Chip Roy Grills ATF Director About The Constitutional Rights For American Gun Owners
Вставка
- Опубліковано 21 вер 2024
- At a House Judiciary Committee hearing on Thursday, Rep. Chip Roy (R-TX) questioned ATF Director Steven Dettelbach about firearms.
Fuel your success with Forbes. Gain unlimited access to premium journalism, including breaking news, groundbreaking in-depth reported stories, daily digests and more. Plus, members get a front-row seat at members-only events with leading thinkers and doers, access to premium video that can help you get ahead, an ad-light experience, early access to select products including NFT drops and more:
account.forbes...
Stay Connected
Forbes on Facebook: forbes
Forbes Video on Twitter: / forbes
Forbes Video on Instagram: / forbes
More From Forbes: forbes.com
They straight up murdered that man in his home next to his wife. Defund ATF..
If they thought he sold someone a gun involved in a crime you would have thought they would have wanted to talk to him first.
ATF has a history of shooting people next to their loved ones
What's sad is that Congress can defund them but will never do it. All talk
Eventually we will discover he crossed Hillary. This is Arkansas after all.
@@brucesmith1544 They like to catch people off guard in their homes to show us we can no longer defend ourselves, very predatory. Not like these idiots couldn't wait for the guy to go to the local pharmacy, Walmart, or whatever. Simpletons.
This guy is a liar, Defund the ATF now!!!
Is a guy asking the questions was trying to lie and he only got exactly the answers that everybody wants to hear and still tried to make the other guy look bad for just saying that they follow the law and that anybody shouldn't just be able to sell weapons to just anybody. So if you agree that you think people should be able to sell weapons to our enemies or everybody that you don't like and don't think should have weapons then you're agreeing with him. So therefore you think terrorists that want to murder people that you care for should be sold weapons just because somebody wants to make some money? Do you not understand that that is what regulation is about? All right you just another Russian spy trying to so descent into the American public to install an idiot dictator to destroy our country?
@@bobmcfierson2163you need to be a little more clear with your question. I don’t understand what you are asking. Chip Roy the Senator who is asking the ATF man the questions is showing how deceptive the ATF is. Ultimately the ATF, FBI, DOJ are trying to disarm America. Only the innocent and law abiding citizens will comply but criminals will not comply they will use a gun to steal, rape, murder sell drugs be in gangs and hurt people. All Chip Roy and other righteous people in congress are saying is that law abiding citizens should have the right to protect themselves! Here in California Gavin Newsom releases very evil criminals from prison early and lets them steal from stores and hurt people including his police then takes away the people’s right to defend themselves. Do you think that is fair? Now he has made it be that even if a criminal enters your home to steal your property you must allow it! Do you think that is right? Well Chip Roy and others are trying to help us ALL. “The right to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed” PERIOD! They need to stop trying to change our Constitution!
@@bobmcfierson2163🤡
Key point, a private individual doesn't need to sell firearms to would be "terrorists" the federal government agencies do that pretty optimally as it is...sell, pretend secret op by DOJ, vacating a foreign nation after destablizing it and leaving behind aboit 87 billion dollars worth of military equipment and munitions...if anyone's got the market for that cornered it's them, the pentagon, and the MIC in general.
Disband the atf
Disband the ATF! Now
Disband 95% of ALL lettered fed agencies
Russian propaganda
Amen, Bob Davis
Lets see what happens with Hunter....case coming up.
@@jackquillman7680 Right, to your point, it would have already been dismissed if he dad wasn't the President.
If I sell 10 of my guns because I need the money, why is that your business? If I own a gun, why is that your business?
you know exactly why they want it to be their business
I have the stance that a private sell (with exception for immediate family) should have the same background check required as if buying from an FFL licensed dealer. Can you help me understand if this is something different? I don't think the seller should have to register for anything, but if someone wants to buy something, head down to your local FFL and have the seller checked out first. (I understand that people are going to light me up for this opinion. But, I'm genuinely trying to learn more because I don't want to be ignorant in my understandings. Thanks!)
