'We Are Open to Peace Talks With India', says Pak COAS, Gen. Asim Munir

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 19 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 454

  • @tesoridellasia
    @tesoridellasia День тому +70

    Gentleman got more audience from Pakistan and less in his own country because of realistic approach.

    • @kamlipaul8498
      @kamlipaul8498 День тому +5

      Yes bcoz he Talk with Logic and Balance. As a Pakistani I also Want Total peace and Business with India but By Civilians not any GHQ Corrupt army Generals. GHQ must Shut their Mouth it’s Civilians Job To Talk with India or other countries. 👍🏼🇵🇰

    • @Elodie12313
      @Elodie12313 День тому +5

      Realistic nahi. ye pak Kai geet 3saal se ga rha hai ...
      Isliye Iski Audience pak ki hai....
      Tum pak wale CT Nhi kra sakte baat karte ho bdi bdi...

    • @nishantshrivastava9674
      @nishantshrivastava9674 День тому +1

      @@tesoridellasia R u saying Pakistanis r realist with pragmatic approach?? 🤭🤭🤭

    • @adeshsingh4381
      @adeshsingh4381 День тому +2

      He is a pakistani supporter

    • @nirmalbhel3231
      @nirmalbhel3231 День тому +2

      If you talk Pak China is great, India is wrong... then you can expect who will listen. This guy is Chinese payroll, teamed with Gazla. both made few visits to China and Pak

  • @deepakseth6256
    @deepakseth6256 День тому +22

    Someone has commented that you have more followers in Pakistan than in India because of your realistic approach!!!

    • @ahmedkauser9996
      @ahmedkauser9996 День тому

      Do you agree?

    • @mayankjaiswal9202
      @mayankjaiswal9202 День тому +1

      😂😂😂

    • @Elodie12313
      @Elodie12313 День тому +2

      😂😂 wahi main soch rha hoon...fir to Zakir naik ka alg hi swag hoga....😂😂

    • @nishantshrivastava9674
      @nishantshrivastava9674 День тому +2

      The very same reason why salman rushidi has more admirers in India than Pakistan😊

    • @MysticSage-hg3jh
      @MysticSage-hg3jh День тому +1

      Yes Pakistanis Are More Realistic Which is Why They Have Number 1 Army, Number1 Intelligence Agency, Number 1 Economy in the World, Number 1 Forex Reserves in the World
      So Whoever Commented That Was 100 % Correct

  • @brasherish
    @brasherish День тому +24

    Both countries should resolve all outstanding issues and become a eu type entity. But never gonna happen as long as BJP type governments persists in india.

    • @tanweeralam1650
      @tanweeralam1650 День тому

      Both countries can do progress on their even when they don't have any relation. Both needs to chart their own path.

    • @SigmaRulesEdit-g3v
      @SigmaRulesEdit-g3v День тому +2

      Why are you worried about India when your own republic was made on religious basis have a shame

    • @tanweeralam1650
      @tanweeralam1650 День тому +1

      @@SigmaRulesEdit-g3v Why should he feel shame because his country was made based on religion?? Your argument is wrong

    • @SigmaRulesEdit-g3v
      @SigmaRulesEdit-g3v День тому +1

      @tanweeralam1650 that's the problem of 1% testosterone level Pakistani can't tolerate simple logic if your country is based on a religion why are you complaining when someone else is doing the same

    • @SigmaRulesEdit-g3v
      @SigmaRulesEdit-g3v День тому +1

      @@brasherish see what eu has become on the verge of collapse with hungary almost out and brexit you keep this in Pakistan only

  • @MJ-cl1dm
    @MJ-cl1dm День тому +9

    You are a man of substance. It's a huge relief to listen to an expert who does not get swayed by biases and other interests. The talk is simple, factual and impersonal.

  • @charliecheng3340
    @charliecheng3340 День тому +47

    I respect this gentleman and his analysis. The man has wisdom.,

    • @manohargajananan6988
      @manohargajananan6988 День тому +1

      @@charliecheng3340 there is absolutely no doubt hat China is a world power along with US. What's in it for India to move into China camp ? India will do far better to remain neutral , protect its own interests and develop with collaboration with US technologies and R&D.

    • @shencheanglow3726
      @shencheanglow3726 День тому

      ​@@manohargajananan6988provided those supremacist element in American society are willing to help India's rise.

    • @In1221kc
      @In1221kc День тому +1

      And bias too

    • @MrMaddss123
      @MrMaddss123 День тому

      Yes he is a tool of Chinese propaganda.you call it wisdom!

  • @pashtoonkhan8548
    @pashtoonkhan8548 День тому +26

    This man is one of the intelligent Indians who speaks truth to Indians and is not biased in his opinions.

    • @santhugowda7179
      @santhugowda7179 День тому +1

      That is he is banned by ispr 😂😂

    • @pashtoonkhan8548
      @pashtoonkhan8548 День тому +1

      @santhugowda7179 ISPR is not what every Pakistani will agree with and is a military wing and not a public forum. We are talking about public and not Modi or ISPR.

    • @Elodie12313
      @Elodie12313 День тому

      ​@@pashtoonkhan8548 kya bol diya isne Aisa...
      Tum pak walo ko bs nya baap mil gya...chin Kai baad

    • @nishantshrivastava9674
      @nishantshrivastava9674 День тому

      ​@@pashtoonkhan8548 Pakistan is supare pawer of Asia paijaan😮😮😮
      Pravin is spot on. Bangladesh is next supare pawer😊

    • @devendranegi8756
      @devendranegi8756 День тому

      bro ... his is doing it only for money ... dont get very emotional ... he is just a businessman doing his business to earn money on youtube

  • @AlokAsthana1954
    @AlokAsthana1954 День тому +15

    Modi and his officers know only one thing- how to organize electoral victories. Sad to say, this includes senior officers of armed forces too.
    To him and them, this knowledge is a waste of time.
    To the Indian public too, which can accept Indian defeat at the border with China as.a great victory, this knowledge is a waste of time.
    Peace with Pak will never happen as anti Muslim sentiment gets votes to Modi. But not will war happen, Gujjus don’t fight.

