I used to assume everyone felt music the same way and was shocked to find out they don’t. I LOVE music. I can feel it in every inch of my being and rocks my soul. I feel bad for those who don’t, they don’t know what they’re missing.
mee too ... when i first heard "ride it - dj regard" i felt crazy euphoria and romantic.... i thought everyone might have felt the same ....but that was not the case ... its amazing how our brain works.
Same, a lot of songs have lyrics that remind me of my past. Or all the friends I've made, and yet to make. And family. And I think of all the UA-camrs that have made me smile along the way. 😊❤ I hope that makes sense. Lol. 😅
I feel that. I like songs and listen to music frequently, but every now and then I find a song that just scratches an itch in my brain. Can feel it in my bones, it’s just euphoria.
I was surprised to hear him not mention the fact that sound is a form of energy, and that when we hear sound, it passes through our ears, which is energy which like any other energy stimulus initiates a response
because maybe it's more important the elaboration of the stimuli (wavelenght, frequency, etc.) in our brain so that's why he explains from a cognitive-affective point of view the different reasons music creates emotions in us
Well he talked about the 6 primary emotions Happiness Sadness Fear Anger Surprise Disgust So that sadness was the closest emotion to something large or imposing creeping up and something large or imposing creeping up is not an emotion lol.
Fun experiment you can do: - find an emotional scene from a movie you like (one with dialogue) - try to match the pitch of their words to the nearest notes. It seems like we're more likely to take large steps up but only small steps down in pitch when happy. The confidence large intervals are around the baseline pitch but really high and lower than normal pitches tend to be where we reel ourselves back in. The opposite is true when sad. We tend to save the large intervals for elevated pitch and energy. When we're close to the baseline pitch, the movements get smaller and less confident. Minor and major scales seem to mirror this experience but in a more codified way. It also seems that the way we structure our conversations and how we tell stories, converse, and listen to others has a big affect on what kind of music we listen to and make ourselves.
Music is a language used with vibrations. The overtones in a Major 3rd relationship vibrate much differently than minor 3rd. The Major 3rd is the 4th overtone in a series and is more consonant, more familiar to the ear, than the minor 3rd. This familiarity adds to the feeling of happiness. Like life, familiar things tend to make you more comfortable and happy. Minor 3rd has more dissonance, not to kind to the ear, which creates that creepy/sad sound. Also, comparing the "sad and happy" melodies: the "happy" melody uses a Ti-Do relationship. The "sad" melody uses a Te-Do relationship. Ti-Do relationship has the most vibrations/dissonance, followed by resolve. This high amount of dissonance, to resolve, creates a strong movement. Strong movements are familiar to the ear and adds to it's happy sound/language. The Te-Do relationship is weaker in vibrations, giving it a weak movement. This creates a sadder sound/language.
If you listen to the speakers voice and ignore the meaning of the words you will notice his voice moves between various pitches with various rhythms. Why? Consider that If his voice were speaking in a monotone at a monotempo he would sound as if he had no emotion. We speak with melody to express our emotions. Try playing a you tube video in a foreign language you don't know, can you feel the emotions of a speaker talking in a language you can't understand? You will find that you can. How is this possible? The only way this could be possible is if music of voice is like facial expression, universal and inherent. The inner ear in a fetus reaches full size at four months gestation, long before any other part of the body. This is probably so a fetus can hear the emotions in its mothers voice. Instrumental music is just a demonstration of human skill extending this capacity to an inanimate object much like puppetry extends body language and facial expression to an inanimate object through human skill.
Songs I cry over: Show yourself, from frozen If you love me for me, from the princess and pauper Someone you loved, Lewis capaldi This town, Niall Horan I see the light, from tangled Without me, Halsey Many, MANY many others.
Few other things have the ability to communicate with our emotions in the same way that music does. It can evoke emotions in us such as joy, sorrow, excitement, relaxation, nostalgia, and even rage. The power of music to activate the pleasure regions in our brains and cause the production of dopamine, a neurotransmitter linked to feelings of pleasure and reward, is responsible for this emotional influence of music. A song's tempo, melody, lyrics, instrumentation, and vocal delivery all have an impact on the emotions it evokes. As a result, music can be a powerful instrument for healing, self-expression, and emotionally connecting with others.
I don’t believe that there are bad genres. There is a song for every mood. I have a lot of negative thoughts about myself and music pretty much always helps. Music is the reason i would rather go blind than deaf.
I had the deepest emotion response I have ever felt when I recently heard the song you are my sun shine... it was bizzaar... what made it weirder was after this emotional response I had a layer of 'static electricity' on my skin that lasted about 30 minutes after the experiance.... like my body was purging energy
@@jamarkusw7064 but what I had felt was deep sorrow... normally the song brings a smile but at that moment it broke me. I cried harder and deeper then I had ever cried....
Not sure realization would be the right word. In truth I can't tie the emotional response to any one lasting thought or trigger idea. The closest thing I can relate it to was a flood gate release. A general pulling the plug. I had spinal surgery about 2 months prior. My kids theorized about electrical build up, or static electricity... but anywhere I was touched on my skin electricity flowed....it was weird....
@@katiedangelo404 maybe talk to someone about your full experience who had neurological knowledge. seems a lot more like a nervous system issue that was triggered by how you were feeling at the time.
I agree with the first explanation. When I listen to non-western music like Indian or Chinese I have no emotional response. One exception is Islamic Nasheeds, which evoke feelings of sadness or nervous excitement.
1:00 music doesn't make me feel anymore. I just absorbed faster pace and slower sound waves. I had a very strange experience which led to me learning how to repair my body. I eventually cured myself from severe allergies. When I had a family, they'd think it weird I'd listen to very morbid songs without feeling. To me, it was just energy to absorb.
I had high hopes for this talk, because I have been enjoying a Great Courses recording about “Music and Your Brain”. But this talk seems underprepared. First, I can’t fully distinguish his four theories. Second, he does little to clarify the distinctions between them. Third, his conclusions about them seem vague and unsupported by the rest of his presentation. I’d love to hear a revised version of this talk, in which he takes the time to explain clearly what he is trying to say. I believe that he knows what he’s talking about, but I’m left with the feeling I get from reading a perfunctory assignment by a freshman in a hurry: some hints of a message, but not laid out clearly enough for me to decipher the thinking involved.
Yes I agree. Sure it makes sense that we can associate major songs with happiness & minor songs with sadness. But it is actually more complicated than this. Because there are countless of happy songs out there that are about depression & suicide. Take the Smashing Pumkins Today for example. It is about the acceptance to pass away due to taking an exit in life. And then there can also be minor songs which sound sad but are actually happy. Theres much more about this phenomen than meets the eye. Im glad you mentioned it
idk if its common or just me, but i hardly ever listen to the lyrics of songs, especially when its the first time i hear something... but that is an interesting idea. there are videos in which people change popular songs into minor(generally sad) melodies...
Kay Kapone I know a song that the melody switches from minor to major in the middle but the lyrics stay sad the entire time, and it was as if it was being sarcastic on itself
That's actually quite common in some non English language musical traditions. For example in Greek rembetika some of the saddest sounding tunes have fairly upbeat lyrics , whereas some of the saddest lyrics have fairly upbeat tunes. The feeling is bittersweet, of sadness mixed with joy. I like it!
