@@futuregamer25 it doesn’t work in the sense that of a piece of red stone works just by itself, however the way it works is that if you combine all of it, the representation will still be odd, which will repeat the cycles enough that it itself is made out of the Minecraft equivalent of electricity and wires.
Just imagine how hard life would be if these machines actually worked. "Oh no, I sat on the front of my office chair wrong and now I'm accelerating out of the building!"
You are an idiot.... but I am sure you are able to understand how this machine works so simply ua-cam.com/video/HMEBpZWckpw/v-deo.html After, you have to create one which works by yourself and to STOP to be a scientist'believer … All these machine works so simply.... and you are wrong...normal, you are a believer. A scientist'believer, BUT a believer. See you. F.R.
@@VirtualizerExtreme I.... stop you Wright there because You are a Believer, a scientist Believer but a Believer. Before preaching Wrong prayers ( friction and inertia) YOU AUGHT TO MAKE ONE MACHINE AND SEE THAT IT WORKS. ........ First Step for Science : expérimentation ! Second one not to be in believing of any kind. I did three machines and of différent type and they work as well as the Bessler one.... So STOP with your believings and go to work ! Thank you. 😀
@@lamuzzo5120 I.... stop you Wright there because You are a Believer, a scientist Believer but a Believer. Before preaching Wrong prayers ( friction and inertia) YOU AUGHT TO MAKE ONE MACHINE AND SEE THAT IT WORKS. ........ First Step for Science : expérimentation ! Second one not to be in believing of any kind. I did three machines and of différent type and they work as well as the Bessler one.... So STOP with your believings and go to work ! Thank you. 😀
No... Twitter has its own external fuel source (usually some news article or bit of entertainment). But it is a very efficient engine, and can go a long way on very little fuel.
Don't forget the other antisocial media. I've been given hate for saying that science is done by scientists using the scientific method - by someone claiming to be scientific.
@@johnkevin5446 pretty sure if there is no friction or gravity it wouldn't stop. I'm not that smart tho so if anyone sees this and you know I'm wrong pls correct me
@@chairvergil4552 You correct it would not stop but if you want to get power from it you’re going to be inducing I’ll go down to it meaning it will stop. Unless the power create it is more than is consumed which is impossible
@@xxdeadoutxx761 Yup, what I thought of when I thought about perpetual motion was basically to take a smooth ball into deep space, away from any sorce of radiation, gravity, ect. then you spin it and let it go. I think that might do it for creating something that moves infinitely, but even if it worked you can't get more energy out of perpetual motion then you put in, so even if you can get it moving forever thats all it can ever do.
Energy loss is a thing. The potential, and kinetic energy of these perpetual items will be lost to its environment over time. You still need to demand more energy than it can produce to itself to profit off of it.
the kinetic pendulum is NOT perpetual motion it will stop like a grand father clock ... those are kinetic pendulums ... and they have to be reset often ... that breaks the basic definition of perpetual motion ... NO external energy input ... by adjusting the weights over time one adds external energy making it JUST a machine
@@marcbee1234 how are they a scam if it's just a street name for this type of kinetic art? Have anybody claimed them to actually break laws of physics? Most of them would look great in school physics class, waiting room or in break room in office. Heck, I'd even say that building one with kids is a good experience and would help to explain THEM why they're impossible.
The irony is the dumbest comments aren't from any people who think it's real, but from people who think they are the only ones who can tell it's fake. Dunning-Kruger in full force
Is perpetual motion impossible? How long would it need to run before you believed it to happen and how long has the solar system been running without input from outside? Even a few days should be enough. How do you know them all to be faked? Did you try to reproduce them? No. You assumed it on your own lack of experience of trying to make perpetual motion machines. You thereby show Dunning Kruger yourself. Don't give it out if you can't take it back. I'm not saying any of those machines were faked or not. I'm only questioning how you know them to be, without testing them. Note that I didn't use insults, unlike you. Insults show poor debating skills. Oh, Dunning Kruger again. You are dumb. See? It didn't prove anything. Use science, not insults, and prove your worth that way. Or not. I don't care.
In the discription he calls perpentual motion "a controversial topic" Something impossibleby the laws of nature isn't "controversial" it's just impossible
@@geoshark12 I don't think you understand just how unlikely we are to be wrong about this... There are few, if any things, that we can say about the natural world with more certainty than that no one will ever see a perpetual motion machine.
@@benjialtman8390 and i assume you know this due to have all the knowledge in the unknown universe and an advanced degree in physics and quantum mechanics? I’m saying theres a hell of alot more that we don’t know then we do ,
In engineering this is called "reincarnating resonance" and it happens quite frequently when you design gears for example. Like when the engineer made a mistake, a gear can spin up uppon assembly and violently destroy itself due to overheating or stress. Also u have to be mindful when loading basicly anything into a pickup truck or a trailer. Sometimes it will just randomly accelerate and tear down everything in its path. And the worst of them all: carussels on playgrounds. One false step and you are doomed. No chance. Spinns up until it defeats gravity and leaves earths atmosphere. This is also the reason for UFOs btw.
Thomas The Offroad Train no, Spencer’s right, these perpetual motion machines exist but the concept is unrealistic. See how most of them are pushed by hand or there may be a small battery built at the bottom within? You can buy one online or in store for a high price. Iron man had one on his desk lol
@@paulspencer331 lol I like the way you think Spencer! But for everyone else, let's just agree to disagree haha I think Spencer just wanted to comment and share his view on the perpetual machines idea, which is the topic of the video, not so much the comment, and since it was the top comment, more people would be here to view it, so there's that perk right? Also, there's this interesting video down below that explains everything in more detail if it intrigues anyone: ua-cam.com/video/A-QgGXbDyR0/v-deo.html&ab_channel=TED-Ed
V B it’s impossible because it breaks the First and Second law of thermodynamics and even if it could work with the First law it can’t work with the second law.
Agreed, and while true perpetual motion will never be possible, I believe that we can manufacture something like what we see here that if refined enough could last for a very long time, say weeks or months even. With that kind of functionality, we could in theory power a vehicle by simply starting such a device in motion, negating the need to ever need gas or the like, just start up the device anytime you need to go somewhere. So I do think this kind of stuff could be useful regardless of not being true perpetual motion.
@@RESIST_DIGITAL_ID_UK while they are functioning machines, the term 'perpetual motion' usually implies that they can run forever with no source of power
No matter how impossible some of those things are, respect for the craftmanship the builder put into those machines. Just nice to watch them go and how they bogge the mind.
Pentru cine dorește să studieze cum ar funcționa un perpetuum mobile recomand să citească o propunere de invenție a osim, anume "motorul care funcționează cu apa" din anul 2017
David Westin perpetual motion obviously isn't possible but recreating it is, or trying to reach an efficient form or something like it. I understand that the magnetic car thing is bs though.
I love how every machine has some sort of physics principle going on that could maybe explain the perpetual motion, and then there's wedge shaped vehicle :D. That's it. Any wedge shaped vehicle will go forever because that's what wedges do :D
Haha, yeah, I saw that and my first thought was..."but that's not how gravity works!" I'm pretty sold on the magnetic powered car though. Already bought two tons of magnets of ebay to put in the back of my car so I don't have to get gas anymore! :)
The Fan and Sail would Work, because Energy is getting Put into IT, that accelerates the Air and then the Sail. IT would actually rather be like a spring pushing a car, while being in the Same Car that IT IS pushing against. Or like pushing against yourself to magicaly accelerate.
