I’m a Sindhi and I cannot thank my grandparents enough for choosing to live in India. Wonder what Najam Sethi saab would say about Mr Kaptaan and the post-Zardari era in Pakistan.
Me too. I am a Sindhi and I am thankful to my Nana and Nani to come to India. The amount of freedom and love we get from India is and will never be comparable to any other country let alone Pakistan
@@soneetramchandani61 Nice to know this but better not talk about Pakistan. You're happy there in India and we are happy here in Pakistan! So there's no use of bringing Pakistan and Pakistanis in between everything........! 🙏
@@sabihanaz7277 Of course you’re happy there, now that you’ve forced all non-Muslims out. But we still think about Sindh as the land of our ancestors … an integral part of our shared history and civilization. And yours too except you’ve been indoctrinated to believe that civilization began after Muhammad bin Qasim arrived with his tribal army on camels and donkeys and enslaved your people. And you choose to believe it as some sort of gospel truth. That is why we need to mention Pakistan - to call out your fraudulent account of history. Outside of that, you’ve done a pretty good job of ruining your own country… You don’t need India for that.
@@alpha-engineer Your name suggests you are a observer but you doesn't seem to be at all. Of course Sindh is important for you, even it is in your anthem.......(though it shouldn't be now). I know that Sindh had a rich historic and cultural background but I never heard anyone here in Pakistan say about Muhammad Bin Qasim as you are saying. Obviously, the history of Sindh dates back to thousands of years ago and I acknowledge it. But the concept of enslavement.....!?? It's out of my understanding and how are we ruining our country? If sticking to your religion and working day and night for your country with sincere devotion is called ruining........then let us ruin our country! Peace 🙏
@Usman Rafique you will not find any....because only extremism is the language your senses understand...and as far as my knowledge is concerned...no extremist is that much popular in India
@Usman Rafique That's why I m telling come once u will see...and about toilet for rural areas its a good initiative taken by bill gates towards our nation.....Any great person in the world even visited Pakistan...They don't even want to
@@siddharthsaxena2310 ko si duniya me ho bhai.....it was a fake news which circulated all the social media along with other fake news.....you need to verify before speak
In the year 1956 almost near the same date Two Countries took two diametrically opposite decisions regarding language 1.Srilanka with (only 2 major languages) passed an act imposing only sinhalese as the language throughout the country........Then followed the Tamil Sinhalese conflict which burns till today 2.India (with 20 major languages about 10 so big numerically as to be in top 20 languages of the world ) took a surprising decision to Divide/Reorganize the country on linguistic basis.What seemed to many international "experts" as a sure formula for balkanization of India..But lo and behold! the country is now stronger than the sum of its states and is growing stronger by the day .
The best thing that happened in India is that no particular language is imposed on others. Hindi is an official language per se but other languages also gets a chance to develop.
Mahesh M. Blame all these on corrupt fame seeking Generals and all these creTion Of Again khan and Jinnah propted by ImperialistBritish the religion and its use by Mullahs who wants to be known as Power behind the throne
International powerful countrys thought that India can not survived 2 or 3 years coz of so many religions and language and various casts but what happen now India is growing stronger day by day bcoz of our love for our country jai hind
I like Mr.Sethi's sense of humor as he clinically analyses Pakistan's blunders. I like to listen to his analyses which are fair and clinical. I hope voices of intellectuals like him make the Pakistani powers that be work to make Pakistan a better country instead of being paranoid about Kashmir and India.
Aap ki saadgi per qurban jayen Rupesh :) Kabhi India k rural areas ki visit karien, quality of life ka pata chal jayega. Facebook per hi sirf ek dafa status rakh dein k Muslims ko gaye ka gosht khaaney ki ijazat milni chahye yeh in ka haq hai, aur aapko freedom of speech ka pata chal jayega. Ek dafa Jammu Kashmir ho ayen, Human rights ka bhi pata chal jayega. Aansu aajyengey aankhoon se.
@@sairahashwani8227 India k rural area choro pak ke to urban areas b rural hi lagte h, human rights violation FATA aur balochistan me hoten hai, Gaye ka gosht??? Tumhari relious feeling hurt hoti h to poora mulk aisa bibi k piche pad jata h.. Freedom of speech to mr. Bugti ko b thi.. Kyu marwa dia use???
The biggest mistake that Pakistan made was that they made Islam as the national religion. Combining politics and religion is the worst thing for a country. Economic progress is possible when religion is kept away from politics.
As a Pakistani, I 100% agree. One of the ways to achieve a progressive Pakistan is to make it tolerant, liberal & secular. Most of Pakistan's earliest leaders held these views. E.g: Ayub Khan, Bhutto & the founding father M. Ali Jinnah himself. Now I know some people here may not agree with all of their policies and acts and I don't either, but that's a separate debate. We're talking about the constitution here and before Zia it was a more liberal, moderate, modern Islam in the days of Ayub Khan & Bhutto. That's when Pakistan's economy progressed faster than India. Field of sciences probably was superior (established our space agency Suparco waayyy before India established theirs). We were better in sports & music as well. But then came Zia ul Haq, who brought Wahhabism from Saudi Arabia/Afghanistan and gave us Kalashinkovs, heroine, mullahs, religious extremism and terrorism. 30 years after his death we're still suffering coz of him
Yeah, learn from India fellows. One of the best Pakistani person that I have ever seen. A frank and neutral analysis. America is literally just using you all.
well ... u r right at some some point ... there is lack of education in Pakistan and india .... poverty is 2nd largest reason of all kinds of crimes and terrors... in all religions .... its the media who hits any religion .... this is media war
And yet, Proudly Indian, do you realise, that this foundation that contrast Pakistan's was laid by Nehruvian politics? Non-alignment, a mixed economy, stress on infra-structure, land reforms, secularism, women's rights, all go back to those initial decisions. But the BJP is at pains to run down that early direction, while the present Congress is unworthy of honouring that legacy.