@@yellowood252no, this situation was the ATF randomly determining that Mr. Malinowski the seller needed a license and without warning him they kicked in his door and killed him. There is zero direction given in the ATF’s policy as to how to know when you need a license and when you don’t, that’s the question here. Buyers and sellers getting background checks have absolutely nothing to do with this, although fortunately for us as citizens private sales do not require background checks unless out of state. The ATF’s own rules state that “if you occasionally sell guns from your personal collection, you likely do not need a license.” What does “occasionally” mean? Why didn’t the ATF warn Brian? Why didn’t they use one of a million other options they had to serve their warrant? Why didn’t they wear body cams? Why did they cover the doorbell cam and purposely not announce or ID themselves? Why didn’t they even knock? Why did they cut the power to the house? Why is the tyrannical and corrupt ATF abusing their power and getting away with it? These are the questions at hand, not background checks.
End “NO KNOCK Warrants” and END qualified immunity
Agreed. This is unjustified!
No knock warrants definitely have a purpose-just like headlocks do for law enforcement. Qualified immunity, if revoked, would lead to every cop in America never intervening again into any dicey situation and even mundane ones. No cop is going to lift a finger to help you or enforce any of our laws if they feel like the slightest mistake will lead to them losing everything.
If they are going to use no knock entry, they should have camera's that are working. If they don't have working cameras, they should be put in prison for life
It's absolute insanity to say not having a body cam should get you life in prison
@um4668 Why in this type of situation, they shut off the cameras that they had, which is against their rules, they get away with no cameras, and there needs to be punishment can you give me a reason they shouldn't have had cameras running and covering the doorbell cam with tape
What a despicable weasel. He a prime example of what is wrong with govt., it is out of control. Congress: fix it. Defund them into oblivion.
You're right he is a weasel
He would look really nice in a jail cell with bubba for about 40 years
He even looks one.
“We don’t make laws, we follow them”?!? Wtf is this pistol brace bullshit?!? And FRTs?!? Stay in your lane then ATF!!!
They are told to drive on the left side
@@user-bq3ce3kw1y they are in for MANY head-on crashes with the Good Citizens of the US of A!!!!
Perfect!
you can blame trump for that 1
@@slimhead666aw wasn’t trump out of office by 2020?? Pistol brace rule happened in 2023 and FRT ruling was 2022. I blame him for the bumpstock ban because that was an executive order. The rest is all on the ATF, unless you have a citation I am unaware of??
The ATF doesn't make laws?
Good, he just admitted that the pistol brace ban is unconstitutional.
What ban?
@@duckhunter8387 the ban that the atf made a rule on, so.......
@@fjb960 it was my understanding that it was blocked by a Circuit Court/ Federal Judge, 8 Nov 2023
@@duckhunter8387
IIRC, the ATF ignored that ruling and tried to enforce the rule anyway.
The issue is the ATF believe they're enforcing the NFA, a law that predates the agency by 40 years.
There is no "ban" on braces, there's an interpretation that braces are stocks, which are perfectly legal on rifles and Short Barrel Rifles.
The ATF director should be fired & locked up this is ridiculous
This guy is a menace to public safety.
Plain and simple get rid of the ATF!!!!
This guy is a menace to public safety.
This mofo just said he don't make laws. Pistol brace comes to mind.
pistol braces, "bump stocks" FRT triggers, "ghost guns" ... ATF makes laws all the time.
You obviously don’t know what a law is..
@@elephantoflight3362 a law is anything you can be put on trial for with a possible sentence of jail time and/or fine.
@@joerobo682 Okay, but regulations are not laws.
@@elephantoflight3362 if it walks like a duck and quacks like a duck, it's a duck. ATF and other three letter agencies make"regulations" that get people jailed and fined all the time. they are unconstitutional and how the leftist deep state bypass Congress to subjugate the people.
