QI Rounds On Literature! Featuring Shakespeare And Tolkien!

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 3 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 79

  • @michaeljohnangel6359
    @michaeljohnangel6359 8 місяців тому +36

    Also, the Earl of Oxford DID write poetry, and it's awful. It is absurd to think that someone would allow his bad poetry to be ascribed to him, but hide his better work.

  • @jb888888888
    @jb888888888 8 місяців тому +18

    3:20 nine doofs, or four and a half doof-doofs.

  • @TheWanderingFire
    @TheWanderingFire 8 місяців тому +32

    Hagridden - a Norse mythology based term. A witch or "hag" would turn a sleeper into a horse and ride them about the countryside at night until the horse was exhausted or had their wind broken. The horse would then be returned to bed in their human form, and wake up feeling terrible.

    • @ValeriePallaoro
      @ValeriePallaoro 7 місяців тому +1

      Wait .... In the Potter Universe there's Hagrid .... JKR is nasty, well, maybe not nasty, but certainly odd.

    • @poilboiler
      @poilboiler 7 місяців тому

      @@ValeriePallaoro No, she is 100% nasty.

    • @annalieff-saxby568
      @annalieff-saxby568 6 місяців тому +1

      That's a great excuse for a hangover.

  • @amaybury4672
    @amaybury4672 5 місяців тому +3

    Daniel Radcliffe is surprisingly delightful on QI.

  • @markloveless1001
    @markloveless1001 8 місяців тому +19

    The Jingling Johnny sounded to me like the Vulcans at Spock's wedding.

    • @somercet1
      @somercet1 8 місяців тому

      TIL about Ultravox, love the song, and will listen to the album now.

    • @ianmontgomery7534
      @ianmontgomery7534 8 місяців тому +1

      As Stephen said it would be called a Lagerphone in Australia as we used bottle tops mounted similarly for bush bands.

    • @lilymarinovic1644
      @lilymarinovic1644 8 місяців тому

      The Jingling Johnny bit has nothing to do with literature AFAIK, wonder why it was included?

    • @markloveless1001
      @markloveless1001 8 місяців тому

      @@lilymarinovic1644 Captain's log, star date 3372.7. A classic. Shakespeare, Dickens, Doyle, Sturgeon....

  • @phillwainewright4221
    @phillwainewright4221 8 місяців тому +147

    Stephen doesn't recall the word 'clitoris' in Shakespeare ... to be fair, it *_is_* hard to find ...

    • @karebushmarebu233
      @karebushmarebu233 8 місяців тому

      When will we accept that the clitoris doesn’t exist. It’s pseudoscientific nonsense, there have been multiple studies done by experts in the STEM fields and none of them have found evidence for this supposed “clitoris”

    • @esskay1513
      @esskay1513 8 місяців тому +2

      😂

    • @thehellyousay
      @thehellyousay 8 місяців тому +1

      👏👏👏

    • @glenni249
      @glenni249 8 місяців тому +16

      I don't imagine he was particularly interested in the search either.

    • @stevo68
      @stevo68 8 місяців тому +1

      I'm not sure there is such a thing.

  • @alunchurcher7060
    @alunchurcher7060 8 місяців тому +9

    1984 is a great read I read it many years ago and still recall how harsh life would be in a regime of life under it's story line.

    • @mileskiddell
      @mileskiddell 8 місяців тому

      You claim to have read it.....

    • @alunchurcher7060
      @alunchurcher7060 8 місяців тому

      @@mileskiddell no I read it in school for English literature so had no choice, try reading it yourself it's a good book but best for adults who know a lot more than normal about politics.

    • @mileskiddell
      @mileskiddell 8 місяців тому

      @@alunchurcher7060 thank you. As somebody who is obviously much smarter than me, you don't need me to point out that as the video says 25% of people who claim to have read it actually haven't. PS: I have read it also (or have I?)

    • @alunchurcher7060
      @alunchurcher7060 8 місяців тому

      @@mileskiddell i don't own a TV so I do read a lot of books, as people used to in the past before TV's took over peoples lives. My old English Literature teacher used to drum the importance of reading in to us and for some of us students it took hold.

    • @mileskiddell
      @mileskiddell 8 місяців тому

      @@alunchurcher7060 as somebody that lives in a country (Madagascar) where internet is "lucky" to be found.... same. I read 1984 because I chose to and loved it. Brave New World was recommended to me but I did not really enjoy it that much.
      I was forced to read (and loved) 'Lord of the Flies' at school (and have read again since) and my favourite book is probably 'The Death of Grass'. Based on these books can you advise my next read please?