@@azamkhan8963 chaiwala is better than your Playboy PM...tell him to control Inflation rate....MODI is well respected PM all around world...we don't need your fucking idea to make whom to PM. I hoped that Imran khan would be good PM for pakistan but he is worse than Nawaz Sharif. There is nothing in being Chaiwala to PM its a successful story. So better make valid comment rather than ranting without using brain.
@@azamkhan8963 our PM is counted among the most powerful personality of the world. Your Pakistan is now struggling to escape from being blacklisted by FATF, begging to IMF, China. Why don't you just accept the fact that India is baap.
What a great mind this Najm Sethi sb. i can only commend him admire him and respect him as our hero. Muneeb Farooq too v smart decent and intelligent. we can still hope to set the course of history right. we have to act honestly.
So much information packed in half hour. It was beautiful. I hope you bring another program in this series which will talk about more such blunders. So much to learn for everyone.
Very true facts. But there is one major blunder is missing. We learnt this in history class. Involving the army in the government was one great mistake. I think this blunder is so great that it's also a stain on the pak army
To Arsala khan, you are the type of muslim who can not take positive criticism for your own good. That's why pakistan is a failed state religiously and politically, cause Muslims like you have closed their eyes on reforms and completely blind in ignorance. I am proud to be an Indian muslim. And thankful to my parents to make the choice of staying in India. Salam.
HaziqTV jahil angresh ki gaad chat ne walo tumari okat Kya Hai Salo gadaro Kal tak Tera bap bharat jindabad bolata tha moka aane par bharat murdabad bol ne laga ye Hai tum gadaro ka Islam gatiya gadaro Ak din tume hindu ka gulam banaya ge yaad rakhana
We Pakistani knows that there many blunders made by politicians and Generals But Quid ideology based upon Islamic instructions, though we cannot implement it completely.Our people are following Islamic instructions and wants that there should be an Islamic system in the country.On other hand,we can prayer independently , we are not slave of any one individually but now a days, in India Muslims are treated as slave . Indians said Indian Muslims are traitors,What BJP and RSS is doing with Muslims in India? What is doing with Muslims in Kashmir? Quid said "Muslims in India will pass away in proving that they are loyal to India".This is becoming true,now.Have you answer? DR Zakir Naik has migrated from India b/c of cruel policies of Indian Government.You can think and understand both the countries in current scenerio.......May GOD bless you. Asslam O Allaikum
Sir, The blunder of blunders happened even before that. It happened when you opted for the '2- Nation theory' and was adamant not to accept independence if this is not accepted. Then you people tried to wash away any damn connection with your Hindustani culture and tried to connect with the Arabs. You had your own "well thought out plans" for doing so, but their culture and the way of living was a way different. The result was - you could not destroy your roots and also, you could not adopt Arabic culture either and therefore a certain distance was always there. Now they are not interested in sharing their wealth in the name of Religion. Live in the real world and work on the agenda to become self-sufficient. That's the only way.
Wow, what an analysis Sethi Sahab. I have to say that this is one of the rarest interviews on any Pakistani media that has explained the blunders in past of Pakistan.Great job..
i m an Indian but i m a big fan of najam sethi sahab, u r a grt scholar and u have tremendous way toh deliver ur knowledge which make me a big fan of urs.. whatever u say, its a complete analysis of what has actually happened around u and us..this is a big reason for the people to belive what actually has happened..most importantly ur face little a bit matches with my grand pa and the way u speak he also used speak in the same manner, particularly the body language u show..anyways love live najam sethi sahab, wish u all the best..heads off to ur knowledge..
I had never seen or heard anyone as brave as Mr Najam Sethi. People like him can only save Pakistan today. The reason he speaks from his mind and openly is because he is a true patriotic and a Pakistani at heart. He feels for Pakistan and genuinely wants Pakistan to improve. My best wishes for this great person......An Indian
@india ki ma ka bhosda Gandhi never demanded India.... It was Jinaah who wanted a separate islamic state, if feasible...pls request your madarsa admin to include history in your Jihadi Syllabus... apart from your default subjects of loading AK-47 and configuring bombs...
Sir Ji real fact was Nehru he was the real reason .he wants to rule but in reality he was dumb he was not even capable to be a peon so Gandhi decided to break country into 2 parts.you can blame to jinha too he deserves that too but root of the cause was Nehru
I am short of words to express my feelings on such a fair and wise analysis which has been done by Mr. Sethi on the issue which determines the future of a nation. Hat's off to Mr. Sethi,. People like Mr. Sethi Saab, should be given opportunity to lead the country if want to give a better future to the generations to come.
Incredible summary of Pakistan's history by Najam Sethi. Even a four-year History program at University can't teach you so much about Pakistan's blunders as this video does in 35 minutes. People like Najam Sethi and Husain Haqqani are very honest about the state of affairs in Pakistan.
I admire your clear head Mr. Sethi. I have always detested Non-alignment movement and other policies anchored by Nehru Ji, but you have explained why this was so much needed to a young India. I now understand he was visionary (followed by future leaders) and opted doing things right way. Thanks to all the Indian leaders who promoted Democracy, "unity in diversity" and secularism . This has laid a good foundation which has helped India to grow and develop despite various challenges. I really wish that there are more leaders like you in Pakistan. I hope, both countries live in peace and harmony so that we can transfer our attention to the development and fighting poverty rather than spending billions in fighting each other...
4th Blunder was the most grievous blunder! Probably it wd hv corrected previous 3 blunders! Military civil bureaucracy wd hv been brought under civilian control and one unit wd hv bn dissolved as Mujib had spelled it in his 6 points.
The way Mr. Najam sethi explains each thing and the expression he had on his face while telling tales was exceptional. I thoughrouly enjoyed this, but the most i enjoyed was Kargil. Proud Indian.
I am from India. Respect for Najam Sethi ji on his knowledge, analysis and his vision. I've been watching him and whatever he predicts, comes true almost all the time. We need millions of people like him on either side of the border.
There needs to be an update to this program. - Continuity & Summary on next decade would be educational for all . Pakistan still needs to progress in many areas compared to other countries who were born around the time or after Pakistan got created . Sethis saab is an honest intellectual who is bold & has clarity in thoughts - his narration is impressive too !
