My favorite anecdotal classical story is about this symphony. Bruckner was visiting his idol Wagner in Bayrueth in 1873 to dedicate either his 1st or 3rd to the master. Bruckner played for Wagner both symphonies on the piano. Wagner at his charming best- yes he had that side-then invited Bruckner to drink some local Weiss beer. Bruckner protested and said he couldn't but Wagner said "Oh come now! Bayreutzer beer is good for you" Then two of the greatest composers of all time got very drunk! Staggering back to his hotel, Bruckner couldn't remember which symphony he had dedicated to Wagner! On hotel stationary he sent back to Wagner " The symphony with trumpet call at the beginning?" [This one] Wagner wrote back on it " Yes yes ! Hearty greetings! R. Wagner. " Bruckner treasured the note all his life.
You are entitled to your opinion but I prefer: I. Mehr langsam, misterioso - 5:21 II. Adagio, bewegt, quasi Andante - 40:51 III. Ziemlich schnell - 94:15 IV. Allegro - 1:02
I really appreciate this orchestra for putting their performances on UA-cam for everyone to enjoy. At last an orchestra that doesn't live in the past, and has adapted to the new times. Thank you a lot, and keep going!!! :D
I first heard this gem of a symphony by sheer chance and was bowled over . I was lucky enough to get tickets to the centenery Ring Cycle in Bayreuth 1976 Boulez/ Chereau and managed to buy 2 tickets for the Munich orchestra /Celibidache which just happened to be on the night between Walkure and Siegfried and a nice drive from Bayreuth . It was magnificent and i will never forget that experience.( no other conductor would dare take the final pages so slowly ). This too is a very good performance and Jarvi is a fine conductor. Great recording and camera work.
The Bruckner’s symphonies are real masterpieces. Although is difficult at first time to be involved in his music, but as far as we continue to heart his works we discover the beauty of his music that touches us deeply and is incomparable to everything that has been composed until the present day. His music simultaneously is majestic and with strong lyricism that are unparalleled. The orchestra performance and direction are magnificent. Thanks for this remarkable recording.
I think we've found a conductor that breathes fresh air into these old dinosaurs of works. Bruckner has always been a hit and miss affair in the concert hall. But that was very good. I'm hoping Jarvi has done the full set. Bravo.
The 3rd is one of my favorite Bruckner symphonies. It doesn't have the gravitas of the later symphonies but there's a rare warmth and sweetness about it. Thank you for this fine performance.
@@hrh2842 PIT's only symphony in a major key and lacking the strong, dark dramatic profile of the others. Perhaps that's why it is played in concert so seldom.
Bruckner’s symphonies have a immeasurable profound attraction. Comfort and solemnity of Bruckner’s symphonyies are off the charts From A Brucknerian of Tokyo
I love Bruckner and I love Järvi, what more can I say? Oh yes, I can say thank you very much indeed to the hr_Sinfonieorchester for putting up these videos! It's a lovely orchestra, with a beautiful sound, and very generous to share this online.
This symphony was my first exposure to Bruckner, and it remains one of my favorite symphonic pieces. It has a very modern sound about it, even though it was composed in the late 19th century. Bruckner's symphonies are so majestic and mysterious, with an ambiguous and tentative quality about them. There are no assertive resolutions to his symphonies, in contrast to other symphonic composers like Beethoven, Schumann and Brahms.
At first I used to dread Bruckner nights at the proms (though some parts were thrilling) but I came to Get it More and he's now an enthusiasm of mine. I thought this performance, though it might not milk the grand and impressive bits to the limit, it makes it sound an organic and logical progression. And the opening is beautifully well balanced with the trumpet being part of the texture, not the soloist.
Marvellous! I heard this symphony for the first time at the Festival hall South bank London May 3rd 2019, four days ago - the London Philharmonic conducted by Vladimir Jurowski, and it was truly thrilling . So glad to come across this performance by Paavo Jarvi.
This is the right tempo! So energetic! Probably it can be even faster! Bruckner fans are usually too attracted to his later spiritual works. But, if Bruckner's Beethoven style personality is not understood, one will often ask how can this seemingly shy and humble man compose so spiritual, gigantic symphonies. That's a fundamental misunderstanding of this man.
Во-первых спасибо что видео без рекламы! Во-вторых или это Гугл так переводит или немцы все так пишут комментарии (как фельдмаршал Манштейн) воду в ступе толкут.