    • @nick-l4o2z
      @nick-l4o2z День тому +3

      how on earth u can win a war with 4 times bigger economy?

    • @raffg7237
      @raffg7237 День тому +2

      Like vietnam win ​@@nick-l4o2z

    • @nick-l4o2z
      @nick-l4o2z День тому +1

      @@raffg7237 i think, we r in 2024 right?

    • @YSN.29
      @YSN.29 День тому

      You hv to sell ur sis then ​@@raffg7237

    • @Elodie12313
      @Elodie12313 День тому

      ​@@raffg7237 abe pagal USA Ko km samjha kya tune Wo chaae puri duniya Ko khtm karde...
      Wo to Keval democracy Kai Karan wapas aa gaye the

  • @avendrasingh2935
    @avendrasingh2935 День тому +12

    He seems a smart guy. To my mind, he has created a space for himself in Pakistan as the only Indian UA-camr who praises Pakistan army. Pakistan has population of 25-30 Cr. Even 1% as audience is good enough to make decent earning
    BTW it takes courage to praise Pakistan army 😂😂😂

    • @Elodie12313
      @Elodie12313 День тому

      Ye budda pura Pakistani hai...or kuch nhi😂

    • @irtizakhanutmanzai5891
      @irtizakhanutmanzai5891 День тому +5

      It takes courage to give credit, talk righteously and praise your enemy when everyone around you is a fool and radical. You guys are literally brainwashed by your media and government. Honestly I don't care, you should fix it for yourself but stop dreaming a out things which are not realistic anymore and specially the one which are associated with China and Pakistan. You really need to level up your game. You guys are losing on all end which is very alarming thing, you cant split yourself from Asia so as long as you are here please try to behave like a civilized nation & neighbor. A peaceful message from your neighbor ❤🇵🇰

    • @nirmalbhel3231
      @nirmalbhel3231 День тому

      what else you can expect from a Chinese paid guy

    • @zawarhussain3687
      @zawarhussain3687 День тому

      ​@@irtizakhanutmanzai5891 Agreed 👍

    • @leotm6675
      @leotm6675 День тому

      @@irtizakhanutmanzai5891 Look who is taking about civilization . If we're really losing on all sides , why your eyes are teary over it . Talking about being realistic and obsessing on kashmir at the same time says a lot about A Nation Built on Ideology .

  • @leoncioco3305
    @leoncioco3305 День тому +22

    Pravin is the only Indian analyst that can bend my ears n worth listening to. He call a spade a spade n that’s more than good enough for me. 👏👏👏👏👍👍👍👍👍

    • @nirmalbhel3231
      @nirmalbhel3231 День тому +2

      but reality is different

    • @anoopmenon9914
      @anoopmenon9914 День тому

      True he is paid by china so you will naturally like him

    • @IronMan-nu3rb
      @IronMan-nu3rb День тому

      ​@@nirmalbhel3231 You are a Pajit and BJP supporter. So shut up.

  • @Murmuz077
    @Murmuz077 День тому +10

    Always a treat to listen to you. Much appreciated

  • @hogwarts2.0
    @hogwarts2.0 День тому +1

    My faith in intellectual discourses just revived listening to your analysis where you are spiting facts without the inherent biases seen in journalists like Arnab Goswami and others . Hats off

  • @saanjanibaar8085
    @saanjanibaar8085 День тому +14

    India should free Kashmir, Zangnan Khalistan and Northeast union from Indian occupancy asap. 🇮🇳

    • @saanjanibaar8085
      @saanjanibaar8085 День тому +3

      Free Kashmir, Zangnan, Khalistan and Northeast union from india asap. 🇮🇳

    • @Elodie12313
      @Elodie12313 День тому +4

      Baap ko Mt sikha...😂😂
      Balochistan dekhle phle...

    • @devendranegi8756
      @devendranegi8756 День тому

      get yourselves freed from the Atta queue first

    • @saanjanibaar8085
      @saanjanibaar8085 День тому +5

      Looks like Godi tea seller send many bot in my comment section. None the less Kashmir, Zangnan Khalistan and Northeast union will get their independence soon from India. 🇮🇳

    • @santhugowda7179
      @santhugowda7179 День тому

      ​@@saanjanibaar8085
      Atta also want free.😂😂😂😂

  • @waseemarchieve
    @waseemarchieve День тому +11

    ❤from Pakistan sir.

    • @devendranegi8756
      @devendranegi8756 День тому +1

      don't get fooled @waseemarchieve ... you are not aware know how much $ you can make by posting such views in india ... love from anywhere doesn't really matter for them ...

  • @netaniyagul1797
    @netaniyagul1797 17 годин тому +1

    If their will be peace between india and pak, whole refiom will be prosperous but america and Britain ll never allow peave in this region

  • @DoctorFishing1989
    @DoctorFishing1989 20 годин тому +1

    Inspit of having Pakistani national and for the regional security intellect i saw Dr Pravin each info video after Balakot & swift retort operations i observe that there is no favortism in reporting terms of defense reality he spoke the real ground realities on the basis of facts no overlapping

  • @zahidanwar6023
    @zahidanwar6023 День тому +9

    Talks are the only way out for development.

    • @devendranegi8756
      @devendranegi8756 День тому +1

      that is what india was saying since the first indo-pak war ... but pak never paid attention ... now looking for talks bcoz of sinking economy and relevance ... pls @zahidanwar , we were not born yesterday

  • @parttimethinker7611
    @parttimethinker7611 День тому +2

    It’s about time for Pakistani and Indian resume their rightful place as brothers. If Indian and Pakistani can overcome their differences, it will bring hope to the world. It’ll be an extremely positive message and lesson.

