Ranking Every Chargeable Projectile in Smash
Вставка
- Опубліковано 10 вер 2024
- Super Smash Bros. Ultimate is a game full of iconic video game moves, and you know what a lot of those are? Projectiles. Out of those, chargeable projectiles are often among the best, which should make today's tier list interesting!
______________________________________________
Main channel: / mockrocktv
Twitter: / mrmockrock
Patreon: / mockrock
Twitch: / mockrocktwitch
Business email: MockRock@inf1uence.com
Teespring: teespring.com/stores/mockrock
______________________________________________
TimeBolt: I used TimeBolt on this video to massively increase the speed of editing, it's a program that essentially creates your jump cuts for you. I consider it to be one of the best things I've ever bought and highly recommend it for tons of applications on UA-cam, so I asked the team to join their affiliate program. Use my affiliate link and coupon code to support the channel AND get a discount on some fantastic software, it's a true win-win!
Affiliate link: mockrock--time...
Coupon code: MOCKROCK
______________________________________________
Music used:
"MockRock Is Here (Relaxed)" - MockRock
"MockRock is Here" - MockRock
"Menu Theme" - Metroid Prime Hunters OST
"Realm Overworld" - The Legend of Zelda: Spirit Tracks OST
"Lost In Thoughts All Alone" - Super Smash Bros. Ultimate OST (original version from Fire Emblem: Fates OST)
"Gusty Garden Galaxy" - Super Mario Galaxy OST
"Moon River (Instrumental)" - Bayonetta 2 OST
"Splattack!" - Super Smash Bros. Ultimate OST (original version from Splatoon OST)
All original music, as well as its stems, are available for download to patrons, UA-cam members, and Twitch subscribers
______________________________________________
Thanks for watching!
#SuperSmashBros #Nintendo #SmashUltimate
Thanks for watching everyone! A projectile tier list has been heavily requested and I figured something more specific like this might be interesting, what did you think? There are a couple moves I'm seeing pop up in the comments a lot, mostly the ones I expected, so here's some more detail on them:
*-Mii Gunner's Stealth Burst:* This move should have been included, I made a mistake. I loosened the criteria after initially compiling the list, which added Zelda's Din's Fire, and Stealth Burst should have been added at the same time. I'd place Stealth Burst in B tier, on most characters' kits it'd probably be in C tier because of the lag but Mii Gunner has so many persistent walling tools to help set it up.
*-Sephiroth's Flare:* I've seen a lot of applications for that move listed, most of which I agree with (these videos can't cover every use case of every move). However, a lot of them are very specific, and also directly competing with something else in Sephiroth's kit. One thing I do while researching these videos is comb through a lot of high level tournament footage, and in those situations (which this list is based on), Sephiroth's [Mega/Giga]Flare is rarely chosen, and when it is, it rarely connects. In offstage situations, you usually see the better Sephiroth players opt either to go out for an edgeguard, or try and 2-frame with down smash or down air. At the ledge? Ftilt, Shadow Flare, and uair get far more use.
The less familiar I am with a move (which isn't actually the case here, but hear me out), the more footage I tend to watch ahead of time, which admittedly has flaws itself that I alluded to in the video. To take an example, WaDi is one of the best ROB players in the world and famously puts very little time into practicing the character's advanced tech, his fundamentals are just that good. Which means that if tournament footage of WaDi was my main source of information, I'd likely think of the character very differently. I compensate for this by watching a variety of players, but it's never going to be perfect. Regardless, in the case of Sephiroth, his better players generally seem to have come to the same consensus that other moves are more useful in more situations. This matches how I feel about the move. This is probably my most contentious placement based on the comments, which I expected, especially because of how much more effective it tends to be in mid level and casual settings, but no regrets with the F tier.
*-Zelda's Phantom:* I've had a few people bring up Phantom displacement (an advanced technique that shifts the Phantom in front of Zelda), which I opted not to cover. The first reason is similar to Sephiroth, I rarely actually see it used, and also comes with the same caveats about relying on tournament footage of the handful of strong Zelda players. The second reason is that I still don't think that's enough to push it into the same tier as moves like Charge Shot or Needles.
*-Hero's Lightning Spells:* As several comments have pointed out, these _technically_ aren't projectiles, they can't be reflected, for example. I understand this, but still think they absolutely belong on the list, they clearly work like projectiles and the fact that they're not coded that way is an unintuitive quirk of the game. Joker's Gun, for example, has the same property, and I'd also include him on any other relevant projectile tier list, although I'll probably attach a disclaimer about it from now on.
*-Ike's Eruption:* To be clear, Ike's Eruption is NOT a projectile, but you could argue that if Hero's lightning spells belong on here, Ike does too. Unlike those moves, however, Eruption's additional flares are irrelevant essentially 100% of the time in competitive play.
*-Bowser Jr.'s Cannonball:* So, I actually originally did the same thing for this move as I did for Diddy Kong, I went back and said "I changed my mind, this move is too good for F tier, I'll move it up." Then I went to find a good clip of Cannonball that supported my point...and literally couldn't, no matter how long I looked. So I changed my mind on changing my mind and deleted that segment. Some other use cases the comments have brought up, like firing it high so that it drops down much later, don't move the needle in my opinion.
*-Corrin's Dragon Fang Shot:* Part of the reason the kill confirm doesn't see much play is likely because it works best when the forward air is done approaching, at risky spacing. The better Corrin players (and swordfighter players in general) tend to prioritize spacing quite heavily. That's something I didn't mention in the video and probably should have. It also ties it to a melee move in a video full of projectiles.
If there are any other tier lists that you'd like to see on the channel, let me know!
-Main channel: ua-cam.com/users/mockrocktv
-Twitter: twitter.com/MrMockRock
-Twitch: www.twitch.tv/mockrocktwitch
-Patreon: www.patreon.com/mockrock
-Teespring: teespring.com/stores/mockrock
-TimeBolt affiliate link (excellent software I use to speed up editing on my videos, use code "MOCKROCK" for a discount): mockrock--timebolt.thrivecart.com/order-page/
What about an armour move tier list, I think that would be interesting
Burst option tier list
Hmm maybe like a comeback mechanic tier list? For example:
Go meter, Arsene, Aura, Clouds limit, one winged angel, etc
How about a bomb tier list I'd like to see your opinions on characters bombs/explosions moves as they use them for either just damage or more importantly (to me) the setplay potential
forgot Ike neutral B
Something I'd love to see is ranking all suicide kills. Wolf down throw/side b, incineroar down throw/up b, ganoncide, bowsercide, kirbycide, mii Brawler has like 3 etc. I think it would be fun to see
Edit: Seeing a lot of people saying they are all the same or similar. Some of them take multiple moves, some don't. Some require specific percentages, some don't. Some kill you first, some don't. Some kill you even if the opponent lives, some let you live if the move doesn't work. Some need difficult spacing or DI, some don't. Some can be mashed out of, others can't. Some don't work on all characters, some do. Some require your opponent to go to ledge or be offstage, some don't. There is plenty of difference imo.
