Thanks so much for being a firm, clear, voice with higher sound. As someone who is hard of hearing I really appreciate the loudness. It's often too difficult to hear on a channel.
(updating as I listen) Chapter 1: Our Riches - 0:20 Part II - 4:04 Part III - 12:37 Chapter 2: Well-Being for All - 21:41 Part II - 30:12 Part III - 37:26 Chapter 3: Anarchist Communism - 41:28 Part II - 53:15 Chapter 4: Expropriation - 1:03:45 Part II - 1:10:26 Part III - 1:20:37 Chapter 5: Food - 1:32:00 Part II - 1:37:57 Part III - 1:43:47 Part IV - 1:52:03 Part V - not included?? Part VI - not included?? Part VII - not included?? Chapter 6: Dwellings - 2:02:01 Part II - Part III - Chapter 7: Clothing - 2:23:39 Part II - Chapter 8: Ways and Means - 2:29:26 Part II - Chapter 9: The Need for Luxury - 2:43:24 Part II - Part III - Part IV - Part V - Chapter 10: Agreeable Work - 3:02:16 Part II - Chapter 11: Free Agreement - 3:18:13 Part II - Part III - Chapter 12: Objections - 3:25:35 Part II - Part III - Part IV - Chapter 13: The Collectivist Wages System - 4:02:31 Part II - Part III - Part IV - Chapter 14: Consumption and Production - 4:35:41 Part II - Chapter 15: The Division of Labour - 4:50:17 Chapter 16: The Decentralization of Industry - 4:56:59 Part II - Part III - Chapter 17: Agriculture - 5:19:05 Part II - Part III - Part IV - Part V - Part VI -
You should join our bookclub this Sunday! I'm serious, we're discussing this book. We're meeting on Google meet, if you wanna join, I'll figure out a way to get you a link! Maybe Twitter DM?
@@jaellana8853 the IWW is an international union that all workers can join. They’ve been around for over 100 years. Back in the day they had some workers killed by klan members. The DSA is the Democratic Socialists of America. They aren’t super radical but they do good work and you can meet other people that have read Kropotkin (if you live in the US).
Can somebody timestamp recipes? Was looking for one for rye and one for sourdough. All I have found so far in skimming this is a desire to decentralize power. Please, I am in charge of bread this year at Thanksgiving and my aunt Marcia will be very upset if all I offer her is a critique of capitalism. Any help is appreciated. Thank you
@@aharrypotterfan5951happens, man. It's like doing your math homework or else you forget what a triangle is or like forgetting to do your taxes and forgetting what it feels like to not be in jail for tax evasion
understandable critique, but it was the technical terminology of the time. it’s similar to the R word to some extent, it was the proper terminology for a long time but stemmed from harmful rhetoric nonetheless.
@@CP-ns5edWhy not both? Breadtube videos sometimes get millions of views and are effective at spreading leftist ideas. More effective than any means that leftists in neoliberal countries have really ever had.
@@CP-ns5ed I disagree to an extent. Yes the foundations of anarchism are made clear through the early thinkers. But it’s important to address things through a modern lens that can only come from modern day anarchists. Anarchism needs to be addressed in today’s sociological and economic climate, new voices should be raised, particular those of women and people of color. But ultimately anyone who can present the ideas in the most palatable and enlightening means, to sway more people in our modern age
It would be a great idea for kid tube but is too long? But I might take selections. I did know little about Bakunin that what would of made the order of primitive man.
I believe the point is that when a person feels they have value in their community/society and feel like they have stakes in the product of their labor, they will willfully work more, harder and better than if FORCED BY ATROCIOUS "LAW".
What do you mean by that? We actually do produce enough food to keep everyone in the world fed, plus a few million more. The biggest hurtle right now (besides capitalism/ states, like kropotkin argues) is transportation. What points of his view are unrealistic?