Why do people feel the need to point out that they are fake. Clearly they are fake perpetual motion is physically impossible. But people can still experiment if they want, it is fun
that because there is nothing smaller than an electron. meaning there is no resistance to slow electrons down how they started there motion and why they do not gradually move closer to the nucleus as they orbit remains to be seen, and is the real question hear
MrIAMSCOPEZ See that's what I said... but then I saw that Rolex doesn't use batteries for their watches.. they claim to use perpetual motion motors, called Oyster motors. I'm still trying to research into that because constant energy without an energy source means 100% energy transfer, which is impossible. Least to say, it's got me stumped... EDIT: I did some research, and it turns out that I was sort of right, not truly believing that the Rolex mechanism is perpetual, seeing as there is no such thing as 100% energy conservation, even in a vacuum. The way the watches work is it harnesses the energy of the persons hand moving. It does this by winding the main spring mechanically with the movement of the hand, thus creating a seemingly perpetual motor. To avoid over-winding, there is a slip mechanism that stops the winding of the spring.
Jedicache electrons do not orbit. They teleport constantly with 95% teleporting next to the nucleus and create an electron cloud. 5% of the time they teleport far away from the nucleus
You are an idiot.... but I am sure you are able to understand how this machine works so simply ua-cam.com/video/HMEBpZWckpw/v-deo.html After, you have to create one which works by yourself and to STOP to be a scientist'believer … All these machine works so simply.... and you are wrong...normal, you are a believer. A scientist'believer, BUT a believer. See you. F.R.
@@420frankp no it says that those who dont understand what perpetual motion is arent looking in the right places ... 16.5+BILLION years our universe takes NO external input .. and has been going and going longer than everready bunny .. . modern science essentially take the carb off an engine and says it cant move a 1 ton vehicle ... leave it on the engine and run the system and it moves the 1 ton vehicle ... . nature is the better teacher she has been at it for 16.5+BILLION years ... modern science a few hundred ..
@@0623kaboom Not the same thing at all. The earths rotation for example is slowing down. Objects in space are not passing through anything so aren't affected by friction and air resistance. If you can solve friction and air resistance on earth you might make something that appears to move perpetually.
@@0623kaboom It seems like you are misunderstanding the definition of perpetual motion and the laws that we have found energy follows. As you say, yes, perpetual motion is very possible even the universe "seems" to do it but it has some conditions to work.
As a mechanical engineer despite these machines not doing what they were designed to do but some are still so sophisticated that one has to appreciate the idea.
You really don't need a perpetual motion machine to create free energy though, in theory a machine exists that turns for a funcionally infinite amount of time. Forget functionally infinite, if I had a flywheel that could sustain something as demanding as a server tower in my house and needs to be spun up once a week I would be set for life.
@@seanlally7384 Hey man. Don't take it as bad but I think you don't understand basic Energy Conversion and Generation. Generators provide energy. If you were to turn a flywheel once a week for whole week of power, it would either need to be so big that you will require too much torque to even start turning it. Or you will require too much speed if it's not that big. Either way it will not be feasible and will end up being more costly, wasteful and high maintenance. A better and more conventional alternative that I can suggest is either utilizing Wind mill or Solar Power. Both of them might not be good enough depending on your location and power requirement but they will be practical rather than a flywheel. Again I am sorry if this is too antagonizing.
@LTNetjak In that case a flywheel may not be the ideal store of energy, maybe a slowly falling bag of rocks tied to a generator through gears or tiles that store energy from being stepped on, use your imagination.
16.5+billion years .. the universe .. as perpetual as it gets ... and it doesnt break the laws of thermodynamics ... . perpetual motion is defined as a system that takes NO EXTERNAL input to run ... . you like modern scinece took the carb off an engine and said it cant move a 1 ton car ... but replace it on the engine and then run the system and it moves the 1 ton car ... again modern science cant see the forest for the trees so they keep cutting down the trees ... that is the definition of MORONIC ... and that is what modern science is moronic ... follow nature it knows better ... it has been doing it longer
Богдан Іваник The metal parts will eventually need to be replaced, notice how the ball sometimes jumps up, that will slowly dent the surface, aswell as the copper wire holding the weight. That weight moving erratically will cause that wire to deform slowly but surely.
ahh so you are well indoctrinated into the modern lies ... nature says modern science is wrong ... the universe 16.5+billion years and counting ... no external energy input ... doesnt break any laws of thermodynamics ... and modern science only ever take parts of it ... . that is like saying a carb on an engine cant move the car ... as part of the system it can .... science cutting down trees to find the forest ...
@@0623kaboom The universe doesn't destroy any energy or mass though. There is a constant sum of energy and mass in the universe. It just changes shape. Quit spouting your new age nonsense.
@@yaeloosthuizen725 was it the one I convinced myself would work which was a dynamo on a wheel..?..I was 8 and nobody could convince me it wouldnt work :( bloody thing stopped
CartUniverse pro gamer for it to speed up would imply it's creating its own energy which is impossible, the most it could do is maintain what's been exerted on it before eventually ceasing all motion. An engine was definitely used.
It's the same problem that occurs with a sailboat using a giant fan to push it, or trying to fly by lifting your own pants. Newton's third law says that with each action there is an equal an opposite reaction so pulling on the same thing your pushing won't work
the vast majority of these were pretty stupid, making me sit and think about how anyone would even begin to believe they should work, was only like 3-4 of them where I was like this actually look like it could work (but ofc it would not in actually still)
The suspended Magnet one, I know technically it will stop eventually but would it end tho? Because it’s always repulsing (If that’s a word) the hanging magnet right? I’m not sure or it can come to an end, I know it would, but how? 😅
Douglas Pantz Even two round magnets that were perfectly centered? Shouldn't even the tiniest of vibrations send it moving? If so it'd make for a good desk ornament.
Loving all the comments explaining how this is impossible and calling the video fake. News flash: duh, the people who made these understand it can't really be done. It's fun to come up with the idea and see how long it lasts.
if you recreate them you realize that many only work for a few seconds (if not less) without a hidden power source. e.g. "Simon Stevin's machine" the "wedge-shaped vehicle/magnet - Powered car"(like wtf?), "optical PPM"(this is getting ridiculous), the list goes on... although I must admit there are a few that would go on for a little bit (like the perpetual train or the kinetic pendulum). but yeah that's what I am trying to point out.
The problem is that if the viewer doesn’t know it’s fake, they won’t know. It’s worse because the description of the video says that they are working. That is why people in the comments are angry.
Life is amazing, perpetual machines are an impossibility, they physically cannot work because they break the first two fundamental laws of thermodynamics. If perpetual machines worked we wouldn't have a need for employment since all of our energy would be created by these supposed machine. But again.... they don't work. This video isn't meant to show you perpetual machines working (because again they cant) but is rather just trying to show you the ideas people had for them. There are countless examples of rotors and gears blatantly powering the devices in this video.