Music/Sound is energy in the form of reverberation. He missed out on a very important aspect of how musical reverberations physically affect the human mind and body.
Sure it makes sense that we can associate major songs with happiness & minor songs with sadness. But it is actually more complicated than this. Because there are countless of happy songs out there that are about depression & suicide. Take the Smashing Pumkins Today for example. It is about the acceptance to pass away due to taking an exit in life. And then there can also be minor songs which sound sad but are actually happy. Just like in real life, some people may keep up a happy & cheerful facade & crack jokes & what not. But they could also very likely be depressed or suicidal.
I doubt responses to music are entirely made by association. I think organic responses to music are natural and mostly universal. What does happen, however, is that we do make associations between the music we listen and our own personal experiences in real time. If you listened to, I dunno, Led Zeppelin's Stairway To Heaven while you were graduating, it's likely that now everytime you listen to that song, you'll be reminded of the events that took place that the time you used to listen to it and the personal emotions you were experiencing at the time you used to listen to it, but this is not caused by the music alone, that's our memory to "blame", music is just the trigger (and so are other sensory based stimuli).
Faster the rhythm the less you are allowed to think as its keep coming... So brain is happy to ignore to think and cheers instead while slow rhythm becomes obnoxious on each note :P
I wanna give an example of my experience with music: rock/metal elicits allot of emotion in me but also, anime/videogame music and the example I wanna give is a mixed bag. Fire emblem warriors is a very high action game that utilises strategy and the music goes hand in hand with it. The music is rock heavy in the action and for me it drives me to attack in force, I pretty much mash the buttons, I feel like a moth drawn to a flame. The softer music is a nice break in between the action, gives you pause in reflection of what has passed and a chance to prepare for another heavy dose of high octane pulse driven action, that's how I see it. There's one theme in this game that is a kin to turning me into a chimera. I say so because, a chimera is a mix of different creatures and I love the topic of monsters and fantasy. The theme is called This Precious World. It starts off with a low key but serious tone as to tell you that something big is going to happen, then the music rampsup and the rock instrumentation tells you to prepare for a huge fight as the battleground is set. Rock and orchestra meet for the battle of all battles within this game and the seriousness is on full blast as a tone of epicness is established. It cuts to a softer downslope with electric guitar playing an emotion tone and this is when I start to feel a little heavy because I get the sense of hope and a good resolution in the battles end. Then the music gets really positive as the light breaks through the darkness and the heroes in the fight shine with unwavering resolve. Then just near the end, there is a slight tone change adding a little more serious vibe before the end which tells you it can still go either way before it ends and loops over. I'm gonna be real deep here... Music opens up the dept's of my soul, I am rendering meself unto an emotional state because I love music, and it takes me to worlds that I can never see in reality. Any game where I can create a chr is of the most joy to me because I can put meself in it and have the best experience I can possibly have and when the music is as I explained above, it feels I have lived something truly great. Music is a way for us to transcend the woes of our reality. Music makes me feel so strong in the moment, it is so pure, so good, so infallible. One last thing. You can choose a boy or a girl as your story chr in fire emblem warriors and I chose the boy. He has blue eyes and blond hair, I have blue eyes and used to have blond hair when I was younger and the action really takes me in, as I stated above. The music on the other hand is what really drives me and playing as Rowen(being that he's like a younger me) I have a fantastic experience and the music is the exclamation point!
Can y'all tell me what it is? So I've been listening alot to cant you see me? by txt and I learned about the story behind it,(basically they made a promise to be friends together but one of them didn't accomplish this one and it tourns out a playful day to a fight night) and after some more listens I feel sad listening to it(it is an energic song) I almost cry every time I hear it, even one time I cried bcs of this song, this song means alot to me, can y'all explain what is it?
If y'all want to know the story here is it, so txt a 5 members group have a unique concept and here is it, so soobin the friend of yeonjun taehyun beomgyu and Kai, made a promise with the group to be their friends forever, but after some year or months together one day he was with the members(he's more attached to taehyun then then the others) taehyun ignored him and no one gave attention to soobin, so he stayed away from them, so soobin actually brooke the promise of them staying together forever, and he wanted to finish with the group, so the thing is that in a clear movement of the choreography they are like making a back move of the pinky promise(meaning they promised it and didn't breake it) but, soobin did the back movement but with the finger as the broke promise finger AND taehyun did it to, meaning they broke it, so one day the 4 other members commed into soobins house whitout him knowing and stayed there, but soobin and taehyun didn't talked at all, in fact soobin looked mad, and taehyun looked like he didn't trust soobin anymore, so they played and in the teasers and poster of them taehyun marked soobin as suspicious but beomgyu tried to suffocate taehyun bcs he thought taehyun was the guilty for trying to split the group appart, but no before that beomgyu actually was making strawberry smoothie and he got some on his hands, so they started playing and picking tomatoes and getting all over soobins house, the house was actually covered in tomatoe juice, in one time yeonjun was with some tomatoes on hands, but transformed into the members blood making us think he's the guilty for this, and actually he thought it was a joke but it actually was a fight, he realised it to late, talking about Kai, he marked soobin as lonely, so when they where playing Kai started to feel lonely like soobin, and actually they broke everything, in one shot whe can see the house behind them burning, (the fire represents the conflict and fight, the more it grows the more intense it gets) and in one part soobin says "save me"as if he could get all out, and everything was destroyed by one simple thing, then in one shot beomgyu is in front of taehyun and he picked a strawberry smoothie and putted ont taehyun shirt, then it cutted into a fast shot of every member looking at him but at the end soobin looked 2 second's and looked away meaning they could understand each other actually soobin didn't want to make a conflict between taehyun and him but taehyun didn't talk to him, so this all is a UT universe story there is alot more so the details are here! : one part they say "save me, can't you see me?, like in magic days I say believe me"it means they don't trust each other anymore, and now soobin doesn't feels guilty but yeonjun the one that caused nothing feels it, but soobin can see by drawing the future in the mind of their members that's why their cote is one dream, bcs they all dream the same thing, but yeonjun in Run away mv actually goes in a train where he has to close his eyes for another reality but he opens it, and in the future this will cause a big trouble, thanks for reading all this I hope you enjoyed byee!!! 🤍^^
The musical examples could have simply switched maj and min 3rds and elicited opposite emotional responses. It would seem the discussion fails in the understanding of emotion because it attempts to apply an objective frame to an inner experience.
Why you all forget about: SOUNDS of WORDS VIBRATIONS from ELECTROMAGNETIC AIRFIELDS: GOOD OR BAD? MUSIC is HEALING: YES, BUT IF IS MIXED WITH BAD WORDS FROM DIFFERENT HARMONY OF WORDS VIBRATIONS: IT BECAME: DISEASED CLOUDS RADIATION of DEADLY FORCE ON PEOPLE BRAINS and BODIES. WORDS OF POETRY HAVE MELODY WITHIN, as "SPRING SUNNY BUTTERFLY'S DANCE", YET NONE IS TEACHING ABOUT IT> WHY?
