P Sainath speaks at
Вставка
- Опубліковано 18 лют 2016
- P Sainath, renowned journalist, spoke in support of #StandWithJNU on Friday, 19 February 2016. He delivered a lecture at the administrative block, JNU, on "Life in the times of inequality and fundamentalism".
There are two types of journalism today- one is journalism and other is corporate stenography !
+nishant singh Well said !
i seemed like clapping for every sentence of his...what a man..
+Dharma Teja (DT) dont u think giving Voice to farmer is contributing to society,for the welfare of poor farmers .
@@DV-lh2ov ujxmikcnzmtdmjb
thanks sir we students of BHU is with JNU.
+Rahul Kumar me too....alumnus of BHU.....spread this in BHU circles buddy....
+Rahul Kumar If you don't mind can I know what have you learned from his speech?
P.Sainath is always speaks for poor farmers.he opposed corporate policy of government.
good.nice to hear
+Ram Narayan And thus you wrote an essay on how actions speak louder than words.
Outstanding speech...The hour was well worth as it educated me the dire state of the widening inequality in our society..aptly put ..the movement to check the criminalisation of dissent must gain momentum ...the nastiest state in a decade needs to be served a timely wake up call that they were sent to serve us and not suppress us
You might agree with him, you might disagree with him, but you have to accept that he is hell of a speaker!
IT IS DIFFICULT NOWADAYS TO TELL DIFFERENCE BETWEEN THE FORTH ESTATE AND REAL ESTATE...
each minute was worth listening.
Awesome speech.We are with you!
#StandWithJNU
I stand with JNU because I support the diversity of our colourful nation.
I stand with JNU because I stand against the injustice.
I stand with the JNU because I stand with the humanity.
I stand with u guys because u guys are our hope and I won't let my hope die. People from all across the world are with u. Thank you for sharing this video.
I'd like to use this platform to thank the students of JNU for their exemplary courage and principles in standing up to repression and stifling of free speech. It is extremely heartening to see young people doing what in essence every single Indian should actually be doing - which is safeguarding democratic institutions. I can only thank you all on behalf of the country. You give me hope that the nation is in safe hands despite the atmosphere of terror which is being spread today. Keep up the good work folks!
Please keep posting . we r circulating it to make people understand, what jnu is.
+AHG Plus Free Sex, Drug
i salute and respect each and every student and all who are associated anyhow with JNU except ABVP members...though i am not a leftist but the very thing i m impressed with is your truth speaking and speaking rational also about every section of the society..i wish i would a JNUite ...hats off u brave people..
What a brilliant lecture.... Mr. Sainath.. Hats off to you
Though I regret i never got an opportunity to pursuit my education (Of Life) from JNU,
These Outdoor Classes I take it as "Wished Opportunity Come True"
Wow this one is awesome :) Never had a lecture like this outdoor, good to see the students so involved.
Don't give up guyz, keep up your culture. #StandWithJNU
Respect for the "Rural Reporter"!! A journalist to the poor, a spokesperson on behalf of the oppressed, marginalized and vulnerable.
Simply Brilliant... An eye opener speech
Listening to his lecture I am reminded of my days in JNU,centre for historical studies
Thanks for uplpading the lecture ...keep uploading the coming lectures on nationalism so the ppl who are not in campus can also hear!
+AHG Sukhi roti vi nehi, sukhi katahua laoda. Muchurman increase from 21 % to 38%
+shikha saxena My nationalism is,that comes under purview of its territory,
Where i could enjoy my culture ,civilization brother hood and mutual respect.Most important is mutual respect,that is validation of other religion as well.A culture and history which is of mine not one copied by Oxford.
In this we believe in assertiveness by Hindus in face of demons And surrender to our beloved. We BELIEVE this land to be our mother,WE can not even think to hurt our nation.We reply with full energy when see anything unethical.
Shame on you ...anti indian ,,,,
Naveen Singh Sahi kaha yaar, e sab gutter ki kutte hai, leki aapne aap ko sare dunia se yada samajdar (intellectual) samajte hai. Asle me budhu hai
+Naveen Singh PDP which is an ally of BJP in Kashmir is a party which believes Afzal Guru should not have been hanged and they described it as 'travesty to justice'. PDP voters are considering Afzal Guru as a martyr . First let BJP leave the PDP alliance in J&K with the hard core anti nationalists.. Doctoring videos, photoshopping, manipulating through channels and making public against one of the prestigious universities in the country, BJP is taking lowest low and people who are supporting them now will soon leave them.
