Why Did Catnap Never Kill Us In Chapter 3?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 3 гру 2024
  • Why Did Catnap Never Kill Us In Chapter 3?
    Poppy Playtime Chapter 3 Full Gameplay Walkthrough Footage with PoppyTheory of Poppy Playtime Chapter 3. This video is the full Poppy Playtime Chapter 3, Deep Sleep. This is Poppy Playtime's biggest and most terrifying chapter yet. You find a decrepit orphanage known as Playcare that sits beneath the once magical toy factory. New monsters await, and they're much more than just simple toys. The GrabPack gets an upgrade! New hands permit new and creative ways to explore. Answers will finally be revealed. Lies can only stay buried for so long...
    #poppyplaytime #poppyplaytimechapter3 #catnap #poppychapter3 #poppyplaytime3 #poppyplaytime4

КОМЕНТАРІ • 1,2 тис.

  • @andrewsanusi8462
    @andrewsanusi8462 8 місяців тому +1698

    Compared to Huggy or Mommy, Catnap is actually very tactical and smart instead of killing the final ms delight and the little critters (which he could have) he instead made deals with them where they would report to him and in exchange he would give them protection and food heck even with the player he allowed the chance to leave when once again he could have easily killed them.
    So yeah as long as you follow his rules and God and not be a “heretic” you’ll likely be safe.

    • @Brandon-xc2pk
      @Brandon-xc2pk 8 місяців тому +70

      problem with us leaving is 1006 would kill us if we try to go back

    • @tayloranderson7547
      @tayloranderson7547 8 місяців тому +31

      Made deals with them where they report to him and in exchange he would give them protection and food. Heck even with the player he allowed the chance to leave when one again he could have easily killed them. For real life.

    • @glitched_ghosty295
      @glitched_ghosty295 8 місяців тому +16

      @@Brandon-xc2pkOr at least that’s what Poppy tells us.

    • @luna_playzwithruby
      @luna_playzwithruby 8 місяців тому +6

      From the fact I actually have a cat irl

    • @Bobbyaceplaysfooty
      @Bobbyaceplaysfooty 8 місяців тому +2

      😮 catnap softy

  • @kyledougherty2823
    @kyledougherty2823 8 місяців тому +778

    I think I have a solid answer for this (*TLDR at the bottom*). It's been hinted that the children were never killed, but rather hidden away after the Hour of Joy. The question is where? Well they needed to be put somewhere secure, and what area is connected to Playcare, protected by a vault, covered in the Red Smoke, guarded by the Prototype's most loyal follower, and home of the Prototype himself? The laboratory.
    We now have established where, but why would they be put down there? The answer is quite simple, it was to protect them from the massacre, obviously, but then we run into a problem, why keep them there? It seems to be a bit more complicated.
    Let's look at Ms. Delight first, she killed and cannibalized the other teachers and is said to have a "hunger," one she cannot control. After being released from the schoolhouse, she said that Cat Nap probably kept her in there so that she and the other teachers wouldn't eat the kids. We can tell that before the hour of joy there were MANY more living toys, such as the rest of the Smiling Critters and many more smaller toys strewn about the factory (they were most likely alive as they have blood near them). We can assume that every toy had this uncontrollable hunger, a hunger strong enough to force them to cannibalize one another.
    If the Prototype decided to let the kids out immediately after the Hour of Joy, the more numerous toys could not have resisted that hunger and would have attacked and killed the kids. The Prototype freed the children from Playtime only to trap them all over again. He had to wait for the toys to kill each other so he could set the children free without threat. He had Cat Nap trap the teachers in the school house to whittle down their numbers, create a cult and keep them fed so they wouldn't go looking for the children, and at the same time whittle down the numbers of those toys (such as Dog Day) by calling them "heretics" and eating the bigger ones, keeping the smaller ones content and killing the bigger threats.
    But it's too slow, the children are running our of food. They haven't even killed all the toys in Playcare. So they had to get creative, they sent the player and undoubtedly other former employees letters telling them to come back (there's no way Poppy herself sent a letter from a glass box). They come back, they die at the start, until we arrive. We kill Huggy, we kill Mommy, and soon arrive at Playcare and kill Ms. Delight, Dog Day, and Cat Nap (sort of). We're speeding up the Prototype's plan, killing other toys and making himself strong enough to protect the other children by taking other toy's parts. He doesn't kill us because he WANTS us to find him. Cat Nap didn't kill us because he was under orders not to, he only wanted to test us. When we beat him, Cat Nap had no more reason to live, so he sacrificed himself to give more power to the Prototype and take out another threat that might attack the kids
    *TLDR*
    We weren't killed because the Prototype needed us to kill the bigger toys to make it safe for the kids to leave, as well as make him stronger so he could protect the kids

    • @MATAX5
      @MATAX5 8 місяців тому +69

      I’m very sure they locked away all the teachers as they would’ve maintained order in the factory since they were all adults. With them running around, they probably would’ve ruined the prototype’s reign and perhaps make set up communities within the factory so that it wouldn’t have led to the mess it became. It’s kind of sad really because the toys could’ve lived much happier lives had the teachers been there to help maintain everything and make crops to grow so the toys wouldn’t have to eat each other. It wouldn’t have been perfect but it would’ve been much better than what it ended up as.

