Prashant Kishor to Barkha Dutt: "NRC will hurt Hindus also, not only Muslims. It will hurt the poor"
Вставка
- Опубліковано 18 гру 2019
- JDU leader and political strategist tells Barkha Dutt that the non BJP chief ministers represents 61% of the country that did not vote for BJP and the onus is on them to stop the NRC.
Kudos to Kishor. He has really helped viewers in understanding why NRC should not be implemented.
Let us be strong and keep on struggling peacefully for a more perfect union. Big sacrifices were made in US in civil war. We made huge sacrifices in partition and even now so many young people and activists and poor are suffering. Let us ensure we don't have fascism in 2025. Form grand alliance--farmers, workers, urban and rural, all opposition parties. Please listen to my father, freedom fighter & Professor Emeritus, Pol Sc, Punjab University, Shanti Swarup a few weeks before he passed away March 2020 ua-cam.com/video/PRR9EPNUUJw/v-deo.html ua-cam.com/video/OMjEzJ1JgZ0/v-deo.html ua-cam.com/video/ynub109LPC4/v-deo.html
What about they bring emergency and implement
Where did he said about emergency?
Yes. It will be another debacle like Demonitization, utter waste of resources and immense misery especially to poor and middle class without achieving the targeted results.
@@krunalbhadra3812 if state govt did not implement central govt can use the state mechinary by governor rule by applying emergency .they are already against the Indian constitution and they can change that also
Now may be only corona bagvan may save us
Please Miss Barkha could you let him speak. He is so logical and clear. Please allow him to explain this to us without constantly interjecting. Thank you
The understanding of prashant kishore is prime minister level.
He's biggest POLITICAL STRATEGIST of this country.. he's behind mamata,modi,Arvind and in future Aazad
I'm sure not the present prime minister's...Prashant is way far in a superior league
One of the most informative interview on CAA-NRC. Kudos!!!
Let us be strong and keep on struggling peacefully for a more perfect union. Big sacrifices were made in US in civil war. We made huge sacrifices in partition and even now so many young people and activists and poor are suffering. Let us ensure we don't have fascism in 2025. Form grand alliance--farmers, workers, urban and rural, all opposition parties. Please listen to my father, freedom fighter & Professor Emeritus, Pol Sc, Punjab University, Shanti Swarup a few weeks before he passed away March 2020 ua-cam.com/video/PRR9EPNUUJw/v-deo.html ua-cam.com/video/OMjEzJ1JgZ0/v-deo.html ua-cam.com/video/ynub109LPC4/v-deo.html
@@smitaswarup7998 thanks for sharing d link , and bringing voice of bright mind to us.
@@smitaswarup7998 sorry fr the loss and mayb hey Rest In Peace and I agree to every word he said 🙏🙏🙏
The only person who’s spoken logically on NRC.
Pratibha Sharma you also
R u serious?
This man should become PM of India Some day. Great respect ✊
I've been thinking on those lines since past 1 month..and Mahua moitra deputy pm...☺
No. I like puspendra " ji" the men wit the white hair to be the pm
@@kshmobi3605 no one with white should be PM Feku modi hatao desh bachaao
@Richard Madden better then Feku fakir Sala
i m using satire in my sentence.
Kishore is a great politician. Great stand 👌
Let us be strong and keep on struggling peacefully for a more perfect union. Big sacrifices were made in US in civil war. We made huge sacrifices in partition and even now so many young people and activists and poor are suffering. Let us ensure we don't have fascism in 2025. Form grand alliance--farmers, workers, urban and rural, all opposition parties. Please listen to my father, freedom fighter & Professor Emeritus, Pol Sc, Punjab University, Shanti Swarup a few weeks before he passed away March 2020 ua-cam.com/video/PRR9EPNUUJw/v-deo.html ua-cam.com/video/OMjEzJ1JgZ0/v-deo.html ua-cam.com/video/ynub109LPC4/v-deo.html
I am a south indian and political researcher as far as I know he will be the PM candidate in the upcoming years and he may bring a federal front..... and every state will support it as in many states local parties are ruling... and nevertheless he is already helping many parties in campaigning and making them win.
I really hope and pray 🙏 ur prediction comes true👍
well it seems to be true now .
The only logical conclusion which can be drawn from this is that you're a pathetic political researcher.