@@dylantaylor3139 I have two theories. Either they thought it was a positive comment (english doesn’t seem to be their first language), or this channel is actually meant to educate on why perpetual motion machines *aren’t* possible
dat calculation tho of course he is using motors! These machines are not possible due to the law of the conservation of energy! Other than kinetic energy, they will generate other forms like sounds and minuscule amounts of heat. So if left running, they would eventually grind to a halt 😅
all of these are machines that where proposed in the 1800's while some of them can run for an extremely long time none can run forever, others are just stupid and being run by a motor/pump
@@Mechanarian you mean the little black "tube holder" that is not necessary for holding the tube, where he can split the tube to go below to the pump in the base. That is the style he shows in a solution video to another machine. Really great and enlighting!
Oh well, there goes the second law of thermodynamics ;-) It must have been so much fun making all of those - especially the historical ones. Good show.
True story: My scienece teacher saw this video and have all the students build a perpetual machine as a final assignment. At the end, no one can make it work and the teacher just told us that we didnt work hard enough
@@zzztriplezzz5264 That confirms what I said: Batteries are heavy, they make the base heavy so the artwork won't flip over. But you could use stones as well, they are also heavy. I don't think batteries have any advantage compared to stones.
@@zzztriplezzz5264 Besides, I've never heard of statues with batteries in the base. Maybe because in former times they didn't have so many empty batteries they wanted to get rid of.
@PrinceFcknCharming this video claims that these work, which if anything slows down innovation. I'm not saying we shouldn't try to invent energy sources, I'm saying we shouldn't claim fake inventions as real ones
@PrinceFcknCharming yeah innovation is great, the only problem i have is this claiming to have already created perpetual motion, which stunts the growth of real energy sources
@@fos1451 if you are joking: ah ok i understand If not: wtf is wrong with your brain But you are probably joking i just cant tell because that is something someone would actually say.
@@0623kaboom huh! if you are talking about why earth aint collapsing into the sun UNTIL NOW then lemme tell you, that there is a person called Centrefugal force and he wants your number. He will explain you the rest. And as per losing energy! NOTHING IS PERPETUAL NOT THE EARH NOT THE SUN! Billions and billions of years later, one day will come when earth will lose its spiraling energy and collapse into the sun. So Mr. 0623kaboom! Chill, this earth wont last forever too. It might seem perpetual now but may be a trillion years but a time will come when earth will collapse into the sun. SO! PERPETUAL MOTION IS JUST AGAINST THE LAWS OF NATURE
SamTheMan Yes! Although its all bullshit they had to come up with all of these! Also i don't understand your reasoning! I think you don't know the meaning of the word "creative"!
mrflakito It is very efficient, produces very little pollution, and the planet is very unlikely to run out of material for it. I like to think of it more as a 'starter' for finding something else that's even better. If we're discrediting power that won't last forever, well... Our star won't last forever, so there goes solar.
AJ Olesen perpetual motion and free energy are not the same thing. if you were hypothetically able to create a true perpetual motion machine, it would be a contained system which you would not be able to draw any useful energy from - it would only recycle the same initial energy put into it and never actually output any energy. of course, both perpetual motion and "free" energy are impossible for the same reasons (which i get that you realize), but i just wanted to point out they are not the same thing even on a purely hypothetical level.
J Smithson The resources for nuclear power are very limited. And when the sun is gone life won't be possible on earth anyway so basically it is 'forever'. At least in a human time span. If humans happen to find another planet to live on, that planet will have another star where solar power could be used.
What happens if you were to connect those Perpetual Train tracks into a circle/ loop? You show 3 track pieces connected in a straight line... but how about adding more track pieces and have them curve around to form a continuous circle/ loop?
There is allways a bunch of tryhards who keep saying this is fake. We know its fake, but give some appreciation to the people who make this awesome mechanisms :)
What is so awesome about a perpetual motion machine that does not work? Why not spend your time making something useful - a machine that actually DOES something is interesting.
@@stevenbishop8625 Nobody has to "prove" that a perpetual motion machine does not work. If you understand the laws of physics, you know that ALL such machines do not work. If you build such a machine without the physics, you are wasting your time and resources.
When i was a kid, i thought of a perpetual motion machine and when i made it, found out it didnt work, this was before I learned about physics and engineering in school. Anyway the videos made in the above models are interesting to watch and well made , even if the don't work, in the end you watched them, even though you know perpetual motion is imposible
@@stevenbishop8625 When you were a kid, you proved that one concept of perpetual motion machine didn't work, not all of them. You didn't completely prove they don't work. The only possible proof here is a mathematical one. There is a lot of things you can't prove by direct experiment, and there is a lot of experiment that leads to false truths. An example of that is optical illusion: Even if your eye see something, that doesn't mean that thing is really as you see it. Have a good day.
The hardest part of making perpetual motion machine is figuring out where to hide the BATTERIES
And also the motor
Couldnt have said it better myself
Starocks tv
Ikrrr
Yeah if we actually had something with perpetual motion the world power would be solved 😂
People think that when you put 2 magnets next to each other it taps into a magic source of energy from another dimension.
that's stupid, extremely stupid
It does. If you don't believe me, just watch...
just watch what?
Well... if you consider the electromagnetic field like "another dimension" ...
Lool
Do I have to say any less than, pistons and redstone blocks
No, redstone repeaters and redstone dust are more efficient.
@Noob Destroyer wireless redstone is best used underwater
It still has a source. The redstone blocks are a source.
@@marcusvergara6193 But they are an infinite and self sustaining source, therefor perpetual.
@@futuregamer25 it doesn’t work in the sense that of a piece of red stone works just by itself, however the way it works is that if you combine all of it, the representation will still be odd, which will repeat the cycles enough that it itself is made out of the Minecraft equivalent of electricity and wires.
Just imagine how hard life would be if these machines actually worked. "Oh no, I sat on the front of my office chair wrong and now I'm accelerating out of the building!"
You are an idiot.... but I am sure you are able to understand how this machine works so simply
ua-cam.com/video/HMEBpZWckpw/v-deo.html
After, you have to create one which works by yourself and to STOP to be a scientist'believer …
All these machine works so simply.... and you are wrong...normal, you are a believer. A scientist'believer, BUT a believer.
See you.
F.R.
@@francoisdelatre woah calm down
@@francoisdelatre I saw the video and that machine is also fake.
@@VirtualizerExtreme I.... stop you Wright there because You are a Believer, a scientist Believer but a Believer. Before preaching Wrong prayers ( friction and inertia) YOU AUGHT TO MAKE ONE MACHINE AND SEE THAT IT WORKS. ........ First Step for Science : expérimentation ! Second one not to be in believing of any kind. I did three machines and of différent type and they work as well as the Bessler one.... So STOP with your believings and go to work !
Thank you. 😀
@@lamuzzo5120 I.... stop you Wright there because You are a Believer, a scientist Believer but a Believer. Before preaching Wrong prayers ( friction and inertia) YOU AUGHT TO MAKE ONE MACHINE AND SEE THAT IT WORKS. ........ First Step for Science : expérimentation ! Second one not to be in believing of any kind. I did three machines and of différent type and they work as well as the Bessler one.... So STOP with your believings and go to work !
