Next you should do good things done by Slytherin characters, dumb things done by Ravenclaw characters, and disloyal things done by Hufflepuff characters.
Slytherin: slughorn in the deathly hallows, fighting in the battle of hogwarts Ravenclaw: Marietta Edgecombe snitching Hufflepuff: zachariah smith in the DA meeting and running as fast as he could in the deathly hallows
I'd say Hermione's jinx on Marietta Edgecomb is worse than she imprisonning Rita Skeeter At least Rita was let out days after But Marietta has to live with horrible facial scaring for the rest of her life
@@ilphi08 I do. I'm never going to be a fan of Snape. Yes he was bullied. Yes I feel for him about that. But, he's worse than his bullies. He joined the death eaters and he also turned around and bullied children while he was an adult.
Glad I got here early! This video reminds me of what Sirius Black said in the fifth book, Order of the Phoenix, "The world isn't split into good people and Death Eaters. We've all got both light and darkness inside us. What matters is the part we choose to act on. That's who we really are."
You only got half the evil of Sirius's sending Snape to meet the werewolf. Remus would never have forgiven himself if he ever infected anyone else ... I think Remus believed tha Sirius was guilty of betraying James because he felt that Sirius had betrayed him by using him in such a way.
Yea so it wasn't just an evil act towards another student but a betrayal of one his best friends (from the guy who said he "would rather die than betray his friends")
That's a really interesting inside I hadn't thought of. I think you're right, it makes sense that lupine would have been convinced that serious betrayed James if you felt like serious had betrayed him years later by trying to use him to kill snape.
@@corywalker8551 It was siriusly evil of him to send Snape to his death, but I don't think he thought it through if he had realised it would hurt Remus so much he wouldn't have done that. He did do really bad things but he would never betray his friends.
He was a coward but he did value bravery, just other people's bravery, he always made sure he was around brave and powerful people who can keep him safe because that's the only thing he cares about
Pettigrew might have been brave at eleven when he got shorted and grew more cowardly as he got older, especially when the first war started to get worse. Or maybe he somehow talked the hat into pointing him in Gryffindor, like Harry talked the hat out of putting him in Slytherin.
@@konakoalaI would argue it probably is justifiable but not condonable. It’s not the first spell that he should have thought of, something like protego or simply even ducking out of the way would have been better.
@konakoala not saying that it is, but there's a difference between intentionally trying to slice him open, and using the first spell that comes to mind in a high stress situation like someone trying to torture you
Harry also didn't know yet what that spell did, which makes it stupid for him to have tried it, but as you said, it was the first thing that came to his mind. Harry wasn't thinking clearly and felt bad once he realized what he had done.
Sirius treating Kreacher badly all through his life is an evil act in itself, resulting in Kreacher to conceal information about the RAB locket, until Hermione treated him well in HP7. Thus he opened up and the trio got to know about Regulus Black's heroic act and sacrifice. Had Sirius treated Kreacher better, the secret of horcuxes would have been revealed by book 5 and the locket should not have ended with umbridge.
Sirius's treatment of Kreacher is definitely a fair point but it's also important to remember that Kreacher has very likely mistreated Sirius when the latter was but a child, based on everything we know about Walburga and her influence over Kreacher. He was also a constant reminder of his parents, the Black Pureblood mania and the life he left behind. It's a complicated situation, especially when you consider that Sirius was essentially still a very young man suffering from severe trauma and depression, so I disagree that it's "an evil act in itself".
Some examples: Snape dedicating himself to protect Harry Snape protecting the students of Hogwarts after Dumbledore's death Snape switching sides and becoming a triple agent Snape giving the key to destroying Voldemort Slughorn giving Harry the memory Slughorn fighting in the Battle of Hogwarts Narcissa lying to Voldemort Regulus betraying Voldemort Draco lying to Bellatrix Something Merlin or some other extra lore character did
And I would put Hermione keeping Skeeter in a jar, “morally grey” since Skeeter’s articles did cause Hermione to get hate mail, some of which, caused Hermione to get hurt.
I think that overall is like this-Slytherin complete bad, Huffepuff complete good. And the other 2 between them. But because Griffindor and Slytherin(the founders) were best friends, maybe that means Griffindor are closer to the evil side. And that puts Ravenclaw close to the good side. That's how I have interpreted it.
Rita deserved what Hermione gave her. Ginny was in a trance 😵💫 then. #1 is certainly the worst. I don’t think Hufflepuff have 10 evil acts. If ever since no house is perfect, maybe 3.
While it was a bad idea, in Harry's defense, he did not know what the spell did, and he was acting in self-defense. You don't always have time to think in those situations.
2:40 i think what is most shocking is in the books we are from Harry's POV. so we are lead to beeive that James was a heroic student who never did anything wrong (and its Harry dad so there is bias) byut we are shocked when we learned how what Snape said about James might have been hate driven but not completely untrue.
Even from hero's perspective, I always thought of James as shady person. Somehow, just the words he used for Snape are not normal for a 'hero'. And then, when we saw Snape perspective, I already realised James was a duche.
I hate how Slytherin is seen as this evil house and Gryffindoor is the pride and joy of Hogwarts. Dumbledoor was clearly bias with the house cub each year.
Your're partially right. But to be fair Slytherins do a lot of evil and the other Slytherins either stay aside or profit from it. And while Dumbledore showed his bias at the end of book 1, Snape was showing his bias every single day.
@@Kubinda12345Dumbledore showed his bias by not expelling Sirius who could have gotten another student killed. Dude Dumbledore was incredibly biased and especially during the most important moments and while Snape was definitely biased he was only super cruel to Harry, Neville, and Hermoine (which is still horrible and bad and an unfair use of power) but we never saw him be that bad to other students from other houses
2:50 the sad part is more then likely James was just flexing and being popular (and it being funny to the crowd) is more then likely why he bullied Snape (who was unpopular and a relatively easy target) then any real reason why he picked on Snape in particular.
It's said in the books he picked on Snape because he was into the dark arts, and because he was Slytherin I think, not a good reason to bully someone, especially that badly, and to be honest I personally think Snape was James’ main target because of jealousy, James had a crush on Lily, but at that time she couldn't stand him, because of the way he acted, but yet was friends with Snape, I think that made James a bit jealous and he took it out on Snape.
