"CURSE ON THE GYPSIES" --- Part 1 of 2 (Excellent Documentary!!)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 28 вер 2024
  • "Curse on the Gypsies" is a one hour History Channel Documentary that aired in the late 1990's and then quickly disappeared, becoming unavailable and out of print. It tells the story of how Linguists traced the historical roots and true origin of the Gypsies back to their original homeland. A fascinating look at the history of the Roma culture over the last thousand years. Watch now before the video disappears again.
    This video is from a 1990's videotape recording of the TV program. The videotape was copied to DVD, then the DVD was copied to the Computer and the MP4 video file downloaded to UA-cam.
    See Part 2 here: • "Curse on the Gypsies"...
    Sorry, Part 3 failed to upload after several attempts.
    I review comments but I do not get involved in a battle of opinions. Watch the movie for information and learning purposes. Realize that Poverty and oppression can force people to live outside of society's rules in a quest for survival. So do not judge, criticize, and generalize a race of people until you walk in their shoes, or bare feet as the case may be.

КОМЕНТАРІ • 2,7 тис.

  • @havis4ever407
    @havis4ever407 2 роки тому +673

    In 1920 a caravan of Gypsies were passing thru my family’s town. One day they approached my Great Grandmother and asked if she could help feed their baby. She agreed to help and they left their beautiful infant daughter with her. Promising to come back for her. They never came back and that beautiful baby became my Aunt Dot. One of the best, most wonderful people I’ve ever known. Our family still treasures the pretty little orange dress with red embroidery she was wearing that day.

    • @havis4ever407
      @havis4ever407 2 роки тому +22

      @Win that’s exactly right! Just more love!

    • @Fastandslow715
      @Fastandslow715 Рік тому +17

      Hi , Do you have photo of that dress?

    • @Fastandslow715
      @Fastandslow715 Рік тому +19

      Gypsies's ancestors and my ancestors use to live together

    • @GalacticTechTrails
      @GalacticTechTrails Рік тому +8

      Wow!

    • @alixalix191
      @alixalix191 Рік тому +8

      How do you say they never came back but you still have your aunt??? You confused me ma'am

  • @rocioaguilera3613
    @rocioaguilera3613 6 років тому +731

    I disagree with many of the commenters. I was born in Mexico city, and when I was about ten, I met a group of gypsies who lived in a big old house ( I don't know if rented or their own) a couple of blocks from my house
    They befriended me and my friends and invited us to eat with them.
    They didn't have any furniture in their living room, but carpets and cushions, where they sat to eat.
    The women were house keepers, and most of the men worked in a nearby garden as gardeners and manteinance workers.
    They never stole anything from us, and they entertained us with tales of magic.
    My mom told me to invite them to our house and so I did. They were honest and reliable friends.

    • @Cuetzpallincihuatl
      @Cuetzpallincihuatl 6 років тому +14

      Rocío Aguilera ..... Lovely ❤️‼️

    • @sterlinghayden4096
      @sterlinghayden4096 6 років тому +1

      S K thank you. Little ass is probably 13 yrs old.

    • @oldman9843
      @oldman9843 6 років тому +5

      I am sure glad no other races do that . Think about how uneducated you sound .

    • @chrisadams1025
      @chrisadams1025 6 років тому +20

      S K I’m a American gypsy my family came on the boat from Romania all though I choose to deal with people in my community only there are many gadre aka non gypsies that are close members of the family and are considered family once we accept you your family for life I speak for American gypsies can’t speak for the tem aka gypsies from other places then the us

    • @jasgleeson8745
      @jasgleeson8745 6 років тому +5

      off the grid people

  • @deniselkaz8259
    @deniselkaz8259 5 років тому +441

    We are ppl. There are good roma and there are bad roma. There are good people and there are bad people, human. Peace and love around the world

  • @kennethkellogg5886
    @kennethkellogg5886 6 років тому +925

    Can we all agree that what has happened to the history channel over the years is nothing short of a crime!?

    • @narcissismrehabilitation
      @narcissismrehabilitation 4 роки тому +19

      Kenneth Kellogg I concur.

    • @joeyo4163
      @joeyo4163 4 роки тому +53

      I don't even subscribe to cable no more cause it's mostly trash..

    • @ivydaniels1
      @ivydaniels1 4 роки тому +16

      Agreed

    • @freakymalik
      @freakymalik 4 роки тому +6

      amene to that

    • @mpcc2022
      @mpcc2022 4 роки тому +36

      It's due to the democratization of media. Now almost every American has TV and cable in their home, so now the History Channels programs must appeal to a wider general audience. Since, no matter how unsettling the fact, there are differences in people. The democratization of media has had the unintended consequences of killing artistic quality. If you want something that's of quality, then don't make it something 'everyone' can appreciate and understand-- don't democratize it. "For everyone or for all" equals of no aesthetic value. UA-cam has higher quality media, because one person or a few people are expressing what they find valuable this has its negative consequences, but it's also the formulation that facilitates high quality media.

  • @ferencfarkas2729
    @ferencfarkas2729 Рік тому +96

    Iam a proud Roma ❤ 🙏 .. and it’s a miracle that we survived as humans and our language music dance our culture survived with us with out a country since the 10th century while we were hunted down slaved tortured mass murded that’s us 💪🏼 ❤ 🙏 .. and I love all of our tribes ❤

    • @ccn8741
      @ccn8741 Рік тому +3

      Yes Frank tell the world the whole truth we've sufferd

    • @_demonkiller_
      @_demonkiller_ Рік тому +1

      Sa O Roma, babo babo, sa O Roma odaje

    • @jasonmaki2343
      @jasonmaki2343 Рік тому

      ​@@ccn8741is

    • @adilaa545
      @adilaa545 Рік тому +3

      Probably the most peacefull culture , to think they never gone to war in so many centuries . The only thing Is that i wonder what Is the filosofy that kept so many pepole together for so long.

    • @mariebarr1745
      @mariebarr1745 Рік тому +3

      I'm from the uk and whenever the gypsy ladies would knock on the door selling pegs , ribbons and lace my mum would always buy some and invite them in for tea and cake 🙂 ❤

  • @shree709
    @shree709 4 роки тому +90

    Two years ago when the RomaTaxi
    driver in Bucharest almost understood my conversation with my wife in the
    native tongue of Rajasthan, a north western state, I decided to spend time on
    this and find out how.. According to records Roma left India around 1050. They
    were the tired soldiers of the army of great Rajput King Prithviraj Chauhan who
    fought 17 wars with Mahmood gajnavi. All Roma belong to warrior tribes. They
    did not want to fight and some went west and some went down to south India
    where they still are in their red and yellow colour clothes and huge moustache.
    On the way,Roma took words from Persian (like bibi for Kaki) and many other
    tongues including Greek( drost for road). They somehow lost their last names of
    fine Rajput warrior tribes . Roma may try to find surnames like Sisodia,
    Chauhan, Shekhawat, Nainavat etc. But they kept first Indian names until 19th
    century like Bihari and his daughter Panna of Romania, both great musicians.
    Today Roma use many of the words from Rajasthani, Hindi and of Sanskrit origin.
    Few are ek do trin yak nak bal angusth bersh diwas sassu sussro saalo Sali
    chora chori cior(chor) gia sov kammes thalle upral purano maal and so on.
    Romani words are from pre Muslim era in India and hence pure Sanskrit lik hiv
    for snow or ice.Please go to the following in UA-cam to see more. “Romani an
    Indo Aryan Language” and “Roma girl from Kosovo finds her roots in India” All
    Roma had moustache which was necessary for Rajput warriors. Purity codes of
    Roma are still practiced in India like a lady not entering the kitchen during
    few days of the month. Roma break the plate if animal licks it. My mother used
    to give them to beggars. Roma had also carried our proverbs like” while
    choosing a daughter in law believe your ears more than eyes” meaning reputation
    of the girls family was more important than her beauty. Would native Europeans
    choose a daughter in law? Roma eventually lost their religion but Sara kali of
    southern France has favourite Rajput deity of Goddess kali. The deity is
    immersed in water body like we do in Rajasthan. “ Dr. HancockDr. Ian Hancock:
    Keynote Address at Romani Studies Conference, UC Berkeley There should be no
    doubt that Roma are our lost pral and Pena. Hats off to them to keep the
    language and culture alive even after 50 generations while we melt away in two
    generations. Any Roma may communicate with me on shree709@gmail.com
    I am a 65 years old factory owner from Hyderabad, India originating from
    Rajasthan where Roma come from.

    • @georgivekilski3054
      @georgivekilski3054 4 роки тому +13

      It is very happy that you noticed us, I hope the Indians and the Gypsies unite soon.

    • @shree709
      @shree709 4 роки тому +8

      @@georgivekilski3054 I have read so much about Roma. I am in regular contact with an Italian Roma Adriano, who calls me kakosa. I know so much about you all.
      I am sure you are part of us. From Rajasthan or Rajputana as it was known.
      Other parts of India have nothing in common. It is only one state in India.
      I have a Roma maid ( who came to South India during same time) and I exchange her words with Adriano. Hundreds are same.
      We lost them as our family left Rajasthan only 100 years ago. You maintain the classic language.
      Best of luck.