    • @jazzputmon9990
      @jazzputmon9990 8 місяців тому +55

      I think k the prototype needs our actual body as well... I believe the player is a toy or bigger body that looks more human like miss delight. I believe they needed a toy person hybrid to transfer the prototypes consciousness into us the player .. I think poppy was lied to by Ollie aka the prototype to keep the player inside the facility thinking we'd be able to save the kids but maybe the prototype is trying to escape alone like ge tried to before ... there's also a slight chance he was feeding the chdeen go the left over toys but that's really messed up and I really.jope the kids are amuck in the gas passed out.and unaged... because there has been no talk of aging once put into the smoke... the toys don't die naturally... I'm just hoping the kids are still children.and safe in the gas asleep

    • @user-nm1lx8qb3u
      @user-nm1lx8qb3u 8 місяців тому +61

      ​@@MATAX5 Exept the toys were trained SPECIFICALLY to eat human flesh and human flesh only. How do I know this? Because if you look closely, all around play care and even in the school you can find completely full vending machines of lemonade and candy. (Admittedly terrible candy, but it's still SOMETHING!) And yet she still complain ed about her and the other teachers starving!
      And let's be honest here, do you REALLY think that playtime co. would be above teaching toys CANNIBALISM as long as it served their own interests? Just look at what happened to Rowan Stoll when he found out about the experiments!

    • @davidromanas8596
      @davidromanas8596 8 місяців тому +15

      That is one of the best theories i read

    • @rajveerpandey7311
      @rajveerpandey7311 8 місяців тому +13

      That is a good theory tbh. Like this can actually be put in the lore of the game. Sick theory dude 🔥

  • @GDeNofa
    @GDeNofa 8 місяців тому +773

    CatNap is being a feline. Those instincts are strong as hell. Cats will let prey go and go after it again and again. Once the prey can't run or fight anymore, the cat decides the game is over and ends it. Just like Ollie said.

    • @JamesSutton-ss1wp
      @JamesSutton-ss1wp 5 місяців тому +12

      The guy who explains the security system sounds like emkay

    • @JacobTang-z9e
      @JacobTang-z9e 4 місяці тому

      You mean catnap is being a pussycat

    • @jarnold
      @jarnold 3 місяці тому +15

      Did you actually take the time to watch the vid before commenting this? Op already says this isn't the full case because catnap gives us a verbal warning to leave before attacking us.

    • @GDeNofa
      @GDeNofa 3 місяці тому +10

      @@jarnold yes, I did. I am restating what I know about cats. Chill 😎

    • @ChazWalser
      @ChazWalser 2 місяці тому +2

      Fact remains a hunter wouldn’t give you a chance to leave

  • @argon2532
    @argon2532 8 місяців тому +461

    There has been an idea floating around that CatNap actually talks to you in the dreams, most notably the backwards radio in the first dream and Poppy's voice in the second dream. If this truly is the case, and going by what the voices say, then another reason CatNap doesn't just kill us is because he's curious. Sure, he likely recognizes us as one of the employees who were aware of the experiments, as evident in the radio voice showing disgust in our actions, but he also wants to know why the Player chose to come back, despite the lack of obvious incentive to do so. Maybe he wants to know what we're gonna do at this point, or he perhaps thinks we feel guilt for our actions. After all, he hasn't labeled us as a proper "heretic". Hence, he chose to just keep a close eye on us throughout the chapter, testing us to see what might happen while at the same time causing the occasional roadblock to prevent us just blitzing straight to the Prototype.
    Since his voice box probably isn't in a good state to talk for long periods of time, he uses the dreams as a catalyst to communicate his questions and thoughts to us.
    On a related note, I feel as though Huggy Wuggy was simply waiting for the right opportunity to corner us. If you pay attention to most of Chapter 1's map layout, there are plenty of routes that lead straight back out to the entrance in some way. By the time we make it to the Make-a-Friend room, he finally attacks since we have no way out. In fact, the only reason we escape is because a vent door opened for some reason (probably the Prototype's doing), taking Huggy by surprise and forcing him to pursue us in full.

    • @dizco7934
      @dizco7934 8 місяців тому +69

      I like this because "curiosity killed the cat" lmao

    • @JacobMead-ph1cx
      @JacobMead-ph1cx 8 місяців тому +13

      @@dizco7934that’s what I was gonna say

    • @What_A_Great_Dude
      @What_A_Great_Dude 8 місяців тому +17

      Could be Ollie's doing too, if dey're separate entities, which I hope so. If dey're da same, den still. I mean Ollie doesn't really want us to die because, same reason as Poppy I guess. If its The Prototype, I don't think so, ya, he's using us to help him merge toy parts to his body, but he literally sent da 3 antagonists to kill us. So der's no way he'll let us live by Chapter 1. Like Poppy saud CatNap is da last toy The Prototype "sent to kill us".

    • @KykyTheGreat
      @KykyTheGreat 8 місяців тому +15

      I love this theory! The way Catnap inspects the grabpack hand in the music video also supports his curiosity.

    • @sboy2044
      @sboy2044 8 місяців тому +2

      Doesn’t really make sense since there hasn’t been any actual paranormal occurrences in the franchise thus far

  • @LVAnimationsX
    @LVAnimationsX 8 місяців тому +283

    Poppy Playtime does have a lot of creepy lore…

    • @randommemeclone1021
      @randommemeclone1021 8 місяців тому +17

      Never thought I'd see the day another indie/mascot horror franchise has creepier lore than FNAF's lore

    • @jonathanwade3882
      @jonathanwade3882 8 місяців тому +9

      Chapter 3 was definitely the closest explanation we'd got with the lore. It'll only get deeper from here..