Gentleman(Sethi Sir) ko sun ke laga ke Pakistan mein bhi honest, sensible, knowledgeable and intelligent people hain. Such people are real assets of a country. God bless you and your troubled country.
mere khiyal naal top 10 galtiya jehriya ke apa history de wich kittia 10. No commen unity between pakistan. 9. Not paying any taxes and corrupt culture. 8. Jinnah saab not managing making a country with a clear cut vision, before he expired. 7. Interfering with Afghan mamle 6. Taliban promotion against India and Afghanistan, and now the sneak is biting us. 5. Not creating own technology, but relieving on foreign aid to run including army on payroll also. 4. Wars with India 3. Not ending Kashmir issue 2. Tight control of Pakistan of Corrupt Bad Men from Land lord families. 1. Janta voting on Corrupt Bad Men
Hamza Mukhtar 8) I would not say an islamic state, but maybe you are right, this was the best clear cut vision Jinnah saab could make, a Turkey kind of state. 3) I agree Indians started the problems, but we should have worked a lot more for peace, it is almost as crazy as north and south korea, to keep problems going for 60-70 years, while the world have moved forward, and we are still dealing with issues from WW2 times. Hopefully a permanent border can be made between India and Pakistan in coming years.
Hamza Mukhtar But is it not COMPLETE UTOPIA to think Pakistan will ever give away Gilgit-Baltistan, which is a part of kashmir. It is our route way to Central Asia and China? only someone complete insane would say yes to such a deal. The best way is to make permanent borders and make peace. Kashmiris must find a way to live in India like all other muslims of India (more then Pakistan) . In my eyes, Kashmir is not more a real issue in Pakistan, we have other more important problems, dealing with taliban, balochistan, karachi etc etc.
first time, I have watched a West Pakistani is speaking the facts. Pakistani always blame sheak Majib and India for splitting Pakistan . Thanks From 🇧🇩
Earlier I would be sad too but then I remember the Kargil war, Parliament attack, Mumbai attack and many other terrorist attacks done by these extremists. I have no sympathy for such terrorist family members. May these piggies rot in hell
Change starts by admitting mistakes first. Good to see such a realization from a top journalist, presented on mainstream media. To all indians: im glad to be living in a country where there is no Arnab Gwaswami.
@@akshay_wakodikar I disagree, the venom a spews is more contagious than all of these dictators combined. One can stand against dictators, as evident from the history, but you can never fight ideology.
I am an Indian . My Name is Shivkumar living in Ahmedabad, Gujarat. I appreciate that there are some people in Pakistan who realise their mistakes.they don't blame others for their hardships.I think that if you had worked for the betterment of yourselves after Independence you didn't need to blame others.you are still not doing ,what you should do.The most important thing you should do is to establish a political govt elected by people and have full faith in it.The elected P.M. should have all the legislative power.military should go to their Barracks.military should not Interfere in govt at all.The elected P.M. is answerable to the parliament as well as people.it is unfortunate to blame the elected govt round the clock and appreciate military blindly.l think that military is only responsible for the present disturbance in Pakistan.
As a Pakistani, I 100% agree. Also I feel we need to get rid of the extremist/conservative elements. They're the least educated and just think because they follow Islam, they can bring Islamic laws and return the country to its former glories. One of the ways to achieve a progressive Pakistan is to make it tolerant, liberal & secular. Most of Pakistan's earliest leaders held these views. E.g: Ayub Khan, Bhutto & the founding father M. Ali Jinnah himself. Now I know some people here may not agree with all of their policies and acts and I don't either, but that's a separate debate. We're talking about the constitution here and before Zia it was a more liberal, moderate, modern Islam in the days of Ayub Khan & Bhutto. That's when Pakistan's economy progressed faster than India. Field of sciences probably was superior (established our space agency Suparco waayyy before India established theirs). We were better in sports & music as well. But then came Zia ul Haq, who brought Wahhabism from Saudi Arabia/Afghanistan and gave us Kalashinkovs, heroine, mullahs, religious extremism and terrorism. 30 years after his death we're still suffering coz of him
2023 June still listening from India Great post and oustanding analysis by Sethi Sahab. Truth should always prevail in our either side of borders always
Najam sethi, Hasan nisar & Taraq fatah are intellectuals & their analytical study of history of Pakistan is really very awakening. The blunders as numerated are important reasons for failure of Pakistan as a Nation.
He never mentions the first blunder the misadventure to capture Kashmir by sending Razakars.Had they not done it.They could have coexisted peacefully with India without needing to build a big army and use valuable resources on its maintenance.The resources available could have been used for progress and development
We should learn from these blunders... it’s the best way yes if we made blunders we should take responsibilities of these and many more..Pakistan zindabad 🇵🇰
Najamji, brilliant as ever!!! I am watching this video second or third time but still sounds fresh! Wish all Pakistanis are honest like Najamji in understanding who is Pakistan's real enemy: it's not India but Pakistan's own elite - it's army and politicians.
As an Indian... this information is an eye opener. Also as a neighbour and our ex territory is in such extreme condition. Sad for our sub continent.....the association with US and UK is done only to hurt India.... so myopic..... MR. Najam Sethiji thank you for this knowledgeable dissemination ....... the ruling class in both nations have exploited us.
i am from india.. and personaly i wish long live pakistan.. and people of pakistan .. because i am ordinary person we are people.. and..people dont want this bullshit,, theY want simple happy life.. . so my wish BLESS U PAKISTAN... FROM INDIA WITH LOVE
Unfortunately as a Pakistani, I'd have to agree with you. The uneducated masses in our country won't understand this and they are enjoying themselves just because being allies with China is annoying neighbour India. It may annoy India now but I fear it'll be worse for Pak later.
As an Indian, I want Pakistan to be economically strong, free of jihadi elements and culturally vibrant. That would help India more than winning wars against our neighbour.
