Exposing the Hidden Cost of Gender Transition - Panel Discussion

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 30 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 162

  • @GordieGii
    @GordieGii 12 днів тому +52

    I remember the story of a 5 or 6 y/o boy who said he wanted to be a woman when he grew up. When they asked him why (back when you were allowed to ask questions) he said he loved his mommy and liked his female teacher and friends and didn't want to be a rapist when he grew up...

    • @Gingerblaze
      @Gingerblaze 12 днів тому +1

      Yeah autoandroPHOBIA, a far bigger motivation for many young straight boys seeking social and medical transition. Both modern corporate feminism and porn have contributed heavily to that.

    • @stacypastry2440
      @stacypastry2440 12 днів тому +11

      Isn't that so sad. Men do so much for us while working on terrible conditions. Being a man should be lauded. Being a bad man is already looked down on.
      ❤men

    • @irisElee
      @irisElee 12 днів тому +17

      Where does a 5yr old learn the word "rapist"?

    • @GordieGii
      @GordieGii 12 днів тому +4

      @@irisElee An excellent question...

    • @josephblue4135
      @josephblue4135 12 днів тому +2

      😢 so sad.

  • @tubermind
    @tubermind 12 днів тому +29

    I look forward to the day when we can all voluntarily drop the verb, "transitioning" from a sexual connotation because by then it will be universally understood that no one CAN actually achieve "a change over into" another sex.

    • @unowen-nh9ov
      @unowen-nh9ov 12 днів тому +2

      Puberty & menopause natural transitions & they can be challenging enough without throwing in hormones & surgeries.

    • @tubermind
      @tubermind 11 днів тому +1

      @@unowen-nh9ov Indeed!

    • @normnicklette5694
      @normnicklette5694 9 днів тому

      Transphobia and many of the other coined …phobias and illogical and not really words that should be used!!

  • @stfnknbb
    @stfnknbb 12 днів тому +16

    We live in frightening times. Thank you so much for your integrity

    • @susanhill833
      @susanhill833 2 дні тому

      So you think that someone who LIES to you constantly has integrity, good to know, by the way, I have some swamp land in death valley to sell you, right in the heart of death valley, really good swamp land.

  • @JaneHilton-u5h
    @JaneHilton-u5h 12 днів тому +31

    There needs to be a law that protects detransitioners and trans activists need to be arrested for threats or attempting to silence others.The so called oppressed cannot oppress a fragile group without reprimand?

    • @Messier45_Pleiades
      @Messier45_Pleiades 12 днів тому +9

      Glinner, thanks for not giving up.

    • @unowen-nh9ov
      @unowen-nh9ov 12 днів тому +1

      They openly promote banned puberty blockers, gateway to sterilization, mutilation, castration, sepsis & suicide of @ risk youth (when they're not calling the police on J.K. Rowling for miss rendering or claiming to be more woman than mother of 3, cosplaying fantasist is right).

    • @freyja802
      @freyja802 11 днів тому

      Have you maybe considered not blaming this on the minority these people tried to copy because they thought they could profit from the label but maybe rather the people who actually did that? If they were minors, that would be the parents. If they are adults capable of making such a decision, then it's on them. Why are transsexuals responsible for telling healthy people to not fuck up their hormones and genitals? This should be common sense! Still, these people ignored common sense and believed in fairy tales. Most of those fairy tales they made up themselves and told each other and they attacked all actual transsexuals who didn't push their twisted narrative by becoming alive props for their show. Now, they are the victims while the people they abused and took advantage of are being punished like we forced them to do all of that - can you really not see how this just comes back to people who do not suffer from transsexualism blaming their shit on those who do and then you all agree in taking collective revenge against their victims.
      And in case you do that on purpose, don't you think we understand what is happening there? Stop hunting down innocent people for not living as your cult demands! #stoptheviolence

    • @robertmarshall2502
      @robertmarshall2502 11 днів тому

      ​@@freyja802 Firstly the violence is 99% from the trans activists to ppl who disagree. Violence against trans ppl is statistically proportionately lower than against non-trans ppl and much lower than the violence committed by trans identifying males. You went on a mindless disassociative rant that isn't connected to reality.
      You seem to believe in some sort of "true trans". Why? Suffering from transsexualism is the state of any human who goes through these hormones and surgeries. On what are you basing this belief in "true trans"? Is it cos you think you're the exception?