    • @shree709
      @shree709 4 роки тому +7

      @x y I have given talks on this subject to interested groups, mostly with Rajasthani origin.
      Please read about Prithviraj Chauhan and generally on Rajputs. You will be proud of your ancestry.
      I am not a Rajput but from trader community of Rajasthan, while you are from warrior or soldier community. Any king has to be a Rajput anywhere in India.
      Write to me for any question.

    • @georgivekilski3054
      @georgivekilski3054 4 роки тому +2

      @@shree709The Rajputs are patriots and soldiers from North India, sir, which I don't understand why the great Prithviraj Chauhan spared Muhammad Ghori when he defeated him in battle 18 times. This means that he was a great leader who made the wrong decision about his enemy. I should have killed Muhammad long before.

    • @shree709
      @shree709 4 роки тому +6

      @@georgivekilski3054 Yes. You are right. An enemy should not be spared no matter weak or strong.
      The history also says that after 18th war Prithviraj Chauhan was captured by Ghori and blinded. Later Ghori wanted to see his archery as a blind person who could send the arrow kust by noise without seeing the object.
      And he killed Ghori in this demonstration.

  • @donitaforrest9064
    @donitaforrest9064 2 роки тому +124

    My favourite book of all time? "The Gypsies" by Jan Yoors. At age 17 in the 1970's it was a second bible to me, alone & on my own in the world. Valuable lessons about indifference to the material world & acquiring possessions.

    • @kathymiller9329
      @kathymiller9329 2 роки тому +6

      I want to check out that book now! Thank you!

    • @JohnSmith-rk6jy
      @JohnSmith-rk6jy 2 роки тому

      What’s it about?

    • @eileenhavern77
      @eileenhavern77 2 роки тому +4

      Love the idea 'indifference to the material world'... Wise!

    • @donitaforrest9064
      @donitaforrest9064 2 роки тому +8

      @@JohnSmith-rk6jy It's the true story about a young european boy, the son of artists, who by a fluke of fate becomes the adopted son of a family of gypsies & lives with them for many years, while still maintaining contact with his parents. It's about the lifestyle & value system, the ways of survival of these gypsies & the various gypsies family groups they meet along the way. It's about freedom & adventure & an unshackled love of life. He also wrote two more books on gypsies: the Gypsies of Spain, with lots of photos, and, Crossings about WWII & coming to America.

    • @trishasgypsyjournal8162
      @trishasgypsyjournal8162 2 роки тому +2

      Thanks for the recommendation I’m gonna check this book out! My father came from gypsy decent…I didn’t know him well…my mom took me to another state to keep me away from my fighting, partying, bad gypsy family! I wish I had known them better…especially my father…he was a different kinda a man with little to no education…with 22 brothers and sisters I know he had a rough life!

  • @cuteladybug8622
    @cuteladybug8622 6 років тому +540

    I can honestly say that from my own experience people will take advantage of you the first chance they get, and it makes no difference what race they are. Conning people, scamming people and getting over on people; is a problem in all races. I watched my dad, a kind, generous man; get taken advantage of all the time. Race doesn't matter.

  • @validesultana
    @validesultana 2 роки тому +131

    My grandfather was raised by gypsies, and he had his physical features, his way of dressing, he even wore gold jewelry. I believe that he was the son of gypsies and that when he lost his parents he was raised by the rest of his family, an aunt or something like that.

    • @shanny4306
      @shanny4306 2 роки тому +8

      You should get help to find his history , you’d be very happy to learn it .

    • @kasturipillay6626
      @kasturipillay6626 2 роки тому +2

      Your ancestors are Indian 😁

    • @validesultana
      @validesultana 2 роки тому +7

      @@kasturipillay6626 If you're right! He had that phenotype, brown skin, green eyes, not very tall, and thin. I had never analyzed him that way. I'm happy about that !!! 🙏😂

    • @kasturipillay6626
      @kasturipillay6626 2 роки тому +1

      @@validesultana 🥳🥳🥳👍

    • @Dougland214
      @Dougland214 2 роки тому +7

      @@validesultana that is why I realized that I was Roma 2% of the population has hazel eyes and of course being thin with curves and arched eyebrows Fuller lips darker complexion. I did hear that they DNA tested to the Atlantis region Neolithic era, which is where Hazel and blue eyes black hair blonde and redhead originated genetically. so I'm wondering if that wasn't the actual origin then start migration towards India and then back up again

  • @harleyholloway6893
    @harleyholloway6893 2 роки тому +51

    For the past 10 years I have been friends with a Romani family they are some of the greatest people I've ever met in my life they would do anything for you I have gotten so close with one of them that I call him my uncle I love the Romani culture I love listening to them speak in their native tongue I have had dinners with them we have gone out together they have made me feel like I'm one of the family

  • @HoboRoadrunner
    @HoboRoadrunner 2 роки тому +72

    I am a traveling train riding hitchhiking hobo. I can understand and relate to most of what the Roma have had to go threw as we hobos are treated the same way. LEOs harassing because we ain't part of their town, people turning you down for work when they supposedly need people. People thinking they can go threw your stuff when ever they want ect. It's infuriating but I live a free life style that only most people can dream of.

    • @SANTANA1deep
      @SANTANA1deep Рік тому +6

      I would love to hear more, my friend. 🙏🏾

    • @mst7155
      @mst7155 Рік тому +5

      To the Texas Roadrunner: the blues music sometimes tells the story of a hobo...Are there still real " hobos" in the USA? It needs a lot of courage to be constantly on the road... And the solitude!!!

    • @joejones9520
      @joejones9520 Рік тому +1

      I rode trains like that a couple of times yrs ago, it was fun but not fun enough to want to do as a lifestyle.

    • @jeanlawson9133
      @jeanlawson9133 Рік тому

      Even Hobos have a cellphone and internet.... AIN'T IT JUST AIN'T IT 😜 lols.... I use to Hobo trains around the hills of Virginia... I knew there schedule.... Mostly Coal trains and timber and lumber in around the Coalmines and Coal camp.... Just so happens the lumber yard was near my destination as where the Coal was being delivered as well 😎...

    • @kati1017
      @kati1017 11 місяців тому

      How do you eat?

  • @pawanraj9475
    @pawanraj9475 3 роки тому +374

    Back when History channel showed actual History . Now its a reality show channel

    • @StopFear
      @StopFear 3 роки тому +7

      Just now? Lol it’s been a reality show channel more than a decade

    • @alexiswaller3065
      @alexiswaller3065 2 роки тому +5

      I now call them the hillbilly channel

    • @bohemianwriter1
      @bohemianwriter1 2 роки тому +5

      So the history of the persecution of the Roma people isn't "history"..
      So what's "history" by your defintion?

    • @bellad.1274
      @bellad.1274 2 роки тому +5

      You're right. Watch - Gypsy child theives documentary

    • @VeraDonna
      @VeraDonna 2 роки тому +1

      "Reality" show channel...

  • @destinyjourdan8945
    @destinyjourdan8945 4 роки тому +104

    I’m a Roma and I’m very proud of it. Opre!

    • @chazdemitro5356
      @chazdemitro5356 4 роки тому +1

      Con San??

    • @karanzed
      @karanzed 4 роки тому +3

      Punjabi girl 👏👏

    • @karanzed
      @karanzed 4 роки тому +2

      Con san means kaun se

    • @marketeagle6794
      @marketeagle6794 4 роки тому +5

      Indian people ✌️

    • @janetopre4530
      @janetopre4530 4 роки тому +4

      My last name is OPRE and my grandfather was from Northeast Hungary. I have no info other than that. I’ve always believed I had a Gypsy spirit but when I asked my father of the possibility.....I was basically told to shut up. Please message me if you have any info that might help me establish my roots

  • @antonvrb1510
    @antonvrb1510 2 роки тому +69

    i had heard all the stories, when a group of 4 horse drawn traditional wooden horse drawn carriges stopped to camp near my town. This was about 20 years ago in the UK. I went round the camp site armed with a massive block of cheese, 4 loaves of proper nice bread and 3 bottles of vodka. My only intention was to learn more about them. What a fun, drunken night! They treated the "tourist" so patiently and told me so many stories, knowing that,that is what i was there for. I walked the 3miles home and still had some tobacco left for the morning.

    • @linaleblanc8288
      @linaleblanc8288 2 роки тому +2

      I would enjoy hearing them tell stories too

    • @cynthiamarston2208
      @cynthiamarston2208 2 роки тому +3

      Nice way to explore!

    • @TREVASLARK
      @TREVASLARK 2 роки тому +3

      Lovely anecdote.

    • @Lyle-xc9pg
      @Lyle-xc9pg 2 роки тому +3

      Not the same people as in the east. We have a settlement of them right near me in russia 40 houses but there are hundreds live in shanty houses and many chldren literally smell like putrid grabage. Theyre also not lliterate. My area is considerd extremely dangerous for the city.