Thank you for opening our eyes sir ! Splendid talk.
Phenomenal sobering account of India today.
Need more journalist like Mr. Sainath at the forefront to lead voices againt anti-people govt. and influence policies in right direction.
P Sainath at his best....#StandwithJNU
+AHG Surely
+AHG Almost all castiests are suffering from this disease, you continue that.....
So refreshing to hear a sane voice speaking over the humbug and self-deception our whole country is being led into nowadays in the name of nationalism.
I student from IIT Dhanbad with JNU
With fearless analysis of the morphed antinational videos and pictures by ABP News, a letter from Barkha Dutt, a faceless speech from Ravish Kumar, this speech from P Sainath, and many other articles/reports, sections of the media are trying to bring sanity to the situation which demands everyone to wear their patriotism on their sleeves. Although this shows that we are still alive and awake as a nation, but the sadness, the anguish, the disappointment, the frustration, and hopelessness these express show that our national conscience is fast approaching its death. Poet Rabindranath Tagore, the author of our national anthem, also wrote, "Patriotism cannot be our final spiritual shelter; my refuge is humanity. I will not buy glass for the price of diamonds, and I will never allow patriotism to triumph over humanity as long as I live". We, as a nation, seem to have lost the consciousness that helps us distinguish between glass and diamond.
When P Sainath Speaks........!!
Excellent speech! All secular progressive liberal people need to fight the fascist BJP and RSS.JNU is now leading the fight.We support JNU!
worth downloading...
nice presentation of minute problem.....and very good line......we are ruled by social fundamentalist and market capitalist.......but i think this is not for politically motivated person.....
Amazing !!!
Truth is unvarnished in the economic sense by Sainath. Social consequence is what others do not link as well as he does. That is why Parliament members love Riot and Drought more than we care to see.
We salute P Sainath.
better than any movie that portrays problems of india........
Thanks for posting !
beautiful lecture , thanx a lot dear, thnx sir,
An eye opening speech. Salute sir
though i am not jnuite but this man journalism us very brave..
#StandWithJNU
Mr.Sainath should write a book in this regard with these facts.
great speech.
Yet again a set of meaningful observations. Making sense and helping decode the madness of Fanatical Hindu and Corporate power broker alliance ruling India right now. #StandWithJNU
BJP is Congress + Cow? hahaha at 10:46
Every 5 years Russians send all their billionaires to prison, Indians send them to the Parlaiment 23:27
+Moonquakes nope russians dont tht ,putin only sends those who dont lick his boot.
+AHG they created Bangladesh in west Bengal and genocide hindu population
+bg s don't use ayurvedik product and drink sonia piss
thanks for the video comrades....
i stand with you
A youngisthan in India needs a role model and P..Sainath an alumnus of JNU marked a socio-politico inclusive peoples' role model for the present day students, an earlier version of Plato;s responsible state in which people are the nucleus with their rights and privileges.
roaring lion. great talk.
Sir Great Speech but people wont understand it. they don't know how it runs
The income inequality is a serious problem for our society.
I wonder what his solution is?
Sowing seeds of contempt between societies and groups could not, in my opinion, be a solution tyo finding an acceptable way forward for society.
Its a nice lecture. Different people have different interpretation about an incident. For P Sainath, conscious sloganeering "bharat ke barbadi taak jung rahegi jari" is only a way to express dissent but for many others (I know quite a few of them), its a way to disrespect and threaten the sovereignty of India, in short anti-nationalism. Each country and society has its own virtues and vices which are always discussed and debated for gradual improvement and rectification but should anti-nationalism be no criminalized? As per my understanding of IPC and constitutional provision of India, it is a crime.
excellent...throughly enjoyed
जेएनयू छात्र जिंदाबाद रहेगा जय संविधान
Very thought provoking
on the seperate note i would like to suggest you to get your lectures translated in hindi and get them to common public to those who form larger part of voters.
