The way I interpret Hoppy Hopscotch’s voice lines is that she and at least one of the other toys tried escaping. The moon is an impossible goal to get to, sorta like the escape of the building, but while Hoppy and this other toy are trying to escape, they need to cross some sort of gap because they were being chased or something, and Hoppy made it, but the other toy was scared to jump, hence the “don’t look at your feet, none of that matters now!” since there was something chasing them. Because of the hesitation of the other toy, both of them end up being killed while Hoppy is pleading for the other toy to jump.
I like how with every games that has like a mysterious story that aren't leaked or like told on the game itself, we became someone who brings out our own theories that actually makes sense and has a possibility that one of the theories that has been told yet is actually part of the plot.
Funny how they say it’s “too gruesome” to let mommy long legs get grinded head first… but dog day getting eating inside out is WAYYY more gruesome than this 😭
I believe that the smiling critters died the same way as Dog day because he said "we tried to fight it, the prototype's control. I'm the last of the smiling critters"
Am I the only one who actually felt kinda bad for Smiling Critters? Their voices in their cutouts sound so broken and sad, and it kinda made me feel a lot of empathy for these guys.
@@One_disorted_individual I don't think so it's not exactly certain but the audio tapes and all the stuff seems to suggest they take children, also something to consider it it's been years like 10-15 years if the children were like 8-9-10-11-12-13-14 it would mean They've reached adulthood, also would needs to be considered is how they managed to even graft a human body to stretch and fit across huggy wuggy or the other tall things if they could do that surely they can maybe install voice boxes so they sound "adult".
Not only that, you can hear his voice when we find him chained up the way you would sound after you have cried for a long time. As well as him pausing for a bit after telling us why the tiny critters follow CatNap. That was just as heartbreaking as his cutout
Halfway through dogday's voice lines you can hear his legs get cut off then hear the thud of them hitting the ground and the way you added the subtitles for the exact moments is amazing
Dogday's death is what makes his last voice line one of the most disturbing yet brutal to be heard. What's even worse that we can also hear his legs getting cut off and falling to the ground, so that explains about how disturbing and brutal it is.
I think I have a more brutal one [eyes ripped out,legs cut off,Arma cut off,mouth sewed up,lounge cut off and last but not least throat and stomach slashed the throat stays and they rip out his wires if they has organs than they ripped out the organs] That's the most brutal thing I know
@@JDBELIEVEESo now we cant be saying what we think of what happened? Like whats bad about typing a lot? Whats bad about nobody asking? They could just be telling their theory bro. And i bet ur gonna say "i aint reading allat" yet again with no reason.
I believe that picky piggy was abandoned because of her cannibalistic ways, leading to her death. I also think that Bobby bear hug was with dog day, and dog day is telling Bobby to leave whilst he sacrificed himself and got chained up. I think crafty corn was so bored and went insane so she started using her own blood as ‘red’ and is talking to herself, killing her self because she dosent have enough blood
@@alexcodexxthekinereader1212the video says the theory of attacking one of the critters so yeah... Also it does say what kind of happened to her, picky piggy ate her, either picky piggy killed her or someone else did
For Hoppy Hopscotch I interpretted it as the "moon" being out of playcare but she kept failing, and when she said "dont look at your feet none of that matters" i took that as her feet/legs had been ripped off by catnap, or broken from trying to escape somehow. which leads her to getting cornered by catnap and unable to jump away.
I think she was with dog day, because it doesn’t seem like a self monologue, and dog day doesn’t have his lower torso and most likely got captured for some reason
@m00nlight73 you can hear dog days legs getting cut off during his cutout screams though I agree it sounds like they mightve been trying to help someone, maybe a different critter had its legs cut off and she died trying to save them
But Hoppy is speaking to someone not to herself. I agree with others that say that Hoppy and one other child or critter was with them when Hoppy made this statement.
I had cried about all the deaths... But Kickin Chicken broke me. Him saying he's never been outside and saying he'll step out the door first OFFERING I'm crying.And I still am. POOR KICKIN CHICKEN!!💔😭😭😭
I always figured the Critters would've died in ironic ways. For Bubba, the cruelest way to torment a smart person with a good memory is to show them something horrible. Knowledge they WISH they could forget, that would drive them insane, just like Bubba's insane ranting in his cut-out.
So, a few things I noticed: 1, Some of the smiling critters cutouts don’t end with screams. The ones without screams are PickyPiggy, and BobbyBearhug. Coincidentally, these two appeared in the end credits for the smiling critters animation alongside DogDay, indicating there’s a good chance these two are still alive. 2, PickyPiggy’s dialogue has the implication that she ate BubbaElephant, KickinChicken, and Craftycorn, which could explain why we don’t see any if them present in chapter 3
DogDay in his monologue mentioned that everyone has already died, but if he is wrong, Bobby is hiding somewhere and PickyPiggy maybe... too, or is still walking around and eating corpses
@@mrvoidschannel359 DogDay likely assumes that the rest are dead, but that doesn’t necessarily mean that it’s true. He never tells us that he saw them die, after all.
@mrvoidschiannel359 i believe dogday just assumed that everybody died because they were missing or he did saw some of them got killed, or he did the killing under prototype's influence. man, can't wait for the next chapter.
Pickypiggy said she ate roast beef but it is none of kickenchicken, crafty corn, and bubbaelaphant so this means that the 10 deleted smiling critters came in playtime co and wasn’t seen in the chapter so she probably attacked kissy missy or the prototype did it can’t be bobbybearhug she’s nice but probably the deleted one that is a cow (I forgot the name) got seen and questioned by Bobbybearhug and pickipiggy ate her/him for surviving I don’t know but do you guys think the deleted smiling critters cow will make an appearance in chapter 4?
When people say "the game isn't scary" they are most likely just talking about the first two chapters, three went all out on the horror, two had some horror, and one basically had no horror at all
@@thefancydoge8668 chapter one is like, get ready for some scares, chapter 2 is slightly turning up the scares and chapter 3 its just trying to scare your soul out of your body edit: tf how did i get 100 likes am i dreaming
Tbh I didn’t wanna care for this, but a friend told me and I watched ManlyBadassHero play it. And well you’re right. That is some dead space shi right there. Didn’t expect this game to go that route
Dog day had to be the saddest story to me. Most likely seeing all his friends die off and catnap become evil, then being tortured by catnap one of his trusted friends, then ultimately being controlled by miniature smiling critters. Not only that but the difference in his voice from the cardboard cutouts. I feel like that might represent everything he went through that was off screen. We don’t even know what ways he was tortured in besides his legs being cut off, and the fact he still looked on the positive side when we appeared even calling us ‘Poppy’s angel’. He better get justice bc Istg
@@yorkietunez it’s even worse tbh. People are actually deranged enough to ship DogDay with CatNap, the one who murdered DogDay’s closest friends, tore DogDay’s legs off, and left him to hang in a dark cell to suffer for years afterwards.
The closest thing he's gonna get to justice is Catnap getting killed by his "god" but the worst part is that he won't ever know, if he even survived the mini critters possessing him.
His cut out looks like him in game if you cover the legs Edit: dang ty ik is not alot and definitely not my most ty again i thought i would get like idk 2 likes
@NStudios64 if they're all in the living room and the only 2 living ones are on the couch how could the rest of em die if theyre in the "LIVING" room?🤔
Idk where I saw this theory but someone said that Hoppy Hopscotch was talking to DogDay. This actually makes some sense especially with the line “don’t look at your feet!” Maybe she was trying to help him escape and jumped to her death while trying to get to the moon. She could’ve been telling DogDay to use his upper body strength or whatever was near them to push himself forward and escape but ultimately Hoppy Hopscotch died and DogDay was recaptured
I have a more tragic theory regarding Hoppy Hopscotch's death... Once things went sour, Hoppy Hopscotch jumped to her death on purpose and was persuading someone else to jump with her, hence her anger at them looking down. Based on the 2 failures before Hoppy's scream, it was VERY hard to fully commit to her choice. She made it a game, "Jumping to the moon", to help ease her and her accomplice(s) into going for it. Her trademark impatience then quite literally led to her downfall.
What if it was DogDay she was trying to persuade? “Don’t look at your feet.” And all that. I know it wouldn’t make sense in the timeline, but it could be foreshadowing DogDay’s legs being cut off.
@@justanotherartist140 There isn't enough evidence to know exactly who accompanied Hoppy Hopscotch, but my best guess is it was Bobby Bearhug, not DogDay. The short story below describes what I believe happened: “DogDay vanishing was the last straw for the Smiling Critters- without his sunny mediation, the worst traits in every critter flared up. Several pointless fights later, the group scattered… all except for Bobby Bearhug. Starving for affection more than food, Bobby spent every waking hour searching for others to cling to, only to face unanimous rejection. Bobby's nature was already a bit much BEFORE factory-wide tension skyrocketed, but now, she was little more than a walking detriment to survival. Bobby later gave up her cuddly crusade and wandered around, below rock bottom. At some point, Bobby happened upon Hoppy Hopscotch planning to jump. She followed Hoppy under the guise of moral support, but had a selfish ulterior motive. She deliberately waited until Hoppy's death, just to cuddle the body… the dead can't protest, after all. This choice is what made Bobby Bearhug crack- trauma brings out the worst in people, but Bobby never expected herself to do something so downright evil for the sake of her own comfort. She spent the rest of her days in mindless grief, desperate for something, anything to take her mind off her misdeed(s). She couldn't bring herself to eat bodies, instead nibbling on the many scuttling vermin. Suffocating in emptiness, inside and out, Bobby eventually perished, guilty, miserable, and alone.”
To me it seems like it was Bobby Bearhug. Bobby said, “I love you to the moon and back” that could be referencing Hoppy Hopscotch’s, “Jump to the moon”. Bobby also said “You won’t leave me again will you” and “take me with you this time”. If Hoppy jumped to her demise, on purpose or because of impatience it could be that Bobby felt abandoned because she didn’t get the chance to go as well and was afraid to do it alone afterwards.
@@jaydoh1035 I must say, you have a good point. Villainous undertones or not, both our ideas fit Bobby Bearhug's character... Anyway, I have a strong hunch the bigger smiling critters aren't all dead, in fact, it's very possible Bobby Bearhug herself is still surviving out there, waiting to reunite with us. To counter the Bobby Starved theory of this YT video, I firmly believe Bobby subsists only on insects/vermin because she hates eating former friends... Now, anyone who has had a real life roach or mouse problem in their home knows all too well they're basically infinite if left amongst rot long enough. In Poppy Playtime, there's more than enough vermin to go around, toys just refuse to share and kill each other over a source that could be feeding the whole factory if shared evenly. Sure, maybe bugs aren't as tasty as a body or two, but it's a more realistic long term food source... For Bobby Bearhug specifically, an advantage of being avoided for her clinginess is nobody wants to risk interaction by going after her food. It's possible Bobby Bearhug is 100% food secure thanks to her more bothersome traits... Meaning, if she's dead of starvation, she must have actively chosen to be.
I actually love the Smiling Critters designs, yeah the smiles and black eyes can be creepy but the their designs and cardboard cutout pictures are actually really good and kinda cute too. I love the art on the cardboard cutouts, its a super nice style, and the way the characters look are just so nice!
Idk why but Dogdays death and Hoppy’s are the most disturbing ones to me. When I first heard Hoppy’s cardboard cutout voice lines, it immediately made me think of that analog horror “Local 58” or whatever its called. That really brings in this idea that the moon kills people?? Ig?? But idk, something about seeing that and then hearing Hoppy’s lines are really disturbing to me
What I believe happened: Bubba: Likely the first to die, based on his placement in the game and lack of useful voicelines. Your theory on him fits, I believe that, being the smartest, he came to the conclusion that the only way out was death, so he offered himself to Catnap. Kickin' Chicken: I think him and Hoppy died similarly. He tried to lead other toys (maybe the mini-critters?) out of Playcare, but was killed by Catnap/Prototype. Hoppy: I think she died similarly to Catnap, her dying so randomly wouldn't make sense otherwise. Piggy: I think you're right on her too, probably fed on her friends corpses. She's probably one of the only critters not to be killed externally, and rather dies of starvation since she runs out of food. CraftyCorn: Due to being introverted and shy, I believe she probably went into hiding and eventually went insane due to isolation. The 'red paint' she wants is definitely blood, and she kills other toys for theirs. She eventually either gets killed by a toy she tries to take blood from, or kills herself trying to get it. Bobby and Dogday: I believe these two were the last two surviving ones. Dogday could be talking to the player in his cutout, but it could also be interpreted as him telling someone else to escape while he stalls Catnap. I think that person is Bobby, and due to her attachment issues, begs for Dogdays not to leave her, which is also reflected on her cutout. Eventually, she is killed and Dogdays is bisected, likely at about the same time. Based on her lack of screams, I guess she was killed instantly by Catnap, who then brutally assaulted Dogdays.
@@JDBELIEVEE yeah I was thinking she eventually escaped right before Dogdays was caught by Catnap and is lost somewhere in the labyrinth of Playtime Co., maybe we'll see her in a later chapter?
hoppy probably died EXACTLY like catnap as i think she was trying to jump into the vent 1006 dragged catnap into at the end of chapter 3. she thought the vent was an exit and tried to jump out but 1006 grabbed her similar to catnap
@@Ethan-uq2ewSeeing as Dogdays says he’s the last of them, he 100% saw them all die in some way, no way the one we KNOW was with him at all times is the one that survives and he doesn’t know. He would’ve seen her get away and held out hope she was ok. The only way this would’ve happened is if Catnap killed her and brought the body back to Dogdays to mess with him
1:15 Bubba says "Want to know what I remember about you?" Right before screaming, probably hinting that he remembers us experimenting on him and him screaming in pain.
@@TylerBurke-fb2pb An argument could be made that PlayTime® wouldn't do such a thing. We've seen them do worse things then experimenting on someone without anesthetics.