    • @monikasoffronow1717
      @monikasoffronow1717 2 роки тому +3

      @@Lyle-xc9pg No running water, no electricity, the working-age adults being shut out from the job market and the children from the local school system - you are right, that does produce dirty, smelly illiterate people...

  • @jenniferlopez1073
    @jenniferlopez1073 2 роки тому +148

    I love other cultures, have nothing against anyone. But let me tell you about when I was 17, I worked at a Sheraton hotel in Billings Mt. The gypsies rented out many floors as they were having a wedding. The other maid gave me one of their floors. I was pregnant with my first daughter so they thought they would be nice to me. They were, especially the grandma, who talked to me so long, when I went to my maids cart everything was stolen off it! Lol good memories

    • @kagimuhadijjah5685
      @kagimuhadijjah5685 2 роки тому +7

      Well i don't know much about gypsies but i wonder how they survive

    • @nickjash
      @nickjash 2 роки тому +8

      Lol At least they paid by renting the rooms. Tour groups and other hotel guests including hotel staff grab whatever they can off the carts, more often the high quality expendables.

    • @Maya_Pinion
      @Maya_Pinion 2 роки тому +7

      My Panni from Poland used to tell me that the "black Irish" had the same reputation ,kinda,as gypsies.....labeled people,just as today.✌️

    • @Beemer917
      @Beemer917 2 роки тому +40

      I went out with a gypsy girl for awhile.A genuine Hungarian speaking gypsy. She told me she was going to change peoples minds about gypsies cause everyone was wrong thinking they were thieves. Then she stole a hundred dollars from my sixteen year old son. Good times.

    • @DiamondDee7622
      @DiamondDee7622 2 роки тому +8

      Yeah working in a hotel that happens a lot 🤣

  • @Nikisright
    @Nikisright 2 роки тому +25

    I'm an American living in Romania for the last 8 years. There are many gypsies here. They do wear long skirts, they collect metal for the scrap yard, they live differently for sure, they are louder than the Romanians. I was almost robbed on the metro but being from Chicago I'm always on guard. I felt someone behind me on the train, felt a slight touch on my purse, and I turned to see a Romanian woman (not a gypsy) with her hand still in my purse. I yelled at her and pushed her. Because I spoke in English she backed away from me like I was from outer space, lol. I've never had any bad encounters with gypsies.

    • @huitrecouture
      @huitrecouture Рік тому

      And you know she wasn't a gypsy how? BECAUSE SHE WASN'T WEARING LONG SKIRTS? Moron.

    • @gabia.6213
      @gabia.6213 Рік тому +3

      How did you know it was Romanian?? Many gypsy are blonde...

    • @simonamihai7188
      @simonamihai7188 Рік тому +4

      True. Gypsies in Romania are dressed as romanians, not necessarily in those "long skirts" às you say. That behaviour, pickpocketing, is specific to gypsies.

    • @Nikisright
      @Nikisright Рік тому

      Maybe she was a gypsy. I didn't ask her, lol. As for wearing long skirts, many still do. I work with a few gypsies (they themselves say they are) and no, they are not wearing the long skirts.

  • @melancholygirl840
    @melancholygirl840 2 роки тому +60

    My ex son in law is Rom I found the culture fascinating!. I also was saddened for all they went through! I loved the food!! Speaking of music his brother is very famous in Bosnia as a musician.

    • @friknwulf5007
      @friknwulf5007 2 роки тому

      Long days and pleasants nights

    • @thomasbrown8468
      @thomasbrown8468 2 роки тому +1

      Cool. I know there is a community of this people in Huntsville Alabama

  • @kiritanJ
    @kiritanJ 6 років тому +75

    I grew up in Latvia in 1980s. there was a distinct Gypsy (Rrom, as I learned from this feature) neighborhood. They sold hashish for living. (I went there sometimes) I thought at that time that it was a scary neighborhood, but now that I recall it there was nothing scary but the occasional corrupt police raids. The people were nice and there were always flowers in their apartments.

    • @nerylhales1857
      @nerylhales1857 2 роки тому +3

      Idolising drug dealers? Great....

    • @kiritanJ
      @kiritanJ 2 роки тому +6

      @@nerylhales1857
      Which part of my comment gave you the idea to refer to it as "idolizing" ?

    • @minkorrh
      @minkorrh 2 роки тому +8

      @@nerylhales1857 The word 'apartment' should be your clue. To rent an apartment you need money either from work or .....selling hash. I'd prefer they sell hash than grift and steal. Is it ideal? No. Is it causing harm? Probably not much. My government sells hash.

  • @jaymanalang1188
    @jaymanalang1188 6 років тому +68

    Iam a filipino from philippines.Lately I've been wacthing documentaries among rohingya minorities of burma. Also heard of about gypsies stories of world war 2. How these people were slaughtered,massacred,persecuted that sort of things. Now, I've just got this question: "What's the difference between the corpse of a prince and the corpse of a gypsy??" Same thing as: "If a king died today,and a gypsy man died also. Would there be any difference between their dead bodies??" There will be no difference except that the dead king will be given a royal funeral with a lot of honors,while there's nothing on the gypsy man except the grieve of his loveones. We are all the same. No matter how genius a man is,,once he died there will be nothing of him.

    • @medusachristo3725
      @medusachristo3725 6 років тому

      Yes

    • @1yourboyken
      @1yourboyken 5 років тому +3

      the difference isn't the dead body the difference is a mans character. are they cheaters liars and beggars? seems that way

    • @allcounties7059
      @allcounties7059 5 років тому +1

      You are a person gypsy .the real name of gypsy in England needy boy I am . One must learn not what words say but what they mean religion come upon gypsy religion think gypsy not understand what they no for what the gypsy no would make most religions crumble should not a starving child just take if they are hungry instead of being offered should I ask a lord if I can drink at a riverside or should I just drink .my people forget where they come from because the last place we came from we got murdered we have always been moved on for 10 thousand years we have had to follow religion because if not we die all religion has forced my people's legs apart .because for who they are gods people .can you imagine the world if the church came out and said jesus was a gypsy and his people are the real gods people .any one who needs to no about religion should look in to Buddhist it's the closest thing to it

    • @kimzafra
      @kimzafra 5 років тому +1

      Bro live with them and see if you will still feel the same afterwards.

    • @allcounties7059
      @allcounties7059 5 років тому

      @@kimzafra Bro I have .never talk of the poor and their needs you will curse yourself and your family bro

  • @RickSuaz
    @RickSuaz 6 років тому +28

    I've met Gypsies in Spain... I gotta say they were pretty cool and super traditional with their guitar and a huge fire by the beach. People are people at the end of the day.

  • @CreekTribe
    @CreekTribe Рік тому +15

    I worked with a woman from India. I asked her if there were any Romany people still living in India-- like some that may have stayed behind or others who went back-- and she had no clue as to what I was talking about, nor has she ever heard of those people. She did say that 'if' there are Romanys still living in India, they would be living in the hills and outskirts of the main cities of Calcutta or Bombay. They referred to those particular people as 'Hill People'.

    • @Zodinthara-jo5yi
      @Zodinthara-jo5yi Рік тому +7

      She was almost right without a clue. But not the ' hill people' they refer to today, who are north easternrrs and have mongoloid features. But gypsies were ' hill people': of ancient central india, specifically Banjara Hills, which is now the poshest part of Hyderabad, Capital of Telangana State.

    • @CreekTribe
      @CreekTribe Рік тому +1

      @Zodinthara-jo5yi That is interesting. Are there any Romany people left in India though?

    • @Zodinthara-jo5yi
      @Zodinthara-jo5yi Рік тому +2

      @@CreekTribe No, not anymore. Those ancient people of Banjara Hills, were not exactly a tribe, but a caste. Which means they used to be from the mainstream society but according to some folktale, were condemned by the priest or king to roam around forever or until some particular time. It's is not strange as Hinduism can be very strang, like theres the thugees, from which the word thugs came, who were religiously condemned to rob and kill strangers by strangulation and have a seperate Goddess Bhavani. In the light of some aspect of Hinduism, I am not surprised by the fate of the Romany people too.

    • @CreekTribe
      @CreekTribe Рік тому +2

      @Zodinthara-jo5yi This is awesome! I'm completely amazed and yet blown away by all of this history I barely knew anything about.
      Most of the Gypsies that the United States is familiar with are the Romanchal. Which are a mixture of English and Romany --Not to insult your intelligence by any means. I've noticed that Romanchals do not have the Eastern Indian features, but more like Mediterranean. Often times, they will pass themselves off as Italian or Greek to avoid persecution.
      I used to watch that one series, My Big Fat American Gypsy Wedding, but I can't say for certain if those are real Gypsies. It's an interesting show....very 'Over the Top'.
      My father told me that even in the United States, many Eastern Europeans, along with the first generation Americans, will show disdain towards Gypsies; which he was correct about, because I've seen it first hand. I've been criticized for my refusal to share those prejudices with those from the Hungary-Romania region. When my grandparents were children in Appalachia, there were traveling showagons that would come through their towns. These showagons were huge in the early to mid 20th century, and they consisted of a variety of performance arts. Many Gypsies would travel with these Showagons, partaking in the activities. The locals were often warned to keep their children close because of the phrase "Here Come the Gypsies". And just like in this documentary, people used to believe that they stole children. That belief was definitely nationwide and not secluded.

