My dad once told me that this piece is like the aftermath of receiving the news of someone's death: You are angry at the beginning, then you sing the same song again, this time wistful... Then at the 'sempre molto adagio' section, you imagine that you might as well give up - that there is no life. When you reach the next 'a tempo' you are changing your style and trying to think on the bright side of things, and whistling a wayward tune. Afterwards, your thoughts spiral in all directions, fast and unstoppable before you finally reach the last repetition of the mourning keen that you were crying at the beginning. Only this time it is the loudest yet, screaming for attention and from grief. The ending is full of sadness, regret and heartache but it is in the similar style to the wayward tune a few minutes ago: it is like you are hoping that you will be able to see that 'bright side' soon, but not now... Even if Faure didn't write this after his wife died, there is so much raw emotion (which you are displaying amazingly) that this is clearly a piece of lamentation.
@ Melisande, pure laine. Nadège comprend. Et elle comprend, surtout, jusqu'à quel point comment "comprendre c'est pardonner." ➡ ↪...if you can even assign extraneous words to Symbolist poetry. And much less: if you dare even attempt to describe in words Fauré's mastery of all things musical, expressed via a "heart that bleeds purple".... ... Il suffit de dire que votre jeu ici, Nadège, m'a attéré. "Melisande." Détenteur de nos désirs les plus légitimes. Et puis la tentative... Finalement poignardés trois fois; comme rituellement. Je reste bouche-bée. Il faut écouter Bach. Le choeur d'ouverture de "Wie schön leuchtet der Morgenstern" par la Bachstiftung CH. Et oui, voilà. Mark (usa)
My cello teacher gave a similar interpretation, he said that at the end even the happy wayward tune has turned sour as it has gone to the relative minor: the memories of the good times can no longer be thought about without sadness. Such a beautiful piece, and beautifully played, thank you.
When my father died somewhat suddenly last year, this is the piece I selected for the service. He and I both love the cello. I was too overwhelmed at the time to practice, but I'll perform it on his cello for his upcoming birthday that he won't be able to attend in person :( Thanks for your moving rendition. You bring out the core of this piece; I am in a paddle of tears every time I am listening to it. Thank you.
3 роки тому+44
Thank you Henner for this moving message, I imagine that this is what I love about music, it connects the human beings through shred emotions. I am sorry about your dad, and wish you all the best.
It is very painful when a loved one leaves earth!! But never leaves the one’s he or she loves.. there are sooo many things to say and understand about our departures ! Cause everyone of us will leave this earth without taking with him or her a single possession except their feelings of love and what they have learned on themselves and others..
I performed that wonderful piece of music in 1977 together with my mother, who accompanied me on the piano ... one year after the sudden death of my father, her beloved husband. I was only 14 then, and played Cello for only few years, so the Elegie was maybe a bit too difficult for me, or let's say challenging. But I think my Cello teacher, lovely Mrs Ana Maria Maldonado, chose that piece especially for us ... as an outlet for our grief, our sorrow 😞
As both a cellist and a pianist . . . This was well done! Well phrased. Voicing superb. I love how the piano gets out of the way of the cello when the cello has the melody. Excellent tempo. Intonation, vibrato, all excellent. I was not expecting something so good and was very pleasantly surprised! Pianist did a fantastic job of bringing out the important inner melodies without being overpowering. BRAVO!!!!
This works as music therapy for me. Long ago when I was a high school student I could never figure out why I was always so good at the cello. I never thought that I was playing my emotions out. Now that I'm older I am just realized that I was just trying to deal with my trauma. And picking up the cello helped me release tension. Love this.
I came to this because my 11 yr old son’s cello teacher set it for him (I’m a professional violinist and was dreaming of the day he would play it! I accompany him on the piano). This quickly became our favourite version because of the fantastic control and lack of over-sentimentality which actually makes it hit all the more emotionally because the music speaks for itself and it’s real. Then, two days ago we heard that my son’s teacher, Michal Kaznowski (cellist of the Maggini Quartet) has passed away and we are devastated. I will help him finish learning it and now we play it for him. 😢 RIP Michał
Magnifique, je l'ai entendue aujourd'hui lorsque les jeunes ont dansé sur la glace avec cette élégie lors des jo de Pékin, et cette musique est un enchantement. Merci à Gabriel Fauré.