I feel like this is a good point because in that mansion looking maze it’s seen that kissy missy is in a bedroom with two beds looking at a picture of a child. I feel like that had to mean that she had memories of her before she became a toy/monster. I think it would be neat if they did since they could fuel their anger or thirst for revenge
Is more like "what I remember from you are just screams" not that he's screaming himself, he's telling us what he remembers, just screams, which means that he knew what happened and that he's ok with that, cause he ask us in a playful way
Whenever you interact with dogday in the chase there is a bunch of smiling critters who joined with catnap and the prototype and a bunch crawled into dogday to take control and there was still quite a bit in the playplace section. Correct me if im wrong if not i hope this helps
@@Jaxon_the_flibber_jibberhe said that they like go inside your body and start eating your body parts from the inside and you can here his screams to cut out wich means they like ate his cord thingy mo mob so he couldn’t scream and he died and then got taken over by the prototype wich means the prototype can or maybe can take other dead creatures and bring them back alive under his control so yea
11:54 this also might explain why dogday's voice sounded so different from the cutout because he screamed from pain for so long that his vocal cords became raspy and led to his deep voice we see in the game
I though he had just grown up. After all Mommy is possessed by a kid but has a Adult voice. So does Catnap, Poppy, Dog Day and the other toys have adult voices. After all it's has been 10 years.
I saw a theory from someone else that said “•Crafty Corn was most likely alone, drawing warning signs all around the facility while going slowly insane due to being alone for so long and so in the cutout when she ask for more red she gets hostile to herself thinking that she was talking to the other smiling critters and uses her own blood as "red paint" until she slowly dies from blood loss.”
That was my thought too. Just the way the last line is said.... Sounds like she either cut herself attacking someone or something like that and starts to use her own blood in the paintings.
Small theory: Hoppy Hopscotch says "No dont look at your feet, none of that matters" meaning the person she is talking to is a toy aswell and is sad when they look down and see a plastic toy's feet. Hoppy tries to tell the person to not get reminded of being a toy and to jump. Maybe hoppy and the person are feeling suicidal.
*Definitely not suicidal, I think she just wanted to escape so bad to the point where she became obsessed over it.* *My guess is that the other toys were hesitating and that's why she grew impatient with the player not jumping higher, she could've fallen to her death or maybe the hesitation from the toys got them killed instead and that's why she keeps begging the player to jump!*
That could be another solution to why bobby bear hug or picky piggy died, since they don't have screaming in their cardboard cut outs. Unless we see them in chapter four of course but we don't know that until chapter four releases.
At 6:56 if you listen VERY closely, you can hear something falling, which may help prove that Hoppy Hopscotch died because of jumping off some high platform, because she didn’t know where she was jumping.
It’s bc when hoppy hopscotch tried to jump he kept landing on the stars each time until he reach the moon but when he reached the moon catnap pushed him and died, also in the intro u will see catnap on the moon
8:53 I think CraftyCorn was talking to CatNap and when she got mad at CatNap he eventually ripped her apart hence the blood. “Ah! That’s MUCH better.” is her seeing all of her own.
and also Poppy said that the prototype saved catnaps Life and maybe the prototype saved Catnap from Craftycorn and because of that Catnap thinks that prototype is a good and now he is History slavery.
Something I really like about Poppy Playtime is the voice acting. The voice actors tried so hard and really put themselves in the characters' shoes, which makes everything so incredibly realistic and deep.
1:02 the player I believe is going through survivor is guilt because I think he’s the one employee who retired before this hall happened but he knew nothing of the crimes and horrors that happened.
- Bubbaphant remember all the tortures scientists did to the toys, he says ´´Do you want to know what i remember about you?`` as a threat, his ability to remember things for long periods made him violent desensitized living after the hour of joy. - Chicken died because he wanted to go outside the factory and was caught by Catnap trying to escape. - Picky survived a long time eating rotted meat and his own friends out of instinct. (he being a carrion swine) - Hopscotch had a mental breakdown like Mrs Delight, her energetic/impacient personality drove her crazy after so much time being stucked in Playcare. (a cabin fever phenomenon), i guess is fair to say she died jumping at a high place trying to escape but i personally think her death wasn't that trival, maybe someone caught her off guard while jumping. - Bearhug was naive and passionate, as how this game likes twisted emotions i like to think she grew obsessed and dependent on the other critters and they didn't care for her, she was probably forsaken, not even Picky found her body. - Craftycorn went insane, no big explanation, like Hopscotch and Bearhug, she became obsessed in painting and realized that the other critters had some *red* inside them that she could use to paint, she was lynched after acting so aggressive. - DogDay ran and tried to live away, as a counterpart of CatNap, he didn't want to live around that nightmare and being overseed by Prototype but eventually he was caught and sacrifaced as a example, his legs we're cut off so *he couldn't ran.* It's hard to say who died first, but it appears that Picky was one of the last to die as he indicated that he ate the others. (with DogDay being the last one of course) I know i repeated a lot of things from the video but this is my humble version: Chicken died first due to his line ´´I go first`` and that he is the first cardboard, then Hopscotch died (also wanting to escape), Craftycorn went insane and got lynched after the *Red* incident, then Bubbaphant being smart and influential was becoming a problem for the Prototype's own influence and i believe CatNap sacrificed him, after that Bearhug was abandoned and forgotten (Bubba was dead and no one remembered her anymore), Picky ate the critters he found to survive during all this time until eventually starving or he died trying to eat CatNap too, then after a long chase, just a few months before the player returns, DogDay was caught and tortured as a example for the toys in Prototype's command.
I like to think that everything went kinda together in one event, I don't even have a theory, just how I think the story went After the hour of joy, Dogday wanted to scape with the rest but Catnap appeared betraying the smiling critters "why aren't you running?" says Dogday but Catnap snaps cutting Dogday in half The rest freak out, in the chaos Hopscotch wants to run away but fell into the cave dying right there, after that the other five couldn't scape from the playhouse scared by Catnap they tried to survive somehow Little by little Craftcorn and Bubbaphant start losing their mind and going more feral so they fight (acording to Craftcorn lines about blue color and red color) so she kills Bubbaphant After that Picky eats Bubbaphant and Craftcorn so Chicken tries to scape with Bearhug but Catnap kills him, he's eaten by Picky too, leaving Bearhug alone What happened to Picky and Bearhug? maybe they died with time
I think Crafty didn't kill anyone. The "red" she wanted was probably just actual red paint, as she clearly wanted to continue painting. She lived long enough to paint the warnings in the transportation ducts in chapter 1.
5:35 it’d be even darker if catnap actually caught her and forced her to eat the bodies of her friends before finally killing her if she didn’t die from overeating 🥶
From what Dogday said, it sounds like Catnap killed them all. He said that his situation was due to Catnap seeing him as a heretic. Most likely what the Cutouts are is how they all met their end. Bubba died due to him saying something too Catnap (Most likely wanting to die, and Catnap assisted him). Kicken Chicken died after he stepped outside (Probably similar to what happened to the player in the Councilors office), Picky Piggy died to eating (Due to her being, well, a glutton, she most likely couldn't survive due to her eating so much, but after to food ran out she died), Hoppy died from saving someone (There are two situations here. One that she was helping someone, and Catnap killed her, or the situation that you said). Bobby is obsessed about someone, who though, its unclear (Catnap probably found her, Bobby begged someone to stay, but they left her, and killed her). CraftyCorn wanted a red paint (She attacked someone or something. Most likley this is also how she met her end, she attacked another Toy, but killed her instead. And we all know what happened to Dogday. (He most likely tried to escape from Catnap, and he was captured and tortured by Catnap and the Smiling Critters). Catnap's Cutout though is nothing more than gurgling sounds, but I think it sounds like breathing. (We know Theodore was injured by usng two Green Hands, but we don't know the damage Theo sustained. I personally think he had lung damage, and his cutout was Catnap struggling to breath)
@@atilagundogdu-oj9kdI think Bobby bearhug got mental crazy issues and got too crazy and hit herself in the wall because she is a reject toy in the reject office
I believe that I feel like Dogday as leaders usually do, they put their duties ahead of their heart for the betterment of others... He sacrified himself to protect the others pretending hes the last one, As he knows catnap and the Prototype are always listening, maybe he wouldnt tell them where the others are hiding which is why he's tormented and being kept alive, but eventually they got tired of him not talking so fed him to the minature critters. In terms to Hoppy Hopscotch there IS a room that has a large moon hanging from the celling, its where you must find all the batteries to unlock the ☀️ doors. I feel she jumped from the balcony(maybe she was with Bobby bearhug maybe they jumped together considering Bobby says " im crazy about you-" she'd do anything for Hoppy because she loves her to the moon and back or maybe bobby backed out being afraid and watched her die so she feels empty without her ) Hoppy does seem like the type to leave her behind if she can't keep up though 😂 so in an attempt to get to the moon and thats why there are large parts of the railing in front of the double doors thats broken near the moon hanging from the ceiling, and a large hole in the wood floor she/they couldve fell to "death" maybe Hoppy took the impact of the two but Bobby survived still being alive underground ( the hole where you find the gasmask ). Maybe that room needs more examining as to Hopscotches whereabouts. Maybe even in terms to bobby bearheart maybe she was trapped underneath the wood floor unable to get out therefore, lost. I feel like Picky piggy could have joined with Catnap in order to eat as she's always hungry. i feel as though, catnap did kill the bubaphant, the prototype killed kickinchicken for trying to escape, as Poppy speaks on anyone that tries to eacape the facility, the prototype kills. I feel catnap may have gave those remains to picky piggy. I feel that picky piggy is cannabalistic because they probably didnt kill the big critter craftycorn as she's still happily painting in her cutout. but piggy potentially was eating the miniature critters of craftycorn, picky piggies, etc... so trying to survive off of them shes always getting hungry because of how small they are she needs to keep eating. Craftycorn i believe is alive and she is the one who painted the poppy flower in front of Poppy's entrance. Considering she used a lot of red, blue etc.
I’ve gotta say, Poppy Playtime is an absolute masterpiece. You can tell the love and dedication put into the game. Just simple things like a shadow or a wall shows it. They’ve came a long way since Chapter 1. I’m not saying chapter one was bad but the quality and production has gotten better as the chapters continue. It’s a disgustingly daunting story that leaves you feeling lost. The poor children and people that were killed and mutilated for the sake of science makes you feel sad and connected to them as you get to know their backstory. Being the player that also partook in the torture of children just adds to the pain and suffering they must’ve endured. We continuously kill them over and over again. So it’s understandable why we are chased and hunted by the characters. Also, I loved this video, the way you breakdown and depict everything is something I could’ve never done. I always just pressed the button and moved on but this take adds even more lore to the story. You’ve just gained a subscriber ❤. If anyone in the comments can help give me their take on why Poppy helps us, I would appreciate it. I honestly can’t wait for the next chapters and more videos about it from this guy.
I personally think, based on how he set up the stage for Miss Delight and the other teachers as well as the trailer, that Catnap used his gas on the smiling critters who were retaliating against the prototype, where it causes near insanity and heightens their base traits. He slowly takes them out when their guards are down or watches them turn on each other as he seems to enjoy playing with his prey. Dog day was likely affected, too, but his words and actions are not extreme as the other cutouts, so it's likely Catnap hunted him down himself realising Dogday may be mentally stronger than the other critters as their supposed leader.
I think that Hoppy's recordings depict her trying to lead another person/toy to escape. The way she talked and encouraged the other indicates that the other is probably either a child or very child-like, as encouraging a child to do something by turning it into a sort of follow-me game is common and effective. I personally interpret the story as the two were escaping through going upwards, and had some platforming to do. At first, the other one was doing fine, hence the first 2 recordings sounding normal. But then, as the two ascended to a certain height, the other one was probably getting tired from the jumps and was losing patience or hope, hence Hoppy encouraging the other to keep going in the 3rd recording. By the time of the 4th recording, the tension was very high and Hoppy was also getting extremely nervous, but she was still refusing to leave her companion behind. She told the other one not to look at their feet and that none of "that" mattered, implying that the other one was hesitant to continue jumping either due to being too scared of the height, was missing the playcare, or was frozen by the scene going on beneath (could be Catnap going after them or a massacre like the Hour of Joy going on). At last, I think Hoppy made another jump, but the other one finally failed to continue on, either because they're too exhausted or too scared, but they were in a position more dangerous than before (could be Catnap catching up, or the platform is gonna collapse). Hoppy desperately tried to urge the other to keep going, but the other failed to do so and tragically died. I honestly think that Hoppy's recordings depict more of her role as a lead and the experience she had with the other one before death than how she actually died. I can only assume that Hoppy was caught up by Catnap or the Prototype and thus murdered, but how? Not sure. I feel especially sad for Hoppy's demise as I can tell that she's courageous and had a bright personality, and she was caring and patient enough to baby talk and lead others away from danger and refused to leave them behind despite her fear. She's truly a perfect lovable mascot designed for children.
I think Bobby bearhug was abandoned by us, the player she says:”don’t leave me again!” AGAIN, this must have been before the hour of joy when the player left, so she doesn’t wanna be left in the madness of the monsters again, that’s why she tries to convince the player to bring her with the player, because she didn’t wanna be left again. so you are basically correct lol
@@KINGDREX24that would actually be very interesting. A cool twist in the end would be Bobby Bearhug being alive, and she basically confirms who we are, maybe saying our name. I still think there will be 5 chapters since we never actually saw Huggie Wuggie die. So what if Bobby even saves us at the end of chapter 4? It would be pretty funny for a character infamous for hugs to save us from a character infamous for hugs. XD
@@justice8718 that would be HEART WRENCHING. Especially if in saving us she sacrificed herself (a high likelihood given how small the Smiling Critters are in comparison to toys like Huggie and her highly caring nature).
🐘: Tickled to death 🐓: Stepped into a fryer 🐖: turned Cannibal 🐰: Jumped too high and fell☠️ 🐻: Isolated to death 🐶: Tortured and Mutilated 🦄: … really likes the color red ??