음악은 도처에서 볼 수 있는 현상입니다. 우리는 매일 음악을 만들고 음악을 듣습니다. 그것은 우리를 올바른 기분으로 만든다.그리고 다른사람과 이어져 공유되었습니다 저는경험이있는데왜음악은잘되고죽어버리는거죠?스스로 하고 있어요. 음악연구자와저는음악이우리에게주는영향을이해하기위해실험을진행합니다. 나는 지금부터 실험하고 싶으니까, 만약 네가 찬성해 준다면 내가 연주하지. 지금 이렇게 생각하는 사람은 처음이니까 (#1) 슬프게 들린다면 손을 들어주세요. 그가 우는 소리 아무한테도 하지 마세요. 해피 손 들어봐.다음 사람(#2)으로 넘어갑시다.쇼씨는 이렇게 말합니다. 또 한 명은 행복했습니다. 그는 손이 없어서 슬프다. 그래서 제가... 많은 분들이... 첫 번째는... 행복의 발췌에 공감할 수 있을지도 모릅니다. 나는 당신을 행복하게 합니다. 두번째는 슬픈 발췌입니다. 나는 슬퍼집니다. 하지만 누구나 그렇게 생각하는 것은 아니고 유사점이나 감정이 있을 수 있다. 하지만 모두가 동의한 것은 아니어서 무슨 이유가 있었을지도 모릅니다. 무엇이 다른가요? 음악이 당신을 여기에 데려온 이유는 무엇입니까? 자,여러가지설명을위해서첫번째는,이것은우리가배운관련성에기초로한것이다라고했어요. 당신은 벨기에 출신이고 서유럽에서도 비슷한 환경에서 자랐습니다. 문화환경이나 음악의 패턴과 관련된 것을 배웠을지도 모릅니다. 예를 들어 음악은 감정적이게 됩니다. 감정적인 접점입니다. 예를 들어, 해피 무비에서 사용되는 기능을 사용한 적이 있습니다. 이러한 특징들을 연결시키려면 사람들이 웃거나 웃고 있는 것을 봅니다. 행복과 발췌는 이 음악을 만든 모래 접촉과 관련이 있을지도 모른다 라고 불리는, 또는 어느 학습에 근거하는가 하는 다른 설명이 있는 것 같다 '음악적 기대'라는 말은 우리가 일상적으로 겪는 음악 속에서 우리가 획득하는 음악구조의 특성에 대한 통계적 지식 예를 들어, 당신이 경험한 적이 있을지도 모르는 것처럼, 음악 패턴을 실제로 배운다. 차 타고 라디오에 프린트하고 노래 한 곡 들으면 지금까지 한번도 들어본적이 없지만 그 노래랑 같이 부를 수 있었을 수도 있고 왜냐하면 음악 패턴의 가능성에 대한 음악 지식이 있잖아요. 음악 구문에 대한 지식과 이 지식은 기대와 이를 낳을 수 있다 기대가 감정으로 바뀔 수 있으므로, 예를 들어 당신이 기대하는 것은, 좋아하는 음악이 오고, 그것이 시온이 될지도 모르는 기쁨을 만들어 낼 것이다. 지금 음악 속 무언가가 오는 건 알지만 언젠간 모르니까 지금부터 무슨 일이 일어날지, 또 저희가 연구를 했을 때 깜짝 놀랄 수도 있고 수년 전, 우리는 참가자에게, 다른 세그먼트(segment)에 이것이 포함되는 작품을 제공했다. 이 부분적인 음악 코너는 이런 느낌으로 들리고(#3) 그 곡의 맥락 속에서 참가자들은 이것이 그들에게 매우 예상 밖이었으며 이는 계산적으로 어렵다고 우리에게 말했다 음악구조로 예측하여 이 코너와 참여자가 놀랄 만한 다른 세그먼트들은 생리적으로 유발되어 우리 참가자에게 주관적으로 눈을 뜨게 하는 세 번째 설명은 음악은 감정을 유발한다 표정이 풍부한 감정의 운동 덕분에 행복과 슬픔을 다시 한번 봅시다. 행복하고 슬플 때, 주관적인 행복과 슬픔이 관계하고 있잖아요. 이런 감정도요. 그에 따른 특별한 행동도 있고 저희가 행복하고 슬프고 행복하고,슬퍼서 활동적이 되어서, 다가와서, 빠르게 움직이고 있지만 슬프게도, 우리는 현재의 행동을 멈추기에 늦는다.왜냐하면 우리가 욕구불만으로 생각하기 때문이다. 어떤 목표에 도달하여 이러한 움직임과 함께 표현이나 움직임도 존재하는 때때로 상처받는 감정표현 지금 남의 기록을 가지고 왔습니다. 행복한 기분이 든 사람은 또 즐길 수 있습니다. 우리가 연구에서 발견한 발소리에서도 사람은 할 수 있다. 감정 표현이나 감정 상태를 인식하고 들어봅시다. 슬픈 기분인 사람, 또 즐겁네. 그래서 이 둘을 비교를 해보면 지금 즐거운 표정이 점점 더 커졌으니까 한번 들어보도록 합시다. 행복한 음악을 다시 한번, 슬픈음악을다시한번, 슬픈 음악에 맞춰서 해피뮤직은 더 높고, 더 빠르고, 더 빠르고, 더 미안했기 때문에 우리는 생각한다 음악이 감정적으로 움직이는 것 같아서 감정적으로 움직이고 있을 수도 있고 감정 표현은 어느 정도 보편적이고 어떤 연구이긴 하다 내 동료는 사람들에게 음악의 일정한 음향 파라미터를 조절해 달라고 요청했다 아까 얘기했던 분들 행복을 표현해 달라고 말씀하신 분들도 계시고 그들은 자신들이 매우 비슷한 설정과 매우 다른 두 가지 분리된 문화를 사용하는 것을 관찰했다 다른 연구들에서는 서로 접촉하는 일 없이 서로 감정적인 인식이 동일하다 동료 몇 명이 그것을 할 수 있었고, 그들은 또한 두 명의 매우 다른 출신이라고 인정했다 가벼운 고립된 문화가 행복과 슬픔과 행복을 서양음악과 슬픈 서양음악이지만, 감정을 인식하는 것은 어떤 식으로 감정을 느끼게 된다 이는 엠머시와 비슷한 과정을 통해 실현될 것으로 우리는 생각한다 예를 들면 X나 여러분들이 행복을 느꼈을 수도 있는 것들을 생각하면 네가 상상했던 그 모든 것에 대해 행복을 표현한다는 것에 대해 네게 공감했다 우리가 수년 전에 실험한 감정 유도의 보편성에 대한 아이디어 맥길대학과 그녀가 다니던 민족 음악학자와 공동 연구를 시작했습니다. 마콩고 북부의 열대 우림에서 그것을 빼고 사는 콩고피그미의 개체군을 방문했다. 전자매체에 대한 접근이 없어 서양음악에 매우 생소한 전기 그들은 기본적으로 우리가 그 참가자들에게, 그리고 그들에 대해 발표하기 전에는 그것을 들어본 적이 없었다 캐나다인의 양악을 양악의 긍정적인 음악 광고 Western으로 분류하다. 부정적인 음악이기 때문에 그것은 우리가 이 반응들을 본 음악에 대한 서양식 의견이다 두 음악이 두 그룹에게 너무 달라서 보편적인 감정은 없었다 포지티브 또는 네거티브 때문에 가격을 유도하지만, 우리가 음악을 그룹화 했을 때 그 잠재력을 존중하고 서양의 의견도 모두 배제할 수 있었다 주관적, 생리적 각성을 유발한 차분한 음악과 비교한 음악을 환기시키는 그룹 교감 신경계는 두 그룹의 참가자이며, 활발해지고, 각성한다 음악과 다시 음정이 빠르고 더 높았지만 제4의 에큘레이션도 있을지도 모른다 표현적인 움직임과 관계없는 이러한 발견들 중 음악은, 또 또한 교감 신경계에 매우 다양한 영향을 주는 소리를 활성화 시킬 뿐입니다. 긴장, 지향, 주관적, 생리적 흥분이 일어나는 곳 당신이 지금 잠에서 깨는 아침 자명종과 비슷한데 결론과 요약을 하게 해주세요. 왜 음악이 우리의 감정을 만들어내는지 첫 번째는 네 가지 다른 식단을 보여드린 바 있습니다. 그럼 이것은 학습한 관련성에 근거한 것이고, 두 번째 관련성에서는, 이것은 제삼자가 말하기를, 음악적 기대를 쌓아올리는 음악구조에 관한 지식 이는과외표현운동이고네번째는소리를활성화시키기때문이라고말한다. 상위 두 가지 메커니즘은 학습에 기반을 두고 있으며 델의 감정이 왜 그렇게 되는지를 설명할 수도 있습니다. 음악을 들으면 굉장히 부자가 되기도 하지만, 그것은 개인차가 있습니다. 지금 소개한 두 가지 메커니즘과 설명은 더 자세히 설명할 수 있을지도 모릅니다. 만능 응답 패턴 및 델의 응답 패턴이 때와 매우 유사한 이유 설명 그리고 우리가 함께 경험을 공유하는 것에 대한 감사함을 담을 수도 있습니다.