Journalism and corporate stenography- best comparison... ha ha
it is really great work
Corporate Stenography.....................Hilarious and Superb.
dont expect anything from this govt other then privatization. this is what they knows best.
great speech i like it jnu we are with u
Just amazing lecture!
I have a question & want anyone from the JNU to answer this.
What is ur stand on anti-india slogans shouted? Does voice of dissent mean you can break India?
I 100% agree that wealth is being accumulated in the hands of few. What is the solution to this?
Sorry for being naive. I ask only because iam confused.
+James Randy I'm not from JNU but I don't see India having been broken despite these slogans. How can the BJP sit and form a govt with the likes of late Mufti Saeed and Sajjad Lone despite them having been secessionist in their pasts?
The solution for your question is social justice (not the rule of law since law can be influenced). How can the govt. write off 1.14 lakh crores and make a hue and cry when writing off farmer debts? How is it made possible for people to stuff their money in Zurich, Ireland and other places while other people have not got enough to eat?
How can you allow corporates to get away with polluting the soil, air and food and get away with murder?
The answers have to come from public consciousness. Unfortunately this will not come if we are greedy and only look to fill our pockets and not worry about our workers and farmers and labourers.
+Navneet Vasistha Lets not digress from the core question. Question is not whether the slogans can break India or not? Question is the sloganeering "bharat ke barbadi taak jung rahegi jaari" is a punishable offence within the sovereign gambit of Indian law or not? Each country and society has its own virtues and vuces which are always discussed and debated for gradual rectification but the core question is can activities against the national sovereignty be allowed? If your answer is yes, then you have a very different understanding about the concept of a Nation. Thanks
No one has shied away from condemning those statements but the sovereignty of a nation is best followed by following the rule of its law. Try them in a court and by the law of the land. But you know as well as I know that these accusations won't stand in court. Is that then why goondaism is considered nationalism? How is airing alleged doctored videos without clarification nationalism. Let's have a debate on nationalism if you want. Let's have scholars from all angles give their views on a public platform without threat to anyones life.
We can't afford to be so divided that a minor incident like this allows people to break the law with gumption and senior ministers like Rajnath Singh look foolish.
I hope you see my point. There is space in my heart for your sentiments but let's debate and solve this. Let us not drive a wedge through this great nation.
Doctored video???? SO, you mean to say the court could not take cognizance of the video of 09th Feb, 2016 or you also think that those guys have been booked based upon 11th Feb, 2016 video. What to debate ?
+Masi Masi Stop beating about the bush and confusing yourself. On what basis has Kanhaiya Kumar been arrested? Is it not the 11th Feb video? Have aspersions not been cast over the versions run by Zee and Times Now?
As for the 9th Feb protest, it is condemn-able and the government should take action as per law. But sedition? Seriously?
As for the debate, let's have a Oxford Union style debate about differing ideas of nationalism, the role of the flag, the national anthem and other state symbols. Let it include Akhand Bharat and also the left-liberal view. I'd even pay to watch that.
Does this government feel confident enough to have it? They are happy to trade Kamlesh Tiwari for muslim votes just as the Congress did and then call out everyone for their 'pseudo-secular' stance.
I am with JNU
👍👍👍
It was your trade unions that caused shut down odd those Mumbai mills. I'm surprised to hear him complain about all those mills giving way to real estate projects. He knows the new generation doesn't know about the strikes in Mumbai by trade unions and can get away with lies.
Why now? What happened in past?If you have been fighting ,what have you accomplished?Why now?Why now?What have you done in the past 10 years.And some times I wonder people make protests against government because of unemployment.When industries are made and jobs are created we protest on government because of land pulling and pollution.Where is jnu constructed?
P Sainath , very well said ., please explain are RSS responsible for the inequality or the misrule of Congress who were only interested in looting the country ... All the statistics rolled out by you ,brilliantly point out the same ...why dont you admit that Congress and not RSS is to be blamed ... wish you have the guts to respond to above
He is stooge of Dynasty & leftist like his Guru Romila Thapar
Hope Bhakts can understand what he wanted to say... Feeling sory for Bhakts.. :'(
Instead of posting" I am with you". Post your reason for supporting him.Don't let media and educated Morans blind you.
his words do echo; but echo on a political walls. he too is political
he talks about the supreme court and how people were trying to defy supreme court order, how come he fails to mention the fact that the convict afzal was hanged after having exhausted three tier of judicial process, and how come the current row of JNU is against the supreme court's decision?