@@saphiramystique2086No it was never mentioned in the book that James did not like Snape coz of dark arts. James hated him from their first school train to Hogwarts just coz Snape expressed desire to be in Slytherin. James bullied Snape coz he was unpopular and was an easy target. Please stop trying to cover James evil actions by making up things that were NOT in the book. James was no different from Malfoy minus the racism. But Malfoy grew up in a death eaters family but James was not. He was just a spoiled, entitled and pampered brat!
Absolutely not if it is why don't he bully the rich ones the reasons James bullied Snape is because: -he exist (from being poor and ugly) -he was an easy target -he was jealous of his closeness with lily So Snape being into the dark arts is not the reason why the kid just bully because he can
@@alesonu "Please stop trying to cover James evil actions" But it's okay to sugarcoat Snape's actions, right? James bullying Snape during their first encounter doesn't mean that his tendencies didn't play a role in their interactions going forward. We have several quotes from multiple people, including Lily herself, pretty much confirming that teenaged Snape was very engrossed in the dark arts and generally a nasty person who surrounded himself with future Death Eaters, thought it was a laugh to torment Muggleborns with dark magic and went around calling people Mudblood despite his "best friend" being Muggle-born. And even as a teenager he was already set on joining a terrorist group which, among other things, existed with the purpose of subjugating Muggle-borns. Lupin also confirmed that Snape and James brought out the worst in each other and never missed an opportunity to curse the other. The whole situation wasn't as one-sided as a lot of Snape stans always make it out to be. James was wrong to bully Snape to the extent he did but Snape's behaviour is objectively and unconditionally much worse, we simply didn't witness it first-hand.
I despise Pettigrew beyond everything as it was his fault about everything that little betraying scum. If Harry just let Remus and Sirius kill him… These soldiers would still be alive -Fred -Sirius -Cedric -Remus -Tonks -Dumbledore -Dobby -Mad-eye -Snape -Colin And more notable soldiers😢🫡
You should make a list exlusively about the evil/sketchy things Dumbledore did. He raised Harry to die, left him at his abusive aunts, the whole grindenwald thing. Him not wanting to reach out to the wizarding world when the chamber was opened to keep his job, so he needlessly let several students remain petrified ( I doubt there wasnt a single adult mandrake in the whole of the UK), also him basically keeping Snape as a subordinate/slave for 17 years, not speaking to Harry at all about his connection to voldemort or giving him any advice on horcruxes. These are just the ones off the top of my head but im sure there are more to be found
I would probably add the fact that he allowed Snape to teach at Hogwarts when he knew that Snape was bullying students. He allowed him to abuse his authority, just so he could keep him as a spy. Disgusting. Also, I couldn't help noticing how Dumbledore would befriend people such as Hagrid, McGonagle, Remus Lupin and others in order so he could have leverage over them and manipulate them into doing his bidding. The more I think about it, the more I can see how Dumbledore would come alongside people who were either outcasts or going through a difficult time under the guise of "helping" or "comforting"them, but only so that he could gain leverage over them in order to manipulate them into doing his bidding and obeying him without question.
@@milanka882 yes, hes pretty manipulative and flawed in his methods. If he wasnt using these people to defeat voldemort he would have been a pretty terrible villain. Literally using everyone in every possible way to reach his goals. It just happens that his ultimate goal was the defeat of voldemort
@@meatrubber pretty much, snape says so in the princes tale. Dumbledore didnt know Harry could survive the whole thing until the end of book 4, up until that point he was a sacrifice in Dumbledores eyes Also its my oppinion that the only reason he gave harry the stone of resurrection to give him the final push to sacrifice himself as the ultimate goal of the Stone is to pursuade the owner if used to suicide as we have seen in the tale of the 3 brothers and the same with Harry, all the projections of his loved ones wanted him to die and encouraged him to do so
I don't consider Ginny opening the Chamber as "evil", considering that (1) she had NO idea what she was doing at the time, & (2) she was just an 11 year-old girl writing in a diary.
Ginny one I don't think should be here. She was like hypnotised. She didn't even remember what she was doing. Harry's Sectumsempra spell, though I don't approve of him using an unknown spell on someone who is not even a true enemy, I would still say Harry was not aware. I doubt he ever thought the spell could kill someone. He was horrified at what he had done. So, I don't find that evil. Other all I agree esp Sirius, Peter Pettigrew and James
Especially since both Ginny and Harry have the benefit of remorse after realizing what they both did, with them both being devastated at causing such harm to others without even realizing it in their respective situations.
I’d also add Harry using the Cruciatus curse twice (on Bellatrix and on Carrow). Also, Wormtail killing Cedric, Hagrid putting a literal pig tail on Dudley and not caring to remove it (after all… it is an adult wizard attacking an 11 yo muggle - also, assuming Hagrid was in Griffindor) and Dumbledore hiring Lockhart for the DADA position knowing about its curse just to get rid of him.
1. Harry was being attacked by Draco and Draco was trying to cause him real harm. Whatever spell he cast besides an unforgivable was fair game. It was self defense. 2. Everybody ignores the fact that Herminoe erased her own parents' memories of her and the magical world. She took it upon herself to force them into leaving the country and took away their freedom. That's the most evil thing she did IMO.
I know this isn’t an “evil” act, but I felt it was fair to mention Harry and Ron taking Arthur Weasley’s Ford Anglia to fly to Hogwarts after missing the train. The reason being that not only did they steal a family car, but their actions got Arthur in huge trouble with the Ministry of Magic because Harry and Ron were seen by muggles while flying the car, which wasn’t meant to be enchanted to fly in the first place.
Next should be Acts of Good by Slytherin characters (since Slytherin was seen as the evil house), followed by Acts of Stupidity by Ravenclaw characters. Don't really know what to do for Hufflepuff characters, though.
With hufflepuffs would be unloyal actions. Although, it maybe a little difficult because there are not many characters from hufflepuff, but Morgan would fine some despicable actions
Honestly the tow hermione ones are both debateable since she had reasons for both that were pretty just. Rita being a bitch and being a illegal animagus and spying on harry and the others. And the sneak one being revenge for ratting out the DA to fucking umbridge.
Wouldn’t say any of these are evil except the 2 abt pettigrew. Most are just bad decisions. I’ve always thought your opinions on the series to be pretty good and reasonable but this has drastically changed my mind
I feel like calling wormtail’s mass-murder evil is giving him too much credit. It makes it sound like he did it for fun or just because he could. The real reason he did it wasn’t because he’s evil but because he’s a coward. It wasn’t evil, it was pathetic cowardice.