    • @nirmalbhel3231
      @nirmalbhel3231 День тому

      Pak is still doing proxy in India.. so how can move forward

  • @rajaturk7713
    @rajaturk7713 День тому +12

    Praveen sir grt admirer of Ur unbiased analysis.

  • @naeemuddinkhan5377
    @naeemuddinkhan5377 День тому +3

    Super analysis. Love from Pakistan

    • @nirmalbhel3231
      @nirmalbhel3231 19 годин тому

      As long as Pakistani text books have anti-Hindu stuffs, peace is not possible. Peace between Islamic and non Islamic nation is not possible

  • @majidhussain412
    @majidhussain412 11 годин тому +1

    Excellent as usually
    Impatiently wait for your v logs
    Please also put us wise on Hot ongoing wars in other parts of world

  • @rizwanzamir3755
    @rizwanzamir3755 День тому +3

    Modi has taken Indians to a point where peace has gone blurry and chauvinism is on the ride.
    It is very hard now to bring people back to rationalism until a big war breaks and the aftereffects of war bring people to normalcy.

  • @munirhaque711
    @munirhaque711 11 годин тому

    Excellent example of true and candid approach
    Only Peace b/w Pakistan and India can turn our fates

  • @ansumanchauhan
    @ansumanchauhan День тому +12

    Mr. Sawhney, accepting the truth is essential for progress and staying vigilant about potential challenges. The reality is that Pakistan sponsors terrorism in India, which makes a weaker Pakistan aligned with our interests. Our primary focus should be on our own development, particularly in education and infrastructure. We should not overly concern ourselves with Pakistan or its alliance with China.

    • @meldyfastenersllp1931
      @meldyfastenersllp1931 День тому +2

      Perfect, but unfortunately this does not go down well with his Target audience.

    • @devendranegi8756
      @devendranegi8756 День тому

      fully agree with @ansumanchauhan ... but what can be done about people like Mr. Sawhney who is still stuck in 1947 era ... and there are a lot of them like him ....

    • @Warlock786
      @Warlock786 День тому

      That is very short sighted. Your border is genuinely under threat

    • @SigmaRulesEdit-g3v
      @SigmaRulesEdit-g3v День тому

      @@ansumanchauhan firstly if Pakistan does terrorism in india I wanna know how cause terrorism has many layers , I guess you're talking about militancy in Kashmir then why are local population supporting them ask your citizens the question if you both countries consider eachother as enemies then it's natural Pakistan will do that

    • @irtizakhanutmanzai5891
      @irtizakhanutmanzai5891 День тому +1

      It takes courage to give credit, talk righteously and praise your enemy when everyone around you is a fool and radical. You guys are literally brainwashed by your media and government. Honestly I don't care, you should fix it for yourself but stop dreaming a out things which are not realistic anymore and specially the one which are associated with China and Pakistan. You really need to level up your game. You guys are losing on all end which is very alarming thing, you cant split yourself from Asia so as long as you are here please try to behave like a civilized nation & neighbor. A peaceful message from your neighbor ❤🇵🇰

  • @mavirk
    @mavirk День тому +1

    What I like about this is the fact that gives you a total picture without imposing his will on the viewer. 🙏

  • @ruhishariff2664
    @ruhishariff2664 День тому +1

    I agree. You are certainly a non judgmental person I seen . I dua and Pakistan has so much common. We can be a force in the world together and make positive impact. Thank you

    • @nirmalbhel3231
      @nirmalbhel3231 День тому

      You can't remove Hindu-India hatred from Pak citizens... as long as those are there, friendship is not possible. Yes, it is civilization war. Many Indian Muslim also favors Pak

  • @brasherish
    @brasherish День тому +13

    But is india open to peace talks? Thats the main question.

    • @abhijithdinesh6962
      @abhijithdinesh6962 День тому +1

      Peace with india will cause end of the current pak regime. Willingness for peace should be seen in actions.

    • @anuragbanerjee2879
      @anuragbanerjee2879 День тому +4

      What do India gain ?

    • @brasherish
      @brasherish День тому

      @anuragbanerjee2879 please watch and listen to this video. My question to you. What has Europe gained thru peace since 1945?

    • @anuragbanerjee2879
      @anuragbanerjee2879 День тому

      @@brasherish Sure it did ... but not with the deal offered by Pakistan ... give me land and I will not killl you !! ... then you give land, he still kills you!

    • @MysticSage-hg3jh
      @MysticSage-hg3jh День тому +1

      *Paxtan has to first give POJK and GB to India, They Also have to give Masood Azhar, Hafiz Saeed, Dawood Ibrahim, Sajid Mir, Zaki Ur Rehman Lakhvi Etc. to India. Paxtan Army and ISI has to Accept Involvement in 1993 Mumbai, 2001 Parliament, 2006 Mumbai Train, 26/11 , Uri, Pathankot, Pulwama etc. and Apologize Publicly For Them* . After All this is Done by Paxtan, Then India and Paxtan Can Begin Peace Talks 😊

  • @muneebkhan7465
    @muneebkhan7465 День тому +2

    As you said Sir and is evident from our analysis also that China is more focusing on becoming an Economic giant while as Russia is focusing on becoming the top military power.
    If both countries are basically aligned to each other and have a civilizational base unlike the USA( As per your statement) then why do these countries have different aspirational priorities? Any special reason?

  • @dmukherjee4814
    @dmukherjee4814 День тому +2

    Pakistan has to understand that to start the talks with India they have to abandon their primary doctrine of hurting india with thousand cuts. Terrorism is perhaps the singular factor that needs to be addressed by Pakistan as it has become a global factory for Terrorism. India tried but its of no avail. Ball is in Pakistan's court. They stop their terror activities and forget about Kashmir and 370 and what not !! They have to decide whether they want Democracy or Military in disguise in the name of democracy. Islamisation and democracy alongwith Military dictatorship cannot go hand in hand. Your analysis on China and Russia is commendable.

