Refusing a Marriage Proposal Because of Ethnicity || The Muslim Family Q&A || AMAU

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 20 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 143

  • @KassimEffect
    @KassimEffect 4 роки тому +53

    I think a lot of the rejections are based on racist views because I personally experienced it. The wali used very insulting language in front of my father when I asked for the ladies hand for marriage. Reason? because she wanted to marry me and not her cousin aka his son.

    • @Beam_Teamer
      @Beam_Teamer 3 роки тому

      Im in similar condition

    • @mubeenreminders7220
      @mubeenreminders7220 2 роки тому +3

      @@Beam_Teamer Been 7 years here.

    • @JJ-xm2km
      @JJ-xm2km Рік тому +2

      @@Beam_Teamer 3 years for me … I’m 37 and divorced… I’m having mental breakdown… I’m being manipulated that they will loose their lives because of the shame I bring to them…. Reason different ethnic group

    • @Beam_Teamer
      @Beam_Teamer Рік тому +5

      @@JJ-xm2km I got married finally alhamdulillah, but difficulty don't stop, I'm 23 I went to different country and marry my current wife, now I have to work without sleep to make her visa, I have not had the chance to live with my wife even a single day ... pray for me

    • @Beam_Teamer
      @Beam_Teamer Рік тому +2

      @@JJ-xm2km im algerian she is pakistani

  • @ayeshapyesha7301
    @ayeshapyesha7301 4 роки тому +99

    The issue is when, for example, a Pakistani family may refuse their daughter marriage to an African brother who is extremely knowledgeable and practicing on the deen and they have a lot in common, in favour of marrying her off to another Pakistani who isn't particularly practising or as educated, purely based on the fact he is of the same ethnicity. This type of situation makes no sense whatsoever.
    Also, the excuse of language is given a lot when refusing marriage to other ethnicities. But this excuse is given in countries where the main language is English, so one would argue why on earth haven't these people learned the common language of the land regardless? It's a complex issue. But speaking as a revert Muslim, it's very hypocritical for us to see muslims happy we've come to Al Islaam but refusing their children in marriage to us.

    • @jeremyh9213
      @jeremyh9213 4 роки тому +24

      This was is my same complaint. Anyway, languages can be learned, so this is a stupid reason to refuse marriage. As long as the couple can speak a common language then it is fine. I think inter-ethnic marriages have a lot of fun in them. I'm hispanic and I can read Bangla better than my Bengali brother in law...And I can also read some Urdu where as my in laws can't and I know more about Bangladesh than my wife and her siblings...the point is, these things can be learned and is no reason to refuse a good match...my biryani is also good :P

    • @MrSuperman957
      @MrSuperman957 4 роки тому +7

      Agreed. Like the Sheikh said, Racism is wrong. Ethnicity should never take precedence over the Deen.

    • @أبوشغل
      @أبوشغل 4 роки тому +12

      This is another benefit of the whole ummah learning Arabic. There would be more opportunities for Muslims of different cultures to marry. The Arabic language is the language of the Muslims. We hope that the ummah will return to learning it, firstly for understanding the religion of الله, but also so that the connection between the Muslims becomes greater.

    • @jeremyh9213
      @jeremyh9213 4 роки тому +2

      @@أبوشغل Agreed..Arabic is a good start. But I prefer also learning other languages of the muslims. I believe this gives us better a better understanding of each other.

    • @sharearabic6619
      @sharearabic6619 2 роки тому

      @@jeremyh9213 because the food is different

  • @tariq2835
    @tariq2835 Рік тому +16

    If your kids want to do something halal. Alhumdulilah and encourage it and make dua and stay close to your kids. Don’t cut ties. Zina is worse also leaving the folds of Islam living in a non islamic is far worse.

  • @MomoLovesCats
    @MomoLovesCats 2 роки тому +28

    is there by chance a Bengali translation of this? I really need to get through my parents and their stubborn Jahiliyah ways of thinking

  • @DryDownfall
    @DryDownfall 4 роки тому +11

    JazakAllah khair this is the most balanced explanation I've heard yet may Allah reward you sheikh with jannatul firdaus

  • @nsultana982
    @nsultana982 4 роки тому +24

    The global marriage crisis is only getting worse, and multiculturalism is only increasing. To maintain our cultural divides in such times would require significant (and consequently toxic) levels of intra-Ummah othering: which does not come without its share of arrogance and superiority/inferiority complex.
    Edit: The only divides we should be upholding at such times are those between haram and halal, liked and disliked, encouraged and discouraged.

    • @Muipal
      @Muipal 11 місяців тому

      Multiculturalism was always been the case until nationalism came into place until 150 years ago. As an example the most of middle eastern people come from intermixing of Semitic, turkic and Aryan people. The entire population of Turkey came out of multi-ethnic mix, with turkic dna average only around 20%. The ottomans themselves come from a mix of multi-ethnicity. It’s not new.
      The nationalism and racism born together from Europe.

