VFX Breakdown Twister (Allan McKay VFX artists reacts to ILM CGI 3D FX)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 26 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 108

  • @AllanMcKay
    @AllanMcKay  5 років тому +4

    Try Dashlane Premium free for 30 days by clicking here bit.ly/32p24Xy
    and then get 10% off Dashlane Premium if you decide to upgrade using my code ALLANMCKAY

    • @The3DSMaxinator
      @The3DSMaxinator 5 років тому

      Dashlane saves me tons of time trying to remember passwords for the multitudes of different logins i have to use daily.

  • @hidalgostudio
    @hidalgostudio 4 роки тому +12

    This film stills blows my mind. I’ve always been impressed by the tracking. Absolutely awesome for 1995.

  • @BreannaMae
    @BreannaMae 2 роки тому +9

    Twister was filmed in 1995 and released in May 1996. So considering it was that long ago, these special effects are pretty spectacular. I remember seeing this in the theater when I was a teenager and being absolutely mind-blown over the CGI. Oddly enough, at the time it didn't make me want to be a special effects artist. It just made me want to be a storm chaser lol. The day I went to see this in the theater, we were actually under a tornado watch that eventually turned into a warning ...and ultimately a tornado did touch down. So it was as though the movie never ended after the credits rolled haha.

    • @AllanMcKay
      @AllanMcKay  2 роки тому +4

      Wow what a story! Thanks for sharing Breanna! It’s a bit meta with there being a drive in theater in the movie that gets hit by a tornado!

    • @BreannaMae
      @BreannaMae 2 роки тому +3

      @@AllanMcKay Exactly! Lol. My friends and I left the theater, noticed the sky looked like it could produce either a very bad thunderstorm or a tornado (or both). So we went from watching a movie about storm chasing, to actually storm chasing 😬. Probably not the safest thing in the world to do haha.

  • @EarleSara
    @EarleSara 5 років тому +8

    OMG YES. Twister is one of my favorite films. I remember watching this film over and over again. I used to watch it and rewind it and watch it again. I'm from Kansas so this film felt somewhat relatable and I used to pretend that I had special "storm-sensing" abilities like Bill haha. I was ten when the massive tornado outbreak of 1999 hit south Wichita where I lived. I kind of lost interest in storms after that as it scared the crap out of me to experience a real tornado.

  • @Trentonpage
    @Trentonpage 2 роки тому +3

    That movie is more real than the modern weather movies.

  • @TurbulentHam
    @TurbulentHam 4 роки тому +8

    It blows my mind that tornadoes in movies these days are obviously fake and look fake but somehow they were able to make the tornadoes look real and feel real in 1996. Almost like they took a step backwards after twister in my opinion. Overall one of my favorite movies of all time and visually amazing. Not to mention a killer soundtrack.

    • @EvripidouM
      @EvripidouM 4 місяці тому

      To be fair, rewatching it i see that the effects have aged a little, but the twisters still look great compared to modern movies

  • @bluetrojan
    @bluetrojan 5 років тому +6

    the secret CGI cow is hilarious!! great secret movie history there 😂😂🤣👌👍✨✨

    • @AllanMcKay
      @AllanMcKay  5 років тому +2

      I know! So cool haha
      I mentioned it to one of the artists on this movie and on Speed 2 and he didn't even know about it

  • @independancedayisawesome4689
    @independancedayisawesome4689 5 років тому +2

    As I'm doing a Twister for a project, your notification comes up with that Breakdown...
    Lucky coincidence!

    • @AllanMcKay
      @AllanMcKay  5 років тому

      That's great man! You'll have to show me how it turns out!

  • @HumanHamCube
    @HumanHamCube 7 місяців тому

    22:53 to achieve the edge; the whole shot could be blue sky and graded. The background looks like a matte painting there was extensive roto on this though. My colleague did the cornfield, said he would go to sleep and just see corn for months. Good video.

  • @A-r-o-h
    @A-r-o-h 10 місяців тому +1

    Those visual effects used for the tornados still hold up today. So much passion went into these movies. I know we have better tech today, but it all looks so fake. Nowadays, I feel as though CGI is just used as a lazy way for movie studios to cut costs rather than elevate the film.

  • @plejra
    @plejra 4 роки тому +1

    About deleted scene from trailer containing tractor. "Fangmeier had previously worked on T2, Hook, Jurassic Park, The Mask and Casper before getting the call-up on Twister from one of ILM’s most experienced visual effects supervisors, Dennis Muren. The senior VFX supe has earlier collaborated with producer Steven Spielberg on the stunning 400 frame POV test shot. “I wasn’t along for that test,” recalls Fangmeier, “but Dennis had the camera operator sit next to the driver in this truck out in Novato, California where he found a dusty road that approximated the film’s Oklahoma locale and then they would be driving along and swerving about. Ultimately all the debris was CG and it had this very hand-held feel which was important to Jan and Steven to represent how people might shoot a real tornado in that situation.”"