Thank you. 😀
The only truly perpetual motion machine I've ever seen is the Twitter hate engine.
No... Twitter has its own external fuel source (usually some news article or bit of entertainment). But it is a very efficient engine, and can go a long way on very little fuel.
After all, it always releases some steam))
Everything is in perpetual motion.
Don't forget the other antisocial media. I've been given hate for saying that science is done by scientists using the scientific method - by someone claiming to be scientific.
xDD. The Astronogeek's spaceship Hermes is powered with that.. Limitless energy xD
Perpetual motion machine: about to be created
Friction and inertia: I'm gonna stop you right there.
I'm pretty sure all of that machines will stop at some point in time.
@@johnkevin5446 pretty sure if there is no friction or gravity it wouldn't stop. I'm not that smart tho so if anyone sees this and you know I'm wrong pls correct me
@@chairvergil4552 You correct it would not stop but if you want to get power from it you’re going to be inducing I’ll go down to it meaning it will stop. Unless the power create it is more than is consumed which is impossible
@@xxdeadoutxx761 Yup, what I thought of when I thought about perpetual motion was basically to take a smooth ball into deep space, away from any sorce of radiation, gravity, ect. then you spin it and let it go. I think that might do it for creating something that moves infinitely, but even if it worked you can't get more energy out of perpetual motion then you put in, so even if you can get it moving forever thats all it can ever do.
Energy loss is a thing. The potential, and kinetic energy of these perpetual items will be lost to its environment over time. You still need to demand more energy than it can produce to itself to profit off of it.
The car ones are the funniest, like “if i put more weight at the front of the car it will roll forever!!!”
Check any FIAT/SEAT Panda XD
The magnet powered one probs does actually move w/o batteries, but magnets dont retain their charge for forever sooooo
@@SynthMasters actually not, the magnets atract each other equally, so it cancels out
@@murilo7794 Huh. Didnt think about that now I feel dumb
Yeah, no more gas, if you ad a WEDGE to your car!
2:01 I like how for this one you can see the ball begin to get lower just after 4 seconds.
I love how you can see some of them just stopping.
The likes were at 69 but i made it 70 likes because I can
@@pinkiepiefan02 you monster
The pendulum ball one was slowing down so fast it nearly gave me whiplash, thank god he cut away before it did.
the kinetic pendulum is NOT perpetual motion it will stop like a grand father clock ... those are kinetic pendulums ... and they have to be reset often ... that breaks the basic definition of perpetual motion ... NO external energy input ... by adjusting the weights over time one adds external energy making it JUST a machine
@@0623kaboom can you stop with the ...
Funny how so many of them have such thick base platforms.
See thru materials are a must or it's a scam.
Those boxes hold the secrets to the universe haha
@@marcbee1234 how are they a scam if it's just a street name for this type of kinetic art? Have anybody claimed them to actually break laws of physics? Most of them would look great in school physics class, waiting room or in break room in office. Heck, I'd even say that building one with kids is a good experience and would help to explain THEM why they're impossible.
Jake Goodman I I I I iiiuuuuuiiu
Jake Goodman I I I I iiiuuuuuiiuy
I like how most of these are sitting on top of suspiciously thick bases and tables that we can't see under.
Or cut out just as they start slowing like the pendulum ones.
you guys all you have is doubts. You will sink into the water
@@theplacebeyondthelies2429 ???
*"In this house, we obey the laws of thermodynamics!"*
"DOH"
Ted Ed moment
THE FIRST TWO LAWS OF THERMODYNAMICS ARE NOT EVEN REAL
Hope your not a evolutionist then. since evolution and the big bang literally defy one of the laws
@@Shadowblitz16 THE FIRST TWO LAWS OF THERMODYNAMICS ARE NOT ACTUALLY LAWS
I like how you can clearly see the Ball and Pendulum one at 2:00 start to slow down before they cut away
Yeah, I mean it’s not real.
Almost all of them cut annoyingly early.
WHY DO YOU LIKE THAT? THATS NOT A PERPETUAL MOTION MACHINE AND ITS ONLY A CONSERVATIVE ENGINE SO WHY DO YOU LIKE IT?
The irony is the dumbest comments aren't from any people who think it's real, but from people who think they are the only ones who can tell it's fake. Dunning-Kruger in full force
Does this comment make Dunning-Kruger apply for you too?
I just learned about the Dunning-Kruger effect about 2 weeks ago! That's awesome! oh , and good point.
@@kanvolu no
I wanted to believe in this stuff enough that I was almost convinced against my better judgement.
Magical thinking I guess.
Is perpetual motion impossible? How long would it need to run before you believed it to happen and how long has the solar system been running without input from outside? Even a few days should be enough.
How do you know them all to be faked? Did you try to reproduce them? No. You assumed it on your own lack of experience of trying to make perpetual motion machines. You thereby show Dunning Kruger yourself. Don't give it out if you can't take it back. I'm not saying any of those machines were faked or not. I'm only questioning how you know them to be, without testing them. Note that I didn't use insults, unlike you. Insults show poor debating skills. Oh, Dunning Kruger again. You are dumb. See? It didn't prove anything. Use science, not insults, and prove your worth that way. Or not. I don't care.
In the discription he calls perpentual motion "a controversial topic"
Something impossibleby the laws of nature isn't "controversial" it's just impossible
It in fact *is* a controversial topic. But not "a controversial topic in science".
As of now anyways perpetual motion is impossible but we may find a way someday ( probably not in my life time though)
@@geoshark12 I don't think you understand just how unlikely we are to be wrong about this... There are few, if any things, that we can say about the natural world with more certainty than that no one will ever see a perpetual motion machine.
@@benjialtman8390 and i assume you know this due to have all the knowledge in the unknown universe and an advanced degree in physics and quantum mechanics? I’m saying theres a hell of alot more that we don’t know then we do ,
@@benjialtman8390 also prepetual motion exists in the form of molecules which are int a constant state of motion
In engineering this is called "reincarnating resonance" and it happens quite frequently when you design gears for example. Like when the engineer made a mistake, a gear can spin up uppon assembly and violently destroy itself due to overheating or stress.
Also u have to be mindful when loading basicly anything into a pickup truck or a trailer. Sometimes it will just randomly accelerate and tear down everything in its path.
And the worst of them all: carussels on playgrounds. One false step and you are doomed. No chance. Spinns up until it defeats gravity and leaves earths atmosphere. This is also the reason for UFOs btw.
ikr, my car just zoomed off, i must’ve put too much weight in the front
nerd 😂
@@WingDingsFont its satire nonce
It is so annoying, one time i was leaning in my chair until suddenly i started rotating exponentially faster until i got sent to space.
Man I wished these existed... not for the infinite energy, but for a cool desk toy
Edit: can we chill in the replies ty
There are toys like that, usually they take really long to stop or require small batteries.
Thomas The Offroad Train no, Spencer’s right, these perpetual motion machines exist but the concept is unrealistic. See how most of them are pushed by hand or there may be a small battery built at the bottom within? You can buy one online or in store for a high price. Iron man had one on his desk lol
Are you have stubid
@@paulspencer331 lol I like the way you think Spencer!