This could be a fun one! I think the title would probably be more like "self destruct moves" haha, but I've added it to my idea doc that a lot of videos get pulled from at some point, thanks for the suggestion!
And let's not forget the iconic Kamikaze
chromikaze & wariocide
I would love this! :D
Cloudicide (:
Mii Gunner's charge shot honestly has some great synergy with their kit, depending on what moveset you have. Unlike the samus version which is a combo starter, Gunners is more conventional being a combo ender with things like Flame Pillar for combos or missles to set up pressure from far away.
The best part is both versions of missile combos into charge blast
Mii Gunner really is just a better Samus huh…
Pro tip: Charge Shot kills if you charge it all the way. I understand the utility in uncharged shots but it seems like people forget it can fully charge. You can get people to choke with just the fear of it alone, my friend.
@@peterduprey7286 no she is not lmao. Mii gunner is a lot worse than Samus.
@@CLSharpman5000 You can but near full charge kills almost just as well as full charge while still granting you the utility (movement option, combo and mixup tool) of uncharged CS. The almost-universal projectile shield damage nerf and BEEEEG endlag of full charge are why you don't see it being used very much.
Robin's thunder is like half the reason why I play him. Each projectile is so unique and situational that you feel like a genius when you get that combo, snipe, or kill off them.
Yep! Same here!
Also forgot to mention how Thoron beats out every other projectile (I think? Or just about) on top of being the big dumb lazer thar can kill. It's really pivotal in winning projectile wars.
@@neog8029 the problem is that robins speed is his greatest enemy. Also the loss of checkmate. Thoron is godly when it comes to beating out moves, but for the total cost, and time spent charging, the value is nowhere near what you can get for an arcthunder. Though arcthunder was nerfed even more than thoron from 4 to ultimate.
All that said, Robin is still incredibly fun to use, and has replaced both marth and pikachu as my main since his release.
@@vla1ne All true points, I suppose. I'm still cursing whoever decided Robin should have the second slowest run speed behind Ganondorf and even Jigglypuff. At least he has...average air speed.
I know I'm not utilizing Arcthunder as well as I should. I need to learn to capitalize on conditioning with it more since I think that's where Arcthunder excels.
Robin is by far the most fun Fire Emblo to me as well. The mixed zoning/swordie playstyle with a big emphasis on ledge and shield pressure just clicked so well for me.
@@neog8029 same. I had to learn to stop aiming for full charge and using basic thunder more often. Robins tools are all for different situations, and even while they still need buffs imo, I can't help but love using robin.
That "laugh into straightfaced F Tier" true combo on Failnaught was gold 😂😂
"Failnaught? More like Failalot!"
While I see your point about bjr's cannon, one thing that you didn't mention was that after a while the ball will just fall down with a hitbox still activated. Many bjr players use it for ledge guarding when spaced well and can snipe recoveries with alot of knockback
adding to this you can cancel its endlag by grabbing ledge which opens up a lot for edgeguarding
Also it fuckin rocks don’t forget that
True to both of these
@@chriiis7002 Do not forget that it has a landing hitbox, which means the cannonball can hit a shield twice. If the move is charged up for even half a second, and if both hits connect on the shield, it’s an instant shieldbreak
@@Scarfy_0S didnt mockcrock mention it though
I know this really isn’t part if the criteria, but I want it to be known that Kirby gets a fairly quick, sorely needed OoS kill confirm from center stage with Link’s arrow at 100% (jump -> arrow throw -> Fair 1 -> FSmash/USmash; reverse arrow throw is even faster) Granted, Link probably shouldn’t be getting close to your shield, but if he gets even somewhat close it works.
Actually, your own take on Kirby’s Smash copy abilities would be pretty interesting to see.
I've covered this in a video before, actually! A Kirby hat tier list is one I've gotten a bunch of suggestions for, I'm a little hesitant just because that's one a lot of people have already made in the past but I'm honestly not sure how much I should care about that, it may happen at some point.
@@MockRockTalk to be fair I haven't seen anyone really as technical and painstaking in their analysis on stuff like this as you. I'd personally be down to see a copy ability tier list from you.
Also I dont mean to be that guy but are you still going to be doing the signature move tier list videos? I do very much enjoy those.
Kirby with strong projectiles is honestly high tier; potentially top with certain projectiles.
@@vick7868 The last video on my main channel starts with a channel update/future plans segment, check that out to see what the future of MockRock looks like.
@@MockRockTalk I think a tier lost of Kirby’s Copy Abilities would be fun!
I kind of want a Spike tier list but maybe split into multiple parts since there’s a lot of them
Little Macs is EASILY S TIER! BEST SPIKE EVER LOL
Rosalina mains rise!!! Let's show mockrock that her spike is the best in the game
I second this Idea
Nah pyra’s is probably the most broken spike. Huge hitbox, goes through the stage, and kills early. Even the sour spot kills.
@@kohjoh4745 Rosalina mains sit down! Before I knock Luma off the stage
Mii gunners charge shot can also 2-frame some characters
thats just stupid
And hits more than half the cast while they're holding the ledge
Also mewtwo’s
and (specifically) dark samus
I’d bump up sephiroth’s neutral B because when he gets a shield break (so easy to do) he has the ability to literally kill at 3 %. (Well spaced N-B into F-smash (or F-tilt) and it’s even better and can kill from anywhere when he has wing.
This is trolling?
i agree it can zero to death so it should be at least one space better than f. no other charge shots kill on a shield break.
By your logic, Warlock Punch, Falcon Punch and Skewer are all good moves, right ? Since if you get a Shield Break you can either kill at 0% or does 60% damage with them.