  • @mooseeygoosey
    @mooseeygoosey 4 роки тому

    I really appreciated the technical discussion for how they rendered the particles. I had always wondered if this was done with sprites. Thanks for taking the time to explain all that Allan.

  • @MarekGajowski
    @MarekGajowski 5 років тому +8

    So if you did The Mummy and Twister breakdowns, now 1995's Jumanji sounds like obvious choice for the next one! :) cheers!

    • @AllanMcKay
      @AllanMcKay  5 років тому

      Great idea thanks Marek!

  • @walkerboh39
    @walkerboh39 5 років тому +1

    Thank you Allan! Great breakdown on this classic movie.

    • @AllanMcKay
      @AllanMcKay  5 років тому +1

      Thanks buddy great to hear from you

  • @roquefortfiles
    @roquefortfiles 4 роки тому +3

    Arnold Gillespie's Twister from Wizard of Oz is STILL amazingly terrifying and that was 1939

  • @michaelcooney9368
    @michaelcooney9368 5 років тому +3

    Actually I'm still hell impressed with the camera tracking in this film. No pressing TRACK bitten back then, and the director shooting all swervy docu style handhelds.

    • @AllanMcKay
      @AllanMcKay  5 років тому +1

      Yeah I remember the VFX sup asking not to add this 'vibration' rig to the cameras to make it even more shaky, so there was a lot of post camera shake. But that doesn't take away from it - they did a fantastic job. Especially the way it was shot, really mind blowing!

    • @michaelcooney9368
      @michaelcooney9368 5 років тому +1

      @@AllanMcKay Yea, films back then, the live action was often shot VistaVision. You could shoot overscan, so the composition is just the center 3/4 the of the image. VistaVision is huge, you can blow it up into an overscan.
      That way, maybe they shot with a mostly steady handheld with low frequency shakes, than if the image is overscanned, the can add lots of shakes and shimmy to the already tracked footage. VistaVision was square almost like tv, so they could bounce up and down on the image a lot if they crop it to cinema scope.

  • @CurveWraps
    @CurveWraps 5 років тому +2

    These case studies are brilliant!! I love listening to your breakdowns! I agree, since you’ve done the Mummy and Twister now, Jumanji should be next!!

    • @AllanMcKay
      @AllanMcKay  5 років тому

      You're not the first to mention jumanji!

  • @lukeswain3630
    @lukeswain3630 5 років тому +1

    Twister was amazing. So glad you did this! :) Thank you!

    • @AllanMcKay
      @AllanMcKay  5 років тому

      Thanks Luke! Yeah this was a lot of fun - please let me know if there's any other projects you want to see covered!

    • @lukeswain3630
      @lukeswain3630 5 років тому

      @@AllanMcKay The Battle sequence from Return of the King with the ginormous stitched matte paintings and Gandalf riding around like...seems like a lot was going on. :)

  • @runsintunson9586
    @runsintunson9586 5 років тому +1

    This is awesome Allan! Thanks for makin' great vids!

    • @AllanMcKay
      @AllanMcKay  5 років тому

      Thanks Runsin!!

    • @runsintunson9586
      @runsintunson9586 5 років тому

      @@AllanMcKay What do you think about a Matrix (one, two or three) VFX Breakdown? I think they are my favorite movies.

  • @jfisherkaaya5958
    @jfisherkaaya5958 5 років тому

    from Tanzania i love learning vfx and i i appreciate you Allan i feel I'm gonna make it br blessed

  • @bluetrojan
    @bluetrojan 5 років тому +1

    Really great work Allan. Many thanks Sir :)

  • @aracturus6220
    @aracturus6220 5 років тому +1

    please edge of tomorrow this time!!! I've been requesting it for a while.. and i believe alot of us will enjoy as well! Congratulations on getting sponsers by the way...

    • @AllanMcKay
      @AllanMcKay  5 років тому

      Thanks Aquib, Edge of Tomorrow would be great I will definitely add it to the list!
      And thanks I am just testing it out but it would definitely help with the costs involved so I'll see how it goes. Thanks again!