    • @Buddhavibez
      @Buddhavibez 9 місяців тому +1

      Gypsies Are a mixture of ethnicities, hence they’re melanated in skin and eyes as in they’re not considered white.

  • @dublinpiper
    @dublinpiper 3 роки тому +73

    I noticed here and there, there are image of Irish travellers mixed in with Gypsies. This is wrong. Irish travellers are distinctly and ethnically Irish. Not Roma. Scotland has a very similar native traveller culture, set apart from the Irish. True, the Roma went to England, so English Gypsies are different to Irish Travellers. Of course there has been some inter-marriage down the centuries in the UK, but generally, Irish travellers do not mix with the Roma, who only really started arriving over here since the 1990s. Recently Irish travellers have actually been granted a special 'ethnic status' in Ireland - Due to them having distinct cultural traits (customs, language history) But many find that a bit over the top, to describe that as ethnically different. Connemara people in the West have hugely distinctive differences than say, Dublin people (language, folklore, customs, sea-faring traditions) So do the Ulster Scots of the North, yet we are all not recognised as having different etnicities. Unfortunately I think it all plays into Identity politics

    • @maryvitorelo572
      @maryvitorelo572 2 роки тому +2

      The Irish Gypsies were called Tinkers.

    • @SebNutter
      @SebNutter 2 роки тому +14

      Not quite right. We've had Romany Gypsies in England for centuries. They tend to look a bit darker than indigenous Brits but centuries of intermingling have made them look more 'British'. They maintained their own traditions: horses, metal work, field work etc and until recently lived in bender tends and then wagons before very recently being moved into permanent sites and housing (although they will often travel on the road in the summer months).
      These Roma you now see are related ancestrally to the Romany already here but came over since the fall of the Soviet Union and the joining of Eastern Bloc countries to the EU. There are some cultural connections to those Romany already here but they are quite distinct in many ways.

    • @coryparni3620
      @coryparni3620 2 роки тому +1

      @@SebNutter well said

    • @Cat-ik1wo
      @Cat-ik1wo 2 роки тому +3

      Yes, I understand what you are saying completely. People lumping everything into one group. Not knowing or understanding the different groups. Its the same way with the Philippine Islands. It was made into one country. Because of the colonial greed. The name given to the islands was changed to king philipp the Spanish king. Which the natives never saw or agreed to, But the islands is an archipelago, and each was ruled by different ethnic tribe. In other words, when you are colonized you don't get the respect. Its like saying that the Samoans, Hawaiians, and new Zealanders are all the same. Now, on the other hand, what they were trying to say, and what they were trying to do was an idealism, which is what you have in America, different people and cultures into one sect, Americans. Its being boxed in. Compartmentalized. And as it stands today, all the people in the Islands are recognized as Filipinos. Even though there is no "F" in its oral or written alphabet and language. You have to speak Spanish to get the f. And the th sound. Yep. Conbulated as it gets. But outsiders don't know this. Because both sides don't get represented. Thats how ignorance starts. Colonialism ignorance evolved into racism, or should I say birthed.

    • @coryparni3620
      @coryparni3620 2 роки тому +1

      @@Cat-ik1wo Filipinos, and you have no F ...😀🤣😂😆😅 sorry but that's pritty funny.😂🤣

  • @gregoryemmanuel9168
    @gregoryemmanuel9168 2 роки тому +12

    I have had the most wonderful interactions and experiences with Rroma people on some Greek islands and a cafe in Omonia Square in Athens. They are amazing people and I admire their spirit and incredible culture. I am grateful for the richness they shared with me.

  • @elzbethdempseyjones8891
    @elzbethdempseyjones8891 6 років тому +34

    They are called Nomads in Australia. The power of spirits dwell from within.
    Just like my family n extended families.
    Peace

  • @bohemoth1
    @bohemoth1 2 роки тому +45

    During the early 60s I met a young Gypsy King and his family. I am still in contact with them.
    I remember as a child I met an entire family of Gypsies who lived in Williamsburg Brooklyn New York on Stagg Street between Leonard Street and Lorimer Street. I loved the parties and festivals that they threw. I don't know why people are DEMONIZING them for they are truly very lovely people. The media had a role in DEMONIZING the Gypsies. Including Hollywood studios were GUILTY of portraying Gypsies as evil people. I trust them MORE THAN I TRUST ANY AMERICAN POLITICIAN!

    • @franceswilliamson6324
      @franceswilliamson6324 2 роки тому +3

      Romney community I love the scotch, Irish and English gypsies as well. Most gypsies are good people

    • @robert_costello
      @robert_costello 2 роки тому +4

      There’s a good chance that those gypsies in Williamsburg are related to me. I am a gypsy by mother and father. If I may correct one thing, there is no actual “King of the Gypsies”. We’ve always been way to proud to bow down to anyone, including one of our own. It’s kinda in our blood. It is for this reason, among others, that over the centuries, so many gypsies were killed. Refusal to acknowledge, and or, submit to authorities.

    • @franceswilliamson6324
      @franceswilliamson6324 2 роки тому +1

      @@robert_costello I'm a scotch traveler.

    • @bohemoth1
      @bohemoth1 2 роки тому

      @@robert_costello
      Do you remember a person named GEORGE who lived in the Projects down the block from the house where the Gypsies lived. He was a BLACK kid around 15 years old? He used to hang out with a Gypsy friend of his from Stagg Street named Nicky who had a Grandmother named Maybelle.
      There was a Gypsy family that had a Place in Greenwich Village on West 10th Street next to the Firehouse. There was a little Gypsy boy named Jack who was about 9 years old and he was a Gypsy Prince. They lived in a place where they also had their business as FORTUNE TELLERS. We went to a beach on City Island and it became a Gypsy Festival.

    • @robert_costello
      @robert_costello 2 роки тому +1

      @@bohemoth1 I think you’re talking about the Bimbos, but then again, there are fortune tellers every 3 blocks in the village. You might’ve been mislead into believing that we abide by a monarch or a hierarchy. I fear that you might have been a punchline in a fairytale story that’s been told for thousands of years. It’s an inside joke. We do listened our elders, especially when it comes to trouble within.

  • @andruska4
    @andruska4 3 роки тому +25

    Not mentioned in this Documentary part 2, Very famous Gypsy guitarist Django Reinhardt had a huge influence on Jazz Music with the Guitar.

  • @shanny4306
    @shanny4306 2 роки тому +5

    And the DANCING , everywhere there is the wonderful dancing that goes alllllll the way back 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼 🥰 💃🕺🏻 my grown son compliments me by referring to me as his Gypsy mom and I’m complimented , I’m Irish Canadian and love to study the history of these wonderful people who have survived and kept their heritage safe and what a RICH COLOURFUL history it is . My great uncle use to have gypsy’s visit him over many years and he would show me what he bought from them or bartered for.I loved his feather duster he had from his friends .❤️😉🙃

  • @staceyshine247
    @staceyshine247 2 роки тому +21

    I just saw a group at a hotel. A female from the group literally started a small fire near the property, in the grass, and cooked up some food! I was impressed.

    • @peekaboots01
      @peekaboots01 2 роки тому

      Interesting. When I was a kid I was absolutely fascinated with them. I read every book about them. I found the women and girls to be very strong and beautiful.

    • @clairecordell2461
      @clairecordell2461 2 роки тому +1

      Gypsy women are the best!

  • @jesusmagana7167
    @jesusmagana7167 3 роки тому +9

    1969 when I was 5 yrs. Old. A caravana of Spanish Gypsis,
    Stoped by my house in mexico. and i still remember the whole tribe.👩‍🦰👨‍🦰👱‍♀️🧔

  • @trends2morrow107
    @trends2morrow107 6 років тому +20

    Metal forging technology was well developed during Indus Valley Civilization in North West India 3000 years B.C.

  • @roberthornbrook8374
    @roberthornbrook8374 5 років тому +88

    I am English but my family were Romany we did descend from Punjab region but we are white now we are very mixed now

    • @karanzed
      @karanzed 4 роки тому +7

      Punjabi boy 👌👌

    • @meganrose3017
      @meganrose3017 4 роки тому

      @@karanzed q

    • @prijak
      @prijak 3 роки тому +11

      Once Punjabi, always a punjabi.

    • @allcounties7059
      @allcounties7059 3 роки тому

      Ha ha ha

    • @GoldieDawn
      @GoldieDawn 3 роки тому +5

      Pakistan as well, we're a complex mix of NW Indian, Pakistani and Afghani tribes, including the Kalash and Pastums, some of whom are white, blonde , red haired and blue eyed, we arrived in Europe as brown and white people, hence why we were branded as child snatchers in loads of European countries. x

  • @philup6274
    @philup6274 6 років тому +8

    Are we watching some old VCR converts . You are a true hero ......