Unless a character can break shield with a move with less than 6-frame start up (in which case I don't think the move that kill is the problem), breaking shield at the highest level of competitive play is never consistent. You also have to factor in perfect shielding (a.k.a. parrying). A move that is almost only used to punish Shield Break is thus never consistent, no matter how punishing it can be
@@hoanganphanle To be fair, for sephiroth specifically, shield breaks arent uncommon if you arent specifically avoiding it, as often sephiroth will use side b, then when they shield, they combine the might of the side B projectiles plus down smash into a shield break
I’d put it atleast in B tier. F tier is an awful ranking for it
I find sephiroth’s neutral B to be a great tool at keeping opponents at a distance and conditions opponents to jump, which you can read
^ yeah, it definitely has its uses, especially at ledge.
you shouldn't really ever edge attack against seph period, jumping would just get you hit by gigaflare/megaflare, roll and normal get up from ledge can just get you hit by fair/ftilt/fsmash/upb (maybe even side b)
as a tool at the ledge it can be extremely good
the main thing is that ftilt and dtilt can two-frame and one wing sephiroth can probably just go offstage instead and do something like fair/dair, or stick to the side and do smth after that
at a minimum I'd say it's C and yeah flare's bad lmao
After a shield break you can do gigaflare and f-smash that I'm pretty sure kills every character in the game.
@@paulikanervo1556 factoring in a Shield Break doesn't make a move good. By that logic should Warlock Punch be considered a good move ? I don't think so. If you're relying on your opponent getting the Shield broken, that's not what I would call a consistent move, which is one of the main criteria to judge whether a move is good or not
I didn't mean that the gigaflare would brake the shield, but that sephiroth would first brake the shield (with down-smash and shadow flares maybe) and when the enemy is fainted, then you could use gigaflare f-smash. Neutral-b used as a shield brake does not really work if you tought that was what I meant.
@@paulikanervo1556 still by that logic warlock punch becomes the best move in the game lmao
As a Byleth main, Failnaught neutral b is great in its uncharged form
You can turn it around up to two times, and if you know your timing you can hit the opponent with it while offstage so you send them away to be able to recover after
Also idk why but i often just randomly shoot a predictable arrow and they just stand there and get hit. I dont know why it happens so often but i land the arrows more often than i should
Yeah failnaught is pretty great if you can read your opponent
And most importantly, you can cancel it anytime and condition the opponent with it, something that he doesn't mention at all and that is used by even Mk Leo because the arrow is still menacing
@@krenw970 Same goes with any other strong move tho like warlock punch and gigaflare
Yeah. I play Byleth on occasion and I can confirm this is true.
As a Corrin main, his/her Neutral B is actually really good for those types of mix-ups as well. It can't be canceled, but it has multiple levels of charging which differentiates the speed, power, and stun effect duration. I totally trick people with this. Sometimes they think I'm doing a weak shot, so they spot dodge, but then they get hit by a bigger ball of energy and then chomped. I also use it to break my fall for a bit, inch down, then bite (this works at times, too). I *also* use the fully-charged projectile to stun someone long enough to run up to them and hit them with tipper Side B attack that will definitely K.O. at the right percents and areas.
@@onlookerofthings6029 but i say the speed and range of failnaught is what sets it apart and above both of those
I think you're underselling Sephiroth neutral b a bit. It's pretty good at baiting out reactions and pressuring recoveries. Do nothing and they eat a Mega Flare. If they go high and you can cancel it and go for fair or uair. Go low and potentially get spiked. I find the threat of the move is stronger than the move itself (same for Byleth). Plus Mega Flare travels super fast, covers a good amount of ground and kills. That said, looking at the rest of the list I agree it is outclassed by most other projectiles and probably doesn't deserve anything higher than C tier.
Relying on opponent to be bad is less effective then using your actually good options.
@@9forMortalMenTo be fair, relying on your opponent to mess up is like… 90% of zoning, tho. You dictate the pace of the match, you punish when they mess up.
@@FedoraKirb this is true, but zoning is also about setting up checkmate situations, where your opponent has too few options to deal with what you are doing. Your other tools as sephiroth can be used as the checkmate more regularly than flare.
I would put Byleth’s a little up cause it’s an excellent conditioning tool. It does amazing shield damage (which Byleth can take advantage of), travels very fast and it kills.
Heavy disagree with PK Freeze. With it being nearly lagless you can practically remain in neutral while pressing advantage/keeping you opponent in disadvantage
It's angle is unforgiving and if landed can essentially Combo into itself and iirc you CAN'T mash out of this freeze keeping the timing strict
Agreed! It’s a great tool when used in the right hands and you can really catch people’s habits with it too. The best part really is the lack of endlag and how that can be used to mixup your edge-guarding and and the way forces people to respect it in certain situations. Maybe i’m biased, but probably put it in high B tier honestly.
It can also kill crazy low given the right placement!
you can also stall offstage by spamming it, but the main reason its better than pk flash is because it forces the opponent to burn resources to avoid it which sets up for the rest of Lucas's edgeguarding tools
When you hit it it also feels like the opponent can't act out of gettign released immediately, most of the time placing a well timed fire just when they break free will hit and kill them if the freeze wasn't enough already. Also the fact that you can damage the opponent while frozen is pretty good.
Not a move that defines the character or anythign but when you fidn a use it can be really good, definetely better than Ness' neutral b
I just think putting it in the same tier as PK Flash is crazy lol
I was kinda thinking about a tier list with all the grabbable items. (The ones that come from characters, for example Diddy's Banana, Mega Man's Saw.) Another amazing video from Mockrock!
This one's already in my idea document, don't expect it for awhile since I don't want to put 2 projectile lists right beside each other but I'd be surprised if this doesn't get made at some point.
I already know what would be in s tier
@@MockRockTalk 1. Thanks a bunch for replying, you’re really an inspiration to me, and 2. Will it include some obscure stuff like King K Rool’s crown?
@@phobixthething5692 Appreciate it! I haven't actually sat down and planned the video out, but I'd imagine that the crown would be included, yeah
@@MockRockTalk Alright, best of luck to you!
i disagree with byleth, it’s a great conditioning move because you HAVE to respect it, either by shield or jumping or parrying if you’re good. you can catch people off guard while edge guarding and get an early kill, and it does high damage despite the slow start up
MkLeo will use it for tech chasing sometimes, and every once in a while he'll snipe with it as an edgeguard. I don't think that elevates it from D-tier. "respecting it by shielding or jumping or parrying" is a non-issue at top-level, and really you could say that about nearly every projectile.
You could make the same argument to Warlock Punch: conditioning your opponent to either jump out of its range or shield it. And I don't think I have to elaborate on why Warlock Punch is one of the worst move
You only have to respect it when it's out though, because it's slow enough that players can either react to the start up at far distances or interrupt it at close distances. Whereas better moves require the opponent to respect the move even when its not being used, either because the startup is too fast to react to or because the reward for hitting the move is that high. Neither pf which applies to Failnaught
@@hoanganphanle i mean yeah but warlock and failnaught are in no way similar
That's exactly what i tried to explain about the blue flare from seph, the conditioning aspect.