  • @michaelcooney9368
    @michaelcooney9368 5 років тому +1

    The ray march tornado was fuzzy but the trees and debris wasn't. I wonder if there was a way to output the tornado with a depth buffer.
    So say it's really impractical to raytrace a tornado at film resolution. You could do a video res 0.5 k ray march twister, and also save a depth map. The trees splinters, trucks, ect can get 1.5k quality or more, but rendered separately. The volume depth buffer is a 3d holdout matte that rubs out the debris when it's hidden by dust.

  • @reed4109
    @reed4109 5 років тому +3

    I would love to see a case study on Ex Machina please.

  • @aracturus6220
    @aracturus6220 5 років тому +2

    seeing this was done in 1990's actually puts me to shame... But its also motivating! Now i am dying in realisation that ive not even achieved a single percent of what's actually being done in the industry!

    • @AllanMcKay
      @AllanMcKay  5 років тому +1

      Keep in mind also it's 30 brilliant minds all working on achieving one goal for months on end. So you by yourself, whatever you accomplish is an amazing feat. So keep going!

  • @bobankrsmanovic9398
    @bobankrsmanovic9398 5 років тому +1

    I am at 20. min... It's great that you decide to do the one of the oldy-goldy. :) I also enjoy studding the effects back then, and still veeery impressed how they did Jurassic Park, back then. It still looks amazing to me.
    When someone tells me these days, that he can't do some effect because of the slow computer, I usually reply with: "Cut the crap. Your mobile phone have much more power, then all the ILM farms back then", so it's just a bad excuse.
    I hope you did more of these videos, because it's awesome seeing old software, and how they had to think smart back then. Also, I love, from time to time, to start my Amiga 500 and real 3D, and playing with some modeling and rendering tools they had back then (I think it's mostly nurbs based). I was actually very surprised that Real 3D had a raytrace shadows.
    Cheers! :)

    • @AllanMcKay
      @AllanMcKay  5 років тому

      haha that's so cool
      and yeah my phone has 6gb of RAM
      I remember my first PC had 1MB of RAM!
      If anything having a slower PC actually forces you to be more efficient and crafty which I think is a really great learning experience
      I plan to do terminator next, and Spiderman far from home - after that Jpark and some of the more recent films so lots in the works. I'd love to make this a weekly thing if time permits
      That's so awesome Boban thanks for sharing!

    • @bobankrsmanovic9398
      @bobankrsmanovic9398 5 років тому

      @@AllanMcKay
      Hah... 1MB of Ram, that was probably some 286... EGA graphics... My first comp was C64 (64kb of RAM :) ), got it when I was 7 years (I am 1981 born).
      Anyway, great to hear you're (when the time permits), continue to work on these videos.... I love T2, and for me, it's still a terrific movie. That morphing effects of T1000 pretty badly aged imho, but some of the practical effects in that movie are mind blowing (minigun scene, for example).
      Now, back to the Jurassic Park, I remember, several month a go watching some clip (in pretty hi res), of a very first sequence with brontosaurus ( giraffe looking dino))...
      ua-cam.com/video/PJlmYh27MHg/v-deo.html
      This scene exactly at 1:00 minute.
      ...and looking at the shaders, and it looks to me like it is displacement, but they didn't had it back then! How can this be a bump map (I guess, they also didn't had normal maps back then)? What sort of magic is here?
      Anyway, the point is: Everyone who complains that have a bad computer, is free to re-create this scene, and I can assure him/her, that will be a pretty impressive piece in demoreel, even by today standards.
      Here's few more ideas for future videos:
      Starship Troopers, Indenpendence Day, Day After Tomorrow,
      well even a Forest Gump had that CG feather at beginning. :)

  • @ДмитрийБыченко-р1щ
    @ДмитрийБыченко-р1щ 5 років тому

    I am Russian, therefore errors in my comment are possible. Allan, i very want to understand VFX, but i don't know were i can study this, and you are the only one, who can help me! I don't understand your videos well, but i hope, what get basic knowledge about VFX with your courses, videos and tutorials. Thank you for this!

  • @twisterxv-tech1160
    @twisterxv-tech1160 5 років тому

    Dude love the visual effects you shared. I didn't notice the tractor scene hitting the windshield was early test used for the promo teaser, then later used for the Twister ride at Universal Studios Orlando. Remarkable.

  • @akshayrox7414
    @akshayrox7414 5 років тому +1

    Awesome loved it

  • @WeatherxCalipha
    @WeatherxCalipha 3 роки тому

    (@ 7:07) Wasn't there a short film made surrounding this footage? Over a decade ago I remember watching a video surrounding teenagers storm chasing in some van, in particular I remember where was a scene on a road where the tornado was chasing them picking up power lines, the film started off in a wheatfield with "Dorothy IV" playing in the background briefly then the rest of the film had "Mobile Home/House VIsit" playing until the very end where it showed the scene of the tractor being thrown and the wheel hitting the windshield.
    Anyone know exactly where I can find this short film again? Haven't seen it since I was little.