    • @naeemuddinkhan5377
      @naeemuddinkhan5377 День тому +1

      It is India who is at fault not Pakistan . Have an open mind pl

    • @KFaizan4857
      @KFaizan4857 День тому

      Kashmir, Zangnan, Khalistan and Northeast union will get their independence soon from India.

    • @pervezak
      @pervezak День тому

      Who has cut who? Indian forces have aghresswd against all its neighbours. Should I enumerate.?

    • @naeemuddinkhan5377
      @naeemuddinkhan5377 День тому +1

      @@dmukherjee4814 you are so wrong in your assessment . My humble request stop abusing Pakistan first and then sit down and talk . Pakistan always are hospitable people and welcome Indians in Pakistan whereas in India what filth is thrown at us by your media . We are a brave and hospitable nation . We have patience and love. Try from your side

    • @dmukherjee4814
      @dmukherjee4814 23 години тому

      @@naeemuddinkhan5377 We are not talking about Pakistani people. Rest you can read from history.

  • @charlesyang4923
    @charlesyang4923 День тому +2

    Dina Boluarte, President of Peru, delivered her speech during Chancay Port opening inauguration by addressing her wish “to become Singapore of S. America” which also suggests Peru will start with playing a transportation hub to a manufacturing hub and possibly leadup to a business and financial hub. American geopolitician is extreme worrisome about China’s move for its emphatically break free of Monroe doctrine which first established 1850 to shut door off to European from interference, and continue to this day before by maintaining and have a complete control over seaport loadable reloadable from S. America must to go thru Panama cannel or Port Mexico for trans-shipment arrangements. In conclusion. This is a historic moments for Peru and extendable to all S. America nations and people. Because S. America just make to their future one big step closer to Asia which is the most economically thriving region where manufactured goods can all be exchanged.

  • @mistman5640
    @mistman5640 День тому +5

    Pakistani air force is training for J-35A as I type this. India will never get F-35 from America.

    • @santhugowda7179
      @santhugowda7179 День тому +1

      Pakistan will get 10 gen 😂😂😂😂
      Mig 21 is more than enough 😂😂😂

    • @nishantshrivastava9674
      @nishantshrivastava9674 День тому +1

      India can get Su 57 anytime it wants.
      We are not Chinese or American colony unlike Superpower Pakistan😊

    • @nirmalbhel3231
      @nirmalbhel3231 День тому

      India can get SU57 or SU75 at any time. Pak needs to gave up Gazwa-e-Hind.. else they will collapse. In 15 yrs, India will $10T economy and Pak will be $0.5 T

    • @mistman5640
      @mistman5640 11 годин тому

      Russia has nothing to export right now. Everything is going to the fight in Ukraine. Maybe after Russia defeated Ukraine and rebuild it military. When will that be?
      Keep smoking the good hash, bai

  • @Sando-q3b
    @Sando-q3b День тому +5

    Sir, your analysis is always very impartial and meaningful. As for Gen Munir, he will be retired very soon and is 2nd most disliked army chief after Bajwa.
    The people will not want dialogue with india without IOK being resolved according to wishes of indigenous Kashmiris.

    • @Juandinggong
      @Juandinggong День тому +1

      At this point what Kashmiri people wants doesn’t matter what so ever. That boat has sailed long time ago after they slaughtered Hindus! Kashmir is the biggest national threat to India

    • @Sando-q3b
      @Sando-q3b День тому +1

      @Juandinggong To you it does not matter because you are a foreigner in kashmir, but for kashmiris they will liberate their nation .
      As for boat sailing ' exactly what soviet union said in 1980s and within a decade the union was a dumped on heap of history. Unions never last, inevitable destiny.

    • @ohm4500
      @ohm4500 14 годин тому

      @@Sando-q3bin your ass

  • @moko8870
    @moko8870 18 годин тому

    Print journalism always undermines India

  • @manohargajananan6988
    @manohargajananan6988 День тому +3

    Ok !
    India and Pakistan should have meaningful dialogue .
    Could you propose a brief ?

    • @hishamyousaf999
      @hishamyousaf999 День тому +1

      India should do meaningful dialogue with Pakistan on Kashmir and bring everlasting peace in South Asia otherwise no peace.

    • @Arunh9-pw7lp
      @Arunh9-pw7lp День тому +1

      @@hishamyousaf999that’s blackmailing. It’s like talk to us on Kashmir or else we’ll not let peace established in the subcontinent. And then you complain why Pakistanis & pakistan aren’t respected in the world.

    • @manohargajananan6988
      @manohargajananan6988 День тому +1

      @@hishamyousaf999 J & K is an integral part of India. Discussion over .
      Next topic ?

    • @nishantshrivastava9674
      @nishantshrivastava9674 День тому

      ​@@hishamyousaf999 Pakistan can't bring anything on the table. For India, there is nothing to gain in this.
      What makes u think.. u have any kind of leverage over us to negotiate??
      Come after 500 yrs and we think about peace🥱

    • @irtizakhanutmanzai5891
      @irtizakhanutmanzai5891 День тому

      ​@@Arunh9-pw7lpIt takes courage to give credit, talk righteously and praise your enemy when everyone around you is a fool and radical. You guys are literally brainwashed by your media and government. Honestly I don't care, you should fix it for yourself but stop dreaming a out things which are not realistic anymore and specially the one which are associated with China and Pakistan. You really need to level up your game. You guys are losing on all end which is very alarming thing, you cant split yourself from Asia so as long as you are here please try to behave like a civilized nation & neighbor. A peaceful message from your neighbor ❤🇵🇰

  • @qasarkhan6628
    @qasarkhan6628 День тому +4

    The problem with Pak india is, the wrong partition took place. 25 crores got more land than 10 crores muslims without phased transfer of population religion wise having population based pro rata basis land distribution. Thus both Muslims and Hindus had suffered and are still facing hatred. .Partition was political, not religious. But Hindus termed it as Muslims got their part. Kashmir and Hyderabad faced military action. Pak is hijacked by the army. .