I dont think he really understands it as a dark pit main himself cuz of the down b is reliable but he can stil be grabbed
I would argue that the Flares should be in C tier, since it’s a decent shield break punish, and Sephiroth can easily break shields.
they kill very low AND SEPHIROTHS MO IS BREAK SHIELD
Yeah thanks to it, he can literally kill you at 0 from a shield break.
and mega flare kills at 100 lmao
Tbf Ganon’s Warlock Punch can ALSO kill at around 0 from a shield break. I wouldn’t say Sephiroth’s Mega Flare is that useful otherwise, but I can respect it.
@@RedWhaley14 bro cmon it 2 frames and is a good mix up between gigaflare
YOU ARE JUST DEAD WRONG ABOUT GIGAFLARE: that move is so intimidating because it’s cancelable and the blue flare is fast. It’s not really that you’re gonna hit the opponent with it but more so for conditioning jumping, reflecting and shielding which seph can punish and if he manages to break your shield(even if you’re bowser) you’re just dead, so it’s at least A-tier
Gigaflare also instabreaks shield if in winged mode as well, aside from covering a lot of options if spaced well, and kills at early percents as well.
Megaflare can force an airdodge offstage, which can let you not worry about that during ledge guards, and can also cover some recoveries if spaced well.
Flare is just kind of there, you can throw it out occasionally to bait or get some damage, or cancel it into a jump if you read a jump
Well, conditioning is good but it's something you can do with a lot of projectile and a lot of it comes from matchup inexperience. I can see it being B tier max but it's certainly not an a tier, considering how good chargeable are in general. And as he said, none of these moves are bad, but you need to rank them. The move that I think is not F tier is dragonfangshot, it is surprisingly great at catching jumps, especially in advantage state, is really versatile and overall more comparable to paralizer.
You cant cancel it ones its gone into gigaflare tho. Also, conditioning can be dine with most projectiles on the list
It's not really that fast is an understatement.
2 whole seconds for ledge trap that's less rewarding than most of Sepy's edge gaurding.
@@artimist0315 yeah thats what i was gonna say B tier solely for Blue Flare/Mega Flare alone because of the conditioning; it's actually a unilateral neutral tool that dictates the pace of the match against characters with no absorber or reflector. Even then, if you time it where the explosion will be right in front of their face, it cant be absorbed or reflected they will eat the explosion and the blast has a huge radius still
The way I use Jr projectile is as a sky drop attack. I launch it in the sky, go low below ledge and while my opponent tries to guard ledge, I'll fake an attack so they put their shield up and cannon ball hits shield, then the ground doing even more shield damage. Their shield pretty much pops. Never advise to use this move grounded. It's a projectile you always wanna use in the air.
I think Corrin’s Dragon Fang Shot deserves a bit more of a nod as a juggling tool weirdly enough. Given that Corrin has some of the best juggling in the game, air dodge punishes are very common for Corrin players, and dragon fang shot actually kills people for air dodging. Cosmos has even used the move for that in the past
LET'S FUCKING GOOOO 27:12
BEST OF EVERY MOVE POST DLC VERSION
CAN'T WAIT
Lucas' PK Freeze will travel below ledge which can catch a lot of people off gaurd. And its low end lag means that air dodging too close to Lucas results in a punish.
Ridley getting hit while charging is actually useful, when that happens it cancels all knockback meaning you can get hit by warlock punch at a high percent and still live, you can almost always avoid it but in a edguarding scenario you can just not get edguarded also if your shield is low and your set up so you can’t go anywhere having that option is useful.
But it also has huge lag and the explosion does no damage, so the enemy always has time for a big followup even if they weren't ready for it. I tried to make it work, but getting weak spotted is rarely actually advantageous even if it seems like it in theory.
It saved me against dedede hammer once that was cool and funny.
Hey! Zelda player here, albeit amateur. I think A tier is fair for Phantom, but I do want to point out one small way in which a lot of people severely underrate it - as a _defensive_ option. Yes, it throws out massive hitboxes and controls a lot of stage space. However, where I personally get more use out of it than anything is simply body-blocking opponents. The body of the Phantom itself is a semi-solid wall while charging, as well as between its hitboxes ending and it disappearing; it can be rolled through, but not walked or dashed through, in a similar way to the Pits' down-B. With careful play and some well-timed B-reverses, it can create an immense amount of openings not just by threatening with its hitboxes, but also by unexpectedly restricting enemy movement and "pinning" them in place when they expected to approach.
Yes yes yes! It saved me from dying by taking so many attacks that would've otherwise hit me. I totally agree with this
It’d be interesting to see a ranking of movement based specials (mainly side-bs like Wario, Villager, Ike, etc.)
I think you have to immediately remove up bs out of the equation for this one, and even then, the line get pretty blurry for this category. Does Incineroar's Alolan Whip count for example? It's a movement option, sure, but I hardly see it used for that purpose.
@@king_alloy it’s mostly a Ko and recovery tool, as a movement option, on stage, it’s pretty laggy
YeH of course alolan whip counts it’s an intergral part of his recovery
Quick draw sucks because it makes you helpless, doesn't kill, and is slow to charge while being completely linear and predictable.
@@KaitouKaiju wait, what move is that ?
You're probably gonna get tired of hearing this really soon but neither Zap, Zapple, OR Kazap are projectiles.
Well, Kazap *does* summon a lightning technically
But yea I wouldn't have included them here
_Technically_ that's correct, I know that, but I attribute that more to the game being weird, they still clearly feel like projectiles and fit the spirit of the list. I'd include Joker's Gun in a broader projectile list as well, for example.
@@MockRockTalk Wouldn't Eruption count then, too? The fully charged one fires a pretty sizeable blaze, and all charges have an upward blast that's somewhat disjointed.
If I had a nickel every time I got hit by Young LInk Fire Arrows, I'd be Scrouge McDuck
Another thing to add about aura sphere is that it’s super good at ledge trapping since you can use the charge to cover an option and the projectile hits under the ledge if you’re over like 70%. This also means it 2 frames so you get some pretty early kills that way.
Pop gun cancelling is so insanely good and imo puts it near A tier. Also ledge trapping with it is amazing as it forces an option off ledge and can combo into fair/bair for a kill
Completely forgot about mega flare 😅 that’s the one that gets the most use for sephi, mega alone should have put it in B tier
I didn't forget? I talked about the middle charge in terms of a 2 frame option.
@@MockRockTalk that’s when you were talking about Giga flare, the only things you talked about was Flare and Giga flare.