When it comes to James & Lily’s relationship, I’ll never understand it. He was a literal bully & he did sh*t that was unforgivable, yet Lily still got with him despite knowing how horrible of a person he was. Not only that, but James literally bullied her friend (Snape). There was no excuse for her, even getting with him from the start. He was a bully in & out along with his friends. I don’t wanna hear the argument “well Snape called Lily a mud-blood,” like okay??? So, that makes it okay for her to get with someone who tormented him throughout his entire school years? Don’t get me wrong if they haven’t gotten together then Harry wouldn’t have been born, but be so frill now. Note: I feel like unless you’ve been bullied yourself then you know the type of trauma & mental scars that actually leaves. That’s probably why it just p*sses me off so much.
One of the reasons why Lily ended up falling for James is because she admired how he stood up for people who were being mistreated by Slytherin students. Even both of Lily's parents (especially her mother) loved James and they preferred James a lot more than they did Vernon, causing Petunia to resent Lily even more.
@@williamreynolds3487 Self defense or not, it still doesn’t make it right to use a spell to try to murder a student. I see your point that Draco was trying to use an Unforgivable spell, but it still doesn’t give Harry an excuse to use a dangerous spell that can kill an opponent without knowing its effects. Harry could’ve disarmed him or stupefied Draco. Again, two wrongs don’t make a right.
Having forgotten that Wormtail killed 12 Muggles, I thought his joining the Death Eaters would be #1... Anyway, now I would love to see a video about heroic acts committed by Slytherin characters!
It’s crazy that I’m in the house of the headmaster that cared the least about the kids….. (BTW Pettigrew is an ass hole, ratting out your best friends, to die, for your own personal gain is crazy)
I would love to see a video where you go over and tell us what moments in the HP books/movies you wish would have gone another way. Like Ron agreeing with Snape about Hermione or Harry saying "but I am the chosen one." It would be interesting to know what you would rather the characters did or said differently.
Slytherin ideologies at their best: Seeking to help reach other people's ambitions. Slytherin ideologies at their worst: Seeking to achieve things even if that means stepping on other people. Ravenclaw ideologies at their best: Seeking wisdoms and sharing the knowledge. Ravenclaw ideologies at their worst: Overachieving to the point of either burning out or trying to appear smarter to feel accepted. Hufflepuff ideologies at their best: Seeking to help friends and teammates in the need of it. Hufflepuff ideologies at their worst: Naively helping supporting a group like yes-men even if it's toxic. Gryffindoor ideologies at their best: Taking the steps to help where other people were too scared to do so. Gryffindoor ideologies at their worst: Recklessly challenging themselves and others and endangering people in the process.
Peter Pettigrew was almost sorted into Slytherin, since his cunning and sly nature was evident, yet the Sorting Hat chose to place him in Gryffindor, which even it admitted was a poor choice.
Slytherin is not the most “ evil” house in Hogwarts that is stereotyped! That is like saying all Gryffindors are truly great and hero’s they are not! PETTYGREW IS A SAMPLE OF THAT!
Not to mention this about number 1: As far as Peter Pettigrew knew, he set up Sirius to spend the rest of his life in Azkaban. While I whould still argue that working for Voldemort and killng 12 muggles is Peter's most evil act; Spending the last years of your life traped in a cell, unable to feal joy, with no hope of ever getting out is (in my opinion) worse than being killed
With the Montague situation I remember Draco talking about it the Half Blood Prince but I can't remember it in the Order f the Phenix despite me reading the books like 100 times
He is a bad person that saw the errors of his ways eventually. Unfortunately, he just didn’t have enough time left to do more good than bad. I think a part of him regretted his actions to some degree, but will never know because of, again, the fact that his life was cut short, and the books never bothered to explore his thoughts in dept after that point.
Marauders weren't perefect. Just like Snape and Dumbledore. Snape, James and Sirius each did messed up things. That doesn't stop later on helping others and doing heroic actions. Sirius being the role model he needed at the time. James saving Snape and being there for Remus. Snape protecting harry, despite his prejudice and bullying he did as a teacher.
Rita deserved we she got, I would've just squashed the bug and pretended I didn't know it was a person. And Marietta kinda deserved that, maybe not forever but for a bit. So did Montique. And Malfoy tried to use crucio on Harry, knowing what it does.
"the movies made Hermione out to be this perfect character" in the movies, I only saw Hermione's flaws. At least in the books she is somewhat relatable and likeable. She may have been a know it all in the books but she was a know it all with a heart. In the movies she is just unbearably annoying.
5. Yes, what Harry did was extreme. But Draco attacked first and used Cruciatus on Harry. So if it was investigated, he would've been in much bigger trouble than Harry. 4. Sirius acted stupidly but Snape was pretty convinced that Lupin was a werewolf and listening to a known enemy (= Sirius) was pretty stupid on Snape's part. 2. Peter not only betrayed Lily and James but was a spy in the Order for an entire year which I imagine caused a lot of damage possibly even deaths amongs the Order members.
James was a bigger Bully than Malfoy by far. Malfoy had some hurtful insults at the trio over the years, but it never resorted to this, unless sometimes they were equally dueling each other. Draco being recruited by Voldemort changed things, but Draco in books 1-5 was much better than James. This is only one moment of James and Sirius being bullies. Imagine all the other unseen times
Absolutely bullshit. You know, comments like yours make me realize that perhaps it will be much better if there was a prequel centred around James Potter being the main/central character in a story about either the Potter family or the Marauders under James's POV. Maybe that way, it will shut up haters like you for good!
U seem to forget or ignore these facts: A. Although Hermionie was an insufferable girl who would never listen and aways assumed she was right, like when she kept insulting the House Elves at Hogwarts with tricking them I into being freed and wasn't even punished for it, Reeta Skeeter was an absolutely evil-woman who ruined so many lives...she deserved what she got! 2. Snape was 1000 times more of a Bully than James Potter and Sirius Black, he used Dark Magic that he was obsessed with on other people along with his Death Eater Pals at School, James and Sirius matured and never used the shit that Snape used on other people...they were better than him! 3. Dumbledore was in love with Grindelwald, so I have read, and he was blinded by that as well as his anger and bitterness for being trapped at home, his words, and he didn't know Grindelwald would actually do all this! 4. Snape was a bullying and malicious little slimeball who was obsessed with the Dark Arts, he should've gone to Durmstang for that, and he would not mind his own business....where Remus went was none of his business and Sirius had to teach him a lesson for that! James saved Snape's worthless life when he could have let him die...proving just how much of a better-man he is than Snape! 5. Snape called Lily, his so called friend, a Mudblood for trying to help him...he deserved what he got after that! 6. Malfoy was a nasty little shit who bullied and tormented Students for years, he also nearly murdered Ron Weasley and Katie Bell, and here's the big one....he was gonna use one of the 3 Unforgiveable Curses on Harry....he deserved the pain he got when Harry used that Curse on him! Wormtail however, we all now he is pure evil and deserved what he got anyway!!!!!!