But for everyone else, let's just agree to disagree haha
I think Spencer just wanted to comment and share his view on the perpetual machines idea, which is the topic of the video, not so much the comment, and since it was the top comment, more people would be here to view it, so there's that perk right?
Also, there's this interesting video down below that explains everything in more detail if it intrigues anyone:
ua-cam.com/video/A-QgGXbDyR0/v-deo.html&ab_channel=TED-Ed
Let's hope we have more inventors in the world and let the brilliant minds make the universe a better way :)
Despite perpetual motion being impossible, i still think these are really cool and interesting to watch
V B it’s impossible because it breaks the First and Second law of thermodynamics and even if it could work with the First law it can’t work with the second law.
Echo Games Preaching to the choir there
Apart from the fact that most of them are just flat out fake and use electricity
Agreed, and while true perpetual motion will never be possible, I believe that we can manufacture something like what we see here that if refined enough could last for a very long time, say weeks or months even. With that kind of functionality, we could in theory power a vehicle by simply starting such a device in motion, negating the need to ever need gas or the like, just start up the device anytime you need to go somewhere. So I do think this kind of stuff could be useful regardless of not being true perpetual motion.
What keeps the earth spinning?
you can see some of them losing energy even in the 3 seconds they're on screen
No, they work, it’s just that they are powered by an external source.
@@RESIST_DIGITAL_ID_UK while they are functioning machines, the term 'perpetual motion' usually implies that they can run forever with no source of power
@@pbjwizard well.. just till the battery runs out..
I'm sold that these spin forever after watching a 5 second clip of each 1.
3:54 that thing rolled less efficiently than a simple cylinder would
Besides, if they had put it on a longer stretch, it is obvious that it would not move for that long
The point of that one is it goes for a long time, but it slows down quickly.
You could literally see it stop and go the other way before they cut
A simple cylinder might be more efficient, but a hollow cylinder with slapping weenies will get you more chicks.
Literally like i push it and it move and then stops and I push it again ✨perpetual motion ✨
These machines are all out of order: without exception, they stop moving when I click on the stop button of my UA-cam viewer.
We all know none of these could run *forever* but some of these could run for a very long time.
Nope , it is all about reducing friction and air resistance. Even a simple spinning disc with really good bearing with spin longer.
Ritesh Lama you seem to be agreeing with blob fish. He described them perfectly. The titles are always misleading.
The Blue BlobFish This would work in space, not on earth
@@blankneverlosegaming6374 no they wouldn't as they require gravity to function
Not unless you plan on sticking a generator to the side of it... Lmao
No matter how impossible some of those things are, respect for the craftmanship the builder put into those machines. Just nice to watch them go and how they bogge the mind.
Bogge ?
NONE OF THESE THINGS ARE IMPOSSIBLE
@@UNABRIDGED_SCIENCE perpetual motion is impossible
I love how these 'perpetual motion machines' spin at such a linear and smooth rate regardless to the mechanisms supposedly powering them.
Pentru cine dorește să studieze cum ar funcționa un perpetuum mobile recomand să citească o propunere de invenție a osim, anume "motorul care funcționează cu apa" din anul 2017
The one at 4:08 is especially obvious lol
When you literally pull yourself up by your bootstraps
That's the logic here lmao
Blowing your own sail?
Pulling yourself and your horse out of the snow by your hair while sitting on that horse
Von Braun would be pissed if he realized he could have just pulled himself up to the moon
These are so hilariously bad
"Magnet powered car" omg I will die from laughter.
What do you mean
It literally says in the about page that these are motorized
@@yeetyfreety6938 Elementary physics proves that would never work. Newton's third law? Not to mention the enormous effect friction has on the wheels.
David Westin perpetual motion obviously isn't possible but recreating it is, or trying to reach an efficient form or something like it. I understand that the magnetic car thing is bs though.
tienes razon imposible que se mueva
I love how every machine has some sort of physics principle going on that could maybe explain the perpetual motion, and then there's wedge shaped vehicle :D. That's it. Any wedge shaped vehicle will go forever because that's what wedges do :D
Haha, yeah, I saw that and my first thought was..."but that's not how gravity works!"
I'm pretty sold on the magnetic powered car though. Already bought two tons of magnets of ebay to put in the back of my car so I don't have to get gas anymore! :)
This is why smart cooks buy their cheese in blocks!
This is troll physics 101. I love it. The magnet car is like having a sail and a fan on the same car -> infinite forward motion
That was my favorite too!!! lolzzz
Actually, Mythbusters proved that that could work....
NO ITS NOT, AND NO ITS NOT,
AND YOU ARE RETARDED AND LAZY
The Fan and Sail would Work, because Energy is getting Put into IT, that accelerates the Air and then the Sail.
IT would actually rather be like a spring pushing a car, while being in the Same Car that IT IS pushing against. Or like pushing against yourself to magicaly accelerate.
Why do people feel the need to point out that they are fake. Clearly they are fake perpetual motion is physically impossible. But people can still experiment if they want, it is fun
Electrons orbit perpetually around the nucleus of an atom. But, y'know, quantum physics is weird
that because there is nothing smaller than an electron. meaning there is no resistance to slow electrons down how they started there motion and why they do not gradually move closer to the nucleus as they orbit remains to be seen, and is the real question hear
MrIAMSCOPEZ I agree... Dylan's an Idiot!
MrIAMSCOPEZ
See that's what I said... but then I saw that Rolex doesn't use batteries for their watches.. they claim to use perpetual motion motors, called Oyster motors.
I'm still trying to research into that because constant energy without an energy source means 100% energy transfer, which is impossible. Least to say, it's got me stumped...
EDIT:
I did some research, and it turns out that I was sort of right, not truly believing that the Rolex mechanism is perpetual, seeing as there is no such thing as 100% energy conservation, even in a vacuum. The way the watches work is it harnesses the energy of the persons hand moving. It does this by winding the main spring mechanically with the movement of the hand, thus creating a seemingly perpetual motor. To avoid over-winding, there is a slip mechanism that stops the winding of the spring.
Jedicache electrons do not orbit. They teleport constantly with 95% teleporting next to the nucleus and create an electron cloud. 5% of the time they teleport far away from the nucleus
They accutally state that it's not possible on their site. This Is just a compilation of ideas.
Whaaat?! Have You Not Seen These Videos Half The People Think That They Are Saying It's Real So Hes Just Clarifying For The Dumbasses
You reassure me
Try telling that to the other guys like jesus christ
great job 👏👍👈 success there family 🤝
Perpetual motion machine. Tie a piece of bacon on a dogs tail
it works
Problem solved
If the dog is exhausted, the dog will lose motion, it won't be called as a perpetual motion machine
no worry, there are endless other dogs
Jerald Gonzales r/wooosh
Challenge: Make the machines entirely out of glass.
ha ha ! nice one
You are an idiot.... but I am sure you are able to understand how this machine works so simply
ua-cam.com/video/HMEBpZWckpw/v-deo.html
After, you have to create one which works by yourself and to STOP to be a scientist'believer …
All these machine works so simply.... and you are wrong...normal, you are a believer. A scientist'believer, BUT a believer.