    • @this-is-fine
      @this-is-fine 7 місяців тому +4

      ​@@randommemeclone1021kinda agree and not at the same time, fnaf has a alot more lore but poppy playtime has more creepy lore

    • @jonathanwade3882
      @jonathanwade3882 6 місяців тому

      @@this-is-fine Im sorry, did my comment confuse you?? 😭

    • @Spookser_god
      @Spookser_god Місяць тому

      @@this-is-finenah fnaf has the creepiest lore remember the bite of 87

  • @laughing5752
    @laughing5752 8 місяців тому +200

    Tbh Catnap standing up like that made me first believe he offered himself up because he failed. Like a plea. Also I’m not quite sure if this is inherently true but I thought The Prototype could telepathically speak to things

    • @Night_Liter
      @Night_Liter 6 місяців тому +8

      I mean, they are technology, not too far fetched to assume Prototype can speak "telepathically" To the others

  • @AhrenHope-es8cj
    @AhrenHope-es8cj 8 місяців тому +100

    I think it was to make the journey more traumatic for us, he was stalking us because it would strike fear and paranoia into us, as for why the Prototype killed him, I think the prototype is using us, not to get himself more powerful though. Poppy and the Prototype obviously know what we (the player) are capable of, and the Prototype is using us to free the souls of the kids, they wanted freedom, and he's using us to give them freedom, to free their tortured souls.

    • @Emily-qg3sd
      @Emily-qg3sd 8 місяців тому +5

      That is kinda cool

    • @aaron_mpg_6Y7
      @aaron_mpg_6Y7 2 місяці тому

      @@Emily-qg3sdyep

    • @OOIXIQINGMoe
      @OOIXIQINGMoe Місяць тому +1

      so that basically william afton,but as a mechanic hand,and didn't killed the childrens

    • @jordanAvila-h7t
      @jordanAvila-h7t 25 днів тому

      @@OOIXIQINGMoewhy is that feel right

  • @keyo3316
    @keyo3316 8 місяців тому +47

    Hey, someone needed to get rid of Ms. Delight. Using the player to eliminate one of the problematic toys would be a good strategy from both Catnap and The Prototype. Also, she could have killed you too. It was a win win situation for 1006.

  • @kyrios1120
    @kyrios1120 8 місяців тому +42

    Two things:
    1. He already gave us a chance to leave Playcare before he comes for us which he did
    2. He lives for the hunt
    Prototype probably wanted to get rid of us that’s why he allows Mommy to give us keys to let us escape but then Poppy crashes the train and prevents us from leaving Playcare

  • @Zach-bo8bz
    @Zach-bo8bz 8 місяців тому +53

    I have a few theories as to why Catnap did not kill us.
    1. He was too lazy to attack us at first.
    2. Catnap wanted the hunt to last longer so he didn’t kill us immediately
    3. Do you want us to survive without he’s god knowing about it because he also believes we are the saviors who can end this chaos.
    Catnap is kinda a good guy deep down. He just can’t show it because of his God. (The Prototype) there’s always gotten everybody. We just got to believe.

    • @CatwithaNapattheend
      @CatwithaNapattheend 8 місяців тому +7

      Can confirm, that day was my day off, I got lazy.

    • @Lina-iv8il
      @Lina-iv8il 8 місяців тому +3

      I have a theory that maybe we the player was at one point close to whoever the prototype was as a human and that through this connection the prototype wants us to leave but this past connection keeps them from killing us outright the prototype first warning was the tape that we first play in chapter 1 then they have huggy follow us when we got to close to poppy the prototype told huggy to get us after w kill huggy it might be that us the player want to leave me in chapter 2 it was most likely the prototypes orders that mommy was willing to give us the code for the train through the games if we die then it’s food for mommy if not then we leave win-win what made little sense to me was why in mommy long legs death does the prototypes show up almost immediately after it’s like they were following us around keeping an eye on us I also want to think that it was the prototypes that opened the door at the end of chapter 2 because why else after killing mommy would that door open that might also be why catnap doesn’t immediately kill us and only warns us to leave catnap only try’s to kill us after it’s clear we won’t listen catnap first decides to kill us off quickly then from orders from the prototype I bet just stalks us and tells us to leave only after it’s clear we won’t listen does catnap take us a threat and try’s to kill us possibly against the prototypes orders because the prototypes after we win outright kills catnap in front of us

    • @LupinRio
      @LupinRio 14 днів тому

      @@Lina-iv8il w theory gang

  • @phoneguy4637
    @phoneguy4637 8 місяців тому +231

    Nah... CatNap is a cat-based entity. Cats love to play with their prey. ever seen what cats do with birds and mice they have caught? yeah, they play with them and let them escape over and over again. the reason? their hunting urge ain't satisfied yet.

    • @FranciscoPetrucioJunior
      @FranciscoPetrucioJunior 8 місяців тому +8

      But he mentions that in the vídeo... thing is, CatNap offers a chance for us to escape, when he absolutely didn't need to

    • @phoneguy4637
      @phoneguy4637 8 місяців тому +16

      @@FranciscoPetrucioJunior do you even READ what I write? Cats do that. And CatNap lets us seemingly escape just to get more playtime.

    • @Happs99
      @Happs99 8 місяців тому +6

      This has to be the most boring theory out of them💀💀💀

    • @phoneguy4637
      @phoneguy4637 8 місяців тому +10

      @@Happs99 this has to be the most boring comment out of them.

    • @Gaming_nerd1987
      @Gaming_nerd1987 8 місяців тому

      @@phoneguy4637 catnap was a 7 YEAR OLD BOY! He wouldn’t have some animal like instincts. He is a human.