I heartily disagree. And so does Bruckner. In his will he said which version he considered the definte one. For the 3rd it is the 1877 version. The 1889 version is a truncated mess, that he should never have spent time on.
@@QuotenwagnerianerWell, Bruckner was wrong, his best version is the 1873. Mind you I'll take any version of a Bruckner symphony they are all wonderful even if the eccentric old composer never believed it himself. The more versions the better as far as I'm concerned .. I still live in hopes even more turn up somewhere. 😊
@@gezobel Bruckner was not wrong. It was his opinion. And his counts. I also prefer the 1873 version but if he considered the 1877 to be his definite one, then that's it.
This performance these performers with splendid skill and specutacular technique is beyond description , immeasurable , unfathomable and inspirational , and full of admiration and deep emotion , and comfortable to the ear and the mind From Tokyo of the Land of the Rising Sun 🇯🇵
We had in program the 2nd Mahler's symphony at a Festival of Sacred music in Rome, many years ago, but they changed the program (I don't know the reason behind), so it was the 3rd Symphony of Bruckner to be the new program gem. There's no other Symphony which can compete with the Resurrection of Mahler, especially on such occasions as Sacred Music Festival. Very beautiful, profound, with solemnity and richness of sound and melody, etc. I usually don't comment here, but listening to this recording, it reminded me about those times and made me relive musically this beautiful score. ❤
I absolutely love your rendering of this Bruckner symphony, as well as Paavo Järvi's other recordings of Bruckner's symphonies with this orchestra. Your interpretations have finally brought me around to appreciating Bruckner's works. Thank you very much for this! :-)
OK! I just watched this performance again. For the 101th time+/=. Really enjoyed it. My favorite recording of the 1889 Edition is with Hartmut Haenchen and the Netherlands Philharmonic Orchestra on a 1991 CD. The brass just blazes as they gallop out in the 4th movement! Eugen Jocum was great with Bruckner and the orchestras he recorded with: I've treasured his recordings with Berlin, Munich, Amsterdam, and Dresden. But Jarvi and Frankfurt Radio here deserve to be on anyone's short list! Thanks for streaming!!!
This is probably only the 50th...or maybe 100th time I have watched this particular performance. I really like the 1889 version, with the brass racing to the finish line. I just wish we could have a further revised edition, call it the 1889+ Edition, including the intriguing coda in the Third Movement of the 1877 Edition. Great concert hall, BTW! SPASIBA!!! BRAVO!!! PARABENS A TODOS!!!
With its beauty, majesty and spirituality, this is music that can suspend time and touch eternity. But Bruckner was also "earthy", and his 3rd and 6th Symphonies to me also exemplify this quality of being totally friendly and accessible. I especially love the lilting second subject of the finale here (first at 42:03); and I never noticed before the extent of the cyclical structure of the work. I've not heard the original 1873 version yet, but certainly plan to do so; composer Robert Simpson said that it has a "majestic momentum that later versions altogether destroyed". This 1889 version is nonetheless quite impressive, especially in this fine performance!
@@Jy3pr6 visit antonbruckner.com. There, you will find extensive tables wich guide your listening; all made by William Carragan. This tables contain not only bars and themes, but minutes and seconds of one or several referencial recordings.
I Gemäßigt, mehr bewegt, misterioso (Moderate, more animated, mysterious) (also Sehr langsam, misterioso) - D minor 00:00 II Adagio. Bewegt, quasi Andante (With motion, as if Andante) - E-flat major 20:42 III Scherzo. Ziemlich schnell (Fairly fast) (also Sehr schnell) - D minor, ending in D major 34:08 IV Finale. Allegro (also Ziemlich schnell) - D minor, ending in D major 40:55
Wunderbare Aufnahme! Und jetzt noch der Bildregie erklären, was eine Bratsche ist, und dann beim Andante quasi Allegretto im 2.Satz auch mal zeigen...:)
Die etwas seltsame Bildregie ist wohl dem Umstand geschuldet, dass die Aufnahme im Kurhaus Wiesbaden entstand, wo der hr nicht die in der Alten Oper oder im hr Sendesaal vorhandenen Möglichkeiten hatte.