James potter and Sirius black are a pack of evil vicious bullies who Tortured a poor Half blood just because of looks and status! Severus snape was not obsessed with other people that’s horrible, I can’t believe you’re justifying the veracity of horrible bullying! No wonder Severus has to invent curses and hexes to get back at those monsters! I’m in Slyhterin and a woman we snakes look after our family!
If bullying is such a major problem in muggle schools then I’m almost certain it’s 10x worse in wizarding schools and the professors do next to nothing to stop it
Overlooked part of how screwed up of what Sirius did was that he didn't ask Remus for permission. If he had, we all know Remus DEFINITELY would NOT have agreed, meaning Sirius was basically forcing one of his best friends to KILL someone.
Nah Hermione holding Rita Skeeter hostage is based. She could've easily squashed her in beetle form and no one would be the wiser on how she went missing. Evil would be if Rita Skeeter was an innocent bystander being held captive but she was stirring up shit all year. Same with the sneak jinx. That goes hard. Marietta was not innocent after snitching and thus it is not evil. To say otherwise for either is just disingenuous.
MF stands for most fantastic (who agrees) Also SOOO close to 2 mil! Congrats and 50% of my Harry Potter knowledge comes from you. Keep YouTubing Morgan!
I thought half of those would be by Peter Pettigrew. IMHO, 2 more by Pettigrew could be added to the list: killing Cedric Diggory and bringing Lord Voldemort back.
Rita Skeeter is one of the worse in HP universe, horrendous living creature who writes lies and slanders which destroy other people lives, so - she is not a human and there is nothing wrong with what Hermione did.
Before even watching the video I can tell Peter Petigrew selling out Harry's parents gonna be here, also Harry using the Sectumsempra on Malfoy, kinda evil. He used a spell not know what it would do, despite Hermione, repeatedly telling him not to!
I feel like Romilda attempting to spike Harry (actually spiking Ron) with a love potion fits well here.
Yeah, it did end up with him being poisoned. (Read book 6)
@@dgg74890 true, but that part really isn't Romilda's fault.
@@dgg74890 that was Malfoy trying to kill Dumbledore that wasn’t Romilda’s fault
It definitely fits,also the Weasley twins actually selling said love potions
@@dgg74890 That was kind of a chain reaction
Next you should do good things done by Slytherin characters, dumb things done by Ravenclaw characters, and disloyal things done by Hufflepuff characters.
Slytherin: slughorn in the deathly hallows, fighting in the battle of hogwarts
Ravenclaw: Marietta Edgecombe snitching
Hufflepuff: zachariah smith in the DA meeting and running as fast as he could in the deathly hallows
@@Sigma-D-Evanyou could also say everything Lockhart has done for Ravenclaw
@@xnet_cascade6257true that
I don't think that would make a long video lmao
Regulus black finding and trying to destroy one of Voldemorts horcruxes
I'd say Hermione's jinx on Marietta Edgecomb is worse than she imprisonning Rita Skeeter
At least Rita was let out days after
But Marietta has to live with horrible facial scaring for the rest of her life
Snitches get pimples! 😂
@@ashleyhannigan505 Yeah
Snape was also a traitor and a snitch, just to the deatheaters
Yet, people don't use that against him
Deserved imo
@@ilphi08 I mean, he would also deserve it, being honest.
@@ilphi08 I do. I'm never going to be a fan of Snape. Yes he was bullied. Yes I feel for him about that. But, he's worse than his bullies. He joined the death eaters and he also turned around and bullied children while he was an adult.
Glad I got here early!
This video reminds me of what Sirius Black said in the fifth book, Order of the Phoenix, "The world isn't split into good people and Death Eaters. We've all got both light and darkness inside us. What matters is the part we choose to act on. That's who we really are."
dumbledore, "it is our choices harry that show who we truly are far more than our abilities"
You only got half the evil of Sirius's sending Snape to meet the werewolf. Remus would never have forgiven himself if he ever infected anyone else ... I think Remus believed tha Sirius was guilty of betraying James because he felt that Sirius had betrayed him by using him in such a way.
Remus should have been in Hufflepuff. He was too good for Gryfendor.
Yea so it wasn't just an evil act towards another student but a betrayal of one his best friends (from the guy who said he "would rather die than betray his friends")
That's a really interesting inside I hadn't thought of. I think you're right, it makes sense that lupine would have been convinced that serious betrayed James if you felt like serious had betrayed him years later by trying to use him to kill snape.
@@corywalker8551 It was siriusly evil of him to send Snape to his death, but I don't think he thought it through if he had realised it would hurt Remus so much he wouldn't have done that.
He did do really bad things but he would never betray his friends.
1:01 Hermione locking up Rita Skeeter wasn’t that bad, considering that Rita Skeeter literally humiliated her in front of the wizarding community
Also, considering that the penalty for failing to register as an animagus was an Azkaban sentence, this was not as bad
And she was only 14 or 15
i see the point, but that is still like taking someone captive.
Still, it's a human😭 and that's why it's number 1 tho. He always saves the best (or worst in this case) for the last
@@farhanara17 Technically its a beetle lol
I’ll never understand why Peter Petigrew was Gryffindor. He was cowardly when bravery is the house’s whole point
J.K. and her one-dimensional writing: Gryffindor - heroes (and friends of heroes), Slytherins- villains
Because it's more about what he values than what he character is
He was a coward but he did value bravery, just other people's bravery, he always made sure he was around brave and powerful people who can keep him safe because that's the only thing he cares about
Peter was a cowardly b************^*! lol
Pettigrew might have been brave at eleven when he got shorted and grew more cowardly as he got older, especially when the first war started to get worse. Or maybe he somehow talked the hat into pointing him in Gryffindor, like Harry talked the hat out of putting him in Slytherin.
5:38 1 Draco was trying to Use an unforgivable curse on him 2 he didn't make the conscious decision he said the first spell that came to his mind
still isn’t justified
@@konakoalaI would argue it probably is justifiable but not condonable. It’s not the first spell that he should have thought of, something like protego or simply even ducking out of the way would have been better.