One of the most sensible voices in Indian politics as of now.
Let us be strong and keep on struggling peacefully for a more perfect union. Big sacrifices were made in US in civil war. We made huge sacrifices in partition and even now so many young people and activists and poor are suffering. Let us ensure we don't have fascism in 2025. Form grand alliance--farmers, workers, urban and rural, all opposition parties. Please listen to my father, freedom fighter & Professor Emeritus, Pol Sc, Punjab University, Shanti Swarup a few weeks before he passed away March 2020 ua-cam.com/video/PRR9EPNUUJw/v-deo.html ua-cam.com/video/OMjEzJ1JgZ0/v-deo.html ua-cam.com/video/ynub109LPC4/v-deo.html
Rightly said.
Bravo Kishor. Thats the way you deal with tough questions ! A lesson for today's politicians !!!
If only she would let him finish....listening is a skill. 🤦♂️
Here after WB results
This man is future.
He said it right...there is no reference to his politics... I somehow like his new way of doing politics...
Prashant is dangerous dog in politics..smarter animal than khujali...
Let us be strong and keep on struggling peacefully for a more perfect union. Big sacrifices were made in US in civil war. We made huge sacrifices in partition and even now so many young people and activists and poor are suffering. Let us ensure we don't have fascism in 2025. Form grand alliance--farmers, workers, urban and rural, all opposition parties. Please listen to my father, freedom fighter & Professor Emeritus, Pol Sc, Punjab University, Shanti Swarup a few weeks before he passed away March 2020 ua-cam.com/video/PRR9EPNUUJw/v-deo.html ua-cam.com/video/OMjEzJ1JgZ0/v-deo.html ua-cam.com/video/ynub109LPC4/v-deo.html
I love to see him as a prime minister... you are totally right!
Kishor is speaking so logically and barkha is not able to play catch up
Usko dimag nahi hai.
Let us be strong and keep on struggling peacefully for a more perfect union. Big sacrifices were made in US in civil war. We made huge sacrifices in partition and even now so many young people and activists and poor are suffering. Let us ensure we don't have fascism in 2025. Form grand alliance--farmers, workers, urban and rural, all opposition parties. Please listen to my father, freedom fighter & Professor Emeritus, Pol Sc, Punjab University, Shanti Swarup a few weeks before he passed away March 2020 ua-cam.com/video/PRR9EPNUUJw/v-deo.html ua-cam.com/video/OMjEzJ1JgZ0/v-deo.html ua-cam.com/video/ynub109LPC4/v-deo.html
Why is this Barkha Dutt interjecting every second.. why can't she let him speak for a while ...
Nitish, that's her old habit
Vomiting words on guest is considered to be experienced journalism old school
With due respect.
Is video ke peeche ka yeh jo dynamic background hai
Yeh bahut distracting hai
Keep it simple.
Woh hum ko Arjun ki tarah focused rehne ki training de rahi hai..Barkhaji.😀
Brilliant person
Someone speaking sense, Thankyou PK.
Two of the smart people ....love these kind of interviews...intelligence and professionalism at its best.
Interesting discussion.
Like this guy..clear headed and integrated..👍👌👏
Country needs people like prashant kishor who has the great idea to lead the country towards development 👍
A pleasure to hear logical politicians.
Amazing leader in making.. superb clarity of thought
I might not agree with his views on NRC..but he is the kind of guy we need in our Political space.
Logical coherent argument from PK.
A lower middle income country that's challenged by basic human needs, wasting productive time, resources, money on a futile exercise to satisfy communal political agenda is astounding. We are staring at a lost decade, if we can come out current situation unscanthed.
He is a fantastic man
Why does she try to sound angry while putting forward a question ?
Would you ask the same question if it was a male rabid journalist ?
@@soumithiyer3227 yes
Haven't watched a video on YT that has made a few things clearer than ever!
Prashant Kishor ji please go even harder to oppose it.
Barkha y so serious and rude with such a nice gentleman?? He is a pleasure to listen to
Nitish kumar rather JDU as a party should endorse PK as next CM of Bihar... I m sure he will prove the next Arvind Kejriwal for Bihar..
Say whatever you want to about him, but he is very very smart.
Prashant Kishor and many of us have done the same mistake by believing in a party who is now heading to dictatorship.