@@nuixtechsolutions0221 Abe chutiye 1948 me 2/3 Kashmir India ne Pakistan ki gaand me haath dal ke muh se nikal liya kyoki kashmir us samay bharat ka hua he nahi tha aur Pakistan ne Jammu ko chhod k lugbhag poora kashmir apne kabje me ker liya tha jiske baad hari singh ne Kashmir ke bharat me shamil hone ke documents sighn kiye the.😂😂😂
@@onealone4822 😂😂 keep on believing , whatever your media says...we will solve our problems in India ....go see HDI of Indian Muslims nd compare it with yourself !
@@prateek7366 Like a clever woman gets caught by her husband and accuses her friend of being true to herself. That he has forcibly raped me. Similarly, the Indian government accuses others, but we are honest in holding ourselves accountable.
@@onealone4822 Nice analogy 😂😂 but thats not the case right now...right wing is gaining momentum everywhere in the world , same in India ....& don't worry about Indian Muslims, we are here for them !
@@prateek7366 what about your lunatic indian media that is by far the most uncivil media of world. We are extremely glad to have pakistan and cant thank enough Jinnah :)
Najam Sethi speaks with clear focus on Pakistans Politics and life style of corruption and weakness. This person speaks with constructive criticism. Imran needs personnel like Mr Sethi in his think tank policies. My esteem and respect to this eloquent person. 😍
I’m a Sindhi and I cannot thank my grandparents enough for choosing to live in India. Wonder what Najam Sethi saab would say about Mr Kaptaan and the post-Zardari era in Pakistan.
Me too. I am a Sindhi and I am thankful to my Nana and Nani to come to India. The amount of freedom and love we get from India is and will never be comparable to any other country let alone Pakistan
Thank the founding founders of India for that...We have nehru ,gandhi , ambedkar to thank..
@@soneetramchandani61 Nice to know this but better not talk about Pakistan. You're happy there in India and we are happy here in Pakistan! So there's no use of bringing Pakistan and Pakistanis in between everything........! 🙏
@@sabihanaz7277 Of course you’re happy there, now that you’ve forced all non-Muslims out. But we still think about Sindh as the land of our ancestors … an integral part of our shared history and civilization. And yours too except you’ve been indoctrinated to believe that civilization began after Muhammad bin Qasim arrived with his tribal army on camels and donkeys and enslaved your people. And you choose to believe it as some sort of gospel truth. That is why we need to mention Pakistan - to call out your fraudulent account of history. Outside of that, you’ve done a pretty good job of ruining your own country… You don’t need India for that.
@@alpha-engineer Your name suggests you are a observer but you doesn't seem to be at all. Of course Sindh is important for you, even it is in your anthem.......(though it shouldn't be now). I know that Sindh had a rich historic and cultural background but I never heard anyone here in Pakistan say about Muhammad Bin Qasim as you are saying. Obviously, the history of Sindh dates back to thousands of years ago and I acknowledge it. But the concept of enslavement.....!?? It's out of my understanding and how are we ruining our country? If sticking to your religion and working day and night for your country with sincere devotion is called ruining........then let us ruin our country! Peace 🙏
One of the very very few Pakistanis with a clear Head.
I was shocked to see Pqkistani who speaks sensible. The other person is Rauf saab
@Usman Rafique you will not find any....because only extremism is the language your senses understand...and as far as my knowledge is concerned...no extremist is that much popular in India
@Usman Rafique and by the way...even without any sensible person according to you....we are one of the major global economies
@Usman Rafique See yourself and your country first.....Just a shit place and mindset of Pakistani people don't even try to accept the fact
@Usman Rafique That's why I m telling come once u will see...and about toilet for rural areas its a good initiative taken by bill gates towards our nation.....Any great person in the world even visited Pakistan...They don't even want to
What a story that Najam Sethi has narrated so precisely and concisely. One of the best interviews ever in Pakistan history.
So lucky my grandparents left there 74 acres land in pakistan and migrated to INDIA.
Hahahah
Hahaha booooooo
That was an intelligent decision bro 👍👍👍
Bhai I'm sorry. But I hope you never felt any different from your home. 😌love your
You still can claim once we won that area in next war... ha ha
After watching this video
I am proud of Nehru, Dr ambedkar, sardar Patel, maulana azad and several other leader
Thank you all for making India great
Same here...I too am thankful to founding fathers of India
Huge thanks to our great leaders in those tough times.
@@siddharthsaxena2310 hoge toh kya hua
Jinnah comunal tha or nehru secular tha
@@siddharthsaxena2310 ko si duniya me ho bhai.....it was a fake news which circulated all the social media along with other fake news.....you need to verify before speak
@@vikasatkan4607 yes you are right.
In the year 1956 almost near the same date Two Countries took two diametrically opposite decisions regarding language
1.Srilanka with (only 2 major languages) passed an act imposing only sinhalese as the language throughout the country........Then followed the Tamil Sinhalese conflict which burns till today
2.India (with 20 major languages about 10 so big numerically as to be in top 20 languages of the world ) took a surprising decision to Divide/Reorganize the country on linguistic basis.What seemed to many international "experts" as a sure formula for balkanization of India..But lo and behold! the country is now stronger than the sum of its states and is growing stronger by the day .
correct
first we liberalized our culture and society and then our economy...............India won
The best thing that happened in India is that no particular language is imposed on others. Hindi is an official language per se but other languages also gets a chance to develop.
Mahesh M. Blame all these on corrupt fame seeking Generals and all these creTion Of Again khan and Jinnah propted by ImperialistBritish the religion and its use by Mullahs who wants to be known as Power behind the throne
International powerful countrys thought that India can not survived 2 or 3 years coz of so many religions and language and various casts but what happen now India is growing stronger day by day bcoz of our love for our country jai hind
I like Mr.Sethi's sense of humor as he clinically analyses Pakistan's blunders. I like to listen to his analyses which are fair and clinical. I hope voices of intellectuals like him make the Pakistani powers that be work to make Pakistan a better country instead of being paranoid about Kashmir and India.