Okay so I heard this piece this morning in my car on Iowa Public Radio classical and what I like is they will give the name of the piece and composer after it finishes so I was sitting there in my car for over an hour waiting for it to finish. Don’t misunderstand it’s good, but to me it seemed Bruckner kept teasing you thinking the finale would happen soon, but never does.
At 14:38 Bruckner wonderfully re-harmonizes (or harmonically enriches by filling in) the opening section. Masterful! Also, the associate concertmaster is missing in some of the first movement, yet she reappears at certain points. And the second bassoon player has a mute(?) in her bell...??
As i recall it, the story which surrounds it is that Bruckner got to meet Wagner, showed him two symphonies and let Wagner choose which one he would like to be dedicated to him. Then, Bruckner got so shitfaced that the next morning, he couldn't remember which one Wagner had chosen, so he had to send him a letter and ask hahaha
....me empecé a familiarizar con la música de Bruckner, escuchando una grabación de esta sinfonía, hace 60 años. Siempre escuche que esta era la sinfonía Wagner del maestro austríaco
I would choose Eugen Euchum's (Classical Music/Reference recordings channel) rendition over this one. I have not got enough experience to express the reason, I only feel it.
I wish that Paavo had put Symphonies 1,2, and 3, with the marvellous Frankfurt Radio Orchestra, on to DVDs, They are just as good as his later symphonies. Paavo's interpretation of Bruckner Symphonies, is far superior to most other conductors. I have the Barenboim set of Mature? Symphonies,on DVD, but he failed to record 1,2,and 3, which would have made the set complete (with the 00 and the 0.) included.
I love all of Bruckner's symphonies ... but there is a (too much) short passage in this 3rd which is sublime : from 20'50" to 23'00" ... this melody comes directly from the sky .. .
I just watched this performance of the Bruckner Third once again. Great! As I have mentioned before, it would be fun to substitute the Scherzo from the 1877-78 version with the coda, to the 1889 edition with the brass blazing away out the door in the fourth movement. This week I am re-watching all of Paavo Jarvi's Bruckner performances posted on YT. Cheers!
Bruckner never stopped revising. Later editions a la Nowak seem to me more polished perhaps more playable. Good to experience the earlier raw power but the influence of critics on Bruckner ultimately improved the product.
Bruckner is just an awesome composer ... people always yell about Beethoven , Mozart , Wagner .... Bruckner just seems to be a forgotten composer that is so rediculous Listen to this and be blown away
I want to end last my life under cherry blossoms in full bloom while listening to this Symphony and being bathed in the blizzard of falling cherry blossoms petals at the brilliant night of the moon . From Tokyo in Japan Which national are you watching this video ？
@@seawanderer8371 Thank-you so much to your fabulous , and specutacular comments Take care of yourself I think without Bruckner's symphonies in this world , this world would have been very lonely and I would feel that the music world is like the taste of stale beer Good luck ！ by the way Someday please come to Japan Japan waits for you Beyond description's Japanese delicious foods , immeasurable heartfelt hospitality and unfathomable amazing and marvellous things wait for you Good luck ！
We have 110 professional full-time orchestras in Germany - a unique “landscape” worldwide. This orchestra is that of the Hessischer Rundfunk, Frankfurt, financed by the fees of all German households - every tenant has to pay 18.00 euros a month, whether they want to or not. In return we get a state-independent radio net and various television stations...
IMHO, outstanding performance, passionate beauty accuracy. just at 27:46 a bit too much speedy for a quasi andante. Paavo Järvi likes it fast, but he's just magnificent.
Um, ziemlich schnell? 38:52 III is closer to Rock. I'm not sure, because it was published in 1890, 8 years before Mahler's 3rd. and in the German, "measured" is more important than "ziemlich" (rather). In any event, the orchestra does slow down a bit, but I've heard this played much slower.
@@remotoadamotroppovelocelaf868 Ho provato, ma non mi hanno entusiasmato. Ignoranza mia in ogni caso, come nel caso del tale che giudica il vino che ha bevuto, solo dopo averne letta l'etichetta.
This is bugging me...those recurring four booming notes. Where have I heard this before? I've never heard of Bruckner till now. Where could I have heard these notes before? EDIT: Found it: The finale of Shosty 12. Now who copied whom here? No, I don't believe anyone copied anyone. Composers are perfectly capable of INDEPENDENTLY coming up with similar-sounding melodies by sheer coincidence.
