVE THIS MUSICAL!!!!

  • @jasoya_gaming
    @jasoya_gaming 11 років тому +122

    Had you missed me good monsieurs, I have written you an opera!
    Here I bring the finished score, THE KING IN YELLOW!!!
    Everyone goes insane.

  • @katypayne5501
    @katypayne5501 12 років тому +78

    I swear the next time I crash a party, this is how it's going to go down

  • @mjvoigts
    @mjvoigts 12 років тому +383

    EVERY time one of them starts to soften the other (Erik and Christine), one of them does something completely STUPID (like in this scene, Erik ripping off Christine's necklace and saying "You belong to me!"). Veeeery frustrating...!!

  • @JikaInFamous
    @JikaInFamous 12 років тому +59

    Best entrance ever, all the men harrased by his presence and all the women tingling with expectations

  • @AkamaraLamia
    @AkamaraLamia 13 років тому +30

    Watched the musical in London.... Phantom of the opera is one of the best musicals i ever saw and i love it!!!!!
    thank you for psoitng this video!

  • @stannisbaratheon5528
    @stannisbaratheon5528 11 років тому +187

    I would kill for a full version of 3:00

  • @thewierdoneout
    @thewierdoneout 11 років тому +4092

    Yeah, until he ruined the moment by ripping off her ring/necklace and saying she belonged to him.
    If he hadn't been such a douche right then, the story might just have ended differently.

  • @purplehearts875
    @purplehearts875 12 років тому +61

    I remember the first time I saw this scene, the gold things at 1:05 freaked me out more than the actual phantom did XD

  • @corkscrewfork
    @corkscrewfork 12 років тому +260

    Really Raoul? Either you have your weapon to begin with or you don't abandon the chick who has TOLD YOU the Phantom's after her. Hell, even Piangi stepped in front of Carlotta when Erik started in on her. Raoul? Upstairs, try again when it's convenient.

  • @mars-aria
    @mars-aria 12 років тому +65

    The Phantom looked so FINE in this seen. I'd let you be my teacher!!!!

  • @kimberlykrier14
    @kimberlykrier14 11 років тому +831

    no she loves the phantom secretly its her pride that betrays her.... of course thats the way that Emmy Rossum presents it, and that is the right way to present the character! And because she is a good actor you can see the love that is hidden behind fear and unknowing and what her young heart doesnt understand is that that is what love builds on and the love that overcomes that fear is always the strongest Check out love never dies the sequel and then see if you can still say she doesnt love him

  • @PrincessCupcake3
    @PrincessCupcake3 12 років тому +19

    in the 25th anniversary the costume is so awesome and creepy plus the way he shows up! EPIC! I LOVE THE PHANTOM OF THE OPERA!

  • @gustavomartinsdesouza5548
    @gustavomartinsdesouza5548 11 років тому +319

    I just need that mask...

  • @niftynafter
    @niftynafter 12 років тому +130

    The Phantom took a break in order to design his new mask and cloths :D

  • @celesteburt8826
    @celesteburt8826 11 років тому +168

    I think he ran off to get his sword. At 3:24 you can kinda see that he's buckling his sword onto his belt.

  • @TNTDynamiteTNTNikki
    @TNTDynamiteTNTNikki 11 років тому +42

    Carlotta Is Enjoying Their Dancing--- Girl Almost Fell Down The Stairs!!

  • @xMinuet
    @xMinuet 13 років тому +25

    i cant believe my highschool is lucky enough to perform this entire musical :)!

  • @analusilvaj
    @analusilvaj 12 років тому +48

    "I'm here, with you, beside you, to guard you and to guide you", said Raoul while he leave the toilet! ¬¬

  • @vamp1024
    @vamp1024 11 років тому +221

    What was Christine thinking? You're so much better. Braver, sexier, and you can SING. :)

  • @738kathleena
    @738kathleena 11 років тому +432

    Yes and in the end she kinda chooses him but he lets her go, you know after the kiss when her tells them to go...

  • @NenadlPopovic
    @NenadlPopovic 13 років тому +20

    THE BEST PHANTOM!

  • @kathy4963
    @kathy4963 12 років тому +19

    OMG this is my favorite scene! Bravissimo

  • @cadethawk1
    @cadethawk1 11 років тому +65

    i wish i had an awsome verse play whenever i entered a room

  • @chocoheartt
    @chocoheartt 11 років тому +296

    My moms best friend, and her whole family have planned dancing at their parties haha

  • @RandomBooksXD
    @RandomBooksXD 12 років тому +28

    At first I wasn't sure how I felt about the movie version, (this is my first time ever seeing anything of it)
    However, after watching this, I am pleased :)

  • @RosedeLioncourt
    @RosedeLioncourt 13 років тому +42

    I love everything about The Phantom of the Opera! Thank you for this video :)

  • @haley188118118
    @haley188118118 12 років тому +16

    my school did phantom as our musical last year and it was amazing all together but this was the most fun scene for sure omg

  • @Gramilla250500
    @Gramilla250500 12 років тому +19

    I want his costume! Especially his mask!