Prashant Kishor is a strategist with a very clear commercial objective. He knows how to project a donkey as a horse. Today all of us are paying a very heavy price for his actions. He knew very well, that the party he was supporting was like a genie in a bottle. Today he is crying foul as the actions of the genie is biting him..
Exactly, he was the man who created IT Cells and now entire country is facing that issue.
Really Barka Dutt is great I liked her attitude very impressive
So?
What's the problem with that?
He too has stopped supporting them. Everyone learns from mistakes.
The problem with ankers are that they ascribe them shelve so much importance as the show is about their bravado and personality.They must listen to the person carefully and should not interfere in between to express their biases and limited understanding.Issues are more important than their personality.
Absolutely correct...yet he's so patient..so far Stupid Arnab, Barkha, Navika, jacob, Rahul kanwal..all these idiots have been doing it except that Dwiwedi fellow in llalantop interview
Wow sir superrrrrrr.... you are great 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Barkha mam let him talk n complete his sentences
True n clear speech about NRC
GENIUS..
Interesting 😊
Lovely interview. 😊
Good sir
That graphics behind them is really distractive and super unnecessary. Just my feeling.
You are right..but they want us to all be like Arjun and only focus on them..😀😀
He is always interesting to watch
Happy to see you barkha ji after a long time...
Such a clear headed person PK is and convincing too.
We don't want to implement NRC to prove within our own family👨👦👧👩👴👵, poor people suffering a lots
Yes rahul is
He & Congress never talk & oppose on this issue
Pk is just great analyst
He says he doesn't belong to any party
Prashant kishore is the closest to my ideal Indian political leader
Yes, support him to make a new party
This Guy is the future PM for India.
Mark my words.
He will change India and Indians in a positive manner where they will live in.peace and harmony within their own country and. Get along very well with their neighbouring countries.
NRC will create a demonetization- like situation.... The poor, tribal and backward class people will suffer like anything.
ua-cam.com/video/lvvytYQgAE4/v-deo.html
Poor will not suffer only illegal migrants suffer stop spreading fake news
Many Bangladeshi are in namma Bengaluru
@@keshorekumar6172 how will u identity illegal migrants?
Great PK
Why is she so rude? She speaks so politely to he cozy club of regulars!
The first truly HINGLISH news interview in India's journalistic history!
Dear Prashant sir..1.)state emergency can be proclaimed by centre on state over its non alignment with executive order by invoking art.356 BUT the ground under which it can be proclaimed are mentioned in art.365..
2. )If centre wishes to continue state emergency beyond 6 months it can do so just by passing resolution in both the house just by simple majority .
Then prepare for massive riots and protests both by hindus and Muslims
@@govindraghavan9493 right & India will suffer in each & every means
Yes PK is right govt has every machinery to identify who r leaving illegally
go ahead and dismiss all governments, if it pleases you. Why is BJP afraid of doing that?
Govind Raghavan we are prepared!! You don’t worry abt that!
Prashant Kishor's words (especially in English) are so very well used. We could learn spoken English from Mr. Kishor.
Barkha never asked him if he is against discrimination or exclude a community, then why does he accept CAB?
haha thinking the constitution doesn't allow for discrimination haha get educated
@manoj Trivedi . you are correct. He is businessman and is not clear of his ideology. He is new to politics and might be still serching his destiny.
We the people of India are the opposition to give safe governing future to our future generations, Good debate but hat"s of to u both, specially to Prashant ji whom I thought a Robot. Extremely sorry bro,. Sabki khoon shaamil hey is meethi main except RSS [ BJP] who choose to lick the Britishers shoes.
The people have to give the information..when they decided not to cooperate..from whom will u get the details..how is it possible?...Assam is a disaster state on NRC...identify the immigrants..demonitization queue was a torture..vivid memories
What is problem with this Barkha ? She is not good listener. She is much more excited to ask questions no matter how silly it be. I don't think she has any interest in understanding.
Very logical talk show ruined by distracting and irritating graphical animated slides in the background. Who’s your channel head who passed this video or is this in video editor’s hands only?
Why everyone is asking that barkha isn't letting him to speak ,as if they have no idea .
Good and informative program. But please change the background graphic. Very distracting.
This they can do in the states where CMs are non-complient.
I wish Barkha you would interrupt so much. By thinking of your questions in your mind you are not seeing that Prashant is making very significant points.