I love this- ab 47:27 min das tönt genau wie Howard shores musik in LOTR 3 wo Legolas auf den Olifant springt!!!!!!!!!!!!! HAMMER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
My favorite anecdotal classical story is about this symphony. Bruckner was visiting his idol Wagner in Bayrueth in 1873 to dedicate either his 1st or 3rd to the master. Bruckner played for Wagner both symphonies on the piano. Wagner at his charming best- yes he had that side-then invited Bruckner to drink some local Weiss beer. Bruckner protested and said he couldn't but Wagner said "Oh come now! Bayreutzer beer is good for you" Then two of the greatest composers of all time got very drunk! Staggering back to his hotel, Bruckner couldn't remember which symphony he had dedicated to Wagner! On hotel stationary he sent back to Wagner " The symphony with trumpet call at the beginning?" [This one] Wagner wrote back on it " Yes yes ! Hearty greetings! R. Wagner. " Bruckner treasured the note all his life.
Love that story--calls for a Guinness, that's all I got in the fridge.
Nice story.. I heard he gave Wagner the choice between the 2nd and 3rd.
@@BritinIsrael Yes, it was the 2nd and 3rd.
wonderful story, wonderful
And nicknamed Bruckner "Herr Trumpet."
I. Mehr langsam, misterioso - 0:21
II. Adagio, bewegt, quasi Andante - 20:51
III. Ziemlich schnell - 34:15
IV. Allegro - 41:02
You are entitled to your opinion but I prefer:
I. Mehr langsam, misterioso - 5:21
II. Adagio, bewegt, quasi Andante - 40:51
III. Ziemlich schnell - 94:15
IV. Allegro - 1:02
@@autismscience8534 Username checks out
Thank you.
@@autismscience8534 Imbecil.
@@alexsandroalvesartecultura5116 They said that about Bruckner's symphonies too.
I really appreciate this orchestra for putting their performances on UA-cam for everyone to enjoy. At last an orchestra that doesn't live in the past, and has adapted to the new times. Thank you a lot, and keep going!!! :D
Absolully rigth. Adpating to new time.
@Val O'Brien adapting to the new times as I understood it was aimed not towards the performance itself, but putting it's recording on the internet.
My reference for Bruckner symphonies is BPO/Barenboim (also BPO/Wand), but I have to say that Järvi does a magnificent work with this rendition.
@Val O'Brien Guess you'll have to get rid of all your audio recordings in your collection, by this logic.
My favs!
When the conductor loves the orchestra and the orchestra loves the conductor then all prayers have been fulfilled !
I first heard this gem of a symphony by sheer chance and was bowled over . I was lucky enough to get tickets to the centenery Ring Cycle in Bayreuth 1976 Boulez/ Chereau and managed to buy 2 tickets for the Munich orchestra /Celibidache which just happened to be on the night between Walkure and Siegfried and a nice drive from Bayreuth . It was magnificent and i will never forget that experience.( no other conductor would dare take the final pages so slowly ). This too is a very good performance and Jarvi is a fine conductor. Great recording and camera work.
The starting of a symphony the most beautiful in the world for me
The Bruckner’s symphonies are real masterpieces. Although is difficult at first time to be involved in his music, but as far as we continue to heart his works we discover the beauty of his music that touches us deeply and is incomparable to everything that has been composed until the present day. His music simultaneously is majestic and with strong lyricism that are unparalleled. The orchestra performance and direction are magnificent. Thanks for this remarkable recording.
A long car ride alone is perfect. Magical stuff. Music at its very best.
知道楊頌斯的人一定會法文
No , they are not masterpieces. They are all boring.
@@thefrankonionThere's always one .. 🤣
This is an outstanding performance with excellent sound for a UA-cam video.
Great performance! It is always a pleasure to listen to the Frankfurt Radio Symphony Orchestra. Many thanks for these uploads.
Oh my goodness ...that was magnificent !
I think we've found a conductor that breathes fresh air into these old dinosaurs of works. Bruckner has always been a hit and miss affair in the concert hall. But that was very good. I'm hoping Jarvi has done the full set. Bravo.
After Wand every Bruckner concert has been a miss for me.
Bruckner’s symphonies must quench and moisturize the dryness of the soul
The 3rd is one of my favorite Bruckner symphonies. It doesn't have the gravitas of the later symphonies but there's a rare warmth and sweetness about it. Thank you for this fine performance.