  • @derpyhooves4914
    @derpyhooves4914 11 років тому +162

    how did they know its him? the random music playing when he shows up?!

  • @cloudydae
    @cloudydae 11 років тому +404

    I bet if he took off that mask he'd look like a panda...

  • @quelzinhaclv
    @quelzinhaclv 12 років тому +26

    Essa cena é linda demais, eles nas escadas sem palavras!!!

  • @tidepoolpotions
    @tidepoolpotions 12 років тому +16

    Red and black is the most sexiest colors on a man...I love his outfit in this part.

  • @blockmasterscott
    @blockmasterscott 11 років тому +775

    The ultimate gate crasher....

  • @MsTripleFff
    @MsTripleFff 12 років тому +135

    "If pride will let her return to her teacher."
    God I wish I had a teacher like that. Awkward teacher fetish emerging.

  • @Marylmac
    @Marylmac 13 років тому +6

    Hi...I am wearing this costume to the Phantom Redux 9 in LA in Nov this year. It's a masquerade at midnight to 3am. So looking forwards to it. I live in Australia...Yes, I love Gerry Butler and Emmy's version of Phantom, but will also be true to ALWebber and go to Broadway for the stage show too!

  • @deathpryer
    @deathpryer 11 років тому +148

    I loved that. I wonder if that was put together by the original author.

  • @kateharden1895
    @kateharden1895 11 років тому +17

    i lovveee this movie!

  • @adollfordolls
    @adollfordolls 11 років тому +1025

    Right? I think she and Phantom belong together. If I were her I would choose Eric, not Raoul.

  • @EnglishFlyingPigs
    @EnglishFlyingPigs 11 років тому +256

    No, she's in love with Raoul. Every time that the Phantom enters the same room as Christine is in, she's pretty much put in a trance. Or, as a lot of people mention, it's his mysterious side, or the fact he needs love.

  • @stephmegary
    @stephmegary 12 років тому +13

    Gerry goes up in flames at the end because he's too hot to handle lol :D I'm a fan, if you couldn't tell ;P

  • @cbarrrus2
    @cbarrrus2 12 років тому +21

    0:54 Me when I'm late to work.

  • @faixkurogane
    @faixkurogane 12 років тому +26

    Gotta love a witty, murderous stalker! :D

  • @judithpipher8624
    @judithpipher8624 11 років тому +13

    WHO IS that dark-haired dancer in the first row on the steps? He is SO GOOD!!!

  • @RaNd0mChicklife
    @RaNd0mChicklife 12 років тому +10

    The whole phantom and Christine the id just so romantic!!!!! ♡♥♡♥♡♥♡♥♡ ^0^

  • @florenciamoreira7959
    @florenciamoreira7959 12 років тому +15

    pero que entrada este fantasma,espectacular y ese traje que lo hace mas imponente de lo que es!!!!!

  • @Endofline4you
    @Endofline4you 13 років тому +5

    cool the drum beats line up wit his steps

  • @MicMic18
    @MicMic18 12 років тому +51

    I know right! It was perfect and Christine was starting to like him a little then he had to do something stupid! He should have just shut up right after saying Your teacher and she might have given him a chance.

  • @ponyrellabellasara
    @ponyrellabellasara 12 років тому +32

    1:46
    perfect time to leave Roaul! CONGRATULATIONS!

  • @sgauden02
    @sgauden02 12 років тому +8

    It's obvious to everyone that The Phantom is right in front of them, but Raoul is the only one who does anything!

  • @EMOLOVE23ful
    @EMOLOVE23ful 12 років тому +12

    you had me at Angel of Music

  • @TheDamien583
    @TheDamien583 11 років тому +23

    This wasposted on my birthday

  • @RedOak30
    @RedOak30 12 років тому +12

    No he's not. The reason he was leaving was so that he could get his sword to be all badass and save his lady love from the phantom. I mean no offense but I don't see why so many people bash on Raoul so often. He seems like a pretty cool guy to me.

  • @faixkurogane
    @faixkurogane 12 років тому +6

    Well, they did, just not in the same scene. The lines he spoke here are in the last note he sends them. In the stage version, he says, "I advise you to comply, my instructions should be clear, Remember there are worse things than a shattered chandelier," then sends a note saying the things about Carlotta and Piangi.

  • @guppygirl1000
    @guppygirl1000 11 років тому +40

    For some reason, 1:06 makes me think "DON'T BLINK."