Who Could See Thestrals by the End of the Series? (How Many People Witnessed Death?)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 15 чер 2024
- Check out this great offer from Displate: displate.com/movieflame
Use Discount Code: MOVIEFLAME
Buy 1-2 Displates to get 22% off & Buy 3+ Displates to get 33% off.
Patreon: / overview
Twitter: / movieflameprod
Personal Instagram: / morgan_ross18
TikTok: www.tiktok.com/@movieflamemor...
Facebook: / movieflame
Music By : Tom J. Harding tomjharding...
Music By: / @bail_bonds
Fanart:
3 way duel that kill Arianna Dumbledore: www.deviantart.com/lucy--c/ar...
Voldemort killing Hepzibah: Fan Film Voldemort Origins of the Heir: • Voldemort: Origins of ...
Regulus Black: www.wizardingworld.com/featur...
Pandora Lovegood: www.deviantart.com/celebratey...
Ted Tonks: www.deviantart.com/iriusabell...
Charlie Weasley: clairee-delunee.tumblr.com/po...
Chapters:
0:00 Intro
2:28 Hogwarts Legacy
3:56 Before the 7 Books
9:05 Fantastic Beasts
10:33 The Main Series
20:04 The Cursed Child - Фільми й анімація
Check out this great offer from Displate: displate.com/movieflame
Use Discount Code: MOVIEFLAME
Buy 1-2 Displates to get 22% off & Buy 3+ Displates to get 33% off.
Gotta love those sturdy paintings
Can you do a video about Nicolas Flamel? 🙂❤
My brain has been melted, this video has been posted 3 hours ago, but your comment was sent 3 DAYS AGO?!
this video has been posted 3 hour afo its says three days ago
hi morgan is voldermort a ghost i mean his whole life was based on avoding it so is he
Bro if we had HP tests in school this guy would be the new Hermione
Yay 100th like and first reply!
@@LWZach tysm
I’m an expert on Harry Potter
@@Lilly6900yw
HAHHA FR
It makes more sense for Harry to not see thestrals in the books than the films, at least prior to Cedric's death. In the book of Philosopher's/Sorcerer's Stone, he passed out before seeing Quirrell die, whereas in the film, he clearly sees him die, so he should have seen the thestrals afterwards.
You forgot uhm his parents
I agree honestly since if we are going with book logic then yeah he didn't see Quirrell die since he passed out (and was told later that Quirrell died) where as in the film logic (since the films did change things) he did see both Quirrell and Cedric died (so likely saw the thestrals from both of them since with his parents he was too young) so technically speaking in both forms he could of saw them sooner (depending which media you want to use)
Not to mention he was right there when Voldemort killed Lilly. This should be a universal rule independent of if the person has memory or self awareness, if someone died within your field of vision, it should count.
@@Akatsukileader9but again, I think this is more a movie thing than a book thing. It’s been a while, but I don’t know if the book explicitly says Harry was facing and looking at Lily when she’s killed. He’s in the room, but as he was a very young toddler (15 months old), he may not have been looking in her direction. Yes, it’s a cop-out as to why he didn’t see thestrals since Day 1 at Hogwarts (or at least by his third year when he took the horseless carriages), and I’m not saying it’s right, but as a mom of three, it’s true that young toddlers aren’t always looking at the direction of the most action. Still, Harry should have seen the thestrals after Cedric’s death. There’s no reason for them to wait to appear to him in Year Five other than the author didn’t have it fully planned, or at least didn’t plan it well enough.
I think Harry had his eyes closed when cedric died🤨
The DEDICATION morgan puts into these videos is just amazing,
Yes! There’s so many different rabbit holes to fall into in Harry Potter lore
I love how Morgan is slowly turning into James Potter, video after video.
This got a good chuckle out of me😆
I see what you mean 😄
Well i can see that.
I mean, he did get his Lily
I didn't get it pls explain 👀
I love how Morgan (not so) aggresively explained about the book cannon and the movie cannon Crabbe, Goyle and Blaise issue lmao
"blaise"
@@timmy3.0 😅
Pretty sure Dumbledore wasn't worried about splitting Snape's soul because it wasn't going to be an act of malice, and would therefore not split his soul.
Yeah, it was a merciful death before the curse on the ring gets the chance to give him much more painful death.
Yeah, it was more like putting a pet down. It, like the reply above me said, was a mercy kill, so Snape's soul was safe.