@@johnharvey3069 modern agricultural production takes a level of planning and skill that the man on the street does not have. The entire reason we have a massive surplus of food is because we don't leave the production of food in the hands of every moron in the country anymore. The more centralized and specialized agricultural production has become, the more food we have and the less we have to worry about famine.
![The State and Revolution by Vladimir Lenin Audiobook | Audible Socialism [English] /u/dessalines_](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/uDOafVeKmpE/mqdefault.jpg)
![The State and Revolution by Vladimir Lenin Audiobook | Audible Socialism [English] /u/dessalines_](/img/tr.png)
Thanks so much for being a firm, clear, voice with higher sound. As someone who is hard of hearing I really appreciate the loudness. It's often too difficult to hear on a channel.
Time to listen to our bread mom
I really like Korporkin's works
(updating as I listen)
Chapter 1: Our Riches - 0:20
Part II - 4:04
Part III - 12:37
Chapter 2: Well-Being for All - 21:41
Part II - 30:12
Part III - 37:26
Chapter 3: Anarchist Communism - 41:28
Part II - 53:15
Chapter 4: Expropriation - 1:03:45
Part II - 1:10:26
Part III - 1:20:37
Chapter 5: Food - 1:32:00
Part II - 1:37:57
Part III - 1:43:47
Part IV - 1:52:03
Part V - not included??
Part VI - not included??
Part VII - not included??
Chapter 6: Dwellings - 2:02:01
Part II -
Part III -
Chapter 7: Clothing - 2:23:39
Part II -
Chapter 8: Ways and Means - 2:29:26
Part II -
Chapter 9: The Need for Luxury - 2:43:24
Part II -
Part III -
Part IV -
Part V -
Chapter 10: Agreeable Work - 3:02:16
Part II -
Chapter 11: Free Agreement - 3:18:13
Part II -
Part III -
Chapter 12: Objections - 3:25:35
Part II -
Part III -
Part IV -
Chapter 13: The Collectivist Wages System - 4:02:31
Part II -
Part III -
Part IV -
Chapter 14: Consumption and Production - 4:35:41
Part II -
Chapter 15: The Division of Labour - 4:50:17
Chapter 16: The Decentralization of Industry - 4:56:59
Part II -
Part III -
Chapter 17: Agriculture - 5:19:05
Part II -
Part III -
Part IV -
Part V -
Part VI -
This is great, thanks a lot comrade)
Nice one Gavin.
Thanks
You're a real one, comrade. Thank you.
Gods work
I love this with multiple readers. Makes it feel like the body-politic or the zeitgeist or something.
Kropotkin turns 180 today, December 9, 2022! I salute you, brothers and sisters anarchists!
Very so fellow anarcho-comrade
Really need someone to discuss this book with 😢
You should join our bookclub this Sunday! I'm serious, we're discussing this book. We're meeting on Google meet, if you wanna join, I'll figure out a way to get you a link! Maybe Twitter DM?
Join the IWW and DSA so you can implement the ideas in this book
@@shaan702 this is a discord room or somth?
@@jaellana8853 the IWW is an international union that all workers can join. They’ve been around for over 100 years. Back in the day they had some workers killed by klan members. The DSA is the Democratic Socialists of America. They aren’t super radical but they do good work and you can meet other people that have read Kropotkin (if you live in the US).
@@jaellana8853 “ isthe IWW a discord server “ 😂😂😂😂 I love this generation
Great audiobook, multiple readers is a really fitting touch considering the work 😊
Kropotkin was based and bread pilled AF
Can somebody timestamp recipes? Was looking for one for rye and one for sourdough. All I have found so far in skimming this is a desire to decentralize power. Please, I am in charge of bread this year at Thanksgiving and my aunt Marcia will be very upset if all I offer her is a critique of capitalism. Any help is appreciated. Thank you
thank you so much for the audio book
I share a birthday with Kropotkin. Fantastic.
Please please please break the video into chapters.
I've listened for six minutes - and that has been enough . thank you for introducing me , I'll skip to reading Kropotkin's books .
I'm surprised you lasted 6 minutes.