  • @VojtechLacina
    @VojtechLacina 5 років тому

    Man, you are great and your deepk knowledge is awesome. Love these breakdowns. My 5 cents are to The Lawnmower Man - this is iconical movie :)

  • @shivsharma6511
    @shivsharma6511 5 років тому +2

    You’re awesome 👏

    • @AllanMcKay
      @AllanMcKay  5 років тому +1

      Thank you Shiv! I appreciate you and the motivating words! Stay awesome! 🙏👊

  • @OBALEHVIEW
    @OBALEHVIEW 5 років тому +1

    Hey Mr. McKAy., Thank you so much for doing this. I am just starting with VFX. I would like to see something with snakes and snake animations. Or if possible provide sites for studying. Supa Work.

    • @AllanMcKay
      @AllanMcKay  5 років тому

      Thanks night shade so you're looking for a tutorial on how to animate snakes is that correct?

  • @TechGamesAU
    @TechGamesAU 4 роки тому +2

    Bro how about the opening scene of the movie where the satellite is going around the earth looking like a N64 render

    • @AllanMcKay
      @AllanMcKay  4 роки тому +1

      Haha - yeah not everything holds up too well. Entirely CG renders aren't all that great back in 96

    • @TechGamesAU
      @TechGamesAU 4 роки тому +1

      @@AllanMcKay you should do some videos specifically on bad cgi/vfx shots in movies.

    • @AllanMcKay
      @AllanMcKay  4 роки тому +1

      @@TechGamesAU I did one with the corridor digital guys (VFX artists react) that was fun. Right before covid.
      However I've actually wanted to do a series on this for years, but actually defending bad cgi. It's pretty funny but I get so defensive when I watch UA-cam videos about bad cgi because they don't know the context as to why those shots were bad. So I keep wanting to do an explainer on a lot of these haha

  • @woodsro
    @woodsro 2 роки тому

    "The movie is terrible, it's more just a showcase for the fx" you're breaking my heart dude hahaha or perhaps it's just nostalgia but my love for this one know no bounds. I love the characters in this.

  • @TheHvidsten
    @TheHvidsten 5 років тому

    Are you struggling with your recording software? Many times the video just stops, but the audio continues (i.e. at 50:26-ish)

  • @browneyes6604
    @browneyes6604 3 роки тому +1

    I love the movie 🍿 That dog looked like my dog 🐶

    • @AllanMcKay
      @AllanMcKay  3 роки тому +1

      Awesome man! Yeah definitely brings back memories of me trying to recreate all this stuff in 3D studio dos, including the cow. Although my version of it would probably break the internet with how embarrassingly bad it was haha
      Thanks for sharing and give your dog a treat or two for being awesome!

  • @atliszilla445
    @atliszilla445 7 місяців тому

    after watching the movie in 4k, theres a few vfx scenes that still held up.

  • @SimonasKorsakas
    @SimonasKorsakas 4 роки тому +1

    I always wanted to ask what annotation software are you using?

    • @AllanMcKay
      @AllanMcKay  4 роки тому

      Do you mean for note taking specifically?
      I use my phone notes which sync to Dropbox for random drug throughout the day.
      But I use one note religiously for most of my stuff
      I actually have a video coming up on exactly this in a few weeks
      We also use Google docs for docs shared with me team that we're all working in. Mostly they use it, anything personal of mine I'm mostly living out of one note which is synced across all my devices
      I think I use the free version if I recall
      I own office but there was something about the free version that I preferred over commercial

  • @gabrielhutton2554
    @gabrielhutton2554 4 роки тому

    Hey Allen I love what you do keep up the good work! Can you a vfx study for Avatar?

  • @RodneyHamiltonKonscious
    @RodneyHamiltonKonscious 5 років тому +1

    Where can I find these Vfx assets allan

    • @AllanMcKay
      @AllanMcKay  5 років тому +1

      1 letterman drive, San Francisco :)

    • @RodneyHamiltonKonscious
      @RodneyHamiltonKonscious 5 років тому +1

      Dude I'm tapped when I come to funds can hitch a ride

    • @AllanMcKay
      @AllanMcKay  5 років тому +1

      @@RodneyHamiltonKonscious I'll send you an Uber!