Très belle interprétation pleine de puissance et de nostalgie. Une respiration parfaite entre le piano et le violoncelle. Beaucoup d'espace, d'interiorité et de passion. Bravo.
I can't stop watching/listening this video. It is such a great performance by two young musicians. Malgorzata Garstka, does also a great job at the piano.
Wow! I just lost almost 7 minutes of my life in the most spectacular way possible! The rawness and emotional feeling of this performance was sublime. Thank you for bringing this into existence. X
Wow so wonderful performance! I am now sixteen and have played cello for five years now. I'm so exited that my teacher said that she can now teach me this piece of music.
4 роки тому
Thanks Linsku, I wish you lots of fun learning this piece!
I just love this piece, It's so mellancolic and kind of tell us a sad story. I love how it's possible to easily understand this story just with notes and emotion
4 роки тому+1
It is exactly why this is one of my favourite work, it tells so much in a short time 🙏🙏🎶
This is amongst my favorite pieces by Faure, who is also on my short list of favorite composers. Your interpretation is exquisite. You manage to coax and tease out of it every ounce of the profound beauty and emotion Faure put in. It's an extraordinary performance that speaks directly to my heart, and now whenever I wish to listen to the Elegie I find that yours is the version I want to hear. Thank you for this wonderful gift. 🙏
2 роки тому+2
Thank you B Lyndon for your kind and encouraging comment 🙏🙂
This is the most beautiful rendition of the piece I have ever heard. You are definitely one of my new cello role models now 😊. Thank you for this, you brightened my entire week! I am learning this piece right now and you inspired me to keep pushing the boundaries of sound and dynamics.
4 роки тому+8
Thank you Chloe! Enjoy the practice 🙂 if you would like any tips, you are welcome to PM me using the contact formular on my website.
La musique de Fauré est magnifique, mais là, on atteint au merveilleux avec une artiste au violoncelle qui est tout simplement sublime. Elle est belle, ses gestes sont d’une grande beauté, et dès les deux premières mesures le charme me saisit… il faut que je revienne au début pour ne plus me séparer de Nadège. Tomber amoureux de cette musique, sans aucun doute, mais aussi sans aucune honte de Nadège. Le matin, je suis avec elle, et le soir elle m’enchante de la musique et de son violoncelle. Toute mon admiration Nadège…à ce soir…. P. R.
Nadège, salut… 🤗 La magnifique Elègie de Fauré est dans mes oreilles depuis un certain temps, et finalement je suis revenue ici, après si longtemps, et j'ai écouté cette belle musique et votre interprétation sensible. C'était un délice en ce beau dimanche matin. Merci beaucoup à toi et à Malgorzata pour ce délice. 🌹❤️🌹
Gabriel. It’s my son’s Christian name and it was given after Gabriel Fauré whose music is so délicate. There is no other requiem but Fauré’s. Here, I am amazed and stunned by the Way these 2 young women perform this piece. Absolutely brilliant.
Got here after searching "Faure," who I'd never heard of. I'm an amateur with classical music, mostly listen to Tchaikovsky, and did a search on "melodic composers" and one lady in a chat mentioned Faure offhand. Of the 20 or so I've sampled, I like him best with Tchaikovsky. And this is the best version I've found of the Elegy.
2 роки тому+1
Thank you Dean I'm happy that Fauré came your way 🙂 he is also one of my favourite composers and especially this piece is very close to my heart. It is worth listening to his requiem too (especially the last piece Im paradisum), his Berceuse, and his trio. Enjoy!
Yes, emotion and composers' alleged feeling while writing. This whole thing is a myth. A composer may feel anything at all related to the emotional impression of a piece he or she is writing. In fact, Tschaikovsky wrote extensively about this topic. Firstly, he said that he had no idea why a particular piece seemed to evoke a particular emotion. It is well known that when he wrote the deeply tragic final movement of the Pathetique his friends observed him to be the happiest they had ever seen him. Things are not always what they seem. This is a deeply moving experience. Thank you so much.