You cannot convince anyone that the ATF is not guilty of murder. Ruby Ridge, Waco.
They’ve always been extremely corrupt.
I accidentally went full fudd at a local pawn shop when I realized they had no clue what Waco or Ruby Ridge was
As i remember the in Waco, there were serious charges against Koresh, like phisycal and sexual violence againt children.
Not murder at all! You probably think abortion is murder!!
@joaopedrobaggio4475 if that were actually true, they had many opportunities to arrest him outside of the compound.
Defund the ATF!!!!!
Defund the dnc n rhinos
You misspelled DISBAND.
Defund the Government, these elected officials, all they do is talk.
@@BobM.-to9jiEven UA-cam thinks you are speaking in another language.
And TSA, DHS, IRS
Where are the murder charges for the ATF? Until there is justice the ATF should be defunded and stopped from operating.
Not until we get justice. They should be defunded as they were NEVER needed in the first place. Shall not be infringed is pretty clear. But go tell that to a bureaucrat gun grabber.
Thank you Chip Roy WHEN WILL THESE CRIMINALS BE PROSECUTED?
GET RID OF THE ATF!!
Nope, keep the ATF.
@@BobM.-to9jiAnd all their supporters.
Forcing a citizen to purchase a federal license to sell their personal property is unconstitutional.
You can sell your guns to a dealer, it's just that you won't get much for them. There's a huge glut of firearms right now--huge.
🎯🎯👍
@@bb5242 Forcing you to sell your property at a lose is unconstitutional as well.
It is taxation of rights and dangerous to the freedom of rights and possessions and the constitution and the Democrats are trying to control the lives and speech and voting in the country by corrupt means to muzzle and handcuff Americans so as to cement power and government under dictatorship of DOJ And DNC
I didn't sell any firearms I gave that gun away for free but had to sell the holster for $450 because he wanted the holster. 😂
He lied when he said ATF doesn't keep a registry.
Indeed.
Yes he did cause they're able to go to a warehouse look through millions of files (sales records) and find out where a crazy person (mass shooter) purchased their firearm but because it’s not on a computer available at their fingertips in a split second it not a "registry" I call BS any form of record keeping is a registry whether or not it's electronic cause as soon as a person is on their radar they go to that warehouse and start looking to see if that person owns any firearms.
@@whysoserious2k3, I have seen videos here on YT where people allege they are scanning all those documents into a searchable database. Why do you think they changed the Form 4473 to put the purchaser's information and the firearm's information together on the first page?
Pretty much. FFLs, upon closing their business, must give all records to (the ATF, I presume). Goes without saying that suppressor records are kept.
On a side note, despite old information still out on the web, the FBI keeps any background check records for concealed permits for an indefinite (aka forever) time. Fingerprints as well.
All this is rather academic. All the government needs to do to search and seize firearms on your property is pass a law that states ammo purchases are enough “probable cause”. And all those companies - online/offline - are going to hand over that information out of fiduciary duty (fear of losing profit if they don’t comply with the government). No subpoena necessary.
People are scared of gun registration - and rightly so. But that’s an old fashioned way governments behaved, right before confiscation. They don’t need registration to know who has the guns. They just need data and some bureaucrat, law, or regulation to take them. And, obviously, the Constitution can’t prevent it from happening, as evidenced by the countless anti-property/gun laws, seizures, and homicidal raids.
In 2021 CT State Police handed me an 'ATF letterhead' printout of every firearm and the S/N's I owned going back over 30 years. What's more amazing than ATF's ability to lie and m*rder with no-knocks, is that Congress has yet to shut the ATF down.
Now that's a House Rep! Chip Roy is a no-nonsense nuts & guts Patriot. Always fighting the good fight for We the people.
ATF... American Gestapo...Disband the ATF.
More like STASI!