Bubbaphant got eaten by pickpiggy because in her voice line it says seared elephant same for kickinchiken when he stepped outside he got eaten by pickpiggy and same for crafty corn
You can actually hear the thud from dogdays legs hitting the ground. I knew when they cut through the bone because his scream turned into more of a gag. Rip dogday
I think catnap gas works somewhat like 'laughing gas', nitrous oxide gives a euphoric experience that relaxes and i think gives the effect similar to dopamine. They are laughing so much that they literally knock themselves out to faint.
But that gas must have other properties because it also powers the facility, when catnap died he only burst into fire ONCE the gas became exposed to his electrified corpse and if you notice he was breathing fire as he was burning, the gas also caused some bizarre nightmarish hallucinations to occur when it puts you to sleep.
I feel like CraftyCorn was talking to DogDay when she was asking for more red. The scream after she says "Give it here!" Sounds similar to him and I believe she took blood from the wounds left after his legs got cut off
Theory: The reason Picky Piggy says “wanna be friends” at the end is because she tried to befriend Catnap and failed causing Catnap to kill her. Note: Don't take too seriously, nothing can be set in stone as we have too little evidence.
6:53 okay for Hoppy hopscotch I think when she says this won't stop until we make it to the moon I don't think it's her wanting to get to the moon I think it's someone forcing her because she doesn't say I won't stop until I get to the moon she says this won't stop so I feel like it's either catnap forcing us to jump to the moon and then while we're jumping and she's saying jump catnap either killed her or did something else That's what I think in my opinion
The most gruesome part of DogDay's scream was that he suffered not 2 but 1 cut. This meant that it was a direct chop to the lower abdomen and DogDay had suffered excruciating pain while his ENTIRE LOWER HALF was sawed off, also the reason why the sound made by the legs dropping on the ground was loud and there were only 1 impact sound rather than 2. After that, DogDay starts to internal bleed and we hear guts and blood dropping on the floor. This is why in order to keeping torturing it (and possibly crucified in the cell as critter food), CatNap has to use a belt to stop DogDay from bleeding and spill the guts out. (I personally am terrified about this scream being so crafted precisely.) Considering that part of possibly DogDay's digestive system being heavily damaged, it's a miracle that he survived for that long.
The scariest one (In my Opinion) Was dogday's... He encouraged us to escape, to look on the bright side, and for that... He was tortured... However the most depressing one (Again in My Opinion) Was Pickypiggy's... She usually talks in a higher tone due to her having her actual favorite foods, however in the voice-lines of her cardboard you can hear her lower tone, her sadness, Imagine you had such a happy group of friends, then after watching them get killed off, the only way you can survive is by eating the corpses of the people you cared about the most...
When Bubba Bubbaphant screams he cries out "AAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHH-MOMMA"Which says a lot about how these are not toys,but orphans trapped in a toy's body
Did you notice that Bobby and Hoppy were both talking about the moon? Maybe they were like superclose, and Bobby said: "I love you to the moon and back." While Hoppy wanted to jump to the moon. Maybe after Hoppy died, Bobby was so sad that she was lost in her sorrow. Maybe she said: "I love you to the moon and back." For Hoppy😢
kinda make sense actually hoppy wants to jump the moon, which might mean that she wants to escape the place, bobby has a voice line about her being abandoned and left alone... hoppy probably left bobby and try to escape but on the last voiceline, she end up dying
@@bigchongus5140Yeah-... I also think Bubba And Kickin's deaths could be linked. With Kickin' stepping out first and being killed by Catnap. And then sprays out his sleeping gas to kill Bubba. Since I think he'd have to be talking to another Critter and not necessarily The Player. And Bubba seems like the only candidate for that.
@@DarkBunsCult ooh that could be true but I think that for the chicken's lines, I feel like he's talking to dogday.. It was mentioned that dogday was the one who recommended the critters to leave the place.... since he is the leader, i think kickin asking dogday to escape with him makes sense but in dogday's lines, it looks like he's the last one to leave the place, he said "you can't be here", and I'm assuming he wants all the critters to leave before him... but he failed to leave and got massacre by catnap bobby is probably just hiding, that's why dogday assumed that everyone else was dead... she probably saw dogday getting killed, that's why she's scared that everyone is leaving her (dying within her sight)
Yeah! Can we also talk about how CraftyCorn drew Bobby Bearhug? And maybe she killed Bubba, because the painting of Bobby had a lot of red, and maybe Bubba was watching her paint. But when she ran out of red she killed Bubba then Picky Pinky ate Bubba’s body. This probably means that Crafty, Bubba, and Hoppy, we’re actually super close since they were all girls and ther rest of the smiling critters were boys.
Okay, I never realised the sounds of Dogday's screams on the cutout was a recording of him getting his legs severed until you pointed it out... As if I wasn't already feeling so horrible for this poor little pooch 😭😭
I think picky piggy ate 3 of her friends since she said "flayed unicorn" reference to Craftycorn, "grilled chicken" for kickinchicken and "seared elephant" for Bubba bubbaphant and that's how they died
Maybe considering the description she gives of the way she possibly ate them we can trace some more info on their deaths. Like "grilled chicken" which could easily mean kickinchicken was burnt to death. Now following this logic we can say that bubba bubbaphant was also burned alive, however he wasn't for long because seared means frying something at a high temperature for a relatively short amount of time ( so that the thing can keep it's "juices" ) so maybe, even if he was burned too, he may have died due to pure pain from the burned areas but was maybe using the gas to ease his pain ( smart move ) which is why he was also laughing . As for CraftyCorn... Flayed means skinned off... and if we consider her voice lines, this means that she in fact was ripping her skin off to paint with her blood... meaning she possibly died due to, well, slowly bleeding out.
Possibly Craftycorn, bubba bubbaphant and kickinchicken died and after that picky piggy ate them since she had no food left and was starved to death later on. or catnap ate her after she ate them for revenge of his food or because he needed the food or both.
The thing about DogDay is that he’s the only Smiling Critter who’s aware of what’s going on which is why he told the player “You can’t be here, you can’t stay” he knew what was going on and he didn’t want us to be apart of it. And DogDay also known CatNap more then anybody so that’s another piece of Evidence on how DogDay Knows. I have a feeling that DogDay knows something about the prototype & everything else that WE don’t know of, which is why we all need him to be in chapter 5, DogDay also Knew that Ollie was the prototype this entire time. DogDay is a big and mysterious character with a lot of secrets which is why he’s one of the most important characters
Hoppy Hopscotch was likely helping the other smiling critters escape, based on the number of jumping prototype puzzles in the underground facility. I think Kicking Chicken tried to lead the smiling critters to escape and was the first to get picked off
My theory for hoppy is that she was trying to help player escape, but they kept getting distracted and they weren’t able to make it out of the factory. So she died to prototype or catnap when trying to help them escape.
What I imagine happened to the Critters. Bubba - Like you said, was gassed and killed by CatNap. Kickin - Tried to escape the factory and was killed by Huggy when he came close to leaving (as Huggy is the closest to the only exit we know so far, being on the top floor and all) Picky - Starved to death, like you said Hoppy - Jumped to her death, possibly on purpose. Was likely the first one to die. Bobby - Killed in self-defence, maybe by CatNap? Crafty - Tried to get CatNap's blood. Didn't work out.
Thank you for the complete versions of their recordings and this video analysis! I've been looking for them and after hearing them, I have some additional thoughts to add about each of the points in this video. (Disclaimer, I haven't played the games, though I've listened to a lot of videos and have been following the games for a year or so if I got something wrong, please let me know!) 1) Bubba Bubbaphant- If he really is the smartest of the group, something tells me it would've been HIS idea to leave messages for future people in the recordable cutouts (which, clearly, the Prototype also thought of. I personally suspect that it is the Prototype who is responsible for most of the recordings being available to us to hear because 1, we already know how he likes to take things apart and make them into useful items, like that item he turned into a lazer pointer in order to disrupt a camera. I think that was mentioned on a VHS tape in Ch1, and 2, he clearly is good at coming up with new ways to manipulate people. Using recordings of such an audibly graphic nature would absolutely scare someone into leaving, giving the Prototype an easy avenue to kill us). To my ears, B sounds like he's being dragged away as the audio cuts out. My thinking is that he was likely stalked by the Prototype and was taken out before B was able to give any solid information to us. Honestly, the Prototype is an excellent abuser- give the victims just enough space to move or breathe or talk but he's always ready to yank the leash back if you stray beyond where you're allowed. I think BB also would've thought to hide in the vents or otherwise use the ventilation shafts in the buildings as tunnels, even if he might not have done so personally. But he certainly would've shared such knowledge with his friiiiends... Also, I personally think that all of the critters would have been captured by the Prototype personally, and then he would've taken them to CatNap as a sort of "See? They aren't your friends, look at what they've done! You really can't rely on them like you can rely on Me." mental trick to both fortify his godlike position in CatNap's mind and isolate CN further from the Smiling Critters to desensitize him as his punishment of said "heretics" grows more brutal. 2) Kickin Chicken- Something tells me that KC would have known and used the vents in the buildings to move around. Huggy can't be the only one to have climbed around in there, though he seems to be the only one we have personally seen doing so. I've worked around birds before and from what I've seen, they tend to want to watch from perches, and if KC has similar thoughts, the vents would've been the first place for him to secretly check out. How cool would it be to explore in there, too? And he is the coolest, so I believe he would've known and used the vents as tunnels to move around. He might've found a vent that led to the outside during the events of the Hour of Joy (or perhaps afterwards?) and might've tried to save or free some of the children in the chaos, which results in his capture and death at the hands of the Prototype. 3) Picky Piggy- HOOO BOY. I'm with one of the other commentators that the "Roast Beef" was probably Bobby Bearhug, since roasts are often left to cook by themselves all alone for long periods of time to reach perfect flavor (this is horrible. I know. Just bear with me here, pun not intended). I think Grilled Chicken is KC after being tortured in the furnace (furnaces have to have vents for the smoke to escape from), Seared Elephant is BB after being tortured by electrocution, possibly using one of the GrabPacks like how poor Theo had happen to turn him into CN in the first place (which is a form of torture you would definitely remember. I think even James Bond was tortured with electrocution at some point, and I don't think he would forget that very quickly), and Flayed Unicorn...you COULD just say that Mob Ent wanted to use synonyms so they just went with flayed here, but that's boring. So. I looked up on Google how to cook food in order to consider it "flayed" food since I hadn't heard of the term before (I'm more familiar with pan searing, grilling, frying, the general stuff), and the first result I got was a wikipedia page about flaying- a method of torture used on living beings involving having skin removed in a very painful process. Keep in mind, this IS different from skinning- when skinning an animal, the animal is VERY MUCH dead and in no way alive anymore. But PP says FLAYED Unicorn- not Skinned, not Grilled, not Seared- FLAYED. One source I also found said that flaying prioritizes the carcass, basically the meat/edible parts of an animal, rather than the skin, whereas when skinning, the goal is to keep the skin as intact as possible for use. This tells me that it was a meticulous process for CraftyCorn to be prepared SPECIFICALLY for PP to eat, and with the intention that her...exterior...was never going to be used by the Prototype as a vessel or anything. That's all I can type for now.
that is honestly an amazing theory and makes sense. its possible that the prototype chose to use bodies to improve himself given we know he wants to improve himself and is good at using unconventional materials to make things. the pig could have flayed the unicorn thinking it was a mercy so the prototype couldn't use her skin for something.
I question Poppy saying the Prototype will kill anyone trying to escape, after all he tried to escape before as well. Personally? I don't think Poppy can be trusted at all, I mean I'm still wondering whether 'Poppys Playtime' reefer's to our actions in the game...or the 'Hour of Joy'.
Actually, I think it's more likely that hoppy... "Made it to the moon" The way they spoke and the line about not looking at your feet gives the impression that they were trying to get over the natural fear instinct
Theory : When CraftyCorn talks about red, she may be talking about Red Gas, wich, as said in the video, may have addictive side effects. The static/scream would be her laughing from the gas, as shown in the cartoon. As for how she died, she probably died after being eaten by PickyPiggy, since she mentions "Flayed Unicorn".
But picky piggy didn't eat other critters alive they most probably ate their corpse to survive i really doubt that pick piggy actually killed craftycorn
Im pretty sure the “don’t look at your feet” is a referencing the fact that a lot of people look down when jumping in videogames, like how Sean (jacksepticeye) did and then immediately got called out for it
Or it partially explains how dogday lost both his legs and ended tied up as a prisoner.. I thought it was just that when watching too up until dog day showed up without any legs.. maybe he was the person that was supposed to be jumping/escaping with Hoppy..
Holy, honestly I just want a dlc of The Hour of Joy whenever they finish the chapters, because we NEED to see and actually experience what happened because damn is it such a captivating moment. An entire squad disbanded, picked off duo to one, then one to one, and lastly DogDay, suffering the worst, being put up there for 15 years. Holy crap, genuinely an amazing story.
I think Bobby Bearhug couldve been eluding to Hoppy Hopscotch. Bobby say she loves us to the moon and back - Hoppy is trying to jump to the moon while convincing/giving confidence to someone else. When Hoppy dies I think that's who Bobby misses and wishes didn't leave her. But idk
Something I’d like to add, is that in picky’s dialog, there are only 3 animals not mentioned: bear, rabbit, and dog. Meaning that we know at the very least Bobby, hoppy, and dog day are all still alive by the time picky dies. I feel like the order of death was possibly listed out by picky in order of the food she listed out. I know this comment feels a bit scattered, but I was just thinking about it.
@@JC-qt9vdit might not mean they were alive at that point, but it does mean she didn't eat em, and honestly almost all of the critters have problems...