Good to see Barkha Dutt
I agree with logistical Challenge good argument but do not agree with Principle
22:45 to 23:15 operative portion.
Bajpeyi was sincere and even Congress also change the stand upon people sentiments but this modi and Amit shah are arrogant they misuse the power.
Can you define ideology? Good Question? Ideology keeps changing but Dharma( means not religion) can not change.Today pity of the nation is you use the word Dharma it is coloured as non secular.
Let mr Kishore speak in English please, most of videos he speaks in hindi which is making hard fr me to understand. I wanted to hear what this man wanted to speak.
the data is god for this man
If 3 country s get citizen ship to other then muslim but so many countries have Christians why join name that
Thank you for your views and opinions.BJP is requesting for suggestions.Please suggest how we can have a NRC so that it serves it's purpose
The congress proposed similar bill in 2003 so it's really just political drama.
If they are doing NRC &CAA,on-line then what u do.
Let the man speak!! She is interrupting so much
Please check title
ua-cam.com/video/lvvytYQgAE4/v-deo.html
corrected thank you
@@mojostory Anytime
He helped mamta to defeat BJP
What about 20 croer begger for NRC&CAA.
Barkha, why does it look as if you are loosing your hold on this interview? This is not suppose to be an argument to win. It should rather be a good discussion and a good debate. Let the person complete what he's explaining and then you choose to agree or disagree or agree to disagree.
Admire Prashant for explaining the drawbacks and the possible sit back that we may face when NRC comes, which our Home Minister have clearly said will be implemented.
👍🏽
But tomorrow the government can change in Bihar and the central in make them do .. they have put it in constitution ..
Please allow your guest to speak. You dont let him answer, put words in his mouth and are very aggressive - to the point of being rude.
Prashant is talking illlogical, where his party supported the the bill to be passed and now he is telling that State government does not co-op with the centre. Totally illlogical.
this guy has serious conflict of interest
I❤️ barkha : Rabish kumar
Barkha let your guest complete don't speak in between
According to Prashant all illegal immigrants should be the part of India, do you have any solution...
Manoj Trivedi is nrc the solution?Mind you they(govt) don’t have problem with illegal immigrants they only have problem with MUSLIM illegal immigrants!
@@akshaymartin7573 xplainin to fake intellectuals brother
When a hard core Hindu...trY to be secular
Pk...have no ..were to go except...liberalendus
Barkha ji 80% of the poor are going to be effected who don"t know all these things. This Law is against all, except Educated Brahmins who believe in Manusmruthi. This Law is made to eliminate Muslims and Dalits "Reservations" in the name of Nationalism to be in Power to hide their Bloody hands, but we the followers of Jai Bheem Army won"t allow
any politics over Humanity. Bharat Maatha ki jai.
Why is she not with NDtV.
Prashant Kishor for PM
Rubbish typical from Barkha Dutt. Main thing is that --"is it beneficial for the nation or not". If YES ,then rest are just playing politics.
21:58 Why Mr X and Mr Y only? Enough of these strong and weak men. It's time India is led by a woman who believes in Equality, Respect, Kindness and Recession. Enough of Politics, we want governance.
we had a woman ounce, she started an emergency. Infect Historians who tried to prove how much better the world would be have shown woman start more wars, mostly cause they think they need to asset themselves as strong in-front of male leaders of other countries, also, totally Islamophobic XD.
last time we let woman lead, that shitshow she brought upon us is enough to not consider this for 100 years atleast.
अब क्या पछतावा जब चीड़ीया चूकगयी खेत कानून तो पास हो ही गया हे इसके गूनहगारो को जनता कभी भी माफ नहीं करेगी यह बात याद रखना होगा
What are the effective ways in your mind.
With out a driving licence you want to drive car in Indian road
What is impossible nothing is impossible. Yes on huminity grounnd you con let non citizen to live here but you can deny them voting right .
but if they can't vote how will the BJP be defeated...?
@@flypig698 are you saying that with the help of non citizens bjp should be defeated?
@@mahadevpowar6553 hindus are fascist
Prashant Kishor works on payment for different parties on different occasions
He can not hv an ideology. He will go to d party which pays more. He is a professional n should adhere to his professionalism.If he joins a
party then he should adhere to its ideology