What would I trust more: a Diamondback rattlesnake on my lap or an ATF agent at my door? Hand me the snake!!
Nice one! 🤣🤣🤣🤣
That’s not even a close contest! Which snake is worse?
No shit
🐍🐍So true🐍🐍😢
@@desculvscalfYou have a better chance surviving the rattlesnake than an attack from the ATF!
Chip Roy is absolutely right!!!!!
he may be right on this, but he is still RINO material.
@@mchrysogelos7623 What makes you say he's a rino?
@@mchrysogelos7623 Yeah, what makes you say Chip Roy is rino material?
As usual!
“We follow the law… except for the RULES we make!” Criminal and a liar
he can't even say what the law is
So which is it ?
Laws or rules?
I don't think this guy knows which one it is!
If it is a law show me!
If it's a rule 😂
This is just frustrating. Chip Roy made a great point here.
"If you can't even answer it, how can the average American know it?"
Ever since we first heard that Awkward Answer From the Past. "Well, it depends on what the definition of IS, IS".
No one can truthfully answer a question anymore, and there you go and here we are.
Dettelbach should be charged with conspiring to commit murder.
agreed!
Agreed
They didn't even try to contact him. Cold blood murder.
I’ve been waiting for 18 months for a license from the ATF. Worthless bunch of traitors.
statistically, you have 6 more months to wait.
Took 2 1/2 year for them to deny my NFA application for a suppressor. Got a letter saying I “may be a prohibited person”. No more explanation than that. Had to enter an appeal online through the FBI website. All for their permission for me to have a suppressor so I can help protect my livestock from predators. I know that doesn’t compare to them murdering this man, but it’s all tied together. This has to stop.
Sounds like an awful lot of "Infringement" to me.
@@mikewurlitzer5217 you got that right. the 2nd amendment seems to be the only God given right you have to pay the government cash to exercise.
@@mcwilliams4546And you need the suppressor so you don’t stampede your livestock when sneaking up on a bear or pack of wild dogs, coyotes or mountain lion or whatever. The moronic traitors in our government need to go!
So the ATF Director admits, Congress explicitly forbids a gun registry, but yet that’s exactly what the NFA is!!!
Very good point
Plus ATF has visited several FFLs around the Country and photograped of all their filled out forms and sales receipts. Which if they wanted to they could very easily keep as records by calling it: " Under ongoing investigation".
So is the background check. Do you really really believe they and the FBI are not keeping those records? Once it's in a computer, it is there forever, even if supposedly erased. Just hand your computer over to an expert, and that person will be able to tell you, everything you have ever done on that computer. Not keeping records? I call bullshit!!
The absolute last people who should be trusted with the safety of the American people work at the ATF.
Disband the ATF.
Defund Fred Flintstone & the ATF.
You’re right, this liar looks like Fred Flintstone!
WTF did Fred Flintstone do?
@@countrysteel8920 he failed to stop at the Border, no brakes
ATF covers for the Mexican Cartel and all drug trafficking that CIA is running, including "adrenochrome"
Good one!
Not gotten right!?! A law abiding family man lost his life due to their overzealous corruption, and incompetence!
No more compromise… shall not be infringed. Disband the ATF.
What a joker he is, then why is ATF going around checking those that bought several recent firearms to see if the buyer still owns them.
Absolutely
Trashing
Freedom
Thank you Chip Roy for standing up for the constitution and second amendment
Hell Yeah 👍
“We follow the laws” LIARS!! Absolute LIARS
Shut the ATF down!
Chip Roy must be SUPPORTED BY AMERICA💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯
This a.t.f turned off camera turns off power why why cover there tracks this was murder an it will continue as long as there power goes unchecked sorry love my country love trump an family god save use 😢😢😢😢
Thank you, Representative Chip Roy!
Dettelbach also lied about pistol braces to Congress's face and nothing happened to him.