",,,,,,warmth and sweetness," just like Tchaikovsky's Third.
@@hrh2842 PIT's only symphony in a major key and lacking the strong, dark dramatic profile of the others. Perhaps that's why it is played in concert so seldom.
Great symphony❤
Beautiful performance 👏
Bruckner’s symphonies have a immeasurable profound attraction.
Comfort and solemnity of Bruckner’s symphonyies are off the charts
From
A Brucknerian of Tokyo
I love Bruckner and I love Järvi, what more can I say? Oh yes, I can say thank you very much indeed to the hr_Sinfonieorchester for putting up these videos! It's a lovely orchestra, with a beautiful sound, and very generous to share this online.
This symphony was my first exposure to Bruckner, and it remains one of my favorite symphonic pieces. It has a very modern sound about it, even though it was composed in the late 19th century. Bruckner's symphonies are so majestic and mysterious, with an ambiguous and tentative quality about them. There are no assertive resolutions to his symphonies, in contrast to other symphonic composers like Beethoven, Schumann and Brahms.
Dennis Middlebrooks Same happen to me, after that I fall in love with Buckner.
At first I used to dread Bruckner nights at the proms (though some parts were thrilling) but I came to Get it More and he's now an enthusiasm of mine. I thought this performance, though it might not milk the grand and impressive bits to the limit, it makes it sound an organic and logical progression. And the opening is beautifully well balanced with the trumpet being part of the texture, not the soloist.
0
It wasn’t my first exposure to Bruckner, but it was the symphony that won me over to his music.
The seventh was my first exposure, and remains my favorite Bruckner. First loves are eternal loves...
I was swallowed by a whirlpool of emotion with so much powerful performance ,
Paavo Jarvi and Frankfurt Radio --- a perfect combination .
11:07 just wow! Bruckner seems to be in a continual process of transformation, from inner to outer, from minor to major, just wonderful.
Paavo Jarvi is the most spot on conductor I've ever seen !
Sehr ernsthafte und ausgezeichnete live Aufführung dieser schönsten Sinfonie Bruckners. Danke fürs Hochladen mit höchster Tonqualität!
Ganz richtig. Tadellos.
Фантастическое исполнение симфонии!!! Главные сольные инструменты - первая флейта и первая валторна просто на высоте!!!
Fantastico Jarvi! Esecuzione ed interpretazione superlative.
Another discovery by me of the work of the incomparable Bruckner. Thank you.
Любимая моя симфония Брукнера. Спасибо за запись.
Marvellous! I heard this symphony for the first time at the Festival hall South bank London May 3rd 2019, four days ago - the London Philharmonic conducted by Vladimir Jurowski, and it was truly thrilling . So glad to come across this performance by Paavo Jarvi.
Check out more Bruckner, especially liking Jarvis interpretations, and as for that marvelous orchestra. Absolutely perfect sound...
This is the right tempo! So energetic! Probably it can be even faster!
Bruckner fans are usually too attracted to his later spiritual works. But, if Bruckner's Beethoven style personality is not understood, one will often ask how can this seemingly shy and humble man compose so spiritual, gigantic symphonies. That's a fundamental misunderstanding of this man.
Still waters run deep
Great performance of one of my favorite Bruckner's symphonies, and Clara Andrada is gorgeous !
A young relative of Mary Kay Place?
From Paavo Jarvi best Bruckner for my ears...
Perfect sound
Во-первых спасибо что видео без рекламы!
Во-вторых или это Гугл так переводит или немцы все так пишут комментарии (как фельдмаршал Манштейн) воду в ступе толкут.
you gotta love the facial expressions the conductor makes through the piece.
Such solid timpani playing on the very last final triumphant chords at 52: 37 BRAVO !!!!
Maravilosa composición de Brukner y maravillosa interpretación de todos los músicos que conforman la orquesta. Muchas felicidades!!
you know a Bruckner piece when you hear it.
totally absoluttely
You know you're a Brucknerian when you have a favorite version of his third symphony. The 1889 version is my favorite 😊
I do agree !
Mine too.
I heartily disagree. And so does Bruckner. In his will he said which version he considered the definte one. For the 3rd it is the 1877 version.
The 1889 version is a truncated mess, that he should never have spent time on.