  • @philasyr
    @philasyr 6 років тому +58

    Man, how do you upload a vhs tape.

    • @Revoluxhumanista19
      @Revoluxhumanista19 5 років тому +3

      philastine with Super Ultra Technology of First Generation

    • @imjustsaying364
      @imjustsaying364 3 роки тому +2

      😭🤣🤣

    • @GailOwens
      @GailOwens 3 роки тому +2

      I think you convert it to a dvd, and upload it to your our computer.

    • @lockandloadlikehell
      @lockandloadlikehell 3 роки тому

      @@imjustsaying364 was that funny for some reason?

    • @imjustsaying364
      @imjustsaying364 3 роки тому +3

      Actually yes, I find it amusing how quickly technology changes and advances. I remember pre VHS, the rise of VHS & the battle with Betamax, and then the demise... it’s interesting and amusing to me...

  • @karinaandersen2618
    @karinaandersen2618 6 років тому +20

    my grandfather on my mum's side, was Roma from Chez he left the family because of strife in the group

  • @sistersuetube
    @sistersuetube 6 років тому +7

    I remember when this was broadcast. Thank you so much for posting.

  • @AntaresBottia
    @AntaresBottia Рік тому +7

    I am Rom and was brought in the late 70s within that culture. It had its hardships but it was equally beautiful and a natural way of being, which for me, although, not brought up religious, is how I imagined how God intended our freedom to look like.
    For me it was paradise on earth - I look at us as being the last of the magical species that one day will only be written and read about like many things lost to mythical lore.
    There is good and bad in all - there are many fascinating stories that I've heard, seen in my time - where our people came across Christ on the Silk road after his Crucifixion travelling with his family.
    The Daughter of Christ and Mary Magdalene, Sarah Tamar who spent alot of her life in Alexandria Is the patreon saint of our people and known as Sarah la Kali - goes hand in hand why were called Egyptians and why we were messengers for nobility among other roles.
    There are tales we aided Robert The Bruce in the 1300s in the Battle of Bannockburn - not as Roma but as Templars - hence why William Sinclair (builder of the Rosslyn Church/Grail family) gave protection to Roms and we took his name.

    • @joltjolt5060
      @joltjolt5060 Рік тому

      I disagree. I don't believe magdalene was wife of the true christ, I believe it was Cleopatra who was mother of Sarah kali.

    • @miriamwells35
      @miriamwells35 Рік тому +1

      My mum’s name was Roslyn. Maybe that is why!

    • @AntaresBottia
      @AntaresBottia Рік тому

      @@joltjolt5060 not only is Magdalena the wife of Yashua but his spiritual successor, in her right, the feminine Christ and Tamar is their daughter who herself was a great prophetess she is nostradamus which basically means Our Lady.

    • @AntaresBottia
      @AntaresBottia Рік тому +1

      @@miriamwells35 there you go and you have the name of Mary

  • @winros
    @winros 8 місяців тому +2

    I'm so intrigued with the Gypsy culture! Growing up as a little girl, we would go to the cemetery to visit my grandparents however, I had to go and visit the GYPSIES!!! Evergreen cemetery in Newark New Jersey has a huge amount of GYPSIES buried there! SINGING SAM STEVENS is buried there as well!

  • @lynndebeal6126
    @lynndebeal6126 6 років тому +57

    The Gypsy families I've met are the most loving, family orientated people I know. People need to put their bigotry in check. All of the negative things that people say about the Rom/ Gypsies can be said about some of the people in any race and culture and nationality.

    • @davekent6023
      @davekent6023 5 років тому +3

      You're very ignorant, sorry

    • @shellybelly1893
      @shellybelly1893 4 роки тому +2

      Lynn DeBeal I see this was posted a year ago, so have they eaten your children and disappeared yet?

    • @reececonston6566
      @reececonston6566 4 роки тому +1

      You're mistaken

  • @DelBaggioo
    @DelBaggioo 4 роки тому +151

    I’m Gypsy end I’m proud of it.
    Jawen saste i bahtałe Romałe.

    • @indefatigable9229
      @indefatigable9229 4 роки тому +1

      good wer r u from bro ?

    • @DelBaggioo
      @DelBaggioo 4 роки тому +6

      Poland but i live in London

    • @indefatigable9229
      @indefatigable9229 4 роки тому +4

      @@DelBaggioo r u facing any discrimination in London being gypsy ?

    • @DelBaggioo
      @DelBaggioo 4 роки тому +10

      No . But in Poland yes .

    • @angelmarie9308
      @angelmarie9308 4 роки тому +9

      Me too #ROMANY Hungarian💯💗

  • @sophia3371
    @sophia3371 2 роки тому +21

    I am proud of my Father’s Hungarian heritage me and my 8 siblings was called Gypsy in Germany.❤️🔥🎶🦋💫

    • @scruffyo4460
      @scruffyo4460 2 роки тому +1

      Yes but are you actually gypsy/Romani or are you just Hungarian?

    • @tommym4167
      @tommym4167 2 роки тому

      my grandmother was a Hungarian gypsy my dads family where gypsies from Spain

    • @adhirajnegi4762
      @adhirajnegi4762 2 роки тому +1

      @@tommym4167 bro always remember you have blood of warriors in you. You have blood of rajput clan the most prestigious and high status class in india. We share blood

  • @oscark5264
    @oscark5264 3 роки тому +10

    People loves you as long they dont know where your from. If they do they will stereotype u and ignores u

  • @kathryndeloria1834
    @kathryndeloria1834 2 роки тому +19

    When I worked in a tourist town, Mackinaw City, in Michigan, the chamber of Commerce would send out a letter warning shopkeepers that “ the gypsies were moving through, with descriptions of their methods of tricking the workers and how to recognize them… later in college I did my anthropology final on the Rom. My great grandmother was said to be “gypsy”.

    • @electricfetus100
      @electricfetus100 2 роки тому +2

      I remember in the early eighties the Holland Sentinel had a front page title " the gypsy's are back in Zeeland "

  • @takingliberties6614
    @takingliberties6614 2 роки тому +25

    Persecuted because they can't be controlled. Same today.

  • @sumeetsingh4992
    @sumeetsingh4992 2 роки тому +3

    I am a Punjabi, story of Romas is sad yet emboldening and wondrous.

  • @LaTimbala
    @LaTimbala 3 роки тому +10

    I very much enjoyed this documentary. Thanks

  • @jrichard5829
    @jrichard5829 6 років тому +12

    Thank you for this, it's fascinating. I hope that you will continue to attempt to load Part 3 at some time in the future

  • @cappy2282
    @cappy2282 3 роки тому +10

    This back when History channel made good television

  • @lancemaruariki1774
    @lancemaruariki1774 6 років тому +26

    WE ARE SO AFRAID OF PAST,WE SPEAK NOTHING OF FURTURE.

    • @peaceknight5485
      @peaceknight5485 4 роки тому +2

      Please do not be. Your culture is a music to my ears.

  • @Eitner100
    @Eitner100 2 роки тому +16

    I lived in southern Spain from beginning of the 60s till 72. The Gitanos were hard workers, kind, truthful and very communicative. They worked for my father and never disappointed us. A totally different experience compared to some gypsies from Romania., Bulgaria and Hungary.

    • @KathyPrendergast-cu5ci
      @KathyPrendergast-cu5ci Рік тому +1

      Yes, I seem to hear very different stories about these people depending on the place. Eastern Europeans seem to be very hostile to them, see them not as hardworking people but just as thieves and scammers who make pariahs of themselves everywhere they go. But it in Western Europe and the west in general, they seem to be generally liked and admired.

    • @iknow2145
      @iknow2145 Рік тому +1

      because east euros are like that and treat people like that

    • @iknow2145
      @iknow2145 Рік тому +1

      you know, unenlightened savages

    • @KathyPrendergast-cu5ci
      @KathyPrendergast-cu5ci Рік тому +4

      @@iknow2145 Or, maybe the ones in Eastern Europe are really different from those in the west. Maybe they've absorbed the worst aspects of the cultures there. Or maybe it's just that Eastern Europeans are poorer and poor people tend not to romanticize or idealize other poor people that much. At any rate your comment seems a tad bigoted, painting all Eastern Europeans with the same brush.

  • @Anne-yi5sb
    @Anne-yi5sb 2 роки тому +7

    I respect them immensely... Because they are survivors!

  • @jinglebell9424
    @jinglebell9424 2 роки тому +6

    When I was a teenager I worked at a carnival, the booth next to us were gypsies. Well I didn't know it then, but I was fascinated by them. Dad and mom were trapeze artists. They lived in Sarasota FL at Circus World.for the winter and traveled carnivals in summer. I was friends with the daughters. They were blond hair and blue eyes. Parents were very guarded with the daughters but they were nice, i had a good impression of them.

    • @GoldieDawn
      @GoldieDawn Рік тому +2

      We're blue eyed, blonde and red haired Roma Gypsies, comes from the mountain/Hindu Kush tribes and nomads. x

    • @ekesandras1481
      @ekesandras1481 Рік тому

      @@GoldieDawn they come from affairs with Saxon, Hungarian and Mountain Romanian (Moți) farmers in Transylvania with whom some gypsy clans lived very closely for centuries.