Why can't any of these Bureaucrats SIMPLY answer a question YES or NO
Yea, really. They all attend dodging questions 101.
Ever since we first heard that Awkward Answer From the Past. "Well, it depends on what the definition of IS, IS".
No one can truthfully answer a question anymore, and there you go and here we are.
@@rickschell7874 Send them to room 101.
ATF adds 400 pages to a law and now the 400 pages are now laws... this is BS.
Only true Americans follow true laws!!! Lol
He straight faced looked at him and asked, “what about Plessy?”
HOOOOLY SH*T
Chip Roy is Awesome! That's Why We Love him in Texas!
An unelected unconstitutional federal police force bureaucracy going out as judge, jury, and executioner.
Yeah just like saying the German Gestapo was a social group. Hold these people up on murder charges and not "I was just following orders" excuse. Sound familiar?????
You don't need 400 pages for a rule. That's just beurocratic nightmare.
You don't need more than 20,000 separate gun control laws on the books across the United States either, but that is what we have, and not one of them has ever stopped a crime.
why are they making rules?
ATF the new Murder Inc.
WTH does it matter unless they are going to face consequences? Like prison??
These hearings should be to figure out if the people being questioned should get life in prison or not
WHY DOES CONGRESS NOT HAVE THE POWER TO FLATLY COME OUT AND SAY, " ANSWER THE QUESTION WITH YES OR NO, OR YOU WILL BE HELD IN CONTENPT!"
That's what they used to do! Now apparently they're nothing more than cowards who gaslight in order to maintain their own political careers! 😬
That would be nice. The question should be asked and the time stopped until the next question is asked. It would stop then because they would be there three days for one session.
Defund the ATF
ATF Director saying that he “follows the law” is like Ted Bundy telling them American public he’s not a rapist in his own words.
No its like telling Congress if they don't like the laws then they are the ones that need to rewrite them.
He works for a law ENFORCEMENT agency. Not a law MAKING agency. They need to be reigned in.
If the ATF was no longer an Agency, we wouldn't need these show and tell displays...
Every rule and regulation the ATF comes up with needs challenged by a well qualified gun Smith and shooter, and let's start with a shotgun with an 18" barrel is legal, and a pistol that shoots shotgun shells is legal but nothing in-between is legal, please expand on these rules that make no sense, then let's move to the pistol rifle conundrum where I have a 1911 let's say in 45 ACP, and I have a rifle of the same caliber and the barrel length can't be less than 18" once again, and what crimes are you preventing with weapons with barrel lengths between those numbers? And show your statistics relative to both pistol and 18" barreled rifles...and crimes committed in the say 10" to 17.9875" barrels, who are we protecting exactly?...it's certainly not a concealment issue, the pistol nullifies that argument...
They don't improve, period! Time to disband the ATF! 🇺🇸
"we follow the law" from the director of an agency that just murdered a prominent businessman during a "no knock warrant" while breaking the law by not having ONE camera running on over a dozen agents...
Disband the ATF & recind the NFA...
Lying to Congress is a big deal so why does he get away with it?.
They want us to believe this is an unfortunate situation, and we need to understand. Unbelievable. They need to go.
The house can suspend funding to the ATF immediately.
the little part of "SHALL NOT BE INFRINGED " trips them up
Dettelbach becoming the director of the ATF is what you should expect in a credentialistic society.
the bigger question is why are all those seats empty
it's a committee meeting. depends on the size of the appointed committee members.
Always are every time I watch ugh
@@joerobo682 no shit my guy the point is they should be full regardless I am well aware of how hearings work I am making a point about how little fucks/interest is given by those elected to serve THE PEOPLE'S INTEREST.
@@Mike-bq7go they can't just show up. they have to be assigned to that committee.
@@joerobo682 you clearly have not seen other committees if they pay the money they are in.
Don’t understand why congress waste time holding hearings when nobody from any bureaucratic institution sitting at that table can answer a simple question. Unfxxking believable
And, after all those hearings.. nothing is done.