  • @abuhijjra
    @abuhijjra Рік тому +8

    The Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: “If there comes to you one with whose character and religious commitment you are pleased, then marry (your female relative under your guardianship) to him, for if you do not do so, there will be tribulation and great mischief on earth.”

    • @AYouTubeCommentator
      @AYouTubeCommentator 11 місяців тому

      Where is this Hadith on marriage and tribulations/mischief on earth?

    • @abuhijjra
      @abuhijjra 11 місяців тому +1

      @@AUA-camCommentator At-Tirmiti and Ibn Maajah]

  • @aatif7518
    @aatif7518 4 роки тому +18

    Just because they can't cook biryani,you can't reject!!!

    • @taimurahmad
      @taimurahmad Рік тому

      They must paki food. My mother food is too good and I want to be spoiled by a housewife

  • @beckasbluenomadtriniamazigh
    @beckasbluenomadtriniamazigh 5 місяців тому +3

    I am a revert. How about choosing when to say Assalamu Alaikom to someone based on ethnicity?! Astaghfirullqh. Absolutely unacceptable and goes against the basic fundamentals of Islam.
    I come from a multi-racial family background. I have family from so many places and some of the blatant hateful racism I have experienced are from fellow Muslims of a different race or so they think not realizing as a Trinidadian American, I am mixed with so many things but then again, racism has nothing to do with Islam. It's a social (human) construct, and absolutely unacceptable.
    I find some people do not ant to chnage. They actually think the character traits are acceptable 😞.

  • @Shay3356
    @Shay3356 5 місяців тому +3

    If the two in question are Islamic-ally satisfied with one another, they should go ahead and take steps to get married. I don’t know where parents come up with the idea they have a right over their children’s marriage.
    Family are meant to support, not control.
    And no marriage is predicted, it’s all about the two standing strong in their marriage against the ignorant.

  • @ummabdulrahmaan
    @ummabdulrahmaan 9 місяців тому +3

    Wallahi that so true my family was big big issue no muslims. Istikarah was the way...

  • @ZeeKay1430
    @ZeeKay1430 Рік тому +2

    Su'Bhaan Allah,
    May Allah guide the parents,
    Amin

  • @ZahirBivings-mt6rh
    @ZahirBivings-mt6rh Рік тому +2

    When they said we have created different tribes race So that you will be able to get to know each other they meant both ways rather of his people in your nation or out of your nation obviously me personally I prefer people who are more similar to me than different from the interns in marriage because I do think it caused less confusion it is a more compatible match overall but that’s just me but at the end of the day ready if you want to be an interrical or non interrical is really the act of commitment and loyalty and also preference not just your ethnic background

  • @jamajijo6674
    @jamajijo6674 4 роки тому +3

    Masha Allah sheikh may Allah bless you in jannah Inshallah 👍👍👍

  • @abuhijjra
    @abuhijjra Рік тому +2

    A person might want to take the matter all the way to a judge and marry the woman by that means as a way to combat racism. The more mixed our cultures and ethnicities become the less racism between the Muslims. Most likely the children from this type of marriage won’t be racist.

  • @bizzytrap1658
    @bizzytrap1658 4 роки тому +5

    Mashallah very beneficial

  • @abuhijjra
    @abuhijjra Рік тому +3

    Most time you won’t find the racist wali strong upon the Quran and Sunnah that he is concerned about how the daughter met the groom or that they have been communicating in a way that’s not from sharia. Allaah knows best.

  • @aar8808
    @aar8808 Рік тому +2

    Alhamdulilah there are hundreds of ethnicities to choose from if one is blocked for you.

  • @sirrykr1679
    @sirrykr1679 Рік тому +1

    In the western world once you are 18 no one has a right to stop you from getting married. No one. No one 18 years of age needs anyones permission except the person they want to marry.

  • @l.k1992
    @l.k1992 4 роки тому +3

    Assalamu alaykum, does anyone know how we can send questions to ustadh tim humble?

  • @saral9817
    @saral9817 Рік тому +2

    BarakAllah feekom

  • @ummabdulrahmaan
    @ummabdulrahmaan 9 місяців тому

    As Salam alaykum wa ramatullah wa barakatuh it's not easy different ethnicity. I'm Brazilian and my husband is Sri Lankan. Al hamdulillah I was Muslim way before but it was challenging to adapt to his desires but we Place Islam before all and all cane easy...

  • @aar8808
    @aar8808 10 місяців тому +1

    Must we accept that our grandkids won't look like us by accepting global majority races? Is racial preservation not allowed for smaller tribes/races? Are only Arabs allowed to preserve their lineage?

  • @hansguenter6263
    @hansguenter6263 Рік тому +1

    Quran 5:51 : O ye who believe! Take not the Jews and the Christians for friends. They are friends one to another. He among you who taketh them for friends is (one) of them. Lo! Allah guideth not wrongdoing folk.

  • @BKAYS
    @BKAYS 5 місяців тому

    جزآك الله خيرا

  • @Arbnvbe
    @Arbnvbe 4 роки тому +1

    As salam aleykoum, how can we ask questions please ?