@@QuotenwagnerianerWell, Bruckner was wrong, his best version is the 1873. Mind you I'll take any version of a Bruckner symphony they are all wonderful even if the eccentric old composer never believed it himself. The more versions the better as far as I'm concerned .. I still live in hopes even more turn up somewhere. 😊
@@gezobel Bruckner was not wrong. It was his opinion. And his counts.
I also prefer the 1873 version but if he considered the 1877 to be his definite one, then that's it.
10:50 a colossal choral worthy of Bruckner (brass, timpanies ans strings)
Thank you for sharing this fine performance!
This performance these performers with splendid skill and specutacular technique is beyond description , immeasurable , unfathomable and inspirational , and full of admiration and deep emotion , and comfortable to the ear and the mind
From
Tokyo of the Land of the Rising Sun 🇯🇵
Järvi hat gezeigt, dass wir auf der Höhe der großen Regisseure sind. Dieses großartige Arbeit glänzt mit dem Push leprovoca dessen Direktor. Brave
We had in program the 2nd Mahler's symphony at a Festival of Sacred music in Rome, many years ago, but they changed the program (I don't know the reason behind), so it was the 3rd Symphony of Bruckner to be the new program gem. There's no other Symphony which can compete with the Resurrection of Mahler, especially on such occasions as Sacred Music Festival. Very beautiful, profound, with solemnity and richness of sound and melody, etc.
I usually don't comment here, but listening to this recording, it reminded me about those times and made me relive musically this beautiful score. ❤
I absolutely love your rendering of this Bruckner symphony, as well as Paavo Järvi's other recordings of Bruckner's symphonies with this orchestra. Your interpretations have finally brought me around to appreciating Bruckner's works. Thank you very much for this! :-)
Absolutely right! Paavo Järvi is really doing a good job, although rather fast, very clear and precise.
Paavo Jarvi's interpretation of Bruckner's 3rd is spot on. Also check out Bychov's interpretation of Mahler's 3rd...simply magnificent 🙌
OK! I just watched this performance again. For the 101th time+/=. Really enjoyed it. My favorite recording of the 1889 Edition is with Hartmut Haenchen and the Netherlands Philharmonic Orchestra on a 1991 CD. The brass just blazes as they gallop out in the 4th movement! Eugen Jocum was great with Bruckner and the orchestras he recorded with: I've treasured his recordings with Berlin, Munich, Amsterdam, and Dresden. But Jarvi and Frankfurt Radio here deserve to be on anyone's short list! Thanks for streaming!!!
El maestro P.Járvi , siempre muestra un rostro amable además de ser un magnífico director
I like this video too much !!!
🎻💿🎵🎼🎶🎻💿🎵🎼🎶🎻💿🎵🎼🎶🎻💿🎵🎼🎶🎻💿🎵🎼🎶🎻💿🎵🎼🎶🎻💿🎵🎼🎶🎻
from PERSIA ArmeniA Israel with Passion
This is probably only the 50th...or maybe 100th time I have watched this particular performance. I really like the 1889 version, with the brass racing to the finish line. I just wish we could have a further revised edition, call it the 1889+ Edition, including the intriguing coda in the Third Movement of the 1877 Edition. Great concert hall, BTW! SPASIBA!!! BRAVO!!! PARABENS A TODOS!!!
Very good interpretation and performance. Enjoyed it.
With its beauty, majesty and spirituality, this is music that can suspend time and touch eternity. But Bruckner was also "earthy", and his 3rd and 6th Symphonies to me also exemplify this quality of being totally friendly and accessible. I especially love the lilting second subject of the finale here (first at 42:03); and I never noticed before the extent of the cyclical structure of the work. I've not heard the original 1873 version yet, but certainly plan to do so; composer Robert Simpson said that it has a "majestic momentum that later versions altogether destroyed". This 1889 version is nonetheless quite impressive, especially in this fine performance!
ronald b woodall Could you recommend a performance of the 1873 version? Preferably on YT
His revisions of the adagio were actually improvements.
@@Jy3pr6 visit antonbruckner.com. There, you will find extensive tables wich guide your listening; all made by William Carragan. This tables contain not only bars and themes, but minutes and seconds of one or several referencial recordings.