While Sainath's work over the decades for rural societies in general and farmers in particular is appreciable, his insinuation that all their are somehow because of the present government is ridiculous. The saturation of rural poverty and thriving of crony capitalism in this country are the result of policy indifference since the reign of the first prime minister of the country. It is fine to sensitize impressionable students to the issues of inequality and political corruption, but to somehow put the entire blame on a government which has been in office for less than two years smacks of his own agenda.
video title is stand with JNU but not with country
whatever slogan raised in jnu is ok but stand with JNU
Indian army democracy police court all r not proper only JNU students r perfect who raised slogan against India but u hv to stand with JNU
La ilaha illalah,
Kashmir is part of Indiaaahhh!
the more they will annoy police ,the more police will take care of them in jail.
What does JNU Students think about reservations that are given on cast and religion and things like that. Because according to what this gentle man is saying nothing is working so in a way reservations is also not working. Why not abolish that???
anti national is always anti national . whether 1976 or 2016
JNU never allowed multipal voices . you never allowed to entire nationalism conversation to speck by right bing .
Brilliant speech sir but we no option except bring to communist
These inequalities have been created since ages...not within 2 years..
+survi makharia Oh ok so lets just sit back forever then. Is that your logic?
+Chirag Shah No don't sit back, In the least,do a weighted criticism of governments....
LAL salam
Excellent talk! But, i simply do not get, how come you students can stand with Rahul gandhi and shake your tails in front of him? Whatever Mr. Sainath spoke is the result of his party's work. This is pure politics. I doubt your actual intentions JNUSU. But, i hope, India emerges out victorious from the challenges, Mr. sainath spoke about.
yes.. you came to Delhi only for this... we know only to gain ur political mileage..
He is a brilliant orator. But although his words are mesmerizing, we all know how badly communist ideology has failed all over the world. I could not listen his full speech because it is too long. I would like to point towards a contradiction in his logic. He says whatever is needed by middle class became cheaper but whatever is needed by poor became costlier. How sir, is it possible? For example if bus fare increase, it will lead to increase in the income of the driver. Anybody plz answer me.
My logic is that if you connect. people to free market they will grow if they work hard. I fully agree with Modiji when he says that govt just needs to remove the hurdle. People will grow on their own
How sick must you be in your head to support a Terrorist who attacked the Indian Parliament and killed many people ?
So anti India slogans in the last two weeks were fantastic for him
It is shocking to see that celebrated journalists like P.Sainath use the issue to propagate their personal views on politics and economics. It is the duty of people like P.Sainath, to mentor the students to select the right frame work of protest and argument rather than a parody of BJP, RSS, VHP, Bajarang Dal,Capitalists, Wealth, Greed and Beef amongst others. Someone might be accused of stealing a cow or a frail octogenarian trying to kill policemen, but that has no relation with students chanting the demise of India.
sainath is very articulate. bt what is the position of Bengal where left rule for 35 years, what is the position???? plz talk that also. people come to Maharashtra and Gujarat nt bengal
i would have wanted to agree with Sainath but such a partisan analysis of the administration without bringing out even a single positive and constantly uttering names of castes and religions, makes me doubt the ingenuity of this speech. It is more a case of sour grapes accumulated by Sainathji over the years especially after being mowed down by his own magazine few decades ago.
You wont let industry to develop and you wont allow liberalization of the economy. That takes away your moral right to comment on the income of rural population. Because of the irresponsible actions and statements of the people like you Mr. Sainath, common people are misguided and they are being hidden from the true reasons for their poverty.