@konakoala not saying that it is, but there's a difference between intentionally trying to slice him open, and using the first spell that comes to mind in a high stress situation like someone trying to torture you
Harry also didn't know yet what that spell did, which makes it stupid for him to have tried it, but as you said, it was the first thing that came to his mind. Harry wasn't thinking clearly and felt bad once he realized what he had done.
Sirius treating Kreacher badly all through his life is an evil act in itself, resulting in Kreacher to conceal information about the RAB locket, until Hermione treated him well in HP7. Thus he opened up and the trio got to know about Regulus Black's heroic act and sacrifice. Had Sirius treated Kreacher better, the secret of horcuxes would have been revealed by book 5 and the locket should not have ended with umbridge.
Good point.
Sirius's treatment of Kreacher is definitely a fair point but it's also important to remember that Kreacher has very likely mistreated Sirius when the latter was but a child, based on everything we know about Walburga and her influence over Kreacher. He was also a constant reminder of his parents, the Black Pureblood mania and the life he left behind.
It's a complicated situation, especially when you consider that Sirius was essentially still a very young man suffering from severe trauma and depression, so I disagree that it's "an evil act in itself".
You should do good acts done by Slytherin next.
BTW how was NYCC
Yes! To both btw would love to know
Some examples:
Snape dedicating himself to protect Harry
Snape protecting the students of Hogwarts after Dumbledore's death
Snape switching sides and becoming a triple agent
Snape giving the key to destroying Voldemort
Slughorn giving Harry the memory
Slughorn fighting in the Battle of Hogwarts
Narcissa lying to Voldemort
Regulus betraying Voldemort
Draco lying to Bellatrix
Something Merlin or some other extra lore character did
The intro never gets old :)
A lot of these I feel are more "morally grey" than specifcally evil. Pettigrew and the various bullying were definitely evil though
And I would put Hermione keeping Skeeter in a jar, “morally grey” since Skeeter’s articles did cause Hermione to get hate mail, some of which, caused Hermione to get hurt.
Definitely not the Fred and George thing
That awkward moment when you realize some well known Gryffindors border on being sociopaths.
I think that overall is like this-Slytherin complete bad, Huffepuff complete good. And the other 2 between them. But because Griffindor and Slytherin(the founders) were best friends, maybe that means Griffindor are closer to the evil side. And that puts Ravenclaw close to the good side. That's how I have interpreted it.
Rita deserved what Hermione gave her. Ginny was in a trance 😵💫 then. #1 is certainly the worst. I don’t think Hufflepuff have 10 evil acts. If ever since no house is perfect, maybe 3.
“It’s just a prank bro”
The prank:
Weasley twins in a nutshell
While it was a bad idea, in Harry's defense, he did not know what the spell did, and he was acting in self-defense. You don't always have time to think in those situations.
Here’s an idea for a Halloween Special: Rank the 15 scariest HP book scenes like for example the graveyard scene in the Goblet of Fire
great idea
That is the scariest/darkest part of the entire series. The cave full of Inferi is also up there on that list 😂
2:40 i think what is most shocking is in the books we are from Harry's POV. so we are lead to beeive that James was a heroic student who never did anything wrong (and its Harry dad so there is bias) byut we are shocked when we learned how what Snape said about James might have been hate driven but not completely untrue.
Even from hero's perspective, I always thought of James as shady person. Somehow, just the words he used for Snape are not normal for a 'hero'. And then, when we saw Snape perspective, I already realised James was a duche.
I hate how Slytherin is seen as this evil house and Gryffindoor is the pride and joy of Hogwarts. Dumbledoor was clearly bias with the house cub each year.
There are memes bout that
Your're partially right. But to be fair Slytherins do a lot of evil and the other Slytherins either stay aside or profit from it. And while Dumbledore showed his bias at the end of book 1, Snape was showing his bias every single day.
@@Kubinda12345Dumbledore showed his bias by not expelling Sirius who could have gotten another student killed. Dude Dumbledore was incredibly biased and especially during the most important moments and while Snape was definitely biased he was only super cruel to Harry, Neville, and Hermoine (which is still horrible and bad and an unfair use of power) but we never saw him be that bad to other students from other houses
Morgan has been posting amazing videos for about 7 years, Massive Respect to this guy.
2:50 the sad part is more then likely James was just flexing and being popular (and it being funny to the crowd) is more then likely why he bullied Snape (who was unpopular and a relatively easy target) then any real reason why he picked on Snape in particular.
It's said in the books he picked on Snape because he was into the dark arts, and because he was Slytherin I think, not a good reason to bully someone, especially that badly, and to be honest I personally think Snape was James’ main target because of jealousy, James had a crush on Lily, but at that time she couldn't stand him, because of the way he acted, but yet was friends with Snape, I think that made James a bit jealous and he took it out on Snape.
@@saphiramystique2086No it was never mentioned in the book that James did not like Snape coz of dark arts. James hated him from their first school train to Hogwarts just coz Snape expressed desire to be in Slytherin.
James bullied Snape coz he was unpopular and was an easy target. Please stop trying to cover James evil actions by making up things that were NOT in the book. James was no different from Malfoy minus the racism. But Malfoy grew up in a death eaters family but James was not. He was just a spoiled, entitled and pampered brat!
Absolutely not if it is why don't he bully the rich ones the reasons James bullied Snape is because:
-he exist (from being poor and ugly)
-he was an easy target
-he was jealous of his closeness with lily
So Snape being into the dark arts is not the reason why the kid just bully because he can
@@alesonu "Please stop trying to cover James evil actions" But it's okay to sugarcoat Snape's actions, right?
James bullying Snape during their first encounter doesn't mean that his tendencies didn't play a role in their interactions going forward.
We have several quotes from multiple people, including Lily herself, pretty much confirming that teenaged Snape was very engrossed in the dark arts and generally a nasty person who surrounded himself with future Death Eaters, thought it was a laugh to torment Muggleborns with dark magic and went around calling people Mudblood despite his "best friend" being Muggle-born. And even as a teenager he was already set on joining a terrorist group which, among other things, existed with the purpose of subjugating Muggle-borns.
Lupin also confirmed that Snape and James brought out the worst in each other and never missed an opportunity to curse the other. The whole situation wasn't as one-sided as a lot of Snape stans always make it out to be.