  • @ScatmanCatNap
    @ScatmanCatNap 8 місяців тому +34

    I got two theories swirling around in my head.First one:the prototype was a bit feeble and couldn't pull itself together,but the moment the player showed up,it took an interest in us.Now,the second version might be a mix of truth and fibs.Here's my take:When we bite the dust,we see those words like "it's too early for you to die,get up,"and I'm hinting that maybe the player himself was there on the day the Joy Hour started,and he volunteered to turn himself into a monster.They made him into that faceless yellow dude we saw on the tape,and the only reason we saw the tape was 'cause he kicked the bucket in that room,or maybe it was that same Ludwig guy.Who knows,right?So,here's the kicker:Why did he keep coming back?It might sound weird,but chances are,the player's body is like a magnetic building set,you know,where the magnetic pieces stick together.And that's probably why the prototype ain't laying a finger on us,cause we're like this special piece for his full recovery,or maybe even for breaking free from this factory to cause some fresh evil out there.And mark my words, I wouldn't be surprised if Poppy Playtime serves up two endings in the final chapter.First one: we take him down and it's all good.But the second one?The prototype breaks loose and starts a bloody rampage,just like in the Terminator movies.Hope you enjoyed my commentary! :)

    • @Nikis.empire
      @Nikis.empire 6 місяців тому +1

      what is that pfp... wth-

  • @OfficalGaku
    @OfficalGaku 8 місяців тому +119

    Here is my theory, well in chapter 3, Ollie said “Catnap lives for the hunt.” So that’s why catnap kept us alive and just watching us first. Even when we were passed out, in the start of chapter 3, he could have killed us right away, but the chapter would be too short. Even we were passed out in home sweet home, he could have killed us. This was my theory.

    • @gachabubblegum
      @gachabubblegum 8 місяців тому +2

      bro u should Collab with this guy

    • @OfficalGaku
      @OfficalGaku 8 місяців тому +2

      @@gachabubblegumwait why and thx

    • @gachabubblegum
      @gachabubblegum 8 місяців тому +2

      @@OfficalGaku cus ur theory's are so good

    • @OfficalGaku
      @OfficalGaku 8 місяців тому +1

      @@gachabubblegumthx, also I made a theory daddy long legs is the chapter 4 main antagonist

    • @tayloranderson7547
      @tayloranderson7547 8 місяців тому +2

      For real life.

  • @SlimSlick384
    @SlimSlick384 8 місяців тому +84

    I believe that catnap let us live to simply get the prototype angry. I’d he wants freedom the only way I see out is death. So I believe that catnap intentionally let us survive so the prototype would end his life, finally letting him rest after all the suffering he’s experienced.

    • @What_A_Great_Dude
      @What_A_Great_Dude 8 місяців тому +13

      I don't think he's da type of guy dat wants to make his "god" angry.

    • @CatwithaNapattheend
      @CatwithaNapattheend 8 місяців тому +13

      Okay first of all, I'm still alive, the prototype conveniently stabbed me at an angle that didn't harm anything, but second of all, why would I make a literal god angry? Like cmon man thats like challenging god to a 1v1 I'm not doing that

    • @What_A_Great_Dude
      @What_A_Great_Dude 8 місяців тому +3

      @@CatwithaNapattheend Remember wat he said about who will win in da main antagonists of every chapter? "Now The Prototype won't be here because we all know that HE WOULD BEAT THE ABSOLU-!"

    • @ashershahzad2185
      @ashershahzad2185 8 місяців тому +7

      @@CatwithaNapattheendI love how you are speaking as if you are Catnap lol😂👏

    • @cruchilsaibot444
      @cruchilsaibot444 8 місяців тому +3

      ​@@CatwithaNapattheendbe careful bro there is already nsfw of you

  • @Pxlr-edits
    @Pxlr-edits 8 місяців тому +87

    It's a valid argument, but it's because he had you let you live. The prototype wanted you or the player to deal with the others

  • @LEG4CYGD
    @LEG4CYGD 8 місяців тому +31

    Theory: i remember watching a video revealing who Ollie really is, basically it had the same arm but different body than the prototype statue we see in ch3. So, my theory is: the "prototype" who killed catnap wasn't actually the prototype himself, but Ollie. Think about it, Ollie knows absolutely everything about playtime co. He could easily find out where the player was and help him at the last minute by pretending to be the prototype and luring catnap into his death.

    • @Astrodudee_
      @Astrodudee_ 6 місяців тому

      what video??

    • @LEG4CYGD
      @LEG4CYGD 6 місяців тому

      @@Astrodudee_ I forgor 💀

    • @Astrodudee_
      @Astrodudee_ 6 місяців тому

      @@LEG4CYGD awh man, the theory sounds so interesting tho.. but how did they knows that ollie had the same arm as prototype?

    • @JacobTang-z9e
      @JacobTang-z9e 4 місяці тому

      It was titled is Ollie the prototype? And Ollie was in front of the prototype

  • @USABall2.0
    @USABall2.0 8 місяців тому +19

    Due to Fact Actually Catnap During The Crash In Chapter 2 Catnap Found Us Then After Catnap Put Us In TheTrash Can Also After We Wake Up Then Catnap Didn't Notice That Were Alive and Keep Following Us Cause Were A Special Employee And Also The Prototype Doesn't Care About Us He Did Not Creating Us The Bigger Bodies Initiative Also The Prototype Only Wants Toys It's Because For The Prototype It's Important That The Toys Have To Be A Part Of Him
    To Make Him Stronger

    • @doorsguy-177
      @doorsguy-177 7 місяців тому +3

      why yo capitalizing everything bru-

  • @phoneguy4637
    @phoneguy4637 8 місяців тому +49

    I believe that Prototype wants our body. Similar to Ennard from FNAF-SL, Prototype can't escape in his current state and appearance. but with our body as a disguise he could. that's why he wants us alive.