Oussama, And..? Something like major and minor keys is just something we, people, invented. Those are literally just combinations of some frequencies (tones). He's talking about why those frequencies have emotional impact on us.
If someone raises a kid and makes him watch movies and in the movies in every happy scene he puts minor chords he will associate the minor chords with happiness. He explained that very well in his talk,
It is not universal, as he said in his talk they went to a country (dont remember the name) and when they play major chords and stuff they showed much different responses from us.
But why tho? 🤔 I mean, how can something external to us namely soundwaves in a particular order and pattern do something with our internal emotions and even be roughly experienced the same way across the globe? Same with human vocal expression.. you could easely hear if someone (not speaking your language) is angry/happy/sad etc. I would've liked this tedx to be more in depth from an evolutionairy standpoint since myself i find it difficult to understand why on earth would this external input correspond so well with our internal emotional experiences and again, being experienced roughly the same across the globe
What exactly did this prove? Everyone feels and knows from experience that music can induces emotion. This provided no new information at all, except that some dude wasted his time researching something everyone already knew.
This guy is seriously scripted and it ruins it for me. Ted talks are supposed to be just that - talks, not scripted speeches or video essays. The oration should be natural, human, easy to follow and digest, and not dense. There's no reason to have clear paragraph lines, either: ideas should flow seamlessly into each other. The essay format this guy uses causes unnatural and unpredictable studdering and voice breaks.
And this guy actually gets paid for this stuff? Major & Minor Keys are Ubiquitously "Under- Stood" And "felt" by humans in general... Just listen to the background music on any broadcast... Hmmm. (Broad-Cast)... There's a thought for ya right there. YOU ARE BEING HU-MAN-IPULATED... And I wonder by whom?
I used to assume everyone felt music the same way and was shocked to find out they don’t. I LOVE music. I can feel it in every inch of my being and rocks my soul. I feel bad for those who don’t, they don’t know what they’re missing.
I relate!
mee too ... when i first heard "ride it - dj regard" i felt crazy euphoria and romantic.... i thought everyone might have felt the same ....but that was not the case ... its amazing how our brain works.
Same, a lot of songs have lyrics that remind me of my past. Or all the friends I've made, and yet to make. And family. And I think of all the UA-camrs that have made me smile along the way. 😊❤ I hope that makes sense. Lol. 😅
I feel that. I like songs and listen to music frequently, but every now and then I find a song that just scratches an itch in my brain. Can feel it in my bones, it’s just euphoria.
@@rk3246 Yes exactly!!!! 💯👍🏻 It's really an amazing thing, music 🎶. It can be captivating sometimes
I was surprised to hear him not mention the fact that sound is a form of energy, and that when we hear sound, it passes through our ears, which is energy which like any other energy stimulus initiates a response
what do you mean by energy? the spiritual way or the scientific way?
@@GDcelta
The scientific way. It takes a physical wave to interact with the ear, not anything metaphysical.
because maybe it's more important the elaboration of the stimuli (wavelenght, frequency, etc.) in our brain so that's why he explains from a cognitive-affective point of view the different reasons music creates emotions in us
BOTH! Music is a gift from God. I really think they will never truly know, it's one of life's mysteries-and that is also what draws me to it.
It doesn’t matter where I am, or what I’m doing. “Godspeed” by Frank Ocean and “Hey Mama” by Kanye West will always bring tears to my eyes
I would argue that the #2 excerpt was not sad, but more of a cue to something large or imposing creeping up.
Well he talked about the 6 primary emotions
Happiness
Sadness
Fear
Anger
Surprise
Disgust
So that sadness was the closest emotion to something large or imposing creeping up and something large or imposing creeping up is not an emotion lol.
You're the reason why there's 4 explinations
I agree - except 1 was playful, excerpt 2 was ominous.
you're missing the point, genius.....
@@aksoyegearal Fear is closer to that tf do you mean? I got a much more spooky, fearful vibe from that. Not sadness whatsoever.
I’m always fascinated on how different music effects everyone in different ways. Even music with lyrics conjure emotion.
Fun experiment you can do:
- find an emotional scene from a movie you like (one with dialogue)
- try to match the pitch of their words to the nearest notes.
It seems like we're more likely to take large steps up but only small steps down in pitch when happy. The confidence large intervals are around the baseline pitch but really high and lower than normal pitches tend to be where we reel ourselves back in.
The opposite is true when sad. We tend to save the large intervals for elevated pitch and energy. When we're close to the baseline pitch, the movements get smaller and less confident.
Minor and major scales seem to mirror this experience but in a more codified way.
It also seems that the way we structure our conversations and how we tell stories, converse, and listen to others has a big affect on what kind of music we listen to and make ourselves.
I'm a metalhead. I've been a metalhead for over a decade. Metal makes me feel happy and sad and releases toxic anger within myself.
Well said👏👏
Yup. And it can make anger feel good.