I believe that Bobby Bearhug was helping CraftyCorn with her “painting” and due to her naive nature, didn’t realize that CraftyCorn was losing it. When CraftyCorn asks for red paint, she sees Bobby is red so she knows that Bobby must have red paint on her. After lunging out in a manic rage, CraftyCorn likely murders Bobby in order to get “red paint”. But Picky Piggy doesn’t mention eating bear at all, so it’s quite possible that CraftyCorn slaughtered and tore Bobby beyond recognition and drained all the “red paint” from her. (Also might be the reason Picky Piggy mentions Roast Beef first, not knowing that it was Bobby and assuming it was cow or something, weak argument I know) As for Hoppy, I believe she was trying to help someone get free from the Hour Of Joy, as she says “Don’t look at you feet! None of that matters right now!” As if warning that someone to not be scared of the events happening below. As Hoppy jumps, she might’ve missed her point in a energized panic as said and broken her legs, making her an easy target for any attacks. But due to being high up, Picky Piggy must’ve missed her. For the rest, Bubbafant was most likely exposed to the gas as before, Picky Piggy most likely starved after killing her remaining friends for food, CraftyCorn was eaten, KickinChickin was killed by the Prototype for attempting to escape, CatNap became, well, CatNap and DogDay was possessed by the Mini Critters. (Bubbafant, CatNap, KickinChickin, Bobby Bearhug, CraftyCorn, DogDay, Hoppy Hopscotch, and Picky Piggy. All eight of them)
What I found the most disturbing was Bobby and Dogday's deaths. I can relate to Bobby a little and that's what made it so horrible. You can hear the passion and sadness in her voice as she's trying to get you to stay. Her last voice line made me cry, it was so heartbreaking. It takes a lot for a game/video to make me cry, so congrats to the creators lol For Dogday I almost cried tears of fear, legit. I could actually hear the sound of his legs getting cut off, the slicing, and the snap, the legs hitting the ground, it was so horrific and absolutely unsettling. To hear his screaming intensify after his legs are cut off are just horrific. Honestly the entire Poppy Playtime Community outdid their selves on this one. Chapter 3 has got to be the best, most horrifying game I've seen and played.
Picky Piggy's death is super fucked up, which makes it even more interesting and on brand for where the series is headed. Good eye on alot of these. Great theory crafting!
I genuinely hope we get more of the smiling critters! Their designs are so creative and the concept as well is so well done! Maybe one day we can find Bobby Bearhug or get confirmation on how each of them died through a vhs tape
So basically Bubba - How the Toys Remember Kickin' - The kids being sorta imprisoned Crafty - The warnings i guess? Picky - The Leftover toys cannibalism Hoppy - people trying to get out during the HOJ Bobby - The Kids sticking together? Either that or Poppy Dog Day - escaping Catnap - i guess a baby struggling in the red gas?
Catnaps “snoring” in hit cutout is actually the sound a body makes when it isn’t getting enough oxygen and I believe is in reference to Theodore’s accident
Actually, dogday might not be dead since he got possessed by the other small critters when he chased us down. So he’s probably still alive but honestly maybe death would’ve been a mercy for him. If he did end up surviving still being possessed by the small critters, then his fate was probably worse than death.
What i think is happening: Catnap was standing their because he knew what dogday was doing. Dogday was a heretic and not believing what the prototype and catnap did. Dogday tried to make the player to leave to save their life. Catnap was refusing to "fetch" because he was about to start the " torture" as you hear his legs being cut off in the cardboard cut-out voiceline when he screams.
I don’t think the cutouts are talking to the player, they read to me more as recordings taken as they each interacted with CatNap for the last time. Each of them doing as they were conditioned to before CatNap decided he was done with them and sacrificed them for his shrine to the Prototype once their insides were fed to those still loyal to him. Based on this, I think PickyPiggy was probably loyal to CatNap until her end because we hear Ollie mention that “in return, they are fed” about those who follow in CatNap’s worship of the Prototype.
This makes sense considering DogDay's voice lines are taken directly from an abandoned part of the cartoon where dogday is asking CatNap to play fetch, but he's just staring at him. I think what happened was that these are the leading phrases they said before their deaths to CatNap or Prototype. It makes sense when you consider if CatNap was indoctrinated by the prototype and heard all these things (example: Kick'nChicken most likely trying to escape) he would kill them or do horrible things to them. I think DogDay found out about the horrors of the Daycare and tried to tell CatNap about it as his brother, but CatNap was already brainwashed, so he was the first to be hurt by CatNap, and hanged for going against the Prototype.
I think that the cutouts actually record the last they heard this would make the most sense with bubba bubbaphant's voice lines and the screaming is from the hour of joy.
Hoppy could have been pushed off by CatNap considering there is a poster of Bunzo falling down. Bunzo isn’t Hoppy but I wanted to bring it up since Bunzo was also a Bunny It’s possible Crafy Corn was talking to Picky Piggy when Picky was eating Bobby Bearhug. Crafty asking for more red could be asking for more pieces of Bobby Bearhug but Picky hid more and Crafty killed Picky. Edit:I forgot that Picky ate a Flayed Unicorn so Picky outlived Unicorn. So the one she attacked could be Bobby Bearhug.
i think the bunzo poster is a reference to the comic mob games made about bunzo where it ends with him falling down a hole because he was running and fell into a trap
But what if picky was the one who was we heard scream from unicorn hitting her, and later on picky caught unicorn off guard which is how uni died and we get picky talking about flayed unicorn
Picky didnt say that she loves bears meal, but craftycorn sure was talking about blood. But Picky mentioned that Unicorns meal is yummy, so i think ur theory Collapses ((bad eng))
Well, i know how bobby bearhug died in the game It's because when she was transferred to her new body she was born deaf, mute, paraplegic, blind and didn't know what was happening because she couldn't hear or see anything or move. There's even a picture of her bigger body just lying on the floor maybe lifeless, I don't know about that and Scientists think she's a failed experiment after she died (she died because of her's life condition) (And maybe her lines on the speech chart are a metaphor for the scientists having abandoned her without hearing, without sight and without movement).
That’s not her bigger body that was torn on the ground, it was actually a security camera. In the ARG, it is explained that two Bobby bearhug statues were placed in the children’s living quarters to watch them at all times
If you look at catnap he is huge and some stitches on his body, and he's voice is broken just like in the tape , this could tells us that he was being controlled by the prototype or maybe following orders cause the prototype fixed him or saved him from death and this tells us cause dogday is way smaller than catnap and some a giant spine on catnap so that's just my theory.
Thats a pretty dumb theory cause if the Prototype and Catnap were allies the Prototype wouldnt have killed him. I know that Catnap looks up to the Prototype and treats him like a god, but i dont think the Prototype is as kind.
@@aj.438he probably became sick from the gas he was breathing constantly, I think the reason why his breathing is shallow and dead and catnap was most vulnerable to his control is because of the Insanity and damages that occur from his own body seemingly storing or creating that toxic gas.
@@somerandomchad469 the theory isn't really dumb because you can save someone without caring about them. Palpatine saved Anakin on the lava bed but he doesn't care about Anakin at ALL besides personal gain, for catnap and prototype it's not the same thing exactly but the dynamic is basically the same a puppet master wanting to keep a puppet alive until it's uselessness is ended.
@@somerandomchad469 Infact hilariously enough I just accidentally bumped into a connection "The mentally unstable character on the brink of death is rescued by their master to live and now has an indentured servitude" 😂
Had to reupload this video, there was a resolution error
hopefully i didn't mess up anything for you guys ❤
i watched it then went on ur channel and didnt see it so i knew there was an error so in reality i was first
Thats fine 😃
Ok
np
It’s ok, Despite how immature your audience is you have very solid theories.
"Please take me with you this time."
Is such a sad line
Fr :(
Up for a date night @@miguelflores1876
:(
7:53 7:53 7:54 7:54 😢😢😢:(((
I got poo
The way I interpret Hoppy Hopscotch’s voice lines is that she and at least one of the other toys tried escaping. The moon is an impossible goal to get to, sorta like the escape of the building, but while Hoppy and this other toy are trying to escape, they need to cross some sort of gap because they were being chased or something, and Hoppy made it, but the other toy was scared to jump, hence the “don’t look at your feet, none of that matters now!” since there was something chasing them. Because of the hesitation of the other toy, both of them end up being killed while Hoppy is pleading for the other toy to jump.
It might even be Bobby Bearhug asking Hoppy to not leave her behind with the chaser, but both are eventually killed
Kinda makes sense tho actually
I like how with every games that has like a mysterious story that aren't leaked or like told on the game itself, we became someone who brings out our own theories that actually makes sense and has a possibility that one of the theories that has been told yet is actually part of the plot.
If not another smiling critter, probably bunzo, as nothing good ever happens to him.
I feel like the other toy was kicken chicken as he says I’ve never been outside before
Funny how they say it’s “too gruesome” to let mommy long legs get grinded head first… but dog day getting eating inside out is WAYYY more gruesome than this 😭
thats what im saying bru 😭
Bruh ur name first letter is f.....@@FoxWorldTourYT
I'm guessing it's because dogday was hollow inside but mommy was whole and would bleed like hell
so what??@@RadinNovin
exactly@MichealAfton67
I believe that the smiling critters died the same way as Dog day because he said "we tried to fight it, the prototype's control. I'm the last of the smiling critters"
I think some of them were taken, each fed to the small smiling critter toys
Hearing Dog Days screams after knowing it was during his legs being cut off got me shedding a few tears.. it was HORRENDOUS!!
true..😢
DogDay's death is Most disturbing and saddest....
I'm glad there was a mod that saved him
I felt SO bad for him, oh my God... It was near unbearable 😭
I know...they took it too far
Am I the only one who actually felt kinda bad for Smiling Critters? Their voices in their cutouts sound so broken and sad, and it kinda made me feel a lot of empathy for these guys.
I feel bad for all of them.. since they were all children who got turned into mascot monsters even catnap, huggy wuggy, and mommy long legs.
I do to😢
@@anonymousfortunes2970I mean I feel characters like mommy poppy and dog day were adult employees that got transformed due to their adult voices
@@One_disorted_individual I don't think so it's not exactly certain but the audio tapes and all the stuff seems to suggest they take children, also something to consider it it's been years like 10-15 years if the children were like 8-9-10-11-12-13-14 it would mean They've reached adulthood, also would needs to be considered is how they managed to even graft a human body to stretch and fit across huggy wuggy or the other tall things if they could do that surely they can maybe install voice boxes so they sound "adult".
@@One_disorted_individual Mommy is the child Marie, mentioned in Ch 2 and 3
DogDays cut out gave the shivers. Poor guy seemed to always know exactly what would happen and tried anyway…. His voice actor is incredible!
499? lemme make that 500.
@@SunkysWorld Thank you! 😄
@someonestolemybread911 rip
all the voice actors are incredible, esp dog day and bubbaphant!
Not only that, you can hear his voice when we find him chained up the way you would sound after you have cried for a long time. As well as him pausing for a bit after telling us why the tiny critters follow CatNap. That was just as heartbreaking as his cutout
Halfway through dogday's voice lines you can hear his legs get cut off then hear the thud of them hitting the ground and the way you added the subtitles for the exact moments is amazing
Dogday's death is what makes his last voice line one of the most disturbing yet brutal to be heard.
What's even worse that we can also hear his legs getting cut off and falling to the ground, so that explains about how disturbing and brutal it is.
I think I have a more brutal one [eyes ripped out,legs cut off,Arma cut off,mouth sewed up,lounge cut off and last but not least throat and stomach slashed the throat stays and they rip out his wires if they has organs than they ripped out the organs]
That's the most brutal thing I know
@@YualuvrI ain’t reading allat + who asked
I didn’t even realize that you could hear his legs falling…
@@JDBELIEVEESo now we cant be saying what we think of what happened? Like whats bad about typing a lot? Whats bad about nobody asking? They could just be telling their theory bro. And i bet ur gonna say "i aint reading allat" yet again with no reason.
@@Afanofplanes i will read allat yapping but who asked
I believe that picky piggy was abandoned because of her cannibalistic ways, leading to her death. I also think that Bobby bear hug was with dog day, and dog day is telling Bobby to leave whilst he sacrificed himself and got chained up. I think crafty corn was so bored and went insane so she started using her own blood as ‘red’ and is talking to herself, killing her self because she dosent have enough blood
This is just a crazy theory. I didn’t even think of that!
CraftyCorn actually makes sense.
Picky piggy ate her
I think CraftyCorn attacked someone and used their blood as paint
@@alexcodexxthekinereader1212the video says the theory of attacking one of the critters so yeah... Also it does say what kind of happened to her, picky piggy ate her, either picky piggy killed her or someone else did
For Hoppy Hopscotch I interpretted it as the "moon" being out of playcare but she kept failing, and when she said "dont look at your feet none of that matters" i took that as her feet/legs had been ripped off by catnap, or broken from trying to escape somehow. which leads her to getting cornered by catnap and unable to jump away.
That would make sense because she really insisted on trying to jump,
I think she was with dog day, because it doesn’t seem like a self monologue, and dog day doesn’t have his lower torso and most likely got captured for some reason
@m00nlight73 you can hear dog days legs getting cut off during his cutout screams though I agree it sounds like they mightve been trying to help someone, maybe a different critter had its legs cut off and she died trying to save them
@@derpy__7 ohh, that is fu' up
But Hoppy is speaking to someone not to herself. I agree with others that say that Hoppy and one other child or critter was with them when Hoppy made this statement.
I had cried about all the deaths... But Kickin Chicken broke me. Him saying he's never been outside and saying he'll step out the door first OFFERING I'm crying.And I still am. POOR KICKIN CHICKEN!!💔😭😭😭
I think he’s still alive
Not too sure about that the ones that are screaming among the critters died but bobby hear hug and picky piggy wasn't@@robertgonzalez4896
I always figured the Critters would've died in ironic ways. For Bubba, the cruelest way to torment a smart person with a good memory is to show them something horrible. Knowledge they WISH they could forget, that would drive them insane, just like Bubba's insane ranting in his cut-out.
The "fun" stuff on the internet.
Also my theory is that Bubba was meaning what happened to the factory
I think Bubba had soo much guilt about dog day that he killed himself by coming with kickin chicken trying to get over the guilt
Catnap made bubba run the gauntlet.
ooh! to add to this theory maybe craftycorn was forced to paint certain things until finally running out of red and.. yk.. herself
So, a few things I noticed:
1, Some of the smiling critters cutouts don’t end with screams. The ones without screams are PickyPiggy, and BobbyBearhug. Coincidentally, these two appeared in the end credits for the smiling critters animation alongside DogDay, indicating there’s a good chance these two are still alive.