Edit: And if you did, you glossed over it so fast I might have confused it for Giga flare talk but even then, mega as so much more use then the other two glossing over it so quickly made it seem like it’s never us
Edit 2: I mentioned the 2 framed but realized I was talking about flare so I just deleted it
Gigaflare + variants do have some good utility, the fully charged one basically turns into an insta kill at ledge and the mid charge is actually really strong so it can catch people offstage and ledge getup options
I think the mid charge is by far the most useful version and he totally glossed over it.
I definitely think that giga flare should be C tier because it could be used to punish a shield break and will kill at zero if you use f smash at the same time and when sephiroth is in one-wing, it is pretty easy to get shield breaks.
I'd like to see a Spike tier list
As a sephiroth main, i would personally bump up neutral-b to c. In my experience i've gotten a lot of use for its second version, and the killpower of its third version makes up for its high risk, and is much more useful in a casual enviroment. Just my thoughts.
I would personally agree with this, as a Kirby that loves to eat Sephiroth for this move. The 2nd charge seems weirdly spammable. And even just the threat of how powerful the move is, the fact that you can cancel it at any time makes it great for conditioning your opponent.
Agreed. I'd also bump up Corrin's Neutral B because it has multiple levels of charging, which differentiates the projectile's speed and power. This allows for a ton of set-ups and mix-ups. It can even stall Corrin in the air a bit, before inching downwards into the bite (so you could float over someone's attack then hit them back). The fully-charged projectile can stun someone long enough for a side B pin or sweet-spot hit in certain situations. It has quite a lot of uses for a slow-starting projectile.
Honestly Robin's Thunder charges rarely matter that much in my experience. It does sometimes suck but because it charges into different moves with different uses Thunder is usually a move you plan to use rather than a move you'd miss out on if you were out of charges with the possible exception of no charge Thunder which you can usually play around not having for a few seconds until you have it back. The only other move I care less about running out of is Nosferatu but that move's so situational I often forget I even have it.
Same. Nosferatu is just free discards, but Thunder isn't something that matters too much when it's gone, it only matters when it's there. Also, the discards from Thunder can be nice.
I would love if you rated all tether grabs in the game. They're especially interesting due to the differing aerial uses for them all being fairly unique.
PK Freeze is A tier. It is used in neutral as an anti air that if that air dodge through you get a free hit. It helps you mix up your recoveries a lot. It is highly mobile so it can catch aerial spammers and when you send lucas in the same direction in the air with the freeze it can be used to cover yourself. Way better than the sample size of pro players would suggest.
splat bomb is easily a tier for me, the way you can completely invalidate some recoveries and force ledge situations and ledge traps make it a top 3 inkling move for sure
Inkling without N-air U-air B-air would be kind of wack. 0_0
@@ivrydice0954 fair enough, top 5 then
I think if you consider that you can perform a Displaced Phantom Slash with Zelda, then the move should be S tier. Because if you do a retreating displaced Phantom, you can charge Phantom while avoiding a good amount of projectiles because Knight protects you. If you do it forwards, you can be perfectly setup for ledge traps, or you can go off stage and leave phantom on the edge to ledge guard covering off stage space. It has counterplay for sure, but because you can mixup timings which make a big difference, move around with Knight fully charged etc. I'd say it's S tier. Certainly I think it's better than the rest of A tier at the least.
I wasn't totally sure how to handle the Phantom tech, this is an issue that comes up sometimes with more advanced techniques for characters I don't play myself. Generally in these cases, I watch a bunch of tournament sets of the character being used, and for Zelda, I honestly rarely actually saw displaced Phantom. Admittedly, this runs into the same issue I talked about in the video, the sample size for a lot of characters isn't that big and the best players of their character aren't necessarily the most knowledgeable about their tech. That said, if I'm struggling to find good examples of a technique, compared to Charge Shot go boom, I find it hard to place them right next to each other.
I agree with you NoNameNate. As a Zelda main this tech makes an already stupid move even more stupid.
@@MockRockTalk That's true, I rarely run into other Zelda mains who can use displaced Phantom, and I am disappointed that Ven, the best Zelda, doesn't use the tech. That's all to say that I do understand your reasoning, it is hard to argue with Charge Shot go brrrr😂
I would put it in its own special tier between A and S, A+ tier
I think even the ledge trapping function is good enough for S tier! Zelda can cover every option with it. You can even 2 frame with it. Or two frame with d tilt which will connect with phantom. Plus you have the different charges which all have different uses. The earlier ones can set up a tech, the over head slash covers people jumping in. It can be used to break shield. It combos. It can be used when returning to stage to cover yourself. It can be used in edge guarding. It can protect against moves. It has a wind box which can move players into a charged up smash or cheese recoveries if they go above the ledge. It can be displaced forward or backward. You can charge it whilst falling through a platform so it forms on the platform. It gives Zelda stage control. If forces limited options for the player. And it’s intimidating to play against.
In terms of dins fire, it’s niche for sure. Should only be used when you’re off stage or your opponent is off stage. Off stage it’ll protect you from players setting up ledgetraps which is essential for Zelda since she struggles getting off the ledge. As an edguarding tool it forces air dodge or jump. Air dodge is worse if you’re high because then you’re left open. Zelda charges a phantom and that’s it for you. But if that jump is read you would die insanely early. 50%. If you’re recovering low and you can edguard and you take the hit you’ll probably die. Would bumb up to B tier
i personally think toon links arrow is a tier. super slow travel time with really good endlag means it covers a lot of space for toon link while being hard to punish in neutral. combined with his insane bombs and good boomerangs its really good
Would be really fun to see a big moves tier list
I understand your reasoning for Bowser Jr's Cannon but, in my experience, it's a really powerful tool when used in combination with his Mecha Koopa. You can use it to set traps and limit your opponents space to work with so you can more easily predict their movements.
Although, it should be said that my experience is very casual. While me and my friends are pretty good I wouldn't say we are anywhere near as good as any of the pros. I'm sure it's a very different case for them.
I wish corrin could charge the paralyzing ball part of the move, with the drawback being you still have to bite after you fire it.
Din’s fire is fantastic for edgeguarding, forces airdodge and very little endlag which she can really capitalize on. I’d definitely put it above peanut pop gun at the very least.
he definitely underrated it, super safe edgeguarding tool i've snagged tons of kills with
displaced phantom and RAR displaced phantom covers for the majority of Zelda's mobility issues when it comes to using phantom. she can move behind it to protect herself from most projectiles and make her even harder to approach while charging phantom, and Zelda can also move away from a charging phantom to chase someone after launching them while still setting up a devastating punish with huge coverage.