    • @Felipa0_1OOmed0
      @Felipa0_1OOmed0 8 місяців тому +9

      It would make sense, if it wasn't plenty of bodies to choose after the hour of joy.

    • @phoneguy4637
      @phoneguy4637 8 місяців тому +3

      @@Felipa0_1OOmed0 so? Ennard had at least two dead technicians at his disposal, yet he craved for Michael's ass. ;) The Prototype obviously has a personal vendetta against us, so he wants our butt. ;)

    • @SunAbasil
      @SunAbasil 8 місяців тому +1

      @@phoneguy4637 The prototype is literally building a body of others bodies, i mean, i think he just wants power. Sure, he might add our body if he feels like it, but i don't think they have an actual way to posses a human body anymore

  • @Baddie_she
    @Baddie_she 8 місяців тому +6

    This guy is so freaking hard working...every morning I wake up there will be new video on different and unique topic.....he deserve more recognition......❤ From India

  • @tampaflbeastforlife
    @tampaflbeastforlife 8 місяців тому +16

    I believe the prototype didn't want Catnap to kill the player right away is because they needed him to unlock the doors that the player did for Ollie so the areas the prototype couldn't go into they used the player to open more doors for them so by the end the prototype told catnap to kill the player he didn't need him anymore and that's my theory on that. also, I have another theory that never came up so I'll be the first to say this lol what if project playtime is really the hour of joy what do ya think about that?

    • @SteamboatMelodies
      @SteamboatMelodies 8 місяців тому +2

      Project playtime was before the hour of joy because in the tutorial leith Pierre or Elliott ludwig (i forgot) speaks to us through the tutorial

    • @-Just_Meh-
      @-Just_Meh- 8 місяців тому

      I believe Project Playtime is connected to The Hours Of Joy since there is a line in Project Playtime "Can you see us? Can you hear us?" line which connected to a song called Sleep Well by CG5 and have the line in it, I believe it's neither Project Playtime is took place before or in or after The Hours Of Joy

    • @SteamboatMelodies
      @SteamboatMelodies 8 місяців тому

      @@-Just_Meh- it can't be after the hour of joy if leith Pierre spoke to us through the tutorial

    • @-Just_Meh-
      @-Just_Meh- 8 місяців тому

      @@SteamboatMelodies I said it "might" take before or in The Hours Of Joys and I personally think it's before starting The Hours Of Joys

  • @Pxlr-edits
    @Pxlr-edits 8 місяців тому +60

    Like dogday said he wants to torture you and make you feel as much pain as possible

  • @MATAX5
    @MATAX5 8 місяців тому +5

    You know, I feel like if you take too long in a certain areas, Catnap should engage with the player out of boredom. In certain areas, there should be a potential puzzle where you would have to figure out a way to get past catnap without being killed by him.

  • @ArtDashie
    @ArtDashie 5 місяців тому +4

    Amazing theory!!!! And CG5 was mentioned! yay!!!!

  • @Felipa0_1OOmed0
    @Felipa0_1OOmed0 8 місяців тому +4

    Maybe catnap doesn't kill us due to prototype's orders. Or maybe because he is curious why the player has returned to factory even we were aware of the dangerous and threats inside of the toy's factory. This curiosity can be seen by the messages he write throughout the game, such as "why have you returned?", "returned was a mistake", "why have you returned?" All the same. He even gave us a verbal warning to leave.

  • @kamikeserpentail3778
    @kamikeserpentail3778 7 місяців тому +5

    I haven't played it (I'll probably wait until it's fully complete), so I only know so much.
    When the Prototype reveals itself, Catnap most certainly does seem to back away in fear, before offing himself to it.
    But I will always feel the need to love cat characters, so I'll imagine numerous ways Catnap might not be the villain he was depicted as.

  • @Ur_pookieSayaka
    @Ur_pookieSayaka 8 місяців тому +5

    This is pretty good I love your theories alot

  • @Th3Tortur3dpo3tsh3art
    @Th3Tortur3dpo3tsh3art 8 місяців тому +17

    Hey man, I love ur vids! Thank you for making my love for Poppyplaytime grow!

  • @JM-ec1ge
    @JM-ec1ge 8 місяців тому +6

    The Prototype probably told catnap that if he lured us deeper into the factory he would give him “freedom”

  • @WilK-kx5fi
    @WilK-kx5fi 8 місяців тому +6

    I think catnap is forced to honor him and he is trying to betray him❤😊

  • @claraxsia8356
    @claraxsia8356 26 днів тому +1

    Im pretty sure the prototype let us live throughout many chapters because he wants us to feel the most pain at the end

  • @BassamAlsebiany
    @BassamAlsebiany 8 місяців тому +7

    Bro I was watching u since your first vid I love you’re content

  • @Theface_strongestface
    @Theface_strongestface 3 дні тому +1

    Catnap just was trying to set us sleep for our good

  • @pokerplayzroblox
    @pokerplayzroblox 8 місяців тому +3

    i have been subscribed to you since u had some 100 subscribers or 1k ur growing so fast and i am so happy about it! keep going!

  • @bulldoggamingreal
    @bulldoggamingreal 6 місяців тому +2

    My theory is that i think catnap didn’t attack us till the end since he wanted to have a bit of fun with his prey, after all, he IS a cat, and since cats like to play with their prey, he was probably trying to make us tired enough to try and kill us, hence his lavender scent and that cats love to tire their own prey only to be killed shortly after. he could also just be having a bit of fun with us since he hasn’t had anyone to kill or toy with for a VERY long time, and then at the end he got tired of it and decided to kill us, or……the prototype decided to tell catnap not to kill us since he wants us to see the horrors of playtime co. And what happened after the hour of joy just to show the player what they missed out on…BUT THATS JUST A THEORY, A GAAAAME THEORY!