０．０
@@TaigiTWeseFormosanDiplomat
|________. _○___|.
| \ / | 🌷
| \ / |
| |
____________________
|___________________//
| 🌻
|____________________|
|____________________|
|
|____________________/
__________________________
' |
'__________. __ _ |
| |
| | 🌹
| |
| |
|________|_
_____________________
/ \
/ _____ \
/ / \ \ 🌺
/_ / ___ \ ---\
/ / \ \
/ / \ \
________. __________\
_____________
[ |
[ |
[ |
[ ]
[ ]
[ ] 🏵🦗
[ ]
[ ]____________
[ ] |
[ |
[________________________|
I love your username. It's the most metalhead username you could have chosen.
Music is a language used with vibrations. The overtones in a Major 3rd relationship vibrate much differently than minor 3rd. The Major 3rd is the 4th overtone in a series and is more consonant, more familiar to the ear, than the minor 3rd. This familiarity adds to the feeling of happiness. Like life, familiar things tend to make you more comfortable and happy. Minor 3rd has more dissonance, not to kind to the ear, which creates that creepy/sad sound.
Also, comparing the "sad and happy" melodies: the "happy" melody uses a Ti-Do relationship. The "sad" melody uses a Te-Do relationship. Ti-Do relationship has the most vibrations/dissonance, followed by resolve. This high amount of dissonance, to resolve, creates a strong movement. Strong movements are familiar to the ear and adds to it's happy sound/language. The Te-Do relationship is weaker in vibrations, giving it a weak movement. This creates a sadder sound/language.
Indian music is so much advanced and learning it will give all answers about questions related to it. It is more than 1000 years old.
If you listen to the speakers voice and ignore the meaning of the words you will notice his voice moves between various pitches with various rhythms. Why? Consider that If his voice were speaking in a monotone at a monotempo he would sound as if he had no emotion.
We speak with melody to express our emotions. Try playing a you tube video in a foreign language you don't know, can you feel the emotions of a speaker talking in a language you can't understand? You will find that you can. How is this possible?
The only way this could be possible is if music of voice is like facial expression, universal and inherent. The inner ear in a fetus reaches full size at four months gestation, long before any other part of the body. This is probably so a fetus can hear the emotions in its mothers voice.
Instrumental music is just a demonstration of human skill extending this capacity to an inanimate object much like puppetry extends body language and facial expression to an inanimate object through human skill.
Christ, are you a Rick and Morty fan? Lol
Absolutely
Robo Charizard I am.
Why was this comment better than the video LOOOL
A fellow intellectual, i see
Your explanation was better than the one in the video. Ahh pretty good boii
The Minecraft sound tracks made me cry.......
Same
Same😁
Facts gets me in my feels every time
I fill same.👍👍
Hahaha Fr tho. "threatening nature"by ab soul make me 😢
Songs I cry over:
Show yourself, from frozen
If you love me for me, from the princess and pauper
Someone you loved, Lewis capaldi
This town, Niall Horan
I see the light, from tangled
Without me, Halsey
Many, MANY many others.
Arcade
All time low
I love them so much
It's not similar to empathy, it IS empathy. You'll never be able to separate them in the lab.
skip to 9:52 to save time ^^
SkaterLauro you're a life saver lol. I wanted something a little simple after hearing Pure Imagination
Thank you...
Legend
life saver my presentation is due tmw
Thank you 🙏
Few other things have the ability to communicate with our emotions in the same way that music does. It can evoke emotions in us such as joy, sorrow, excitement, relaxation, nostalgia, and even rage. The power of music to activate the pleasure regions in our brains and cause the production of dopamine, a neurotransmitter linked to feelings of pleasure and reward, is responsible for this emotional influence of music. A song's tempo, melody, lyrics, instrumentation, and vocal delivery all have an impact on the emotions it evokes. As a result, music can be a powerful instrument for healing, self-expression, and emotionally connecting with others.
Music will always be a great topic to talk about.
Honestly, 1st excerpt could easily be the first few notes of some last episode ending theme, they get me every time
I don’t believe that there are bad genres. There is a song for every mood. I have a lot of negative thoughts about myself and music pretty much always helps. Music is the reason i would rather go blind than deaf.
I had the deepest emotion response I have ever felt when I recently heard the song you are my sun shine... it was bizzaar... what made it weirder was after this emotional response I had a layer of 'static electricity' on my skin that lasted about 30 minutes after the experiance.... like my body was purging energy
that is happiness imo, happened when my ex finally left her abusive home, i felt so much joy.
@@jamarkusw7064 but what I had felt was deep sorrow... normally the song brings a smile but at that moment it broke me. I cried harder and deeper then I had ever cried....
@@katiedangelo404 i understand, do you think maybe it was a realization that brought that sadness ?
Not sure realization would be the right word. In truth I can't tie the emotional response to any one lasting thought or trigger idea. The closest thing I can relate it to was a flood gate release. A general pulling the plug. I had spinal surgery about 2 months prior. My kids theorized about electrical build up, or static electricity... but anywhere I was touched on my skin electricity flowed....it was weird....
@@katiedangelo404 maybe talk to someone about your full experience who had neurological knowledge. seems a lot more like a nervous system issue that was triggered by how you were feeling at the time.
I agree with the first explanation. When I listen to non-western music like Indian or Chinese I have no emotional response. One exception is Islamic Nasheeds, which evoke feelings of sadness or nervous excitement.
Strangely I experience feelings of sadness or angst when I listen to some really upbeat songs like “hello Eileen” or “bittersweet symphony”.
YES!! Hello eileen is totally angst
1:00 music doesn't make me feel anymore. I just absorbed faster pace and slower sound waves.
I had a very strange experience which led to me learning how to repair my body. I eventually cured myself from severe allergies. When I had a family, they'd think it weird I'd listen to very morbid songs without feeling. To me, it was just energy to absorb.
Music is like the group conciousness!
Once i cried while listening to Vicent's 'starry night'
Music has no language and barriers. That's why you can enjoy music you don't understand the lyrics or the language or the culture.
I think a good example of emotions in music is Peter and the Wolf.
I had high hopes for this talk, because I have been enjoying a Great Courses recording about “Music and Your Brain”.
But this talk seems underprepared. First, I can’t fully distinguish his four theories. Second, he does little to clarify the distinctions between them. Third, his conclusions about them seem vague and unsupported by the rest of his presentation.
I’d love to hear a revised version of this talk, in which he takes the time to explain clearly what he is trying to say. I believe that he knows what he’s talking about, but I’m left with the feeling I get from reading a perfunctory assignment by a freshman in a hurry: some hints of a message, but not laid out clearly enough for me to decipher the thinking involved.
Doug Lipman I agree
Yes I agree.
Sure it makes sense that we can associate major songs with happiness & minor songs with sadness.
But it is actually more complicated than this. Because there are countless of happy songs out there that are about depression & suicide. Take the Smashing Pumkins Today for example. It is about the acceptance to pass away due to taking an exit in life.
And then there can also be minor songs which sound sad but are actually happy.
Theres much more about this phenomen than meets the eye. Im glad you mentioned it
：０
Music makes me feel emotions and get a different image or feel in my mind
JUNGKOOK
I wonder what emotions would be provoked by playing a song with sad music, but happy lyrics?
idk if its common or just me, but i hardly ever listen to the lyrics of songs, especially when its the first time i hear something... but that is an interesting idea. there are videos in which people change popular songs into minor(generally sad) melodies...