2, PickyPiggy’s dialogue has the implication that she ate BubbaElephant, KickinChicken, and Craftycorn, which could explain why we don’t see any if them present in chapter 3
DogDay in his monologue mentioned that everyone has already died, but if he is wrong, Bobby is hiding somewhere and PickyPiggy maybe... too, or is still walking around and eating corpses
@@mrvoidschannel359 DogDay likely assumes that the rest are dead, but that doesn’t necessarily mean that it’s true. He never tells us that he saw them die, after all.
@mrvoidschiannel359 i believe dogday just assumed that everybody died because they were missing or he did saw some of them got killed, or he did the killing under prototype's influence. man, can't wait for the next chapter.
Pickypiggy said she ate roast beef but it is none of kickenchicken, crafty corn, and bubbaelaphant so this means that the 10 deleted smiling critters came in playtime co and wasn’t seen in the chapter so she probably attacked kissy missy or the prototype did it can’t be bobbybearhug she’s nice but probably the deleted one that is a cow (I forgot the name) got seen and questioned by Bobbybearhug and pickipiggy ate her/him for surviving I don’t know but do you guys think the deleted smiling critters cow will make an appearance in chapter 4?
so... you basically agree with the video?
‘His voice lines are actually the most tame’
‘If you exclude the screaming’
Least terrifying thing in poppy chapter 3
Well it's true
Him:"we dont rlly know how crafty died"
Picky:oh well it cant be me-
Bruh picky piggy ate the CORPSES
piggy ate their corpse while crafty probably used her own blood to paint till she suffered from bloodloss
Say all you want about the game not being scary, you gotta admit that not that many games have the balls to depict what happened to dog day
Gotta agree
Idk how some ppl would say the game isn’t scary tbh
Chapter 3 was definitely one of the most horrific experience I had with a horror game
When people say "the game isn't scary" they are most likely just talking about the first two chapters, three went all out on the horror, two had some horror, and one basically had no horror at all
@@thefancydoge8668 chapter one is like, get ready for some scares, chapter 2 is slightly turning up the scares and chapter 3 its just trying to scare your soul out of your body
edit: tf how did i get 100 likes am i dreaming
Tbh I didn’t wanna care for this, but a friend told me and I watched ManlyBadassHero play it. And well you’re right. That is some dead space shi right there. Didn’t expect this game to go that route
Dog day had to be the saddest story to me. Most likely seeing all his friends die off and catnap become evil, then being tortured by catnap one of his trusted friends, then ultimately being controlled by miniature smiling critters. Not only that but the difference in his voice from the cardboard cutouts. I feel like that might represent everything he went through that was off screen. We don’t even know what ways he was tortured in besides his legs being cut off, and the fact he still looked on the positive side when we appeared even calling us ‘Poppy’s angel’. He better get justice bc Istg
He was the SWEETEST smiling critter istg... He didn't deserve what happened to him *at all* 😭
@@haneenasad exactly dude he always looked on the positive side. If catnap got no haters im dead 🙏
@@yorkietunez 😢
@@yorkietunez it’s even worse tbh. People are actually deranged enough to ship DogDay with CatNap, the one who murdered DogDay’s closest friends, tore DogDay’s legs off, and left him to hang in a dark cell to suffer for years afterwards.
The closest thing he's gonna get to justice is Catnap getting killed by his "god" but the worst part is that he won't ever know, if he even survived the mini critters possessing him.
I love the little detail at 2:07 , where we can see dogday in the same pose we see him as in the game, even his legs are covered
yup
😲 YOU RIGHT I JUST CHECKED
His cut out looks like him in game if you cover the legs
Edit: dang ty ik is not alot and definitely not my most ty again i thought i would get like idk 2 likes
And only he and catnap are on the sofa while the others are on the ground, showing they are the only living ones.
@NStudios64 if they're all in the living room and the only 2 living ones are on the couch how could the rest of em die if theyre in the "LIVING" room?🤔
Idk where I saw this theory but someone said that Hoppy Hopscotch was talking to DogDay. This actually makes some sense especially with the line “don’t look at your feet!”
Maybe she was trying to help him escape and jumped to her death while trying to get to the moon. She could’ve been telling DogDay to use his upper body strength or whatever was near them to push himself forward and escape but ultimately Hoppy Hopscotch died and DogDay was recaptured
I have a more tragic theory regarding Hoppy Hopscotch's death...
Once things went sour, Hoppy Hopscotch jumped to her death on purpose and was persuading someone else to jump with her, hence her anger at them looking down. Based on the 2 failures before Hoppy's scream, it was VERY hard to fully commit to her choice. She made it a game, "Jumping to the moon", to help ease her and her accomplice(s) into going for it. Her trademark impatience then quite literally led to her downfall.
What if it was DogDay she was trying to persuade? “Don’t look at your feet.” And all that. I know it wouldn’t make sense in the timeline, but it could be foreshadowing DogDay’s legs being cut off.
@@justanotherartist140
There isn't enough evidence to know exactly who accompanied Hoppy Hopscotch, but my best guess is it was Bobby Bearhug, not DogDay. The short story below describes what I believe happened:
“DogDay vanishing was the last straw for the Smiling Critters- without his sunny mediation, the worst traits in every critter flared up. Several pointless fights later, the group scattered… all except for Bobby Bearhug. Starving for affection more than food, Bobby spent every waking hour searching for others to cling to, only to face unanimous rejection. Bobby's nature was already a bit much BEFORE factory-wide tension skyrocketed, but now, she was little more than a walking detriment to survival. Bobby later gave up her cuddly crusade and wandered around, below rock bottom. At some point, Bobby happened upon Hoppy Hopscotch planning to jump. She followed Hoppy under the guise of moral support, but had a selfish ulterior motive. She deliberately waited until Hoppy's death, just to cuddle the body… the dead can't protest, after all. This choice is what made Bobby Bearhug crack- trauma brings out the worst in people, but Bobby never expected herself to do something so downright evil for the sake of her own comfort. She spent the rest of her days in mindless grief, desperate for something, anything to take her mind off her misdeed(s). She couldn't bring herself to eat bodies, instead nibbling on the many scuttling vermin. Suffocating in emptiness, inside and out, Bobby eventually perished, guilty, miserable, and alone.”
To me it seems like it was Bobby Bearhug. Bobby said, “I love you to the moon and back” that could be referencing Hoppy Hopscotch’s, “Jump to the moon”. Bobby also said “You won’t leave me again will you” and “take me with you this time”. If Hoppy jumped to her demise, on purpose or because of impatience it could be that Bobby felt abandoned because she didn’t get the chance to go as well and was afraid to do it alone afterwards.
@@jaydoh1035
I must say, you have a good point. Villainous undertones or not, both our ideas fit Bobby Bearhug's character... Anyway, I have a strong hunch the bigger smiling critters aren't all dead, in fact, it's very possible Bobby Bearhug herself is still surviving out there, waiting to reunite with us. To counter the Bobby Starved theory of this YT video, I firmly believe Bobby subsists only on insects/vermin because she hates eating former friends... Now, anyone who has had a real life roach or mouse problem in their home knows all too well they're basically infinite if left amongst rot long enough. In Poppy Playtime, there's more than enough vermin to go around, toys just refuse to share and kill each other over a source that could be feeding the whole factory if shared evenly. Sure, maybe bugs aren't as tasty as a body or two, but it's a more realistic long term food source... For Bobby Bearhug specifically, an advantage of being avoided for her clinginess is nobody wants to risk interaction by going after her food. It's possible Bobby Bearhug is 100% food secure thanks to her more bothersome traits... Meaning, if she's dead of starvation, she must have actively chosen to be.
nobody kills themselves, they are FORCED
I actually love the Smiling Critters designs, yeah the smiles and black eyes can be creepy but the their designs and cardboard cutout pictures are actually really good and kinda cute too. I love the art on the cardboard cutouts, its a super nice style, and the way the characters look are just so nice!
I know right I'm sad they all just die :(
yesss. I agree.
Bobby Bearhug's last line made me cry real, actual, genuine tears. God damn it this game never ceases to amaze me
you have a kind heart ❤
Idk why but Dogdays death and Hoppy’s are the most disturbing ones to me. When I first heard Hoppy’s cardboard cutout voice lines, it immediately made me think of that analog horror “Local 58” or whatever its called. That really brings in this idea that the moon kills people?? Ig?? But idk, something about seeing that and then hearing Hoppy’s lines are really disturbing to me
What I believe happened:
Bubba: Likely the first to die, based on his placement in the game and lack of useful voicelines. Your theory on him fits, I believe that, being the smartest, he came to the conclusion that the only way out was death, so he offered himself to Catnap.
Kickin' Chicken: I think him and Hoppy died similarly. He tried to lead other toys (maybe the mini-critters?) out of Playcare, but was killed by Catnap/Prototype.
Hoppy: I think she died similarly to Catnap, her dying so randomly wouldn't make sense otherwise.
Piggy: I think you're right on her too, probably fed on her friends corpses. She's probably one of the only critters not to be killed externally, and rather dies of starvation since she runs out of food.
CraftyCorn: Due to being introverted and shy, I believe she probably went into hiding and eventually went insane due to isolation. The 'red paint' she wants is definitely blood, and she kills other toys for theirs. She eventually either gets killed by a toy she tries to take blood from, or kills herself trying to get it.
Bobby and Dogday: I believe these two were the last two surviving ones. Dogday could be talking to the player in his cutout, but it could also be interpreted as him telling someone else to escape while he stalls Catnap. I think that person is Bobby, and due to her attachment issues, begs for Dogdays not to leave her, which is also reflected on her cutout. Eventually, she is killed and Dogdays is bisected, likely at about the same time. Based on her lack of screams, I guess she was killed instantly by Catnap, who then brutally assaulted Dogdays.
Or Bobby could still be alive 🤔
@@JDBELIEVEE yeah I was thinking she eventually escaped right before Dogdays was caught by Catnap and is lost somewhere in the labyrinth of Playtime Co., maybe we'll see her in a later chapter?
true she could still be alive because she didnt say she was straving in the cutout
hoppy probably died EXACTLY like catnap as i think she was trying to jump into the vent 1006 dragged catnap into at the end of chapter 3. she thought the vent was an exit and tried to jump out but 1006 grabbed her similar to catnap
@@Ethan-uq2ewSeeing as Dogdays says he’s the last of them, he 100% saw them all die in some way, no way the one we KNOW was with him at all times is the one that survives and he doesn’t know. He would’ve seen her get away and held out hope she was ok. The only way this would’ve happened is if Catnap killed her and brought the body back to Dogdays to mess with him
1:15 Bubba says "Want to know what I remember about you?" Right before screaming, probably hinting that he remembers us experimenting on him and him screaming in pain.
I think they would have gave him anaesthesia
@@TylerBurke-fb2pb
An argument could be made that PlayTime® wouldn't do such a thing. We've seen them do worse things then experimenting on someone without anesthetics.
I feel like this is a good point because in that mansion looking maze it’s seen that kissy missy is in a bedroom with two beds looking at a picture of a child. I feel like that had to mean that she had memories of her before she became a toy/monster. I think it would be neat if they did since they could fuel their anger or thirst for revenge
I think its more from the hour of joy, the scream of the innocent people.
Is more like "what I remember from you are just screams" not that he's screaming himself, he's telling us what he remembers, just screams, which means that he knew what happened and that he's ok with that, cause he ask us in a playful way
12:19 didn't you literally explain how they are DEAD even dogday says he is the last one and we know how he ends up
I don't get it (edit I GET IT he need content)
Whenever you interact with dogday in the chase there is a bunch of smiling critters who joined with catnap and the prototype and a bunch crawled into dogday to take control and there was still quite a bit in the playplace section. Correct me if im wrong if not i hope this helps
@@Jaxon_the_flibber_jibberhe said that they like go inside your body and start eating your body parts from the inside and you can here his screams to cut out wich means they like ate his cord thingy mo mob so he couldn’t scream and he died and then got taken over by the prototype wich means the prototype can or maybe can take other dead creatures and bring them back alive under his control so yea
11:54 this also might explain why dogday's voice sounded so different from the cutout because he screamed from pain for so long that his vocal cords became raspy and led to his deep voice we see in the game
I didn't even think of that!
I though he had just grown up. After all Mommy is possessed by a kid but has a Adult voice. So does Catnap, Poppy, Dog Day and the other toys have adult voices. After all it's has been 10 years.
that actually makes sense
I think the original theory is correct,
I feel this voice is broken little bit that give him deep voice
I saw a theory from someone else that said
“•Crafty Corn was most likely alone, drawing warning signs all around the facility while going slowly insane due to being alone for so long and so in the cutout when she ask for more red she gets hostile to herself thinking that she was talking to the other smiling critters and uses her own blood as "red paint" until she slowly dies from blood loss.”
That was my thought too. Just the way the last line is said.... Sounds like she either cut herself attacking someone or something like that and starts to use her own blood in the paintings.
Wait that sounds even more logical
I don’t think the red is refering to blood o think it’s catnaps gas and she tryed to get more from catnap fighting him and losing.
I kinda think Catnap cut some of her blood and then she dies from blood loss
This theory could work cause who wrote all those things on the walls like "the hour of joy" like she was warning others about it
Small theory: Hoppy Hopscotch says "No dont look at your feet, none of that matters" meaning the person she is talking to is a toy aswell and is sad when they look down and see a plastic toy's feet. Hoppy tries to tell the person to not get reminded of being a toy and to jump. Maybe hoppy and the person are feeling suicidal.
True but I don’t think it’s suicide because Hoppy kept talking about “Reaching the moon” I think she was trying to escape or something.
*Definitely not suicidal, I think she just wanted to escape so bad to the point where she became obsessed over it.*
*My guess is that the other toys were hesitating and that's why she grew impatient with the player not jumping higher, she could've fallen to her death or maybe the hesitation from the toys got them killed instead and that's why she keeps begging the player to jump!*
That could be another solution to why bobby bear hug or picky piggy died, since they don't have screaming in their cardboard cut outs. Unless we see them in chapter four of course but we don't know that until chapter four releases.