  • @girijeshtiwari6933
    @girijeshtiwari6933 3 роки тому +33

    They must be absolutely supreme warriors. They survived toughest challenges, ever possible to survive for any human group in last 1000 year in the world. Their journey is inspiring. We love our Roma brother & sisters. With love from India...🙏🇮🇳🇮🇳

    • @rumble1925
      @rumble1925 3 роки тому +11

      Will you please take them back?

    • @ryancostello537
      @ryancostello537 3 роки тому +4

      @@rumble1925 A little racist don’t you think

    • @ashokkumar-yd5kz
      @ashokkumar-yd5kz 3 роки тому +4

      Do you know how bad they portarit india????

    • @scruffyo4460
      @scruffyo4460 2 роки тому +2

      Those Roma Gypsies who now live in Europe (and have done for 100s and 1000s of years) do not like Indians and do not see them as brothers and sisters lol. Ask any Roma what they think of Indians…you will not like the answers!

    • @ashokkumar-yd5kz
      @ashokkumar-yd5kz 2 роки тому +3

      @@scruffyo4460 majority of Indians don't give a damn about gypsies....only very few like the one who commented above has such interest and that too because of political reasons......

  • @eclecticems
    @eclecticems Рік тому +2

    My mums side of the fam are of romani gypsy and Irish traveller ancestry, settling around Northumbria, Kent, suffolk and surrey for a few hundred years, im still tracing my roots there, and my dad's side are ancestors of william bradford and palatine immigrants who moved to Pennsylvania then later to suffolk, to think how both sides have survived prejudice and travelling these long journeys just amazes me of their courage and determination to live

  • @reginamoore6897
    @reginamoore6897 6 років тому +14

    i would very much like to meet a person from this culture...love learning about ppl different from myself.

  • @ghost84429
    @ghost84429 6 років тому +43

    I'm Roma and proud of it!

    • @ryanbraganza2259
      @ryanbraganza2259 5 років тому +1

      So you actually belong to Rajasthan :)

    • @weird8485
      @weird8485 5 років тому +1

      Mel Holmes you should be proud:)

    • @bmwsincekid
      @bmwsincekid 4 роки тому +1

      Mel Holmes Me too Brother

    • @deepakpanwar6204
      @deepakpanwar6204 3 роки тому

      ua-cam.com/video/aNUYGRn3W9Q/v-deo.html Yes rajasthan

  • @ecuadorexpat8558
    @ecuadorexpat8558 6 років тому +9

    I am from Germany and had lots of Roma and Sinti Friends who made me feel ,ore welcome than my own family..They are a fascinating group of peoples and their history goes back all the way to India more than 5000 years ago

    • @jordanpesta
      @jordanpesta 8 місяців тому

      You litlebit wrong we be just slaves in North India for 400 years originally we coming from Abraham we lost tribes from Izrael

  • @augustusplebeian3268
    @augustusplebeian3268 5 років тому +22

    Im a gypsy! I am an entertainer type. I make art and music and skateboard. I have been homeless in a huge city and liked it. I am in and out of mental hospitals. Poor and alone. But i will make it one day! With or without a "deal"!

  • @Patrick-ub4qj
    @Patrick-ub4qj 4 роки тому +6

    I am a Romney gypsy and I am proud of my heritage and don’t hide it

  • @KaliMaaaaa
    @KaliMaaaaa 2 роки тому +56

    The irony of constantly talking about slavery and abuse when not mentioning the fact of how women and children in this "culture" are treated. Innnzest, domestic violence, child marriage is ubiquitous. This is a very romantic depiction.

    • @coryparni3620
      @coryparni3620 2 роки тому +2

      What a load of shit

    • @arielstrafing5225
      @arielstrafing5225 2 роки тому +9

      additionally, and for the same reasons - balance - they should mention WHY they have always been hated and rejected - thievery.

    • @coryparni3620
      @coryparni3620 2 роки тому +3

      @@arielstrafing5225 jails are full of youre type .

    • @bohemoth1
      @bohemoth1 2 роки тому

      Stereotyping as usual for your race.

    • @d0n0mar55
      @d0n0mar55 2 роки тому

      @@bohemoth1 well ! ask people from Spain what they say about this topic, you will be sorprise !

  • @DreamBelief
    @DreamBelief 2 роки тому +63

    As a child I'd say I was probably a bit prejudiced. I didn't trust them as my only interactions with them had been very negative - a group camping out on our small property without permission and absolutely trashing it, and (in a different country) attempting to kidnap me. As you get older though you realise that there are awful people (and, likewise, lovely people) in literally any group. We have moved and travelled extensively all my life, and I am yet to find a group for whom this doesn't apply.

    • @Maya_Pinion
      @Maya_Pinion 2 роки тому +3

      Right on...👍

    • @scruffyo4460
      @scruffyo4460 2 роки тому +6

      So, other groups of people tried to kidnap you as well? That’s very interesting. Which were the other groups that tried to kidnap you? That’s very sad you had to go through that, sorry to hear ❤️

    • @tamaracoba
      @tamaracoba 2 роки тому +3

      They trashed the camp site and on one occasion tried to kidnap you??? Nuff said.

    • @clairecordell2461
      @clairecordell2461 2 роки тому

      Nashti zhas vorta po drom o bango!

    • @cynthiamarston2208
      @cynthiamarston2208 2 роки тому

      Nice for you to learn

  • @Fireboat52
    @Fireboat52 6 років тому +52

    I think the problem of persecution for nomadic tribes come from the fact that they try to keep their identity instead of being absorbed and assimilating into the nation or community they occupy. In doing so they create suspicion and distrust from those around them. They appear to be trying to serve two cultures and their motives and loyalties are suspect. Nothing creates distrust more than speaking a foreign language in public. It is akin to whispering at a party. All relationships, especially enduring relationships are founded on mutual trust. When your loyalty is suspect the tiniest betrayal is amplified.

    • @user-yo5yr9yr2h
      @user-yo5yr9yr2h 6 років тому +17

      Assimilating does not mean someone has to give up their own religions, languages, and cultural identity. You can be a part of a society without giving up your roots. No one ever told white people colonizing south Africa, the Americas, and India to "assimilate".

    • @mudvayne451
      @mudvayne451 6 років тому +12

      I agree that this does adds to creating tension. But it is a brave thing to maintain ones individuality, while being persecuted, and staying the course non the less. Most ppl in this world aren't built for that and dont have the backbone for it!

    • @blixten2928
      @blixten2928 5 років тому +9

      "Serve two cultures". So all of us have to choose one culture to "choose"? Like punks, hippies, bikers, video-nerds, gays, Mexican-Americans, all are suspect because they have more than one (WASP?) "culture"? C'mon. We all have more than one culture. Those who like cosmopolitan or nomadic cultures, however, are persecuted (Jews, Gypsies) by us who stay more in one place. But don't blame THEM for our prejudices!!

    • @Ginelabean
      @Ginelabean 4 роки тому +1

      Never thought about it this way. Thank you for this!

    • @everythingsreal
      @everythingsreal 4 роки тому +6

      exactly what I was thinking. Very similar to jewish people who were hated in every land they travelled to

  • @annikahamalainen1665
    @annikahamalainen1665 6 років тому +19

    My father is a gypsy, greetings from finland.

    • @blixten2928
      @blixten2928 5 років тому

      Greetings back from Kungsör, Sweden, we have some Kaale gypsies here!!

    • @martinristic2562
      @martinristic2562 5 років тому

      Greetings from England we also have gypsies 😂

    • @danielfinch362
      @danielfinch362 4 роки тому +2

      If your father is gypsy you are gypsy. My father is gypsy my mother is not. I'm accepted as gypsy.

    • @kk-by9wq
      @kk-by9wq 4 роки тому

      Kuuntele hyvä nainee menää ostellee

    • @Lenn869
      @Lenn869 2 роки тому

      tragedy

  • @mikegibson4332
    @mikegibson4332 11 місяців тому +1

    I miss this era of history channel

  • @Will-kk5zm
    @Will-kk5zm Рік тому +1

    I've met lots of them in north Georgia all great people always looking out for the entire community they are always welcome at my table!!!!!!

  • @debrairwin7963
    @debrairwin7963 4 роки тому +3

    Born & bred 3rd generation New Zealander but something my grandmother taught me was ..." my mother said that I never should..play with the gypsies in the wood..if I did she would say..naughty girl to disobey!" Born in the '50s...most of us were taught this nursery rhyme...sad...

  • @Chercheure_Indépendante
    @Chercheure_Indépendante 3 роки тому +32

    Romani, Roma appears to derive from the Indian god Rama, the god of protection. (Vishnu has had nine incarnations on earth as different beings. One of these is as Rama) This is an hypothesis for now but I thought to mention it.

