The most amazing Transgender debate ever - Real dialogue, real agreement

Поділитися
Вставка

КОМЕНТАРІ • 31

  • @neidracross8626
    @neidracross8626 3 місяці тому +4

    25:50 - 28:18 I have always wondered about this is nice to hear a dialogue on it. The entire video is great, well done. Thank you for sharing.

  • @Unknown-sz8kg
    @Unknown-sz8kg 4 місяці тому +5

    Why should i be forced to accept someone for who they think they are, when they can't accept themself for who they actually are?

    • @EgardWatches
      @EgardWatches  4 місяці тому +5

      I don’t think this person was advocating any forced behavior and even criticized that notion… but sadly the movement itself is.

    • @EgardWatches
      @EgardWatches  4 місяці тому +3

      @@joeaddison7120 did you enjoy the conversation? You seem pro trans rights so curious to hear your thoughts.

    • @wolfrunning1
      @wolfrunning1 3 місяці тому

      ​@@joeaddison7120 So a woman who is forced to have men in their women's bathroom at work, and call a man a woman, or lose their job, isn't being forced or coerced? Everyone is entitled to their delusions, but not to forcing other people to play along, especially when it's a safety issue for women and a free speech issue for everyone

    • @joeaddison7120
      @joeaddison7120 3 місяці тому +1

      @@wolfrunning1 who lost their job? Seems like you’re obfuscating because you know there’s no legal basis for firing someone for misgendering someone in speech, at work.
      But, show me those STATISTICS if I’m wrong.
      For the life of me, I can’t really figure out what people’s obsession with bathrooms is. Do grown men not go into the women’s bathroom with their kids? And vice-versa?
      Is there some sort of idea running in the background of sexual deviancy that makes you uncomfortable? Well, news flash, straight men, gay men, straight women and gay women all commit sexual assault. ON children.
      Look up THOSE statistics. I’m sure you’d be surprised.
      The only “olive branch” I might offer is gender neutral bathrooms are fine as a third option. Unless you want to inspect everyone’s genitalia to see if they’re allowed to be in any given bathroom, then be my guest.
      Further, I’m not convinced that any transgender person believes they are biologically the gender they’ve landed on. None I’ve ever met have, but that’s simply anecdotal and not data.
      That seems to bear out in the distinction of “cis” and “trans.”
      Really, I think the “delusion” is really that many people seem to think “trans” is something that it’s not.
      So, no….i don’t find any of your points to be salient, succinct or even valid. Intellectually stunted, to be more precise.

    • @joeaddison7120
      @joeaddison7120 3 місяці тому +1

      @@wolfrunning1 show me statistical findings that what you’re saying is true. Show me the law in place that says you can be fired for “misgendering” someone.

  • @michaelkeller5008
    @michaelkeller5008 3 місяці тому +2

    i wonder how old your guest (in lack of names) was when the puberty-blockers were applied, when gender disphoria was applied, and if all this is ok, why your guest wants to DE-transition; was the diagnose gender-disphoria wrong? if yes - how to fix the diagnose-system to prevent the false diagnoses that may ruin the life of the patient completly?

    • @michaelkeller5008
      @michaelkeller5008 3 місяці тому

      Hi Mary - thanks for your reply (though i can't see it on YT anymore) and clarifying! (english's my 4th foreign language - guess i gotten some things wrong again)
      BUT - one issue with your reply: you wrote "I really feel like the solution is to ensure that all people in question meet the criteria"; this is very dangerous in todays day and age (and ideology driven politics); bc "ensuring something" nowadays means "lower the criteria/make them as vage as possible so everyone can meet them". and THIS might lead to a rise of "regrets leading to permanent solution for a temporary problem" (it's funny how many words you can't use on this plattform anymore, bc someone might feel someone else being offended if that person'd read this....!?).
      edit: yt conformitycheck

    • @DannerCando-ev4fo
      @DannerCando-ev4fo Місяць тому

      I can’t see the reply either, maybe she removed it? My sense was this person is preparing to transition surgically soon. I couldn’t help thinking of the studies done long ago before this was popularized, that showed something like 90% of boys with this issue no longer had dysphoria after going through puberty and went on to become gay men as adults. It appears this person has been on puberty blockers through their teens and has missed the opportunity of going through puberty-that is why they remain small statured and don’t have a low voice. But had this person gone through puberty they may very well no longer be living with an identity disorder.

  • @alanchilds1456
    @alanchilds1456 4 місяці тому +7

    Wow, this person needs spiritual help

    • @joeaddison7120
      @joeaddison7120 4 місяці тому +2

      Prove there’s a sprit, prove there’s a god, prove that it says anything, prove that you have ANY basis to say anything regarding “spirituality.”

  • @Johhubrauva
    @Johhubrauva 3 місяці тому

    Its very hard to so see men like this...

  • @DannerCando-ev4fo
    @DannerCando-ev4fo Місяць тому

    Great conversation, thank you. It appears that Mary has remained on puberty blockers throughout puberty which explains a small stature and high voice. Studies shown that teens with gender dysphoria who go through puberty no longer have gender identity issues after going through puberty and go on to be gay or lesbians as adults. I can’t help wondering if Mary had gone through puberty if he would have developed self acceptance and not be facing a lifetime of medical interventions and expenses. There is a very high cost for these folks as individuals and to our society.

    • @maryelizamoore7870
      @maryelizamoore7870 13 днів тому

      I was never on puberty blockers. I should have been but my parents did not allow it. My whole point of coming onto this video was to make it known how awful it is for trans kids to go through puberty without puberty blockers.

  • @shannonclark3755
    @shannonclark3755 4 місяці тому +9

    I will never accept this. No hate..It's Sin.

    • @joeaddison7120
      @joeaddison7120 4 місяці тому +5

      And no one should ever accept your god, that you have ZERO evidence that’s real. No hate, just facts.

    • @Paulo.da.SilvaUK
      @Paulo.da.SilvaUK 4 місяці тому +1

      True ​@@joeaddison7120

    • @Johhubrauva
      @Johhubrauva 3 місяці тому +1

      Right here with you. This is intolerable.

    • @wolfrunning1
      @wolfrunning1 3 місяці тому

      @@joeaddison7120 No one is forcing anyone in America to pronounce belief in a Christian or Muslim god, but Christians and Muslims and others who just believe men and women are biologically different are being coerced to either go against their religion and belief in basic biological truth, and agree with the transgender cult's definitions of reality, or possibly lose their job and careers in many cases