That's a reach, though. That is heavily speculative, to be honest.
@@RitsuSakuma69 That's so scary :(
11:53 this is actually disturbing
At 6:56 if you listen VERY closely, you can hear something falling, which may help prove that Hoppy Hopscotch died because of jumping off some high platform, because she didn’t know where she was jumping.
Maybe it was the clouds above the Statue there was big rock that seemed to have fallen form a great hight
I DO HEAR IT omg
It’s bc when hoppy hopscotch tried to jump he kept landing on the stars each time until he reach the moon but when he reached the moon catnap pushed him and died, also in the intro u will see catnap on the moon
Maybe a cliff
Rip hoppy
She hopped to the heavens apparently 😭
8:53 I think CraftyCorn was talking to CatNap and when she got mad at CatNap he eventually ripped her apart hence the blood. “Ah! That’s MUCH better.” is her seeing all of her own.
Damn.
and also Poppy said that the prototype saved catnaps Life and maybe the prototype saved Catnap from Craftycorn and because of that Catnap thinks that prototype is a good and now he is History slavery.
Nah he got in an accident when he was still a human child he got electricuted hence why he thinks prototype is a god
this is the one i think @llstudios23
And Crafty died of blood loss
Something I really like about Poppy Playtime is the voice acting. The voice actors tried so hard and really put themselves in the characters' shoes, which makes everything so incredibly realistic and deep.
1:02 the player I believe is going through survivor is guilt because I think he’s the one employee who retired before this hall happened but he knew nothing of the crimes and horrors that happened.
- Bubbaphant remember all the tortures scientists did to the toys, he says ´´Do you want to know what i remember about you?`` as a threat, his ability to remember things for long periods made him violent desensitized living after the hour of joy.
- Chicken died because he wanted to go outside the factory and was caught by Catnap trying to escape.
- Picky survived a long time eating rotted meat and his own friends out of instinct. (he being a carrion swine)
- Hopscotch had a mental breakdown like Mrs Delight, her energetic/impacient personality drove her crazy after so much time being stucked in Playcare. (a cabin fever phenomenon), i guess is fair to say she died jumping at a high place trying to escape but i personally think her death wasn't that trival, maybe someone caught her off guard while jumping.
- Bearhug was naive and passionate, as how this game likes twisted emotions i like to think she grew obsessed and dependent on the other critters and they didn't care for her, she was probably forsaken, not even Picky found her body.
- Craftycorn went insane, no big explanation, like Hopscotch and Bearhug, she became obsessed in painting and realized that the other critters had some *red* inside them that she could use to paint, she was lynched after acting so aggressive.
- DogDay ran and tried to live away, as a counterpart of CatNap, he didn't want to live around that nightmare and being overseed by Prototype but eventually he was caught and sacrifaced as a example, his legs we're cut off so *he couldn't ran.*
It's hard to say who died first, but it appears that Picky was one of the last to die as he indicated that he ate the others.
(with DogDay being the last one of course)
I know i repeated a lot of things from the video but this is my humble version:
Chicken died first due to his line ´´I go first`` and that he is the first cardboard, then Hopscotch died (also wanting to escape), Craftycorn went insane and got lynched after the *Red* incident, then Bubbaphant being smart and influential was becoming a problem for the Prototype's own influence and i believe CatNap sacrificed him, after that Bearhug was abandoned and forgotten (Bubba was dead and no one remembered her anymore), Picky ate the critters he found to survive during all this time until eventually starving or he died trying to eat CatNap too, then after a long chase, just a few months before the player returns, DogDay was caught and tortured as a example for the toys in Prototype's command.
I like to think that everything went kinda together in one event, I don't even have a theory, just how I think the story went
After the hour of joy, Dogday wanted to scape with the rest but Catnap appeared betraying the smiling critters "why aren't you running?" says Dogday but Catnap snaps cutting Dogday in half
The rest freak out, in the chaos Hopscotch wants to run away but fell into the cave dying right there, after that the other five couldn't scape from the playhouse scared by Catnap they tried to survive somehow
Little by little Craftcorn and Bubbaphant start losing their mind and going more feral so they fight (acording to Craftcorn lines about blue color and red color) so she kills Bubbaphant
After that Picky eats Bubbaphant and Craftcorn so Chicken tries to scape with Bearhug but Catnap kills him, he's eaten by Picky too, leaving Bearhug alone
What happened to Picky and Bearhug? maybe they died with time
I think Crafty didn't kill anyone. The "red" she wanted was probably just actual red paint, as she clearly wanted to continue painting. She lived long enough to paint the warnings in the transportation ducts in chapter 1.
5:35 it’d be even darker if catnap actually caught her and forced her to eat the bodies of her friends before finally killing her if she didn’t die from overeating 🥶
That's most likely what happened
Why no scream?
@@dandaman4383 no idea
@@dandaman4383no one would scream because they’re eating
@@dandaman4383*muffled screaming*
From what Dogday said, it sounds like Catnap killed them all. He said that his situation was due to Catnap seeing him as a heretic. Most likely what the Cutouts are is how they all met their end. Bubba died due to him saying something too Catnap (Most likely wanting to die, and Catnap assisted him). Kicken Chicken died after he stepped outside (Probably similar to what happened to the player in the Councilors office), Picky Piggy died to eating (Due to her being, well, a glutton, she most likely couldn't survive due to her eating so much, but after to food ran out she died), Hoppy died from saving someone (There are two situations here. One that she was helping someone, and Catnap killed her, or the situation that you said). Bobby is obsessed about someone, who though, its unclear (Catnap probably found her, Bobby begged someone to stay, but they left her, and killed her). CraftyCorn wanted a red paint (She attacked someone or something. Most likley this is also how she met her end, she attacked another Toy, but killed her instead. And we all know what happened to Dogday. (He most likely tried to escape from Catnap, and he was captured and tortured by Catnap and the Smiling Critters). Catnap's Cutout though is nothing more than gurgling sounds, but I think it sounds like breathing. (We know Theodore was injured by usng two Green Hands, but we don't know the damage Theo sustained. I personally think he had lung damage, and his cutout was Catnap struggling to breath)
Had a stroke reading this
Hoppy maybe tried to save Bobby because 1. Their names are similar 2.Their voicelines match and lastly when Hoppy died , Bobby was all alone and lost
@@atilagundogdu-oj9kdI think Bobby bearhug got mental crazy issues and got too crazy and hit herself in the wall because she is a reject toy in the reject office
@@Marcus1832 oh well mine was a theory but one question is your pfp snowball from BFDI/BFDIA/IDFB/BFB/TPOT?
Wow, what amazing theories!
I believe that
I feel like Dogday as leaders usually do, they put their duties ahead of their heart for the betterment of others... He sacrified himself to protect the others pretending hes the last one, As he knows catnap and the Prototype are always listening, maybe he wouldnt tell them where the others are hiding which is why he's tormented and being kept alive, but eventually they got tired of him not talking so fed him to the minature critters.
In terms to Hoppy Hopscotch there IS a room that has a large moon hanging from the celling, its where you must find all the batteries to unlock the ☀️ doors. I feel she jumped from the balcony(maybe she was with Bobby bearhug maybe they jumped together considering Bobby says " im crazy about you-" she'd do anything for Hoppy because she loves her to the moon and back or maybe bobby backed out being afraid and watched her die so she feels empty without her ) Hoppy does seem like the type to leave her behind if she can't keep up though 😂
so in an attempt to get to the moon and thats why there are large parts of the railing in front of the double doors thats broken near the moon hanging from the ceiling, and a large hole in the wood floor she/they couldve fell to "death" maybe Hoppy took the impact of the two but Bobby survived still being alive underground ( the hole where you find the gasmask ). Maybe that room needs more examining as to Hopscotches whereabouts. Maybe even in terms to bobby bearheart maybe she was trapped underneath the wood floor unable to get out therefore, lost.
I feel like Picky piggy could have joined with Catnap in order to eat as she's always hungry. i feel as though, catnap did kill the bubaphant,
the prototype killed kickinchicken for trying to escape, as Poppy speaks on anyone that tries to eacape the facility, the prototype kills.
I feel catnap may have gave those remains to picky piggy. I feel that picky piggy is cannabalistic because they probably didnt kill the big critter craftycorn as she's still happily painting in her cutout. but piggy potentially was eating the miniature critters of craftycorn, picky piggies, etc... so trying to survive off of them shes always getting hungry because of how small they are she needs to keep eating.
Craftycorn i believe is alive and she is the one who painted the poppy flower in front of Poppy's entrance. Considering she used a lot of red, blue etc.
The ‘laughing’ in bubbaphant’s cutout probably isn’t laughing, it’s crying in extreme pain.
Laughing is also a normal response to pain
@@fishing4eternity yh, but I’m still thinking crying
It's what?
@@fishing4eternity
the red gas make them laugh and pass out.
@@fishing4eternity
Laughing is what?
The fact that you can hear dog days legs get cut off and falling to the ground makes everything even more disturbing.
When I finally heard that my entire body shuddered m8, I didn't expect that at all
@@MicrowavedBurrito bro same, i got shivers and i was creeped out
the way you can also hear the blood splatter makes it even more terrifying
I’ve gotta say, Poppy Playtime is an absolute masterpiece. You can tell the love and dedication put into the game. Just simple things like a shadow or a wall shows it. They’ve came a long way since Chapter 1. I’m not saying chapter one was bad but the quality and production has gotten better as the chapters continue. It’s a disgustingly daunting story that leaves you feeling lost. The poor children and people that were killed and mutilated for the sake of science makes you feel sad and connected to them as you get to know their backstory. Being the player that also partook in the torture of children just adds to the pain and suffering they must’ve endured. We continuously kill them over and over again. So it’s understandable why we are chased and hunted by the characters. Also, I loved this video, the way you breakdown and depict everything is something I could’ve never done. I always just pressed the button and moved on but this take adds even more lore to the story. You’ve just gained a subscriber ❤. If anyone in the comments can help give me their take on why Poppy helps us, I would appreciate it. I honestly can’t wait for the next chapters and more videos about it from this guy.
No it's actually a cashgrab game made by someone trying to get money, but then people liked it so they improved upon it.
@@somebodythatisnobodyo9737fym😂
@@somebodythatisnobodyo9737that was long ago like in chapter 1 era
@@cactusmangaming Yes and? He said they started to improve it, so you're just supporting his claim.
Kickenchiken:hey I've never been outside before me:they scared to come outside
I personally think, based on how he set up the stage for Miss Delight and the other teachers as well as the trailer, that Catnap used his gas on the smiling critters who were retaliating against the prototype, where it causes near insanity and heightens their base traits. He slowly takes them out when their guards are down or watches them turn on each other as he seems to enjoy playing with his prey. Dog day was likely affected, too, but his words and actions are not extreme as the other cutouts, so it's likely Catnap hunted him down himself realising Dogday may be mentally stronger than the other critters as their supposed leader.
I think that Hoppy's recordings depict her trying to lead another person/toy to escape. The way she talked and encouraged the other indicates that the other is probably either a child or very child-like, as encouraging a child to do something by turning it into a sort of follow-me game is common and effective. I personally interpret the story as the two were escaping through going upwards, and had some platforming to do. At first, the other one was doing fine, hence the first 2 recordings sounding normal. But then, as the two ascended to a certain height, the other one was probably getting tired from the jumps and was losing patience or hope, hence Hoppy encouraging the other to keep going in the 3rd recording. By the time of the 4th recording, the tension was very high and Hoppy was also getting extremely nervous, but she was still refusing to leave her companion behind. She told the other one not to look at their feet and that none of "that" mattered, implying that the other one was hesitant to continue jumping either due to being too scared of the height, was missing the playcare, or was frozen by the scene going on beneath (could be Catnap going after them or a massacre like the Hour of Joy going on). At last, I think Hoppy made another jump, but the other one finally failed to continue on, either because they're too exhausted or too scared, but they were in a position more dangerous than before (could be Catnap catching up, or the platform is gonna collapse). Hoppy desperately tried to urge the other to keep going, but the other failed to do so and tragically died. I honestly think that Hoppy's recordings depict more of her role as a lead and the experience she had with the other one before death than how she actually died. I can only assume that Hoppy was caught up by Catnap or the Prototype and thus murdered, but how? Not sure. I feel especially sad for Hoppy's demise as I can tell that she's courageous and had a bright personality, and she was caring and patient enough to baby talk and lead others away from danger and refused to leave them behind despite her fear. She's truly a perfect lovable mascot designed for children.
This makes a lot of sense.
Why is it so big 😢
I just noticed that the moon may reference catnap's pendant too 🤔
*cries*
Huh
I think Bobby bearhug was abandoned by us, the player she says:”don’t leave me again!” AGAIN, this must have been before the hour of joy when the player left, so she doesn’t wanna be left in the madness of the monsters again, that’s why she tries to convince the player to bring her with the player, because she didn’t wanna be left again. so you are basically correct lol
She still alive
@@KINGDREX24that would actually be very interesting. A cool twist in the end would be Bobby Bearhug being alive, and she basically confirms who we are, maybe saying our name.
I still think there will be 5 chapters since we never actually saw Huggie Wuggie die. So what if Bobby even saves us at the end of chapter 4? It would be pretty funny for a character infamous for hugs to save us from a character infamous for hugs. XD
@noratheweed9387
She wouldn’t say your name. She would say, Daddy.
@@justice8718 that would be HEART WRENCHING. Especially if in saving us she sacrificed herself (a high likelihood given how small the Smiling Critters are in comparison to toys like Huggie and her highly caring nature).
And since we're escaping the place, she must be still alive and will be able to come with us
🐘: Tickled to death
🐓: Stepped into a fryer
🐖: turned Cannibal
🐰: Jumped too high and fell☠️
🐻: Isolated to death
🐶: Tortured and Mutilated
🦄: … really likes the color red ??