4 роки тому
Thank you Daniel, and I am happy that you agree 🙂🎶
@UCuFzdt_i1rgcXCgPIn-XUIQ Thanks for your very prompt response. I thought of another mismatch between a composer's feeling and the feeling evoked by the music. It is the famous intermezzo to Cavaleria Rustica. To paraphrase he said when asked: I thought it would be fun to write and when I did I had a lot of fun just writing it. Now this piece is so serious and reverent. What a contradiction!
On distingue des anges sur votre violoncelle. Je comprends mieux maintenant l'expression "être aux anges..." car je devine dans quel état d'extase ils sont mis grâce à votre sonorité superbe
Nadège, hi… Fauré’s exquisitely beautiful Elègie has been in my ears for some time, and eventually I came here, again, after so long time, and listened to this beautiful music, and your sensitive performance. It was a delight on this beautiful Sunday morning. Thank you and to Malgorzata so much for this delight. 🌹❤️🌹
I caught the end of this piece in the car home today. Had to listen to the whole thing. Music has a way of expressing emotion that is beyond articulation.
I’ve been reading Dostoyevsky’s Crime and Punishment. I’m almost finished with the novel, but even at this point it’s clearly the best thing I’ve read up to this point in my life. Transformative reading is what I might call it. While reading the novel, I can’t help but think of this song. It’s become the theme to the novel in my mind. It’s almost eerie how well the song’s mood matches up with that of the novel. Thank you for this hauntingly beautiful music.
2 роки тому+3
Thanks Theeab for sharing, I think thatbit goes wonderfully with Crime and Punishment, you are absolutely right!
This magnificent performance she plays with exquisite skill and incomparable technique and beautiful attire is beyond description , and full of admiration and emotion , and comfortable to the ear and the mind
Hallo Nadège, zuerst habe ich auf englisch kommentiert, was wie ich gerade herausgefunden habe gar nicht notwendig ist. Das ist eine schöne Abwechslung. Ich kenne (bzw. sehe) sonst nur englischsprachige Künstler auf UA-cam. Mir gefällt deine Interpretation gut - vielen Dank fürs hochladen. Danke auch für Deine Videobeschreibung. Ich habe das darin erwähnte Video mit dem "berühmten Lehrer" gesehen und hatte bis eben auch die Geschichte mit Faurés Frau im Kopf, wenn ich das Stück gehört habe. Ich wünsche Dir einen guten Rutsch und alles gute für 2021!
3 роки тому+1
Danke lieber Dominic! Ja Deutsch geht auch 🙂 ich freue mich, dass Dir diese Interpretation gefällt. Auch Dir ein schönes Jahr 2021, hoffentlich mit Konzert Besuche!
thank you for playing this beautiful piece, i'm playing this piece right now and i've really been struggling to play with emotions on the cello and how you played this piece has encouraged me
Thanks for posting such a beautiful music which my heart feels the pain in the beginning, the hopeful middle part and the serenity and acceptance at the end part. I am a cello music lover. Bravo for you both madame and your assisting pianist!
3 роки тому+1
Thank you Norvi for this nice comment, I am happy you like it 🎶
@ Me too Nadège, I just found some information and high-quality pictures of the painting on this cello. When I first saw you playing it, I was so impressed by the way it look and how heart-broken it sound, and then now I findout it was a stunning treasure. I'm happy that I can encourage you, I was a painter but can play violin and piano, I experience sometimes practice seem so overwhelming ;). But look how amazing performance you have done! Please keep moving forward, you will be the master someday for sure!
There is a divinely noble sensibility to Gabriel Faure's sense of melody and movement within the music. The structure is so well established but feels so free flowing. It just hits... different than anything else I've ever heard. We need more composer with these kind of skills but I fear that the world may be lacking the power in imagination that features so strongly in Faure's and his pupils works and styles.