There's also an argument that Snape was an adult whose life was already irreparably destroyed by the loss of Lily, while Draco was still a kid with his whole life ahead of him.
i think Snape had to kill in the first place in order to be take the dark mark tho i'm not sure this is confirmed anywhere
@@AlexB-vt5xeAs a death eater I would assume he killed A LOT in general before Lily’s death
I like to think the "let it sink in" as in Harry was still in heavy denial, not accepting Cedric had died.
I would argue that a ghost may or may not be able to see thestrals, at least when it comes to their own death: you must witness it and then come to terms with/accept it, but a ghost is made when a witch or wizard can not accept death and remain. I'd say it could go either way.
I think since thestrals and ghosts are one and the same in death, they can likely see each other.
that's interesting because there are loads of ghosts in Hogwarts. so it would make sense for ghosts to see Thestrals.
That brings up an interesting brain teaser if being able to see Thestrals is dependent on “seeing” death and Hogwarts is full of ghosts shouldn’t most of the students and staff already be able to see Thestrals if they hadn’t before they came to school since ghosts are one of the few physical remnants of death that exist in the Wizarding world?
@@krisynthiagomez5883 they didn't witness the deaths. You have to see it happen, and your brain has to process and realize somebody died in front of you. Otherwise, almost everybody who attends a funeral would see thestrals.
Question: What if you believe someone died right in front of you without actually dying? If you never find out that this person is actually alive, would you still be able to see thestrals then?
Answer: Well I think that must count. You will possibly able to see Thestrals if the thought of a person's death has been accepted by you. The reason is--- Harry denied Cedric's death at the end of book 4 and he could not see at that point(Rowling confirmed this)
So.........If a person cannot see thestrals because he or she denied it even if he or she saw it, the opposite can also happen i.e. A person CAN see thestrals if they accepeted the death of a person though he or she is not dead
I just love your videos about the HP universe. Hope many more new videos are on the way.
For J.K Rowling's explanations, the one about Harry being a baby makes sense. As for the second one, I think it's that Harry COULD see them at the end of his 4th year, but he didn't give it any mind at the time because he was too preoccupied with not just Cedric's death but also Voldemort's return.
As the late Queen of England used to say to unsuspecting tourists asking if she knew the Queen; she had never met the Queen, but her bodyguard knew her quite well. I support the idea that you cannot witness your own death.
Just to pause the vid real quick and say I haven't played the game and don't want spoilers, so I just appreciate you work man. Leaving a like.
There are chapters that allow you to skip over the game
@@MovieFlame oh hell yeah! Thank you for reminding me this xD I truly wanted to see what's up
I Would also say, That even though 2 of the three Peverell brother litterally Saw someone die, they all three encountered “DEATH” and were therefore allowed to see thestrals. Love the video and love the Content, i love being able to Watch Your videos and getting the stories of the books from you, for someone who doesnt like Reading books much🙏🏻🙏🏻❤️
You could argue that Frank and Alice Longbottom might have witnessed someone die during their careers as aurors, but that would just be speculation, so I agree with not putting it in as canon
Most Aurors can see Thestrals. Unless you just started out as an Auror, you'd have had to kill in self defense. Comes with the job
Like Sense Fabian And Gideon Who Is Molly Weasleys Brothers Who Died In The 1st Order Of The Phoenix Battle
@@wolverineisdaman "might have witnessed someone die during their careers as aurors, but that would just be speculation" yeah he knows. Did you even read what you responded to?
yay another video! i just feel like everyvideo is better than the other! you are helping me in dark times morgan! it really dose make me happy when i see an upload
The amount of effort u put into these videos is amazing!
this has been my favorite channel since covid i use to spend all my time watching you hp videos cause i am a huge fan
I just love that you always seem to have fun making your videos
It was Goyle who died, not Crabbe. Just kidding😂🤣😂🤣😆😆
I really love your lighting and studio, it looks really good.
this is my favourite hp channel on here
love the glasses morgan
Brilliant video once’s again Morgan love the channel ❤
im always amazed morgan's dedication to his videos
Great video Morgan 😊😊
Thank you for being so thorough. I’ve read the books forever and it’s nice that my husband can be a fan too without him having to read the books, love this channel
Thank you so much for all your work Morgan! Please do the Hunger Games couples ranked
Hey Morgan I think you might have missed Blaize Zabini in the movie, Crabbe wasn't even there, lol
Lol you’re funny
When Peter killed the 12 muggles, clearly the ministry would have the brains of the muggles who witnessed in the event altered. I wonder if they could still see thestrals even if the memory is altered. I feel like it's definitely possible as though witnessing death does something to your brain or person that can never be undone
18:36 Percy probably saw many if the muggles or muggle-born people die in the Ministry when he was working there undercover.