  • @Thatusualgirl
    @Thatusualgirl 8 місяців тому +6

    Thx for the video

  • @Extr3meUSER
    @Extr3meUSER 4 місяці тому +1

    mad respect for this guy for paying a lot of attention to everything that ever happened when he played the game. You earned a new subscriber my friend!

  • @Eclipse_crazy32
    @Eclipse_crazy32 6 місяців тому +5

    To me, I think catnap would be betrayed by the prototype. Catnap looks up to the prototype as his god, So that would make the prtotype seem more powerful with the followers thingy. And when Catnap found the player from the train crash, The prototype probably ordered catnap to find a soft and painful death for them, but catnap gave them the garbage disposal which still gave them time to escape. And catnap followed us all around playcare like what huggy did in the factory. When catnap died though, I think he was either giving himself up because he knew he failed, or he was giving himself up for us because he still had his childhood self in him. And I also think that catnaps death could be just a hallucination because before the catnap boss fight, he put them to sleep with his red gas. and it was probably like the nightmare huggy situation. Thats just my theory.

  • @amtrakp4242
    @amtrakp4242 8 місяців тому +2

    Honestly, I feel like Catnap is Good-Hearted inside, but outside, he wants revenge on Playtime Co. for Recalling him even though he was innocent, that explains why he did stuff like just throw us in the trash chute and gave us a chance to leave playcare

  • @SomeoneNews
    @SomeoneNews 8 місяців тому +21

    4:47 perhaps the prototype was too much like a god to the point where his follower had to interpret his words instead of fulfilling them directly.

  • @ConnorGillen-si8tl
    @ConnorGillen-si8tl 2 місяці тому +3

    And why doesn't CatNap kill us instantly: OLLIE LITTERALY SAYS THAT HE BASICALLY TORTURES HIS PREY BEFORE FINALLY KILLING THEM

  • @fc3sthebunta
    @fc3sthebunta 7 місяців тому +3

    That was very relatable🐱

  • @NANDEDENP
    @NANDEDENP 23 години тому +1

    He was trolling bro 🤣

  • @OTAKUFANFICSIU
    @OTAKUFANFICSIU 8 місяців тому +4

    Good one bro can you make a vedio about what can happened in poppy play time ch 4 plz

  • @RyanM1689
    @RyanM1689 8 місяців тому +5

    He’s here he’s there he’s everywhere, who you gonna call? Physic friend Fred- oops catnap

  • @coolergamer6094
    @coolergamer6094 8 місяців тому +3

    Funny thing catnap is very smart at this work the reason he got a mercy kill was when miss delight dies it could be him taking her body and giving it to the prototype
    The prototype uses us to give him his power by making us kill the toys to upgrade himself

  • @MaxRainos
    @MaxRainos Місяць тому

    Huggy Wuggy - Strong, wrathful
    Mommy Long Legs - Psychotic, broken
    Catnap - Cunning, overconfident

  •  8 місяців тому +16

    Sense the prototype has the ability to mimic voices, I have a theory that Ollie may be the prototype. Ollie talks in a suspicious way. Almost like an ai or robot is mimicking a child. Sense the prototype kills Catnap right in front of us, that leads me to thinking that he is Ollie. Ollie also leads us to the exact places that we need to go. Almost like he is always watching us. @PoppyTheory also mentions that the prototype chose to kill catnap right in front of us. Like he knew we would be there.
    edit: Also, Ollie doesnt talk to us after the prototype kills catnap

    • @ava811
      @ava811 4 місяці тому

      Of course Ollie is AI he is not the Prototype the Prototype killed him killed catnap he just doesn't want to say anything because that was the end of the game

  • @briannahansen7641
    @briannahansen7641 2 дні тому +1

    I believe he was another part of the security system but he's a cat so he was actually planning to eat us after stalking us and see what we were up to kind of like Huggy Wuggy and Mommy Long legs though I can't explain the prototype killing CatNap I mostly think it's because the prototype was mad at CatNap for allowing the player to escape when it wasn't really his fault, leaving the player sad that the prototype would do this.

    • @NANDEDENP
      @NANDEDENP 23 години тому +2

      Interesting 😮

  • @sangeetapatel4347
    @sangeetapatel4347 8 місяців тому +33

    Hey, i have a theory. That prototype kept everyone in the factory for these many years because he wanted to kill them.
    Prototype does not allow toys to go out of factory because he know the government would experiment on them and can use them for their good.
    Prototype is good, and if he will go on a kill spree, someone or many might have a chance to run out of factory. But if the factory collapses, small toys would not have Chance to survive the collapse.
    Here comes another theory, why he called us. To kill the bigger bodies that can survive the collapse of factory .
    Poppy for her life wants to kill him and want to stay, and she is manipulating us

  • @jeandanielrobert8792
    @jeandanielrobert8792 7 місяців тому +2

    I feel like the backstory of theo is that he got electrecuted with the grab pack, then the prototype helped him, when Theo turned into CatNap, he still worshipped the prototype as a savior, a god.
    At the end of the chapter, CatNap got electrecuted by the grab pack again, expecting help from the prototype, he raises himself, but the Prototype kills him, for not doing his job to kill us.