I was working, fully concentrated, when suddenly I stopped because of the beauty of that passage, from 1:09 to 1:36, in which after low note chromatic movements on the piano and anxious wandering from the cello, both land softly on the relative major E flat. It's so beautiful :-)
My dad once told me that this piece is like the aftermath of receiving the news of someone's death:
You are angry at the beginning, then you sing the same song again, this time wistful... Then at the 'sempre molto adagio' section, you imagine that you might as well give up - that there is no life. When you reach the next 'a tempo' you are changing your style and trying to think on the bright side of things, and whistling a wayward tune. Afterwards, your thoughts spiral in all directions, fast and unstoppable before you finally reach the last repetition of the mourning keen that you were crying at the beginning. Only this time it is the loudest yet, screaming for attention and from grief. The ending is full of sadness, regret and heartache but it is in the similar style to the wayward tune a few minutes ago: it is like you are hoping that you will be able to see that 'bright side' soon, but not now...
Even if Faure didn't write this after his wife died, there is so much raw emotion (which you are displaying amazingly) that this is clearly a piece of lamentation.
Beautiful, thank you for sharing 🙏
@ Melisande, pure laine. Nadège comprend. Et elle comprend, surtout, jusqu'à quel point comment "comprendre c'est pardonner."
➡
↪...if you can even assign extraneous words to Symbolist poetry. And much less: if you dare even attempt to describe in words Fauré's mastery of all things musical, expressed via a "heart that bleeds purple"....
...
Il suffit de dire que votre jeu ici, Nadège, m'a attéré. "Melisande." Détenteur de nos désirs les plus légitimes. Et puis la tentative... Finalement poignardés trois fois; comme rituellement. Je reste bouche-bée.
Il faut écouter Bach. Le choeur d'ouverture de "Wie schön leuchtet der Morgenstern" par la Bachstiftung CH. Et oui, voilà. Mark (usa)
My cello teacher gave a similar interpretation, he said that at the end even the happy wayward tune has turned sour as it has gone to the relative minor: the memories of the good times can no longer be thought about without sadness. Such a beautiful piece, and beautifully played, thank you.
An elegie in poetry is actually a poem that talks about someone dead. So yeah, this is exactly that
Fauré actually wrote this piece for his friend’s death!
When my father died somewhat suddenly last year, this is the piece I selected for the service. He and I both love the cello. I was too overwhelmed at the time to practice, but I'll perform it on his cello for his upcoming birthday that he won't be able to attend in person :(
Thanks for your moving rendition. You bring out the core of this piece; I am in a paddle of tears every time I am listening to it. Thank you.
Thank you Henner for this moving message, I imagine that this is what I love about music, it connects the human beings through shred emotions. I am sorry about your dad, and wish you all the best.
It is very painful when a loved one leaves earth!!
But never leaves the one’s he or she loves.. there are sooo many things to say and understand about our departures ! Cause everyone of us will leave this earth without taking with him or her a single possession except their feelings of love and what they have learned on themselves and others..
I performed that wonderful piece of music in 1977 together with my mother, who accompanied me on the piano ... one year after the sudden death of my father, her beloved husband.
I was only 14 then, and played Cello for only few years, so the Elegie was maybe a bit too difficult for me, or let's say challenging. But I think my Cello teacher, lovely Mrs Ana Maria Maldonado, chose that piece especially for us ... as an outlet for our grief, our sorrow 😞
As both a cellist and a pianist . . . This was well done! Well phrased. Voicing superb. I love how the piano gets out of the way of the cello when the cello has the melody. Excellent tempo. Intonation, vibrato, all excellent. I was not expecting something so good and was very pleasantly surprised! Pianist did a fantastic job of bringing out the important inner melodies without being overpowering. BRAVO!!!!
Every now and again, I come back and listen to this and feel happy and sad at the same time. So beautiful
4:30-438 and that kids is precisely why it's so important to practice our scales!!
😉
Hahaha, Well said.
It’s wonderful to hear you actually play real Pianissimos that are full of energy and dare I say a glimmer of hope. ❤️
Thank you Scott!! 🙏🎶
I second this! The perfect bar 6 ❤ and an even better bar 18! 🙌🏻
Una interpretazioni meravigliosa, sentita, profonda. Complimenti!!