After watching this video I feel so happy being born in India...
don't worry beta i can count more then 10 blunders of india,,,
But still quality of life, educcation, security, freedom of speech, human rights, medical, etc is way better than Pakistan ;)
Aap ki saadgi per qurban jayen Rupesh :) Kabhi India k rural areas ki visit karien, quality of life ka pata chal jayega. Facebook per hi sirf ek dafa status rakh dein k Muslims ko gaye ka gosht khaaney ki ijazat milni chahye yeh in ka haq hai, aur aapko freedom of speech ka pata chal jayega. Ek dafa Jammu Kashmir ho ayen, Human rights ka bhi pata chal jayega. Aansu aajyengey aankhoon se.
@@sairahashwani8227
India k rural area choro pak ke to urban areas b rural hi lagte h, human rights violation FATA aur balochistan me hoten hai,
Gaye ka gosht???
Tumhari relious feeling hurt hoti h to poora mulk aisa bibi k piche pad jata h..
Freedom of speech to mr. Bugti ko b thi.. Kyu marwa dia use???
Yeah....what Indira did in Golden temple you should be very happy.
Very very Intectual analysis by Nazam Sethi Saheb
The biggest mistake that Pakistan made was that they made Islam as the national religion. Combining politics and religion is the worst thing for a country. Economic progress is possible when religion is kept away from politics.
As a Pakistani, I 100% agree. One of the ways to achieve a progressive Pakistan is to make it tolerant, liberal & secular. Most of Pakistan's earliest leaders held these views. E.g: Ayub Khan, Bhutto & the founding father M. Ali Jinnah himself. Now I know some people here may not agree with all of their policies and acts and I don't either, but that's a separate debate. We're talking about the constitution here and before Zia it was a more liberal, moderate, modern Islam in the days of Ayub Khan & Bhutto. That's when Pakistan's economy progressed faster than India. Field of sciences probably was superior (established our space agency Suparco waayyy before India established theirs). We were better in sports & music as well. But then came Zia ul Haq, who brought Wahhabism from Saudi Arabia/Afghanistan and gave us Kalashinkovs, heroine, mullahs, religious extremism and terrorism. 30 years after his death we're still suffering coz of him
brother we are going on the same track with rise in extremists that we need to stop
we need to give equality to every religion
@@ayusmashu bjp is the only party that is stopping India to become an Islamic country
Yeah, learn from India fellows. One of the best Pakistani person that I have ever seen. A frank and neutral analysis. America is literally just using you all.
well ... u r right at some some point ... there is lack of education in Pakistan and india .... poverty is 2nd largest reason of all kinds of crimes and terrors... in all religions .... its the media who hits any religion .... this is media war
@@romikhan7834 Media is from us. It can only compound a problem not create it. The situation always exist.
And yet, Proudly Indian, do you realise, that this foundation that contrast Pakistan's was laid by Nehruvian politics? Non-alignment, a mixed economy, stress on infra-structure, land reforms, secularism, women's rights, all go back to those initial decisions. But the BJP is at pains to run down that early direction, while the present Congress is unworthy of honouring that legacy.
Najam Sethi should be made Prime Minister of Pakistan. He is true to loyalty to his Motherland. He has rational understanding of cause and effect.
You are welcome to replace him with your Chaiwala PM. At least he does not have blood on his hands.
@@azamkhan8963 chaiwala is better than your Playboy PM...tell him to control Inflation rate....MODI is well respected PM all around world...we don't need your fucking idea to make whom to PM. I hoped that Imran khan would be good PM for pakistan but he is worse than Nawaz Sharif. There is nothing in being Chaiwala to PM its a successful story. So better make valid comment rather than ranting without using brain.
He is a analyst not a leader
oye apne kam se kam rk
najam sethi saab america ka bekhari hai
dont go with his ideas and thoughts
@@azamkhan8963 our PM is counted among the most powerful personality of the world. Your Pakistan is now struggling to escape from being blacklisted by FATF, begging to IMF, China. Why don't you just accept the fact that India is baap.
What a great mind this Najm Sethi sb. i can only commend him admire him and respect him as our hero. Muneeb Farooq too v smart decent and intelligent. we can still hope to set the course of history right. we have to act honestly.
Very good analysis. Habib Yousuf from Bangladesh
Habibullah Yousuf they also admitted that how Pakistan tortured Bangladeshi & strangely now again situation turs to the same way now a days
A very interesting explanation and analysis by Najam Sethi - worth watching!
So much information packed in half hour. It was beautiful. I hope you bring another program in this series which will talk about more such blunders. So much to learn for everyone.
Very true facts. But there is one major blunder is missing. We learnt this in history class. Involving the army in the government was one great mistake. I think this blunder is so great that it's also a stain on the pak army
He clearly stated it in his 1st blunder that army got right to intervene in every aspect of pakistani internal affairs
I mean why the army got involved in internal affairs is not discussed. It's a sensitive topic by one angle so I guess its good its not discussed.
Pakistan me army hi sab kuch hH.
.... Democracy hah hi nii pakistan me
@india ki ma ka bhosda Indian doctors hijdo ka Lund check nai karte pakistan ki maa ka vosda
True
It is one of the best interviews I have seen. Hats off to Nazam Sethi Sahab.
Thank you for uploading this video. I never knew NS did a program on this topic.
Mr.Nazam sethi and Mr. Has an nisar is the best analysist well known about Pakistan
To Arsala khan, you are the type of muslim who can not take positive criticism for your own good. That's why pakistan is a failed state religiously and politically, cause Muslims like you have closed their eyes on reforms and completely blind in ignorance.
I am proud to be an Indian muslim. And thankful to my parents to make the choice of staying in India.
Salam.