    • @onemanarmy3406
      @onemanarmy3406 3 роки тому +4

      🙏Namaskaram from India 🇮🇳

    • @noorgonzalez1076
      @noorgonzalez1076 3 роки тому +1

      🙇🏻‍♀️🕊🙇🏻‍♀️🙇🏻‍♀️🕊🙏🏽

    • @dianareintges4117
      @dianareintges4117 2 роки тому +1

      I have only met one gypsy family when I worked in an emergency room. A mother came in with her son. They both went by the same last name, as her maiden name. She was very caring of the child and both were very clean about their persons and clothing.

  • @matthewpocock4824
    @matthewpocock4824 Рік тому +1

    What a fascinating people. I can't wait to learn more.

  • @navigatormother7023
    @navigatormother7023 2 роки тому +19

    "Not a proper language..." on the contrary, it's a fascinating map of a language that tells a history so much more lucidly than commonplace countries.... it's fascinating, mysterious, and so far beyond interesting as an anthropological study. How many stories does it tell... and that's just the language. What about the customs, traditions, dress, jewellery, on and on it goes. Those professors are welcome to go back to their dry, dust strewn libraries with no gifts for the minds of our children.

    • @mystiqueropiha9537
      @mystiqueropiha9537 2 роки тому

      L

    • @coryparni3620
      @coryparni3620 2 роки тому +4

      Romanes is a fascinating language to which there are many dialects containg words from all the different countries they passed through. It is indeed like reading a map .

    • @GoldieDawn
      @GoldieDawn Рік тому

      @@coryparni3620 Barrie chavvi. x :)

  • @rkjohnston9692
    @rkjohnston9692 2 роки тому +4

    I wish History Channel would go back to this type of programming and get away from those stupid contest programs

  • @ToniBourque
    @ToniBourque Місяць тому +1

    My mom would talk about the gypsies that would camp near her small town in Louisiana she always was fascinated my them

  • @lahorkajasar5628
    @lahorkajasar5628 2 роки тому +1

    Nice to see you Mr. Shani Rifati in this documentary, regards from NYC

  • @redragonfly3040
    @redragonfly3040 6 років тому +14

    The children look so sad and unhappy.

  • @theproudyindian3324
    @theproudyindian3324 4 роки тому +8

    Jay Shree Ram 🚩🇮🇳🙏

  • @Dusty357
    @Dusty357 6 років тому +39

    Speak as you find is what a was always taught, and there is good and bad in all off us.

  • @eleveneleven572
    @eleveneleven572 2 роки тому +25

    Sadly, here in France, we have constant problems with the Roma. Only a couple of weeks ago I had to rescue my local bar owner from two who were bullying him into changing some fake euro notes.
    Once you understand you learn to deal with their scams and pickpocketing. Despite being in a very rural area you soon learn not to leave anything of value out in your garden as their children are often mooching around looking for something to take. Recently a neighbour had a scooter stolen. Fortunately the police went straight down to there publicly funded camping ground and got it back before they'd moved it on.

    • @ytcarol
      @ytcarol 2 роки тому +6

      Such actions are exactly how stereotypes grow. Sad.

    • @sugarsnap7883
      @sugarsnap7883 2 роки тому +2

      Ytcarol, so we should keep such things a secret ? If this is truth, I had trouble WTH them in So Cal.

    • @Lyle-xc9pg
      @Lyle-xc9pg 2 роки тому +6

      @@ytcarol Oh god its the same exact thing here in russia, We have a settlement of them right near me (40 houses) but there are hundreds live in shanty houses and many chldren literally smell like putrid grabage. Theyre also not lliterate. My area is considerd extremely dangerous for the city.

    • @lovelylady1966
      @lovelylady1966 2 роки тому

      WOW they are guilty of what whites,blacks,latinos you cant even use that crime to say all gypsies do this you sound ridiculous every human in any race are doing things like that but here you are singling them out.

    • @MCE851
      @MCE851 2 роки тому +4

      @@lovelylady1966 Im part roma and sorry but there is a high incidence of some races or ethnicities doing certain behaviours more so then others, stereotypes from for a reason. Get over it.,

  • @gennarosavastano6268
    @gennarosavastano6268 6 років тому +17

    People can't distinguish between race and ethnicity ! There are only three races but there multiple ethnicities Scattered around the globe, Roma or gypsy is not a race !

    • @MrDarkoKos
      @MrDarkoKos 5 років тому +3

      Gennaro Savastano its like saying americN is a race...ppl dont realize how old the earth is, and that humans have been here the entire time. Ppl moved and mated as they did this. Its all a melting pot

    • @jakubgruszczynski4069
      @jakubgruszczynski4069 4 роки тому +3

      Good point. I caught that one out too.

    • @shawnahall7246
      @shawnahall7246 2 роки тому

      It’s said to be 4-5 races actually

    • @olafharoldsonnii4713
      @olafharoldsonnii4713 2 роки тому +1

      Race isn’t determined by skin color either

    • @rahowherox1177
      @rahowherox1177 Рік тому

      ​@@shawnahall7246 no, 3 - Caucasoid, mongoloid and negroid. With anything else being considered a combo...

  • @sweeeita
    @sweeeita 6 років тому +5

    so basically most the first part was talking about...
    1- the gypsies are an assembled army that took women and children into battle with them to face another army.
    2- historically the Muslims won and ruled most or at least the northern parts of India, which makes it safe to say the gypsies failed in their mission.
    3- after being defeated, they peacefully were allowed to travel as an army or one unit, into the empire/country that defeated them.
    4- travel in it safely and staying for long periods of times in various locations of that empire and even settling and making communities inside their enemies land. all the way to the Balkan establishing their highest populated communities till date.
    does anyone else see anything wrong with that story ! or have I missed something !?

  • @maggiefollett636
    @maggiefollett636 4 роки тому +35

    I'm a very amateur historian (and linguist), but I've been interested in the origins of the Rom people for ages and there is no doubt about their Indian origins. It's important to note that there are STILL several nomadic tribes such as the Kalbelia (so-called) "gypsies" in the Rajasthan area, with innumerable similarities. Also, the general area of Romania is home to a vast Rom population. The name "Romania" (and the country's Latin language) derives from a former Roman occupation, so is it possible that "Rom/Romany" simply comes from their time spent in Eastern Europe? I would be curious to know how many Romance language words and expressions exist today amongst the world's Rom.

    • @DM-nl7kf
      @DM-nl7kf 3 роки тому +3

      You are crazy mam. In Romania is a small population of Gypsies. They came from India in the Middle Age!
      The name of Roma, Romani is created by Vatican Germany, Austria and Hungary to hit Romania. The Romanians are white and Europeans like you!
      It is a propaganda against Romania!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
      If you do not know these, then go back to school!
      Nobody in Europe heard this name ,, Roma,, Romani,, untill 30 years ago!
      After 1990, this word began in Europe and whole over the world!!!!!!!!!!!!!
      I repeat is a word created, especially, by Vatican to hit Romanian people!
      They are not Roma, they are Indians!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
      Indeed, you are a very amateur historian.
      Stop with all these lies about Romania!
      Do you that your western civilization is immortal? No, next decades you will disappear!
      In Romania we have some words ,, the wheel is turning,,!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
      The Vatican is the big our enemy! Unfortunately!
      Anyway, Vatican will be destroyed next decades!
      So, go back to school!

    • @hayerubihayerubi5720
      @hayerubihayerubi5720 3 роки тому +2

      Maybe the lady just didn’t know mate , was asking information on threads of comments, it’s like a school. You ask about people and cultures and information , and then the truth comes through. By asking nice people questions . Now
      I assume she understands who you are and what your saying

    • @darbysabini4248
      @darbysabini4248 2 роки тому

      @@hayerubihayerubi5720 so behave your self. Romanian pykey 🤩

    • @sdsurfgirl60
      @sdsurfgirl60 2 роки тому +6

      @@DM-nl7kf actually she's correct. She's not commenting on Roma nationals. She's saying Romani gypsies (Romani or Rom) were nomads from India who settled across Europe. You need a history lesson.

    • @sandrineroesch8706
      @sandrineroesch8706 2 роки тому +7

      I think he needs English lessons,first of all.
      It’s true that Romania has the biggest population or Roma gypsies in Europe,followed by Bulgaria,Hungary and Slovakia.

  • @riturao6565
    @riturao6565 3 роки тому +3

    The attire , the culture, the dresses they wear, rituals they do is very similar to Rajasthani state of North India

    • @ashokkumar-yd5kz
      @ashokkumar-yd5kz 3 роки тому

      Do you know how bad these people portrait our nation?????

    • @jdaimaoh765
      @jdaimaoh765 2 місяці тому

      ​@@ashokkumar-yd5kz are you a Rajasthani?

  • @Deltawhiskeymike
    @Deltawhiskeymike 9 місяців тому

    I saw a documentary on "Cobra Gypsies" (JUST YESTERDAY)), & I've never heard of "them" before, but "they" are such a beautiful, colorful, and happy people!
    (YT is weird)

  • @abhid.2679
    @abhid.2679 2 роки тому +8

    These guys were the original hippies - so freespirited :D

  • @afanniecraddock9033
    @afanniecraddock9033 Рік тому +4

    We survive my great grandmother used to leave her baby in a hedge while she went calling and then pub picked the baby up when she went home. She wore all black and she did fortunes and curses.She broke nearly every bone in her body once she was laying in the lane drunk and her husband run her over with the horse and cart she lived to 99.