See you.
F.R.
@@francoisdelatre i see why ur mom regretted not having an abortion
@@francoisdelatre Please if you are a scientist, tell us the first and second laws of thermodynamics.
All nice conversation pieces and toys, cleverly done too. Of course we all know perpetual motion is impossible but it's fun to imagine it isn't.
It's pretty apparent reading through these comments that not everyone knows it is impossible.
16.5 billion years no external energy input ... the universe says you are WRONG.
@@420frankp no it says that those who dont understand what perpetual motion is arent looking in the right places ... 16.5+BILLION years our universe takes NO external input .. and has been going and going longer than everready bunny ..
.
modern science essentially take the carb off an engine and says it cant move a 1 ton vehicle ... leave it on the engine and run the system and it moves the 1 ton vehicle ...
.
nature is the better teacher she has been at it for 16.5+BILLION years ... modern science a few hundred ..
@@0623kaboom Not the same thing at all. The earths rotation for example is slowing down. Objects in space are not passing through anything so aren't affected by friction and air resistance. If you can solve friction and air resistance on earth you might make something that appears to move perpetually.
@@0623kaboom It seems like you are misunderstanding the definition of perpetual motion and the laws that we have found energy follows. As you say, yes, perpetual motion is very possible even the universe "seems" to do it but it has some conditions to work.
As a mechanical engineer despite these machines not doing what they were designed to do but some are still so sophisticated that one has to appreciate the idea.
As a truck driver I completely agree
You really don't need a perpetual motion machine to create free energy though, in theory a machine exists that turns for a funcionally infinite amount of time. Forget functionally infinite, if I had a flywheel that could sustain something as demanding as a server tower in my house and needs to be spun up once a week I would be set for life.
@@seanlally7384 Hey man. Don't take it as bad but I think you don't understand basic Energy Conversion and Generation. Generators provide energy. If you were to turn a flywheel once a week for whole week of power, it would either need to be so big that you will require too much torque to even start turning it. Or you will require too much speed if it's not that big. Either way it will not be feasible and will end up being more costly, wasteful and high maintenance. A better and more conventional alternative that I can suggest is either utilizing Wind mill or Solar Power. Both of them might not be good enough depending on your location and power requirement but they will be practical rather than a flywheel. Again I am sorry if this is too antagonizing.
@@UsmanSaleemSulehri A flywheel is obviously an impractical store of energy but the point was simply to make the case for functionally infinite power.
@LTNetjak In that case a flywheel may not be the ideal store of energy, maybe a slowly falling bag of rocks tied to a generator through gears or tiles that store energy from being stepped on, use your imagination.
Anyone else come from the Ted Talk about why perpetual machines don't work?
Me
Yes, me
Yeee
Also me
Yes
Alternative title for this video: “10 things that break the first & second laws of thermodynamics! (Not fake!)”
The description says the machines are powered or shown for a few seconds
16.5+billion years .. the universe .. as perpetual as it gets ... and it doesnt break the laws of thermodynamics ...
.
perpetual motion is defined as a system that takes NO EXTERNAL input to run ...
.
you like modern scinece took the carb off an engine and said it cant move a 1 ton car ... but replace it on the engine and then run the system and it moves the 1 ton car ... again modern science cant see the forest for the trees so they keep cutting down the trees ... that is the definition of MORONIC ... and that is what modern science is moronic ... follow nature it knows better ... it has been doing it longer
@@0623kaboom the universe does not appear to be perpetual
@@ricardo-hc2yb Finally someone that got more than 2 nerons instead of "calling out the fake"
@@piksqu9544 it's a long story in another comment thread
These machines are so cool! And very well built! :-)
Law of thermodynamics, law of thermodynamics,
LAW OF THERMODYNAMICS!!!
redstone craft guy did u watch a ted ed video in ur recomended xd
Dude.. that video was uploaded today
hey could i know that all of these are fake but COULD SOMEBODY WXPLAIN HOW WILL THIS STOP EVENTUALLY -- 1:24
Богдан Іваник The metal parts will eventually need to be replaced, notice how the ball sometimes jumps up, that will slowly dent the surface, aswell as the copper wire holding the weight. That weight moving erratically will cause that wire to deform slowly but surely.
Yes. Then this one was recommended with it. It's as if UA-cam wanted me to come here and dislike the video or be confused by physics or something.
Guy invents a perpetum mobile: "I'm not gonna solve the world energy crysis and become a trillionaire, I'd rather make a UA-cam video instead."
it dont work
@SIBI CHARAN DINAKARAN msybe it's supposed to be a joke?
I am sure this is a joke and not to be taken seriously
@SIBI CHARAN DINAKARAN
/facepalm
j100j Every thing is a joke these days, heck even the world itself
Thermodynamics: am I a joke to you
It's Perpetual machine's choice
Yes
Exactly, The laws of thermodynamics will stop them
Time: I'll think about that.
A cruel joke. Played on us.
The “wedge shaped vehicle” had me ROTFL 🤣
Lmao I remember believing on this kinda stuff when I was kid.
Ikr, I spent my childhood trying to build one. You'll never guess how it went.
When you plug the extension into itself thinking it would make infinite power.
ahh so you are well indoctrinated into the modern lies ... nature says modern science is wrong ... the universe 16.5+billion years and counting ... no external energy input ... doesnt break any laws of thermodynamics ... and modern science only ever take parts of it ...
.
that is like saying a carb on an engine cant move the car ... as part of the system it can .... science cutting down trees to find the forest ...
@@0623kaboom The universe doesn't destroy any energy or mass though. There is a constant sum of energy and mass in the universe. It just changes shape. Quit spouting your new age nonsense.
@@yaeloosthuizen725 was it the one I convinced myself would work which was a dynamo on a wheel..?..I was 8 and nobody could convince me it wouldnt work :( bloody thing stopped
2:21 ground breaking stuff right here. a magnet on a string
Octavio Espinoza hour*
SOLVED.
@@hwfq34fajw9foiffawdiufhuaiwfhw nope, magnets lose their magnetic properties over time
Love how the "Infinite Fan" lagged before getting powered by an engine.
SARDA thomas not necessarly. actualy it works by the weigth attached to the fans. I think that it would stop when the weigths slip out
Infaust so why did it start slowly ? I'm not angry just asking
Infaust It's still impossible
it doesnt get powered by an engine. its moved by the weights (and the guys initial push) we just dont get enough of the video to see it stop.
CartUniverse pro gamer for it to speed up would imply it's creating its own energy which is impossible, the most it could do is maintain what's been exerted on it before eventually ceasing all motion. An engine was definitely used.
The best thing of these machines is that none of them are of perpetual motion
The wedge shaped vehicle and the magnetic car looked stupid
Whaaat?! I know none of these machines work, but the concept looked especially stupid compared to the others
It's the same problem that occurs with a sailboat using a giant fan to push it, or trying to fly by lifting your own pants. Newton's third law says that with each action there is an equal an opposite reaction so pulling on the same thing your pushing won't work
the vast majority of these were pretty stupid, making me sit and think about how anyone would even begin to believe they should work, was only like 3-4 of them where I was like this actually look like it could work (but ofc it would not in actually still)
HorseDog it was full coyote and roadrunner level of physics. it was just missing the ACME branding.