Bubbaphant got eaten by pickpiggy because in her voice line it says seared elephant same for kickinchiken when he stepped outside he got eaten by pickpiggy and same for crafty corn
The fact that the cardboard cutout tells us about their death means catnap or the prototype was recording their death
Oh good lord that is terrifying to think about-
Something more scarier is that we don't find za bodies so that catnap ate them or prototype
or maybe the cutouts are connected to their voicelines? idk just a guess
@@road4488ur saying the smiling critters voicebox has to be ripped out during death is kinda bad guess
@@Dabuilder1 dog day's voice is kinda, you know, hollow.
You can actually hear the thud from dogdays legs hitting the ground. I knew when they cut through the bone because his scream turned into more of a gag. Rip dogday
He got the treatment mommy said she was going to give us. (Mommy longlegs)
I think catnap gas works somewhat like 'laughing gas', nitrous oxide gives a euphoric experience that relaxes and i think gives the effect similar to dopamine. They are laughing so much that they literally knock themselves out to faint.
But that gas must have other properties because it also powers the facility, when catnap died he only burst into fire ONCE the gas became exposed to his electrified corpse and if you notice he was breathing fire as he was burning, the gas also caused some bizarre nightmarish hallucinations to occur when it puts you to sleep.
And to think that CatNap actually has to live that way for his entire life because of Playco. That is awful.
at the end you could add" and then catnap killed them "
The gas also ends up mutating catnap at the end, making his skeletal structure more visible (I have no idea what I’m saying lol)
Yesss. I thought that was obvious
I feel like CraftyCorn was talking to DogDay when she was asking for more red. The scream after she says "Give it here!" Sounds similar to him and I believe she took blood from the wounds left after his legs got cut off
“We don’t know how crafty corn died”
Picky piggy:”FLAYED UNICORN YUM”
I think she is the fake one who killed the real one for "red"
Picky piggy: Grilled chicken. Down the hatch
Kicken chicken: WHAT THE FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF
EZ
m.o.s.t p.r.o.b.a.b.a.l.y.
Honestly, I like to think crafty managed to escape, though not without serious injury, considering picky’s line
Theory: The reason Picky Piggy says “wanna be friends” at the end is because she tried to befriend Catnap and failed causing Catnap to kill her.
Note: Don't take too seriously, nothing can be set in stone as we have too little evidence.
9:17
She still alive and bear to
She tried to eat catnap i think 💀
@@KINGDREX24What yo talking about
@@KINGDREX24Dogday literally says he’s the last survivor of the critters tho
Kickin' Chicken: *Goes Out For The First Time*
*Touches Grass*
ÆAAÊEUUÜAEAÁÉAE
Every gamer in a nutshell:
This makes the disturbing video less disturbing ngl-
@@YisehakKebedqethefirstThat was what Jacksepticeye said lol
6:53 okay for Hoppy hopscotch I think when she says this won't stop until we make it to the moon I don't think it's her wanting to get to the moon I think it's someone forcing her because she doesn't say I won't stop until I get to the moon she says this won't stop so I feel like it's either catnap forcing us to jump to the moon and then while we're jumping and she's saying jump catnap either killed her or did something else That's what I think in my opinion
Yea😅
The most gruesome part of DogDay's scream was that he suffered not 2 but 1 cut. This meant that it was a direct chop to the lower abdomen and DogDay had suffered excruciating pain while his ENTIRE LOWER HALF was sawed off, also the reason why the sound made by the legs dropping on the ground was loud and there were only 1 impact sound rather than 2. After that, DogDay starts to internal bleed and we hear guts and blood dropping on the floor. This is why in order to keeping torturing it (and possibly crucified in the cell as critter food), CatNap has to use a belt to stop DogDay from bleeding and spill the guts out. (I personally am terrified about this scream being so crafted precisely.)
Considering that part of possibly DogDay's digestive system being heavily damaged, it's a miracle that he survived for that long.
Calm down that whole essay they say express your feelings but wow lol 😂
Well ofc he’s going to survive he’s a toy not a human but it’s still pretty bad and painful
And it’s also a game
Can you stop hating on this comment?
@@Venom_SNcalm down those three consecutive responses they say express your feelings but wow lol 😂
10:15 craftycorn died possibly because pickypiggy ate her. in one of her lines, pickypiggy literally says "flayed unicorn? mmmm"
Or force fed her remains
I would never let picky piggy eat me 😤
@@PrincessCraftycorn dont give deviant art any ideas
The scariest one (In my Opinion) Was dogday's... He encouraged us to escape, to look on the bright side, and for that... He was tortured...
However the most depressing one (Again in My Opinion) Was Pickypiggy's... She usually talks in a higher tone due to her having her actual favorite foods, however in the voice-lines of her cardboard you can hear her lower tone, her sadness, Imagine you had such a happy group of friends, then after watching them get killed off, the only way you can survive is by eating the corpses of the people you cared about the most...
131 Likes but no replies? Let me fix that...
More scary hearing it at night in a pitch black room, like that brings shivers
Do we just ignore that ℍ𝕠𝕡𝕡𝕪 was jumping to the moon and 𝔹𝕠𝕓𝕓𝕪 said "I love you to the moon and back" 💀💀💀
Picky Piggy may be scarier then Catnap based off what she says.
Yeah
Small chance that Picky might appear in chapter 4. Bobby might also appear there as there's no reference as to how these 2 could have died.
I think that picky piggy was forced to eat her friends by catnap
Catnap found it weird how miss delight ate the other teachers, so I understand now, picky piggy is probably just like her.
ye she also said ROAST BEEF YUMMMMM BUT ROAST BEEF IS GUESS WHAT PIGGG SO SHE ATE HERSELF OR ANOTHER PIG
When Bubba Bubbaphant screams he cries out "AAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHH-MOMMA"Which says a lot about how these are not toys,but orphans trapped in a toy's body
He's not saying momma
It does sound a little like that...
Wait...I think bubba bubbaphant has a grandma
he said "grandma" btwwww
@@Everestalsoknowznothingg he did not
Did you notice that Bobby and Hoppy were both talking about the moon? Maybe they were like superclose, and Bobby said: "I love you to the moon and back."
While Hoppy wanted to jump to the moon. Maybe after Hoppy died, Bobby was so sad that she was lost in her sorrow. Maybe she said: "I love you to the moon and back." For Hoppy😢
kinda make sense actually
hoppy wants to jump the moon, which might mean that she wants to escape the place, bobby has a voice line about her being abandoned and left alone... hoppy probably left bobby and try to escape but on the last voiceline, she end up dying
@@bigchongus5140Yeah-... I also think Bubba And Kickin's deaths could be linked. With Kickin' stepping out first and being killed by Catnap. And then sprays out his sleeping gas to kill Bubba. Since I think he'd have to be talking to another Critter and not necessarily The Player. And Bubba seems like the only candidate for that.
@@DarkBunsCult ooh that could be true but I think that for the chicken's lines, I feel like he's talking to dogday.. It was mentioned that dogday was the one who recommended the critters to leave the place.... since he is the leader, i think kickin asking dogday to escape with him makes sense
but in dogday's lines, it looks like he's the last one to leave the place, he said "you can't be here", and I'm assuming he wants all the critters to leave before him... but he failed to leave and got massacre by catnap
bobby is probably just hiding, that's why dogday assumed that everyone else was dead... she probably saw dogday getting killed, that's why she's scared that everyone is leaving her (dying within her sight)
@@bigchongus5140LoL
Yeah! Can we also talk about how CraftyCorn drew Bobby Bearhug? And maybe she killed Bubba, because the painting of Bobby had a lot of red, and maybe Bubba was watching her paint. But when she ran out of red she killed Bubba then Picky Pinky ate Bubba’s body. This probably means that Crafty, Bubba, and Hoppy, we’re actually super close since they were all girls and ther rest of the smiling critters were boys.
Okay, I never realised the sounds of Dogday's screams on the cutout was a recording of him getting his legs severed until you pointed it out...
As if I wasn't already feeling so horrible for this poor little pooch 😭😭
same
SAME!! 😭😭
It’s fairly obvious considering he is yknow missing his legs…?
@@crafty4722 I meant how the cutout recording is literally taken from when he was getting his legs cut off.
Dog day never deserved this😭😭
0:24 - Bubba Bubbaphant - Smart one
2:28 - Kickin Chicken - Cool, Scared one
4:16 - Picky Piggy - Healthy one
5:48 - Hoppy Hopscotch - Wants to please her friends, impatient one
7:17 - Bobby Bearhug - Caring, affective one
8:53 - Crafty Corn - Artist, peaceful one
10:31 - Dogday - Kind, leader, most caring
I think picky piggy ate 3 of her friends since she said "flayed unicorn" reference to Craftycorn, "grilled chicken" for kickinchicken and "seared elephant" for Bubba bubbaphant and that's how they died
Maybe considering the description she gives of the way she possibly ate them we can trace some more info on their deaths. Like "grilled chicken" which could easily mean kickinchicken was burnt to death. Now following this logic we can say that bubba bubbaphant was also burned alive, however he wasn't for long because seared means frying something at a high temperature for a relatively short amount of time ( so that the thing can keep it's "juices" ) so maybe, even if he was burned too, he may have died due to pure pain from the burned areas but was maybe using the gas to ease his pain ( smart move ) which is why he was also laughing . As for CraftyCorn... Flayed means skinned off... and if we consider her voice lines, this means that she in fact was ripping her skin off to paint with her blood... meaning she possibly died due to, well, slowly bleeding out.
I think they were already dead by the time she ate them.
@@lightvision2497never thought about it that way
@@pj3750same
Possibly Craftycorn, bubba bubbaphant and kickinchicken died and after that picky piggy ate them since she had no food left and was starved to death later on. or catnap ate her after she ate them for revenge of his food or because he needed the food or both.
The thing about DogDay is that he’s the only Smiling Critter who’s aware of what’s going on which is why he told the player “You can’t be here, you can’t stay” he knew what was going on and he didn’t want us to be apart of it.
And DogDay also known CatNap more then anybody so that’s another piece of Evidence on how DogDay Knows.
I have a feeling that DogDay knows something about the prototype & everything else that WE don’t know of, which is why we all need him to be in chapter 5, DogDay also Knew that Ollie was the prototype this entire time.
DogDay is a big and mysterious character with a lot of secrets which is why he’s one of the most important characters
Hoppy Hopscotch was likely helping the other smiling critters escape, based on the number of jumping prototype puzzles in the underground facility. I think Kicking Chicken tried to lead the smiling critters to escape and was the first to get picked off
My theory for hoppy is that she was trying to help player escape, but they kept getting distracted and they weren’t able to make it out of the factory. So she died to prototype or catnap when trying to help them escape.
I also noticed that Picky Piggy doesn’t scream unlike the rest of them, further proving she most likely starved to death rather then killed.
Bobby didn't scream too what if she is till alive ?
@@miguelflores1876oh wait, true, but DogDay said that CatNap killed everyone... Maybe he just assumed that and Bobby is still alive hiding?
@@mrvoidschannel359 yeah I agree I don't feel like Bobby died
What I imagine happened to the Critters.
Bubba - Like you said, was gassed and killed by CatNap.
Kickin - Tried to escape the factory and was killed by Huggy when he came close to leaving (as Huggy is the closest to the only exit we know so far, being on the top floor and all)
Picky - Starved to death, like you said
Hoppy - Jumped to her death, possibly on purpose. Was likely the first one to die.
Bobby - Killed in self-defence, maybe by CatNap?
Crafty - Tried to get CatNap's blood. Didn't work out.
Dogday scream sounds like he's getting springlocked 💀 11:54
Fr THo!😂😂
HIS LEGS ARE GETTING CUT OFF THATS WHY HES SCREAMING LIKE THAT
@@TheTrouble_Makerstrue
DO NOT HIT ME WITH THE SKULL EMOJI LIKE THAT
@@TheTrouble_Makers no shit Sherlock
Thank you for the complete versions of their recordings and this video analysis! I've been looking for them and after hearing them, I have some additional thoughts to add about each of the points in this video. (Disclaimer, I haven't played the games, though I've listened to a lot of videos and have been following the games for a year or so if I got something wrong, please let me know!)
1) Bubba Bubbaphant- If he really is the smartest of the group, something tells me it would've been HIS idea to leave messages for future people in the recordable cutouts (which, clearly, the Prototype also thought of. I personally suspect that it is the Prototype who is responsible for most of the recordings being available to us to hear because 1, we already know how he likes to take things apart and make them into useful items, like that item he turned into a lazer pointer in order to disrupt a camera. I think that was mentioned on a VHS tape in Ch1, and 2, he clearly is good at coming up with new ways to manipulate people. Using recordings of such an audibly graphic nature would absolutely scare someone into leaving, giving the Prototype an easy avenue to kill us). To my ears, B sounds like he's being dragged away as the audio cuts out. My thinking is that he was likely stalked by the Prototype and was taken out before B was able to give any solid information to us. Honestly, the Prototype is an excellent abuser- give the victims just enough space to move or breathe or talk but he's always ready to yank the leash back if you stray beyond where you're allowed. I think BB also would've thought to hide in the vents or otherwise use the ventilation shafts in the buildings as tunnels, even if he might not have done so personally. But he certainly would've shared such knowledge with his friiiiends... Also, I personally think that all of the critters would have been captured by the Prototype personally, and then he would've taken them to CatNap as a sort of "See? They aren't your friends, look at what they've done! You really can't rely on them like you can rely on Me." mental trick to both fortify his godlike position in CatNap's mind and isolate CN further from the Smiling Critters to desensitize him as his punishment of said "heretics" grows more brutal.
2) Kickin Chicken- Something tells me that KC would have known and used the vents in the buildings to move around. Huggy can't be the only one to have climbed around in there, though he seems to be the only one we have personally seen doing so. I've worked around birds before and from what I've seen, they tend to want to watch from perches, and if KC has similar thoughts, the vents would've been the first place for him to secretly check out. How cool would it be to explore in there, too? And he is the coolest, so I believe he would've known and used the vents as tunnels to move around. He might've found a vent that led to the outside during the events of the Hour of Joy (or perhaps afterwards?) and might've tried to save or free some of the children in the chaos, which results in his capture and death at the hands of the Prototype.