  • @irisElee
    @irisElee 12 днів тому +30

    Andrew Doyle and Graham Linehan - LOVE LOVE LOVE them! ❤❤❤

    • @thetransagender2866
      @thetransagender2866 2 дні тому

      You do know that Graham linehan is a sexual predator who stalked a 17 year old, and posted a picture of someone’s genetalia?

  • @jones6119
    @jones6119 11 днів тому +11

    Thank you all for your courage.

  • @tubermind
    @tubermind 12 днів тому +20

    It's so encouraging that "the trans issue" was a major issue in recent American politics. There's some denial of this (of course) by people wanting to erode its importance in "decision 2024," but we who know, do know that this was actually Very Big. They have to spin it that way to try to save face and encourage their camp, but the truth is that the Tide is truly Turning.

    • @unowen-nh9ov
      @unowen-nh9ov 12 днів тому +1

      Voters didn't ignore Jan. 6, 34 convictions & sex crimes because of 1% of the population, now they will be ruled by 1%ers,. Buh bye, democracy & hello space travellings oligarchs!

    • @robertmarshall2502
      @robertmarshall2502 11 днів тому

      ​@@unowen-nh9ov I can't quite work out your comment. Do you think Harris would have been better? Clearly on this issue the answer would be no and we'd continue to see women's rights trashed and children needlessly medicalised.
      For me the Democrats could have easily one by just not being extremist lunatics. They chose to only try to appease the extremists and denigrate everyone else who had normal views.

  • @MarcConroy-p1j
    @MarcConroy-p1j 10 днів тому +4

    As an Irishman and father of 3 daughters I've been following this whole debate with great interest over the past number of years. It's great to see intelligent, common sense discussion from people like those on this panel discussion and others like Helen Joyce, Stella O'Malley and many others. It is encouraging to see this fight back against the dangerous trans ideology, I am encouraged and hopeful for the future. Thank you!

    • @susanhill833
      @susanhill833 2 дні тому

      The people on this panel are LYING THROUGH THEIR TEETH TO YOU. Just because they make it sound good does NOT mean it is, what they are doing is called GASLIGHTING. Not one of them knows ANYTHING about transgender PEOPLE, joyce is a doctor of MATHEMATICS, not psychology, and she has NEVER studied ANY transgender person, o'malley is a PROVEN hater of transgender people she is NOT unbiased, she approaches this from the point of HATE and it colors everything she says.

  • @pamelaroyce5285
    @pamelaroyce5285 12 днів тому +14

    I wonder whether “The Lost Boys” movie and the one on destransitioners *could* get some distribution in theaters now. Late last year Matt Walsh’s “Am I Racist?” did very well. In light of the recent U.S. election results, there might be greater willingness to air and consider views not held by the ideologues. Mark Zuckerberg has announced changes to the speech-monitoring algorithm.
    This was an excellent panel. I liked Andrew Doyle’s point about having a transubstantiation correspondent. 😄

  • @adamaccountname
    @adamaccountname 11 днів тому +3

    In Australia a judge deemed that the Cass report was political and therefore they should use the standards of care which were demonstrated to be political by the Cass report

  • @vickils9571
    @vickils9571 11 днів тому +6

    Your content is always amazing. Please consider doing a podcast on female aggression; how it is different from male aggression, and how it might be an undercurrent of many cultural issues today given the rise of females in power.

  • @lovesomeone7285
    @lovesomeone7285 11 днів тому +7

    I listened twice. Deleted first comments. I applaud each of their bravery. I listen to The Heretic with Andrew Gold and Triggernometry with Constantine and Francis. Admire all and Helen Joyce 👏 and Douglas Murray 👏 keep me sane. Graham's story broke my heart and happy to see him fighting and writing. Andrew Doyle is new to me but heard great things. Don't let insanity win. Balance, measured and sensible.