Morgan I really love these videos that you make and you have the brains of hermione,definitely! I love all this passion and dedication you have to give us these amazing videos!😊
This is a really interesting topic ive never thought about 🤔
You're videos are awesome! You put in so much effort in your videos.I just wanted to suggest a video idea, could you please make a list of the smartest characters in Harry Potter, please? And could you make a top 3 or 4 including Lupin , Hermione , and Roina Ravenclaw. Love your videos!
I love this video so much!
Great video. 👏👏👏
I love how much work you put into your videos! Doing so much research. One question: Greyback did witness the death of the three muggle boys he killed, didn't he?
I love this knowledge I‘m learning because I’m a Huge Harry Potter fan I love your videos
A very Good Video 👍🏻
great video
❤ your video there amazing ❤❤❤
I love you Morgan. Excellent work, as always ❤ Did actually Justin Finch-Fletchley fight in the final battle of Hogwarts?
I love your UA-cam Channel
Cool idea for a video 👍
I appreciate how much Morgan digs beep into Harry Potter Lord❤❤❤
Love the glasses morg
YOU SHOULD DO LORENZO BERKSHIRE AND/OR THEODORE NOTT! love your videos morgannn
no way im here this early omg HI
I feel like dying would be like witnessing your own death, so I don't think it's illogical to assume ghosts can see Thestrals
Also amazing channel
interesting concept 🧐
Ur new glasses look so good on u
I just wanna say that this is one of those things I appreciate of thw writer, a world those who witnessed dead can only see, truly a magic world indeed.
This is also something I wish could be explored more, because not just a thestral horse, but what about more animals? Places, items, lore... This could be very interesting and definitely appeal to the niche of gothics and dark loving mages without necessarily being evil.
“Muggles can see thesterals”
Sweet I can se them
and that's called taking things out of context
Good video. Started to make me think which Marvel comics characters are able to see the Thestrals if they would be in the same universe.
You know, you can do what if episodes in Harry Potter (or any other series you post) eg...
1. What if Dumbledore became the Minister for Magic?
2. What if Salazar Slytherin was never particular about the blood wise discipline?
Morgan is one of the rare channels that dedicate time for the sponsor part.
Looking good bro
I loved the lord of the rings break, seeing you outta your element was cool. But I’m so glad your Harry Potter coverage is back… Go Birds!
Great video! The total might even be 123 because yusuf kama probably also witnessed the kills at grindelwalds rally.
Love your videos
If you could, bring back the life of videos. There are so many characters left to do. Fleur, Molly, Arthur, Lavender, Dean, Seamus, Dolohov, and Flitwick.
Also do the ranking Slytherins and Hufflepuffs by ambition and loyalty.
Thanks
edit- also Flitwick might have seen Dolohov die in the battle of Hogwarts after he defeated him in a duel and Romilda Vane didn't see Voldemort die becuase she was with the younger students in Hogsmeade
Hello MovieFlame. I am a new Harry Potter fan, who's only watched the movies, and you've encouraged me to read the books, so I guesss I'll have to reconsider my favorites after reading the source material
Please read them. They are much better than the movies.
@@occheermommyI am eager to take this long challenge. Have you read the books?
@@ManavJith about 20 times. Mostly actually read although I have listened to the audio books a couple times. I am currently listening to the audio books read by Stephan Fry which is the guy that did them in the UK. In the US it was Jim Dale. I never actually cared for Jim Dale’s voice i dont know why. It’s nothing against him, he is talented with all the voices he does it is just something with some of his word fluctuations that i find jarring. So I was very happy that the Stephen Fry option is finally available in the US. I am a huge fan of the books and rarely watch the movies anymore. I have taken to listening to the books instead of watching.
Interesting video
Please post part 2 of your Breakdown and review Netflix avatar !!
Never in a million years would I think that this many people would have witnessed death. Holy moly that’s a big number!
Can you do a video about Nicolas Flamel? 🙂❤
thankyou
The glasses fit perfectly for the video. You should wear them more often.