Vikram PV shut up Hindu who told you to get in this conversation does it look like your invited man plz just leave asking you in a polite Manor
HaziqTV jahil angresh ki gaad chat ne walo tumari okat Kya Hai Salo gadaro Kal tak Tera bap bharat jindabad bolata tha moka aane par bharat murdabad bol ne laga ye Hai tum gadaro ka Islam gatiya gadaro Ak din tume hindu ka gulam banaya ge yaad rakhana
Brilliant decision by Ur parents , it will benefit u and all Ur coming generations
Yousef Sharma nitya
We Pakistani knows that there many blunders made by politicians and Generals But Quid ideology based upon Islamic instructions, though we cannot implement it completely.Our people are following Islamic instructions and wants that there should be an Islamic system in the country.On other hand,we can prayer independently , we are not slave of any one individually but now a days, in India Muslims are treated as slave . Indians said Indian Muslims are traitors,What BJP and RSS is doing with Muslims in India? What is doing with Muslims in Kashmir? Quid said "Muslims in India will pass away in proving that they are loyal to India".This is becoming true,now.Have you answer? DR Zakir Naik has migrated from India b/c of cruel policies of Indian Government.You can think and understand both the countries in current scenerio.......May GOD bless you. Asslam O Allaikum
Najam Sethi is a national asset. He's troubled a lot but he can't be quiet for long. God bless you sir
Sir, The blunder of blunders happened even before that. It happened when you opted for the '2- Nation theory' and was adamant not to accept independence if this is not accepted. Then you people tried to wash away any damn connection with your Hindustani culture and tried to connect with the Arabs. You had your own "well thought out plans" for doing so, but their culture and the way of living was a way different. The result was - you could not destroy your roots and also, you could not adopt Arabic culture either and therefore a certain distance was always there. Now they are not interested in sharing their wealth in the name of Religion.
Live in the real world and work on the agenda to become self-sufficient. That's the only way.
Pakistan ki neeev hi jhooti hai
Well said 👌👍🙏
Wow, what an analysis Sethi Sahab. I have to say that this is one of the rarest interviews on any Pakistani media that has explained the blunders in past of Pakistan.Great job..
Well done. I appreciate Mr. Sethi for his candid honest analysis
i m an Indian but i m a big fan of najam sethi sahab, u r a grt scholar and u have tremendous way toh deliver ur knowledge which make me a big fan of urs.. whatever u say, its a complete analysis of what has actually happened around u and us..this is a big reason for the people to belive what actually has happened..most importantly ur face little a bit matches with my grand pa and the way u speak he also used speak in the same manner, particularly the body language u show..anyways love live najam sethi sahab, wish u all the best..heads off to ur knowledge..
Mr Sathi is a Honest Man.
I Salute .
He is a qadyani
I had never seen or heard anyone as brave as Mr Najam Sethi. People like him can only save Pakistan today. The reason he speaks from his mind and openly is because he is a true patriotic and a Pakistani at heart. He feels for Pakistan and genuinely wants Pakistan to improve. My best wishes for this great person......An Indian
This is 12 years old but so meaningful till now. I am from india and find mr sethi so erudite and uncomplicated.
Well done mr sethi.
You missed the very first blunder.....it was when jinah demands Pak...
@india ki ma ka bhosda Gandhi never demanded India.... It was Jinaah who wanted a separate islamic state, if feasible...pls request your madarsa admin to include history in your Jihadi Syllabus... apart from your default subjects of loading AK-47 and configuring bombs...
Sir Ji real fact was Nehru he was the real reason .he wants to rule but in reality he was dumb he was not even capable to be a peon so Gandhi decided to break country into 2 parts.you can blame to jinha too he deserves that too but root of the cause was Nehru
Haan
thats blunder for nehru and gandhi alhamdullilah we living in a society were we are save and our religious rights
@@nuixtechsolutions0221 our religious rights are also save if you know what I mean....😎😎😎😎 #hindutvarises....
विश्लेषण अच्छा लगा। सेठी साहब का कहने का लहज़ा भी काबिले तारीफ है । 2011 के बाद भी ब्लंडर जारी है तो सिलसिला को आगे बढ़ाया
जाय ।
Amazing insight by Mr. Najam Sethi, we need one in India too to highlight its neglected areas. Great Insight!!!
best analysis...its take great courage to say against our country....thanks sethi sir
Good analysis.. learned a lot.. and understood how two nation who started at same time same place but reached different places.
The only genuine and honest journalist/analyst in pakistan....
I am short of words to express my feelings on such a fair and wise analysis which has been done by Mr.
Sethi on the issue which determines the future of a nation. Hat's off to
Mr. Sethi,.
People like Mr. Sethi Saab, should be given opportunity to lead the country if want to give a better future to the generations to come.
One of d vry few educated nd honset person of pakistan👌👌👏👏
Yes dada
Najam Sethi is a honest man. I have a very high respect for Mr. Sethi
Incredible summary of Pakistan's history by Najam Sethi. Even a four-year History program at University can't teach you so much about Pakistan's blunders as this video does in 35 minutes. People like Najam Sethi and Husain Haqqani are very honest about the state of affairs in Pakistan.
Pakistan needs more intellectuals like Nazam Sethi.
Nice analysis by Najam Sethi. I see no India obsession, Hindu hate, Kashmir centric negative view about India.
Points he put are worth thinking....
I admire your clear head Mr. Sethi. I have always detested Non-alignment movement and other policies anchored by Nehru Ji, but you have explained why this was so much needed to a young India. I now understand he was visionary (followed by future leaders) and opted doing things right way. Thanks to all the Indian leaders who promoted Democracy, "unity in diversity" and secularism . This has laid a good foundation which has helped India to grow and develop despite various challenges. I really wish that there are more leaders like you in Pakistan. I hope, both countries live in peace and harmony so that we can transfer our attention to the development and fighting poverty rather than spending billions in fighting each other...
4th Blunder was the most grievous blunder! Probably it wd hv corrected previous 3 blunders! Military civil bureaucracy wd hv been brought under civilian control and one unit wd hv bn dissolved as Mujib had spelled it in his 6 points.
The way Mr. Najam sethi explains each thing and the expression he had on his face while telling tales was exceptional.
I thoughrouly enjoyed this, but the most i enjoyed was Kargil.
Proud Indian.
One of the best interviews ever in Pakistan's history.
If Pakistan had a true and honest federal system. Pakistan would have been different.
Respect to this man.. The biggest thing is to accept your mistakes..
Accept your defeat on Feb 2019 standoff aswell./
@@mustajibazad7588 yes you also except your defeat of maqbool Hussain .
Hi,
We Indians have a strong message on centralization of power.It leads to blunders.We need to protect our constitution.
