An absolutely excellent analysis and comparison of the world of THX 1138 and reality. Your video was the first time I had a complete A HA! moment concerning an analysis of this movie. The moment concerned the drugs leaving THX's body and the government losing control over him. I've watched the movie several times, and my perspective was always that of an all-knowing government controlling everything. But I didn't put it together that the "drugs" also allowed for mindlock. It's a world where even ones mind was not their own. People truly owned nothing... and they weren't happy or unhappy. They were drones. Period. AI is here. It is proliferating. Drugs are here, they're running through the course of our veins. Alleged wars and rivalries are here. EVERYTHING we type is able to be scrutinized. Everything we say can be listened to if we have one of this black screens within a microphones range. And...we all volunteer for it. An open-air prison.
This appears to be the World they want. A gender neutral, mind controlled, techno autocracratic......... Termite Mound. I saw this when released. I was blown away. Unfortunately, the Establishment seems to want exactly this kind of Hellish Society. Worker Drones, forced drugging, total control of every single thing and every single person. Isolate people from nature and any real, natural human relationship. Mr Lucas created a dystopia that still has me pondering it over 50 years later. I guess some people watched this flick back then and thought: "Wow! What A Great Idea!"
Bread, circuses, and circuits continue as planned. For the good of the Borg, by the bad of the Borg, and with nothing but the Borg, so help us, Zuckerborg. Acceptance is fertile.
If only Lucas had left this sublime, transcendent film alone, in original condition, the way WE experienced it back in the day. Yet again, he has ZERO respect for the viewer, if he did, at the very least, he’d offer both versions. Same for the original Star Wars.
For some reason I thought my DVD set came with a theatrical as well as director's cut. While I personally am okay with the edits in the THX special edition, especially compared to Star Wars, this remains a strong case to keep hard copies of old media. Your own copy cannot be edited, censored, or destroyed and can be enjoyed for as long as the technology lasts.
@@jonmcinnis1645 I agree, that could be interesting… I wonder if it could possibly match the Gifted prescient nature of the first film… it would have to be quite something to be as advanced for it’s day
I viewed this film for the first time in my life today I actually got from the library which holds some little jewels. Donald and Robert has it chemistry very brilliant actors Robert being one of the greatest of all time I loved the intense dark tone of this film. It was a bit linear. It was a bit an orthodox I compared to Logan’s run or future world or Westworld or planet of the apes, total recall and terminator similar in that two characters, male and female attempt to escape unpleasant environments or adversaries . I appreciated the cinematography was incredible. The white void actually was anxiety inducing. It was a subtle film and that’s the genius of Robert Duvall. He’s has a subtle style in his acting. There wasn’t a very high climax and a happily ever after ending and there wasn’t a face to all that human denigration and depravity put 2001 space Odyssey was similar in that linear tone and storyline, which I appreciate it in this film. It’s definitely a film. I want to add to my collection.
Great video; precise and no sugarcoating it. I think THX 1138 is the most accurate dystopia in fiction. However, if I may, I'll defend about 90% of the special edition changes in Star Wars. I think people forget how bad some of the original version looked.
It's true that a lot of the original movies looked bad, but they should have just done a digitally remastered version to make it look good, rather than add distracting and unnecessary things in the background or make egregious changes like Greedo shooting first.
@@MetaCinema I'll meet you halfway. I agree the Greedo thing is silly, and some CG is unnecessary. I just think some people have nostalgia goggles on and ignore some of the genuine improvements. Thanks for replying.
@@whatsinameme5258 Do you wonder what would the surface look like I hope this movie gets a sequel will focus THX’s survival on the surface and meets a group of people And joins forces with him and needs to learn what happened to the surface and need to encourage everyone in the underground city to return to the surface.
My username has been thus since 2004. Designed for dating sites as a sarcastic way of giving nothing away (read : why not just use your real name?) not knowing that malenesss and femaleness would be challenged in our education system, which in my opinion goes along with tramshumanism, which you allude to in your comments on 'mindlock' . Add to that my beloved son being born in 2016 - his name is Tex for clear reason as an homage, but never foreseeing the woefully extended lockdowns and censorship and worse that started in 2020. My son's name was never designed make him a hero and they'll be no pressure on him. But considering what's already happening, he at least will know, so that he will have choices Excellent video, thank you
Great video, i disagree on the holograms though, i perceive them to be human, they are all one race and only seen by the majority on hologram projectors.. Entertainment 'drones.' the others - worker drones. To me the ending shows yes you can escape but whats is there to escape to?!