    • @tanweeralam1650
      @tanweeralam1650 День тому

      Partition ke time se bahar aao... Kashmir issue is important. Wo solve ho jaye to phir... Pakistan can progress.
      Remember Pakistan progress karne ke liye India ka zarurat Nahin he

    • @CosmicValkyrie
      @CosmicValkyrie День тому

      Partition should never have been allowed. It's better for all of us to be together. Now the West is playing divide and rule once again.

    • @SigmaRulesEdit-g3v
      @SigmaRulesEdit-g3v День тому +1

      ​@@tanweeralam1650 should water be stopped you will be thirsty

    • @nishantshrivastava9674
      @nishantshrivastava9674 День тому

      Total exchange of population is the only way.. even if some lands r given on negotiations😊
      Thats the wrong part in partition.

    • @CosmicValkyrie
      @CosmicValkyrie День тому

      @@nishantshrivastava9674 stop saying dumb things. there is already too much stupidity in india.

  • @MdKhanb-p5d
    @MdKhanb-p5d День тому +2

    Sir I am big fan of you from BD

  • @Truthstelling
    @Truthstelling Годину тому

    Intelligent and knowledgeable host. thank you for sharing

  • @gauravtejpal8901
    @gauravtejpal8901 4 години тому

    The truth is that India and Pakistan are brothers - but harming each other under the influence of the evil Western powers 😢

  • @itzadi786
    @itzadi786 День тому +1

    How did you get in margala conference

  • @304Gopal
    @304Gopal День тому +9

    Excellent analysis.. Thank you

  • @santhugowda7179
    @santhugowda7179 День тому +1

    Chinese support pakistan complete.
    Pakistan no i will go to IMF. We are member.of IMF 😂😂😂

  • @hasnainhaider8914
    @hasnainhaider8914 День тому

    Respect from Pakistan, I have been seeing your videos for a long time and agree with the balanced approach. Its time we move forward in mutual develpment. We have similar culture, I can easily say more Pakistani see northern Indian movies more than the Indian south see northern Indian movies. Thankfully the hate mongering in both countries are going down, and the reality is upon us, global warming, smog and water shortage are its signs. It will test the subcontinent first in the world. Now both countries should be prepared for it, and work jointly to move forward. Both should give mutual assurance to each other that they will look after the minorities and help them develop, and not to take advantage of them.

  • @bhagwanbhagchandani5627
    @bhagwanbhagchandani5627 19 годин тому

    FOOLS BE FOOLED BY FOOLISH OR FOOLISH ARE EASY TO BE FOOLED BY FOOLS

  • @PuruShothama-i7z
    @PuruShothama-i7z 17 годин тому

    Pak leaders talked
    but Kargil happened.
    Now what.

  • @hockchyequa2776
    @hockchyequa2776 День тому +5

    You should be the foreign minister of India instead of the dishonest Jai---.

    • @santhugowda7179
      @santhugowda7179 День тому +2

      😂😂😂😂
      Asim munir is prim minister of pakistan.
      Shazzad Hussain shariff is chprasee😂😂😂

    • @nishantshrivastava9674
      @nishantshrivastava9674 День тому

      I can feel ur pain n frustration😢
      Jai Shankar doesn't suit ur narrative😊

  • @sumitray6615
    @sumitray6615 День тому +1

    Can terrorism & dialogue continue simultaneously?Previously whenever there was a peace process there was a terrorist attack.

    • @irtizakhanutmanzai5891
      @irtizakhanutmanzai5891 День тому

      It takes courage to give credit, talk righteously and praise your enemy when everyone around you is a fool and radical. You guys are literally brainwashed by your media and government. Honestly I don't care, you should fix it for yourself but stop dreaming a out things which are not realistic anymore and specially the one which are associated with China and Pakistan. You really need to level up your game. You guys are losing on all end which is very alarming thing, you cant split yourself from Asia so as long as you are here please try to behave like a civilized nation & neighbor. A peaceful message from your neighbor ❤🇵🇰

  • @dipakchoudhuri4629
    @dipakchoudhuri4629 День тому

    PAK IS OPEN TO PEACE TALKS WITH INDIA!!!!!!!!!...
    REALLY???????????????
    HAVE I MISSED SOMETHING?????? 😅

  • @MysticSage-hg3jh
    @MysticSage-hg3jh День тому +8

    *Mr. Pi Xhing Son Yi , Paxtan has to first give POJK and GB to India*
    *They Also have to give Masood Azhar, Hafiz Saeed, Dawood Ibrahim, Sajid Mir, Zaki Ur Rehman Lakhvi Etc. to India*
    *Paxtan Army and ISI has to Accept Involvement in 1993 Mumbai, 2001 Parliament, 2006 Mumbai Train, 26/11 , Uri, Pathankot, Pulwama etc. and Apologize Publicly For Them* . After All this is Done by Paxtan, Then India and Paxtan Can Begin Peace Talks 😊

    • @Fawad-do6zy
      @Fawad-do6zy День тому +1

      Lun te waj tu te teri army 😂
      Why most of the indians especially Hindus are childish and very emotional 🤦

    • @suvosingho-pp9xf
      @suvosingho-pp9xf День тому

      ​@@Fawad-do6zyH CEO ka youtuber kyu chala rha hai ab dull? 😂

    • @khursheedyasin4695
      @khursheedyasin4695 День тому +1

      You did not ask for biryani, what drug are you on?

    • @umairahmed7704
      @umairahmed7704 День тому +3

      Keep on counting. But don't forget to count East Pakistan first at your side then continue doing counts for Pakistan....