James was wrong to bully Snape to the extent he did but Snape's behaviour is objectively and unconditionally much worse, we simply didn't witness it first-hand.
Don’t he become a better person later though
The jinx on the sign up sheet was basically like the death note
I despise Pettigrew beyond everything as it was his fault about everything that little betraying scum. If Harry just let Remus and Sirius kill him…
These soldiers would still be alive
-Fred
-Sirius
-Cedric
-Remus
-Tonks
-Dumbledore
-Dobby
-Mad-eye
-Snape
-Colin
And more notable soldiers😢🫡
Literally😢
😢💔🫡
o7
And Colin Creevey
@@lockydocky just added that now😢
You should make a list exlusively about the evil/sketchy things Dumbledore did.
He raised Harry to die, left him at his abusive aunts, the whole grindenwald thing. Him not wanting to reach out to the wizarding world when the chamber was opened to keep his job, so he needlessly let several students remain petrified ( I doubt there wasnt a single adult mandrake in the whole of the UK), also him basically keeping Snape as a subordinate/slave for 17 years, not speaking to Harry at all about his connection to voldemort or giving him any advice on horcruxes.
These are just the ones off the top of my head but im sure there are more to be found
Also, isolating Harry from everyone else, leaving him defenseless against Voldemort's mind tricks.
I would probably add the fact that he allowed Snape to teach at Hogwarts when he knew that Snape was bullying students. He allowed him to abuse his authority, just so he could keep him as a spy. Disgusting.
Also, I couldn't help noticing how Dumbledore would befriend people such as Hagrid, McGonagle, Remus Lupin and others in order so he could have leverage over them and manipulate them into doing his bidding. The more I think about it, the more I can see how Dumbledore would come alongside people who were either outcasts or going through a difficult time under the guise of "helping" or "comforting"them, but only so that he could gain leverage over them in order to manipulate them into doing his bidding and obeying him without question.
“raised Harry to die” yeah ok. 🤦🏻♀️
@@milanka882 yes, hes pretty manipulative and flawed in his methods. If he wasnt using these people to defeat voldemort he would have been a pretty terrible villain. Literally using everyone in every possible way to reach his goals. It just happens that his ultimate goal was the defeat of voldemort
@@meatrubber pretty much, snape says so in the princes tale. Dumbledore didnt know Harry could survive the whole thing until the end of book 4, up until that point he was a sacrifice in Dumbledores eyes
Also its my oppinion that the only reason he gave harry the stone of resurrection to give him the final push to sacrifice himself as the ultimate goal of the Stone is to pursuade the owner if used to suicide as we have seen in the tale of the 3 brothers and the same with Harry, all the projections of his loved ones wanted him to die and encouraged him to do so
I don't consider Ginny opening the Chamber as "evil", considering that (1) she had NO idea what she was doing at the time, & (2) she was just an 11 year-old girl writing in a diary.
Ginny one I don't think should be here. She was like hypnotised. She didn't even remember what she was doing.
Harry's Sectumsempra spell, though I don't approve of him using an unknown spell on someone who is not even a true enemy, I would still say Harry was not aware. I doubt he ever thought the spell could kill someone. He was horrified at what he had done. So, I don't find that evil.
Other all I agree esp Sirius, Peter Pettigrew and James
Especially since both Ginny and Harry have the benefit of remorse after realizing what they both did, with them both being devastated at causing such harm to others without even realizing it in their respective situations.
I’d also add Harry using the Cruciatus curse twice (on Bellatrix and on Carrow).
Also, Wormtail killing Cedric, Hagrid putting a literal pig tail on Dudley and not caring to remove it (after all… it is an adult wizard attacking an 11 yo muggle - also, assuming Hagrid was in Griffindor) and Dumbledore hiring Lockhart for the DADA position knowing about its curse just to get rid of him.
I don’t know who carrow is is because i haven’t read the books but Harry torturing Bellatrix was fair
Morgan likes Harry Potter, Star Wars, Marvel, and is an eagles fan. We would be so good friends.
1. Harry was being attacked by Draco and Draco was trying to cause him real harm. Whatever spell he cast besides an unforgivable was fair game. It was self defense.
2. Everybody ignores the fact that Herminoe erased her own parents' memories of her and the magical world. She took it upon herself to force them into leaving the country and took away their freedom. That's the most evil thing she did IMO.
I know this isn’t an “evil” act, but I felt it was fair to mention Harry and Ron taking Arthur Weasley’s Ford Anglia to fly to Hogwarts after missing the train. The reason being that not only did they steal a family car, but their actions got Arthur in huge trouble with the Ministry of Magic because Harry and Ron were seen by muggles while flying the car, which wasn’t meant to be enchanted to fly in the first place.
Next should be Acts of Good by Slytherin characters (since Slytherin was seen as the evil house), followed by Acts of Stupidity by Ravenclaw characters. Don't really know what to do for Hufflepuff characters, though.
With hufflepuffs would be unloyal actions.
Although, it maybe a little difficult because there are not many characters from hufflepuff, but Morgan would fine some despicable actions
Honestly the tow hermione ones are both debateable since she had reasons for both that were pretty just. Rita being a bitch and being a illegal animagus and spying on harry and the others. And the sneak one being revenge for ratting out the DA to fucking umbridge.
I just know that rat pettigrew is gonna be on here
No one is truly evil or truly holy besides voldemort who was formed from evil
Hem hem Dolores
Bellatrix and Greyback come pretty darn close
@@TheLazyFusspot_3428 I’m sorry do you need a cough sweet
@@supermilesio5035 yes but their evil was brought mostly out from Voldemort
“The world is not split into good people and death eaters.” -Sirius Black
Good Job! You're Videos Are So Entertaining!
Wouldn’t say any of these are evil except the 2 abt pettigrew. Most are just bad decisions. I’ve always thought your opinions on the series to be pretty good and reasonable but this has drastically changed my mind
Wow amazing vid as always!❤ Also how was NYYC
It’s not where you are placed in Hogwarts. It’s what you CHOOSE to do with your talents and free will,
I feel like calling wormtail’s mass-murder evil is giving him too much credit. It makes it sound like he did it for fun or just because he could. The real reason he did it wasn’t because he’s evil but because he’s a coward. It wasn’t evil, it was pathetic cowardice.