Kay Kapone I know a song that the melody switches from minor to major in the middle but the lyrics stay sad the entire time, and it was as if it was being sarcastic on itself
That's actually quite common in some non English language musical traditions. For example in Greek rembetika some of the saddest sounding tunes have fairly upbeat lyrics , whereas some of the saddest lyrics have fairly upbeat tunes. The feeling is bittersweet, of sadness mixed with joy. I like it!
His vest makes me sad.
i even cry to heavy dubstep
Trance makes me emotional with dancing
Music/Sound is energy in the form of reverberation. He missed out on a very important aspect of how musical reverberations physically affect the human mind and body.
Sure it makes sense that we can associate major songs with happiness & minor songs with sadness.
But it is actually more complicated than this. Because there are countless of happy songs out there that are about depression & suicide. Take the Smashing Pumkins Today for example. It is about the acceptance to pass away due to taking an exit in life.
And then there can also be minor songs which sound sad but are actually happy.
Just like in real life, some people may keep up a happy & cheerful facade & crack jokes & what not. But they could also very likely be depressed or suicidal.
Why does every song give me a different feeling.
Like a different gut feeling also
Listen to tartini's devils trill....or danse macabre...those songs make you go on an emotional rollercoaster.
I doubt responses to music are entirely made by association. I think organic responses to music are natural and mostly universal. What does happen, however, is that we do make associations between the music we listen and our own personal experiences in real time. If you listened to, I dunno, Led Zeppelin's Stairway To Heaven while you were graduating, it's likely that now everytime you listen to that song, you'll be reminded of the events that took place that the time you used to listen to it and the personal emotions you were experiencing at the time you used to listen to it, but this is not caused by the music alone, that's our memory to "blame", music is just the trigger (and so are other sensory based stimuli).
I live for music ♥️
Faster the rhythm the less you are allowed to think as its keep coming... So brain is happy to ignore to think and cheers instead while slow rhythm becomes obnoxious on each note :P
A picture can speak a 1,000 words
Sounds can speak a 1,000 pictures
After watching this video, I feel confused 🤔
I wanna give an example of my experience with music: rock/metal elicits allot of emotion in me but also, anime/videogame music and the example I wanna give is a mixed bag. Fire emblem warriors is a very high action game that utilises strategy and the music goes hand in hand with it. The music is rock heavy in the action and for me it drives me to attack in force, I pretty much mash the buttons, I feel like a moth drawn to a flame. The softer music is a nice break in between the action, gives you pause in reflection of what has passed and a chance to prepare for another heavy dose of high octane pulse driven action, that's how I see it. There's one theme in this game that is a kin to turning me into a chimera. I say so because, a chimera is a mix of different creatures and I love the topic of monsters and fantasy. The theme is called This Precious World. It starts off with a low key but serious tone as to tell you that something big is going to happen, then the music rampsup and the rock instrumentation tells you to prepare for a huge fight as the battleground is set. Rock and orchestra meet for the battle of all battles within this game and the seriousness is on full blast as a tone of epicness is established. It cuts to a softer downslope with electric guitar playing an emotion tone and this is when I start to feel a little heavy because I get the sense of hope and a good resolution in the battles end. Then the music gets really positive as the light breaks through the darkness and the heroes in the fight shine with unwavering resolve. Then just near the end, there is a slight tone change adding a little more serious vibe before the end which tells you it can still go either way before it ends and loops over. I'm gonna be real deep here... Music opens up the dept's of my soul, I am rendering meself unto an emotional state because I love music, and it takes me to worlds that I can never see in reality. Any game where I can create a chr is of the most joy to me because I can put meself in it and have the best experience I can possibly have and when the music is as I explained above, it feels I have lived something truly great. Music is a way for us to transcend the woes of our reality. Music makes me feel so strong in the moment, it is so pure, so good, so infallible. One last thing. You can choose a boy or a girl as your story chr in fire emblem warriors and I chose the boy. He has blue eyes and blond hair, I have blue eyes and used to have blond hair when I was younger and the action really takes me in, as I stated above. The music on the other hand is what really drives me and playing as Rowen(being that he's like a younger me) I have a fantastic experience and the music is the exclamation point!
Like 21 pilots? Or do you have something specific in mind?
@@en7998 what do you mean?
The song Baby Mine (from dumbo) makes me want to SOB. Like heaving, gasping, audibly sob.
SAMEEEEEE
Yes! And I rarely get emotional. Not even the saddest movie sceen. But that song. Lord!!!
Arbol de mi suenos.. im peruvian american but that song... its too beauiful.
Can y'all tell me what it is? So I've been listening alot to cant you see me? by txt and I learned about the story behind it,(basically they made a promise to be friends together but one of them didn't accomplish this one and it tourns out a playful day to a fight night) and after some more listens I feel sad listening to it(it is an energic song) I almost cry every time I hear it, even one time I cried bcs of this song, this song means alot to me, can y'all explain what is it?
If y'all want to know the story here is it, so txt a 5 members group have a unique concept and here is it, so soobin the friend of yeonjun taehyun beomgyu and Kai, made a promise with the group to be their friends forever, but after some year or months together one day he was with the members(he's more attached to taehyun then then the others) taehyun ignored him and no one gave attention to soobin, so he stayed away from them, so soobin actually brooke the promise of them staying together forever, and he wanted to finish with the group, so the thing is that in a clear movement of the choreography they are like making a back move of the pinky promise(meaning they promised it and didn't breake it) but, soobin did the back movement but with the finger as the broke promise finger AND taehyun did it to, meaning they broke it, so one day the 4 other members commed into soobins house whitout him knowing and stayed there, but soobin and taehyun didn't talked at all, in fact soobin looked mad, and taehyun looked like he didn't trust soobin anymore, so they played and in the teasers and poster of them taehyun marked soobin as suspicious but beomgyu tried to suffocate taehyun bcs he thought taehyun was the guilty for trying to split the group appart, but no before that beomgyu actually was making strawberry smoothie and he got some on his hands, so they started playing and picking tomatoes and getting all over soobins house, the house was actually covered in tomatoe juice, in one time yeonjun was with some tomatoes on hands, but transformed into the members blood making us think he's the guilty for this, and actually he thought it was a joke but it actually was a fight, he realised it to late, talking about Kai, he marked soobin as lonely, so when they where playing Kai started to feel lonely like soobin, and actually they broke everything, in one shot whe can see the house behind them burning, (the fire represents the conflict and fight, the more it grows the more intense it gets) and in one part soobin says "save me"as if he could get all out, and everything was destroyed by one simple thing, then in one shot beomgyu is in front of taehyun and he picked a strawberry smoothie and putted ont taehyun shirt, then it cutted into a fast shot of every member looking at him but at the end soobin looked 2 second's and looked away meaning they could understand each other actually soobin didn't want to make a conflict between taehyun and him but taehyun didn't talk to him, so this all is a UT universe story there is alot more so the details are here! : one part they say "save me, can't you see me?, like in magic days I say believe me"it means they don't trust each other anymore, and now soobin doesn't feels guilty but yeonjun the one that caused nothing feels it, but soobin can see by drawing the future in the mind of their members that's why their cote is one dream, bcs they all dream the same thing, but yeonjun in Run away mv actually goes in a train where he has to close his eyes for another reality but he opens it, and in the future this will cause a big trouble, thanks for reading all this I hope you enjoyed byee!!! 🤍^^
Amazing! I loved this video.