To all the ProJNU people..pls sell me your ideology. I want to know more about your perspective :)
+Navjot Singh Just one .... antinational
Afzal Guru, from what I read, had joined a terrorist group in POK with an intent to liberate Kashmir, surrendered to BSF, got a second lease of life and worked as an area manager for some pharmaceutical company, then gets caught with proofs of conspiring a terrorist attack on Indian parliament, punished after some 12 years which I think is disgraceful for the judiciary system. I hate the system, I hate it for the time it took when they believed they had solid evidence. That said, I am not in a position to actually judge Afzal Guru because I dont know what actually happened, I dont have any of my own intelligence team to find if it was a mistake, lets say he may have dialled the attackers no. randomly as a marketing call part of his job or he was framed, may be intelligence picked up from chits of a lakh names, and I am pretty sure these slogan shouters, I wont generalize them as JNU students because not all share the same sentiment, don't have an intelligence system in place either to find that out. Still, lets say their very own in-house James Bond figured out that Afzal Guru was picked up randomly. But then I have some doubts and confusions, how is it that there have been no such attacks in Pakistan and China? How is it that Kashmiris who want to be liberated do not go shout slogans, or plan attacks in these two countries? Have they forgotten that what Pakistan and China has is also Kashmir or they have accepted that they cannot get it back? How is it that the attacks always happen in India and gets planned in Pakistan? Why was a wide spread hatred orchestrated among Kashmiri Muslims to clear out Kashmiri Pandits? Where they not Kashmiris? Why is the voice of Kashmiri Pandits and a large section of Kashmiri Muslims not even considered the voice of Kashmiris? Why are the students, political groups, the human rights activists not shouting slogans in Pakistan or against Pakistan protesting their occupation of Kashmir? Why no one came out in support of Kashmiri Pandits when they were massacred? Can the slogan shouters assure that these section of Kashmiris wont be massacred again? Can they assure Pakistan and China wont take over Kashmir if Indian forces leave the state? Let’s say it’s not India’s problem after it lets go off Kashmir. But can they assure that Pakistan would not try to penetrate Himachal and come up with POH? Would these slogan shouters be safe if the Indian Army pulls out? Would these slogan shouters have raised a voice if one of their family members got killed in the parliament attack? 15 died for the respect of this country. Why are they not condemning their death? Why is the Parliament attack not protested against? Were they not humans or these so called human rights activists believe that getting killed was part of their job? Even if I keep all this aside I do not understand. How are the slogans Destruction of India & Partition of India & hail Pakistan not an act of treason? The whole episode is being manipulated to sound as sedition. Its sad to see how much politics of this country has fallen that they have to play such a low level of politics. This wasn’t even the government when Afzal Guru was hanged. But an attempt at sedition can be tolerated. Everybody wants to rule, everyone wants power. But I fail to see how is this not anti-national? These people are challenging the existence of India not the government. It’s pathetic to see how political parties have made mockery of the situation and allowed the real problem to be shadowed out. One attacking, the accuse other condemning it, it’s a joke. As for separatist, we already have so many problems with the two countries that got created and mind you there’s nothing good that’s happening there either. It’s not that they lived happily ever after. Two new countries only allowed for two extra PMs, some more political parties to be created, some more to become leaders who may have never got a chance otherwise, some more scams, some more getting a chance to earn that extra money. General people who live there face almost the same problems that we face, actually its worse over there. Number of Bangladeshi refugees we have is an open example of this. Division based on religion or language is only to fuel the political motive of a group of people who are as much hungry for power as the one they are fighting against. Over 90% population in these two partitioned countries practice one common religion, but they eventually figured out not everyone shared the same thoughts. People and groups with problems will always have problems. And these problems will always be manipulated by power hungry groups to use to their cause. History is a proof to that. For people who stays out of these problems never have one. Pakistan was created for the want of this power by some men, not every Muslim wanted the partition not every Muslim left. Everyone wants to lead, everyone wants power and one of the classic lessons taught by the British "Divide and Rule" always works.
+Raunaq Sahay Appreciate you agree with me. Its not out of sentiments. Its analysis. How many really gain out of this? If you see its mostly the people you see in the picture and people around them. People shout slogans for farmers, question is how many really help them? If these political parties really cared to help, their members got enough money in their bank accounts to spend 100s of crores in their campaign, which is enough for atleast some of the things they claim to do after their party wins.
few days more, than who is kanhaiya, jnu ??? we don't give a damn to these damn lecturers n students, do something in the society if there us problem, rather than barking only. Every society will have problem, the society which works for better being will evolve, only barking will do nothing.
Excellent. The entire 60 years of rule of congress. Too cleverly pinned on BJP. Wow!