"actually"
This works as music therapy for me. Long ago when I was a high school student I could never figure out why I was always so good at the cello. I never thought that I was playing my emotions out. Now that I'm older I am just realized that I was just trying to deal with my trauma. And picking up the cello helped me release tension. Love this.
Thank you for sharing Brenda 🙏💕
music helps.... the "vibrations", and good ones attract other good ones. as a Reiki healer as i got more into this realised this is all going on.
Absolutely amazing😊❤
I came to this because my 11 yr old son’s cello teacher set it for him (I’m a professional violinist and was dreaming of the day he would play it! I accompany him on the piano). This quickly became our favourite version because of the fantastic control and lack of over-sentimentality which actually makes it hit all the more emotionally because the music speaks for itself and it’s real. Then, two days ago we heard that my son’s teacher, Michal Kaznowski (cellist of the Maggini Quartet) has passed away and we are devastated. I will help him finish learning it and now we play it for him. 😢 RIP Michał
The last six inches of the bow is a dagger to the heart.
-Benjamin Zander
Such a beautiful performance! I also love the angels on the cello!
Thanks Brianna :) the cello is called Ex Vatican Strad you can read about it here en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ex_Vatican_Stradivarius
@ incroyable! quelle une belle violoncelle
I also love the angels on the cello
Magnifique, je l'ai entendue aujourd'hui lorsque les jeunes ont dansé sur la glace avec cette élégie lors des jo de Pékin, et cette musique est un enchantement. Merci à Gabriel Fauré.
Merci Ginette 🙏
oh my god the part at 4:35 is absolutely gorgeous. i honestly can’t even accurately describe how that part makes me feel it’s just soooooooo beautiful
🙏🙏
Très belle interprétation pleine de puissance et de nostalgie. Une respiration parfaite entre le piano et le violoncelle. Beaucoup d'espace, d'interiorité et de passion. Bravo.
Merci Charles 🙏
Magnifique. Mon compositeur favoris et mes 2 instruments préférés 🤩✨✨✨
I can't stop watching/listening this video. It is such a great performance by two young musicians. Malgorzata Garstka, does also a great job at the piano.
WOW!!!!! An absolute fan over here!!!!
Wow!
I just lost almost 7 minutes of my life in the most spectacular way possible!
The rawness and emotional feeling of this performance was sublime.
Thank you for bringing this into existence. X
This piece hits me right in the heart.
🙏 It is also one of my favourite of all pieces for cello and piano
Fauré is definitely one of my many classical favorites. Beautiful performance, Nadège. Thank you
Wow so wonderful performance!
I am now sixteen and have played cello for five years now. I'm so exited that my teacher said that she can now teach me this piece of music.
Thanks Linsku, I wish you lots of fun learning this piece!
I must have watched it a hundred times since yesterday. I especially enjoy the flight from 4.30 on. Beautiful, thank you ! And very nice instrument !
Thank you 🙏🙏
I just love this piece, It's so mellancolic and kind of tell us a sad story. I love how it's possible to easily understand this story just with notes and emotion
It is exactly why this is one of my favourite work, it tells so much in a short time 🙏🙏🎶
C'est beau à en pleurer ! Je n'ai pas les mots pour dire ce que je ressens quand j'écoute ce morceau ! C'est juste... magnifique et triste à la fois !
Merci Catherine 🙏🙏
I like the rich tone and soulful interpretation. Thanks for the lovely performance.
Beautiful. I can’t tell you how many times I’ve listened to this. 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾
I'm happy that you like it Chizoba 🙂🙏
Favorite song by faure. This was a great watch.
Thanks 🙏🙂
beautifully played! thank you...O! Faure! such beautiful gifts he left us...
Una interpretazioni meravigliosa, sentita, profonda. Complimenti!!
This is amongst my favorite pieces by Faure, who is also on my short list of favorite composers. Your interpretation is exquisite. You manage to coax and tease out of it every ounce of the profound beauty and emotion Faure put in. It's an extraordinary performance that speaks directly to my heart, and now whenever I wish to listen to the Elegie I find that yours is the version I want to hear. Thank you for this wonderful gift. 🙏
Thank you B Lyndon for your kind and encouraging comment 🙏🙂
This is the best version of this piece on youtube !!