I think I see what you're saying. THX and the others may as well be constructed bio-AI like the holograms are holo-AI, both made to be autonomous drones to fill a position in society. Makes me think we modern humans are similar drones. I like to think THX got out and there were others above ground, similar to how the shell is filled with shell dwellers. What kind of society they would form above ground, if any, is anyone's guess.
Thats my take, the holograms are human just like all the other humans - but in the world of THX1138 you are your job or designated role, thats it - no love, freedom, art, friendships, literature etc. So people whose job is to be a hologram are simply their jobs, live with all the other people whose job is to be a hologram, in a separate area and just do that.
Lucas' great film. Downhill thereafter but we should not complain. THX will outlive much that passes for film these days.
MASTERPIECE
Nope but very very close..a magnificent film..
Your monotone voice really adds to the dystopian sentiment
An absolutely excellent analysis and comparison of the world of THX 1138 and reality.
Your video was the first time I had a complete A HA! moment concerning an analysis of this movie. The moment concerned the drugs leaving THX's body and the government losing control over him. I've watched the movie several times, and my perspective was always that of an all-knowing government controlling everything. But I didn't put it together that the "drugs" also allowed for mindlock. It's a world where even ones mind was not their own. People truly owned nothing... and they weren't happy or unhappy. They were drones. Period.
AI is here. It is proliferating. Drugs are here, they're running through the course of our veins. Alleged wars and rivalries are here. EVERYTHING we type is able to be scrutinized. Everything we say can be listened to if we have one of this black screens within a microphones range. And...we all volunteer for it. An open-air prison.
Looks to me like an updated version of Plato’s Allegory of “The Cave”.
This is one of my favorite future dystopian movies, as it perfectly portrays the dehumanizing effects of an industrial welfare police state.
Agreed. A plausible future, in my opinion.
This appears to be the World they want. A gender neutral, mind controlled, techno autocracratic......... Termite Mound.
I saw this when released. I was blown away. Unfortunately, the Establishment seems to want exactly this kind of Hellish Society. Worker Drones, forced drugging, total control of every single thing and every single person. Isolate people from nature and any real, natural human relationship. Mr Lucas created a dystopia that still has me pondering it over 50 years later.
I guess some people watched this flick back then and thought: "Wow! What A Great Idea!"
@@MetaCinema a definite future
Bread, circuses, and circuits continue as planned. For the good of the Borg, by the bad of the Borg, and with nothing but the Borg, so help us, Zuckerborg. Acceptance is fertile.
"Bread and circuits" indeed. I was going to put the Borg in, but like you said, Zuckerborg is practically the same thing.
Zuckerberg is a replicant! His father is Roy Batty& his mama is Pris! His advisor is Elon Musk!😉😆
@@tomscerbo1588 I always assumed he was Data's long-lost twin.
@@funkymunky Could be! Food for thought.🤔
@@tomscerbo1588 Food for sloth 🦥
Really interesting video. Great commentary and images. 👍👍👍
Thank you, glad you liked it
Blessing of the masses! Work hard & be happy! Be thankful you have an occupation to full fill!🤔
If only Lucas had left this sublime, transcendent film alone, in original condition, the way WE experienced it back in the day. Yet again, he has ZERO respect for the viewer, if he did, at the very least, he’d offer both versions. Same for the original Star Wars.
For some reason I thought my DVD set came with a theatrical as well as director's cut. While I personally am okay with the edits in the THX special edition, especially compared to Star Wars, this remains a strong case to keep hard copies of old media. Your own copy cannot be edited, censored, or destroyed and can be enjoyed for as long as the technology lasts.
@@MetaCinema
Well said!
@@rumpstatefiascoyou do have a point Also I hope THX 1138 gets a sequel in my opinion. Just saying?