I think Sephiroth's neutral B is severely undervalued. mid-charge is great if you're trying to get back on stage (forces the opponent to work around it), and full charge forces the opponent to fall into another trap. even if you time it perfectly, Sephiroth can react to the option you choose and punish you for that anyways.
Also cancelling the full charge and then hitting the opponent with another move is a great conditioning tool
Flare's underrated. Didn't even mention it allows Sephiroth a free 0-death. Gigaflare kills Pichu at ledge with optimal DI with no follow-up.
Great conditioning tool, reversing momentum, etc. A situational move that gets you a free kill once every few high level games can still be a good move and this one isn't even that situational.
Played a tournament vs my brothers, a friend came to play as well and we were seeded against each other. He ragequit because of that move alone. (Though this is low level play.) :p
I'd put Lucas's PK freeze into high B tier or low A tier.
It's one of the safest projectiles on a shield (-15 if uncharged to -5 at full charge) that locks a character into an animation. It is just nuts on shield or hit. & most characters can't even punish a partially charged pk freeze on shield 3 character lengths away from Lucas. It actually lingers (4 frames from 1) & enables combos from 0-30 with normals or leads into more pk freeze chains or DJ pk fires for nasty offstage sniping gimps (it even has 23 frames of endlag after the hitbox is over & it takes 5 frames from the startup to detonate, making parrying it nigh impossible because of the massive delay mixups). Lucas being hit on the frame you release the special button does NOT stop freeze from detonating either.
It bypasses the annoying attack/defensive option landing strategies that most of the cast opts to do & makes them forfeit stage control or risk potentially getting gimped afterward. It's transcendent, meaning only full body intangibility, invincibility, or reflector hitboxes can actually avoid it safely, especially if one is cornered, has limited landing mixups, is slow in the air, or has meh landing options.
the endlag on it is so low that lucas can actually use it to bait predictable landing options or force normal getups on ledge as well if he has the time to set it up. It forces many characters to heavily alter their recovery trajectories or flat-out die.
It's a good chargeable projectile, because once it's out during Lucas's advantage with snatching landings or general corner pressure, it can command lots of respect & cheese while being very risky to punish.
Failnaut is so fast when you take in to account it’s kill power that it deserves minimum B tier, sephiroth’s neutral B is a zero to death shield break punish with forward smash. They both are better than or as good as diddy gun.
The useful thing about Ridley's Boss hurtbox on his breath attack is that cancels all knockback, regardless of Ridley's damage percentage, which can make it a situational survival option, it's not ADVISED cause of the heavy lag you'll have after but it COULD just save you
You cannot say that links arrow is b teir and flare is f teir. The arrow is basi ally useless in comparison to boomerang and bomb. Flare is used more often by sephiroths than arrow is for link. It's also used as a pressure tool to approach with because of how slow the base charge is. Also even if you can time a getup, sephiroth can wait for your getup with f tilt or grab.
In regards to Luma shot, looking at how it gets used when we only look at the projectile aspects, a Kirby with Luma Shot can be an absolute nightmare due to the lack of a hurtbox to stop it, meaning it basically beats anything that normally could stop a fully charged projectile, and sometimes even reflectors fail to actually reflect it far enough because of that tight distance control.
If we look at it in the context of Rosalina herself having it, it's mostly used in advantage like the non-projectile non-stoage charging moves; a glorified mid air smash attack. And if we look at it in neutral, it can be used decently as a mixup to setup desyncs or grab confirms on foes who shield it - the odd case where your opponent shielding the move could easily be more beneficial than them getting hit
You may also want to consider the neutral B when luma is gone (often called "wand wave") in that case, it's even more apples to oranges, but it does mean you now have access to a free B reverse button, and a spammable windbox that can be used against certain recoveries to almost guarentee the foes' demise.
All in all, A tier does seem about right
With the game's infamous online, I would suggest making a Wi-Fi tier list, like moves that get the most out of online lag (zoners in particular are infamous online for that reason). You did briefly touch upon that aspect in some videos, but with how the world has been throughout most of Ultimate's life, I feel like it deserves a list of its own.
Something that I think should move Corrin's dragon shot up a tier or two is 1. The stun scales with the percentage and 2. Because of that you can get a really easy tipper pin confirm if you know how to space it and at higher percents (around %100-110) you can even get it if the dragon shot hits from across the stage. Granted it is somewhat difficult to learn the spacing but once you do you have a somewhat easy kill option if your opponent likes jumping which in ultimate is very common.
popgun is also really good for it's tech usage
I feel like MR is almost… over qualified to talk about smash. He’s so articulate and detail oriented
Not really, im 7 minutes in and he’s made some pretty shit opinions. Sephiroths grapes are not S tier, and pop gun is definitely not b tier. Literally anything out prioritizes the peanuts, it has a really niche use that isn’t even that great. Like, he showed it being used against luigi and that honestly seems like one of the few characters that actually might have some small issues with the peanuts. The best thing about pop gun is cancelling it and he didn’t even mention that. It’s also not very difficult to avoid Sephiroths grapes. The annoying part is that you have to shield or retreat to ledge, but it isn’t that bad. If you just knock Sephiroth away, or just run, then it isn’t a big issue. Just don’t be an idiot and get caught lacking by the downsmash. No idea how could put grapes and charge shot in the same tier
@@carldalord Having even one shadow flare on you means you're getting interrupted in 5 seconds. Sure you didn't get hit, but you had to take some shield damage or retreat or stop your combo or whatever which breaks your momentum and gives Sephiroth time to breathe. Landing a shadow flare basically guarantees a second free attack for your opponent to deal with.
@@carldalord you can disagree with the content, but you can't deny the man really puts some thoughts into it and argument for his point relatively on the fly. Mad props for that.
@@nocturn333 I can’t remember a time where his grapes messing up my combos was a big issue. Also it’s really easy to avoid it. You don’t see good Sephiroths using his grapes a lot. Sephiroths grapes just shouldn’t be used most of the time. Terribly small hitbox too
@@ark8021he’s making really basic summaries of these moves tbh. Literally anyone can do this if they’ve played smash for a few hundred hours
Surely Sephiroth's Flare deserves some extra credit for allowing him some ridiculous early kills off of shield breaks, by itself or paired with Fsmash, as a character who can get shield breaks with relative frequency? Like, while that aspect wouldn't save the likes of Warlock Punch from being labeled an F tier move, Flare itself starts with a good deal more usefulness, as a projectile that can be canceled for mindgames and conditioning, and then has the ludicrous kills on top of that. Having that move is arguably a large part of why his shield damage is so threatening, as his Fsmash alone wouldn't get him kills as early or as reliably when platforms are involved.