Thanks Megan 🙏🎻
Nadège Rochat I have just perform this piece this morning and thank you soooo much for replying
Absolutely love this piece. I learned it four years ago and I adore your playing of it, gives me chills still!
Thank you! I continue to love this piece too, after all these years 💜
I am working on this piece and just cannot get the emotion work like you did here. Well done.
Thank you 🙏🙏
I researched what elegie means and that is how I found out it is a sad piece with sad emotion.
Both these young ladies have so much soul. They do a musical giant the justice his genius deserves 🙏
Thank you Jim 🙏🙏
This is the most beautiful rendition of the piece I have ever heard. You are definitely one of my new cello role models now 😊. Thank you for this, you brightened my entire week! I am learning this piece right now and you inspired me to keep pushing the boundaries of sound and dynamics.
Thank you Chloe! Enjoy the practice 🙂 if you would like any tips, you are welcome to PM me using the contact formular on my website.
I must agree.
La musique de Fauré est magnifique, mais là, on atteint au merveilleux avec une artiste au violoncelle qui est tout simplement sublime.
Elle est belle, ses gestes sont d’une grande beauté, et dès les deux premières mesures le charme me saisit… il faut que je revienne au début pour ne plus me séparer de Nadège. Tomber amoureux de cette musique, sans aucun doute, mais aussi sans aucune honte de Nadège.
Le matin, je suis avec elle, et le soir elle m’enchante de la musique et de son violoncelle. Toute mon admiration Nadège…à ce soir…. P. R.
🙏merci
Out of every version of the piece I’ve seen on UA-cam your one has got to be the best! So talented
Thank you Vincent 🙏🙏
Excellent, très émouvant, une très subtile sensibilité ! Bravo et merci.
such interesting fact about the piece in the description! you played it beautifully, bravo!
Merveilleuse interprétation, merci.
That cello is absolutely stunning.
There is something about the French and cello that produces the most wonderful music, Poulenc is another favourite
Nadège, salut… 🤗
La magnifique Elègie de Fauré est dans mes oreilles depuis un certain temps, et finalement je suis revenue ici, après si longtemps, et j'ai écouté cette belle musique et votre interprétation sensible.
C'était un délice en ce beau dimanche matin. Merci beaucoup à toi et à Malgorzata pour ce délice. 🌹❤️🌹
The 5 stages of grief in a piece
Tout simplement MAGNIFIQUE. Tout en sensibilité et en émotion. Bravo! Et Merci
Merci Jean-Pierre 🙏
Delightful warm playing, and the tone of the lighting was suitable too...harsh lights on the player, the wood, can overwhelm with brightness.
Thanks Zaroff I'm happy you like the intimate lightings, it feels better with less direct spots 🙂 🙏
This piece is so beautiful, great playing, and I would like to point out how unique that cello is with the angles on it!
Angles? Angels?
@eugeneclasby518 if you look closely, you can see them painted on either side towards the top.
@@SimonIsaCello Thank you for pointing that out.
Enjoyable to hear. Your cello is also quite a piece of artwork. I love this piece with all the phrases and emotions that go with the composition.
Ces’t un délice votre interpretación. Merci/ the pianist est aussi magnifique
Merci Javier !
Gabriel. It’s my son’s Christian name and it was given after Gabriel Fauré whose music is so délicate. There is no other requiem but Fauré’s. Here, I am amazed and stunned by the Way these 2 young women perform this piece. Absolutely brilliant.
Bravo! Such an emotional performance!
Maravillosa, que gusto encontrar tanto virtuosismo, mis mejores deseos de éxitos desde Colombia
Gracias 🙏🙏🙂
this was a beautiful rendition of this piece- thank you for it!
happy you liked it!
Wow! Beautiful, exquisite presentation by both artists. Delicate, precise, passionate, mournful... just magnificent!🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟
Thank you 🙏
Wow, this is amazing. I'm learning this piece for a competition in a few months and this is my favorite recording so far.