I Gemäßigt, mehr bewegt, misterioso (Moderate, more animated, mysterious) (also Sehr langsam, misterioso) - D minor 00:00
II Adagio. Bewegt, quasi Andante (With motion, as if Andante) - E-flat major 20:42
III Scherzo. Ziemlich schnell (Fairly fast) (also Sehr schnell) - D minor, ending in D major 34:08
IV Finale. Allegro (also Ziemlich schnell) - D minor, ending in D major 40:55
Sounds sublime , complex ,a salve for a busy mind, 🙂
It purifies the soul filled with chaos .
Wunderbare Aufnahme! Und jetzt noch der Bildregie erklären, was eine Bratsche ist, und dann beim Andante quasi Allegretto im 2.Satz auch mal zeigen...:)
Die etwas seltsame Bildregie ist wohl dem Umstand geschuldet, dass die Aufnahme im Kurhaus Wiesbaden entstand, wo der hr nicht die in der Alten Oper oder im hr Sendesaal vorhandenen Möglichkeiten hatte.
Okay so I heard this piece this morning in my car on Iowa Public Radio classical and what I like is they will give the name of the piece and composer after it finishes so I was sitting there in my car for over an hour waiting for it to finish. Don’t misunderstand it’s good, but to me it seemed Bruckner kept teasing you thinking the finale would happen soon, but never does.
Bruckner loves to edge his listeners
Marvelous, thank you!
At 14:38 Bruckner wonderfully re-harmonizes (or harmonically enriches by filling in) the opening section. Masterful! Also, the associate concertmaster is missing in some of the first movement, yet she reappears at certain points. And the second bassoon player has a mute(?) in her bell...??
0, 3, 4 my favorite Bruckner
7, 8, 9 gut 2
0?
@@Jason-kx3cd The 0 symphony is good, but it lacks the monumental codas of Bruckner's later works
3, 7, 8 e 9.
Magnífica interpretación. Enhorabuena al metal.
So good to be with You ...
It was dedicated to Richard Wagner :)
And the slow movement has a wonderful passage that could have come straight out of Tannhauser!!
I do think so
... who often referred to Bruckner as "Trompeter Bruckner" :P
It actually has bits that DO come straight from Tristan.
As i recall it, the story which surrounds it is that Bruckner got to meet Wagner, showed him two symphonies and let Wagner choose which one he would like to be dedicated to him. Then, Bruckner got so shitfaced that the next morning, he couldn't remember which one Wagner had chosen, so he had to send him a letter and ask hahaha
....me empecé a familiarizar con la música de Bruckner, escuchando una grabación de esta sinfonía, hace 60 años. Siempre escuche que esta era la sinfonía Wagner del maestro austríaco
This is an incredible performance of Bruckner's Third!
最もブルックナーらしい音楽。
ただただ圧倒的。
不気味なほどの迫力、美しさはブルックナー交響曲中最高峰かも。
34:14 Soooo energetic! Wonderful indeed.
Un homenaje a Wagner expresado con certeza por el compositor y con Jarvi encabezando magistralmente la orquesta.
Very GOOD! Thank you very MUCH~~~()
I would choose Eugen Euchum's (Classical Music/Reference recordings channel) rendition over this one. I have not got enough experience to express the reason, I only feel it.
I wish that Paavo had put Symphonies 1,2, and 3, with the marvellous Frankfurt Radio Orchestra, on to DVDs, They are just as good as his later symphonies. Paavo's interpretation of Bruckner Symphonies, is far superior to most other conductors.
I have the Barenboim set of Mature? Symphonies,on DVD, but he failed to record 1,2,and 3, which would have made the set complete (with the 00 and the 0.) included.
I love all of Bruckner's symphonies ... but there is a (too much) short passage in this 3rd which is sublime : from 20'50" to 23'00" ... this melody comes directly from the sky .. .
This is the first Bruckner symphony which I have played.
enjoy a true master
I just watched this performance of the Bruckner Third once again. Great! As I have mentioned before, it would be fun to substitute the Scherzo from the 1877-78 version with the coda, to the 1889 edition with the brass blazing away out the door in the fourth movement. This week I am re-watching all of Paavo Jarvi's Bruckner performances posted on YT. Cheers!
Bruckner never stopped revising. Later editions a la Nowak seem to me more polished perhaps more playable. Good to experience the earlier raw power but the influence of critics on Bruckner ultimately improved the product.
Bruckner is just an awesome composer ... people always yell about Beethoven , Mozart , Wagner ....