Before replying, please see the Human development index. And then tell when Modi came to power. Then listen to the rest of the video and correlate to which govt it should actually apply to.
At the end, comment whom will you vote for as well!
80% ko yeh speech hi samajh me nahi ayegi. Sirf 20% ko samajh me ayegi jo Indian hain. Kyonki sirf unhi ko yeh baatein zayada pareshan karti hain ki kyon ek Hindustani bhook se mar raha hai , kyon rich and poor ka margin badh raha hai, kyon health ki itni problem badh rahi hai.
Sabse badi problem jo basic problem hoti hai woh hai .. Why uneducated are ruling Educated ? Who are giving certificates to these MLA and MP, why not there is any written and Objective test for them ?
not said anything new.These are being in writings and slogans for sometime now in all anti establishment sections.one reads and knows.I knew them. however he found time to discuss these in JNU(which already knows all ) is welcome.I felt Hindu is hated word in Hindustan.Every other word is welcome.One can not overlook the fact that the it is hindu mentality that made gandhi a hero and the chela Nehru kept a distance while fully milking the Hindu psychology then. If Rahul becomes PM it will be due to this very psychological inclination of hindus. Anyway What he said about hindi language i said that to a friend about 16 years back or so. I was held anti national.
china has more disparity than india sainath ,u conveniently passed it on as if nothing is wrong in china
Dharma Teja ppl suffering from hunger and shelter are not done by rss ,so to say tht just after bjp came to power farmers somehow started dying is an illogical argument. wen cpim supported sharad pawar ,which thy still do, thy never asked themselves the question as to whether sharad pawar is helping the farmers of vidarbha who die like flies . also 30 yrs of unquestioned rule of cpi in west bengal ,wat is the progress there and on top of it thy are supporting anti india sentiments ..wow
+Dharma Teja (DT) They suffer from much more, You are brainwashed if you are told China is doing better off.. In China, Communists control the Government and even Media, They show what pleases them and choose to ignore things that are unpleasant.
I hope India never becomes anything like Communist China, Communism is a sick disease that should be exterminated from the face of the Planet. Do you know Millions cant even afford homes in China and live in underground caves ? You are not told all this because China censors its media !
more than 50% of indias parliamentarian are obc,sc and st so how are they oppressed wen u say 83 % mps are crore pati
+rajani kanth number of mlas is small fraction of 1.20 billion popularization of india u should not generalize wealth of mla
tula V ya its like saying 500 odd mps are small number of 1.2 billion ppl . since logic and science doesnt go into ur head , u do realize tht if the concept of india ceases to exist jnu will not get free money for its anti india activities.
*UGC should stop giving grants to these institutions *
Either we are no 2 in world as beef exporter or market devoid of one of its bye product leather .. Sainath is fooling around people.
This is just hands-waving argument without any sound logic.
how much assets does he has? he must be in the top 25% wealthiest in our india. (the grand son of our ex president v.v. giri.)
I have very high regards for you Sir & have always applauded all your speeches. Having said this, let me ask, is this very speech a justification for slogans like 'Bharat ki barbadi tak jung rahegi' ? How can any speech glorifying the drawbacks of the country or the Government be a justification for acts that clearly show disregard for the NATION. I stand for dissent, I stand for variance on ideologies, I stand for democracy, I firmly stand for freedom of expression. But I don't stand with JNU on this. No freedom is absolute, there are reasonable restrictions on Freedom of expression as well.You can curse the Government, you can curse a political party; it is totally okay. But venomous statements like 'Bharat tere tukde honge' 'Bharat teri barbadi tak jung rahegi' is anti-nationalism. Sir, are you trying to say that it is okay to shout out such statements in a public platform?
Chutya
*Cant blame the students when they are taught by minds like these*
With due respect and considering the concerns of Mr. P Sainath, I just wonder where he was in the 10-year-long congress regime. The points he is raising are all valid and need to be looked at, but do they really have any connection with the BJP? India does have problems but that doesn't make a bunch of terrorists worthy of creating havoc in the peaceful environment of a prestigious university. The JNU protest is in support of the likes of Umar Khalid, Kanhaiya Kumar who in my thought are not even worthy of being called students. How do I convince myself to stand with JNU on such a foolish premise?
Well said..