When it comes to James & Lily’s relationship, I’ll never understand it. He was a literal bully & he did sh*t that was unforgivable, yet Lily still got with him despite knowing how horrible of a person he was. Not only that, but James literally bullied her friend (Snape). There was no excuse for her, even getting with him from the start. He was a bully in & out along with his friends. I don’t wanna hear the argument “well Snape called Lily a mud-blood,” like okay??? So, that makes it okay for her to get with someone who tormented him throughout his entire school years? Don’t get me wrong if they haven’t gotten together then Harry wouldn’t have been born, but be so frill now.
Note: I feel like unless you’ve been bullied yourself then you know the type of trauma & mental scars that actually leaves. That’s probably why it just p*sses me off so much.
One of the reasons why Lily ended up falling for James is because she admired how he stood up for people who were being mistreated by Slytherin students.
Even both of Lily's parents (especially her mother) loved James and they preferred James a lot more than they did Vernon, causing Petunia to resent Lily even more.
You should make this a series like Slytherin’s nicest moments and Ravenclaw stupidest
Yes!
And Hufflepuff's jerkiest moments (because i don't remember any Hufflepuff being truly evil except Cedric in the book that shall not be named)
Or rabeclaws dumbest moments
Being a Gryffonder/brave does not mean that somebody is a good person.
Pretty sure that's exactly the point of this video
Why does everyone always forget that Draco was about to use the Cruciatus curse on Harry in the bathroom? He got what he deserved, plain and simple.
Two wrongs doesn't make it right.
@@natalietaylor1579 that doesn’t apply here lol. That was self defense. The alternative is Harry being tortured.
@@williamreynolds3487 Self defense or not, it still doesn’t make it right to use a spell to try to murder a student. I see your point that Draco was trying to use an Unforgivable spell, but it still doesn’t give Harry an excuse to use a dangerous spell that can kill an opponent without knowing its effects. Harry could’ve disarmed him or stupefied Draco. Again, two wrongs don’t make a right.
@ it absolutely does.
@@williamreynolds3487 okay, whatever, you say.
Excuse me, she held Rita Skeeter prison for a good reason
Having forgotten that Wormtail killed 12 Muggles, I thought his joining the Death Eaters would be #1... Anyway, now I would love to see a video about heroic acts committed by Slytherin characters!
Thank you for another great video! ❤
It’s crazy that I’m in the house of the headmaster that cared the least about the kids….. (BTW Pettigrew is an ass hole, ratting out your best friends, to die, for your own personal gain is crazy)
Bro this guy read the whole series like 10 times I’m still on number 4😭😭😭
I'm on book 5
I would love to see a video where you go over and tell us what moments in the HP books/movies you wish would have gone another way. Like Ron agreeing with Snape about Hermione or Harry saying "but I am the chosen one." It would be interesting to know what you would rather the characters did or said differently.
Yassss another video I was waiting forever
Percy going against his family...
You should do things like Unloyal Things Hufflepuffs Did or Good Things Slytherins Did
Slytherin ideologies at their best: Seeking to help reach other people's ambitions.
Slytherin ideologies at their worst: Seeking to achieve things even if that means stepping on other people.
Ravenclaw ideologies at their best: Seeking wisdoms and sharing the knowledge.
Ravenclaw ideologies at their worst: Overachieving to the point of either burning out or trying to appear smarter to feel accepted.
Hufflepuff ideologies at their best: Seeking to help friends and teammates in the need of it.
Hufflepuff ideologies at their worst: Naively helping supporting a group like yes-men even if it's toxic.
Gryffindoor ideologies at their best: Taking the steps to help where other people were too scared to do so.
Gryffindoor ideologies at their worst: Recklessly challenging themselves and others and endangering people in the process.
Peter Pettigrew was almost sorted into Slytherin, since his cunning and sly nature was evident, yet the Sorting Hat chose to place him in Gryffindor, which even it admitted was a poor choice.
Why though
Slytherin is not the most “ evil” house in Hogwarts that is stereotyped! That is like saying all Gryffindors are truly great and hero’s they are not! PETTYGREW IS A SAMPLE OF THAT!
Not to mention this about number 1:
As far as Peter Pettigrew knew, he set up Sirius to spend the rest of his life in Azkaban. While I whould still argue that working for Voldemort and killng 12 muggles is Peter's most evil act;
Spending the last years of your life traped in a cell, unable to feal joy, with no hope of ever getting out is (in my opinion) worse than being killed
Finally, a vid like this for Gryffindor.
With the Montague situation I remember Draco talking about it the Half Blood Prince but I can't remember it in the Order f the Phenix despite me reading the books like 100 times
It was after Umbitch became headmistress
I don't think Ginny counts. She was possessed by Tom Riddle. She blacked out when she did it, and had no idea that she was doing it.
Snape's worst memory is more evil than the twins or Harry's joke because James did it on purpose. To me, James is a bad person
Then try telling that to JK Rowling who loves James Potter and favours him all the time.
He is a bad person that saw the errors of his ways eventually.
Unfortunately, he just didn’t have enough time left to do more good than bad.
I think a part of him regretted his actions to some degree, but will never know because of, again, the fact that his life was cut short, and the books never bothered to explore his thoughts in dept after that point.
@@paulyb7267 And the Marauders apologists who'll jump through hoops to act like they were good people
Marauders weren't perefect. Just like Snape and Dumbledore.
Snape, James and Sirius each did messed up things. That doesn't stop later on helping others and doing heroic actions.
Sirius being the role model he needed at the time.
James saving Snape and being there for Remus.
Snape protecting harry, despite his prejudice and bullying he did as a teacher.
So he was being a douchey teenager?
Rita deserved we she got, I would've just squashed the bug and pretended I didn't know it was a person. And Marietta kinda deserved that, maybe not forever but for a bit. So did Montique. And Malfoy tried to use crucio on Harry, knowing what it does.
This is the perfect topic of discussion! I am rather impressed with myself; I knew every evil act except one.
Ginny said it best:it looks as if Malfoy was trying to curse him we're lucky Harry had something good up his sleeve 5:29
Yeah and Harry was the only who pointed out that Draco was a deathearer and no one believed it
@movieflame may you please make a what each character would see if they drank the potion in the cave (the one Dumbledore and regulus drank) thanks
Great idea!
*Dont forget the brave Kreacher
"the movies made Hermione out to be this perfect character" in the movies, I only saw Hermione's flaws. At least in the books she is somewhat relatable and likeable. She may have been a know it all in the books but she was a know it all with a heart. In the movies she is just unbearably annoying.