Thanks Jay 🙏🙂
Nadège, this is so beautiful!! Thanks so much for sharing!
Thanks Hidekazu!
This musicalways touches my soul
Learning this piece at the moment it’s beautiful
Got here after searching "Faure," who I'd never heard of. I'm an amateur with classical music, mostly listen to Tchaikovsky, and did a search on "melodic composers" and one lady in a chat mentioned Faure offhand. Of the 20 or so I've sampled, I like him best with Tchaikovsky. And this is the best version I've found of the Elegy.
Thank you Dean I'm happy that Fauré came your way 🙂 he is also one of my favourite composers and especially this piece is very close to my heart. It is worth listening to his requiem too (especially the last piece Im paradisum), his Berceuse, and his trio. Enjoy!
@ Wow. ua-cam.com/video/nS9W8BnVeVM/v-deo.html
첼로도 잘하지만 피아노가 너무 잘 맞춰주네요 너무듣기좋았습니다
:)
Amazing! So great interpretation and beautiful sound
Thank you Diego
Awesome 👏
🙏
gorgeous touching outstanding nowords
🙏🙏
Yes, emotion and composers' alleged feeling while writing. This whole thing is a myth. A composer may feel anything at all related to the emotional impression of a piece he or she is writing. In fact, Tschaikovsky wrote extensively about this topic. Firstly, he said that he had no idea why a particular piece seemed to evoke a particular emotion. It is well known that when he wrote the deeply tragic final movement of the Pathetique his friends observed him to be the happiest they had ever seen him. Things are not always what they seem. This is a deeply moving experience. Thank you so much.
Thank you Daniel, and I am happy that you agree 🙂🎶
@UCuFzdt_i1rgcXCgPIn-XUIQ Thanks for your very prompt response. I thought of another mismatch between a composer's feeling and the feeling evoked by the music. It is the famous intermezzo to Cavaleria Rustica. To paraphrase he said when asked: I thought it would be fun to write and when I did I had a lot of fun just writing it. Now this piece is so serious and reverent. What a contradiction!
Wonderfully playing 👏👏
thank you 🙏
...💐👌🙏👏🧚♀️📹🎧... exquisite video.. Compliment all involved.. so when is the next one..😊..
On distingue des anges sur votre violoncelle. Je comprends mieux maintenant l'expression "être aux anges..." car je devine dans quel état d'extase ils sont mis grâce à votre sonorité superbe
Merci 🙏🙏
Nadège, hi…
Fauré’s exquisitely beautiful Elègie has been in my ears for some time, and eventually I came here, again, after so long time, and listened to this beautiful music, and your sensitive performance.
It was a delight on this beautiful Sunday morning. Thank you and to Malgorzata so much for this delight. 🌹❤️🌹
I'm accompanying a friend on this piece for an exam in March and it's one of the most beautiful pieces ever! Amazing interpretation, thank you!
Thanks StrawB 🙏🙂
This is the best version I've ever heard.
Thank you so much for your passion.
Thanks Beu! 🙏🙏
Superb, magnificent musicians. Than you.
Thank you Jay :)
Wonderful interpretation Thank you .. helping my practice
Thank you Nigel
I caught the end of this piece in the car home today. Had to listen to the whole thing. Music has a way of expressing emotion that is beyond articulation.
This is a wonderful, touching performance! And not sappy at all, like so many performances, thank you!
I’ve been reading Dostoyevsky’s Crime and Punishment. I’m almost finished with the novel, but even at this point it’s clearly the best thing I’ve read up to this point in my life. Transformative reading is what I might call it. While reading the novel, I can’t help but think of this song. It’s become the theme to the novel in my mind. It’s almost eerie how well the song’s mood matches up with that of the novel. Thank you for this hauntingly beautiful music.
Thanks Theeab for sharing, I think thatbit goes wonderfully with Crime and Punishment, you are absolutely right!