    • @RodneyHamiltonKonscious
      @RodneyHamiltonKonscious 5 років тому

      @@AllanMcKay dude I'm in new orleans

    • @RodneyHamiltonKonscious
      @RodneyHamiltonKonscious 5 років тому

      Last I'm was in sf was for an atreyu concert and ideas with my ex that was 8 years ago

  • @thunderstormjoeyhaneypart3809
    @thunderstormjoeyhaneypart3809 4 роки тому

    Is the ef6a real life tornado or not a real life twister

  • @stana1980
    @stana1980 5 років тому

    Hai if you're doing the twister movie again what will be your approach. Could you make a tutorial on twister like an f1 or f2
    Could you please post the link to the latest f5 twister that you did thanks

  • @felix.catalogue
    @felix.catalogue 5 років тому

    Ef4 tornado: Here's Johnny!!!

  • @ericbrown5588
    @ericbrown5588 11 місяців тому

    Very cool 😎

    • @ericbrown5588
      @ericbrown5588 11 місяців тому

      Can you do a VFX study for the Planet of the Apes reboot films?

  • @CPpdx20
    @CPpdx20 3 місяці тому

    I don't understand how this movie STILL looks lightyears more realistic than any other movie with weather effects. Same with the first two Jurassic Parks, they look better than the new ones.

  • @mlondimzizivfx2862
    @mlondimzizivfx2862 4 роки тому

    Allan Mackay
    Sir I like your channels but sir why you don't let us know which software you used .if so please let me know

  • @brightgarinson3099
    @brightgarinson3099 5 років тому +1

    My mom's favorite movie.

    • @AllanMcKay
      @AllanMcKay  5 років тому

      oh nice! I guess it has Helen Hunt, and Wesley from Princess Bride, plus giant killing Tornados, it's a win win right?!
      Great to hear thanks for sharing!

    • @brightgarinson3099
      @brightgarinson3099 5 років тому

      @@AllanMcKay Yeah, she introduced me to it when I was younger and I always pointed out to her "the VFX are amazing for it's time." Even back then, I was interested in VFX I just didn't know it.

  • @danielrivas3757
    @danielrivas3757 5 років тому +1

    can you do a breeakdown about the movie FURY ?

    • @AllanMcKay
      @AllanMcKay  5 років тому

      That's a great idea Daniel!

    • @danielrivas3757
      @danielrivas3757 5 років тому

      Allan McKay a tutorial will be awesome as well , recreating something in this first battle scene : ua-cam.com/video/q21AazXT9xo/v-deo.html

  • @browneyes6604
    @browneyes6604 3 роки тому +1

    It’s name is Rudy

  • @sheykaja5273
    @sheykaja5273 5 років тому +1

    One day i will become like you 😎😎 as vfx supervisor 😎😎

    • @AllanMcKay
      @AllanMcKay  5 років тому

      That's so great Shey, I hope we work together one day!

    • @sheykaja5273
      @sheykaja5273 5 років тому

      @@AllanMcKay 😱😱😱😱

  • @tdt7223
    @tdt7223 5 років тому

    It would be interesting to study the latest Harry Potter movies

  • @hmdkv7502
    @hmdkv7502 5 років тому +1

    Do some indiana jones scorpion mode

  • @RodneyHamiltonKonscious
    @RodneyHamiltonKonscious 5 років тому +3

    Was most of the cgi trasked masked

    • @AllanMcKay
      @AllanMcKay  5 років тому

      The CGI trucks or which do you mean

  • @rhashadcarter2051
    @rhashadcarter2051 5 років тому

    Can you do one for Godzilla King of the Monsters ?

  • @AKG58Z
    @AKG58Z 5 років тому

    Next do AVERAGES ENDGAME

  • @marilynchitwood1620
    @marilynchitwood1620 5 років тому

    Way did all take it off youth

  • @browneyes6604
    @browneyes6604 3 роки тому

    Well was rudy

  • @Roozy_Persepolis
    @Roozy_Persepolis 5 років тому +1

    Does JAWS have anything worth covering and breaking down?

    • @AllanMcKay
      @AllanMcKay  5 років тому

      I think from a shooting and composition aspect there's definitely great stuff - but what made Jaws so special was that the shark kept breaking down so they had to minimize it's availability in the movie. Which worked great by showing less of it rather than what was originally planned. Less = more.
      When CGI comes along typically now you can show things off a lot more freely, which is why suddenly we start seeing too much of various creatures in movies

  • @drsjamesserra
    @drsjamesserra 4 місяці тому +1

    Not going to see this film, the original beats everything.

    • @AllanMcKay
      @AllanMcKay  4 місяці тому +1

      @@drsjamesserra this is the original :)