Thanks
Ramaprasad Srinidhi
Your write
Right..Buy sadly centralization is happening now
Very good analysis. As an indian, I am glad that such astute analysis is possible sitting in Pakistan.
Sethi Sahab is a very intellectual person. His analysis is top class and without any bias.
Shethi sahib, the great analyst! what he said as a last point about jardari , proved in 2019.
Brilliant Realistic Analysis... Thank You
!0 Blunders is very informative. I liked it.
I am from India. Respect for Najam Sethi ji on his knowledge, analysis and his vision. I've been watching him and whatever he predicts, comes true almost all the time. We need millions of people like him on either side of the border.
Excellent, honest analysis!!! No politician or military personnel in Pakistan will ever admit these blunders!!!
Thank you Nehru ji for leading our India in those initial crucial days.
Indeed
Pandit JII zindabaad
You are committing blunders even today. You extended the tenure of present army chief. India never extends tenure of any army, navy or air chief.
I hear it first time, that what happened ,, I feel proud that I am indian. Because we are not cheater
There needs to be an update to this program. - Continuity & Summary on next decade would be educational for all . Pakistan still needs to progress in many areas compared to other countries who were born around the time or after Pakistan got created .
Sethis saab is an honest intellectual who is bold & has clarity in thoughts - his narration is impressive too !
Gentleman(Sethi Sir) ko sun ke laga ke Pakistan mein bhi honest, sensible, knowledgeable and intelligent people hain. Such people are real assets of a country. God bless you and your troubled country.
mere khiyal naal top 10 galtiya jehriya ke apa history de wich kittia
10. No commen unity between pakistan.
9. Not paying any taxes and corrupt culture.
8. Jinnah saab not managing making a country with a clear cut vision, before he expired.
7. Interfering with Afghan mamle
6. Taliban promotion against India and Afghanistan, and now the sneak is biting us.
5. Not creating own technology, but relieving on foreign aid to run including army on payroll also.
4. Wars with India
3. Not ending Kashmir issue
2. Tight control of Pakistan of Corrupt Bad Men from Land lord families.
1. Janta voting on Corrupt Bad Men
please give comment, what you think? should list number be different?
Hamza Mukhtar 8) I would not say an islamic state, but maybe you are right, this was the best clear cut vision Jinnah saab could make, a Turkey kind of state. 3) I agree Indians started the problems, but we should have worked a lot more for peace, it is almost as crazy as north and south korea, to keep problems going for 60-70 years, while the world have moved forward, and we are still dealing with issues from WW2 times. Hopefully a permanent border can be made between India and Pakistan in coming years.
Hamza Mukhtar But is it not COMPLETE UTOPIA to think Pakistan will ever give away Gilgit-Baltistan, which is a part of kashmir. It is our route way to Central Asia and China? only someone complete insane would say yes to such a deal. The best way is to make permanent borders and make peace. Kashmiris must find a way to live in India like all other muslims of India (more then Pakistan) . In my eyes, Kashmir is not more a real issue in Pakistan, we have other more important problems, dealing with taliban, balochistan, karachi etc etc.
Hamza Mukhtar you did not answer my question, is it imaginable pakistan giving away gilgit-baltistan? I give it 0% chance? Is it possible?
Hamza Mukhtar lol you are full of BS. i need to talk with someone else, more intellectual, you sound like someone from same 1947 mentality.
Once upon a time,,,,,,,, Pakistani journalists used to speak truth.
first time, I have watched a West Pakistani is speaking the facts. Pakistani always blame sheak Majib and India for splitting Pakistan .
Thanks From 🇧🇩
Clarity of thought and analysis. Thx Sethi saheb.
zabardast najam seti sb.bilkul such batein ki hain
100% Najam Setti Sahib agreed
I am proud to be an Indian🇮🇳
Imran becoming pm is the big blunder in the history of pak
Sahi bole
Very good ..currect points ...10 top blundders of Paaakisthaaan ...nice Analysis ....100000000000cnt currect .....🙏🙏🙏🙏👌👌👌👌👌
Ultimate analysis........ultimate presentation....hats off to you sethi saab.....(from India)
As an Indian this is so sad. Its like watching a family member make wrong decision after wrong decision to ruin their life.
Earlier I would be sad too but then I remember the Kargil war, Parliament attack, Mumbai attack and many other terrorist attacks done by these extremists. I have no sympathy for such terrorist family members. May these piggies rot in hell
Change starts by admitting mistakes first. Good to see such a realization from a top journalist, presented on mainstream media.
To all indians: im glad to be living in a country where there is no Arnab Gwaswami.
Arnab Goswami was an excellent journalist but within the last 4 years he detoriated
I would prefer arnab goswami over people like ayub khan, yayha khan, zia-ul-haq, musharraf
@@akshay_wakodikar I disagree, the venom a spews is more contagious than all of these dictators combined. One can stand against dictators, as evident from the history, but you can never fight ideology.
Arnab Goswami is your father… pay respect if you are still alive in banana republic poopistan
I am an Indian . My Name is Shivkumar living in Ahmedabad, Gujarat. I appreciate that there are some people in Pakistan who realise their mistakes.they don't blame others for their hardships.I think that if you had worked for the betterment of yourselves after Independence you didn't need to blame others.you are still not doing ,what you should do.The most important thing you should do is to establish a political govt elected by people and have full faith in it.The elected P.M. should have all the legislative power.military should go to their Barracks.military should not Interfere in govt at all.The elected P.M. is answerable to the parliament as well as people.it is unfortunate to blame the elected govt round the clock and appreciate military blindly.l think that military is only responsible for the present disturbance in Pakistan.