    • @alibrown6268
      @alibrown6268 11 днів тому +1

      Andrew Doyle posts are brilliant. He's definitely worth a listen to

  • @robertmarshall2502
    @robertmarshall2502 11 днів тому +9

    It is horrible that young mothers are deprived of resources because we have to devote resources to denigrating motherhood

  • @janet3782
    @janet3782 12 днів тому +12

    I just want to clarify something that many misunderstand about "toxic masculinity"; for one i think the term is misleading, it insinuates that all masculinity is toxic which of course isn't true but their are certain stereotypes/traits of masculinity that's internalised by society that are toxic to young boys and men.
    These stereotype are misogynistic and deeply homophobic. I live in Australia and i can tell you here its rife amongst our boys and young men. These stereotypes of musculinity are harming our boys. An example is that boys are chastised or ridiculed by their peers, or worse from their parents, for showing emotions "boys don't cry" "toughen up" "don't cry like a girl", I have seen parents say this to their kindergarten age boys 😢. Another example is my 8 year old Son didn't want to wear a pinkish tshirt to school for muftiy day, his words exactly "I will get bullied and called gay", growing up my kids have been able to wear any colour they like, we don't do "gendered" colours. Do girls get bullied for wearing blue coloured clothes? No they don't.
    There is this culture of chastising and ridiculing boys or men for showing emotions or doing anything that might be seen as nurturing or slightly feminine.
    Toxic traits of masculinity are linked to violence against women, high suicide rates amongst young boys and men, it is linked to homophobia and even internalised homophobia, so intern, also gender ideology "I'm not gay, I'm just born in the wrong body".

    • @FruityHachi
      @FruityHachi 12 днів тому +4

      the term isn't misleading, it's people misunderstanding the term
      it's like saying fast cars, doesn't insinuate that all cars are fast, and million other examples when an adjective is used in front of a noun
      plus, the term is only invoked in bad situations, nobody ever used it for LOTR or Keanu Reeves for example

    • @janet3782
      @janet3782 12 днів тому +1

      @@FruityHachi Yes, it's misunderstood or misinterpreted might be better way of explaining it. What do you mean by "the term is only invoked in bad situations"? I have no idea about the Keanu Reeves reference or what LOTR means

    • @lancewalker2595
      @lancewalker2595 12 днів тому +1

      I wonder how much my "lived experience" is worth to you? Let's find out. As a man, who grew up as a boy, the VAST MAJORITY of the stigmatization and shaming I, and ALL of my male friends, experienced came from women (like you) who presumed (like you) to project their feminist prejudices upon our NATURAL WAY OF BEING. Sure, sure. Of course I'm not disagreeing that overtly repressive narratives which place arbitrary and decontextualized constraints upon boys is bad... what I'm pointing out is the fact that such narratives are NOT DOMINATE in contemporary western culture. The dominant narrative is that of all the female teachers who take it upon themselves to SHAME, RIDICULE, and summarily DRUG into a state of pharmaceutically enforced passivity every boy born with the apparently "disordered" condition of being TYPICALLY MALE. Please, spare me this old rhetoric about the harmful consequences of "traditional masculinity"... THAT ISN'T A THING ANYMORE; and if you were willing to set aside the myopia of the feminist ideology to which you so incorrigibly cleave, and actually ACTED as though you respected the humanity and individuality of boys by asking THEM about THEIR experiences through childhood, you'd realize the simple fact that in a world wherein "The Future Is Female!" the majority of boys aren't being dehumanized, shamed, and blamed for failing to act ENOUGH like a boy... their punished for their inevitable and incontrovertible failures to STOP being boys. From your comment, it's clear that you fundamentally do not regard males as equally human to yourself, as evidenced by your blithe disregard for even the pretense of considering the possibility that YOUR assessment of the male perspective and experience might be just a little less perfect than you imagine it to be. I would never even think to assert that women and girls do not have a unique and EXCLUSIVELY FEMALE set of experiences and challenges in life... and nor would you, you'd agree that there are simply aspects to female existence that males simply cannot understand for want of a uniquely female perspective; the funny thing is, it never occurred to you to wonder if perhaps it might be the case that there is an equivalently exclusive set of experiences and challenges behind each of the perfectly HEALTHY masculine behaviors that you deign to judge and condemn in consequence of the erroneous assumption that your feminine perspective subsumes ALL valid human perspective. I'm sure you mean well, but truly I say: women like you are creating generations of boys too afraid to live for fear of being the monster feminism takes them to be, and many of them do not recover because they're too busy either biting the bullet they've spent their entire boyhood attempting to reconcile in silent existential despair, or else swallowing that bullet in acts of hopeless acquiescence to the gnawing futility of longing for a sense of belonging that they have always been alienated from.