  • @brettjohnson536
    @brettjohnson536 6 місяців тому

    3:43 You know, that really doesn't surprise me 😂

  • @toddmarryatt443
    @toddmarryatt443 8 місяців тому +20

    Inductive reasoning is mostly what Sherlock used as well. A conclusion that has supporting evidence that gives it the most likely hood to be correct. Abductive logit is also called inference. Best guess. Sherlock used all three types.

  • @kladdagh
    @kladdagh 8 місяців тому +2

    Do you know anything about consistent sound levels?!

  • @jrpipik
    @jrpipik 8 місяців тому +19

    I can't believe Stephen Fry got through a conversation about starlings without mentioning murmuration.

    • @richardjames7905
      @richardjames7905 8 місяців тому +1

      I’m surprised Alan didn’t know it either.

    • @Codex7777
      @Codex7777 7 місяців тому

      Bear in mind that these are just clips and are often not the full conversation. Still, at least it provided you with an excuse to flaunt your knowledge. ;) :)

    • @jrpipik
      @jrpipik 7 місяців тому

      @@Codex7777 In the spirit of the show.

  • @jaywalker3087
    @jaywalker3087 8 місяців тому +8

    I read it at 14 at school.
    I've read it at least once every 10 year's and at 65 I've just bought the 40th anniversary publication to read again, having lent my last copy to someone about 8 year's ago.

    • @nosuchthingasshould4175
      @nosuchthingasshould4175 8 місяців тому +3

      I have also read it in high school and was massively freaked out by it. It seemed to me to be plausible and therefore inevitable. Later I was comforted by the realisation that simple human incompetence would have collapsed the system within a generation or so. The current advancements in technology, eliminating the human factor, are a cause for renewed concern.

    • @Somethingwickedthisway
      @Somethingwickedthisway 8 місяців тому

      I've read it a few times, the first time was because of the bbc's The Big Read way back in the 00s. Despite this, I don't think I have ever actually owned a copy of it.

  • @markrowland1366
    @markrowland1366 3 місяці тому

    I saw tshirt, beautifully printed all over the back. The dominant space, was the word, NAME. Ready for Schakespiearres, true name.

  • @PanglossDr
    @PanglossDr 7 місяців тому +2

    I have read that it wasn't Shakespeare who wrote the plays. It was another guy called Shakespeare .

  • @bren106
    @bren106 7 місяців тому

    1984 was on our GCE reading list for the English Literature examination.

  • @AND-od5jt
    @AND-od5jt 8 місяців тому +3

    4:54 Having read both, I'd still suggest "Brave New World" 1st, then "1984"...
    "Have you found the genes you would like to be enhanced on your baby?" --
    'member, when the EU had a strict law AGAINST genetic engineering?
    'member, when NATO promised the CCCP never to "touch" their neighbouring states?
    If the big ones don't follow the rules, why should the lil ones... which rounds the circle and brings us to the -- nah, read it for yourself ;p

    • @AND-od5jt
      @AND-od5jt 8 місяців тому

      p.s.: Although Ridley Scott is interested, there is no cinematic movie adaptation for it yet (both the 1980 and the 1998 versions are sh*t)

  • @wizlon6757
    @wizlon6757 7 місяців тому

    Seaside Shuffle TERRY DACTYL & THE DINOSAURS: ua-cam.com/video/p62dmF2Bdpw/v-deo.html Credit. www.youtube.com/@sunryse111

  • @Cassie_28
    @Cassie_28 8 місяців тому +2

    Did anyone else think David Mitchell and the guy in the video thumbnail looked alike👀

  • @zapkvr
    @zapkvr 3 місяці тому

    Victoria hasnt been on QI for ages. Please bring her back

  • @scottmcarthur207
    @scottmcarthur207 7 місяців тому

    We read 1984 (I know, should be written out) in grade 9 in my school in western Canada. It mattered. Everyone should read it

  • @j.f.christ8421
    @j.f.christ8421 8 місяців тому +1

    "Inside Mrs Shakespeare"

  • @Mr_Grimbley
    @Mr_Grimbley 8 місяців тому +2

    This feels like it was compiled by a deaf AI.

  • @dianecheney4141
    @dianecheney4141 8 місяців тому

    I think Miss Marple used the same sort of logic as Sherlock Holmes

  • @TheAlps36
    @TheAlps36 8 місяців тому +1

    2:46 where the HELL did that come from?! 😂

  • @stephenkerensky710
    @stephenkerensky710 7 місяців тому +1

    If you think the Earl of Oxford wrote "Shakespeare", take a look at his poetry. It`s absolute crap. Anyway, Ben Jonson was a drinking-mate and described his manner.