As a Pakistani, I 100% agree. Also I feel we need to get rid of the extremist/conservative elements. They're the least educated and just think because they follow Islam, they can bring Islamic laws and return the country to its former glories. One of the ways to achieve a progressive Pakistan is to make it tolerant, liberal & secular. Most of Pakistan's earliest leaders held these views. E.g: Ayub Khan, Bhutto & the founding father M. Ali Jinnah himself. Now I know some people here may not agree with all of their policies and acts and I don't either, but that's a separate debate. We're talking about the constitution here and before Zia it was a more liberal, moderate, modern Islam in the days of Ayub Khan & Bhutto. That's when Pakistan's economy progressed faster than India. Field of sciences probably was superior (established our space agency Suparco waayyy before India established theirs). We were better in sports & music as well. But then came Zia ul Haq, who brought Wahhabism from Saudi Arabia/Afghanistan and gave us Kalashinkovs, heroine, mullahs, religious extremism and terrorism. 30 years after his death we're still suffering coz of him
Very good took for najim Sathi sab
2023 June still listening from India
Great post and oustanding analysis by Sethi Sahab.
Truth should always prevail in our either side of borders always
Bande ki knowledge bhot tagdi h ..👏👏👏
Najam sethi, Hasan nisar & Taraq fatah are intellectuals & their analytical study of history of Pakistan is really very awakening.
The blunders as numerated are important reasons for failure of Pakistan as a Nation.
He never mentions the first blunder the misadventure to capture Kashmir by sending Razakars.Had they not done it.They could have coexisted peacefully with India without needing to build a big army and use valuable resources on its maintenance.The resources available could have been used for progress and development
Sethi ji very intelligent and clear in thoughts. Not biased for Pakistan.
Very informatve , balanced n rational discussion. Hats off. I pray pakistan will progress in future.
We should learn from these blunders... it’s the best way yes if we made blunders we should take responsibilities of these and many more..Pakistan zindabad 🇵🇰
A good interview . I like the style of the panelist . Indian news channel need to learn from these about how to conduct a discussion .
Najamji, brilliant as ever!!! I am watching this video second or third time but still sounds fresh! Wish all Pakistanis are honest like Najamji in understanding who is Pakistan's real enemy: it's not India but Pakistan's own elite - it's army and politicians.
As an Indian... this information is an eye opener. Also as a neighbour and our ex territory is in such extreme condition. Sad for our sub continent.....the association with US and UK is done only to hurt India.... so myopic..... MR. Najam Sethiji thank you for this knowledgeable dissemination ....... the ruling class in both nations have exploited us.
I am a Indian Mr. NajamSethi sir is a true and intelligent person. I slot you Sir
i am from india.. and personaly i wish long live pakistan.. and people of pakistan .. because i am ordinary person we are people.. and..people dont want this bullshit,, theY want simple happy life.. . so my wish BLESS U PAKISTAN... FROM INDIA WITH LOVE
11 th blunder is friendship with china 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂🔜🔜
Gajab bhai gajab
👏👏👏👏💓💖❤️
Perfect quote
but this time they can not even cry 😂😂😂
Yes they are addicted
CPEC would be next
Hahahhaha... Lol
THATS A GREAT POINT.. AND A TRUE POINT.
Unfortunately as a Pakistani, I'd have to agree with you. The uneducated masses in our country won't understand this and they are enjoying themselves just because being allies with China is annoying neighbour India. It may annoy India now but I fear it'll be worse for Pak later.
@@maazmustafa2322 I hope we both nations rise above hate and progress on their own respective nations.
@@neeraj8169 Hopefully 🤞
Great analysis of pakistan's history
Very Well Presented. The way to solve any problem is to first recognise there is a problem. More strength to you.
Thanks Sethi Sahab...
Knowledgeable and logical Analysis .. Thanks sir 👍 👍
Proud to be an Indian.Pakistan failed as Nation.jai Hind.Salute to Indian army.
As an Indian, I want Pakistan to be economically strong, free of jihadi elements and culturally vibrant. That would help India more than winning wars against our neighbour.
@@ritadatta1249 tumari yhi soch aj problems create kar rahi hAi
@@ritadatta1249 Your comment is so intelligent that I doubt that you are Indian!
@@pratikmishra3517 Your comment is so stupid that I am convinced that you are Indian!
@@iftkhin3317 you know what..... The way you narrated this.... Shows your intelligence....
Excellent analysis of Pakistani blunders committed over the years by Najam Sethi Saheb
Mr Sethi is excellent analyst of many matters.
6:11 ek bhi jung jeet nai sakee!!😂
jeeta jung 1949 ko jam one third kashmir india ka halak me see hath dal kr nikalaya or 1965 ko whole west side pakistan defence kya india se
@@nuixtechsolutions0221 ye khud bola Jung har Gaye humne nai kaha ja Mar isko boom bandhke gale lagale isko dono khatam ho jao 4-5 ko aur lete jao
@Muhammad Danyal Dil behla le apna. Sach kadwa hi hota hai bete
Chup kr gando .
@@nuixtechsolutions0221 Abe chutiye 1948 me 2/3 Kashmir India ne Pakistan ki gaand me haath dal ke muh se nikal liya kyoki kashmir us samay bharat ka hua he nahi tha aur Pakistan ne Jammu ko chhod k lugbhag poora kashmir apne kabje me ker liya tha jiske baad hari singh ne Kashmir ke bharat me shamil hone ke documents sighn kiye the.😂😂😂
a good information by sethi sahab,,,,,
the day u ask for freedom fm india that was u biggest and bad blunder
in 1947.
Now Muslims of India realised that M.A Jinnah was right
@@onealone4822 😂😂 keep on believing , whatever your media says...we will solve our problems in India ....go see HDI of Indian Muslims nd compare it with yourself !
@@prateek7366 Like a clever woman gets caught by her husband and accuses her friend of being true to herself. That he has forcibly raped me. Similarly, the Indian government accuses others, but we are honest in holding ourselves accountable.
@@onealone4822 Nice analogy 😂😂 but thats not the case right now...right wing is gaining momentum everywhere in the world , same in India ....& don't worry about Indian Muslims, we are here for them !
@@prateek7366 what about your lunatic indian media that is by far the most uncivil media of world. We are extremely glad to have pakistan and cant thank enough Jinnah :)
Mr. Najam Sethi is Real Gem of Pakistan By Thinking & Thoughts As Human
Najam Sethi speaks with clear focus on Pakistans Politics and life style of corruption and weakness. This person speaks with constructive criticism. Imran needs personnel like Mr Sethi in his think tank policies. My esteem and respect to this eloquent person. 😍