@@ras2239😏
@@ADHDisYippeeeeeeeeeethey said they’d skip to reading it themselves, and that the audio book was a good introduction
I needed to listen to this again I started to stray away from true anarchism and started to become a bigot
LMAO BASED
man, i hate when I forgot to read/listen to my weekly libertarian works and accidentally turn into a notsee
self-awareness is a valuable tool
@@aharrypotterfan5951happens, man. It's like doing your math homework or else you forget what a triangle is or like forgetting to do your taxes and forgetting what it feels like to not be in jail for tax evasion
man, y'all in the replies are annoying. i'd rather someone recognize when they've strayed from the path than double down on bigotry
Fire 🔥🔥🔥
After watching many Breadtube essays, I'm ready to listen to this
We can have our bread and eat it too… I get it now
We getting that 🍞🥖🥐 with this one 🗣🔥🔥
No theft!
No waste!
No violence!
That's all you need. And then move on from there.
His critique of post industrial capitalism is valid but I hate hoshe talks about 'savages' and 'primatives' it's very European.
it was written in 1892 tbf lmao
@@universal_hyssoap"Product of its time" or whatnot
I notice many libertarian thinkers do too.
understandable critique, but it was the technical terminology of the time. it’s similar to the R word to some extent, it was the proper terminology for a long time but stemmed from harmful rhetoric nonetheless.
Yeah, true.
Thanks for the reading and upload ❤📚
Anything else I should check out?
Hmmm... so this is where the "breadtube" term comes from?
Hmmm...
🤔
Something seems to have gone awfully wrong.
@@CP-ns5edWhy not both? Breadtube videos sometimes get millions of views and are effective at spreading leftist ideas. More effective than any means that leftists in neoliberal countries have really ever had.
@@CP-ns5ed Ah ok I got you. Totally agree.
@@CP-ns5ed I disagree to an extent. Yes the foundations of anarchism are made clear through the early thinkers. But it’s important to address things through a modern lens that can only come from modern day anarchists. Anarchism needs to be addressed in today’s sociological and economic climate, new voices should be raised, particular those of women and people of color. But ultimately anyone who can present the ideas in the most palatable and enlightening means, to sway more people in our modern age
YES.
I thought about this again. I added it to mine kid tube. Thank you so much.
No kings; only jacks of all trades
4:06:00
based
It would be a great idea for kid tube but is too long? But I might take selections. I did know little about Bakunin that what would of made the order of primitive man.
4:16:48
Also, thank you to whoever posted this and to the team that read the book. I’m too lazy to read myself
Nothing has changed
Thomas Daniel Lee Betty Lopez John
what?? anarchists reading theory?? woah
Anarchism has a grand wealth of theory??? Why are you surprised????
🥱
Vocal fry. Yuk. Cannot listen.
Lmao at Kropotkin's thoughts on American blacks working "harder than their forefathers"
spotted the racist
I believe the point is that when a person feels they have value in their community/society and feel like they have stakes in the product of their labor, they will willfully work more, harder and better than if FORCED BY ATROCIOUS "LAW".
Anyone who thinks that Kropotkin's views on agricultural production are even remotely realistic has never stepped foot on a farm
Elaborate
What do you mean by that? We actually do produce enough food to keep everyone in the world fed, plus a few million more. The biggest hurtle right now (besides capitalism/ states, like kropotkin argues) is transportation. What points of his view are unrealistic?
@@johnharvey3069 modern agricultural production takes a level of planning and skill that the man on the street does not have. The entire reason we have a massive surplus of food is because we don't leave the production of food in the hands of every moron in the country anymore. The more centralized and specialized agricultural production has become, the more food we have and the less we have to worry about famine.
@@rainbowkittycat627 see the above comment
@Jacob B you have never been on a livestock operation in your entire life. Or probably even seen the inside of a tractor or combine.
The pretentious tone of the chapter 4 reader is pretty distracting.
C'mon man, it's a free audiobook.
1:31:30
based