Deltarune soundtracks made me cry, especially lost girl
Nice explanation , sir !
Awesome topic 🌍😉
anybody know where to find the studies referenced in the talk?
awesome !!!
This stuff only proves God's glory!
Motion Picture Soundtrack by Radiohead always makes me leak a lake out of my eyes
death stranding soundtracks makes me feel depressed all the time because of covid
brilliant talk mate.
@Kolbe Arreola no. why ?
Thank you for your explanation.
So basically they have no darn clue
Was listening to kick out the Jams by the MC5 I swear on my bed. I swear I just wanted to get out and play my guitar and move
how come the happy music didnt cure my depression
我的歌声里 had made me emotional all my fuckin life its insane!
I didn’t get happy from the first one.
🙏🏼
it's also to do with majors and minors
so how would music based on pentatonic scales, modes, or even atonal music fit?
The musical examples could have simply switched maj and min 3rds and elicited opposite emotional responses. It would seem the discussion fails in the understanding of emotion because it attempts to apply an objective frame to an inner experience.
My breathing gets heavy when i listen to fuka no carte
This man didnt explain why. He just said statememts.
Why you all forget about: SOUNDS of WORDS VIBRATIONS from ELECTROMAGNETIC AIRFIELDS: GOOD OR BAD? MUSIC is HEALING: YES, BUT IF IS MIXED WITH BAD WORDS FROM DIFFERENT HARMONY OF WORDS VIBRATIONS: IT BECAME: DISEASED CLOUDS RADIATION of DEADLY FORCE ON PEOPLE BRAINS and BODIES. WORDS OF POETRY HAVE MELODY WITHIN, as "SPRING SUNNY BUTTERFLY'S DANCE", YET NONE IS TEACHING ABOUT IT> WHY?
I play music to make my neighbours happy but the call the cop
Did they complain that it was not loud enough? You will learn with time.. as i did.. to buy bigger speakers.
Turn it down !!!!stop getting in your neighbors personal space
음악은 도처에서 볼 수 있는 현상입니다. 우리는 매일 음악을 만들고 음악을 듣습니다.
그것은 우리를 올바른 기분으로 만든다.그리고 다른사람과 이어져 공유되었습니다
저는경험이있는데왜음악은잘되고죽어버리는거죠?스스로 하고 있어요.
음악연구자와저는음악이우리에게주는영향을이해하기위해실험을진행합니다.
나는 지금부터 실험하고 싶으니까, 만약 네가 찬성해 준다면 내가 연주하지.
지금 이렇게 생각하는 사람은 처음이니까 (#1)
슬프게 들린다면 손을 들어주세요. 그가 우는 소리 아무한테도 하지 마세요.
해피 손 들어봐.다음 사람(#2)으로 넘어갑시다.쇼씨는 이렇게 말합니다.
또 한 명은 행복했습니다. 그는 손이 없어서 슬프다. 그래서 제가...
많은 분들이... 첫 번째는... 행복의 발췌에 공감할 수 있을지도 모릅니다.
나는 당신을 행복하게 합니다. 두번째는 슬픈 발췌입니다. 나는 슬퍼집니다.
하지만 누구나 그렇게 생각하는 것은 아니고 유사점이나 감정이 있을 수 있다.
하지만 모두가 동의한 것은 아니어서 무슨 이유가 있었을지도 모릅니다.
무엇이 다른가요? 음악이 당신을 여기에 데려온 이유는 무엇입니까?
자,여러가지설명을위해서첫번째는,이것은우리가배운관련성에기초로한것이다라고했어요.
당신은 벨기에 출신이고 서유럽에서도 비슷한 환경에서 자랐습니다.
문화환경이나 음악의 패턴과 관련된 것을 배웠을지도 모릅니다.
예를 들어 음악은 감정적이게 됩니다. 감정적인 접점입니다.
예를 들어, 해피 무비에서 사용되는 기능을 사용한 적이 있습니다.
이러한 특징들을 연결시키려면 사람들이 웃거나 웃고 있는 것을 봅니다.
행복과 발췌는 이 음악을 만든 모래 접촉과 관련이 있을지도 모른다
라고 불리는, 또는 어느 학습에 근거하는가 하는 다른 설명이 있는 것 같다
'음악적 기대'라는 말은 우리가 일상적으로 겪는 음악 속에서 우리가 획득하는
음악구조의 특성에 대한 통계적 지식
예를 들어, 당신이 경험한 적이 있을지도 모르는 것처럼, 음악 패턴을 실제로 배운다.
차 타고 라디오에 프린트하고 노래 한 곡 들으면
지금까지 한번도 들어본적이 없지만 그 노래랑 같이 부를 수 있었을 수도 있고
왜냐하면 음악 패턴의 가능성에 대한 음악 지식이 있잖아요.
음악 구문에 대한 지식과 이 지식은 기대와 이를 낳을 수 있다
기대가 감정으로 바뀔 수 있으므로, 예를 들어 당신이 기대하는 것은,
좋아하는 음악이 오고, 그것이 시온이 될지도 모르는 기쁨을 만들어 낼 것이다.
지금 음악 속 무언가가 오는 건 알지만 언젠간 모르니까
지금부터 무슨 일이 일어날지, 또 저희가 연구를 했을 때 깜짝 놀랄 수도 있고
수년 전, 우리는 참가자에게, 다른 세그먼트(segment)에 이것이 포함되는 작품을 제공했다.
이 부분적인 음악 코너는 이런 느낌으로 들리고(#3) 그 곡의 맥락 속에서
참가자들은 이것이 그들에게 매우 예상 밖이었으며 이는 계산적으로 어렵다고 우리에게 말했다
음악구조로 예측하여 이 코너와
참여자가 놀랄 만한 다른 세그먼트들은 생리적으로 유발되어
우리 참가자에게 주관적으로 눈을 뜨게 하는 세 번째 설명은 음악은 감정을 유발한다
표정이 풍부한 감정의 운동 덕분에 행복과 슬픔을 다시 한번 봅시다.
행복하고 슬플 때, 주관적인 행복과 슬픔이 관계하고 있잖아요.
이런 감정도요. 그에 따른 특별한 행동도 있고
저희가 행복하고 슬프고 행복하고,슬퍼서
활동적이 되어서, 다가와서, 빠르게 움직이고 있지만
슬프게도, 우리는 현재의 행동을 멈추기에 늦는다.왜냐하면 우리가 욕구불만으로 생각하기 때문이다.
어떤 목표에 도달하여 이러한 움직임과 함께 표현이나 움직임도 존재하는
때때로 상처받는 감정표현 지금 남의 기록을 가지고 왔습니다.
행복한 기분이 든 사람은 또 즐길 수 있습니다.
우리가 연구에서 발견한 발소리에서도 사람은 할 수 있다.
감정 표현이나 감정 상태를 인식하고 들어봅시다.