  • @this_is_my_username200
    @this_is_my_username200 8 місяців тому +3

    Maybe Catnap didn't kills us was because he remembered who we were. Perhaps Theo was a close buddy of ours while we worked at the factory, prior to his transformation into Catnap. Perhaps we were Theo's primary caretaker when we worked in the factory. That most likely explains why, while we were experiencing hallucinations from the red smoke, we saw locations of the orphanage where Theo and other kids were playing. My theory as to why Catnap was unable to kill us is this.

  • @Minitune-lol856
    @Minitune-lol856 4 місяці тому +2

    My answer is that maybe catnap didn’t want to kill anyone but the prototype was telling catnap to kill the player and co workers
    But that’s my answer, yeah

  • @monochaos9442
    @monochaos9442 8 місяців тому +4

    Have you never seen a cat before, my dude? They like to play with their prey before they kill it.

  • @fredericopires6658
    @fredericopires6658 8 місяців тому +5

    Who else loves poppy theory?

  • @RedHotFilms11
    @RedHotFilms11 8 місяців тому +8

    “Much like Huggy, Mommy was trained up in a certain way”
    _what do you mean by that?_

  • @Granite_Hell2
    @Granite_Hell2 8 місяців тому +1

    catnap is probably angered by the years he has been stuck in playcare so he probably got enjoyment out of tormenting us.

  • @unluckycoin8820
    @unluckycoin8820 8 місяців тому +6

    00:52 sorry i gotta correct you.But what he means by "cameras on our mascots eyeballs" isnt that huggy has cameras in his eyes, but rather he THOUGHT huggy has cameras in his eyes becouse he didnt know that huggy was alive and a part of the BBI.

  • @ash._.lovesanine
    @ash._.lovesanine Місяць тому

    Am I the only one who thinks CatNap was silently begging the Prototype not to kill him? AM I THE ONLY ONE?! Because it looks like he is begging quietly, but I could be wrong

  • @SalariaStudios
    @SalariaStudios 8 місяців тому +3

    I dont know why people aren't realising that the entire time he was putting us in a deep sleep which allowed our subconscious to then reveal all of our past transgressions. We abandoned them at their most vulnerable. I almost bet that the train was suppose to continue moving forward we weren't there to make sure it didn't stop. We were the out and without us to operate the train they moved on to plan B and we are to blame for the slaughter.

  • @emilyg6905
    @emilyg6905 8 місяців тому +2

    You know one of the sentences Ollie says is basically a summarizes into the prototype wanted you to leave the factory and then he could kill you

  • @PR1ME98
    @PR1ME98 8 місяців тому +19

    New theory?
    (Drops everything)
    Im listening (●__●)

  • @Flake._.
    @Flake._. 8 місяців тому +1

    It would make sense if catnap verbally told us to leave, Because catnap sall chance of saving you while its not to late, but as we continued going forward in the game. Catnap being as loyal as he is to the prototype, He wouldn't have a chance because we were to far into the game and had to try to hunt and lure us before the prototype noticed catnaps true feelings and how he felt, So catnap continued what the prototype wanted into begin with.. and to how it got this way the prototype sall potential in catnap, Because at the time catnap was outcasted from the smiling critters for being different from the other smiling critters with Theodore Grambell being fused in within catnap. which means the prototype basically manipulated a child into preventing anyone from escaping, so that the prototype can power himself more without anyone stopping him by having catnap kill off the smiling critters so that he can trap dogday because he is the heroic type and catnap knows that dogday would interfere with the prototype's plan. and for miss delight she's just hungry and there was no food after the hour of joy and any food remaining her sisters hid food so she resorted them as for food and everyone she comes across to so that's why she's evil, she couldn't of resorted to going outside the school and catnap never go's to the general area of the school anyway that's what id believe in.

  • @qavvas6859
    @qavvas6859 8 місяців тому +3

    I disagree. Although this is a smart theory, I have a different answer for the prototype not wanting to kill us. The prototype doesn’t have the body needed to kill more toys and become stronger. He wants us (the player) to kill more toys so he can collect the body parts left.

  • @tahayousaf7664
    @tahayousaf7664 8 місяців тому +2

    I think that catnip is in our side. He might have betrayed the prototype and give us chance to leave.The prototype might have realized that catnip has betrayed him so he killed catnap to not give us chances to leave

  • @ellenshin6644
    @ellenshin6644 8 місяців тому +3

    I love your theory’s there so interesting😮

  • @adriancarson6706
    @adriancarson6706 8 місяців тому +2

    The prototype probably has more enemies deeper down the factory and he can't kill them himself,so he needs us to kill them for him

  • @AutonomousVx
    @AutonomousVx 8 місяців тому +3

    My Theory Is That He Told Catnap Not To Kill Us Since He Knows That We Could've Damage Catnap So He Could Use It For He's Body Also If Your Thinking Catnap Could've Just Defeated The Prototype, The Prototype Is Not Even Complete Of Finishing His Body He Could Use Catnap's Red Smoke Alot Thats My Theory. A Game Theory. Man I Already Miss Matpat.

    • @Abg5342
      @Abg5342 3 місяці тому

      I miss matmat too😢

  • @marialash4925
    @marialash4925 8 місяців тому +2

    Or the player had nothing to do with the Bigger Bodies, but the daughter of someone who worked on the Bigger Bodies, but she is lovely, she saved Huggy Wuggy, then CatNap helps her at the end of the Chapter ☢BOOM☢

  • @naiathasamarabudhram3033
    @naiathasamarabudhram3033 7 місяців тому +13

    8:20
    Finally, someone who says Catnap sacrificed himself
    FINALLY

  • @BETTERDarkENG
    @BETTERDarkENG 6 місяців тому +1

    I don’t think catnap is dead, he sprays us with his gas so him dying could be an allusion so he could get away

  • @bloodblues85
    @bloodblues85 8 місяців тому +9

    You're a pro for baking-in your captions. Thank you! 👍👍

  • @PopcornVR-q1s
    @PopcornVR-q1s 2 місяці тому +1

    They are keeping you away from something..