  • @fatimadamishq
    @fatimadamishq Рік тому +1

    Jazākallāhu khairan

  • @Shumayal
    @Shumayal Рік тому +2

    I'm a male and my parents don't accept

    • @Bsbawkdbeisnwpwy
      @Bsbawkdbeisnwpwy 8 місяців тому +4

      Luckily your parents don’t have to approve your marriage. Women on the other hand do have it a little tougher in the sense that our marriage is deemed invalid if our wali doesn’t approve

  • @Mohamed-uc9mb
    @Mohamed-uc9mb 4 роки тому +15

    my personal opinion is, I married from my background, even though I and my wife was brought up in the UK and I want my kids to be married to my background, simply, the same tradition, the same expectation and if anything goes wrong, we will have access to our kids even if she or I go back home still we have easy access to our kids but if we marry from different background and they went to their country, we will not have access to our kids. furthermore, we all want us to go back home, and it's unlikely a spouse from different ethnicity will agree to go back home with you.

    • @jeremyh9213
      @jeremyh9213 4 роки тому +9

      If your kids grow up in the UK then back home for them is the UK...and if their kids grow up in the UK then back home is the UK for them...consider this, whatever primary or secondary language you speak will fall away and be replaced by English. I live in the USA and I am 3rd generation hispanic...my niece can't even understand really basic Spanish when I talk to her...which is fine. Honestly speaking, I couldn't care less if my kids speak Spanish as none of my family speaks it much anyway. I prefer English, and I want my kids to live in the USA in sha Allah, as that is "back home" for me.

    • @nsultana982
      @nsultana982 4 роки тому +16

      People who prioritize ancestral culture want to marry others who will want to prioritize that same culture. But the point is - nothing should be prioritized over deen. If you have a hard time moving away from your culture (even with no language barrier being there) - then that may be a symptom of you having significant bias for your culture over the deen, at least in the down-low, if not outright. And Allah knows best.
      Also, agreed with the comment made by @Jeremy H

    • @Mohamed-uc9mb
      @Mohamed-uc9mb 4 роки тому +7

      There is difference between assimilation and integration. No one want to assimilate England as they are not Islamic culture. Protecting our culture and our language is part of religion as our culture is very deeply rooted in Islam. In order our kids to be very easily attached is through language and culture. Look what happened to afghani cameleers when they assimilated To the Australian culture , what happened to tartars when they assimilated To finish culture and what happen to Lebanese when they assimilated to American culture. You have to be proud of where your come from and not feel inferior to the nation you are immigrated to, to a point you feel you have to assimilate.

    • @Mohamed-uc9mb
      @Mohamed-uc9mb 4 роки тому

      N Sultana who told to you our deen is against our culture. Religion didn’t come to destroy cultures rather to enhance and perfect it. I don’t know which culture you come from but our culture is very deeply rooted in Islam, if one loses his language and culture and assimilate in western culture, there is a high chance we lose our religion. Our culture always priorities deen, in order to protect our kids religion, we have to protect our language and culture.

    • @jeremyh9213
      @jeremyh9213 4 роки тому +3

      @@Mohamed-uc9mb I don't know about that bro. What does language and culture have to do with the actual religion? Isn't taqwa primary? Which can be achieved through striving and struggling in any linguistic, cultural and/or socio-economic background? And we know that many cultural practices are completely against the Quran and Sunnah. If you don't mind my asking what is your ethnicity? Also, as an American, born and bred, I am not assimilating into America. I am American. Your comment doesn't make sense in the context of Muslims emigrating to western lands as it is debatable as to whether they should even be here in the first place for the long term. They can't come to our lands and then shun the locals without a backlash of some sort. Once again, if your kids are born and bred in the UK, then they have more in common with your average British "bloke" than some chap from Afghanistan or Pakistan or any where else. I'm not theorizing, that is simply a fact.

  • @ichimokutrader1845
    @ichimokutrader1845 2 місяці тому

    38 and single due to Ashiq Jinn and black magic + evil eye.

  • @mmathari3485
    @mmathari3485 4 роки тому +2

    You should be focussing on dawah and not put yourself in a position where you're giving fatwas.

    • @ibnjafar4025
      @ibnjafar4025 4 роки тому +3

      Why so

    • @SN-ly6yx
      @SN-ly6yx 4 роки тому +18

      He has the relevant qualifications

    • @juliasawadski
      @juliasawadski 4 роки тому +12

      Every word has consequences. Be careful!

    • @fbi8345
      @fbi8345 4 роки тому +23

      this is dawah to muslims who refuse marriage because of ethnicity even tho everything else is good

    • @SamiMuktar
      @SamiMuktar 4 роки тому +17

      M Mathari he’s a graduate of Madinah university from the college of Hadith, you have no authority to say who is qualified to give a ruling or not. Sad

  • @wishingtomarryagain2052
    @wishingtomarryagain2052 3 роки тому +3

    Im in the rush..im 61 Mashaallah..no same age lady and no wedding 😱