That's a lot of characters. I never thought there would be that many.
Can you please make a vid about every spell Harry casted
Movieflame, around 16:50, you said Bill only saw gibbon, but they also saw Mad-eye die from avada kedavra, he got hit swuarenin the face
When is the part 2 of Netflix Avatar breakdown+review coming up?
I love the cursed child all of my friends love it too
Baby Harry is adorable
If its possible, could you make a detailed video about the Dark Mark?
Can you make a video of the so called Slytherin gang?
Basically 𝙳𝚛𝚊𝚌𝚘 𝙼𝚊𝚕𝚏𝚘𝚢, 𝙼𝚊𝚝𝚝𝚑𝚎𝚘 𝚛𝚒𝚍𝚍𝚕𝚎,𝚃𝚑𝚎𝚘𝚍𝚘𝚛𝚎 𝙽𝚘𝚝𝚝 𝚊𝚗𝚍 𝚖𝚘𝚛𝚎.
The Slytherin gang is basically a group of people from the slytherin house.🐍
Just commenting for the algorithm 🧡
You said every ghost should see the thestrals , but I think Binns wouldnt see them because he was a sleep when he died.
Gaunt is named after the street name in dr Jekyll and mr Hyde
You could probably make the argument that a good portion of wizards that took part in the Battle of Hogwarts were able to see thestrals afterwards.
Morgan: “Does a ghost’s death count as a death to see thestrals?”
Me: brain starts melting
GOD DAMN BRO IS LOOKING SHARP 😮❤
The 3 muggle children Percival Dumbledore killed in retribution for Ariana could have meant 2 of the muggle kids could see thestrals in the case they were all present and if the kids didn't die all at once.
6:29 wouldn’t Voldemort have witnessed death of moaning myrtle since that event happened in June 1943 and the other one was around August of that year
the basilisk is what killed myrtle
@linexi you don't have to be the killer to see thestrals (otherwise Harry wouldn't have seen them after Cedric's death), even if the basilisk is what actually killed Myrtle, seeing it still counts
@@linexi harry didn’t kill Cedric nor Luna with her mother and so on with other characters but was able to see the thestrals so I don’t think you have to be the one to kill the person just be a witness to the act and also be of a age where death is understood
Thanks for the good videos Morgan’s but POST THE RETURN OF THE KING VIDEO!!!!!!!!
Coming next
@@MovieFlame Omg you responded, thanks for the good content you really make my day
@@MovieFlamealso I think that maybe you should post some game of thrones, if you want too I think you would really enjoy it
Very intresting. Very intresting indeed. Again, I'm begging you to do a video about the wizarding fairytales and again more of Rick Riordan universe with Magnus Chase, the Kane siblings, and Daughter of the Deep. Also please finish the house ranking. ANd agian put all the characters you've sorted into Hogwarts houses and what house they belong in illvomroy, and that inculdes the the harry potter cast
Also speaking of the AMerican Wizarding school you forgot to add Isolde Sawyer's family who saw her evil aunt die and how she witness her parents die.
i am not surprised the number is that high honestly, considering that just in the main series everyone is living through a war and murders by mostly death eaters and voldemort himself.
Morgan!!! What if a character in the HP Series witness a death through a video Recording? Would that count as a witness of death to be able to see Thestrals?
Hey morgan, can you do another " [harry Potter character] entire life" thing? I think they're very interesting
Harry saw his parents die at one year old so he's always been able to see thresrals
Nice
Thanks for another great, in-depth video. Wow! That's a lot of death, but it is a war so I'm not totally surprised. To answer your question, no I don't think ghosts witness their own death.
Could you please do a video sorting games of thrones characters into Hogwarts houses, I think it would be very interesting to see where they get sorted especially the Lannister's who's house colours and sigial is already associated with Gryffindor
I think ghost should see thestrals. They witnessed their own death. And some probably didn’t die immediately like Sir Nickils and most likely Helna Ravenclaw. And ghost probably knew they were gonna die before death. So yes I think ghosts can see thestrals.
But you have to see death and then process it. So since they don't see their own death they can't process it after. The fact that harry didn't see thestrals until 5th year proves that ghosts wouldn't.
Yes
18:05 sooo you saying that Crabe saw Zabini die
😂😂
yes
18:14 I mean Blaise did have six suspiciously dead stepfathers, so its pretty likely he saw at least one of them die, and was therefore able to see thestrals