  • @jennyt966
    @jennyt966 8 місяців тому +3

    Some people believe that Ann Hatherway, who was a writer, also might have written some of Shakespeare's works.

  • @dianecheney4141
    @dianecheney4141 8 місяців тому

    I read it and when I mention bits of it to people who have also said they read it, they'll say they don't remember that part. We're the same age, I remember it but you dont? So weird

    • @badaboum2
      @badaboum2 8 місяців тому +2

      Different people have different memories and different selective memories. Some people are good at memorizing names, some aren't, even if they're heard those names the same amount of times. I'm sure even yourself have better recollection of some things you've read than others, even from the same author, I definitely do.
      I've never read 1984 but I've read Animal Farm and Down and Out in Paris and London by Orwell, and there's definitely plenty of bits in them that I've forgotten, more than bits that I rememember. I couldn't even name a single character from Down and Out except Orwell himself (it's non-fiction).

  • @davidevans3227
    @davidevans3227 8 місяців тому +1

    adverts after each clip is too much

  • @Bethgael
    @Bethgael 8 місяців тому +2

    I have read 1984 (no really); we were assigned the book when I was in Yr 8. I was 13. That was, actually, in 1984. Most of the questions involved how it didn't come true, blah blah.
    _None_ of the things my English teacher said that year about how the book was a load of nonsense have aged well. No.

  • @hugorune766
    @hugorune766 8 місяців тому

    I'm a muggle... and proud of it 🙃

  • @killaloekittens2834
    @killaloekittens2834 7 місяців тому

    Dumbledore, sounds so English, could it possibly be French? Gold bee? 1066!

  • @vangroover1903
    @vangroover1903 4 місяці тому

    It's always a bit disappointing when real QI highlights are mixed in with the post-Fry era, but thanks for this.

  • @peztopher7297
    @peztopher7297 8 місяців тому +1

    There's more evidence for Edward De Vere's writing 'Shakespeare' than there is for William of Stratford! Some for Christopher Marlowe as well. Read "Shakespeare Was A Woman, and Other Heresies", by Elizabeth Winkler.

  • @NicolasMogensen
    @NicolasMogensen 7 місяців тому +1

    Always had a bit of an Aisling crush,, she's gorgeous. Not so much that voice though,,

  • @Thisandthat8908
    @Thisandthat8908 8 місяців тому +4

    there a re a lot of (wrong!) people who call listening to audiobooks "reading".

    • @susanhale6197
      @susanhale6197 8 місяців тому +36

      Hi- English literature & Education major here. Final thesis in Shakespeare.
      I can attest, as a former teacher, that however a person takes in a work of literature, be it braille, direct reading, or via audible book, that person HAS READ THE BOOK. Many of the greatest books produced by humans have actually become popular via both reading or being read to, since many books started out as oral/performing tradition. Example: the Iliad, the Bible, Shakespeare’s plays, Dumas was often read allowed by a person paid to do so while factory workers assembled goods.
      There are many veterans with traumatic brain injuries who use audible books- and since I had Covid and it effected my sight? So do I.
      Don’t scorn another person’s opinion or method of intake just because you find direct reading of printed text an easy feat.

    • @tracyanne8616
      @tracyanne8616 8 місяців тому +10

      Thank you Susanhale6197. I have been an avid reader of English literature in particular since a young girl, now 65. I cannot read much anymore due to eyesight though I do honestly insist that I do. Asleep after ten minutes though 😊. My two grandsons are being homeschooled and my daughter finds that the boys get more out of hearing a story, current,y Ronald Dahl’s Boy. If you can’t get them one way then to listen to a story is another way. Really important to read of course and who knows it may be a catalyst for them to make their own decision to pick up a book. Though no matter either because to know a story can elicit questions which is just marvellous.

    • @ScotchTape
      @ScotchTape 8 місяців тому +8

      Ok boomer…

    • @somercet1
      @somercet1 8 місяців тому

      @@susanhale6197 "Read" here in the looser sense, much as we say we "butt-dialed" someone even though I'm pretty sure no cell phone ever made had a rotary dial on it.
      Besides, if we didn't say someone read to had "read" the book, we'd be forced to say they, what? "Consumed" it? Ew.

    • @thefinewino
      @thefinewino 8 місяців тому +1

      🙄