Pacman's bonus fruit is the reason why I decided to main the character back in Smash 4. It's nice seeing it get an S tier here
Before watching the video: zelda's down b has to be S tier. It is good for neutral, edgegarding, reverse edgegarding, it has much different properties based on how much of a charge it has with the 2nd highest covering so much vertical space and the highest charge covering almost all ledge options. There's a delay after the charge that can let zelda get tons of combos, or you can mix it up with no delay, it does a ton a shield damage and down b + fair can break shields super easily. It kills well, it tanks hits for Zelda, it is easily the best move in her kit
I had a weird idea for a new tier list
What about ranking every single “gimmick” in Smash? So, for example, Kirby’s inhale, Steve’s crafting, etc
Obviously the criteria for what counts as a gimmick would be tricky to nail down though…
Something you forgot to mention with Gunner, is that it’s really easy to start Gundashing (reverse fairing for hella speed) when recovering by b reversing chargeshot, jump to cancel, and immediately fair.
16:36 "Not really the list this move belongs in, but I do have to include it, it is a projectile, you can pocket and reflect it."
*Talks about Zapple four seconds later*
You’re completely wrong about Sephiroth’s neutral B. It’s by far one of the best ledge trapping moves in the entire game. It really makes it so your opponent has to work around it, which in itself is super challenging to do without getting caught by the projectile.
9:41 MockRock sounds like a literal villain here lmao
Wow, I’m gonna keep this list in mind while playing Kirby
The fact that I can do forward throw into charge shot is insane. And he adds 1.2x damage multiplier
I think Zelda's phantom should be in S tier personally as it has really good defensive utility if you can learn how to get behind it while it's being summoned. It can cover you from other projectiles and even force your opponent to whiff and give you an opportunity to punish them.
kinda off topic, but man, your intro is seriously amazing. i can't help but rewatch it like 7 times every time i watch one of your videos-
I feel like some of these don't really count cause you don't exactly *charge* them, you just hold the button and change the trajectories. The ones I'm talking about specifically are the Splat Bomb, Din's Fire, and both PK moves, since holding the button purely just changes where the move goes instead.
I paused at 8:42 to make a "you spin me right around" joke, then realized that I paused it at the perfect time to see Dark Pit aiming it through the monitor, straight at me.
It kinda funny when you said "most characters would trade their neutral special for this" when talking about gunner charge shot, when a lot of people trade that for another neutral special.
That might say more about those other moves than it says about Charge Blast :p
@@SSM24_ yeah it does, it just think it's funny that the one character that could actually switch this to be there neutral special has a better one (debatably)
Top 10 best spikes in smash, that would be a cool video.
I have to say that Bowser Jr.'s cannonball is way more useful than you state it as. The purpose of this move is not just to force an option but also to make an everlasting presence due to it having a lingering hitbox, its falling property, the high priority over many other projectiles, and the fact that it does not stop when shielded. These properties do several things. It makes breaking shields and covering escape options from shield possible. It makes it a menacing edge-guarding tool and a complimentary recovery tool when falling from the top corner, which is common. It makes it an unexpected anti-zoning tool when it powers through other projectiles. It also makes it a solid tech-chasing tool, especially on platforms that limit the effectiveness of tech-rolling. While the charge-up does force more attention to positioning, the cannonball takes advantage of that to have a much higher skill-ceiling instead of a simple fast kill move.
So, fun fact: I actually did a similar thing as with Diddy, I went back after my initial recording session and said "you know what, I think I underrated this one a bit, I'll move it up to C tier." So then I went to find a nice clip of Bowser Jr. using the cannonball in a way that supported my point...and I literally couldn't. I watched probably 15 matches looking for a moment where a Bowser Jr. player prioritized Cannonball over pulling Mecha Koopa and that decision actually payed off in some meaningful way, and I never found it. So I deleted the revision. I'm not saying it never happens, but it doesn't happen enough.
As a Plant main, trapping someone in a poison cloud with jab or pummel is rare, but cathartic. Landing poison cloud for more than a second just feels *good*.
Byleths arrow is A tier (in my opinion) Simply for its ability to condition your opponent. I’m a byleth main and I only follow through to the arrow maybe 25 percent of the times that I use it
Fun Fact about Ridleys Boss Weakpoint Thing: It cancels out every knockback you would receive. This does include Litte Mac's KO Punch if it connects just right.
Chargeable projectiles are just so good in general. They're situational at worst and amazing at best. Even the worst ones are still VERY good in their intended use cases.
surprised you didnt bump popgun up cuz of popgun cancels
Isn't Snake up-smash technically a chargeable projectile too?
Technically yes but the only attribute that changes is how far the shell goes, it doesn't get any stronger and the hitbox always stays the same.
In my opinion, I think that Sephiroth’s neutral b could’ve been put a little higher. Sephiroth’s standard flare isn’t really that great, but it does have some combo potential, mega flare can be used after a shadow flare detonates, and gigaflare is one of the best shield punishes in the game because you can also fit a forward smash during the explosion which does roughly 70% damage. This is also really useful considering the fact that Sephiroth has almost zero problems when it comes to shield breaks
I main plant and i honestly see myself using poison breath when you get a shield break. If you dont know, plant fully charged down b almost breaks shield in one hit, so if the opponent has some shield damage it will just break. It does 50-60% and it can kill at 0 with a follow up to an f smash, and if you feel lucky you can combo a jab when theyre in the poison to do soo much damage. so I think its one of plants better moves but its very situational.
I agree with Charge Shot wholeheartedly.
Not only is it arguably the best move in Ultimate, it is arguably the single best move across the entire series
Like, it's one of the most powerful single projectiles in the game, it's power level varies depending on how long you charge it, which gives it almost endless utility, and it's fairly non-committal.
It's basically a Smash attack from afar, that's something that literally every character could utilize in their toolkit to great effect.
2:04 S for Samus!
This is my humor
"Fail-lot"
Dad jokes are amazing lol
How is sephiroph's gigaflare in the same tier as Byleth's failnaught? One is an incredible ledge-trapping tool the other is just an excuse to b-reverse
While I don't think PK Freeze is as good as some lucas players say it is, putting PK Freeze and PK Flash in the same tier is kinda unfair. PK Freeze has a fair amount of utility in Lucas' kit; annoying spacing tool that can be tricky to punish (even more so if he b reverse mid air because of his high air mobility), non committal edge guard that works 99% of the time against certain recoveries, and hovering the move close to Lucas can make him very hard to approach against close ranged characters because the blast radius is bigger than it looks. Meanwhile PK Flash is realistically just a niche mix-up. You can get good value out of it if you hit, but it doesn't provide quite the same utility as PK Freeze.