You look stupid.
Subtitle: "How electromagnets work"
*EXPOSED*
not even that would be right. For example the magnetic car is completly bullshit lmao
Congrats, you created a machine that eventually Will stop
It’s batteries lol
4:44 thank you so much. i had been curious about this one
Lost it at the magnet powered car.
Oh wait, that's not try not to laugh :/
VΛNTE dude u killed me xD
Same here lol
VΛNTE "constant downhill"
that was absolutely fake
Quit ripping off people's comments ;)
The magnet powered car doesnt even make sense XD
exactly ,,just like some one push his car while hi is in side it...!!!!!
GD Kanine nothing makes any sense
PICASSO exactly
GD Kanine
Most of them dont
GD Kanine
Some of these are actually really cool pendulums.
Perpetual motion is impossible
The suspended Magnet one, I know technically it will stop eventually but would it end tho? Because it’s always repulsing (If that’s a word) the hanging magnet right? I’m not sure or it can come to an end, I know it would, but how? 😅
2:25 btw for Suspended Magnet
KalouDaFlowa It Would Rest Slightly Beside The Magnet.
Douglas Pantz
Even two round magnets that were perfectly centered?
Shouldn't even the tiniest of vibrations send it moving? If so it'd make for a good desk ornament.
Nice Reggae jam Irie mon!
Loving all the comments explaining how this is impossible and calling the video fake. News flash: duh, the people who made these understand it can't really be done. It's fun to come up with the idea and see how long it lasts.
Thomas Stewart you do realize that 90% of them have motors? So they last as long as the batteries do.
Thomas Stewart thank you for having intelligence
SirSkyRage lol what?
if you recreate them you realize that many only work for a few seconds (if not less) without a hidden power source. e.g. "Simon Stevin's machine" the "wedge-shaped vehicle/magnet - Powered car"(like wtf?), "optical PPM"(this is getting ridiculous), the list goes on... although I must admit there are a few that would go on for a little bit (like the perpetual train or the kinetic pendulum). but yeah that's what I am trying to point out.
The problem is that if the viewer doesn’t know it’s fake, they won’t know. It’s worse because the description of the video says that they are working. That is why people in the comments are angry.
Perpetual motion machine: make an afk pool in minecraft
Lolol
Redstone clock...
Scientist hate him!
@@astrabytedotexe 🤣🤣
02:00
it is clear that device is gradually stopping
lol they didn't want to show it was fake so they recorded 5 seconds of it
Mr. spatula Not to mention 2:21
Life is amazing true such fake this is all impossible
Life is amazing it's not trying to show you it works it's just showing you the designs people have had, they are moving the machines with motors
Life is amazing, perpetual machines are an impossibility, they physically cannot work because they break the first two fundamental laws of thermodynamics. If perpetual machines worked we wouldn't have a need for employment since all of our energy would be created by these supposed machine. But again.... they don't work. This video isn't meant to show you perpetual machines working (because again they cant) but is rather just trying to show you the ideas people had for them. There are countless examples of rotors and gears blatantly powering the devices in this video.
2:13 I love how it's like they purposefully made the movements of The Carousel Machine extremely robotic and not move with the weight at all
Some of these I have no idea where even in theory the perpetual motion should be coming from...
2:46
like... wtf?
Who's here from TedEd video?
Chaitanya Singh me
me
Me too
Chaitanya Singh me
me
I think I lost half of my brain cells watching this video
Why did the channel like this comment?
Because they know PHYSICS, that’s why
@@dylantaylor3139 I have two theories. Either they thought it was a positive comment (english doesn’t seem to be their first language), or this channel is actually meant to educate on why perpetual motion machines *aren’t* possible
Prob the second
These are really awesome!
(Thanks for sharing!)
At 2:01 you could see it slowing down
Crazy Contraptions iiii
Of course, the ball is losing energy through friction
Crazy Contraptions fidget spinner is more efficient
Crazy Contraptions Ii
Crazy Contraptions I
Friction: *sees this video*
Friction: Imma bout to end this man's whole career
Nature: ... Im going to prove them all wrong ... 16.5 + Billion years later the universe is still running with no external energy ...
@@0623kaboom i hope thats a joke
See it yourselves! This week on a new episode of "Fact or Friction".
@@0623kaboom The universe isn't perpetual it just has a lot of energy that hasn't been converted yet
I really love all of these videos. I just wish they worked!
"40 Perpetual motion machines, everything works"
Yeah, and I'm Santa Claus!
come on guys you need to applaud the way they so carefully his the motors...
dat calculation tho I lost brain cells trying to read your comment
dat calculation tho of course he is using motors! These machines are not possible due to the law of the conservation of energy! Other than kinetic energy, they will generate other forms like sounds and minuscule amounts of heat. So if left running, they would eventually grind to a halt 😅
Andrew Hamilton thank you science side of youtube
all of these are machines that where proposed in the 1800's while some of them can run for an extremely long time none can run forever, others are just stupid and being run by a motor/pump
Like spinning a heavy wheel with a ball bearing.
Nor can any of them produce any usable energy.
The point of the video is to show off IDEAS! Sure, none of these would work but it's for the sake of showcase!
@@ryanjackson5245 except it is physically impossible.there is no way to create any perpetual motion machine.
Did you even understand the WHOLE POINT of my comment
I think the term "pretty nifty" accurately describes most of these objects.
I am especially fascinated how he manages to rise the fluid in the Robert Boyle Flask at 4:19
@@uwose there is a small air pump on the bit of the tube that touches the wooden base
@@Mechanarian you mean the little black "tube holder" that is not necessary for holding the tube, where he can split the tube to go below to the pump in the base. That is the style he shows in a solution video to another machine. Really great and enlighting!
Oh well, there goes the second law of thermodynamics ;-)
It must have been so much fun making all of those - especially the historical ones.
Good show.
Tesla is going to mount one of these inside its new models.
True story: My scienece teacher saw this video and have all the students build a perpetual machine as a final assignment. At the end, no one can make it work and the teacher just told us that we didnt work hard enough
Ask Teacher to make it himself
I remember trying to make the magnet car as a little kid thinking I was a genius and being really disappointed lol
8 yo me thinking he would trash fuel engines :')
@@alexredison what about redstone flying machines
or tnt dupers
If only that magnetic force could be made unidirectional. It will be possible
こんな世界だと良いな！great amazing !
Благодаря, браво!
they're all working like our world's physical engine is Unity
Notice how almost all of these have a GIANT base. To store the batteries.
No, that they don't flip over, and for presentation purposes. Like any statue in an exhibition.
@@uwose nope it’s batteries lol
@@zzztriplezzz5264 That confirms what I said: Batteries are heavy, they make the base heavy so the artwork won't flip over. But you could use stones as well, they are also heavy. I don't think batteries have any advantage compared to stones.
@@zzztriplezzz5264 Besides, I've never heard of statues with batteries in the base. Maybe because in former times they didn't have so many empty batteries they wanted to get rid of.
@@zzztriplezzz5264 But there is one other thing they could use the base for: To hide the driving mechanism.