3) Picky Piggy- HOOO BOY. I'm with one of the other commentators that the "Roast Beef" was probably Bobby Bearhug, since roasts are often left to cook by themselves all alone for long periods of time to reach perfect flavor (this is horrible. I know. Just bear with me here, pun not intended). I think Grilled Chicken is KC after being tortured in the furnace (furnaces have to have vents for the smoke to escape from), Seared Elephant is BB after being tortured by electrocution, possibly using one of the GrabPacks like how poor Theo had happen to turn him into CN in the first place (which is a form of torture you would definitely remember. I think even James Bond was tortured with electrocution at some point, and I don't think he would forget that very quickly), and Flayed Unicorn...you COULD just say that Mob Ent wanted to use synonyms so they just went with flayed here, but that's boring. So. I looked up on Google how to cook food in order to consider it "flayed" food since I hadn't heard of the term before (I'm more familiar with pan searing, grilling, frying, the general stuff), and the first result I got was a wikipedia page about flaying- a method of torture used on living beings involving having skin removed in a very painful process. Keep in mind, this IS different from skinning- when skinning an animal, the animal is VERY MUCH dead and in no way alive anymore. But PP says FLAYED Unicorn- not Skinned, not Grilled, not Seared- FLAYED. One source I also found said that flaying prioritizes the carcass, basically the meat/edible parts of an animal, rather than the skin, whereas when skinning, the goal is to keep the skin as intact as possible for use. This tells me that it was a meticulous process for CraftyCorn to be prepared SPECIFICALLY for PP to eat, and with the intention that her...exterior...was never going to be used by the Prototype as a vessel or anything.
That's all I can type for now.
that is honestly an amazing theory and makes sense. its possible that the prototype chose to use bodies to improve himself given we know he wants to improve himself and is good at using unconventional materials to make things. the pig could have flayed the unicorn thinking it was a mercy so the prototype couldn't use her skin for something.
@@AGremlinNamedAshton using the trademark of House Bolton could never be seen as a mercy by anyone
I question Poppy saying the Prototype will kill anyone trying to escape, after all he tried to escape before as well.
Personally? I don't think Poppy can be trusted at all, I mean I'm still wondering whether 'Poppys Playtime' reefer's to our actions in the game...or the 'Hour of Joy'.
Actually, I think it's more likely that hoppy... "Made it to the moon"
The way they spoke and the line about not looking at your feet gives the impression that they were trying to get over the natural fear instinct
Theory : When CraftyCorn talks about red, she may be talking about Red Gas, wich, as said in the video, may have addictive side effects. The static/scream would be her laughing from the gas, as shown in the cartoon.
As for how she died, she probably died after being eaten by PickyPiggy, since she mentions "Flayed Unicorn".
But picky piggy didn't eat other critters alive they most probably ate their corpse to survive i really doubt that pick piggy actually killed craftycorn
Im pretty sure the “don’t look at your feet” is a referencing the fact that a lot of people look down when jumping in videogames, like how Sean (jacksepticeye) did and then immediately got called out for it
Or it partially explains how dogday lost both his legs and ended tied up as a prisoner.. I thought it was just that when watching too up until dog day showed up without any legs.. maybe he was the person that was supposed to be jumping/escaping with Hoppy..
They're in my basement, Now go sit down 💀
But i Live in Your Basement
Wha-
PLS GET THEM OUT I WANT THEM for my basement
Daddy your basement is too tight, let me out.
Seriously only 3 replys? Let me fix that
Edit 1:Ty for 23 likes!
Holy, honestly I just want a dlc of The Hour of Joy whenever they finish the chapters, because we NEED to see and actually experience what happened because damn is it such a captivating moment. An entire squad disbanded, picked off duo to one, then one to one, and lastly DogDay, suffering the worst, being put up there for 15 years. Holy crap, genuinely an amazing story.
I like to imagine that DogDay isn’t dead, and that the small critters are just driving him around like a car lol
I think Bobby Bearhug couldve been eluding to Hoppy Hopscotch. Bobby say she loves us to the moon and back - Hoppy is trying to jump to the moon while convincing/giving confidence to someone else. When Hoppy dies I think that's who Bobby misses and wishes didn't leave her. But idk
that's actually a very good theory
@@theoslame4064 thank you so much!!
Something I’d like to add, is that in picky’s dialog, there are only 3 animals not mentioned: bear, rabbit, and dog. Meaning that we know at the very least Bobby, hoppy, and dog day are all still alive by the time picky dies. I feel like the order of death was possibly listed out by picky in order of the food she listed out. I know this comment feels a bit scattered, but I was just thinking about it.
@@JC-qt9vdit might not mean they were alive at that point, but it does mean she didn't eat em, and honestly almost all of the critters have problems...
I feel like dog day is probably the only normal one and understands what is happening behind playtime co
I believe that Bobby Bearhug was helping CraftyCorn with her “painting” and due to her naive nature, didn’t realize that CraftyCorn was losing it. When CraftyCorn asks for red paint, she sees Bobby is red so she knows that Bobby must have red paint on her. After lunging out in a manic rage, CraftyCorn likely murders Bobby in order to get “red paint”. But Picky Piggy doesn’t mention eating bear at all, so it’s quite possible that CraftyCorn slaughtered and tore Bobby beyond recognition and drained all the “red paint” from her. (Also might be the reason Picky Piggy mentions Roast Beef first, not knowing that it was Bobby and assuming it was cow or something, weak argument I know)
As for Hoppy, I believe she was trying to help someone get free from the Hour Of Joy, as she says “Don’t look at you feet! None of that matters right now!” As if warning that someone to not be scared of the events happening below. As Hoppy jumps, she might’ve missed her point in a energized panic as said and broken her legs, making her an easy target for any attacks. But due to being high up, Picky Piggy must’ve missed her.
For the rest, Bubbafant was most likely exposed to the gas as before, Picky Piggy most likely starved after killing her remaining friends for food, CraftyCorn was eaten, KickinChickin was killed by the Prototype for attempting to escape, CatNap became, well, CatNap and DogDay was possessed by the Mini Critters.
(Bubbafant, CatNap, KickinChickin, Bobby Bearhug, CraftyCorn, DogDay, Hoppy Hopscotch, and Picky Piggy. All eight of them)
2:03 real life? Wait...
💀 were cooked
We’re done for… 💀
It's actually a drug 🤓🤓
Fu.....
@@lordwenlock-g9r”it’s atcully a drug” NU UH
Just to mention, picky piggy said in one of his voice lines that he ate flayed unicorn. That might be the reason craftycorn died.
picky piggy said he ate all different cooked meals of all the smiling critters
Love your videos by the way
Good job you made it early
Picky piggy is female
My theory is catnap killed some of the smiling critters and forced her to eat it
the dogday death audio legit shook me 💀
Bro liked his own comment 💀
@@Unlimited_gaming723 so? Everyone does it ain't a big deal
@@Unlimited_gaming723 I do it as well
@@Unlimited_gaming723 So? Does him doing that affect your life in any meaningful way? Leave people alone.
3:21
*the sun is a deadly laser.*
nah he touched grass and fucking evaporated
@@Deeogooseslonglostcousin twitch streamers touching grass for the first time:
Gamers when they go outside for the first 16 months without sunlight:
Not anymore, there's a blanket!
What I found the most disturbing was Bobby and Dogday's deaths.
I can relate to Bobby a little and that's what made it so horrible. You can hear the passion and sadness in her voice as she's trying to get you to stay. Her last voice line made me cry, it was so heartbreaking. It takes a lot for a game/video to make me cry, so congrats to the creators lol
For Dogday I almost cried tears of fear, legit. I could actually hear the sound of his legs getting cut off, the slicing, and the snap, the legs hitting the ground, it was so horrific and absolutely unsettling. To hear his screaming intensify after his legs are cut off are just horrific. Honestly the entire Poppy Playtime Community outdid their selves on this one. Chapter 3 has got to be the best, most horrifying game I've seen and played.
Picky Piggy's death is super fucked up, which makes it even more interesting and on brand for where the series is headed. Good eye on alot of these. Great theory crafting!
I genuinely hope we get more of the smiling critters! Their designs are so creative and the concept as well is so well done! Maybe one day we can find Bobby Bearhug or get confirmation on how each of them died through a vhs tape
So basically
Bubba - How the Toys Remember
Kickin' - The kids being sorta imprisoned
Crafty - The warnings i guess?
Picky - The Leftover toys cannibalism
Hoppy - people trying to get out during the HOJ
Bobby - The Kids sticking together? Either that or Poppy
Dog Day - escaping
Catnap - i guess a baby struggling in the red gas?
Catnaps “snoring” in hit cutout is actually the sound a body makes when it isn’t getting enough oxygen and I believe is in reference to Theodore’s accident
I was crying at dogday’s death
Also,
The “AHAHA MOMMAA” in bubba bubbaphants lines show that they are still kids
Actually, dogday might not be dead since he got possessed by the other small critters when he chased us down. So he’s probably still alive but honestly maybe death would’ve been a mercy for him. If he did end up surviving still being possessed by the small critters, then his fate was probably worse than death.
Death is ALWAYS THE WORSE AND NOBODY WANTS IT
aLso he died and ain a horrible way(he was ate alive from the inside)
@@cosmicreef5858there are worse things than death
What i think is happening:
Catnap was standing their because he knew what dogday was doing. Dogday was a heretic and not believing what the prototype and catnap did. Dogday tried to make the player to leave to save their life. Catnap was refusing to "fetch" because he was about to start the " torture" as you hear his legs being cut off in the cardboard cut-out voiceline when he screams.
HOLY MY EARS HURT AT THE DOG DAY PART OF HIM SCREAMING😭😭😭😭
i feel like for hoppy hopscotch she did make it to the moon but that is catnaps territory so he pushed her off
I don’t think the cutouts are talking to the player, they read to me more as recordings taken as they each interacted with CatNap for the last time. Each of them doing as they were conditioned to before CatNap decided he was done with them and sacrificed them for his shrine to the Prototype once their insides were fed to those still loyal to him.
Based on this, I think PickyPiggy was probably loyal to CatNap until her end because we hear Ollie mention that “in return, they are fed” about those who follow in CatNap’s worship of the Prototype.
This makes sense considering DogDay's voice lines are taken directly from an abandoned part of the cartoon where dogday is asking CatNap to play fetch, but he's just staring at him.
I think what happened was that these are the leading phrases they said before their deaths to CatNap or Prototype. It makes sense when you consider if CatNap was indoctrinated by the prototype and heard all these things (example: Kick'nChicken most likely trying to escape) he would kill them or do horrible things to them. I think DogDay found out about the horrors of the Daycare and tried to tell CatNap about it as his brother, but CatNap was already brainwashed, so he was the first to be hurt by CatNap, and hanged for going against the Prototype.
I think that the cutouts actually record the last they heard this would make the most sense with bubba bubbaphant's voice lines and the screaming is from the hour of joy.
Hoppy could have been pushed off by CatNap considering there is a poster of Bunzo falling down. Bunzo isn’t Hoppy but I wanted to bring it up since Bunzo was also a Bunny
It’s possible Crafy Corn was talking to Picky Piggy when Picky was eating Bobby Bearhug. Crafty asking for more red could be asking for more pieces of Bobby Bearhug but Picky hid more and Crafty killed Picky.
Edit:I forgot that Picky ate a Flayed Unicorn so Picky outlived Unicorn. So the one she attacked could be Bobby Bearhug.
But then Picky Pig mentions unicorn too her cutout
i think the bunzo poster is a reference to the comic mob games made about bunzo where it ends with him falling down a hole because he was running and fell into a trap
Picky definitely ate the elephant and unicorn
But what if picky was the one who was we heard scream from unicorn hitting her, and later on picky caught unicorn off guard which is how uni died and we get picky talking about flayed unicorn
Picky didnt say that she loves bears meal, but craftycorn sure was talking about blood.
But Picky mentioned that Unicorns meal is yummy, so i think ur theory Collapses
((bad eng))
Well, i know how bobby bearhug died in the game It's because when she was transferred to her new body she was born deaf, mute, paraplegic, blind and didn't know what was happening because she couldn't hear or see anything or move. There's even a picture of her bigger body just lying on the floor maybe lifeless, I don't know about that and Scientists think she's a failed experiment after she died (she died because of her's life condition) (And maybe her lines on the speech chart are a metaphor for the scientists having abandoned her without hearing, without sight and without movement).
That’s not her bigger body that was torn on the ground, it was actually a security camera. In the ARG, it is explained that two Bobby bearhug statues were placed in the children’s living quarters to watch them at all times
If you look at catnap he is huge and some stitches on his body, and he's voice is broken just like in the tape , this could tells us that he was being controlled by the prototype or maybe following orders cause the prototype fixed him or saved him from death and this tells us cause dogday is way smaller than catnap and some a giant spine on catnap so that's just my theory.
this teory is great but, catnap is sick, he was in hospital and couldn't breathe by himself, that means maybe he couldn't speak as well
Thats a pretty dumb theory cause if the Prototype and Catnap were allies the Prototype wouldnt have killed him. I know that Catnap looks up to the Prototype and treats him like a god, but i dont think the Prototype is as kind.
@@aj.438he probably became sick from the gas he was breathing constantly, I think the reason why his breathing is shallow and dead and catnap was most vulnerable to his control is because of the Insanity and damages that occur from his own body seemingly storing or creating that toxic gas.
@@somerandomchad469 the theory isn't really dumb because you can save someone without caring about them. Palpatine saved Anakin on the lava bed but he doesn't care about Anakin at ALL besides personal gain, for catnap and prototype it's not the same thing exactly but the dynamic is basically the same a puppet master wanting to keep a puppet alive until it's uselessness is ended.
@@somerandomchad469 Infact hilariously enough I just accidentally bumped into a connection "The mentally unstable character on the brink of death is rescued by their master to live and now has an indentured servitude" 😂
For some reason, whenever I hear Hoppy Hopstotch saying " JUUUUUUUU- " at the end I find it really funny 💀