This magnificent performance she plays with exquisite skill and incomparable technique and beautiful attire is beyond description , and full of admiration and emotion , and comfortable to the ear and the mind
Thank you Shin-i-chi 🙏
@
You are welcome
Good luck ！
Go for it
Hallo Nadège, zuerst habe ich auf englisch kommentiert, was wie ich gerade herausgefunden habe gar nicht notwendig ist. Das ist eine schöne Abwechslung. Ich kenne (bzw. sehe) sonst nur englischsprachige Künstler auf UA-cam. Mir gefällt deine Interpretation gut - vielen Dank fürs hochladen. Danke auch für Deine Videobeschreibung. Ich habe das darin erwähnte Video mit dem "berühmten Lehrer" gesehen und hatte bis eben auch die Geschichte mit Faurés Frau im Kopf, wenn ich das Stück gehört habe. Ich wünsche Dir einen guten Rutsch und alles gute für 2021!
Danke lieber Dominic! Ja Deutsch geht auch 🙂 ich freue mich, dass Dir diese Interpretation gefällt. Auch Dir ein schönes Jahr 2021, hoffentlich mit Konzert Besuche!
thank you for playing this beautiful piece, i'm playing this piece right now and i've really been struggling to play with emotions on the cello and how you played this piece has encouraged me
Thanks Arielle 🙏🙏
Suono bellissimo, grande intensità ed espressività, bravissima..
Grazie Alessandro!
excellent excellent
Thanks for posting such a beautiful music which my heart feels the pain in the beginning, the hopeful middle part and the serenity and acceptance at the end part. I am a cello music lover. Bravo for you both madame and your assisting pianist!
Thank you Norvi for this nice comment, I am happy you like it 🎶
Bravo❤❤❤🤗
Just wonderful playing!
Thank you
I love Faure Elegie thank you😍
🙏🙂
This is, honestly, the most wonderful, beautiful cello performance that I heard so far. Thanks you for your hard work to get such skillful!
Thank you Do Alma 🙏 I am very happy that you precieve it that way, it is very encouraging :)
@ Me too Nadège, I just found some information and high-quality pictures of the painting on this cello. When I first saw you playing it, I was so impressed by the way it look and how heart-broken it sound, and then now I findout it was a stunning treasure. I'm happy that I can encourage you, I was a painter but can play violin and piano, I experience sometimes practice seem so overwhelming ;). But look how amazing performance you have done! Please keep moving forward, you will be the master someday for sure!
There is a divinely noble sensibility to Gabriel Faure's sense of melody and movement within the music. The structure is so well established but feels so free flowing. It just hits... different than anything else I've ever heard. We need more composer with these kind of skills but I fear that the world may be lacking the power in imagination that features so strongly in Faure's and his pupils works and styles.
😂😂😂I agree monsieur
Very tender performance, Brava!
Thank you Gia 🙏
Learning this piece at the moment, and using your gorgeous interpretation as reference ❤
Amazing performance!
Thanks Maggie 🙏
Muito Belíssima está melodia e bela interpretação...
Grazie Marcos 🙏
such a beautiful song! it is a pleasure listening to you two! thanks for sharing this video...
🙏🙏 🙂
I love this piece. Fantastic and emotional playing!
Thank you 🙏🙏
Sonuna kadar dinlemek bir zevkti.. harika yorum.
me encanta tu interpretación de elegie ♥
Gracias Jesus 🙏
I cry every time.
It makes me happy every time
I was working, fully concentrated, when suddenly I stopped because of the beauty of that passage, from 1:09 to 1:36, in which after low note chromatic movements on the piano and anxious wandering from the cello, both land softly on the relative major E flat. It's so beautiful :-)
Glad this music speaks to you too :) 🙏
She made cello cry
So beautiful - many thanks.
Thank you Martin 🙏
Sublime ✨🙌👏. La plus belle interpretation de ce chef d'oeuvre. Je travaille sur cette piece et vous etes une source d inspiration inegalee ❤
Bravo! bellas muchachas
🙏🙂 Gracias
absolutely beautiful! you touched my heart❤
Thanks Koen!
Faure wrote this piece shortly after , his beloved wife died. Every decent cellist should know this , and play it accordingly.
@@heathermcdougall8023 he got married with Marie Frémet 3 years after writing this piece, and she outlived him...