    • @devendranegi8756
      @devendranegi8756 День тому

      yes ... but prior to that we must handover Mr. Sawhney to Pakistan so that he can join Asim Munir as his advisor ... and may be get a plot in DHA ... anyways the Librandus, Democrats, Soros and Xi will very soon stop funding such youtubers .... their time is up !!

  • @drycloud
    @drycloud День тому

    The peace talk offer means nothing until a people's representative government is in place . Dynamics of Pak politics have changed

  • @zahiddurrani4688
    @zahiddurrani4688 День тому +3

    Sir.pl also have us vlog.on Russian scholar

  • @moizshaban4677
    @moizshaban4677 День тому

    As usual, liked and loved your video. Not surprised to hear that lots of ministers and other dignitaries do the same. Thanks for the video, really appreciate

  • @Adlersimon
    @Adlersimon День тому

    Amazing person you are Sir. bht hi great analyses krty hain esy logon ko dekh kr lgta hai shayad qudrat hm se abhi completely disappoint nhi hui hai.

  • @CZAC
    @CZAC День тому +1

    question is peace at what price for the Kashmiri people on both side

  • @Wishfulthinker9383
    @Wishfulthinker9383 День тому

    The video became a paid promotion of BRI and China 😂😂

  • @sidsharma8100
    @sidsharma8100 День тому

    Pakistan is doing a really good job right now and hopefully will keep doing the same in the future. India should sit all of this out and not interrupt them at all. Everyone getting what they deserve, we will not need any talk in about 20 years or so. We should protect our borders and be indifferent to all advances.

  • @santhugowda7179
    @santhugowda7179 День тому

    Standard dialogue.
    He has not said from position of weakness 😂😂😂😂

  • @anjummirza1452
    @anjummirza1452 Годину тому

    Excellent information and narration...

  • @stevenpreston5619
    @stevenpreston5619 День тому +7

    Great information as usual

  • @coolbreeze2213
    @coolbreeze2213 18 годин тому

    While this man talks intelligently and even wisely I get the feeling he is a spy for China.

  • @baizamehdi4951
    @baizamehdi4951 День тому +3

    As always,an intellectual ,informative un biased assessment of the topic. THANK YOU from Pakistan

  • @rizwanhussain645
    @rizwanhussain645 День тому +4

    Spot on as always 👌. Kudos Sawhney Sahab

  • @AsifAhmedKhan-n1z
    @AsifAhmedKhan-n1z День тому +5

    Respected Mr Praveen Sahab
    General Bazwa is very betrayal parson to pak Army
    Betrayal deceitful cowardice in pak Amry Mr Bazwa

    • @nick-l4o2z
      @nick-l4o2z День тому

      he is just misleading u and not giving a true picture of india and Morover he is merely a youtuber like others so be careful what u r consuming

    • @tanweeralam1650
      @tanweeralam1650 День тому

      ​@@nick-l4o2z what is the true picture??

    • @nick-l4o2z
      @nick-l4o2z День тому +1

      @@tanweeralam1650 whatever he has been telling in the course of his youtube journey is nothing but a propaganda of indian opposition and unfortunately even Pakistani r falling in his trap because thatswhat makes them happy but that's not true!

    • @tanweeralam1650
      @tanweeralam1650 День тому

      @@nick-l4o2z ok. What is the true picture which you mentioned?

    • @nick-l4o2z
      @nick-l4o2z День тому

      @@tanweeralam1650 there is no appetite in india for restoring any sort of relationship with Pakistan regardless of the political parties but he will not reveal that because then his audience ( which happened to be only Pakistani) will stop watching him and moreover he will never disclose that he is informal member of congress whose job is just to speak lies sothat he can manipulate some Muslims votes and so on so forth ,its impossible for a Pakistani to fathom the complexities of indian politics!

  • @Wishfulthinker9383
    @Wishfulthinker9383 20 годин тому

    India’s dialogue with Pakistan will lead to nothing.
    Look at this cycle-> India talks to civilian govt in Pak-> moving towards peace -> Pak army lose its significance, can no more hype bogey of Indian threat-> Pak army does terrorist act in India may be without Pak civilian govt knowledge-> Pak govt denies that they did attack-> relationship sours-> next round: after many years some new Pravin Sawhney talks about peace.
    Problem is with Pakistan govt is that they can not control its Army’s India policy. If there is peace with India, Pak ppl will question -what did you do for country except for raking up kashmir/India threat in last 7 decades, even Bangladesh moved ahead. Why do Pak need such expenditure on army? Etc etc.
    Animosity with India is desirable for Pak Army that controls everything in Pakistan. Even if India agrees to LoC as permanent boundary, Pak army will not stop terrorism.

  • @fakhrealam2008
    @fakhrealam2008 День тому +1

    Very good conclusion but it's challenging times.

    • @manohargajananan6988
      @manohargajananan6988 День тому

      @@fakhrealam2008 where is the conclusion? India and Pakistan are in a idealogical colflict . Do you agree that India and Pakistan share a common civilizational state ? The chunt is cuckoo! Pakistan was formed on the basis of civilizational differences that resulted in a identity crisis ! India is in the process of reclaiming that civilizational identity! That's the foundation of the bloody crisis !

  • @MAR-lt7xo
    @MAR-lt7xo День тому

    The Pakistani establishment is on a very weak political footing locally. They are desperate for peace talks with India to satisfy China and the West. It's a golden opportunity for India to engage them and try to strike a deal quickly but there is no guarantee of public support for any such deal and could be rejected at any later stage as it happened in Bangladesh. But a two-front war pressure from India will be reduced.

    • @nishantshrivastava9674
      @nishantshrivastava9674 День тому +1

      There can never be any deal or peace with them.
      Aaj jeb phati h, pet khali h, hath me 🥣 h to peace peace kr rhe.. kal jaise hi economically stable ho gye India se trade krke.. phir se..
      Twra mera rishta kya... la😊😊😊😊

  • @MuhammadKhan-hk5qz
    @MuhammadKhan-hk5qz День тому

    One question why army generals have red band on cap ,this is remnant of British control.Our army shoukd have a green band around cap.