Bruckner just seems to be a forgotten composer that is so rediculous
Listen to this and be blown away
Simply stunning
I heard it with Christian Thieleman at Grafenegg. I sadly do not remember the Orchestra.
51:30...best part.
Affascinante come le Sinfonie di Bruckner
I want to end last my life under cherry blossoms in full bloom while listening to this Symphony and being bathed in the blizzard of falling cherry blossoms petals at the brilliant night of the moon .
From Tokyo in Japan
Which national are you watching this video ？
Beautiful image :-)
Shin-i-chi Kozima Porando kara kimashita demo Kannada ni sunde imasune
@@seawanderer8371
Thank-you so much to your fabulous , and specutacular comments
Take care of yourself
I think
without Bruckner's symphonies in this world ,
this world would have been very lonely
and I would feel that the music world is like the taste of stale beer
Good luck ！
by the way
Someday please come to Japan
Japan waits for you
Beyond description's Japanese delicious foods , immeasurable heartfelt hospitality and unfathomable amazing and marvellous things wait for you
Good luck ！
@@miroslavtokarski
Thank-you so much to your fabulous Japanese comments
Someday please come to Japan
Japan waits for you who love Japan
This is not a "song." It is a symphony.
Прекрасный концерт!
No, but three trombones!
We have 110 professional full-time orchestras in Germany - a unique “landscape” worldwide. This orchestra is that of the Hessischer Rundfunk, Frankfurt, financed by the fees of all German households - every tenant has to pay 18.00 euros a month, whether they want to or not. In return we get a state-independent radio net and various television stations...
Perhaps you should precise in your description that the 3rd and 4rth movements (Finale : Allegro) are following each other without interruption.
0:20 is a good place to start.
Maravillosa sinfonía. En algunos pasajes se advierte el germen de la Cuarta...
Pra mim, só a 5 e a nona fazem uma equipe com está. A 4, 7 e a 8 são bem distintas mesmo que a 8 faz passagens se referindo à 7.
haha so much applause I just cried .......
le début de cette symphonie me rappelle celui de la 9è, mystérieux aussi
IMHO, outstanding performance, passionate beauty accuracy. just at 27:46 a bit too much speedy for a quasi andante. Paavo Järvi likes it fast, but he's just magnificent.
SAI DAQUI BOZOMINION, AS MILÍCIAS ESTÃO SENDO DESMASCARADAS
Excellent.
Merci beaucoup
Um, ziemlich schnell? 38:52 III is closer to Rock.
I'm not sure, because it was published in 1890, 8 years before Mahler's 3rd. and in the German, "measured" is more important than "ziemlich" (rather). In any event, the orchestra does slow down a bit, but I've heard this played much slower.
That was actually a nicely shaped, but rather "tame" Bruckner third.
Pity he didn't use the score of the other version of the scherzo with an extended exhilarating ending.
Desmond P T Are you referring to the 1873 version?
Nope. That is the 1877 version.
@@Quotenwagnerianer no is the 78 version
There is no '78 Version.
@@Quotenwagnerianer is 77/78 actually the 77 is the version without that coda from the scherzo he's refering
Ho sempre pensato che la direzione di Celibidache, quando si tratta di Brukner, sia la migliore. Ma anche Järvi si colloca bene. Mi piace.
Ha mai ascoltato la V diretta da karajan? E anche la I. Lo faccia è poi mi dica.
@@remotoadamotroppovelocelaf868 Ho provato, ma non mi hanno entusiasmato. Ignoranza mia in ogni caso, come nel caso del tale che giudica il vino che ha bevuto, solo dopo averne letta l'etichetta.
FRS = world class orchestra
Where is the co-leader at 8:38? Empty chair?
Rotundamente fantástica!
This is bugging me...those recurring four booming notes. Where have I heard this before? I've never heard of Bruckner till now. Where could I have heard these notes before? EDIT: Found it: The finale of Shosty 12. Now who copied whom here? No, I don't believe anyone copied anyone. Composers are perfectly capable of INDEPENDENTLY coming up with similar-sounding melodies by sheer coincidence.
Good Chef, but Remember Sir Solti and Thielmann🌹
I love this- ab 47:27 min das tönt genau wie Howard shores musik in LOTR 3 wo Legolas auf den Olifant springt!!!!!!!!!!!!! HAMMER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!