    • @FruityHachi
      @FruityHachi 12 днів тому +1

      @ by bad situations I meant situations which you were describing above.
      and LOTR is Lord of The Rings, Keanu Reeves is a beloved actor who plays masculine roles and nobody ever said anything bad about that

    • @janet3782
      @janet3782 12 днів тому +1

      @@FruityHachi I'm not following what you mean. When there's a pattern of negative or damaging behaviours or traits that's observed, and linked to a particular cohort, it's often given a label. I agree the term "toxic masculinity" is often used when it shouldn't be, but I think this is because it's misinterpreted or misunderstood, like I've explained.
      I'm still not understanding what you mean about LOTR or Keanu Reeves? Can you explain that.

  • @garypowell9612
    @garypowell9612 8 днів тому +1

    I was a co-writer of the film this panel is discussing & provided a male perspective as well as a gay male perspective during my many hours of work on this film, both of which I regard as very important in the discussion about why young men are being drawn into transgenderism.

  • @garrick5873
    @garrick5873 12 днів тому +23

    Oh it's Andrew Doyle! Love that dude.

    • @janet3782
      @janet3782 12 днів тому +3

      He's so well spoken

  • @jumblyman
    @jumblyman 8 днів тому

    Can you please put the date these discussions. Really important.

  • @Matti-r4c
    @Matti-r4c 11 днів тому +3

    No plastic surgery on any child EVER!!!!!!

    • @apersonwhoknows
      @apersonwhoknows 8 днів тому

      Even ear or nose? Some people do that for their kids.

  • @sn4rff
    @sn4rff 11 днів тому +4

    thanks for this ❤

  • @karenrussodalmolin9451
    @karenrussodalmolin9451 7 днів тому

    Thank you for your courage 💛🤍💜

  • @robertmarshall2502
    @robertmarshall2502 11 днів тому +4

    10:12 100%. This shouldn't be happening to anyone. These surgeries are terrible whatever your age.

  • @MelindaNorth
    @MelindaNorth 11 днів тому +1

    How do we get a copy of this document?

  • @westcoastblue
    @westcoastblue 3 дні тому

    this was great!
    (I have one complaint--there was a lot of great discussion about bad stereotyping of males and females...
    I wish there had not been a dig about mansplaining at the beginning!)

  • @AndyJarman
    @AndyJarman 9 днів тому +1

    "Reassigning gender" - just think about that term. If you think gender is assigned, then it is simply a fashion statement and not immutable.
    Truly nonsensical!

  • @MidNightRider2001
    @MidNightRider2001 12 днів тому +2

    The hidden costs?

  • @ll1881ll
    @ll1881ll 10 днів тому

    Excellent lecture. But when describing anti trans or anti gay , it’s not phobia. It’s anti.

  • @clairhonnor6211
    @clairhonnor6211 10 днів тому

    We will keep fighting
    We will win
    The alternative is not acceptable
    Ive voted left for 35 years and shan't again untill this cancer is expunged from the labour party

  • @HearthMoonRising1
    @HearthMoonRising1 8 днів тому

    Answer to question "why California is not leading on this issue but TERF Island is": Lots of reasons, but one that should be emphasized: UK feminists! (The real kind.) They are well-organized, sophisticated, experienced, and effective.

  • @orchideeimperiale9670
    @orchideeimperiale9670 12 днів тому

    THANKS !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @ll1881ll
    @ll1881ll 10 днів тому

    Please don’t say we or us when describing theses issues. As if all of you and us are part of this problem.
    “We “ are the solution to this madness .