  • @TheLone323
    @TheLone323 8 місяців тому +3

    The reason why catnap didn’t kill us is because the devs wanted a story line-💀

  • @Keatsshorts
    @Keatsshorts 2 місяці тому +1

    Reason he didnt kill us at the beginning:
    The game wouldve ended. Permanently. :)

  • @bluesnikers656
    @bluesnikers656 8 місяців тому +6

    Hey

  • @Innocent_girl-not_rlly
    @Innocent_girl-not_rlly 7 місяців тому

    Thanks for giving us info with Ur vids! New sub!

  • @Doomshadowyt
    @Doomshadowyt 2 місяці тому +4

    0:50 why does he have the same name as me in real life?

  • @tb5090
    @tb5090 Місяць тому

    I will say this…. Huggy didn’t attack until we were attempting to steal the make a friend we made.
    CatNap didn’t attack until we disobeyed his rules.
    Mommy just missed her kids… and tbh we deserved to die lmao
    I think the kids are still alive (the ones from the orphanage that wasn’t turned into a bigger body.)

  • @ammarelbahy5432
    @ammarelbahy5432 8 місяців тому +7

    I want them to get back to this family: huggy kissy mommy smiling crit and others i want the end to be all left toys to live together again.

  • @seekchan-im2ui
    @seekchan-im2ui 8 місяців тому +2

    I think the player cared for the kid in catnap so catnap has a connection to the player and he lets the player leave

  • @Boonieshorts
    @Boonieshorts 8 місяців тому +8

    Hi I’m first commenter 0:17

  • @Ace_Trace
    @Ace_Trace 8 місяців тому +2

    I have a theory that catnap put us in the trash compactor just to see if we were already dead,once he found out we were alive he went to stalk the player.

  • @hmz_fn_1234
    @hmz_fn_1234 8 місяців тому +643

    Under 1h 👇
    Edited: 4 minutes 15 likes

  • @olgamaria8062
    @olgamaria8062 6 місяців тому +1

    Sometimes, I'm not with the team with Poppy, but im SOMETIMES with the monsters...
    Am i the only one!?

  • @LavieKerns-vk5dm
    @LavieKerns-vk5dm 2 місяці тому +6

    GOD will always be real and good to you wether or not you know HE'S the real GOD and HE will always love you.❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

  • @ahyoungchoi3157
    @ahyoungchoi3157 3 місяці тому +1

    Sometimes theory’s are better than the reality😂😅

  • @Boonieshorts
    @Boonieshorts 8 місяців тому +4

    Hi guys

  • @VinceQuinit
    @VinceQuinit Місяць тому +1

    Wait wait this is confusing, other youtube channels said that the prototype and catnap were the natural enemies from the play care instead to protect the children... I did not expect the other people said that the prototype and catnap are the real threats but instead of a threat this is a twist it's hard for me to decide who i trust because other said that they are evil and harshly punished and other said that they are sitting this up to protect the children i don't know who to decide and i also think that other people have their own decisions and what do they feel about the toys

  • @ForgottenBlox
    @ForgottenBlox 8 місяців тому +6

    I have a good theory why catnap doesnt kill us
    Plot armor

  • @ameliamarem9031
    @ameliamarem9031 8 місяців тому +1

    I think catnap was killed by the prototype because he didn’t kill us .😢 He was forced to kill all the smiling critters 😔

  • @Echothesonicfan22
    @Echothesonicfan22 8 місяців тому +49

    Only real poppy theory fans can like👇

  • @drhadj
    @drhadj 8 місяців тому

    I love your theories they’re so cool! Pls make more❤❤❤

  • @laweartis5217
    @laweartis5217 8 місяців тому +1133

    Make this the most liked comment for no reason😂

    • @Randomff2player
      @Randomff2player 8 місяців тому +17

      I’m trying

    • @tommarnt
      @tommarnt 8 місяців тому +50

      nuh uh no begging

    • @shezantariq968
      @shezantariq968 8 місяців тому +14

      💀💀💀

    • @Siblingworld-c6g
      @Siblingworld-c6g 8 місяців тому +25

      Stop begging if you beg you will get ban

    • @tommarnt
      @tommarnt 8 місяців тому +15

      you won't get bannedfor begging, people will find you annoying if you beg but not ban.@@Siblingworld-c6g

  • @a-b-d-s
    @a-b-d-s 8 місяців тому +2

    Maybe he likes to play with his food?

  • @SuperlexPlays
    @SuperlexPlays 8 місяців тому +8

    *Thanks for 0 like and 0 subscribers* ❤️‍🔥

  • @I7a6m
    @I7a6m 2 місяці тому +1

    What I think 1006 promised freedom that could be it

  • @UnknownErrorHacker
    @UnknownErrorHacker 8 місяців тому +3

    This will get the most likes,
    Under 10 years
    👇🏼

  • @Goober-12-p8i
    @Goober-12-p8i 8 місяців тому +2

    Theory: Catnap acts like a predator, more or less like an ambush and oportunist, predators will often observe prey before pouncing, to know how it behaves to better trap it, that's why he didn't attack

  • @TJDowski
    @TJDowski 8 місяців тому +35

    Only true poppytheory fans can like this comment

  • @Caiptian.cringe
    @Caiptian.cringe 8 місяців тому +1

    No, he was just stalking and playing with us throughout most of the chapter. He failed in killing us in the counselors office and at the very end.