@@jonmcinnis1645
I agree, that could be interesting… I wonder if it could possibly match the Gifted prescient nature of the first film… it would have to be quite something to be as advanced for it’s day
@@rumpstatefiasco I think if they do a sequel to THX 1138 I think it should be called THX 1138: World Beyond in my opinion. Just Saying?
My Father did Sound and had a cameo in the original Short film with Lucas at USC
I viewed this film for the first time in my life today I actually got from the library which holds some little jewels. Donald and Robert has it chemistry very brilliant actors Robert being one of the greatest of all time I loved the intense dark tone of this film. It was a bit linear. It was a bit an orthodox I compared to Logan’s run or future world or Westworld or planet of the apes, total recall and terminator similar in that two characters, male and female attempt to escape unpleasant environments or adversaries . I appreciated the cinematography was incredible. The white void actually was anxiety inducing. It was a subtle film and that’s the genius of Robert Duvall. He’s has a subtle style in his acting. There wasn’t a very high climax and a happily ever after ending and there wasn’t a face to all that human denigration and depravity put 2001 space Odyssey was similar in that linear tone and storyline, which I appreciate it in this film. It’s definitely a film. I want to add to my collection.
ALSO: GEORGE'S OTHER RETOUCHED, ENHANCED, AND CG-FX-LADEN MASTERPIECE. WE NEED A HARMY'S.
I think it may have been his best movie.
I think it is.
Great video; precise and no sugarcoating it. I think THX 1138 is the most accurate dystopia in fiction. However, if I may, I'll defend about 90% of the special edition changes in Star Wars. I think people forget how bad some of the original version looked.
It's true that a lot of the original movies looked bad, but they should have just done a digitally remastered version to make it look good, rather than add distracting and unnecessary things in the background or make egregious changes like Greedo shooting first.
@@MetaCinema I'll meet you halfway. I agree the Greedo thing is silly, and some CG is unnecessary. I just think some people have nostalgia goggles on and ignore some of the genuine improvements. Thanks for replying.
@@whatsinameme5258 Do you wonder what would the surface look like I hope this movie gets a sequel will focus THX’s survival on the surface and meets a group of people And joins forces with him and needs to learn what happened to the surface and need to encourage everyone in the underground city to return to the surface.
5:41 That was a brutal shot at Zuckerberg.
❤
My username has been thus since 2004. Designed for dating sites as a sarcastic way of giving nothing away (read : why not just use your real name?) not knowing that malenesss and femaleness would be challenged in our education system, which in my opinion goes along with tramshumanism, which you allude to in your comments on 'mindlock' . Add to that my beloved son being born in 2016 - his name is Tex for clear reason as an homage, but never foreseeing the woefully extended lockdowns and censorship and worse that started in 2020. My son's name was never designed make him a hero and they'll be no pressure on him. But considering what's already happening, he at least will know, so that he will have choices
Excellent video, thank you
Good stuff. Liked and subbed
Glad you liked it, thank you
I still have no clue what the theater of sound is :( so many hidden things in this film. Sometimes it’s about what you can hear vs see.
Great video, i disagree on the holograms though, i perceive them to be human, they are all one race and only seen by the majority on hologram projectors.. Entertainment 'drones.' the others - worker drones.
To me the ending shows yes you can escape but whats is there to escape to?!
I think I see what you're saying. THX and the others may as well be constructed bio-AI like the holograms are holo-AI, both made to be autonomous drones to fill a position in society. Makes me think we modern humans are similar drones. I like to think THX got out and there were others above ground, similar to how the shell is filled with shell dwellers. What kind of society they would form above ground, if any, is anyone's guess.
Thats my take, the holograms are human just like all the other humans - but in the world of THX1138 you are your job or designated role, thats it - no love, freedom, art, friendships, literature etc. So people whose job is to be a hologram are simply their jobs, live with all the other people whose job is to be a hologram, in a separate area and just do that.
Well done. I enjoyed it very much. You got a subscriber. I’ll check out the rest of your
Thank you, and I'm glad you liked it
buy more and...be happy..
This movie sucked too.
Shut Up
Go and watch marvel sheet boi
@chuck Go watch garbage Star Wars 😂
1+1+3+8 = 13