  • @ericswann1417
    @ericswann1417 11 днів тому

    30 seconds in and I'm NOT impressed. I hope things get better!!!

  • @xmaseveeve5259
    @xmaseveeve5259 8 днів тому

    Are you kidding?

  • @janebennetto5655
    @janebennetto5655 12 днів тому

    ❤️🇬🇧❌❌

  • @Selmamander
    @Selmamander 12 днів тому

    👁️👁️

  • @freyja802
    @freyja802 11 днів тому

    You are all so clueless... Wasting your last months on trying to justify your hatred to ensure you can't lose it before it ends you. I'm glad it's over soon.

    • @MelindaNorth
      @MelindaNorth 11 днів тому

      It appears that, yes, you are perhaps clueless as to what the Marxist/Communist agenda really is….the goal is to erase gender in order to push the Marxist/Communist agenda forward. The trans movement is the sacred cow of the movement. It represents the goal of getting rid of gender. It also dismantles the Capitalist family system-another goal of the Marxist movement-in order to usher in little adults into becoming the party of Democratic socialist/Marxist/ Communist movement. Marxism is evil!

    • @robertmarshall2502
      @robertmarshall2502 11 днів тому +1

      Your later months?
      Hatred?
      Where did you get that from?
      What is over soon?

    • @jocec3283
      @jocec3283 11 днів тому

      Ah... another woke leftist claiming "hatred" again...
      Same old...

    • @renbakes5083
      @renbakes5083 10 днів тому

      Project much?

  • @susanhill833
    @susanhill833 2 дні тому

    Definition of a woman: How you define a woman is by how she sees herself, a woman is one who sees herself as one in mind and soul. If a person sees themselves as a woman, thinks as a woman, acts as a woman, and lives as a woman, then what is the harm to treat and respect her as one? If you cannot have compassion for another human being then how can you ask others to have compassion for you? Show compassion, empathy, and respect by calling them the name they prefer and with the pronouns they prefer. It does NOT harm you to do so but it does great harm to them when you don’t. Definition of a Man: How you define a man is by how he sees himself, a man is one who sees himself as one in mind and soul. If a person sees themselves as a man, thinks as a man, acts as a man, and lives as a man, then what is the harm to treat and respect him as one? If you cannot have compassion for another human being then how can you ask others to have compassion for you? Show compassion, empathy, and respect by calling them the name they prefer and with the pronouns they prefer. It does NOT harm you to do so but it does great harm to them when you don’t.

  • @mariaericksen884
    @mariaericksen884 12 днів тому +7

    Disappointed to hear the anti-mask comment from a practising nurse. We are talking biological reality here yet she doesn't seem to understand how viruses spread. When we are still in an active pandemic but have ditched all mitigations, I appreciate medical staff intelligent enough to wear a mask when in the presence of a newborn baby.

    • @janet3782
      @janet3782 12 днів тому +16

      @@mariaericksen884 In America asymptomatic school children were forced to wear masks, actually physically forced, it was horrendous. I can understand her stance on masks. A lot wasn't based on science it was based on irrational fear.

    • @eswyatt
      @eswyatt 12 днів тому

      You're deranged lunacy is not "biological reality."

    • @DrGreenGiant
      @DrGreenGiant 11 днів тому +4

      We know how the virus was transmitted, yes. We also know that those masks are not designed, or efficacious, against virus transmission. Loads of research done into it way before the pandemic.
      Enforcing masks that would reduce transmission might be reasonable, but that isn't what happened.

    • @robertmarshall2502
      @robertmarshall2502 11 днів тому +5

      Sorry do you think we're in "an active pandemic"?
      That's ludicrous.

    • @jaythomas5045
      @jaythomas5045 11 днів тому

      @@DrGreenGiantif “those masks” you mean surgical or cloth masks then absolutely. If you mean a well fitting kn95 or n95 however you’re off here, countless studies have shown those masks to be highly effective in reducing viral transmission. Masks don’t work like a filter or sieve and the physics and technology involved is actually pretty amazing!