  • @diabetesasia
    @diabetesasia День тому +2

    Thanks for analysis 🎉 act of balancing

  • @abdulqayyumgoraya3843
    @abdulqayyumgoraya3843 День тому +1

    Positive competitiveness is wt. India and china should look for the collective good of " The Third World Countries".

  • @nikkala786
    @nikkala786 День тому

    Pravin Sir is a wise man whose strategical knowledge is of the highest order but sadly his advice is not taken or endorsed by the powers that are because he shows the mirror to them which makes them appear ugly

  • @gauravdas6741
    @gauravdas6741 День тому

    What's your take on recently test of hypersonic missile? Does Pakistan will beg for such technologies from china and paint them green.? 😅😂😂

  • @iqbalmohammed51im
    @iqbalmohammed51im День тому +3

    Peace talk should be done with. Imran khan... Pakistan army generals have no support of public

    • @abhijithdinesh6962
      @abhijithdinesh6962 День тому

      But pakisthanis run by the generals. The elected govt is just a puppet 6:20

    • @sahibzadasafi1701
      @sahibzadasafi1701 День тому +1

      Kon hai Imran Khan?? Loooorhooo kci skasiat ki muhabbat m Etna aagy Mt brho k mulk sy aagy rakh loo..

  • @yaqootmir6761
    @yaqootmir6761 День тому

    It’s GEO ECONOMICS FOLKS. That is the secret sauce if this new dish is to be prepared.

  • @serajulhuda3624
    @serajulhuda3624 День тому

    India was divided in 1947 to live like USA and Canada and even after bitterness of partition both countries without passport or visa till1951and peaceful travell till 1965 Why we cannot return to the previous era of 1965?

  • @ghulamyasin7790
    @ghulamyasin7790 День тому +6

    i always wait your analysis and notification

  • @samirlg5
    @samirlg5 День тому

    India reply to Asif Munnir of Pakistan..... We are open to Listen to Peace Talks of Pakistan... Come on Start Talking Mr Asif Munnir. We are Listening.

  • @quazisanjeed6395
    @quazisanjeed6395 День тому

    First, army is not the representative of people. Therefore, Pakistan must learn to let people's representatives run the country. Your appeal will only make the world laugh.

  • @ranjitsumati27
    @ranjitsumati27 День тому

    Unfortunately, the ministers, leaders and especially the FM heading Foreign Ministry, controlled and directed by THE Foreign power WILL NOT at all do anything or work towards having good relations with PAK or CHINA as good relations with either and will NOT be in the interest of THE Foreign Power which will always be working towards isolating India to keep and USE India for it's interest.

  • @mujtabaleghari8284
    @mujtabaleghari8284 День тому +1

    ❤ from PAKISTAN 🇵🇰

  • @nirmalbhel3231
    @nirmalbhel3231 День тому +1

    India had enough, should avoid any talks with Pak... CPEC is a failed project

  • @yathindrak1295
    @yathindrak1295 День тому +1

    Who is funding this channel?

    • @TheAnuragsingh
      @TheAnuragsingh День тому

      CCP

    • @nirmalbhel3231
      @nirmalbhel3231 День тому

      He Gazla started this. Gazla is a Kashmiri separatist both made few trips to Pakistan and China. their videos are available

    • @gauravtejpal8901
      @gauravtejpal8901 3 години тому

      ​@@TheAnuragsingh Go complain to Trump 😂

  • @TariqKhusrou
    @TariqKhusrou День тому

    India a competitor of China?? Indian GDP is $ 3.8 Trillion vs China at $ 18.3 Trillion??

  • @RHRHVL
    @RHRHVL День тому +1

    Mr. Sawhney Pakistan shares geography not civilizational heritage with India 🇮🇳

  • @fabianprudence
    @fabianprudence День тому

    Gen Asim Munir Naqvi is not a Syed but 'Chohan' and his real caste is Dhobi. Pak Armed Forces' peace overtures are obvious enough to suggest that they are only interested in pelf and perfidy and stashing the ill-gotten wealth overseas instead of defending the valid basis of separation of Pakistan from India with the requisite tenacity i.e., the Hindu Rashtra. Pakistan's matric pass mad Gens are prima facie dishonest hence offering the Hindu Rashtra peace only to exhibit their real intentions, i.e., truce, a clear preference for pomp and show and robbing and looting the national wealth while making the nation lulled with glib assertions.

  • @jaferazeem-es8ih
    @jaferazeem-es8ih День тому

    Who let asim munir start talks? He has no legitimacy & support to do this.

  • @bluebird7230
    @bluebird7230 День тому +4

    BJP don't want to talk with Pakistan their politics agenda is not to talk with Pakistan.

  • @deepakseth6256
    @deepakseth6256 День тому

    By now foretell fairly accurately what Mr Sawhney will have to say

  • @farhanakhan3747
    @farhanakhan3747 День тому

    And theres soo much misinformation around his talk portraying it in a hostile light towards India.😮.😢.
    Its soo draining to check every news factually to get a balanced analysis .

  • @OnkarShrma
    @OnkarShrma День тому +1

    80% video was dedicated to China. We thought video was about Pak. It looked like PR for CCP.

  • @shakir1665
    @shakir1665 День тому +1

    Until the liberation of my Kashmir from both india pakistan...every initiative is going to fail.

    • @abhijithdinesh6962
      @abhijithdinesh6962 День тому +3

      Never gonna happen dude. Acceptthe reality and move on

    • @shakir1665
      @shakir1665 День тому +1

      @abhijithdinesh6962 then kashmir ulcer is going to ruin india and pakistan. Bro kashmir is unfinished business of partition which is benefiting only politicians of both sides not common people.