I like how you can literally see some of these slowing down
@PrinceFcknCharming lmao calm down snowflakeass
@PrinceFcknCharming this video claims that these work, which if anything slows down innovation. I'm not saying we shouldn't try to invent energy sources, I'm saying we shouldn't claim fake inventions as real ones
@PrinceFcknCharming yeah innovation is great, the only problem i have is this claiming to have already created perpetual motion, which stunts the growth of real energy sources
I loved perpetual motion. Thank you for sharing your videos. I’m interested in free energy. Watching with full support from Canada 🇨🇦.
Wish they could actually work forever.
Yeah that way we can hook em up to a thing and creat endless energy so we can power anything we dream of like an forever driving electric car
Hydrowaffles Any energy given to a perpetual motion machine can't be outputted as it would be losing the energy. Therefore making it not perpetual
0:28 “self spinning drum” *pushes*
What it should be called: "Self spinning lazy drum" it just needs a little push y'know.
Most if not all of those require a little push to start. You can't make energy out of zero, even those machines are bound by this.
@@FMHikari you cant make energy at all you have to get energy which is why these dont work and eventually stop
@@theratking14 most of these machines are transferring energy between each other
@@fos1451 if you are joking: ah ok i understand
If not: wtf is wrong with your brain
But you are probably joking i just cant tell because that is something someone would actually say.
3:04 TROLL PHYSICS IRL
and the fucking weights in the mirrors one too lmao. I know they're all fake but holy shit those are just hilarious.
stampycatfan01 I
how dont you react to the water one ??????
stampycatfan01 o
stampycatfan01 it's physically impossible for something with magnets on it to use just it's self to propel its self.
Amazing engineering. Thks for sharing.
To make: (just for me, I don't have anything to write on right now)
1:10
1:41
2:15
2:23
did you make them?
lol I do this type of stuff too lol
Made them?
2:00 you see its going slower and slower
Thats cause perpetual motion machines are FUCKING IMPOSSIBLE
@Neternis that is true but that defeats the pourpose of it to work forever
You realize none of these work right?
I would like to see some of these run for a bit longer
That's what I'm saying. Even they could last for hours or even years. Not perpetual.
get a telescope ... 16.5+ Billion years .. and counting ... as perpetual as one can get and modern science cant even see it
@@0623kaboom huh! if you are talking about why earth aint collapsing into the sun UNTIL NOW then lemme tell you, that there is a person called Centrefugal force and he wants your number. He will explain you the rest. And as per losing energy! NOTHING IS PERPETUAL NOT THE EARH NOT THE SUN! Billions and billions of years later, one day will come when earth will lose its spiraling energy and collapse into the sun. So Mr. 0623kaboom! Chill, this earth wont last forever too. It might seem perpetual now but may be a trillion years but a time will come when earth will collapse into the sun. SO! PERPETUAL MOTION IS JUST AGAINST THE LAWS OF NATURE
Shift levers is very hypnotic.
We all know its fake, but it was a fun video! Some of these were really creative!
Gresi Lamaj Is it really that creative if it doesn't work?
SamTheMan Yes! Although its all bullshit they had to come up with all of these! Also i don't understand your reasoning! I think you don't know the meaning of the word "creative"!
Gresi Lamaj I just don't see how it's creative, to me they're just more and more obscure failures
SamTheMan
They thought hard about physics to create these.
too bad all of this will not last forever. :( really wish for clean energy that will last forever.
AJ Olesen Solar, wind, water, nuclear
J Smithson Nuclear energy lasts forever??
mrflakito It is very efficient, produces very little pollution, and the planet is very unlikely to run out of material for it. I like to think of it more as a 'starter' for finding something else that's even better.
If we're discrediting power that won't last forever, well... Our star won't last forever, so there goes solar.
AJ Olesen perpetual motion and free energy are not the same thing. if you were hypothetically able to create a true perpetual motion machine, it would be a contained system which you would not be able to draw any useful energy from - it would only recycle the same initial energy put into it and never actually output any energy. of course, both perpetual motion and "free" energy are impossible for the same reasons (which i get that you realize), but i just wanted to point out they are not the same thing even on a purely hypothetical level.
J Smithson The resources for nuclear power are very limited. And when the sun is gone life won't be possible on earth anyway so basically it is 'forever'. At least in a human time span. If humans happen to find another planet to live on, that planet will have another star where solar power could be used.
Isn’t The Da Vinci overbalanced wheel suppose to spin the other way? 5:31
It depends on what way you pulls it 😆
It doesn't matter what the inventors thought how they should work. It isn't supposed to spin in any direction. So it's up to the builder to decide.
At the end it's gonna stop after a while so no matter which side u spin 😂😜
Man, the law of physics is just too hard for my brain😅😂🤣
@@madhuriwaghule3281 after a looong while. If you didnt notice the bottom is dipping into the base and im assuming there is just a wheel spinning it.
Thanking you so much
What happens if you were to connect those Perpetual Train tracks into a circle/ loop? You show 3 track pieces connected in a straight line... but how about adding more track pieces and have them curve around to form a continuous circle/ loop?
I've tried the magnet cars at 3:00 with Lego when I was little.
Spoiler alert: It didn't work
That car is even in a trollge video
There is allways a bunch of tryhards who keep saying this is fake. We know its fake, but give some appreciation to the people who make this awesome mechanisms :)
What is so awesome about a perpetual motion machine that does not work? Why not spend your time making something useful - a machine that actually DOES something is interesting.
well, its the only way to completly prove they dont work
@@stevenbishop8625 Nobody has to "prove" that a perpetual motion machine does not work. If you understand the laws of physics, you know that ALL such machines do not work. If you build such a machine without the physics, you are wasting your time and resources.
When i was a kid, i thought of a perpetual motion machine and when i made it, found out it didnt work, this was before I learned about physics and engineering in school. Anyway the videos made in the above models are interesting to watch and well made , even if the don't work, in the end you watched them, even though you know perpetual motion is imposible
@@stevenbishop8625 When you were a kid, you proved that one concept of perpetual motion machine didn't work, not all of them.
You didn't completely prove they don't work. The only possible proof here is a mathematical one.
There is a lot of things you can't prove by direct experiment, and there is a lot of experiment that leads to false truths.
An example of that is optical illusion: Even if your eye see something, that doesn't mean that thing is really as you see it.
Have a good day.
Amazing!
When you study mechanics it gets to the point where these things just *feel* wrong XD
I took 2 thermodynamics classes in uni, seeing this stuff is just entertaining since I know all laws by heart.
Idea for perpetual motion: tie buttered toast to a cat and drop from a height
WolfPack 1030 😂
Pretty sure Dolan got it from somewhere else too ;)
Thats just anti gravity. Not perpetual motion.
?????? ? Perpetual flotation, then
?????? ? Well, in order for the anti gravity to work, it'd need to spin.
My IQ is lowering by watching this...
joe nodden same
sy fy lol. Mine as well.
Same bro
It's not about being right or wrong. Science most of the time is not. Science is about exploration.
As if it wasn’t low enough
It's really great and it's inspiring..
When I seen the magnetic car I thought I’m in an other universe