  • @RamonaRayTodosSantosBCS
    @RamonaRayTodosSantosBCS 2 роки тому +9

    I have Roma ancestors. I'm proud of that fact! It's where my RH negative blood comes from. I have the sight. And that's inherited. My grandma had dark skin. She said she was black Norwegian. Genetics lead to India. The RH negative blood also.

    • @adhirajnegi4762
      @adhirajnegi4762 2 роки тому +1

      You are from a rajput warrior race most high status and respect in india be proud of it

    • @joltjolt5060
      @joltjolt5060 Рік тому

      Rh negative is from Spain.

  • @grayelmore9425
    @grayelmore9425 2 роки тому +2

    My friend who lives in Croatia had recently bought a new boiler for his heating system. When he left the house the Gypsies came and stole it.

    • @ccn8741
      @ccn8741 Рік тому

      I'm roma antique restorer and have been robbed 2 times in 2o years they took all I had saved for my old age. and they were not roma .just thieves from the settled community

  • @Every2Days...
    @Every2Days... 2 роки тому +2

    My whole life i though My neighbor's were indians, but i randomly remember once their kid says that they were gypsy's. Now i understand... they were probably hiding their origin, because all the stereotypes. They were kinda loud but i LOVED THEIR FOOD AND FESTIVALS. They were generally good and hard working people.

  • @aditimukherjee1572
    @aditimukherjee1572 3 роки тому +9

    Gypsy are the Banjara group of Rajasthan , India..I feel that they are still Indian for me

    • @sr3yu
      @sr3yu 3 роки тому +1

      Me too

    • @abyss.6482
      @abyss.6482 3 роки тому

      Yes brother

    • @ashokkumar-yd5kz
      @ashokkumar-yd5kz 3 роки тому

      Do you know how bad these people portrait our nation?????

  • @bharatindian6633
    @bharatindian6633 6 років тому +4

    ROAMAS/Gypsys/Banzaras are the true fore-fathers of whole of fashion, advertising and entertainment industry of the world... All the bollywood, hollywood is originated by the concepts of Banzara guys... They are also the original marketing and advertising professionals, who used to sell and advertise Indian textile products from North west ancient India in European, Persian, Egypt, Russia & middle eastern Asian markets since ancient time immemorial. They were highly rich, popular and influential people during peak of their times due to their extra-ordinary music and dancing skills as well as high quality textile products of India. With the advent of Islam in Midlle east asia, their profession was seen as of lower category and their movements were restricted due to Islamic violence. They lost connections with their roots and original profession. In India, Banzaras (Indian Romas) were the real advertisers and entertainers till 100 years back before the advent of Cinemas and TVs .. Just ask simple questions: How the Europeans came to know about quality Silk and Cotton products of India in ancient times? Who were introducing these products to them? ....There are authentic records available when Ancient Roman Parliamnet passing resolutions on the trends that ladies are buying Indian silk products in exchange of Gold.. who were the people introducing those products to European ladies.?............ you will get the answers..

  • @finalbossoftheinternet6002
    @finalbossoftheinternet6002 5 років тому +54

    I’m mostly Black American, doing some ancestry research I found that my maternal grandfather descends from Romani people, I’m made of two races but of 100% oppressed people smh I’m not personally oppressed though.

    • @harmeetsinghkhalsa7427
      @harmeetsinghkhalsa7427 4 роки тому +10

      then you are also connected to India because Romanis migrated out of India after Islamic invasions by Mahmud of Gazni

    • @anonymouswoman2060
      @anonymouswoman2060 4 роки тому +3

      @@harmeetsinghkhalsa7427 Watch a short history of India! Thiss will sgow you how the people of India migrated out of Africa to shat is now India. maxing connections.

    • @harmeetsinghkhalsa7427
      @harmeetsinghkhalsa7427 4 роки тому +4

      @@anonymouswoman2060 I know my history more than u idiot..we never came from Africa..

    • @harmeetsinghkhalsa7427
      @harmeetsinghkhalsa7427 4 роки тому +5

      @@LK-ho1dg Thats an unproven theory which is now more disputed than ever. There is no evidence that all humans originated from Africa.

    • @sonnyblack6121
      @sonnyblack6121 4 роки тому +9

      @@harmeetsinghkhalsa7427 Incorrect, Africa is the cradle of humankind.Everyone has African blood.

  • @marneyblarney1858
    @marneyblarney1858 5 років тому +20

    Prior to my birth, my parents lived in a rural area in Texas. One day, while my dad was at work, a couple of gypsy men knocked on the door. They wanted to “inspect” the septic tank...free of charge, of course.
    By the time my dad made it home and discovered what was happening, the gypsies had already dug a hole and had cracked the concrete lid to the septic tank!
    My dad was FURIOUS! My mom was raised in Kansas and had never had any interactions with gypsies. She didn’t realize that “free septic tank inspections” were a fairly common gypsy scam in the area at that time.
    There’s a reason why there are so many negative stereotypes regarding gypsies. Unfortunately, a large number of those stereotypes began, and were perpetuated by, gypsies themselves.
    It’s a shame, too, because there are good & bad ppl in every culture.

  • @timkahn2813
    @timkahn2813 2 роки тому +1

    i like them i worked for them in seattle WA. the steavens family. they where fun hard working and nice.

  • @bigspoon7984
    @bigspoon7984 5 років тому +12

    It is clear, the Rom have endured horrific conditions. Even today, society still persist, the Gypsy is something - somebody to be feared and hated.
    I'm hear to tell you are okay; you are fine.
    We are not a threat. We are Rom and living among you.

  • @mulawarmankwsuper
    @mulawarmankwsuper 5 років тому +6

    The only gypsies i know are The Peaky Blinder and they're cool, good tv series, very recommended. In serious tone, people should stop with their prejudice and stereotyping.

  • @aleksk4151
    @aleksk4151 7 років тому +33

    i won't curse at them. They are people too
    CHRIST cares for them

    • @mihailnikoloff2554
      @mihailnikoloff2554 5 років тому

      Idiot. Thats why you dont live in Bulgaria and you emigrated

    • @1947DFC
      @1947DFC 5 років тому +1

      They will sell you , me , christ , god for 5 euros even if we saved their lives before lol trust me ...

    • @martinristic2562
      @martinristic2562 4 роки тому

      1947DFC why trust u

    • @Olori-Ogun
      @Olori-Ogun 4 роки тому

      @@1947DFCI ain't gypsy but if I see Christ , I'm taking his halo

  • @thejmfedak
    @thejmfedak 7 років тому +5

    Above indicates this is a one hour program. Parts 1 and 2 are 30 minutes each. So based on that there is no part 3.

    • @openlens3990
      @openlens3990  7 років тому +3

      Sorry, Part 3 failed to upload after 6 attempts. I will attempt to fix it at some point in the future.

    • @openlens3990
      @openlens3990  7 років тому +1

      Sorry, Part 3 failed to upload after 6 attempts. I need to consult with somebody on this.

    • @bradburkley5811
      @bradburkley5811 6 років тому +2

      Gypsy's stole the third half!

  • @loridisney3782
    @loridisney3782 Рік тому +1

    What a beautiful culture❤️

  • @Sheila2024-x8w
    @Sheila2024-x8w Місяць тому

    The Gypsies caused havoc where my grandparents lived. They travelled the river and exited when they saw something they fancied. They caused a lot of fear.

  • @kati1017
    @kati1017 2 роки тому +23

    When I was on a tour in Spain, a gypsy woman squirted mustard on one of my tourmates back to distract her so her friends could steal her bags. Luckily her boyfriend grabbed the bags. It's was scary and so low-down!

  • @adrianaslund8605
    @adrianaslund8605 2 роки тому +4

    Its interesting how the Romani were originally well known for their metalwork.
    Edit: Seeing as they're possibly linked to the indian warrior caste I mean.

    • @arielstrafing5225
      @arielstrafing5225 2 роки тому +1

      they were thrown to the wolves. 'warriors' pfffft. they were never respected.

    • @Rctdcttecededtef
      @Rctdcttecededtef 2 роки тому

      Im just learning about this stuff now as I am apparently linked to these people and this 'warrior' class. Could you provide a link on the theory of them being connected

  • @TraceyanneMcCartney
    @TraceyanneMcCartney 2 роки тому +3

    Searching my heritage, I discovered my nan was full Roma (Smith & Lovells). I never knew, it was kept quiet. I'm educating myself on the history as seems to be so much misconception and hatred, it's quite heart-breaking what they've been through as a people, even up to the present day.

  • @gypsydave23
    @gypsydave23 6 років тому

    ... thanx for posting this ... I recorded all the prog on v h s .. loaded to laptop not bad quality .. took it down after a copyright issue with some little thing I uploaded ... youtube threatened to shut my account ...still got the video tape somewhere .. kushti bok mush..