I agree Freeze is good, but not because of those reasons
It's not an annoying tool to deal with in neutral (unless you're extremely slow like Ganon or Dedede) since it has a ton of startup, so most characters can just run in and dash attack or something on reaction to the audio cue, and it doesn't edgeguard many recoveries for free due to not being particularly mobile or active for very long. However, it's excellent for forcing the opponent to take a different recovery path than they'd like to and/or forcing them to burn a resource and punishing it (since it's extremely threatening on hit and will pretty much kill the opponent at any percent if it hits them while offstage, they absolutely need to get around it somehow, and it only has about 20 frames of endlag on release). Lucas can struggle a bit to cover high recoveries, but Freeze is good for discouraging them and making the opponent want to recover low/mid which moves like Thunder, Fire, Dsmash, Ftilt angled down, and any number of aerials work very well against.
Freeze also has some niche utility as a tool for catching landings against floaties. It similarly forces the opponent to burn a resource or move around it in a way they wouldn't like to have to do, then punishes them for whatever they did to avoid it by only having 20 frames of endlag, but a lot of non-floaty characters can just fall fast enough to not have to worry about this. It's still good to know about in the relevant matchups, though.
"Failnaught, more like fail-a-lot!"
That got me so good.
I would put Phantom Slash in S tier because of how versitile it is. It can be used in so many situations and is even compared to the S tiers much more often used. A move that helps you out in many situations and so many times must be S tier.
Poison Breath and Plasma Breath are both overpowered.
It's so sad that heroes with downtime are always looking at the menu every chance, considering how Most of the time the risk/reward for using menu is only really worth it if your oppoent can reasonably be killed off of it (theres no point in leaving yourself so vulnerable for a flame slash or sizzle if you arent getting a ko for your troubles).
Hero can consistently and safely rack up some solid damage as a zoner between all of his specials and a few of his better normals, but everyone only ever uses the fully charged kafrizz and kazap if they aren't spamming the menu...
It is even sadder that 80% of the match has me looking at the menu to react to what they are going to choose. My goodness, it's the worst :(
That's why I usually use that time to charge up to the middle charge of neutral b. It's really underrated.
That one Japanese hero (forgot his name) basically plays like you described. He only really uses the menu for the stat buffs, and primarily concentrates on Hero's other insane special moves.
@@jonathanlgill akakikusu
Cause they aren't lame
Shadow flare has barely any range and because of it's spammability it's easily read and punished when seph uses it up close.
This man used prime hunter music while talking about charge shot, and charge shot was damn scary in that game too. Coms could land that move in your face, and it charged so fast that they could throw it out at any time.
Solid tier list. Couldn’t find myself disagreeing with these placements.
I always thought Thoron was pretty bad. It requires the most resources, locks you out of better moves, and at 120 you could just close out with other stuff. And Also they removed the mechanic that you can hold B to make it stronger
I don't think they removed that. Also, there are a bunch of things Thoron can do for Robin. Like Arkfire -> Thoron, Discard -> Thoron, Back Throw -> Thoron, and of course Arkfire -> Phantom Footstool -> Arkfire -> Thoron. It's a great tool even if none of these are true combos because of its speed, power, and range. Also, it doesn't require the most resources if you use it as your last Thunder use.
Isn't Mii Gunners side b 2 also a chargeable projectile, because you counted zeldas side b too
Yes, this has been added to the pinned comment
Something something Sephiroth neutral b can deal 59,000+ percent
I’m surprised that ptooie didn’t make the list. Yes, it isn’t a chargeable move in the traditional sense, however you can still charge it to change the distance, similar to Din’s fire and splat bomb.
10:37 haha here we are 3 months later, and MKLeo used Corrin's charge shot to kill sparg0 TWICE in grand finals. Still not a good move, but perhaps it deserves higher than F tier due to Leo's usage of it as a non-commital long-range edge guarding tool.
Bayonetta is my most played character and I have to say it's probably C tier, definitely better than PK flash. Since a lot of her combos send off stage, it is actually used regularly, it forces your opponent to waste a recovery tool which is way better than for byleth or sephiroth since her edguarding is one of the best in the game. Otherwise you can just use the uncharged version to rack up damage and make your opponent lose his jump. I think it is the best of those "edguard" projectiles.
Also corrin dragon fang shot is definitely B tier, really comparable to paralizer, the uncharged version is really good for catching jumps, you have the kill confirm (which is definitely a sample size issue, fue people main corrin and know this is a thing), it is tricky to punish due to the fang, and you can bait a lot of things into it, even the charged one is good in advantage state. You can eventually argue it's C tier but F tier is just not where it is.
The other projectiles I think are missplaced are PK flash, which for me is an F tier, yes it's nich but so is failnot and sephiroth balls and you see it even less than those, ness has a better tool in pretty much any situation anyway. I'm ok with diddy in c tier, it's fine but so is PK freeze and din's fire, and is really underwhelming. I think the pits, ROB and greninja are B tier, the competition is huge and while they are useful, they feel just a little underwhelming, where thoron, fire and the knight are just broken and only not S because it's not "what makes the character" and luma shot is just more impactful and not a bad projectile in itself. For the S tier, I would like to say there are less but honestly they are all arguably the best move of the characters and fantastic, maybe lucario, sephiroth and mewtwo are A tier but honestly I don't think so. I would say Ridley is C tier, it's just not as good as the rest of B tier.
I've got a couple comments about this, mostly about Corrin and Robin. For Corrin, a lot of their advantage comes from people not knowing the matchup, and a charged dragon fang is a really good skill check. It will kinda break shields if they just expect to shield the projectile so hold shield, it's a decent ledge trap to make your opponent stay on ledge longer which lets Corrin instant pin to kill them below ledge, or f-smash if they're still hanging there. It's also pretty good at anti-zoning which is something Corrin has a lot of issues with, while it is slow, it does clank with most other projectiles.
For Robin, they struggle to kill a lot of the time because their kill moves have meter, and you'll probably run out of it once or twice by the time your opponent has enough % to kill. That's where Elthunder comes in, it's fast, doesn't require a lot of meter, can be charged in less time than it takes to land from a full hop, scales extremely well with %, and even if it doesn't kill, it'll knock your opponent offstage pretty easily at anywhere above 100%. Kills starting at 140 ish which isn't bad at all for a really fast, safe, small projectile. That's the main use you'll probably see Robin players get out of it, other than maybe using arcthunder for shieldbreak setups, or the uncharged thunder as a decent poke projectile. It's not S-tier, but it's got a lot more use than just thoron.