Biden's Department of the Gestapo 😮
The ATF actively keeps a registry!
Of course they are!!
None of them deserve to be thanked.
Remember when the People told the government what it could do instead of the other way around? I liked that better. We have entire federal agencies that we would be better off without.
The question is why is the ATF able to do this in the first place? Congress makes the law not ATF
Because they normalized delegation of their authority to the ‘experts’
Mr. Dettelback just said the ATF follows the law.....yet, under his watch, the ATF is making rules they do not have the authority to do. Thank you Mr. Roy for your work and support for We The People!!!
Just fucking DEFUND the ATF already.
Chip Roy is my hero!!! I love how he grills liar's that are in power
This is not the way a government is supposed to treat their citizens.
This guy is a menace to public safety.
Corruption oozes from the ATF director!
He can’t answer simple questions.
Ever since we first heard that Awkward Answer From the Past. "Well, it depends on what the definition of IS, IS".
No one can truthfully answer a question anymore, and there you go and here we are.
The constitution says it not the supreme court, I see what he is trying to do seroconvert your rights with law.
The non-answers ARE answers and speaks volumes!
Disband the ATF
He is there because ATF did not Follow The Law Fast & Furious ATF broke the law Many Many Times once a Liae always a Liar .
Obama was in charge of Fast & Furious what a failure
What part of the right to keep in bear arms shall not be infringed do you not have to comply with? I guess this guy does not deserve his paycheck or his outrageous benefits. If you do not follow the Constitution then you do not deserve pay and benefits from the federal government. Should be arrested and charged for every constitutional rights violation he sanctioned.
wow.. he almost said "just following orders" Totality of the circumstances.. translation Whatever I feel like at the time.
Defund the ATF...every penny!
The ATF claiming they follow the law while constantly being successfully sued in court for breaking laws.
As if we needed this exchange to know we are dealing with an inept bureaucrat.
Not inept at all.
They lie through their teeth if you purchase 3 gun's or more a year you get put on a watch list!!! If they don't keep a registrar how do they know that you bought more than 3 gun's!!?
Thanks congressman Roy. Intelligent questions that snake can't answer. Answers a lot for the American people.
Snake refuses to answer.
The atf director doesn't know anything about guns, gun laws or apparently the US constitution
Thank you Mr.Roy!
Thank you Chip Roy
CUT ATF FUNDING NOW !
This guy is a callaberator. He needs to be watched.
No more tough questions,,,, Only Tough Jail Sentences.
Sending a guy a letter 💌 telling him he needs a Federal Firearm License... just doesn't satisfy that ATF bloodlust.
Direxctor Dettelbach MUST publicly recognize that is NOT the Supreme Court which grants us citizens our rights.
Correct..its the damn constitution..not congress
@@craigm3777it's actually God, and the protections are enumerated in the Constitution.
Fundamental inalienable Rights, protected by the Constitution, Rights Not granted by the government, but endowed us by the Creator. Congress was never given authority to Infringe the 2A, in fact the 2A is an unqualified command to Not infringe the 2A.
@@teresamoore15 Congress is explicitly named in the 2A as having no ability to change, modify, or affect the 2A in any way.
The director of ATF is a liar.
Thug.
"Totality of circumstances" is designed to be ambiguous and a revolving door to selective interpretation and prosecution.
I am embarrassed that this ATF director is from my home state!
Get rid of this ATF player!!!
Where is ATF's license for dealing firearms ?
He's a liar; ATF makes up all kinds of gun related policy that is extra-judicial. His claim they just follow whatever laws are in place is laughably untrue.
ATF is shady AF. They are a bunch of thugs at this point. No reason at all to not wear body cams, and to cover up a home owners doorbell camera.
All federal law enforcement are that way. Unaccountable
"We obey the law" except when we don't want to.
Don’t understand explain 😮😮😮
The ATF has overreached