    • @abhijithdinesh6962
      @abhijithdinesh6962 День тому

      @@shakir1665 you are right. I just told u that kashmir won't be free anytime soon. I just mentioned the possibility. Nothing to do with history of kashmir or any moral basis of kashmiri freedom.

    • @nick-l4o2z
      @nick-l4o2z День тому +1

      ​@@shakir1665not possible, and Morover kashmir issue is fully based on religion and thatswhy u guys needs to be cope within india or ................😢😢😢😢😢

    • @nick-l4o2z
      @nick-l4o2z День тому

      ​@@abhijithdinesh6962anytime soon?

  • @MazharHussain-id2ke
    @MazharHussain-id2ke День тому +1

    A very incisive analyst...zabardast

  • @sathishballal8173
    @sathishballal8173 День тому

    But Pakisthan has already proved its highly inconsistent decisions making and its motives are not its own but predominently of Chaines instigated. Otherwise it can develop close friendship ties with India and enjoy the Kahsmir benifits together with it which is economically and culturally of great advantage for iitself.

  • @asimjabbar8445
    @asimjabbar8445 День тому

    India should take advantage of the Pakistani General's condition. Bajwa was ready to surrender before india. Now this army chief also offered the similar deal to india. Pakistani generals and PDM Govt is desperate to have cordial relations with India to please the American empire.

    • @nishantshrivastava9674
      @nishantshrivastava9674 День тому

      They hadn't honour their words before.. not with America, not with Afghanistan. We learn from other's mistakes.
      Absolutely no relationship.. double cross has become their natural policy😊

  • @yaqootmir6761
    @yaqootmir6761 День тому +1

    Peru by the way is the leading nation in the world in mining along with Chile.

  • @atul4349
    @atul4349 День тому

    What happened to CPEC? Dint live in a make believe world

  • @shahidkorotanaadv8146
    @shahidkorotanaadv8146 День тому +1

    This Asim Munir is a psychopath, has imposed a martial law plus n has destroyed the democratic fibre of the country , thousands belonging to Imran s party r missing or in jail , human rights violations r it's peak. He has totally gone mad

  • @naveedsafder2190
    @naveedsafder2190 22 години тому

    Very well explained

  • @professoraftab7488
    @professoraftab7488 День тому

    Our generals are floating ideas that how important is to restore peace in the region.can Indian generals do this job.this is good offer by general Asim.please take it seriously.

    • @asimjabbar8445
      @asimjabbar8445 День тому +1

      Sorry to say Indian Generals job is to fight or get his forces ready to fight when ordered by their Govt. Indian Generals don't make policies, foreign relations, build business empires, make parallel for of Government etc etc.
      The Indian PM or cabinet member like Jay shankar, Defence minister or Modi would be the people to expect reaction from the Indian side. May be they form the policy and their foreign secretary would respond to some foreign army chief's offer.
      In Pakistan army chief is the ultimate ruler, the undeclared king of the country. India doesn't operate like that.

    • @asimjabbar8445
      @asimjabbar8445 День тому

      All indian general can say is that "we are ready to take kinetic action against adversary." Or he would say "we would take back GB or Pakistani Kashmir whenever our Govt would tell us to do so." That's the real job of General Army Chief. Militaries don't negotiate in foreign affairs or make peace deals with their enemy. It's the job of the politicians and civil bureaucracy sitting in the foreign office.

    • @asimjabbar8445
      @asimjabbar8445 День тому +1

      The peace offers 🕊️ delivered by the military commander shows the signs of weakness or surrender. Whenever a military general offers peace, it generally means to wave the white flag of surrender.
      There's a reason why Generals shouldn't sit on the negotiating tables. But Pakistan is a unique case indeed. The modern militaries and civilized Govts don't work like that.
      Have you ever seen the top military commander of any other nuclear power discussing/offering peace deals or sitting on a peace negotiating table? That's disgusting and utter disgrace for the rank of a military chief, but not for Pakistan though.

  • @nikaawan9555
    @nikaawan9555 День тому

    I HAVE ALWAYS ADMIRED MR PRAVIN FOR HIS SENSIBLE AND LOGICAL EXPLANATIONS.
    Pakistan from the very first day is open to any sensible, and logical dialogue as far as it is based and is on par on mutual respect and recognition,NO DISRESPECT Pak has never been hostile and given the size of its adversary its not in Pakistan's favor logically, But Pakistani counterpart THE SO CALLED IN. DIANS always mistook it as Pakistan's weakness, And has lived in their own delusional world, Thinking its somekind of Boll. ywood movie.
    But the truth is They can never make pak subdue.Pakistan has never been deterred by them Nor it ever will be, and has always made sure pak is on par with them on the operational level.... which has given them nightmares.They must come out of this and think sensibly...The world is changing rapidly and They cannot stay in their bubble for any more longer....Its high time they must think logically before its too late.
    They must not become a pawn for the west in this game, and should look at the regional opportunities which are obviously gonna benefit them as well.
    They must stop looking itself as a big brother and that they can take on china.

  • @RanaMohsan-fl7el
    @RanaMohsan-fl7el День тому +6

    Genius

  • @Red.bulldozer3
    @Red.bulldozer3 День тому +1

    Indians should be more demanding with pakustan as india recently had tested some fearful weapons.

  • @m.junaidmahmood4209
    @m.junaidmahmood4209 День тому

    There can be many keyboard warriors from both sides of the spectrum saying ill words about each other because of 1, they lack any understanding of geo politics and driven by media fed agendas & 2, historic perceptions that have been well fed to each other in their educational systems about one another.
    The fact is that one thing is being denied from one side or the other is people to people contact. Because when people to people contact starts, these perceptions and biases start to fade out. Many people can confirm this who have worked together in the Middle east, US and Europe. They have worked in good harmony, and honestly take care to avoid conflicting statements on religion/politics to avoid unnecessary un ease among the colleagues. The politicians fear that if people to people contact start, how can they sell their wares and get into the corridors of power if people start seeing through their ideologies and practices.