This list needed Fred and George selling love potions. These are basically a date rape potion and they’re selling it to high school kids.
yeah
love potions are dangerous
I love how when i saw evil and Gryffindor in the same sentence i immediately thought wormtail
5. Yes, what Harry did was extreme. But Draco attacked first and used Cruciatus on Harry. So if it was investigated, he would've been in much bigger trouble than Harry.
4. Sirius acted stupidly but Snape was pretty convinced that Lupin was a werewolf and listening to a known enemy (= Sirius) was pretty stupid on Snape's part.
2. Peter not only betrayed Lily and James but was a spy in the Order for an entire year which I imagine caused a lot of damage possibly even deaths amongs the Order members.
I discovered you a couple weeks ago and I think this is the first video I’ve seen that is new. Good stuff!
James was a bigger Bully than Malfoy by far. Malfoy had some hurtful insults at the trio over the years, but it never resorted to this, unless sometimes they were equally dueling each other. Draco being recruited by Voldemort changed things, but Draco in books 1-5 was much better than James. This is only one moment of James and Sirius being bullies. Imagine all the other unseen times
Absolutely bullshit. You know, comments like yours make me realize that perhaps it will be much better if there was a prequel centred around James Potter being the main/central character in a story about either the Potter family or the Marauders under James's POV. Maybe that way, it will shut up haters like you for good!
U seem to forget or ignore these facts:
A. Although Hermionie was an insufferable girl who would never listen and aways assumed she was right, like when she kept insulting the House Elves at Hogwarts with tricking them I into being freed and wasn't even punished for it, Reeta Skeeter was an absolutely evil-woman who ruined so many lives...she deserved what she got!
2. Snape was 1000 times more of a Bully than James Potter and Sirius Black, he used Dark Magic that he was obsessed with on other people along with his Death Eater Pals at School, James and Sirius matured and never used the shit that Snape used on other people...they were better than him!
3. Dumbledore was in love with Grindelwald, so I have read, and he was blinded by that as well as his anger and bitterness for being trapped at home, his words, and he didn't know Grindelwald would actually do all this!
4. Snape was a bullying and malicious little slimeball who was obsessed with the Dark Arts, he should've gone to Durmstang for that, and he would not mind his own business....where Remus went was none of his business and Sirius had to teach him a lesson for that! James saved Snape's worthless life when he could have let him die...proving just how much of a better-man he is than Snape!
5. Snape called Lily, his so called friend, a Mudblood for trying to help him...he deserved what he got after that!
6. Malfoy was a nasty little shit who bullied and tormented Students for years, he also nearly murdered Ron Weasley and Katie Bell, and here's the big one....he was gonna use one of the 3 Unforgiveable Curses on Harry....he deserved the pain he got when Harry used that Curse on him!
Wormtail however, we all now he is pure evil and deserved what he got anyway!!!!!!
So you're basically excusing the behavior of James for bullying Snape? Sounds like you're a classic Gryffindor without deep context.
James potter and Sirius black are a pack of evil vicious bullies who Tortured a poor Half blood just because of looks and status! Severus snape was not obsessed with other people that’s horrible, I can’t believe you’re justifying the veracity of horrible bullying! No wonder Severus has to invent curses and hexes to get back at those monsters! I’m in Slyhterin and a woman we snakes look after our family!
If bullying is such a major problem in muggle schools then I’m almost certain it’s 10x worse in wizarding schools and the professors do next to nothing to stop it
Honourable mention to the Twins trying to get Ron to do an Unbreakable Vow!
Maybe you should do dumb acts by Raveclaws, though it'll be most likely be Lockhart
Great video mate
Overlooked part of how screwed up of what Sirius did was that he didn't ask Remus for permission. If he had, we all know Remus DEFINITELY would NOT have agreed, meaning Sirius was basically forcing one of his best friends to KILL someone.
Pure evil act right their!
Great video and you look really good 😊
Also montuge probably wet himself due to fact there was no toilet in the vanishing cabinet
now to be fair to harry, the sectumsempra was done in self defense bc malfoy had tried to crucio harry
I thought Merrietta had red curly hair? Who’s this blonde girl?? 1:48
Nah Hermione holding Rita Skeeter hostage is based. She could've easily squashed her in beetle form and no one would be the wiser on how she went missing. Evil would be if Rita Skeeter was an innocent bystander being held captive but she was stirring up shit all year. Same with the sneak jinx. That goes hard. Marietta was not innocent after snitching and thus it is not evil. To say otherwise for either is just disingenuous.
Under 20 minutes keep up the good work Morgan 🧡🧡🧡🧡🧡🧡🧡🧡🧡
Umbridge is freaking the example of evil. She tortured Harry for no absolute reason !
James Potter and the Mauraders were bullies. Plain and simple. James specifically was an arrogant toe-rag
Exactly.
evil and monsters is what they were!
This is wonderful
Once again Morgan gives us an interesting topic
This video was so good ❤ I always appreciate your thoughtful analysis and witty. commentary I just wish it was a touch longer!
How many evil hufflepuffs are there Hufflepuff's hufflepuff's 😁
First been watching u for ages❤
You should do a similar video where you go through the opposite. Ten good acts commited by Slitherins
MF stands for most fantastic (who agrees) Also SOOO close to 2 mil! Congrats and 50% of my Harry Potter knowledge comes from you. Keep YouTubing Morgan!
Yep and Morgan deserves all those subs
Morgan aqui casual sacando los trapitos de Gryffindor al aire hahaha
OMG IVE NEVER BEEN LESS THAN A DAY EARLY AND IM FIVE MINUTES EARLY?!
Honestly Peter Pettigrew should’ve been a Slytherin and not a Gryffindor
Well, Harry only used sectumsepera because Malfoy was about ti use crucio which is a unforgivable curse so I'd say its self defense
I thought half of those would be by Peter Pettigrew. IMHO, 2 more by Pettigrew could be added to the list: killing Cedric Diggory and bringing Lord Voldemort back.
i love Hermione but she can be sadistic AF 😅
I think the Ginny one 2as was Harsh but I understand why you pit it in
babe, you forgot to wake me up when MovieFlame posted😡
(i still binge watch all of your HP videos lol)
Rita Skeeter is one of the worse in HP universe, horrendous living creature who writes lies and slanders which destroy other people lives, so - she is not a human and there is nothing wrong with what Hermione did.
Before even watching the video I can tell Peter Petigrew selling out Harry's parents gonna be here, also Harry using the Sectumsempra on Malfoy, kinda evil. He used a spell not know what it would do, despite Hermione, repeatedly telling him not to!