슬픈 기분인 사람, 또 즐겁네. 그래서 이 둘을 비교를 해보면
지금 즐거운 표정이 점점 더 커졌으니까 한번 들어보도록 합시다.
행복한 음악을 다시 한번, 슬픈음악을다시한번, 슬픈 음악에 맞춰서
해피뮤직은 더 높고, 더 빠르고, 더 빠르고, 더 미안했기 때문에 우리는 생각한다
음악이 감정적으로 움직이는 것 같아서 감정적으로 움직이고 있을 수도 있고
감정 표현은 어느 정도 보편적이고 어떤 연구이긴 하다
내 동료는 사람들에게 음악의 일정한 음향 파라미터를 조절해 달라고 요청했다
아까 얘기했던 분들 행복을 표현해 달라고 말씀하신 분들도 계시고
그들은 자신들이 매우 비슷한 설정과 매우 다른 두 가지 분리된 문화를 사용하는 것을 관찰했다
다른 연구들에서는 서로 접촉하는 일 없이 서로 감정적인 인식이 동일하다
동료 몇 명이 그것을 할 수 있었고, 그들은 또한 두 명의 매우 다른 출신이라고 인정했다
가벼운 고립된 문화가 행복과 슬픔과 행복을
서양음악과 슬픈 서양음악이지만, 감정을 인식하는 것은 어떤 식으로 감정을 느끼게 된다
이는 엠머시와 비슷한 과정을 통해 실현될 것으로 우리는 생각한다
예를 들면 X나 여러분들이 행복을 느꼈을 수도 있는 것들을 생각하면
네가 상상했던 그 모든 것에 대해 행복을 표현한다는 것에 대해 네게 공감했다
우리가 수년 전에 실험한 감정 유도의 보편성에 대한 아이디어
맥길대학과 그녀가 다니던 민족 음악학자와 공동 연구를 시작했습니다.
마콩고 북부의 열대 우림에서 그것을 빼고 사는 콩고피그미의 개체군을 방문했다.
전자매체에 대한 접근이 없어 서양음악에 매우 생소한 전기
그들은 기본적으로 우리가 그 참가자들에게, 그리고 그들에 대해 발표하기 전에는 그것을 들어본 적이 없었다
캐나다인의 양악을 양악의 긍정적인 음악 광고 Western으로 분류하다.
부정적인 음악이기 때문에 그것은 우리가 이 반응들을 본 음악에 대한 서양식 의견이다
두 음악이 두 그룹에게 너무 달라서 보편적인 감정은 없었다
포지티브 또는 네거티브 때문에 가격을 유도하지만, 우리가 음악을 그룹화 했을 때
그 잠재력을 존중하고 서양의 의견도 모두 배제할 수 있었다
주관적, 생리적 각성을 유발한 차분한 음악과 비교한 음악을 환기시키는 그룹
교감 신경계는 두 그룹의 참가자이며, 활발해지고, 각성한다
음악과 다시 음정이 빠르고 더 높았지만 제4의 에큘레이션도 있을지도 모른다
표현적인 움직임과 관계없는 이러한 발견들 중 음악은, 또
또한 교감 신경계에 매우 다양한 영향을 주는 소리를 활성화 시킬 뿐입니다.
긴장, 지향, 주관적, 생리적 흥분이 일어나는 곳
당신이 지금 잠에서 깨는 아침 자명종과 비슷한데 결론과 요약을 하게 해주세요.
왜 음악이 우리의 감정을 만들어내는지 첫 번째는 네 가지 다른 식단을 보여드린 바 있습니다.
그럼 이것은 학습한 관련성에 근거한 것이고, 두 번째 관련성에서는, 이것은
제삼자가 말하기를, 음악적 기대를 쌓아올리는 음악구조에 관한 지식
이는과외표현운동이고네번째는소리를활성화시키기때문이라고말한다.
상위 두 가지 메커니즘은 학습에 기반을 두고 있으며 델의 감정이 왜 그렇게 되는지를 설명할 수도 있습니다.
음악을 들으면 굉장히 부자가 되기도 하지만, 그것은 개인차가 있습니다.
지금 소개한 두 가지 메커니즘과 설명은 더 자세히 설명할 수 있을지도 모릅니다.
만능 응답 패턴 및 델의 응답 패턴이 때와 매우 유사한 이유 설명
그리고 우리가 함께 경험을 공유하는 것에 대한 감사함을 담을 수도 있습니다.
현지 what
Oct 7,2022
219k views
3.2k likes
36.4M sub's
172 comments
it was C major and the second was a D minor what the hell you are expecting
Oussama, And..? Something like major and minor keys is just something we, people, invented. Those are literally just combinations of some frequencies (tones). He's talking about why those frequencies have emotional impact on us.
If someone raises a kid and makes him watch movies and in the movies in every happy scene he puts minor chords he will associate the minor chords with happiness. He explained that very well in his talk,
ege aral aksoy
But there's also the innate emotional/ physiological arousal that's universal
It is not universal, as he said in his talk they went to a country (dont remember the name) and when they play major chords and stuff they showed much different responses from us.
@@aksoyegearal The arousal response is indeed universal. The emotional responses were different, but the arousal was the same.
But why tho? 🤔 I mean, how can something external to us namely soundwaves in a particular order and pattern do something with our internal emotions and even be roughly experienced the same way across the globe? Same with human vocal expression.. you could easely hear if someone (not speaking your language) is angry/happy/sad etc. I would've liked this tedx to be more in depth from an evolutionairy standpoint since myself i find it difficult to understand why on earth would this external input correspond so well with our internal emotional experiences and again, being experienced roughly the same across the globe
0:55
1:16
nice
Origa Inner Universe/Rise acapella.
At 6:13 he slammed the door 🚪
Berserk Guts theme😢
I’m saying 😭
Why is his intro like that 😂
He seemed nervous. Hmmm
Ofc
What exactly did this prove? Everyone feels and knows from experience that music can induces emotion. This provided no new information at all, except that some dude wasted his time researching something everyone already knew.
Lol, #2 sounded like a horror song
purple hair
2:12
I had to watch this because I’m in the class and this was the most boring thing I have ever watched
i like how he doesnt use good music lol
This man has to do a lot more thorough thinking and in depth research to move forward. Not a man for TED.
this guy don't have a clue about music
I think,he tries to explain it to them without any musical theory maybe because he is not sure if they would understand
This guy is seriously scripted and it ruins it for me.
Ted talks are supposed to be just that - talks, not scripted speeches or video essays. The oration should be natural, human, easy to follow and digest, and not dense. There's no reason to have clear paragraph lines, either: ideas should flow seamlessly into each other. The essay format this guy uses causes unnatural and unpredictable studdering and voice breaks.
not if English isnt your mother tongue
And this guy actually gets paid for this stuff?
Major & Minor Keys are Ubiquitously "Under- Stood"
And "felt" by humans in general...
Just listen to the background music on any broadcast...
Hmmm. (Broad-Cast)... There's a thought for ya right there.
YOU ARE BEING HU-MAN-IPULATED... And I wonder by whom?
tedx sucks
The worst Ted talk ever!!
Far from it!
0:56 1:16